- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Assistant Collector Of Customs v. Smt. Maria Rege And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
The Collector of Customs filed a Criminal Writ Petition challenging two orders of the Judicial Magistrate, F.C., Margao (dated 7 April 1990 and 11 April 1990) in Criminal Misc. Application No. 30.C/90. On 18 February 1990 an Assistant Collector of Customs raided the residence of respondent No.1 (Smt. Rege) at Merces Wadi and seized currency notes amounting to Rs. 22,000 on a reasonable belief of involvement in smuggling. On 31 March 1990 respondent No.1 applied to the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Margao for release of the seized currency. On 7 April 1990 (when the acting Judicial Magistrate, F.C., was functioning as Chief Judicial Magistrate) the court ordered release of the Rs. 22,000 to respondent No.1. The Assistant Collector then approached higher courts, but respondent No.1 filed an application for non-compliance and contempt; on 11 April 1990 the trial Judge directed the Assistant Collector to comply with the earlier order. Both orders are challenged in the present writ petition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a Magistrate has jurisdiction under section 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure to deal with property seized by an Assistant Collector of Customs (i.e., property seized by a Customs Officer rather than a Police Officer).
- Whether a Customs Officer qualifies as a "Police Officer" within the meaning of section 457 Cr.P.C. and related definitions enabling Magistrate's jurisdiction over seized property.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's (Assistant Collector of Customs) Arguments
- The learned Magistrate lacked jurisdiction to entertain an application under section 457 Cr.P.C. because that section applies only to property "seized by a Police Officer."
- The Assistant Collector of Customs is not a Police Officer; the Criminal Courts therefore cannot pass orders regarding disposal of property seized by a Customs Officer.
- No proceedings had been taken by the Assistant Collector under the Customs inquiry; the matter was pending with Customs, and at that stage the Magistrate had no jurisdiction under section 457.
- Prayed that the impugned order of 7-4-1990 and the subsequent direction of 11-4-1990 be quashed and set aside.
Respondent No.1 (Smt. Rege) Arguments
- Because the property was seized by an officer of the Customs Department and respondent No.1 apprehended criminal prosecution, she was justified in approaching the Criminal Court for release of property she alleged was wrongly seized.
- Supported the impugned order directing release of the seized currency.
Public Prosecutor's Arguments
- The Public Prosecutor adopted the same stance as counsel for the petitioner, i.e., that the Magistrate lacked jurisdiction under section 457 as the seizure was not by a Police Officer.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| P.O Thomas v. Union of India | Supports that a seizure effected by a Customs Officer and action taken by a Magistrate do not confer jurisdiction under section 457 Cr.P.C. | The court relied on this Division Bench Kerala High Court decision (1990 Cri. L.J. 1028) as supporting authority that seizures by Customs Officers are not cognizable under section 457. |
| State Of Punjab v. Barkat Ram | Supreme Court authority relied upon in support of the principle applied in P.O Thomas (cited as part of the foundation for the view that non-police seizures fall outside s.457). | The opinion notes the decision of P.O Thomas is based on reported decisions of the Supreme Court including this case; the court treated these Supreme Court authorities as supportive of its conclusion on jurisdiction. |
| State Of West Bengal v. S.N Basak. | Supreme Court authority relied upon in the line of decisions addressing the scope of "Police Officer" and criminal court jurisdiction. | Cited (via the P.O Thomas decision) as part of the Supreme Court precedents supporting the proposition that section 457 applies to seizures by Police Officers. |
| Badaku Joti Svant v. State Of Mysore | Supreme Court authority cited in the cluster of cases underpinning the court's jurisdictional analysis under section 457. | Referenced (through P.O Thomas) as a Supreme Court decision forming part of the basis for holding that seizures by non-police officers are not within s.457 jurisdiction. |
| Babulal Lodhi v. State of Madhya Pradesh | High Court decision holding that a Forest Officer is not a Police Officer within the meaning of the Cr.P.C., so a seizure by such an officer cannot be taken cognizance of by a Criminal Court under section 457. | The court cited this Madhya Pradesh High Court decision (1987 Cri. L.J. 1709) as a similar precedent to support the conclusion regarding Customs Officers not being Police Officers for purposes of section 457. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court examined Chapter XXXIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure and identified section 457 as the provision covering "disposal of property seized by the Police." A textual reading of section 457 indicates jurisdiction is conferred on the Magistrate only in respect of property “seized by a Police Officer” during inquiry or trial. The court observed that the Cr.P.C. does not define the general term “Police,” though the phrase "Officer in charge of a Police Station" is defined in section 2(o). It noted that under the Bombay Police Act a "Police Officer" is defined as one belonging to the police cadre above the rank of constable, and that the Customs Act does not define Customs Officers or Assistant Collectors as Police Officers.
On this textual and statutory basis the court concluded that Customs Officers are not Police Officers and therefore seizures effected by them do not fall within the ambit of section 457. The court reinforced this conclusion by reference to relevant case law: it relied on the Kerala High Court decision in P.O Thomas v. Union of India, which itself was based on reported Supreme Court decisions (State Of Punjab v. Barkat Ram; State Of West Bengal v. S.N Basak; Badaku Joti Svant v. State Of Mysore). The court also cited Babulal Lodhi v. State of Madhya Pradesh, where a Forest Officer's seizure was held outside section 457. Applying these authorities and the statutory text, the court held the Magistrate had no jurisdiction to pass the impugned orders.
The court also recorded that an additional ground regarding the territorial jurisdiction of the Margao Criminal Court was raised by counsel for the petitioner but was not pressed in view of the primary jurisdictional finding.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Criminal Writ Petition is allowed; the impugned orders dated 7th April, 1990 and 11th April, 1990 are quashed and set aside.
Implications: As a direct consequence, the Magistrate's orders directing release and directing compliance with release of the seized Rs. 22,000 are annulled. The court's decision rests on the jurisdictional conclusion that section 457 Cr.P.C. applies only to property seized by Police Officers and that Customs Officers are not Police Officers for this purpose. The opinion does not articulate any broader changes to precedent beyond relying on and applying existing decisions; it addresses the direct effect on the parties by setting aside the Magistrate's orders.
S.W Puranik, J.:— Feeling aggrieved by the order dated 7th April, 1990 passed by the Judicial Magistrate, F.C, Margao, Goa in Criminal Misc. Application No. 30.C/90 the Collector of Customs has preferred this Criminal Writ Petition seeking the same to be quashed and set aside on the following facts.
2. On a reasonable belief that respondent No. 1 along with others is invloved in smuggling activities and further on the reasonable belief that respondent No. 1 had her residence at Merces Wadi, Taluka Tiswadi, is in posession of certain currency notes directly related to the offence of smuggling goods, carried out a raid on the house of respondent No. 1 on 18th February, 1990 and seized currency notes worth Rs. 22,000/- from the said house.
3. On 31st March, 1990, respondent No. 1 Smt Rege moved an application before the Chief Judicial Magistrate, Margao seeking lelease of the currency notes seized from her residence by the Assistant Collector. On 7-4-1990 the said application came up for hearing after notice to the Collector of Customs and was taken up by the Judicial Magistrate, F.C, Margao who was on that day acting as Chief Judicial Magis trate. Upon hearing both the parties, the learned trial Judge passed the impugned order directing the release of currency notes of Rs. 22,000/- in favour of respondent No. 1. By the time the Assistant Collector could move the higher Courts, the respondent No. 1 also Hied an application for non-compliance and contempt of the trial Court's order. That application was filed on 11th April, 1990 on which day the trial Judge directed the Assistant Collector to comply with his earlier order of 7-4-1990.
4. Both these orders are challenged by the Assistant Collector in this writ petition.
5. Shri Khandeparkar, the learned Counsel appearing for the petitioner, contended that the learned Magistrate did not have jurisdiction to deal with an application under section 457 of the Cr. P.C preferred by the respondent No. 1. According to him the Assistant Collector of Customs is not a Police Officer and as such the Criminal Courts do not have any jurisdiction to pass orders regarding disposal of property seized by a Customs Officer, in the present case according to him the Assistant Collector of Customs had not taken any proceedings either and the matter was pending inquiry with the Customs. At that stage according to Shri Khandeparkar, the learned Magistrate does not get any jurisdiction under section 457 since the Customs Officer is not a Police Officer. He therefore prayed that the impugned order be quashed and set aside as also the further direction dated 11-4-1990 to comply with the order.
6. Shri Diniz, the learned Counsel appearing for respondent No. 1 urged that since the property has been seized by an oficer of the Customs Department and the respondent No. 1 was apprehending criminal prosecution in respect thereof, the respondent No. 1 was justified in approaching the Criminal Court for the necessary relief of release of property which according to the respondent was wrongly seized. He therefore supported the impugned order.
7. Shri Bhobe, the learned Public Presecutor however took up the same stand as that of the Counsel for the petitioner.
8. Chapter XXXIV of the Code of Criminal Procedure deals with disposal of property. Section 451 deals with orders regarding custody and disposal of property pending trials in certain cases. section 452 of the code deals with orders for disposal of property at conclusion of trials, while section 453 deals with payment to innocent purchaser of money found on the accused. Section 454 deals regarding right of appeal against orders passed under sections 452 or 453. Section 455 deals with destruction of libellous and other matters, while section 456 deals with power to restore possession of immovable property. All these provisions are not applicable to the present case which deals with “disposal of property seized by the Police” which is covered by section 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
9. A perusal of section 457 clearly indicates that the Magistrate gets jurisdiction to deal with property “seized by a Police Officer” during inquiry or trial. It is therefore clear that unless the property in question has been seized by a Police Officer during inquiry or trial the Criminal Court will not get jurisdiction under section 457 to deal with such seizures.
10. In the instant case the seizure has been effected by the Assistant Collector of Customs. The word “Police” has not been defined under the Criminal Procedure Code. But the words “Officer in charge of a Police Station” has been defined in section 2(o). It states that the Officer in charge of a police station includes, when the officer in charge of the police station is absent from the station-house or unable from illness or other cause to perform his duties, the police officer present at the station-house who is next in rank to such officer and is above the rank of constable or, when the State Government so directs, any other Police Officer so present.
11. Even under the Bombay Police Act, “Police Officer” is defined to be one belonging to the Police cadre above the rank of a constable. The Customs Act does not define the Customs Officer or Assistant Collector as a Police Officer. It is in these circumstances I have no hesitation to held that the Customs Officers are not Police Officers. Consequently the Customs Officers is not a Police Officer and the seizure of property effected by him and the disposal thereof cannot be taken cognizance of by a Criminal Court under section 457 of the Code of Criminal Procedure. I am supported in this view by the decision of the Division Bench of the Kerala High Court in (P.O Thomas v. Union of India)1, reported in 1990 Cri. L.J, 1028. The said case also relates to a seizure effected by Customs Officer and action taken by the Magistrate thereupon. The said decision is based on reported decisions of the Supreme Court in (State Of Punjab v. Barkat Ram )2, reported in A.I.R 1962 S.C 276 (State Of West Bengal v. S.N Basak.)3, reported in A.I.R 1963 S.C 447 and (Badaku Joti Svant v. State Of Mysore)4, A.I.R 1966 S.C, 1746. Similar is the view expressed by a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in (Babulal Lodhi v. State of Madhya Pradesh)5, reported in 1987 Cri. L.J, 1709. In the said case the seizure was effected by a Forest Range Officer and the order passed under section 457 Cr. P.C came to be challenged. The High Court held that the Forest Officer is not a Police Officer within the meaning of the Criminal Precedure Code and the seizure cannot be taken cognizance of by a Criminal Court under section 457 of the Code.
12. In view of the above reasoning it is clear that the Magistrate had no jurisdiction whatsoever since the seizure in question was effected by a ‘Customs Officer’ and not a ‘Police Officer’. The order being impugned is liable to be quashed and set aside.
13. Shri Khandeparkar had also taken up the ground of jurisdiction of Margao Criminal Court in respect of the seizure held at Merces Waddi, Taluka Tiswadi. However, in view of the above finding he does not press the other ground.
14. In the result the Criminal Writ Petition is allowed.. The impugned orders dated 7th April, 1990 and 11th April, 1990 are quashed and set aside.
Petition allowed.
Alert