- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
S.G Rajadhyakshya v. Razak Cassim Narkar And Others
Summary of Opinion — Criminal Revision Application (Order dated June 30, 1983)
Factual and Procedural Background
This Criminal Revision Application challenges the Order dated June 30, 1983, in Case No. 40.CW/1983 and Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983, passed by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Esplanade, Bombay.
On Feb. 21, 1982 the Assistant Collector of Customs, Bombay filed a complaint (Case No. 40.CW/1983) under S. 120B, I.P.C., S. 135(1)(b)(ii) of the Customs Act and S. 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act against six accused. The complaint alleged that accused No. 1 (Razak Kasim Narkar, a South African national) was about to fly to Salisbury and that examination of his baggage disclosed 200,000 tablets of Mandrex (valued at Rs. 2,00,000/-) and some foreign exchange; it was alleged he lacked permission to export these items and they were seized. Accused No. 1 was released on bail the same day. The Customs Department examined two witnesses before charge, the last being on May 11, 1983, and then considered the first complaint to suffer from defects that needed to be cured.
On June 17, 1983 the Customs Department filed a second complaint on the same facts (Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983) against three of the original accused (original Nos. 1, 5 and 6) for offences under S. 120, I.P.C. and S. 135(1)(b)(ii) of the Customs Act read with S. 5 of the Imports and Exports Act. The trial Magistrate declined to take cognizance or issue process on the second complaint while the first complaint (Case No. 40.CW/1983) remained pending at the stage of framing charge, and ordered that issuance of process in Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983 would be considered only after disposal of Case No. 40.CW/1983. This order was the subject-matter of the present Revision Application.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial Magistrate erred by refusing to take cognizance of the second complaint (Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983) on the ground that the first complaint (Case No. 40.CW/1983) was pending and process had already been issued in that case.
- Whether the filing and taking cognizance of a second complaint on the same facts is prohibited by law, including whether Article 20(2) of the Constitution (prohibition against being prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once) prevents such a second complaint from being taken cognizance of.
- Whether considerations of hardship or harassment to the accused (including delay, repeated proceedings, fresh bonds/security and the accused's foreign nationality and desire to leave the country) justify refusing to take cognizance of the second complaint.
Arguments of the Parties
Complainant (Customs Department) — as represented by Shri A.R. Gupte
- The trial Magistrate failed to exercise jurisdiction by not considering or taking cognizance of the second complaint.
- The second complaint was filed to cure defects in the first complaint and was lawfully filed.
- Once cognizance and process are taken in the second complaint, the Customs Department could seek appropriate orders to drop the first complaint.
- If the first complaint were withdrawn but the Magistrate refused to take cognizance of the second complaint, the accused would escape prosecution; therefore the Magistrate should have taken cognizance and decided the second complaint on its merits.
Accused — as represented by Shri R.G. Matadar
- The Magistrate's order was correct: if the Customs Department noticed defects in the first complaint, it should have dropped that complaint and taken legally permissible steps rather than seeking a conditional order on the second complaint.
- Accused No. 1 (a foreign national) and others have suffered harassment by being made to face repeated proceedings in India and wish to return to their residence (South Africa); entertaining the second complaint would exacerbate that harassment.
- Taking cognizance of the second complaint would require fresh personal bonds and/or security and further delay; the alleged offence occurred as early as Jan. 1, 1982 and over two years have passed without trial.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| R.P. Kapur v. Delhi Development Authority, 1976 Cri LJ 1285 (Delhi High Court) | Held that being prosecuted in two cases for the same offence is not itself vitiated; Art. 20(2) bars punishment more than once, not necessarily prosecution twice. | The court relied on this decision to support the proposition that filing and cognizance of a second complaint on the same facts is not thereby prohibited by Article 20(2) and that the Magistrate should have taken cognizance of the second complaint and considered it on the merits. |
| S.A. Venkataraman v. Union of India, AIR 1954 SC 375 : 1954 Cri LJ 993 (Supreme Court) | Authority relied upon by the Delhi High Court in the R.P. Kapur decision on the scope of Art. 20(2) (as cited in the opinion). | The Court noted that the Delhi High Court relied upon this Supreme Court judgment in addressing whether two prosecutions for the same offence vitiate the proceedings; it was therefore part of the chain of precedent the Court used to conclude Art. 20(2) did not bar the second complaint at the present stage. |
| Assandas v. Nathrimal, 1954 Cri LJ 1234 (Ajmer / Rajasthan High Court) | Held (in that decision) that a second complaint is not maintainable. | The present Court noted this decision but expressly disagreed with it, preferring the Delhi High Court view (R.P. Kapur). The Court did not follow Assandas v. Nathrimal. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded in a step-wise analysis grounded on the statutory and constitutional position as reflected in the record and precedent:
- The Court examined whether any provision of the Code of Criminal Procedure expressly prohibits filing a second complaint on the same set of facts or taking cognizance of it while an earlier complaint is pending. No such prohibition in the Code was pointed out by counsel, and the Court did not find one in its review.
- The Court identified Article 20(2) of the Constitution ("No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once.") as the only clear constitutional prohibition potentially relevant to consecutive proceedings. The Court reproduced the text of Art. 20(2) and analyzed its scope.
- The Court held that Article 20(2) addresses prosecution and punishment for the same offence more than once, and that given the procedural stages of the two pending criminal cases in the present matter, Article 20(2) was not attracted. The Court explained that at the stages at which the two matters stood, it could not be said that Art. 20(2) would be violated merely by taking cognizance of the second complaint.
- The Court relied on the Delhi High Court's decision in R.P. Kapur (which itself relied on the Supreme Court decision in S.A. Venkataraman) for the proposition that prosecuting a person in two cases for the same offence is not necessarily vitiated; what Art. 20(2) prohibits is punishment more than once. The Court quoted the relevant passage from the Delhi High Court decision to illustrate this principle.
- The Court considered the accused's argument concerning harassment and hardship (fresh bonds/security, protracted delay, and the accused's desire to return abroad). The Court acknowledged that entertaining the second complaint would cause hardship — including the possibility of fresh security/bonds — but held that such hardship cannot defeat the complainant's right to file a second complaint and seek cognizance and further action according to law.
- The Court noted the contrary view in Assandas v. Nathrimal (where the Ajmer Court held a second complaint not maintainable), but expressly disagreed with that decision and preferred the view of the Delhi High Court in R.P. Kapur.
- On these bases, the Court concluded that the trial Magistrate erred in refusing to take cognizance of the second complaint and in making the issuance of process under the second complaint conditional upon disposal of the first complaint.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The petition is allowed. The impugned order dated June 30, 1983 is quashed and set aside. The matter is remitted to the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate for consideration of Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983 on its merits and for further orders in accordance with law. The Rule is made absolute.
Implications:
- The trial Magistrate is directed to take cognizance of and consider the second complaint (Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983) on its merits and pass appropriate orders in accordance with law.
- The direct effect on the parties is that the second complaint must now be considered; this may result in issuance of process and related steps (which could lead to fresh bonds/security and continued proceedings against the accused).
- The Court acknowledged potential hardship to the accused if the second complaint is entertained, but ruled that such hardship does not bar the complainant from filing a second complaint and seeking legal proceedings.
- No new legal principle or precedent was declared beyond the application and preference of existing authorities (the Court expressly preferred the Delhi High Court view in R.P. Kapur over the Ajmer decision in Assandas v. Nathrimal).
Note: This summary is based exclusively on the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.
1. This Criminal Revision Application is directed against the Order dated June 30, 1983, in Case No. 40.CW/1983 and Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983, passed by the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Esplanade, Bombay.
2. The learned trial Magistrate has precisely and correctly narrated the facts of two complaints lodged by the Customs Department in his Court. I may only briefly refer to few dates which are necessary to appreciate the rival contentions raised before me in this Revision Applications. On Feb. 21, 1982, the Assistant Collector of Customs, Bombay, filed a complaint bearing Case No. 40.CS/1983 under S. 120B, I.P.C.S 135(1)(b)(ii) of the Customs Act and S. 5 of the Imports and Exports (Control) Act. This complaint was filed against six accused persons. It is alleged in that complaint that accused No. 1 — Respondent No. 1 Razak Kasim Narkar, a South African national was about to leave for Salisbury by air and upon examination of his baggage it disclosed 2 lac tablets of Mandrex valued at Rs. 2,00,000/- and some foreign exchange. It is then alleged that the accused No. 1 was not having requisite permission to export these articles and, therefore, these articles came, to be seized under a panchanama. After carrying out the necessary investigation, the aforesaid criminal complaint came to be filed against these six accused persons. The accused No. 1 was released on bail by the trial Magistrate on Feb. 21, 1982. The Customs Department then examined two witnesses before the charge. Last witness was examined on May 11, 1983. At this stage Customs department prima facie opined that the complaint suffers from some defects and those defects need to be cured.
3. The Customs Department, therefore, took the decision to file another complaint, and accordingly, on June 17, 1983, second complaint on the same facts came to be filed in the Court of Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, Bombay. The said case is numbered as 4.Misc. of 1983. Second complaint is filed by the Customs Department only against the three accused persons who are original accused Nos. 1, 5 and 6 in Case No. 40.CW 1983. This new complaint is filed for the offences punishable under S. 120, I.P.C and S. 135(1)(b)(ii) of the Customs Act read with S. 5 of the Imports and Exports Act. The learned trial Magistrate has considered the allegations contained in both these complaints in his Judgment and I do not think, it is necessary to reproduce the same in this Judgment. The difficulty that arose before the learned trial Magistrate was in connection with taking congnizance of the second complaint when the first complaint bearing Case No. 40.CW/1983 is still alive and in which process has already been issued and the said case is at the stage of framing of the charge. The Customs Department in its second complaint has made a reference to the pendency of the first complaint. It also recites the necessity of filing of this second complaint. The second complaint bearing No. 4.Misc. of 1983 was placed before the Chief Metropolitan Magistrate for taking congnizance. The Magistrate upon perusing the contents of the second complaint opined that unless the first complaint is disposed of, the cognizance of the second complaint including the issuance of the process cannot be considered. In view of this conclusion, the learned trial Magistrate passed the following order:
“Issuance of process on the complaint in Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983 would be considered only after the disposal of Case No. 40.CW/1983. Case No. 40.CW/1983 to continue.”
4. It is this Order passed by the learned Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, is the subject-matter of this Revision Application.
5. Shri A.R Gupte, the learned Advocate appearing for the Complainant Customs Department in support of this Revision Application urged that the order passed by the trial Magistrate suffers from vice of failure to exercise the jurisdiction vested in him by not considering and/or taking cognizance of the second complaint filed by the Customs Department. Shri Gupte then urged that since the Customs Department prima facie opined that there are some defects in the first complaint and in order to cure those defects, the second complaint has been filed in accordance with law. He also submitted that moment the learned trial Magistrate takes the cognizance and issues the process in the second complaint, necessary orders will be obtained in regard to the first complaint for dropping the same. The main apprehension presented before me by the learned Counsel is that at this stage if the first complaint is withdrawn and/or dropped against the accused and if the learned trial Magistrate refuses to take the congnizance and/or to issue process in the second complaint then the alleged offence of the accused would go untied and unpunished. Having regard to the nature of offence and the complicity of the accused, the learned Counsel submitted that the learned trial Magistrate ought to have taken congnizance of the second complaint and he ought to have passed the orders on merits. Shri R.G Matadar, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the accused urged that the order passed by the learned trial Magistrate is right in as much as if the Customs Department had noticed defects in their first complaint, then it was expected on their part to drop that complaint and take such necessary steps as they deem fit and permissible under law and they cannot ask for a conditional order on the second complaint from the Court. In this connection, Shri Matadar strongly urged that the accused No. 1 is a foreign national and has been put to great harassment inasmuch as he is made to face several proceedings in India. He also urged that the accused No. 1 is very keen to go to his place of residence in South Africa and because of this criminal proceedings he is unable to go to his place. He also made a grievance about the execution of the bail bonds that will be required to execute in case the trial Magistrate takes the cognizance of the second complaint and issues the process. With the assistance of the learned Counsel, I have gone through the Judgment of the trial Magistrate as well as the relevant papers. Both the learned counsel were unable to point out any provision under the Code of Criminal Procedure which prohibits filing of the second complaint on the same set of facts and/or taking the congnizance of the same by the learned trial Magistrate. The only prohibition that could be spelt out is the one contained in Art. 20(2) of the Constitution. The provision reads as under:
“20.(2) No person shall be prosecuted and punished for the same offence more than once.
6. The prohibition therefore, is in connection with the prosecution and punishment for the offence more than once. In the present case, having regard to the nature of stages at which these two criminal cases are pending, it cannot be said that the provision of Cl. (2) of Art. 20 of the Constitution would be attracted. A somewhat similar question fell for consideration before Delhi High Court in R.P Kapur v. Delhi Development Authority, 1976 Cri LJ 1285. The Delhi Development Authority in that case has filed separate complaints against each of the petitioners under S. 29(2) read with S. 14 of the Act. While considering the maintainability of the two complaints for the same offences on the touchstone of Cl. (2) of Art. 20 of the Constitution, Delhi High Court for its conclusion relied upon the judgment of the Supreme Court in S.A Venkataraman v. 1. Union Of India, AIR 1954 SC 375 : (1954 Cri LJ 993). Delhi High Court has held as follows (At p. 1292 of Cri LJ):
“Therefore, even if we assume for a moment that the first petitioner is being prosecuted in two cases for the same offence, such a prosecution itself is not vitiated. What is prohibited by Art. 20(2) is his punishment in both the cases. In this connection, it is pointed out on behalf of the DDA that both the complaints filed against the first petitioner being tried together and that there was an offer made by the DDA at one stage to withdraw one of the complaints which was, however, opposed by the first petitioner himself. We have no doubt that the learned Magistrate will take note of the provisions of Art. 20(2) of the Constitution in dealing with these cases against the first petitioner.”
7. Thus, in my opinion, the learned Magistrate ought to have taken the cognizance of the second complaint filed by the Customs Department and would have passed the appropriate orders in accordance with law.
8. Coming to the second argument of Shri Matadar that the accused No. 1 and other accused persons will be put to harassment if second complaint is entertained and process is issued, he urged that each of the accused will have to give fresh personal bond and/or furnish the security. In addition to this, he also urged that the alleged offence took place as back as on 1st Jan. 1982 and more than two years have passed yet it has not seen the light of the trial. For all these two years, accused No. 1 as well as the other accused person have suffered a great harassment and the same will be perpetuated if the cognizance of the second complaint is taken by the trial Magistrate. I see some force in this argument of Shri Matadar and there would be undoubtedly some hardship to the accused persons who will have to undergo ordeal of fresh security etc. if they are released on bail upon taking cognizance of the second complaint and if the process is issued against them. This aspect, however, cannot affect the right of the complainant to file second complaint and pray for taking cognizance and take further action in that behalf in accordance with law.
9. Shri Matadar then drew my attention to the judgment of Rajasthan High Court in Assandas v. Nathrimal, 1954 Cri LJ 1234 (Ajmer). It is true that learned Judge of the Ajmer Court held that the second complaint is not maintainable but however, I do not agree with the said judgment. I prefer to rely upon the Judgment of the Delhi High Court (Division Bench) which I have referred hereinabove. The learned Magistrate is thus directed to consider the second complaint No. 4.Misc. of 1983 on merits and pass appropriate orders thereon. The petition succeeds. The impugned order dated June 30, 1983 is quashed and set aside the matter is remitted back to the trial Magistrate for further orders in Case No. 4.Misc. of 1983 in accordance with law. Rule is made absolute.
10. Petition allowed.
Alert