- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Asaram Bhavandin Yadav v. State Of Maharashtra .
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant was originally accused No. 4 in Criminal Case No. 23 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Dhule. The accused were charged, inter alia, under section 3 read with section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act; other offences were also charged but described as not very material for the appeal.
The learned Additional Sessions Judge acquitted original accused Nos. 1, 2 and 3 of all offences but convicted original accused No. 4 (the present appellant) under section 3 read with section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act. The sentence imposed on the appellant was one day's simple imprisonment till the rising of Court and a fine of Rs. 1,000/-, with default R.I. for three months. The appellant preferred the present appeal against that conviction and sentence.
The formal charge (dated 2 February 1988) as framed by the trial Judge was reproduced in the record. In summary, the charge alleged that on 5-1-1987 at about 7:30 PM on Agra Road accused Nos. 1 and 2 were found in possession of 13 bags of wheat and 4 bags of rice; a second charge linked accused Nos. 3 and 4 (the appellant) to facilitating the sale/removal of those commodities from a fair price shop (contravening a sub-clause of Maharashtra Foodgrains Rationing Regulations); a third charge alleged forgery (section 465 read with 34 IPC) by accused Nos. 2 and 4 in relation to documents to enable the sale.
At trial the learned Judge found (paragraph 7 of judgment) that wheat and rice were available in the open market and that wheat had been deleted from Schedule No. 1 by government notification dated 24-11-1986; further, there was no prosecution evidence to show that certain bags were issued from a government godown or fair price shop. On that basis the Judge held that the first charge (relating to the seized commodities on Agra Road) was not proved and acquitted the accused on that charge.
Nevertheless, in paragraph 8 of the judgment the trial Judge relied on a subsequent police panchanama at the appellant's fair price shop, noting shortages in stock, and concluded from those shortages that the appellant had disposed of material unlawfully on the black market. The appellant's counsel contended that those facts were not part of the framed charge, that the appellant was not confronted with them, and that no admission was recorded under the Court's 313 inquiry in relation to those shortages; it was submitted that convicting on the basis of those uncharged facts vitiated the conviction.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a conviction may be sustained where the trial Court records a finding against an accused based on facts that do not form the subject matter of the framed charge.
- Whether, when facts emerge in evidence suggesting offences under the same statutory sections but different factual incidents, the trial Court may proceed to convict without framing a separate charge for those distinct facts.
- Whether the non-framing of a charge in respect of a separate incident is an incurable defect (resulting in failure of justice) or is an irregularity that can be remedied by framing a charge and recommencing trial pursuant to section 464 of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
- If a failure of justice is found, whether the appellate court should exercise its discretion to order framing of a charge and recommencement of trial, or whether the conviction should simply be quashed without remand.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments (Mr. Navin Shah)
- The charge as framed was limited to the incident of 5-1-1987 (seizure on Agra Road) and therefore the case the accused was required to meet was circumscribed by that charge.
- The trial Judge's findings show that the seizure-related charge was not proved (wheat and rice were available in open market; wheat removed from Schedule), so the Judge could not validly convict on a different incident.
- The conviction rested on facts (shortages noticed at the appellant's shop in the panchanama) that were not the subject matter of the charge; the appellant was not confronted with those facts nor did he make any admission in response to a 313 inquiry — thus he was convicted without a proper charge, vitiating the conviction.
Prosecution's Arguments (Mr. Patil, Public Prosecutor)
- The trial Judge's procedure was justified because if, in the course of trial, facts emerge in evidence indicating that offences under the same sections of law have been committed, it is not necessary to frame a separate charge for those facts.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Kantilal's case, (1969) 3 SCC 166 : AIR 1970 SC 359 | Illustrates that omission to frame a charge can occasion a failure of justice and that, where such failure occurs, the trial may need to be recommenced from the stage after framing the proper charge. | The Court referred to this authority when discussing the remedy under section 464 CrPC and the circumstances in which a retrial should be ordered; it used the case to support the proposition that omission to frame a charge resulting in failure of justice can justify restarting the trial. |
| Dalchand v. State, 1982 Cr. L.J. 1487 (Delhi High Court) | Holds that where an accused was charged for various offences but no specific and separate charge was framed for a particular grave offence (section 302 IPC), conviction under that uncharged offence prejudiced the accused and therefore conviction and sentence were set aside. | The Court cited this decision as an example where prejudice caused by non-framing of a specific charge led to quashing of conviction, supporting the result reached in the present case that prejudice from omission requires quashing. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court conducted a step-by-step legal analysis rooted in the statutory scheme of Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure and the trial record.
- Examination of the charge: The Court noted that the charge as framed was specifically confined to the first incident (seizure on Agra Road on 5-1-1987) and that the second set of factual circumstances (shortages observed at the appellant's fair price shop during the police panchanama) were distinct and not pleaded in the charge.
- Findings at trial: The trial Judge himself found that the first charge (the Agra Road seizure) was not proved — wheat had been deleted from the relevant schedule and there was no evidence linking some bags to the government godown/fair price shop. Thus the framed charge was disproved on the evidence.
- Reliance on uncharged facts: Despite the failure of proof in relation to the framed charge, the trial Judge convicted the appellant on the basis of the second incident (shortages at the shop) which had not been the subject of the framed charge. The Court identified that the appellant had not been confronted with these facts nor had he admitted them in his 313 statement, which meant he lacked an opportunity to meet that case.
- Statutory requirements and protections: The Court outlined statutory features of a valid charge (section 211 — contents; section 212 — particulars of time, place and person; section 216 — power to alter charge but with obligation to give accused opportunity; section 218 — separate charge for each distinct offence; sections 219 and 220 — related procedural provisions). The Court emphasized that these requirements protect the accused's right to fair notice and to prepare a defence, and cannot be bypassed.
- On cure and failure of justice: The Court applied section 464 CrPC which permits conviction not to be set aside merely because a charge was not framed unless it resulted in failure of justice, and authorizes framing of a charge and recommencing trial if failure has occurred. The Court held that here there was a failure of justice: the accused was prejudiced by absence of a charge in respect of the second incident because he was not given an opportunity to explain or defend those facts.
- Discretion on retrial: Having found failure of justice, the Court considered whether to exercise its discretion under section 464 to order a framing of a charge and recommencement of trial. The Court weighed factors such as passage of time, change of circumstances and whether a retrial would serve any useful purpose. Observing that the charges were of a trivial nature and that, on scrutiny of the record and investigation, remanding for retrial would not be useful, the Court declined to order a retrial and instead quashed the conviction.
- Reliance on precedent: The Court referenced Kantilal's case and Dalchand v. State as instructive authorities on remedies and prejudice resulting from omission to frame a charge and used them to frame its conclusion that prejudice had occurred and that conviction must be set aside.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal was allowed. The conviction and sentence of the appellant were set aside. The fine, if paid, was ordered to be refunded to the appellant.
Implications:
- Direct effect on parties: The appellant's conviction and sentence are quashed and any fine paid must be refunded. The Court declined to order framing of a fresh charge and a retrial because it exercised its discretion against remand — the Court concluded remanding would not serve any useful purpose given the trivial nature of the charges and the record of investigation.
- Precedential effect: The opinion applies established statutory standards and cited authorities (including Kantilal and Dalchand) to reinforce the principle that an accused must be tried on the charge as framed and must be given an opportunity to meet any facts relied upon; the Court did not purport to lay down a new principle of law. There is no indication in the text that the Court intended to set a new, broader precedent beyond applying existing law to the facts of this case.
Appeal allowed.
1. The appellant in this case was the original accused No. 4 in Criminal Case No. 23 before the Additional Sessions Judge, Dhule. The appellant along with the other accused was charged with having committed offences punishable under section 3 read with section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act. The accused were also charged with certain other offences which are not very material for the purposes of the decision of this appeal.
2. The learned Additional Sessions Judge acquitted the original accused Nos. 1, 2 and 3 of all the offences with which they stood charged but as far as original accused No. 4 i.e the present appellant is concerned, the learned Additional Sessions Judge convicted him for having committed an offence punishable under section 3 read with section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act. The accused was sentenced to one day's simple imprisonment till the rising of the Court and to pay a fine of Rs. 1,000/- in default, R.I for three months. It is against this order of conviction and sentence that the present appeal has been preferred.
3. Mr. Navin Shah, learned counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant has raised a point of procedure that is fundamental to all criminal trials. Mr. Shah, in the first instance, has drawn my attention to the charge framed by the learned Additional Sessions Judge on the 2nd of February 1988. Since this issue is of some importance, the charge that was framed is reproduced below:
“CHARGE:
I. Shri M.N Ahmed, Additional Sessions Judge of Dhule, hereby charge you:
1. Asaram Dadlat Patil, age 46 years, residing at Thalner, Taluka Shripur.
2. Shantilal Bhagchand Jain, age 32 years, residing at Thalner, Taluka Shripur.
3. Ramkishore @ Kalya Asaram Yadav, age 32 years, residing at Palasner, Taluka Shripur.
4. Asaram Bhavandin Yadav, age 64 years, residing at Palasner, Taluka Shripur, Dist. Dhule.
As follows:
That you accused Nos. 1 and 2 on 5-1-1987 at about 7.30 P.M on Agra Road near Aadhe Fata, were found in possession of 13 bags of wheat and 4 bags of rice, which was not available in the market and which is only sold in the fair price shop on ration card i.e on document cards, and thus contravened clauses 5, 7 and 20 of the Order of Maharashtra Scheduled Commodities Regulation and Distribution, 1975, under section 3 of the Essential Commodities Act, and thereby committed an offence punishable under section 7 of the said Act, and within my cognizance.
Secondly, on the same date, time and place, you accused No. 3 a salesman of fair price shop of Palasner, Mohida and Wakwad, and you accused No. 4 being the owner of fair price shop of Palasner sold above ration articles pamely 13 bags of wheat and 4 bags of rice to the accused Nos. 1 and 2, and thereby failed to distribute the same through your establishment or shop for whom they were ordered within 24 hours of receipt of the said indent from the Government godown, and thereby contravened sub-clause 3(a) of clause 18 of Maharashtra Foodgrains Rationing (Second) Regulations, 1966, and thereby committed an offence punishable under section 7 of the Essential Commodities Act and within my cognizance.
Thirdly, you accused Nos. 2 and 4 on the same date, time and place, forged certain documents, to wit, rationing cards, receipt books, stock registers etc., with intent to commit fraud i.e to sell the above ration goods to the accused Nos. 1 and 2, and that you thereby committed an offence punishable under section 465 read with 34 of the Indian Penal Code and within my cognizance.
And I hereby direct that you be tried by me on the aforesaid charges.
Dated this the 2nd day of February 1988.”
4. A perusal of the charge that has been framed will indicate that the entire charge proceeds on the footing that on 5-1-1987, the accused Nos. 1 and 2 were apprehended by the police on Agra Road at which time, they were found in possession of 13 bags of wheat and 4 bags of rice. It is in respect of this particular commodity alone that the learned Judge has framed the first charge against accused Nos. 1 and 2. As far as the second charge is concerned, it is alleged that accused Nos. 3 and 4 had facilitated the wrongful removal and disposal of essential commodities i.e the very same commodities that were seized by the police on 5-1-1987 at 7.30 p.m The third charge also is very specifically linked up with the same incident and it deals with the consequent fabrication of certain records in relation to the subject matter of the goods that were seized by the police. It is the submission of Mr. Shah that the case that the accused was asked to meet was one that was limited and circumscribed to the facts and circumstances as set out in the charge that was framed. He has drawn my attention to the findings of the learned Judge which are at paragraph 7 of the judgment. The learned Judge has very clearly recorded that it is not in dispute that wheat and rice were available in the open market and that wheat was deleted from Schedule No. 1 of the Maharashtra Food Grains Dealers Licensing Order, 1963 by the Government Notification dated 24-11-1986. Furthermore, the learned Judge has observed: “We have no evidence from the prosecution to come to the conclusion that the other 10 bags of wheat and 1 bag of rice were of fair price shop or issued by the Government from Government Godown”. The learned Judge has, therefore, concluded that there is absolutely no evidence to conclude that the accused Nos. 1 and 2 contravened the provisions of the Maharashtra Scheduled Commodities (Regulation of Distribution) Order, 1975. In the light of these findings, it is the submission of Mr. Shah that as far as the ingredients of the charge that was framed are concerned, the learned Judge has very clearly acquitted all the accused and that, consequently, there is no warrant for the subsequent procedure adopted by the learned Judge in the judgment.
5. In paragraph 8 of the judgment, the learned Judge has observed that on the same evening, when the police visited the fair price shop of the appellant and drew up a panchanama, certain shortages were noticed by the police in respect of the stocks that ought to have been found there. It is the conclusion of the learned Judge that by virtue of these shortages that were noticed by the police from the shop of the original accused No. 4, it can reasonably be concluded that he had disposed of that material unlawfully and in the black-market. Mr. Shah has submitted that in the first instance, these facts were not the subject matter of the charge and secondly, a perusal of the evidence on record will indicate that the appellant had not been confronted with this aspect nor is there any admission on his part in the 313 statement recorded by the Court. Under these circumstances, it is the submission of Mr. Shah that the conviction of the present appellant would virtually amount to the accused having been convicted without even a proper charge having been framed and consequently, the conviction is vitiated and is liable to be set aside.
6. There is considerable substance in the submission advanced by Mr. Shah when Chapter 17 of the Code of Criminal Procedure and in particular. Sections 211, 212, 213 and 214 very clearly spell out the manner in which the charge is required to be framed in a criminal trial. It is basic that as far as the framing of a charge is concerned, not only should all material particulars be set out but, furthermore, the particulars as to time, place and person as also the provisions of law that are alleged to have been contravened must be spelt out in the charge. This is an essential requirement for the reason that in a criminal trial where the accused is required to enter upon his defence, and where the consequences to the accused person are serious in so far as an adverse verdict would result in the loss of his liberty, no allowance can be made in respect of a charge that may be found to be defective or wanting in material particulars. It is essential to point out that under section 216 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, it is open to the Court at any subsequent state of the trial to alter the charge, to give the accused a fair opportunity of meeting that charge and to thereafter pronounce judgment. Under no circumstances, however, would a court be justified in recording a finding against an accused person in respect of facts that do not form the subject matter of the charge.
7. Mr. Patil, the learned Public Prosecutor has sought to justify the procedure adopted by the learned Judge by submitting that if in the course of the trial, it came to the notice of the Court that on basis of the certain set of facts that emerge in evidence, offences under the very same sections of law have been committed, then, it would not be necessary for the trial Judge to frame a separate charge. This submission, however, is unacceptable for the reason that if such a procedure is to be sanctioned, not only would it be in breach of the specific provisions of Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure, but it would result in miscarriage of justice in so far as the accused who is facing trial before the Court is concerned and who is required to enter his defence only to the charges that are framed against him, would be seriously handicapped and would also be prejudiced inasmuch as he would be taken totally unaware. There is no legal sanction for condoning the breach of the strict procedure that has been laid down in Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure.
8. Chapter XVII of the Code of Criminal Procedure is quite explicit with regard to the principles relating to the constitution of a valid charge. Section 211 specifies the contents of charge generally, and lays down seven broad features that govern the basic structure of a valid charge viz., that the charge shall state the offence, the name or description of the offence of if the law does not specifically name the offence, so much of the definition as will give the accused notice of the charge with which he is charged, the law and the section of the law, the fact that the necessary legal conditions required by law to constitute the offence charged were fulfilled and further, that the charge shall be written in the language of the Court and that if the accused was previously convicted and is liable, by reason of such conviction, to enhanced punishment or to punishment of a different kind, the particulars of the previous offence. It is a further requirement as per section 212 of the code, that the particulars as to the time, place and person in respect of which the offence was committed be set out in a manner as reasonably sufficient to give notice to the accused of the matter with which he is charged. Furthermore, in those of the cases where the nature of the offence is such that the particulars mentioned aforesaid do not give the accused sufficient notice of the matter with which he is charged, it is necessary that the charge should contain such particulars of the manner in which the alleged offence was committed. These are statutory pre-requisites which can neither be watered down nor by-passed because any defect in the charge would have serious repercussions on the validity of the trial. It is, however, true that under section 216 of the code, it is open to a Court to alter or add to any charge and the natural consequences followed, that if the accused is prejudiced by any such alteration, that the Court shall, if necessary, follow the procedure prescribed in section 217 of the code by recalling the witnesses.
9. In addition to these mandatory requirements, section 218 of the code very clearly specifies that there shall be a separate charge for every distinct offence with which a person is charged and that an accused shall be tried separately in respect of every such charge. section 219 of the code prescribes the situation in which three offences of the same kind within a year may be charged together, and section 220 further prescribes that at one trial, an accused may be tried for more than one offence with the series of acts so connected together to form the same transaction.
10. It is necessary to consider whether, in the light of the submissions advanced by Mr. Shah, the present trial is vitiated or whether, the non-framing of a charge in respect of the second and later incident is a mere irregularity or whether it is curable. In the first instance, it is a fundamental principle of criminal jurisprudence that the charge as framed must be proved. In the present case, the charge as framed confines itself to the first incident relating to the seizure and admittedly, on the finding of the learned trial Judge, this charge was not proved. It is only a logical consequence that on the basis of this charge, the learned Judge could not have held that some other offence stands proved. Conversely, having regard to the aforesaid provisions of the Code, before holding that the second set of facts established an offence, it was the primary duty of the trial Court to have framed a charge in respect of those offences and in the absence of a charge, the trial Court could never have held the offences proved on the second set of facts.
11. It is unnecessary to elaborate on this aspect of the matter except to consider the effect of section 464 of the code which clearly specifies that such a finding or sentence of a Court shall not be set aside merely on the ground that a charge was not framed or that a charge was defective unless it has resulted in a failure of justice. In such a case, where failure of justice has in fact occasioned, the Court is empowered to order that a charge be framed and the trial be recommenced from the point immediately after the framing of the charge. The proviso to this section, however, states that if in the opinion of the Court, the facts of the case are such that no valid charge could be framed against the accused in respect of the facts proved, it shall quash the conviction. In Kantilal's case, reported in (1969) 3 SCC 166 : AIR 1970 SC 359, the Supreme Court observed that there was a failure of justice due to the omission to frame a charge against the accused and that, Consequently, the trial should be recommenced from that stage. On the other hand, the Delhi High Court in Dalchand v. State, 1982 Cr. L.J 1487, held that where an accused was charged for various offences, including under section 302, Indian Penal Code read with section 149, but no specific and separate charge under section 302 was made, but he was convicted under that section, held that the accused had been prejudiced in his defence and, therefore, the conviction as well as sentence were set aside.
12. Applying these tests to the facts of the present case, there can be no manner of doubt that the non-framing of a charge in respect of the second set of circumstances has seriously prejudiced the accused, because he was neither afforded an opportunity to explain these circumstances, as he could have done, nor was he able to put forward an adequate defence to that effect. It must, therefore, be held that there was a failure of justice and consequently, the conviction in respect of this set of facts would have to be quashed.
13. The last question that remains to be determined is as to whether this Court should direct that a charge be framed and that the trial should be re-commenced. This is a discretionary power vested in the Court for the obvious reason that with the passage of time, the change of circumstances and an overall consideration of the facts of the case, the Court would have to decide as to whether any useful purpose would be served by remanding the matter to the trial Court. One of the material considerations is a scrutiny of the record, which would indicate as to whether the set of facts present a degree of seriousness or whether they are of a trivial nature. An appeal Court would also be justified in evaluating as to whether in the overall circumstances of the case, those set of facts are likely to result in a conviction or whether such a situation is a remote possibility. I am of the view, that having regard to the investigation carried out and the record of this case and the fact that the charges are of a trivial nature, that no useful purpose would be served by remanding this case for a retrial and consequently, I am not inclined to pass any such order.
14. In the result, the appeal is allowed. The conviction and sentence of the appellant are set aside. The fine, if paid, is directed to be refunded to the appellant.
Appeal allowed.
Alert