Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Patel Aluminium Pvt. Ltd. v. Miss K.H Tawadia, Income-Tax Officer, Bombay And Another

Bombay High Court
Dec 12, 1985
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

For Assessment Year (AY) 1977–1978 the petitioners' income-tax assessment was completed on 19 April 1978 and their income was determined to be nil. The petitioners' previous year for AY 1979–1980 ended on 30 June 1978. Because the prior year assessment showed nil income, the petitioners did not file the statement of advance tax or pay the first instalment of advance tax due on 15 June 1978.

On 29 June 1979 the petitioners filed a return for AY 1979–1980 declaring income of Rs. 2,88,360/-. They filed a revised return on 11 September 1981 declaring total income of Rs. 5,47,710/-. The petitioners paid tax on a self-assessment basis on 28 June 1979 and again on 7 September 1981 (on the revised return). The assessment for that year was completed on 11 December 1981 and the total income was determined at Rs. 5,54,010/-. The assessment order recorded: “Interest under section 217(1)(a) is charged. Penalty show-cause notice under Section 273 is issued.”

A notice to show cause why a penalty under Section 273 should not be imposed was served on the petitioners on 9 December 1981. The petitioners filed this writ petition on 11 January 1982 seeking to quash the assessment order insofar as it charged interest under Section 217(1)(a), and to quash the notice dated 9 December 1981.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether persons who have been previously assessed and whose computation under Section 209(1)(a) shows that no advance tax is payable are nevertheless obliged to send “a statement of advance tax payable by him computed in the manner laid down in” Section 209(1)(a) as required by Section 209-A(1)(a).
  2. Whether, if no such obligation to send the statement exists when the computed advance tax is nil, the petitioners can be made liable to pay (a) interest under Section 217(1)(a) and (b) a penalty under Section 273 for failure to furnish the statement.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioners') Arguments

  • Because the petitioners were assessed to a nil income for the previous assessment year, a computation under Section 209(1)(a) did not make them liable to payment of advance tax.
  • Consequently, there was no “advance tax payable” and no obligation under Section 209-A(1)(a) to send the statement of advance tax to the Income-tax Officer.
  • On this basis, the petitioners argued they were not liable to interest under Section 217(1)(a) nor to penalty under Section 273 for failing to furnish the statement.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondents' counsel submitted that the petitioners were obliged to send to the Income-tax Officer a statement of advance tax payable computed in the manner laid down by Section 209(1)(a) even if that computation showed that the amount payable was nil.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court focused on the proper interpretation of the phrase “a statement of advance tax payable by him computed in the manner laid down in” Section 209(1)(a). It examined the statutory scheme formed by Sections 209(1)(a), 209-A(1)(a), 208 and the provisions imposing interest and penalty (Section 217(1)(a) and Section 273(1)(b) as described in the opinion).

The court observed that Section 209(1)(a) prescribes how an assessee's advance tax is to be computed — by first ascertaining total income of the latest previous year in which he was assessed, making specified deductions, calculating tax at rates in force and adjusting for amounts deductible under specified withholding provisions — and that an assessee who has been previously regularly assessed has three linked obligations under the statutory scheme:

  • to compute the advance tax payable in the manner provided by Section 209(1)(a);
  • to send a statement of such computation to the Income-tax Officer (the statement required by Section 209-A(1)(a)); and
  • to pay the amount so computed as advance tax.

The court reasoned that the statement mandated by Section 209-A(1)(a) is a statement of the computation of the advance tax payable. If, after making the computation required by Section 209(1)(a), no advance tax is found to be payable (i.e., the computed amount is nil), then there is, by definition, no “advance tax payable.” The court held that where no advance tax is payable there is no obligation to send the statement of its computation because the object of the statement is to disclose to the Income-tax Officer the computation on which an advance tax liability arises. Where there is no liability, the court found no purpose in requiring the statement.

Applying that interpretation to the facts, the court concluded that the petitioners, whose earlier assessment showed nil income and whose computation under Section 209(1)(a) gave rise to no advance tax payable, were not obliged to send the statement required by Section 209-A(1)(a). Because the failure to submit that statement is the basis for charging interest under Section 217(1)(a) and for imposing a penalty under Section 273(1)(b) (as identified in the opinion), the court held that the petitioners could not be made liable to pay such interest or penalty on the basis of a failure to furnish the statement.

The court further noted that, notwithstanding an interim order made in the writ petition on 13 January 1982, the respondents had recovered interest under Section 217(1)(a) in the sum of Rs. 50,722/-. The opinion explains the manner of recovery: a notice of refund for AY 1982–1983 was issued for Rs. 1,83,798/-, but the actual refund made was only Rs. 1,33,076/-, the shortfall equalling Rs. 50,722/-. The court concluded it was necessary to order that this amount be paid forthwith to the petitioners.

Holding and Implications

The petition is allowed and made absolute in terms of prayer (a).

Direct consequences ordered by the court (as recorded in the opinion):

  • The court held that the petitioners were not obliged to send the statement referred to in Section 209-A(1)(a) when the computation under Section 209(1)(a) showed that no advance tax was payable.
  • Accordingly, the petitioners cannot be made liable to pay interest under Section 217(1)(a) or a penalty under Section 273 for failing to furnish that statement.
  • The respondents were ordered to pay to the petitioners forthwith the sum of Rs. 50,722/-, representing interest which the respondents had recovered from the petitioners despite the interim order.
  • The respondents were ordered to pay the costs of the petition.

Broader implications: The opinion contains an interpretation of the statutory phrase at issue and applies it to the parties' facts. The opinion itself does not discuss any broader legal or policy implications beyond the direct effect on the parties; the ruling resolves the petitioners' claim and directs repayment and costs in their favour.

Order accordingly.

Show all summary ...

1. The income-tax assessment of the petitioners for the Assessment Year 1977–1978 was completed on 19th April, 1978 and it was determined that the income was nil. For the Assessment Year 1979–1980 the petitioners' previous year ended on 30th June, 1978. The petitioners did not file a statement of or pay any advance tax on 15th June, 1978 when the first instalment thereof became due because their income for the previous Assessment Year had been determined as nil. On 29th June, 1979 the petitioners filed a return of income for the Assessment Year 1979–1980 in the sum of Rs. 2,88,360/-. They filed a revised return on 11th September, 1981 declaring their total income at Rs. 5,47,710/-. They paid tax on self-assessment basis on 28th June, 1979 and again on the revised return on 7th September, 1981. The petitioners' assessment for the Assessment Year was completed on 11th December, 1981 and the total income was determined at Rs. 5,54,010/-. The assessment order concluded thus:

“Interest under section 217(1)(a) is charged. Penalty show-cause notice under Section 273 is issued.”

2. On 9th December, 1981 the petitioners were served with a notice to show cause why a penalty under Section 273 should not be imposed upon them. This petition was filed on 11th January, 1982 to quash the assessment order insofar as it charged interest under section 217(1)(a), and the notice dated 9th December, 1981.

3. To appreciate the arguments it is necessary to set out the relevant provisions of the Income-tax Act, 1961. They read thus:

“Section 217(1) Where, on making the regular assessment, the Income-tax Officer finds—

(a) that any such person as is referred to in clause(a) of sub-section (1) of Section209-Ahas not sent the statement referred to in that clause or the estimate in lieu of such statement referred to in sub-section (2) of that section;

…….…….…..…..…..

simple interest at the rate of fifteen per cent per annum from the 1st day of April next following the financial year in which the advance tax was payable in accordance with the said sub-section (1) or sub-section (2) upto the date of the regular assessment shall be payable by the assessee upon the amount equal to the assessed tax as defined in sub-section (5) of Section 215.”

“Section 271(1) If the Income-tax Officer, in the course of any proceedings in connection with the regular assessment for any assessment year, is satisfied that any assessee;

….…..…..…..….

(b) has without reasonable cause failed to furnish a statement of the advance tax payable by him in accordance with the provisions of clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 209-A

he may direct that such person shall, in addition to the amount of tax, if any, payable by him, pay by way of penalty a sum.”

….….….….….

“Section 209-A(1) Every person shall, in each financial year, on or before the date on which the first instalment, or where he has not previously been assessed by way of regular assessment under this Act, on or before the date on which the last instalment, of advance tax is due in his case under sub-section (1) of Section 211, if his current income is likely to exceed the amount specified in sub-section (2) of section 208, send to the Income-tax Officer—

(a) where he has been previously assessed by way of regular assessment under this Act; a statement of advance tax payable by him computed in the manner laid down in clause (a) or, as the case may be, sub-clause (i) of clause (d) of sub-section (1) of section 209.

….….….….….

and shall pay such amount of advance tax.”

“Section 209(1) The amount of advance tax payable by an assessee in the financial year shall, subject to the provisions of sub-sections (2) and (3), be computed as follows:

(a)(i) his total income of the latest previous year in respect of which he has been assessed by way of regular assessment shall first be ascertained;

(ii) the amount of capital gains and income referred to in sub-clause (ix) of clause (24) of section 2, if any, included in such total income shall be deducted therefrom, and on the balance income-tax shall be calculated at the rates in force in the financial year;

(iii) the income-tax so calculated shall be reduced by the amount of income-tax which would be deductible during the said financial year in accordance with the provisions of sections 192 to 194, section 194-A, section 194-C, section 194-D and section 195 on any income (as computed before allowing any deductions admissible under this Act) on which tax is required to be deducted under the said sections and which has been taken into account in computing the said total income;

(iv) the net amount of income-tax calculated in accordance with sub-clause (iii) shall, subject to the provisions of clauses (c) and (d), be the advance tax payable.”

“Section 208(1) Advance tax shall be payable during the financial year—

(a) where the total income, exclusive of capital gains (and income referred to in sub-clause (ix) of clause (24) of section 2) of the assessee, referred to in sub-clause (i) of clause (a) of sub-section (1) of section 209, exceeds the amount specified in sub-section (2), or

(b) where it is payable by virtue of the provisions of section 209-A.”

4. Section 208(2) prescribes the amount referred to in clause (a) of sub-section (1).

5. Interest under section 217(1)(a) is payable when the Income-tax Officer finds that a person who has been previously assessed by way of regular assessment has not sent the statement referred to in Section 209-A(1)(a). Section 273(1)(b) provides for the payment of a penalty where the Income-tax Officer finds that an assessee has without reasonable cause failed to furnish a statement of advance tax payable by him in accordance with the provisions of Section 209-A(1)(a). The failure to submit the statement called for by Section 209-A(1)(a) forms the basis both for the levy of interest under section 217(1)(a) and the levy of penalty under Section 273(1)(b).

6. Section 209-A(1)(a) requires that every person who has been previously assessed by way of regular assessment under the Act shall, in each financial year, on or before the date on which the first instalment of advance tax is due in his case, if his current income is likely to exceed the amount specified in Section 208(2), send to the Income-tax Officer “a statement of advance tax payable by him computed in the manner laid down in” section 209(1)(a). The provisions of sub-clause 1 also call for the payment of that amount of advance tax. section 209(1)(a) requires that an assessee's total income of the latest previous year in which he has been assessed by way of regular assessment shall first be ascertained, that certain deductions shall be made therefrom, and that the net amount of income tax thereon as so computed shall be the advance tax payable.

7. The argument of Mr. Dwarkadas, learned counsel for the petitioners, is that the petitioners are not liable to pay interest under section 217(1)(a) or a penalty under Section 273 because they were under no obligation to furnish to the Income-tax Officer the statement required by Section 209-A(1)(a). The petitioners had been assessed to a nil income for the previous Assessment Year. A computation made under section 209(1)(a), therefore, did not make the petitioners liable to payment of advance tax. There being no advance tax payable by the petitioners, there was no obligation cast upon them by section 209(1)(a) to send to the Income-tax Officer the statement contemplated thereby.

8. Mr. Jetly, learned counsel for the respondents, submitted that the petitioners were obliged to send to the Income-tax Officer a statement of advance tax payable by them computed in the manner laid down by section 209(1)(a) even if such computation showed that the amount payable was nil.

9. The question really boils down to an interpretation of the words “a statement of advance tax payable by him computed in the manner laid down in” section 209(1)(a).

10. Under section 209(1)(a) the obligation of an assessee who has been previously regularly assessed to tax is to compute the advance tax payable by him in the manner provided by section 209(1)(a), to send a statement of such computation to the Income-tax Officer and to pay the amount so computed. The statement that the assessee is obliged to send is a statement of the computation of the advance tax payable by him, such computation to be made as provided by section 209(1)(a). If upon such computation being made no advance tax is found to be payable, there is no “advance tax payable”. There being no “advance tax payable” there is no obligation to send to the Income-tax Officer a statement of such computation.

11. It would appear that the object of sending the statement is to make known to the Income-tax Officer the computation upon which the figure of advance tax has been arrived at. Where no advance tax payment is to be made, there is no purpose in sending to the Income-tax Officer the statement of its computation.

12. In this view of the matter, it must be held that the petitioners were not obliged to send to the Income-tax Officer the statement referred to in section 209(1)(a). They cannot, therefore, be made liable to pay interest under section 217(1)(a) or a penalty under Section 273.

13. It appears that, despite the interim order made in this writ petition on 13th January, 1982, the respondents have recovered from the petitioners interest under section 217(1)(a) in the sum of Rs. 50,722/-. They have done so by this means: A notice of refund was issued to the petitioners on 19th April, 1983 for the Assessment Year 1982–1983 in the sum of Rs. 1,83,798/-. The refund order thereon, however, was only in the sum of Rs. 1,33,076/-. The amount deducted is the exact sum of Rs. 50,722/-. In the circumstances, it is necessary to order the respondents forthwith to pay to the petitioners the sum of Rs. 50.722/-.

14. The petition is made absolute in terms of prayer (a). The respondents are ordered and directed forthwith to pay to the petitioners the sum of Rs. 50,722/-. The respondents shall pay to the petitioners the costs of the petition. Rule accordingly.

Order accordingly.