Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Mahindra And Mahindra Ltd. v. Union Of India

Bombay High Court
Jul 23, 1990
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioners challenged orders passed by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise confirming demands of Rs. 67,928.53 and Rs. 53,650.96. They filed appeals before the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals), Bombay, along with applications for stay of the operation of these orders pending appeal. The Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) disposed of the stay applications without hearing the petitioners and declined to waive the pre-deposit required under Section 35F of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944. Consequently, due to non-deposit, one of the appeals was dismissed. The petitioners sought relief against the dismissal and the refusal to grant stay.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) erred in disposing of stay applications without giving the petitioners an opportunity of being heard, thereby violating the principles of natural justice.
  2. Whether the dismissal of the appeal for non-compliance with the pre-deposit requirement under Section 35F of the Excise Act was justified in the absence of a hearing on the stay applications.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • The petitioners contended that the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) wrongly disposed of the stay applications without hearing them.
  • They argued that they had a strong prima facie case and that it was just and convenient to grant stay of payment pending appeal disposal.
  • They challenged the dismissal of the appeal resulting from non-deposit of the amount confirmed by the Assistant Collector.

Court's Observations on Arguments

  • The court agreed with the petitioners that the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) violated the principle of natural justice by not affording a hearing before passing adverse orders on stay applications.
  • The court emphasized that stay applications are independent proceedings and require oral submissions before disposal.
  • The court noted that the prior consistent practice was to hear parties, and there was no justification for departure from this practice.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analyzed that the principle of natural justice mandates that no adverse order be passed without hearing the concerned party. The Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) had erred in disposing of the stay applications without affording the petitioners an opportunity to be heard. The court recognized that stay applications are separate proceedings distinct from the main appeal and require oral submissions before an order is passed. The orders refusing waiver of pre-deposit and dismissing one appeal for non-compliance were therefore unsustainable. The court directed that the matter be remitted to the Collector for fresh disposal after hearing the petitioners on the stay applications.

Holding and Implications

The court set aside the two orders dated June 8, 1990, refusing stay and the order dated June 29, 1990, dismissing one appeal due to non-compliance with Section 35F of the Excise Act. The proceedings were remitted back to the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) for fresh disposal of the stay applications after providing the petitioners an opportunity to be heard.

The direct effect is that the petitioners will have their stay applications reconsidered with a hearing, and the dismissed appeal is reinstated for adjudication. No new precedent was established beyond reinforcing the requirement of natural justice in stay proceedings before the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals).

Show all summary ...

Rule, returnable forthwith.

Shri Shah waives service on behalf of the respondents.

Heard counsel.

1. The grievance of the petitioners is that the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals), Bombay has disposed of the applications for stay of the order passed by the Assistant Collector of Central Excise during pendency of the appeal without giving them an opportunity of being heard. The petitioners also complain that consequently because of the failure to comply with the provisions of Section 35F of the Central Excises and Salt Act, 1944 the appeal was dismissed by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals).

2. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise passed on order on December 29, 1989 against that petitioner confirming the demand amount of Rs. 67,928.53. The Assistant Collector had also passed another order confirming the demand of Rs. 53,650.96. In respect of these two orders the petitioners preferred appeal before the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals), Bombay. The petitioners also filed application for stay of the operation of the order pending the appeal. The petitioners claimed that they have very good prima facie case on merits, and therefore, it would be just and convenient to grant stay of the payment of amount ordered by the Assistant Collector pending hearing and final disposal of the appeal. Both the stay applications were disposed of by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) without giving any hearing to the petitioner and holding that he was not satisfied that pre-deposit required under section 35f of the excise act would cause undue hardship to the petitioner as to warrant a waiver of the same. As a consequence of the failure of the petitioner to deposit the amount confirmed by the Assistant Collector, the appeal in respect of demand of Rs. 67,928.53 was dismissed. The petitioners challenge the order declining stay and dismissal of one of the appeals.

3. Shri Korde, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the petitioners, is right in his submission that the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) was in error in disposing of the stay application without giving any hearing to the petitioners. In the system which we have adopted, it is the principle of natural justice that no adverse order should be passed against any party without giving him a hearing. It was the consistent practice followed by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) for over several years and there was no reason why the present authority should have made departure from the same. It is not proper for the authority to merely read the stay application and pass order adverse against the petitioners. The authority should realise that an application for stay is a proceeding independent of the appeal filed against the order of the Assistant Collector. The Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) shall hear the parties when an application for stay is filed, and only after hearing the oral submissions should dispose of the stay application. The two orders passed by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) refusing to waive the pre-deposit required under Section 35-F of the Excise Act therefore can sustained. The consequential order dismissing one of the appeal also cannot be sustained. The proceedings are therefore required to the remitted back to the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) with a direction that the authority shall give hearing to the petitioner in respect of two applications for stay in respect of two appeals preferred and thereafter pass appropriate orders.

4. Accordingly, petition succeeds and the two orders dated June 8, 1990 passed by the Collector of Central Excise (Appeals) on the stay applications filed by the petitioner in respect of two appeals are set aside and proceedings are remitted back to the Collector for fresh disposal of the two stay applications. The order dated June 29, 1990 dismissing an appeal for non-compliance of section 35f of the excise act is also set aside.

5. There will be no order as to costs.