Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

United India Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Abdul Munaf Majur Hussain Momin And Others

Bombay High Court
Aug 17, 1984
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (P. B. Sawant, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

These three appeals arise from the same motor-vehicle accident. Appeal No. 1012 of 1980 and Appeal No. 1013 of 1980 were filed by the insurer of the truck (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.) challenging the Tribunal's findings making the insurer liable to pay compensation to heirs of two deceased passengers. Appeal No. 224 of 1981 was preferred by the heirs of one deceased passenger (Dost Mohammed) seeking enhancement of compensation and to challenge the dismissal of their claim against the truck owner.

Material facts (as stated in the opinion): On 9 May 1979 a goods truck returning from a dairy carried 35 persons (allegedly for Re. 1/- each) though it had a goods permit only. Within minutes the truck turned turtle and six passengers died, including Jamilabi (heirs are claimants in Appeal No. 1012) and Dost Mohammed (heirs are claimants in Appeal No. 1013). The Tribunal found that the driver carried passengers with his knowledge and charged Re. 1/- per passenger, and it made the insurer and the driver liable to pay compensation (amounts of Rs. 6,200/- in Appeal No. 1012 and Rs. 50,300/- in Appeal No. 1013). The owner had been exonerated by the Tribunal. The insurer appealed in both matters; the heirs of Dost Mohammed appealed (No. 224/1981) against the dismissal of claim against the owner and for enhancement of compensation.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the insurer (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.) was liable to pay compensation to passengers (or their heirs) who were carried in a goods vehicle used contrary to the permit and contrary to policy conditions.
  2. Whether the owner of the truck was vicariously liable for the acts of the driver in taking passengers in the truck contrary to the terms of employment and/or contrary to the vehicle's permit.
  3. Whether the compensation awarded by the Tribunal (in respect of Dost Mohammed) required enhancement, and what components (salary projection, family pension, deductions for lump-sum) should be included or excluded in the computation.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Insurer)

  • The truck was insured only as a goods vehicle; the insurance policy expressly excluded use for conveyance of passengers for hire or reward.
  • The truck did not have a permit to carry passengers; therefore the insurer was not liable for passenger injuries/death under the policy.

Owner (Respondent No. 6 in Appeal No. 1012 / Respondent No. 7 in Appeal No. 1013)

  • The owner denied liability, asserting that the driver acted contrary to his express instructions and outside the scope of employment by taking passengers; therefore owner should not be held liable.

Driver (Respondent No. 7 in Appeal No. 1012 / Respondent No. 8 in Appeal No. 1013)

  • The driver stated he did not know the 35 passengers had boarded and that they had boarded without his knowledge or consent; thus he sought to avoid liability.

Claimants (Heirs of Deceased)

  • In the enhancement appeal (Appeal No. 224/1981) claimants contended that the deceased (Dost Mohammed) had a pay-scale and at death was drawing Rs. 500/- per month (not Rs. 733 as alleged in some parts of the Tribunal's calculation), would have risen to higher pay within nine years and that the Tribunal wrongly deducted family pension; they argued for a higher dependency rate (Rs. 500/- or more) and thus a higher total compensation.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Pushpabai's case, 1977 A.C.J. 343 S.C. Holds that passengers travelling in a vehicle are not "third parties" for the purpose of motor insurance third-party coverage. Applied to reject the Tribunal's reasoning that payment of additional premium for third-party risk made the insurer liable for passenger deaths; court held passengers are not third parties and thus passenger risk was not covered by the third-party premium.
National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nathibai Chaturabhuj, 1982 A.C.J. 153 (Gujarat) (Full Bench) Affirms that where vehicle use is prohibited by permit/policy, insurer is not liable for liability arising from that prohibited use. Relied upon to support the proposition that under section 96(2)(b)(i)(c) (MV Act) and policy conditions, insurer had a valid defence where the truck, permitted only as a goods vehicle, was used to carry passengers.
Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt (Supreme Court) Authority concerning vicarious liability of owner for acts of driver (used to support court's conclusion on owner liability). The court stated it was "fortified" by this Supreme Court decision in concluding that the owner need not be held vicariously liable when driver acted contrary to his authority/instructions.
M. Visalakshi v. Luthern Charch (High Court) and Mohiddinsab Gaffarsab Kundgol v. Rohidas Hari Kindalkar, 1973 A.C.J. 424 (Mysore) High Court authority on vicarious liability principles (cited together with Sitaram Motilal Kalal). Used to support the conclusion that the owner was not vicariously liable where driver acted outside the scope/contrary to employment.
Narayanlal v. Rukhmanibai, 1979 A.C.J. 261 (M.P.) Holds that where driver was not expressly prohibited from taking passengers, the owner may be liable. Distinguished by the court: not applied because here the court found the driver's solitary denial of prohibition was insufficient and the facts did not permit relying on Narayanlal's ratio.
Kashiram Mathur v. Sardar Rajendra Singh, 1983 A.C.J. 152 (M.P.) Holds that family pension should not be deducted from compensation (Full Bench of Madhya Pradesh High Court). Referred to in the context of whether the family pension amount should be deducted from dependency; court considered the authority when addressing the Tribunal's deduction of family pension.
Bhagat Singh Sohau Singh v. Om Sharma, 1983 A.C.J. 203 (P. & H.) High Court authority holding that family pension should not be deducted from compensation. Considered by the court when assessing whether the Tribunal properly deducted family pension from the dependency amount; the court noted lack of material about terms of pension before it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court's analysis proceeded in distinct steps addressing liability of the insurer, the liability of the owner, and the quantum of compensation.

1. Insurer's liability:

  • Admitted facts: the truck had a permit for use as a goods vehicle only; the insurance policy explicitly excluded "use for the conveyance of passengers for hire or reward" and contained provisos excluding passengers from third-party coverage except as required by section 95 (Workmen's Compensation Act reference).
  • The Tribunal had concluded insurer was liable because an additional premium of Rs. 64/- was paid to make the insurer's third-party liability "unlimited". The Tribunal equated third-party risk coverage with passenger risk coverage.
  • The court found this to be a basic error: relying on Pushpabai's case, the court reiterated that passengers are not "third parties" for the purpose of third-party insurance cover; therefore payment for extended third-party coverage did not extend to passengers carried contrary to the policy.
  • Additionally, the truck was used contrary to the R.T.O. permit (it was prohibited from carrying passengers) and this breach of permit and an express condition in the policy excluded coverage. The court cited section 96(2)(b)(i)(c) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 and the Full Bench decision in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nathibai Chaturabhuj to support the legal proposition that insurer is not liable where vehicle was used for a purpose not allowed by its permit and policy conditions.
  • Conclusion: the Tribunal misread policy terms and misapplied the concept of third-party risk; insurer had a valid defence and its appeals overturning Tribunal findings on insurer liability succeed.

2. Owner's vicarious liability:

  • The claimants relied on the proposition that the driver had not been specifically prohibited by the owner and sought to fasten vicarious liability on the owner.
  • The court examined the evidence: documentary proof showed the truck was registered and permitted only as a goods vehicle and prohibited from conveying passengers; the owner stated he never permitted the driver to carry passengers; the driver gave inconsistent/negative evidence (one solitary statement that the owner had not prohibited him).
  • The court explained that negative testimony by the driver alone would not suffice to fasten liability on the owner, particularly where documentary evidence contradicted the notion of owner permission and where the driver admitted collecting Re. 1/- from passengers and that passengers had boarded perhaps without his conscious admission.
  • Referencing Sitaram Motilal Kalal and two High Court decisions, the court concluded the driver's act was contrary to his employment and not within the scope of his authority; therefore, owner could not be held vicariously liable on these facts.

3. Quantum of compensation (Appeal No. 224/1981):

  • The Tribunal's original calculation for Dost Mohammed: Tribunal assumed monthly disposable dependency about Rs. 500/- (after allowing Rs. 200 for deceased's personal expenses from emoluments of Rs. 733/- stated by the Tribunal), then deducted family pension (Rs. 175) and interest on gratuity (Rs. 75) yielding net dependency Rs. 250; multiplied over 20 years and reduced by 25% for lump-sum acceleration, giving Rs. 45,000, plus Rs. 5,000 general damages and Rs. 300 funeral expenses = Rs. 50,300.
  • Claimants argued the deceased's pay-scale showed he was drawing Rs. 500/- basic and would rise to maximum within nine years and subject to future revisions/D.A., and also argued the Tribunal should not have deducted family pension (citing authorities).
  • The court found the Tribunal erred in ignoring prospective rises in emoluments and in taking family pension into account without evidence as to its terms. The court noted there was no material before it on the precise terms/conditions of the family pension; if the pension were available on the same terms as for other government servants it might involve employee contributions and be payable on natural death too (hence the appropriateness of deduction is questionable).
  • Balancing these considerations, the court adopted a corrected approach: it fixed monthly dependency at Rs. 600 (allowing for revisions/rises and adjusting the Tribunal's deduction), multiplied 600 × 12 × 20 = Rs. 1,44,000, then applied a 50% deduction for acceleration of benefits (stated by the court), yielding Rs. 72,000. Interest at 6% per annum was awarded until realization.

Holding and Implications

Core Rulings:

  • Appeal No. 1012 of 1980: Allowed. The Tribunal order was modified (text of modification stated in the opinion). The court concluded that the insurance company was not liable to pay the compensation as held by the Tribunal; the Tribunal's order was set aside to the extent it made the insurance company liable.
  • Appeal No. 1013 of 1980: Allowed. For the same reasons as in Appeal No. 1012, the Tribunal's order insofar as it made the insurer liable for Rs. 50,300/- was set aside.
  • Appeal No. 224 of 1981 (by the claimants): Partly allowed and partly dismissed. The appeal as against the owner was dismissed (owner not liable). However, on the question of enhancement of compensation, the court increased the award against the person held liable (the driver / respondent liable under the decision) from Rs. 50,300/- to Rs. 72,000/-, with interest at 6% per annum until realization.

Implications for the parties:

  • The insurer (United India Insurance Co. Ltd.) was relieved of liability for passenger deaths because the policy and permit excluded passenger carriage for hire or reward and passengers are not "third parties" under the insurance cover at issue (per Pushpabai's case).
  • The truck owner was not held vicariously liable because the driver acted contrary to the terms of his employment and documentary evidence supported lack of owner permission; the owner's appeal dismissal means claim against owner fails.
  • The claimants (heirs of Dost Mohammed) obtained an enhanced award: Rs. 72,000 with 6% interest, payable by the respondent held liable (as framed in the court's order). The Tribunal's earlier award of Rs. 50,300 was held to be inadequate.
  • No new legal principle or departure from cited authorities was announced; the court applied existing precedent (as cited) to the facts. The opinion does not state that it establishes a new precedent; the decision operates to apply existing case law to the present facts and to determine the rights/liabilities of the parties accordingly.

Selected Quotations from the Opinion (for clarity)

"This makes it abundantly clear that the policy did not cover use for the conveyance of passengers for hire or reward." (Opinion, discussion of policy provisos)
"As has been held by the Supreme Court in Pushpabai's case, the passengers travelling in the vehicle are not third parties, and hence, the conclusion arrived at by the Tribunal that the insurance company was liable because of the said coverage of the third party risk is obviously erroneous." (Opinion)

Notes on Sources and Limits of this Summary

This summary is prepared exclusively from the text of the provided court opinion. It does not add facts or inferences that are not contained in the opinion. Where the opinion quotes or cites authorities and statutes, the summary reports those citations and their use by the court but does not supplement them with external material.

Show all summary ...

P.B Sawant, J.:— These three appeals arise out of the same accident and are being disposed of by this common judgment since the material facts are common. Appeal No. 1012 of 1980 arises out of an application for claim made by the heirs and legal representatives of one of the victims of the accident while Appeal No. 1013 of 1980 arises out of the application for claim made by the heirs and legal representatives of another victim of the accident. Appeal No. 224 of 1981 is preferred for enhancement of compensation by the heirs of the second victim. For the purposes of convenience we will deal first with Appeal No. 1012 of 1980. Reference to the parties hereafter is with reference to Appeal No. 1012 of 1980. This appeal is preferred by the insurer of the truck, namely the United India Insurance Co. Ltd. challenging the liability to pay the compensation to respondents 1 to 5 who are the original claimants, and heirs and legal representatives of the deceased Jamilabi. Respondent No. 6 is the owner of the truck which met with the accident in question and respondent No. 7 was the driver of the truck at the material time. The truck was insured with the appellant-insurance company at the relevant time. On the 9th May, 1979, the truck in question was returning in the morning with empty milk cans after delivering milk at the milk dairy at Faizpur. On this return journey, respondent No. 7 driver allowed 35 persons to board the truck by charging them Re. 1/- per head as fare for their journey from the dairy at Faizpur to Yawal. After the truck left Faizpur with 35 empty cans and equal number of passengers, within a couple of minutes and about a couple of furlongs away from the dairy the truck turned turtle and the passengers in the truck were thrown overboard. Some of them were crushed under the truck. As a result in all six passengers died. Two of them died on the spot. One of them was Jamilabi whose heirs, i.e respondent Nos. 1 to 5 are the claimants in the present proceedings and the other was one Dost Mohammed whose heirs are the claimants in Appeal No. 1013 of 1980. We will deal with the facts of that case at a later stage.

2. The claim was resisted by the appellant-insurance company on the ground that the truck was insured with it only as goods vehicle. The policy did not cover the use of the vehicle for the conveyance of the passengers for hire or reward. The truck also did not have a permit to carry any passengers, but was registered with the Regional Transport office as a goods vehicle. In the circumstances, the insurance company was not liable to pay compensation to the passenger-victims or their heirs, who were carried in the truck contrary to the terms of the insurance policy. Respondent No. 6, the owner denied his liability urging that the driver had acted in contravention of his instructions in taking passengers in the truck and that when he was driving the truck he was acting contrary to and outside the terms of his employment. The persons who boarded the truck knew that it was not a passenger vehicle, he was therefore not liable to pay compensation either to the victims or to their heirs and legal representatives. According to respondent No. 7, driver, he did not know that the said 35 passengers had boarded the truck and since they had boarded the truck without his knowledge or consent he was not liable to pay compensation to the victims or the claimants on their behalf. On these pleadings and the evidence on record, the Tribunal held that the fact that said 35 persons were travelling in the truck at the time of the accident was established; that the respondent No. 7 the driver was driving the truck at the material time and that the said passengers had boarded the truck with his knowledge and consent in as much as he had also charged them Re. 1/- per head for carrying them from Faizpur to Yawal. The Tribunal further held that the insurance policy covered unlimited risk and since the additional premium of Rs. 64/- was paid for covering third party's risk, the insurance company was liable to pay compensation. The Tribunal also held that since the driver in taking the passengers in the truck had acted against the express injunction of the owner, respondent No. 6, owner was not liable to pay the compensation. In the result, the Tribunal held the insurance company and the driver liable to pay compensation of Rs. 6,200/- to the claimants, respondent Nos. 1 to 5. It is aggrieved by this decision that the insurance company has filed the present appeal. The claimants have not preferred any appeal against the decision of the Tribunal holding that the owner of the truck was not liable to pay the said compensation. We have thus before us only the appeal of the insurance company in this case. As regards Appeal No. 1013 of 1980 is concerned, this is also filed by the insurance company. The claimants in that case are the heirs of the said Dost Mohammad. They are respondents 1 to 6 in the appeal, the owner and the driver being respondents 7 and 8 respectively. In that case on the same reasoning the Tribunal allowed claim of Rs. 50,300/- against the insurance company and the driver respondent No. 8 in favour of the claimant-respondent Nos. 1 to 6. In that case, however, the claimants, i.e original respondent Nos. 1 to 6 have preferred an appeal being first Appeal No. 224 of 1981 both against the dismissal of their claim against the owner of the truck as well as for enhancement of the amount of compensation awarded to them.

3. We will first deal with a question of law which is common to both the appeals, namely, whether the insurance company on the facts and circumstances of the case was liable to pay the compensation as held by the Tribunal.

4. The admitted facts are that the truck had a permit under the Motor Vehicles Act only for the purposes of running it as a goods vehicle. The insurance policy which is Exh. 56 on record did not cover the use of the truck for the conveyance of passengers for hire or reward. In fact, in specific words an injunction against such user has been incorporated in the policy itself. Proviso (c) to clause (1) of section II of the policy makes this abundantly clear. Section II relates to the liability to third parties and sub-clause (i) of clause (1) states as follows:

“(1) Subject to the limits of liability the company will indemnify the insured against all sums including claimant's cost and expenses which the insured became legally liable to pay in respect of

(i) death of or bodily injury to any person caused by or arising out of the use (including the loading and/or unloading) of the motor vehicle.”

5. Then follows the proviso (c) which states as follows:

“Provided always that:

(a) xxxxxx

(b) xxxxxx

(c) Except so far as is necessary to meet the requirements of section 95 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, in relation to liability under the Workmen's Compensation Act, 1923, the company shall not be liable in respect of death of or bodily injury to any person (other than a passenger carried by reason of or in pursuance of a contract of employment) being carried in or upon entering or mounting or alighting from the motor vehicle at the time of the occurrence of the event out of which any claim arises.”

6. Further the policy mentions limitations as to use and one of the limitations stated is as follows:

“Use for the conveyance of passengers for hire or reward.”

7. This makes it abundantly clear that the policy did not cover use for the conveyance of passengers for hire or reward. The extra premium of Rs. 64/- was paid only for making the insurance company's liability unlimited so far as the third parly risks were concerned. Admittedly the third parties did not include the passengers in the vehicle in view of the decision of the Supreme Court in Pushpabai's case . 1977 A.C.J 343 S.C.. The other additional premium of Rs. 24/- further was paid in order to cover the risk of the driver and the cleaner as stated in endorsement No. 16. Thus the truck being a goods vehicle the insurance policy of the truck did not cover the risk to the pas-sengers travelling in it. Under section 96(2)(b)(i)(c) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 the appellant-insurance company, therefore, had a valid defence to the claim. Further, the said section says that if the conditions specified in the policy is that the insured vehicle will not be used for a purpose not allowed by the permit under which the vehicle is used, where the vehicle is a transport vehicle no sum shall be payable by the insurer in respect of the liability arising out of the accident. This is also the view expressed by the Full Bench of the Gujarat High Court in a decision reported in National Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Nathibai Chaturabhuj . 1982 A.C.J 153 Gujarat.. This position of law is not disputed before us by any of the contesting parties. The learned Member of the Tribunal has however saddled the insurance company with the liability by misreading the terms of the policy and their implications. According to the Tribunal since section II of the policy dealt with liability to the third parties and since the insurance company had charged additional amount of Rs. 64/- for covering third party risk, the company would be liable to pay the compensation to the claimants. While arriving at the said conclusion the Tribunal has committed a basic error in confusing the third party risk with the passenger risk. As has been held by the Supreme Court in Pushpabai's case, the passengers travelling in the vehicle are not third parties, and hence, the conclusion arrived at by the Tribunal that the insurance company was liable because of the said coverage of the third party risk is obviously erroneous. This is apart from the fact that, as pointed out earlier, in the present case it was established by the insurance company that the truck was prohibited by the R.T.O permit to carry any passengers for hire or reward. A specific condition in the policy excluded the use of the truck for the carriage of any passengers for hire or reward. The truck was therefore admittedly used in breach of the permit and the condition in the policy. We are therefore more than satisfied that the order of the Tribunal is erroneous to the extent that it makes the insurance was admittedly in the employment of company liable to pay compensation to respondent No. 1 at the relevant time. It the claimants on account of the death of is further contended that there is no Jamilabi who was a passenger in the truck. This appeal therefore will have to be allowed and the order of the Tribunal to that extent will have to be set aside. Appeal No. 1012 of 1980 is hereby allowed and the order dated the 28th October, 1980 passed by the Tribunal is modified as follows:

“The petitioner's claim for Rs. 6,200/- is decreed against opponent No. 2 only. Claim against opponent Nos. 1 and 3 is dismissed. The rest of the money claim is dismissed. Parties to bear their own costs. Interest at 6% per annum is granted on the sum of Rs. 6,200/- from the date of the petition till the amount is realised. Award be drawn accordingly. In the circumstances of the case there will be no order as to costs.”

8. Coming now to Appeal No. 1013 of 1980 filed by the insurance company, for the same reasons we allow the said appeal and hold that the Tribunal's order so far as it makes the insurance company liable to pay the said amount of Rs. 50,300/- to respondents 1 to 6 to the appeal, will have to be set aside and is hereby set aside.

9. As regards Appeal No. 224 of 1981 filed by the claimants both against their dismissal of claim against respondent No. 7, owner and for the enhancement of the compensation, for the reasons stated hereinafter, the appeal against the owner will have to be dismissed. We have already allowed the appeal of the insurance company, and therefore, the appeal against the insurance company will stand dismissed at the threshold.

10. Our reasons for dismissing the appeal against the owner respondent No. 1 to the said appeal, are as follows: The only contention advanced in support of their claim against the owner of the truck is that the truck belonged to respondent No. 1 and respondent No. 2, the driver, positive evidence brought on record to show that respondent No. 1, owner, had specifically prohibited respondent No. 2 from taking any passengers in the truck. On the other hand, deposition of the driver shows that he was not so specifically prohibited by the owner of the truck. We are afraid that for fastening the liability on the owner, the negative evidence of the driver will alone not be sufficient. This is particularly so when the documentary evidence on record shows that the truck was registered and has permit only to ply as a goods vehicle and further that it was prohibited from being used for conveying passengers either for hire or reward. What is more, the stand taken by the driver himself is that the passengers in question had boarded the truck without his knowledge. In other words, his case was that he had not taken the passengers in the truck consciously. If the owner of the truck had permitted the carriage of the passengers, then, certainly he would have come out with the positive case that he was carrying the passengers with the permission of the owner of the truck. On the other hand his prevarication on the point shows that he was carrying the passengers slyly to make money on his own without the knowledge of the owner of the truck. The evidence also further shows that he had collected Re. 1/- from each passenger to whom he gave lift. The truck had admittedly gone to the dairy plant with milk cans and it was returning with the empty cans when the driver obviously tried to make the fast buck. The owner in his deposition has stated that he had never permitted the driver to carry any passengers in the truck. All that the claimants had succeeded in eliciting from the driver was a solitary sentence in his deposition where he has stated that the owner had not prohibited him from taking passengers. However, this is far from saying that the owner had permitted him to take the passengers for hire or reward. In the circumstances of the case it will be difficult to hold that the driver had taken the passengers either under the authority of or with the knowledge or consent of the owner and that he was carrying the passengers during the course of his employment. On the contrary it will have to be held that the driver's act in taking and carrying the passengers in the truck was contrary to the terms of his employment, and the conveyance of the passengers was not during the course of his employment. In the circumstances, it will be difficult to hold the owner responsible even vicariously for the act of the driver. In this view we are fortified by the decision of the Supreme Court reported in Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt and of the two High Courts in M. Visalakshi v. Luthern Charch and Mohiddinsab Gaffarsab Kundgol v. Rohidas Hari Kindalkar . 1973 A.C.J 424 Mysore.. Mr. Pandit the learned counsel appearing for the claimants strongly relied upon a decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court reported in Narayanlal v. Rukhmanibai . 1979 A.C.J 261 M.P. which takes the view that when the driver is not expressly prohibited from taking the passengers in the vehicle, the master, i.e the owner is liable for the act of the driver. Since we have taken the view in the present case that it is not possible to rely upon the evidence of the driver when he says that he was not expressly prohibited by the owner, the ratio of the said decision will not be applicable to the facts of the present case. In this view of the matter, we have to hold that the owner of the truck is not liable and the appeal against him must be dismissed. Coming now to the claimants' case for enhancement of the compensation, the Tribunal has worked out the compensation on the following basis: The deceased Dost Mohammed was a Senior clerk in the Block Development Office of the Zilla Parishad, Jalgaon, and hismoathly emoluments were Rs. 733/-. At the time of his death, he was 38 years old and his superannuation age was 58. The Tribunal has held that Rs. 200/- or thereabout were spent by the deceased on himself, and therefore, the balance of about Rs. 500/- was available to the family. The Tribunal then took into account the family pension of Rs. 175/- per month that the claimants would get and also Rs. 75/- as and by way of interest on the gratuity that they would get and deducted the amount of Rs. 250/-, i.e, Rs. 175/- plus Rs. 75/- from the monthly amount of Rs. 500/- which was the dependency of the claimants, and came to the conclusion that the family would get during the period of 20 years Rs. 250×12×20 = Rs. 60,000/-. From that amount the Tribunal deducted amount equal to 25% in view of the fact that the claimants were getting one lump sum and arrived at the amount of Rs. 45,000/-. To this amount of Rs. 45,000/- the Tribunal added Rs. 5,000/- as and by way of general damages and Rs. 300/- for funeral expenses, and granted an amount of Rs. 50,300/- as and by way of compensation. The argument advanced by Mr. Pandit on behalf of the claimants is that the deceased was in the pay-scale of Rs. 335-15-500-20-580-20-680 and at the time of his death he was drawing a salary of Rs. 500/-. He would have reached his maximum within nine years. This pay-scale was further subject to future revisions. So also the dearness allowance. Inasmuch as the Tribunal had taken Rs. 500/- per month as the basic salary, the figures worked out by the Tribunal were very much on the lower side. It was further contended on behalf of the claimants that the Tribunal could not have taken into consideration the family pension since it is held by a Full Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Kashiram Mathur v. Sardar Rajendra Singh . 1983 A.C.J 152 M.P. and by the Punjab and Haryana High Court in Bhagat Singh Sohau Singh v. Om Sharma . 1983 A.C.J 203 P. & H.. the family pension could not have been taken into account by the Tribunal. Hence in the present case the dependency rate should be taken as Rs. 500/- instead of Rs. 250/- per month and thus calculated the compensation would come to Rs. 1,20,000/-, i.e, Rs. 500×12 × 20 = Rs. 1,20,000/-.

11. There is no doubt that to the extent the Tribunal ignored the rise in emoluments and took into consideration the family pension without finding out the terms on which the said pension was granted, the Tribunal had committed an error in calculating the compensation. Some allowance has, no doubt, to be made for the increase in the salary, and therefore, the increase in the quantum that would have been available for expenses of the family. As regards the family pension, there is absolutely no material before us to show the terms of the family pension. If we presume that the family pension was made available to the claimants on the same terms and conditions as was given to the family of any other Government servant, it would appear that the deceased would have been required to make some contribution to the family pension fund periodically. The family pension would further have been available to the claimants even if the deceased were to die a natural death. In that case as held by the Madhya Pradesh and Punjab and Haryana High Courts in the decisions cited above, it will not be permissible to deduct the amount of the family pension from the compensation payable to the claimants. Taking therefore into consideration the revision of the pay-scales that the deceased might have been entitled to during the course of his service, and the deduction made by the Tribunal on account of the family pension, according to us, Rs. 600/- would be the proper monthly dependency rate. Calculating the compensation on the said basis, the amount of compensation works out to Rs. 600 × 12 × 20 = Rs. 1,44,000/-. From this amount 50% of the amount will have to be deducted for the acceleration of the benefit. That works out the compensation to Rs. 72,000/-. The claimants would therefore be entitled to Rs. 72,000/-. Hence the amount of Rs. 50,300/- worked out by the Tribunal is very much on the lower side. Hence, it will have to be held that respondent No. 2 is liable to pay to the claimants Rs. 72,000/- instead of Rs. 50,300/- as awarded by the Tribunal. Interest is granted at 6% per annum till the amount is realised.