Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Lalit Ballabhdas Taori v. Nagpur University, Nagpur And Others

Bombay High Court
Apr 11, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Judgment (V.A. Mohta, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The Court heard two writ petitions together because they raised common questions of law concerning (i) the validity of Rule 4 of Ordinance No. 159 (rules for revaluation of answer books) framed under section 40 of the Nagpur University Act, 1974 and (ii) the interpretation of the Ordinance.

Writ Petition No. 536 of 1985 (Lalit Taori): The petitioner appeared in the Final M.B.B.S. Examination (Winter 1984) and was declared successful. In Medicine (Paper-I) he was originally awarded 49/100. He applied for revaluation on 17 December 1984. In or about March 1985 the University informed him that his marks were reduced on revaluation to 42, and his result was revised to unsuccessful. He sought information from the Registrar about the revaluation procedure and, receiving what he considered vague replies, filed the writ petition.

Writ Petition No. 568 of 1985 (Kumari Vandana Bhishikar): The petitioner appeared in the Final M.B.B.S. Examination (Winter 1984). She was originally awarded 55/100 and 57/100 in the two papers of Obstetrics & Gynaecology and 59/100 in Paper-I of Paediatrics. She applied for revaluation on 8 January 1985. In the second week of March 1985 she was informed that in both Obstetrics & Gynaecology papers her marks were reduced to 45 each; Paediatrics remained unchanged. She made a representation to the Vice‑Chancellor on 14 March 1985 asking restoration of original marks; when that was not done she filed the writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether Rule 4 of Ordinance No. 159, to the extent it authorises the Vice‑Chancellor to appoint examiners for revaluation (including selecting particular examiners from the panel), is contrary to section 64 of the Nagpur University Act and therefore invalid.
  2. Whether, under the Ordinance, marks resulting from revaluation can be varied to the detriment of the student who sought revaluation (i.e., whether a reduction in marks on revaluation is binding on the student).

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioners' Arguments

  • Rule 4 is invalid insofar as it authorises the Vice‑Chancellor to select particular examiners for revaluation from the list prepared under section 64; that function must belong to the Executive Council under section 64.
  • The Ordinance should be interpreted so that a student who seeks revaluation should not suffer a reduction in marks — i.e., revaluation should not be permitted to operate to the student's detriment.

Respondent / University Position (as presented in the opinion)

  • The revaluations in the present cases were conducted by examiners drawn from the list prepared under section 64.
  • Section 64 contemplates preparation of a panel of examiners; it does not, in the Court's view, prevent the Vice‑Chancellor from forwarding particular answer books to particular examiners within that approved list.
  • Ordinance No. 159 was amended (Ordinance No. 65 of 1983) and received the Chancellor's approval (30 May 1984); section 24(xli) permits delegation by the Executive Council of its powers (subject to Chancellor's approval), which supports the validity of delegation to the Vice‑Chancellor.
  • The Ordinance requires an undertaking from the student that the result of revaluation shall be binding and that the student shall accept the result of revaluation instead of the original valuation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Ku. Rohini Dattatraya Tare v. Nagpur University, AIR 1984 Bom 115 Holds that revaluation is part of the examination process and section 64 applies to revaluation; results based on revaluation by examiners not appointed under section 64 were invalid; delay justification rejected. The Court relied on Rohini to confirm that section 64's requirements must be observed. It noted, however, that Rohini does not support the petitioners' contention that the Vice‑Chancellor cannot forward particular answer books to particular examiners from the approved list. The Court distinguished Rohini by observing that in the present cases the revaluations were carried out by examiners from the section 64 list, and therefore Rohini did not invalidate those revaluations.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court addressed the two canvassed points sequentially.

On the validity of Rule 4 vis‑à‑vis section 64:

  • The Court examined the language and scope of section 64, observing that section 64 requires the annual constitution of a committee to prepare lists (panels) of persons for appointment as University examiners, with those lists being submitted to the Executive Council for approval and subject to change by the Executive Council only by a specific resolution stating grounds.
  • However, the Court found nothing in section 64 that prevents the Vice‑Chancellor from selecting which examiner from the approved list will be sent a particular answer book for revaluation. Section 64 deals with preparation and approval of the panel; it does not prescribe the mechanical process of forwarding particular answer books to particular examiners.
  • The Court observed that Rohini had held that revaluation falls within section 64's ambit and that appointment of examiners for revaluation must conform to section 64. But Rohini did not preclude the Vice‑Chancellor from forwarding answer books to examiners from the approved panel; indeed Rohini contemplated that forwarding to examiners in the list can be done as necessary.
  • The Court further pointed out that Ordinance No. 159 had been amended by the Executive Council (Ordinance No. 65 of 1983) and approved by the Chancellor (30 May 1984). Section 24(xli) permits delegation by the Executive Council of its powers (subject to Chancellor's approval), which allowed delegation to the Vice‑Chancellor of certain appointment powers that otherwise might have been exercised by the Executive Council.
  • Accordingly, the Court concluded that Rule 4's authorisation for the Vice‑Chancellor to appoint examiners for revaluation from the approved list was not illegal or contrary to section 64.

On whether marks reduced on revaluation can be binding:

  • The Court characterised revaluation as part of the examination process and as a fresh appraisal of a student’s performance by other examiners. If revaluation results in an increase, the University must vary the result accordingly; the Court asked why a decrease should be treated differently.
  • The Court read the Ordinance (particularly Rule 3) as requiring an undertaking by the student that the result of revaluation shall be binding and that the student shall accept the revaluation result in place of the original valuation. The Ordinance also authorises the University to re‑examine all papers even if revaluation is sought only for some.
  • The Court reviewed the original wording of Rule 5, which explicitly mentioned both rise and decrease, and noted that the amended text uses the word "varies" — an unqualified term — which the Court interpreted as encompassing all types of variation (increase or decrease). The Court said this showed no intent to exclude decreases from the operation of revaluation.
  • The Court rejected the view that the Ordinance must be interpreted favorably to the student in a way that would prevent decreases on revaluation; it held that such an interpretation would be contrary to both the letter and spirit of the Ordinance and to the mandatory undertaking required by Rule 3.
  • Finally, the Court cautioned against reading Rule 5(ii) in isolation; that provision clarifies that the fresh result carries all consequential benefits (e.g., division, merit, medals, prizes) and that the old result is erased for all purposes.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petitions were dismissed and the rules discharged. The Court found no substance in the petitions. The judgment states: "Petition dismissed." and specifies "No costs."

Implications (as stated or directly inferable from the opinion text):

  • The Court held Rule 4 of Ordinance No. 159 valid insofar as it authorises the Vice‑Chancellor to appoint examiners for revaluation from the list prepared under section 64 and, where appropriate, to make appointments in circumstances permitted by the Ordinance and delegated powers.
  • The Court held that results of revaluation — whether they increase or decrease the marks awarded — are binding and final; the original valuation is erased after revaluation and the student’s undertaking to accept the revaluation result is operative.
  • The Court confirmed that Rule 5(ii) should not be read in isolation and that revaluation results carry consequential benefits, with the old result being erased for all purposes.
  • The decision disposed of the two petitions by upholding the University's revaluation process and results in these cases; the petitions were dismissed and no costs were awarded. The opinion does not indicate that the Court was creating a new, broader precedent beyond its application of existing statutory provisions and the cited Rohini decision.
Show all summary ...

V.A Mohta, J.:— As common questions of law relating to (i) validity of Rule 4 of Ordinance No. 159 “prescribing rules for revaluation of answer books of examines at University Examinations” framed under section 40 of the Nagpur University Act, 1974 the NU Act)(ii) interpretation of the Ordinance, are involved in these two petitions, they are heard together and are being disposed of by a common judgment.

2. Writ Petitioner — Lalit Taori (Writ Petition No. 536 of 1985) appeared for the Final M.B.B.S Examination of Winter 1984 held by the Nagpur University and was declared successful. In the subject Medicine (Paper-I), he was awarded 49 out of 100 marks. He was not satisfied with the valuation of this paper as the marks were not as per his reasonable expectation. He, therefore, on 17th December, 1984, applied for revaluation of this paper as provided for in the Ordinance No. 159. University informed the petitioner some time in March, 1985 that as a result of revaluation, there was adverse change in the marks from original 49 to 42. As a consequence the petitioner's result was revised and he was declared unsuccessful. The petitioner sought information from the Registrar of the University on certain matters relating to the procedure that is followed in the matter of revaluation. According to him, only vague reply was given and hence this petition. Writ Petitioner Kumari Vandana Bhishikar (Writ Petition No. 568 of 1985) appeared for the Final M.B.B.S Examination of Winter 1984. She was awarded 55 out of 100 marks in Paper-I and 57 out of 100 marks in Paper-II in the subjects Obstetrics and Gynaecology and 59 out of 100 marks in Paper-1 of the subject Paediatrics. She was not satisfied with the valuation of these papers as she did not get marks as per her reasonable expectation and, therefore, on 8th January, 1985, applied for revaluation. She received a communication in the second week of March, 1985 that as result of revaluation, there was an adverse change in the marks awarded to the petitioner in both papers of Obstetrics and Gynaecology. She was awarded 45 marks each. In the subject of Paediatrics, marks were not changed. Aggrieved by the result of the revaluation, she addressed a representation to the Vice-Chancellor on 14th March, 1985 requesting him to restore the original marks. As this was not done, the present writ petition has been filed.

3. Only two points were canvassed before us. The first is that the Rule 4 of the Ordinance to the extent it authorizes the Vice-Chancellor to make appointments of examiners for revaluation, is contrary to section 64 of the nu act and therefore invalid. We begin with extracting relevant rules 3, 4 and 5 for ready reference:

“3. (i) An examinee may apply for revaluation for one or more papers.

(ii) The examinee applying for revaluation of his answer-book(s) shall have to give all undertaking to the effect that

(a) The result of revaluation shall be binding on him, her and that he she shall accept the result of revaluation instead of the original valuation.

(b) The University shall have the right to re-examine all his, her papers even though he she seek revaluation only for one paper or some of them. In such case, the decision of the University shall be binding on him her.

(iii) Nothing in this Ordinance shall apply to scripts of Practical Examinations/Team Work/Internal Assessment/Sessional Marks/Dissertation/Thesis/Viva-Voce and Examination where marking is not provided.

4. (i) Appointment of examiners for revaluation shall be made by the Vice-Chancellor from the list of examiners recommended by the Section 64 Committee and approved by the Executive Council. The answer books shall be revalued by 2 examiners other than the original examiner who valued them initially. In case the revaluation warrants the appointment of an examiner from outside the University area or in case where no name is available or found suitable in the given list, the Vice-Chancellor is authorised to make such appointment on behalf of the Boards of Studies, Section, S. 64 Committee and the Executive Council as need be.

(ii) The remuneration of the Examiners shall be as decided by the Executive Council.

(iii) The memorandum of instructions for the guidance of the examiners, if prepared by the paper-setter, will be sent to each of the two examiners to enable him to value the answer books concerned in accordance with the instructions.

5. (i) If the average of marks awarded in the paper by the two examiners appointed for revaluation varies from the marks given by the Original Examiner by 5% or more of the maximum marks prescribed for the paper, this average of marks shall be awarded to the candidate for the revision of his result and the marks given by the Original Examiner shall be deemed null and void

(ii) If as a result of revaluation-

(a) the examinee attracts the provisions of Condonation of Deficiency and of Exemptions and Compartments, these shall be applied to him;

And (b) the examinee if eligible for Division, Merit, Medals, Prizes etc. the same shall be granted to him”.

Section 64 contemplates the following procedure to be followed in preparing the list of University examiners:

Every year for each Faculty, a Committee is constituted for the purpose of preparing lists of persons for appointment as University Examiners. The lists are prepared from amongst persons included in the panels prepared by the Board of Studies and are submitted for approval to the Executive Council. No change in the lists can be made by the Executive Council except by passing a resolution stating the specific ground on which the change is either suggested or made. If any examiner is unable to accept the examinership and a fresh appointment cannoe be made in time by the Executive Council, the vice-Chancellor can appoint another examiner and report such appointment to the Executive Council.

4. At one stage, for re-valuations even the examiners outside the panel approved by the Executive Council as laid down under section 64 were appointed by the Vice Chancellor on the basis of special resolutions of the Academic Council and the Executive Council. Such appointments were challenged in this Court in the case of Ku. Rohini Dattatraya Tare v. Nagpur University, Nagpur . AIR 1984 Bom 115 and this Court held that even revaluation was a part of examination and section 64 applies with equal vigour even to revaluation and the results based on the revaluation of papers by examiners not from amongst those appointed under section 64 were invalid. As a result those results were quashed and set aside. Negativing the contention that the departure in the procedure was made in the interest of the examinees to get the papers revalued within a short-time, it was held:

“Moreover, we fail to see how a delay is caused on account of getting papers examined by examiners appointed under S. 64. The panel of examiners can be prepared in good time and it is only a question of forwarding the answer books to the concerned examiners in the said panel”.

NOW it is not disputed before us that the revaluations in question were made by the examiners from the list of examiners duly prepared under section 64. Submission is that section 64 does not empower the Vice Chancellor even to select a particular examiner from the list of examiners for revaluation of particular answer books, that even such decision has to be taken by the Executive Council and that as Rule 4 empowers the Vice-Chancellor to make such selection the said Rule is contrary to section 64. We find it extremely difficult to accept this submission as valid. There is nothing in section 64 to warrant this conclusion. All that section 64 contemplates is the preparation of panel of approved examiners. It has nothing to do with forwarding a particular answer book to a particular examiner. Such a decision can certainly be taken by the Vice Chancellor in terms of section 11(5). Rohini's case far from supporting the petitioner's case lays down that question of forwarding answer books to any of the examiners from the list can always be done afterwards. We thus see nothing illegal in Rule 4 authorizing the Vice-Chancellor to make appointment of examiners for revaluation from the list prepared under section 64.

5. There is yet another angle to the issue. It appears that after the decision in Rohini, Ordinance No. 159 was amended by the Executive Council on 1-12-1983 by Ordinance No. 65 of 1983 and the amended Ordinance has duly received the approval and assent of the Chancellor on 30th May, 1984. Section 24 (xli) permits delegation by the Executive Council of any of its powers (except the power to make Ordinances) to the Vice-Chancellor and/or other functionaries, subject to the approval of the Chancellor. Thus assuming for a moment that Executive Council and none else is authorized under section 64 to select the examiners vis-a-vis particular answer book/books, there is a valid delegation of the power to the Vice-Chancellor.

6. This takes us to the second point viz. as a result of revaluation the marks cannot be varied to the detriment of the student seeking revaluation under the Ordinance. We find that second point is equally devoid of any merit. Revaluation is a part of examination and is a fresh appraisal of the performance of a student by other examiner. In case the marks increase as a result of revaluation the increase is binding on the University which is obliged to vary result on that basis. How then the decrease in the marks can be held not binding on the student? The result of revaluation — whather it is - has to be accepted as correct and final by all concerned and for all purposes. Indeed after revaluation the result of original valuation is erased. To hold otherwise would be against the basic concept of revaluation. It is submitted that the Ordinance is a beneficial piece of legislation intended for the benefit of student community and must be interpreted in its favour as far as possible. Apart from the consideration that such interpretation would be basically wrong, neither the letter nor the spirit of this Ordinance leaves any scope for such interpretation. Rule 3 makes the intention very clear. It requires an undertaking by a student that he shall accept the result of revaluation instead of the original valuation. It also authorizes the University to re examine even papers of which revaluation is not sought. No student can be allowed to get over the obligation of these mandatory undertakings but for which revaluation is not permissible. Person giving this undertaking is thus estopped from contending that undertaking is not binding on him’. It is pertinent to notice that Ordinance, as it stood originally, read thus:

“5. (i) If the average of marks awarded in the paper by two examiners varies from the marks given by the original examiner by 10% or more of the maximum marks of the paper, this average of marks will be awarded to the candidate for the revision of his result;

(ii) If as a result of the re-valuation of the answer-books, the marks as being the score of the examinee, rise over or decrease below by 10% of the original marks in a paper/papers and accordingly his original result is changed, then only the results of re-valuation shall be accepted by the University and 50% of the fee for revaluation will be refunded to the examinee.

(iii) If as a result of revaluation—

(a) the examinee attracts the provision of Condonation of Deficiency and of Exemption and Compartments, those shall be applied to him;

and (b) the examinee is eligible for Division, Merit, Medals, Prizes, etc., the same shall be granted to him”.

Thus rise and decrease both were specifically mentioned in the Rule. Now in the place of the words “rise over or decrease below” the word “varies” is used. The term “varies” is unqualified and therefore must mean variation of all types. No change in the basic concept of revaluation was thus intended by amendment. Only a shorter and simpler terminology has been used to convey the same intention. If intention was otherwise nothing prevented the use of the relevant qualified words. Reading differently would amount to remaking the Ordinance.

7. Rule 5(ii), which refers to condonation of Deficiency and Exemptions and Compartments and eligibility for Division, Merit, Medals, Prizes etc., all points favourable to student is also heavily relied upon. We find it improper to read this Rule in isolation. It refers only to some aspects and not all. The clear intention of Rule 5(ii) is to make the position clear that fresh result shall have all the consequential benefits including with relation to Division, Merit, Medals, Prizes etc. and the old result shall be erased for all purposes. May be that Rule 33 of Ordinance No. 6 dealing with the preparation of a merit-list was also in view of the University in making this provision.

8. For all these reasons, we see no substance in these petitions which are dismissed and rules discharged. No costs.

Petition dismissed.