Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Rajendrakumar Chandrakant Nadkarni v. University Of Bombay And Another

Bombay High Court
Sep 5, 1990
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This petition under Article 226 of the Constitution challenged the vires of the second part of Ordinance 237-A of the Ordinances and Regulations of the University of Bombay and a communication identified as Ex. F issued pursuant to that provision.

The petitioner and the second respondent were students of the M.Com. course at a college affiliated to Bombay University. The M.Com. degree required two examinations; marks from both examinations are aggregated for ranking. In Part I the petitioner applied for revaluation in Cost Accounting: his original marks of 54/100 were revised to 71/100 on revaluation. In Part II the petitioner obtained 240/400. The aggregate became 502/800.

On 17-8-1983 the Registrar issued a special certificate (Ex. D) proclaiming the petitioner first among those who passed. On 30-3-1984 the University issued Ex. F invoking the impugned part of Ordinance 237-A which provides that revised marks accepted by the University shall be taken into account for amendment of results but "these marks shall not be taken into account for the purpose of award of scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit." The petitioner challenged the vires of that provision and Ex. F.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the second part of Ordinance 237-A (which excludes accepted revised marks from consideration for scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit) is vires and constitutionally valid.
  2. Whether Ex. F, issued on the basis of that provision to the petitioner's detriment (recalling the special certificate), should be quashed and the special certificate (Ex. D) confirmed.
  3. Whether the impugned provision violates the guarantee of equality under Article 14 of the Constitution (as addressed through precedent relied upon by the petitioner).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The petitioner (through Mr. More) relied upon the decision in Anjay Bansal v. Banglore University AIR 1990 Karnataka 225, which involved a provision substantially similar to the impugned clause and in which the Karnataka High Court held the provision violative of Article 14.

University's Arguments

  • Counsel for the University (Mr. Shankarnarayanan) submitted that a candidate who attains superiority after revaluation belongs to a different class from one who attains superiority in the ordinary appraisal; therefore the University may treat them differently for purposes such as ranking for prizes and order of merit.
  • It was further argued that subjectivity in examinations cannot be ruled out and that those who gain on revaluation benefit from a re-appraisal which is not available to others who succeed in the original evaluation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Anjay Bansal v. Banglore University AIR 1990 Karnataka 225 The Karnataka High Court construed a provision similar to the impugned clause (which prevented declaration of revised rank or incidental benefits on revaluation) and held it violative of Article 14. The court accepted and followed that decision, treating the similarity between the provisions as significant and applying the same principle to quash Ex. F and to confirm the special certificate (Ex. D) awarded to the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the University's contention that candidates who obtain improved results on revaluation form a different class from those who attain their results on the original appraisal. The court rejected that classification:

  • Both sets of candidates sit the same degree examination, answer the same questions in the same subjects, and are assessed against the same competency standards.
  • The very mechanism of revaluation presupposes that the original appraisal may have been erroneous; where such an error is corrected by revaluation, there is no logical basis to restrict the benefit to the mere declaration of a class.
  • If revaluation is accepted and ranking in respect of class is awarded to candidates who benefit from it, the court found no reason to deny them full benefits (including consideration for scholarships, prizes, medals and order of merit) that flow from their corrected marks.
  • The court agreed with the reasoning of the Karnataka High Court in Anjay Bansal and considered the provisions substantially similar, concluding that the discriminatory treatment attempted by the impugned clause could not be sustained under Article 14.

On this basis the court held that the second part of Ordinance 237-A could not be used to deprive the petitioner of the benefits that accrue from the accepted revised marks, and that the University's action embodied in Ex. F was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court made the rule absolute by quashing Ex. F and confirming Ex. D (the special certificate dated 17-8-1983). The court ordered that the parties bear their own costs.

Implications: The direct consequence is that the petitioner's status as first among successful candidates, as declared in Ex. D, stands; Ex. F is quashed. The opinion follows and applies the principle from Anjay Bansal that excluding accepted revised marks from consideration for scholarships, prizes, medals and order of merit is discriminatory under Article 14. The opinion does not elaborate broader novel precedent beyond applying the cited authority to the facts before it.

Rule made absolute.
Show all summary ...

1. This petition under Art. 226 of the Constitution questions the vires of the second part of Ordinance 237-A of the Ordinances and Regulations of the University of Bombay and Ex. F issued on the basis thereof.

2. The petitioner and the second respondent were students doing the Master of Commerce course from a College affiliated to the Bombay University. For obtaining a M.Com degree the candidate has to undergo two examinations conducted annually. Marks of both the examinations are aggregated for the purposes of ranking amongst the candidates. In the M.Com Part I examination the petitioner had applied for a revaluation of his answer books in the subject of Cost Accounting. Initially, he was awarded 54 marks out of 100 marks, and upon a revaluation was given revised marks of 71. In the Part II examination, petitioner secured 240 marks out of 400 marks. The total for the two examinations worked out to 502 marks out of 800 marks. On 17-8-1983, under the signature of the Registrar of University, a special certificate was sent to the petitioner proclaiming that he had stood first amongst a total number of 260 candidates who had passed from amongst 645 candidates who has appeared for the examination. In the next year on 30th March 1984 the University issued the communication at Ex. F bringing to the petitioner's notice the alleged error in proclaiming him the first amongst the successful candidates. This was on the basis of the impugned Ordinance. To appreciate the impugned provision in its proper perspective it will be necessary to reproduce the same in full:—

“The revised marks obtained by a candidate after revaluation as accepted by the University shall be taken into account for the purpose of amendment of his results in accordance with the rules of the University in that behalf, but these marks shall not be taken into account for the purpose of award of scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit.”

(Underlinings mine)

Admittedly, but for the application of the second part of the impugned Ordinance, the University would not be in a position to recall the special certificate awarded to the petitioner on 17-8-1983. The University takes the stand that whatever it has done is correct and that there is no substance in the challenge levelled to the vires of the impugned Ordinance.

3. Mr. More in support of the contention taken by his client relies upon Anjay Bansal v. Banglore University AIR 1990 Karnataka 225. The provision impugned in that decision was worded thus at page 226:—

“No revised rank will be declared in respect of those who get benefit in the revaluation (review) and no incidental benefit which accrue due to the revaluation (review) will be granted except, declaration of class.”

The similarity, if not the virtual identity, between the provision figuring in that case and the impugned Ordinance before me, is striking. The learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court held the afore-mentioned provision to be violative of the Constitutional guarantee of equality enshrined in Article 14 of the Constitution. Mr. Shankarnarayanan representing the Bombay University contends that the judgment relied upon by Mr. More proceeds on the erroneous assumption that an examinee who attains a superior rank in the course of an ordinary appraisal is equal to one who attains superiority pursuant to an applied for revaluation. Counsel submits that the two belong to two different classes and cannot be placed on an equal footing. It is not possible to agree with this submission. Both the candidates appear for one and the same examination in one and the same degree examination. They are examined in the same subjects and they are asked to give answers to the same questions. The level of competency expected from both is identical. In fact the very provision for a revaluation is based upon the possibility of the original appraisal being erroneous. If this be the case, I do not see why the result of the revaluation should be restricted to the declaration of a class and not render the candidate eligible for the purpose of award of scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit. Mr. Shankarnarayanan says that the element of subjectivity in examinations can never be ruled out and whereas the person succeeding on revaluation has the benefit of a re-appraisal of his product, those who appear at the ordinary examination are deprived of that benefit. But the converse of this argument is that one who should have got the benefit of that evaluation at the very first appraisal is deprived thereof, by virtue of what the University itself considers to be an error. If revaluation is permitted and if ranking in so far as class is concerned is awarded to candidates who get the benefit of a revaluation, there is no reason to restrict the result to the mere declaration of a class. The full benefit to the vindicated candidate has to be awarded and his marks have to be taken into account for the purpose of scholarships, prizes, medals and/or the order of merit. Agreeing with the learned single Judge of the Karnataka High Court I make the rule absolute by quashing Ex. F and confirming the correctness of Ex. D i.e the special certificate awarded on 17-8-1983. Rule in these terms is made absolute with parties being left to bear their own costs.

Rule made absolute.