- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Kerbaji Maroti Rao Shinde v. State Of Maharashtra And Others
Judicial Opinion Summary — C.S. Dharmadhikari, A.C.J.
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner was elected Chairman of Harbal Seva Sahakari Society on 15 August 1981 for a three-year term and was elected a Director of Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh in 1982 for a five-year term. The petitioner had taken (i) a loan from respondent No.5 (Maharashtra State Co-operative Land Development Bank Ltd.) in 1971 for purchase of an electric motor repayable in ten yearly instalments (with the petitioner stating the last instalment was due in 1981–1982), and (ii) a loan of Rs. 6,300 in 1973 for construction of a well repayable in ten equal instalments (last instalment due in 1987–1988). The petitioner asserted earlier loan of Rs. 3,000 had been paid within ten years and that instalments were being paid regularly. Respondent No.5 instructed a sugar factory (Sakhar Karkhana) to deduct amounts due from the petitioner from bills payable to him under a practice recognised by Section 48(A) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960.
Despite that arrangement, and at the instance of interested persons, the Deputy Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, by letter dated 9 August 1983, informed the petitioner that he had ceased to be a Director of the Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh under Rule 58(2) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961. The petitioner challenged that intimation by filing the present writ petition on various grounds.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner was a "defaulter" within the meaning of Rule 58(1) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961 (i.e., whether he incurred a disqualification under Rule 58).
- Whether the Deputy Registrar could, by issuing an intimation under Rule 58(2), cause a member to cease to hold office without first taking recourse to Section 78 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act (i.e., whether Rule 58(2) is self-operative or requires an order under Section 78).
- Whether Rule 58(2) is solely consequential (not conferring power) and therefore an order under Section 78 is mandatory before cessation of membership can be effected.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Shri Godhamgaokar)
- Factually and legally the petitioner was not a defaulter under Rule 58.
- No order or intimation under Rule 58(2) could be issued by the Deputy Registrar without taking recourse to Section 78 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act; Rule 58(2) does not itself confer power to pass such an order and is not self-operative.
- If it were held that no enquiry or order under Section 78 is necessary where Rule 58 applies, then Rule 58 would be arbitrary and unreasonable.
- Reliance was placed on Keshavrao Narayanrao Patil v. District Deputy Registrar (1987 Mah. L.J. 709) and the Supreme Court decision in Moolchand Sharma v. State of U.P., AIR 1967 SC 112, in support of the contention that an order under Section 78 is necessary.
Respondents' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. A. S. Bobde and Shri J. V. Savant)
- Rule 58(2) is self-operative and no further action under Section 78 is contemplated or necessary to make a member cease to hold office once a disqualification under Rule 58(1) has arisen.
- Reliance was placed upon earlier decisions of this Court, including Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank Ltd. v. The Judge, Co-operative Court, Alibag (1977 Mah. L.J. 712; AIR 1978 Bom 62) and Murlidhar Tukaram Bhandekar v. The Nagpur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd. (1986 Mah. L.J. 599), which were argued to support the self-operative view of Rule 58(2).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Keshavrao Narayanrao Patil v. District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Akola, 1987 Mah. L.J. 709 | Held that passing an order of removal as required under Section 78 is mandatory; cessation under Section 73FF(2) is not automatic without an order under Section 78. | The Court applied the law laid down in this decision to Rule 58(2), concluding that an order under Section 78 is necessary before a member can be made to cease to hold office under Rule 58(2). |
| Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank Ltd. v. The Judge, Co-operative Court, Alibag, 1977 Mah. L.J. 712; AIR 1978 Bom 62 | Earlier decision treated as holding that cessation under the relevant rule operates without the necessity of an order under Section 78 (i.e., a contrary view to Keshavrao's case). | The Court observed that Roha Ashtami was rendered per incuriam in that it did not notice the provisions of Section 78; Keshavrao's case therefore took a different view and Roha Ashtami's differing approach was not followed when read with Section 78. |
| Murlidhar Tukaram Bhandekar v. The Nagpur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., 1986 Mah. L.J. 599 | Referred to and followed the earlier view in Roha Ashtami (i.e., supported self-operative effect). | The Court noted that Murlidhar Tukaram Bhandekar's case had merely referred to and followed Roha Ashtami; this did not alter the Court's conclusion that Keshavrao's reasoning (requiring Section 78 action) controls. |
| Murlidhar Malu v. Sudhakar Patil, Writ Petition No. 4470 of 1986 (decided 8 September 1987) | Followed the decision in Keshavrao's case. | The Court noted that Keshavrao's case was subsequently followed by the Division Bench in this matter, supporting the view that Section 78 action is required. |
| Moolchand Sharma v. State of U.P., AIR 1967 SC 112 (Supreme Court) | Cited by petitioner in support of the proposition that an order of removal or adjudication is necessary (as part of broader authority cited). | The Court recorded that the petitioner relied on this Supreme Court decision; the opinion does not elaborate further application beyond noting the reliance. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by setting out the relevant statutory and rule provisions, notably Rule 58(1) and (2) (disqualifications and resulting cessation), Section 73FF (inserted by Maharashtra Act No. 20 of 1986, also dealing with disqualification and cessation), and Section 78 (power of the Registrar to remove a disqualified member after giving opportunity of being heard).
The Court observed overlap between Rule 58 and Section 73FF, and explained that subsection (2) of Section 73FF—declaring that a member who has incurred disqualification shall cease to be a member—was akin to sub-rule (2) of Rule 58. The Division Bench decision in Keshavrao was then examined: that decision held that an order of removal under Section 78 is mandatory and cessation under Section 73FF(2) is not automatic without such an order.
The central question before the Court was whether the law in Keshavrao applied equally to Rule 58(2). The Court reasoned that Rule 58(1) specifies disqualifications while Rule 58(2) states the consequence; but the existence of a disqualification may be disputed or doubtful, and where that is so, an adjudication is necessary. The Court characterized such adjudication as judicial or quasi-judicial, not purely administrative, which is why Section 78 provides a procedure for removal with opportunity to be heard.
Reading Section 78 harmoniously with Section 73FF and Rule 58, the Court concluded that an order under Section 78 is necessary before a person can be made to cease to be a member under Rule 58. The Court emphasized that the provisions must be construed together to produce a consistent and reasonable result. The Advocate General (Shri Bobde) conceded the legal position arrived at by the Court.
Applying this reasoning to the present facts, the Court found it was admitted that no action under Section 78 had been taken against the petitioner and that there was a dispute about whether the petitioner had incurred the disqualification. Because Section 78 proceedings had not been invoked, the Court held the intimation of cessation dated 9 August 1983 was invalid.
Holding and Implications
Holding: Rule made absolute; the intimation dated 9 August 1983 issued by the Deputy Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, Taluka Kandhar is quashed and set aside.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: Because no action under Section 78 had been taken and there was a dispute regarding the disqualification, the petitioner did not cease to be a Director of the Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh; the impugned intimation is invalid and set aside.
- Procedure clarified: The Court applied and reaffirmed the principle from Keshavrao Narayanrao Patil that an order under Section 78 is required before a member can be removed (or be said to have ceased to hold office) on account of disqualification under the rules; Rule 58(2) is not to be treated as operating to effect cessation without such an order in disputed cases.
- Costs: The Court ordered no costs in the circumstances of the case.
Rule made absolute.
C.S Dharmadhikari, A.C.J:— The petitioner was elected as a Chairman of Harbal Seva Sahakari Society in the election held on 15th of August 1981, for a term of three years. He was also elected as a Director of Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh in the year 1982 for a term of five years. The petitioner had taken loan from respondent No. 5 — the Maharashtra State Co-operative Land Envelopment Bank Ltd. for purchase of electric motor in the year 1971 which was repayable in 10 yearly instalments. According to the petitioner the last such instalment was due in the year 1981-1982. In the year 1973 he again took a loan of Rs. 6,300/- for construction of a well and this loan was also repayable in 10 equal instalments within a period of 10 years and last such instalment will become due in the year 1987-1988. It is his case that earlier loan of Rs. 3,000/- was paid back within the period of 10 years and he was paying the instalments regularly. Petitioner is also a share-holder of Kalambar Vibhag Sahakari Sakhar Karkhana Ltd. The Respondent No. 5 — the Maharashtra State Co-operative Land Development Bank Limited had given instructions to the Sakhar Karkhana that the amount due from the Petitioner towards the loan instalments, should be deducted from the bills payable to him towards the price of sugarcane supplied by the petitioner. This arrangement was made as per the approved practice recognised by Section 48(A) of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act, 1960. Thus it is his case that he was not a defaulter under Rule 58 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961. However, at the instance of persons interested, the Deputy Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, vide letter dated 9th August 1983, informed the petitioner that he has ceased to be a Director of Respondent No. 4 — the Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh under Rule 58(2) of the Rules. It is this intimation issued by the Deputy Registrar, which is challenged in this writ petition on various grounds.
2. Shri Godhamgaokar, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, contended before us that in fact and in law the petitioner was not a defaulter under rule 58. Further, no order or intimation could have been issued under rule 58(2) by the District Deputy Registrar, without taking recourse to section 78 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Act.
3. According to the learned Counsel Rule 58(2) only lays down the consequences or result of disqualifications and does not confer any power upon the Deputy Registrar to pass such an order. Rule 58(2) is not self-operative. An order in that behalf could only be passed by the competent authority under section 78 of the Act which deals with the removal of a member of a Society and unless recourse was taken to section 78 it was not open to the District Deputy Registrar to pass the impugned order. In support of this contention he has placed strong reliance upon the decision of this Court in Keshavrao Narayanrao Patil v. District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Akola, 1987 Mah. L.J 709 and a decision of Supreme Court in Moolchand Sharma v. State of U.P, AIR 1967 SC 112. It is also contended by the petitioner, that if it is held that no enquiry or order under section 78 is necessary in a case covered by rule 58, then the said rule is arbitrary and unreasonable.
4. On the other hand, it is contendnded by Mr. A.S Bobde, learned Advocate General, and Shri J.V Savant, learned Government Pleader, that rule 58(2) is self-operative and no further action under section 78 is contemplated. In support of this contention they have placed reliance upon the earlier decisions of this Court in 1977 Mah. L.J 712, Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank Ltd. v. The Judge, Co-operative Court, Alibag, 1977 Mh. L.J 712 : AIR 1978 Bom. 62 and Murlidhar Tukaram Bhandekar v. The Nagpur District Central Co-operative Bank Ltd., 1986 Mah. L.J 599.
5. For properly appreciating the controversy raised before us it will be worthwhile if a reference is made to the relevant provisions of the Act and the Rules. Rules 58(1) and (2) which are relevant for our purpose and deal with the disqualification for membership of the committee read as under:—
“58. DISQUALIFICATION FOR MEMBERSHIP OF COMMITTEE:
(1) No person shall be eligible for appointment or selection as a member of the committee of a society, if—
(a) he is in default to any society in respect of any dues from him, either as a borrower or as a surety for such period as is specified in this behalf in the by-laws of the concerned society, or for a period exceeding three months, whichever is less; or
(b) he is, in the opinion of the Registrar, persistently and deliberately committing breach of the Co-operative discipline with reference to linking up of credit with co-operative marketing or co-operative processing; or
(c) he has been held responsible under section 79 or 88 or has been held responsible for payment of costs of inquiry under section 85.
(2) A member of the committee of a society shall cease to hold office if he incurs any of the disqualifications mentioned in sub-rule (1)”.
6. It is not disputed that rule 58, applies to all the co-operative societies, including specified societies. By Maharashtra Act No. 20 of 1986, section 73FF was inserted in the Statute Book. It also deals with the disqualification for membership of the Committee. Certain disqualifications in Rule 58 and section 73FF are overlapping. sub-section 2 of section 73ff lays down that the member who has incurred any disqualification under sub-section 1 shall cease to be a member of the committee and his seat shall be deemed to be vacant. This provision is akin to sub-rule 2 of rule 58. Section 78 then confers a power upon the Registrar to remove a member of a society if he stands disqualified by or under the Act for being a member. The Registrar is empowered to remove the member if he has incurred a disqualification and appoint any person as a member of such committee in his place of direct the society to elect or appoint a member in his place for the remainder of the term of the office of a member so removed. Section 73FF and Section 78 fell for consideration of this Court in Keshavrao Narayanrao Patil v. District Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Akola, 1987 Mh. L.J 709 where the Division Bench took a view that the passing of an order of removal as required under section 78 of the Act in the matter of incurring disqualification under Section 73FF(1) is mandatory. The cessation of the membership under Section 73FF(2) is not automatic and a person does not cease to be a member unless an order of removal as required under the said provision is passed. In the said decision earlier decision of this Court in Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank Ltd. v. The Judge, Co-operative Court. Alibagh, 1977 Mh. L.J 712 : AIR 1978 Bombay 62 was referred to and considered. The Division Bench held that the said judgment is rendered per incuriam as the provisions of section 78 where not noticed nor were brought to the notice of the learned Judges who decided the Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank Ltd.'s case. In Murlidhar Tukaram Bhandekar's case the earlier view of this Court in Roha Ashtami Co-operative Urban Bank's case was merely referred to and followed. Decision in Keshavrao's case was subsequently followed by another Division Bench in writ petition So. 4470 of 1986. Murlidhar Malu v. Sudhakar Patil, decided on 8th September 1987.
7. Therefore the only question which requires consideration in the present writ petition is to find out as to whether the law laid down by this Court in Keshavrao's case will apply even to Rule 58(2) of the Act. We would like to make it very clear that in this case we are concerned with Rule 58(2) which deals with the cessation of membership after the person is elected as a member of the society which is akin to removal of a member from the membership of the committee of the society in view of incurring a disqualification mentioned in sub-rule 1 of Rule 58. In our view, if section 78 is read in its context and harmoniously with the other provisions of the Act, including section 73FF, a conclusion is inevitable that the law laid down by this Court in Keshavrao's case must apply even to an action contemplated by Rule 58. Rule 58(1) lays down the disqualifications and rule 58(2) provides consequence or the result of disqualification. Though in a given case a declaration could relate back to the date of the disqualification itself, that does not mean that no adjudication or order is necessary. When a disqualification has been incurred by a member, is in itself, in doubt or disputed, then an adjudication is obviously necessary. An enquiry in that behalf is not administrative but is judicial or quasi-judicial in nature. This seems to be the reason why a provision is made under section 78 of the Act, for removal of member if he stands disqualified by or under the Act for being a member, after giving the member an opportunity of being heard. In substance, after the person is elected as a member of the committee if he is to cease as a member, an order of removal under section 78 of the Act is necessary. That seems to be the view taken by this Court in Keshavrao's case, though in the context of section 73FF of the Act. In this context it is pertinent to note that Rule 58(1) and (2) also applies to the specified societies. The provisions of Section 73FF are in addition to, and without prejudice to other provisions of the Act and rules made thereunder in relation to disqualifications. Therefore provisions of section 73FF, rule 58 and section 78 will have to be read and construed harmoniously so as to make them consistent and reasonable. So construed, in our view, unless an action under section 78 of the Act is taken a person cannot cease to be the member of the committee even under rule 58 of the Rules. The learned Advocate General Shri Bobde fairly conceded this position.
8. In the present case it is an admitted position that no action under section 78 of the Act was taken against the petitioner though there was a dispute about it. In view of this it cannot be said that the petitioner has ceased to be the Director of Kandhar Taluka Shetkari Sahakari Kharedi Vikri Sangh. Therefore, the order passed or intimation issued vide letter dated 9th August, 1983, by the Deputy Registrar of the Co-operative Societies, Kandhar, must get vitiated and, therefore, deserves to be set aside.
9. In the result, therefore, Rule is made absolute. The order incorporated in the letter dated 9th August 1983, written by the Deputy Registrar, Co-operative Societies, Taluka Kandhar is quashed and set aside. However in the circumstances of the case, there will be no order as to costs.
Rule made absolute.
Alert