- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dharamsi Morarji Che... v. N.G Desai, The Regio...
Legal Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners are a public limited company which established a factory at Ambarnath (District Thane) around 1921 (the "Ambarnath factory"). On 9 July 1977 the Company established another factory at Roha (District Kolaba) (the "Roha factory") to manufacture certain organic chemicals not produced at Ambarnath.
Under Section 16(1)(b) of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 ("the Act"), the Roha factory would have been exempt from the Act for three years from its inception (till 9 July 1980). At the request of Roha employees, the Company sought a reduction of this exemption/infancy period and agreed to give up the full three-year advantage, instead seeking to avail exemption for a reduced period. The Company applied to the 1st respondent for such reduction.
The 1st respondent, by order dated 4 March 1980, refused the exemption on the ground that the Ambarnath and Roha factories were under common management and therefore constituted one establishment; accordingly the Roha factory was covered by the Act from its inception on 9 July 1977. The petitioners submitted replies and representations; the 1st respondent rejected the representations by order dated 12 June 1980 and by order dated 2 July 1980 called upon the petitioners to implement the provisions of the Act. The Company filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution seeking to set aside the orders dated 4 March 1980, 12 June 1980 and 2 July 1980.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Roha factory and the Ambarnath factory constitute a single "establishment" (i.e., whether there is "functional integrity") for the purposes of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 such that the Roha factory is covered by the Act from its inception.
- Whether the petitioner Company is entitled to the benefit of the reduced infancy/exemption period under Section 16(1)(b) of the Act in respect of the Roha factory (specifically, exemption for two years from 9 July 1977 as sought by the Company).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' (Company's) Arguments
- The two factories manufacture different products: Ambarnath manufactures heavy inorganic chemicals and mainly fertilizers; Roha manufactures organic chemicals not made at Ambarnath.
- The factories are separately registered (including separate registration under the Factories Act) and have separate registration/code numbers.
- Separate Works Managers and plant superintendents manage each factory; there is no supervisory control of one factory over the other.
- Separate profit and loss accounts were maintained throughout the year; any consolidation occurred only at year-end for statutory purposes (Companies Act and Income Tax Act).
- The workforce at each factory is separate, with no inter-transferability; Roha workers were recruited directly from outside and only 5–6 employees were temporarily sent from Ambarnath to assist in setting up Roha.
- There is no functional inter-dependence or integration; therefore the Roha factory should be treated as a distinct establishment entitled to the infancy exemption under Section 16(1)(b).
Respondents' Arguments
- The management of the two factories was common and there was no separate ownership, capital, profit and loss accounts, implying that both units were one establishment.
- There exists functional integrity between the two factories, making the Roha factory covered by the Act from its inception (9 July 1977).
- The respondents relied on precedent (a Gujarat High Court Division Bench ruling) which, on its facts, had found two units to constitute one integrated unit covered by the Act.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Korula Rubber Company Pvt. Ltd. v. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner (Spl. Civil Appln. No. 198 of 1978 decided 3-8-1981) | Rule/principle supporting the position that, on facts where units are separate in management, products and personnel, they may be treated as distinct establishments for the purpose of infancy/exemption under the Act. | The Court noted that this Division Bench ruling of the same Court supports the petitioner's contentions and fairly and squarely governs the instant case in favour of the Company. |
| Albright Morarji & Pandit Ltd. v. N.G. Desai (Writ Petition No. 1438 of 1980 decided 15-6-1984) | A prior judgment of the same judge which supports the petitioner's contention that separate units can be treated as distinct establishments for infancy/exemption purposes. | The Court treated this judgment as supporting the petitioner's case and as relevant precedent in favour of granting the exemption. |
| Indian Rayon Corporation Ltd. v. Miss K.P. Sarojini (Spl. Civil Appln. No. 4617 of 1983 decided 23-9-1983) (Gujarat High Court Division Bench) | Held, on that case's facts, that the two units constituted one establishment because of integration in ownership, management and control, and transfer/loan of technical and executive staff between units. | The Court distinguished that ruling on its facts, noting that the Gujarat case involved frequent transfers/loans of technical and executive personnel and managerial integration, facts not present in the instant case; therefore the Gujarat ruling did not govern the present decision. |
| Supreme Court dismissal of the Special Leave Petition (against the Division Bench ruling of this Court) | Demonstrated that the Division Bench ruling of this Court (Korula Rubber) had been upheld in effect by the Supreme Court's refusal to grant leave (as stated in the opinion). | The Court treated the Supreme Court's dismissal of the Special Leave Petition as reinforcing that the Division Bench ruling of this Court was binding and therefore the Gujarat High Court ruling could not be relied upon to defeat the petitioner's claim. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the factual matrix and applied the statutory test of whether the Roha and Ambarnath factories formed a single "establishment" (i.e., whether there was "functional integrity") for the purposes of Section 16(1)(b) of the Act.
The Court emphasized the following factual findings, many of which were undisputed:
- The factories manufacture distinct and different products (Ambarnath: heavy inorganic chemicals and mainly fertilizers; Roha: organic chemicals not made at Ambarnath).
- The workers at the two factories are separate and were recruited independently; there is no institutional inter-transferability of workmen from one factory to the other (apart from about 5–6 employees initially sent from Ambarnath to help set up Roha).
- Each factory had separate registration numbers and separate registration under the Factories Act.
- Separate profit and loss accounts were maintained during the year; consolidation of accounts occurred only at year-end for statutory purposes (Companies Act and Income Tax Act).
- Each factory had its own Works Manager and plant superintendent; there was no supervisory, financial or managerial control of one factory over the other.
On these facts, the Court found that the inference of "functional integrity" urged by the respondents was not supportable. The temporary or limited transfer of a small number of employees to assist in set-up was held not to be determinative; in the nature of new industrial set-ups such assistance is common and does not transform two separate units into a single establishment. The Court also held that consolidation of accounts for Companies Act and Income Tax purposes does not, by itself, demonstrate that two separate factories are one establishment under the Act.
The Court considered conflicting precedents. It found the Division Bench ruling of its own Court (Korula Rubber) and the judge's earlier judgment (Albright Morarji & Pandit Ltd. v. N.G. Desai) to support the petitioner's position. The Gujarat High Court ruling in Indian Rayon was distinguished on its facts (which showed significant transfers and managerial integration). The Court also noted that a Special Leave Petition against the Division Bench ruling of this Court had been dismissed by the Supreme Court, making the Division Bench ruling binding for present purposes.
On application of the legal principles to the established facts, the Court concluded that the Roha factory and the Ambarnath factory were distinct and separate establishments. Consequently, the petitioner was entitled to the reduced infancy/exemption period under Section 16(1)(b) of the Act for the Roha factory.
Holding and Implications
HOLDING: The petition is allowed. The orders of the 1st respondent dated 4 March 1980, 12 June 1980 and 2 July 1980 are set aside and quashed, and the respondents are restrained from acting upon them.
Direct Effect on the Parties:
- It is held and directed that, in respect of the Roha factory, the petitioner Company is exempted from the provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 for a period of two years from 9 July 1977.
- Under orders of the Court the petitioner had deposited Rs. 1,27,600 with the 1st respondent (being the provident fund contribution for the first two years for the Roha factory). The 1st respondent is directed to refund that sum to the petitioner as expeditiously as possible and preferably within three months from the date of the judgment.
- On receipt of the refunded amount, the petitioner Company is directed to return to the respective workmen at the Roha factory their respective contributions (if such contributions had earlier been recovered from them) within one month of receipt.
- Rule is made absolute in terms of the above directions. There is no order as to costs.
Implications Regarding Precedent: The Court applied existing authorities and distinguished contrary authority on its facts; the judgment did not purport to establish a new legal principle beyond applying the statutory test to the facts. The decision's effect is therefore the direct relief granted to the petitioner and the procedural directions for refunding contributions; the opinion does not state that any broader binding precedent is being newly established.
Rule made absolute.
1. The petitioners are a public limited company (hereinafter “the Company”) in existence since about the year 1921. It had then established a factory at Ambarnath, District Thane (hereinafter “the Ambarnath factory”). This factory manufactures heavy inorganic chemicals and fertilizers, but predominantly fertilizers. Several years thereafter the Company established on 9th July, 1977 another new factory at Roha, District Kolaba (hereinafter “the Roha factory”) for the manufacture of certain organic chemicals which are not manufactured at the Ambarnath factory.
2. Under Section 16(1)(b) of the Employes' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 (hereinafter “the Act”), the provisions of the Act were not applicable to the Roha factory for a period of three years that is till 9th July, 1980. However, pursuant to a request of the employees of the Roha factory, the petitioners agreed to make a representation to the 1st respondent for reducing this exemption or infancy period from three years to two years.
3. The Company thus agreed to give up the full advantage of three years and instead avail the same for only one year. Application was accordingly made to the 1st respondent. However, by his order of 4th March, 1980 the 1st respondent refused exemption on the ground that the management of the two factories viz., the factory at Ambarnath and the factory at Roha was common and that there was no separate ownership, capital, profit and loss accounts and as such both the units or the establishments were one and, therefore, the Roha factory was covered by the Act from its inception on 9th July, 1977. The petitioners replied stating that the two factories were not interdependent at all; that they were also separately registered under the Factories Act; that the Roha factory was not in the least a branch of Ambarnath factory; that the two factories were managed by two separate Works Managers; that there was no inter-transferability of the workmen of these two factories; that separate code numbers were given to these two factories; that there was no supervisory control over either of these two factories by the other; that accounts were also separately maintained throughout the year with consolidation effected only at the end of the year. There was thus no functional integrity at all. After hearing the petitioners in the matter of their aforesaid representations and submissions, the 1st respondent by his order dated 12th June, 1980 rejected the same. By his subsequent order dated 2nd July 1980, the petitioners were called upon to implement the provisions of the Act. Hence this petition under Article 226 of the Constitution for setting aside the orders dated 4th March, 1980, 12th June, 1980 and 2nd July 1980 disentitling the company from availing itself of any benefit of the normal or even the reduced voluntary infancy period under Section 16(1)(b) of the Act.
4. Hearing Mr. Kapadia, learned Counsel for the Company and Mr. Master, learned Counsel for the respondents, I find this to be a clear case where the Company is entitled to the benefit of the reduced voluntary infancy period under Section 16(1)(b) of the Act. As indicated, the Ambarnath factory was established as long back as in the year 1921 or thereabout while the Roha factory was established as late as in July 1977. The Ambarnath factory manufactures heavy inorganic chemicals and mainly fertilizers while the Roha factory manufactures only organic chemicals. The products manufactured at these two factories are thus separate, distinct and different. The workers of these two factories are also separate. Though at the time when the Roha factory was established or set up, about 5 or 6 employees of the Ambarnath factory were sent to Roha factory to take advantage of their expertise and experience in help set up the Roha factory, this circumstance by itself has hardly any significance in deciding as to whether in law the two factories constitute one or separate establishments. In the very nature of things when a new factory is sought to be set up, the benefit of such expertise and experience is and surely can be availed of. This by no stretch can be construed to conclude that the two factories, therefore, constitute one establishment.
5. Other facts and circumstances also militate against the contention on behalf of the respondents that the two factories are indeed one for the purposes of the Act. Thus, the two factories have separate registration numbers. The same are also separately registered under the Factories Act. The said factories also maintain and draw up separate profit and loss accounts. The said two factories also have separate Works Managers and plant superintendents. And each factory also has a separate and independent set of workman or employees who are not as such transferable from one factory to the other. The workers at the Roha factory were recruited directly from outside sources. One also does not find any supervisory control by either of these factories over the other. The two factories do not have any inter-connection as such in the matter of supervisory, financial or managerial control Inference and conclusion is irresistible that these two factories constitute distinctly different entities and separate establishments.
6. Such being the emerging facts and circumstances, it is not possible to accept the contention of Mr. Master, learned Counsel for the respondents that there is here what is termed as functional integrity between the two factories. Indeed, the facts and circumstances which are mainly undisputed, distinctly point in the other direction. Except the fact that the two factories are owned by one and the same Company, all the other relevant factors lead to the conclusion, fair, just and reasonable, that the two factories are different and separate establishments. The Roha factory is neither a branch of the Ambarnath factory nor its subsidiary nor can it with any justification be termed a feeding factory. There is no bar to a Company establishing more than one factory. Indeed, in this case, taking advantage of the incentives given to factories established in backward areas, the Company several years after the establishment of their original Ambarnath factory, decided to establish another factory independent and distinct in management, in products, in workmen, etc. at Roha, far away from the factory at Ambarnath. The mere fact that the Company ultimately consolidated the accounts of the two factories for the purpose of the Companies Act and the Income Tax Act cannot result in a conclusion that, therefore, the two factories constitute one establishment. It is not unknown that where one and the same Company establishes separate, distinct and different factories at different places in the country with each having its own separate accounts, consolidation is annually effected for the purposes of the Companies Act and the Income Tax Act. In all the circumstances, the Company's claim to the benefit of the infancy period under Section 16(1)(b) of the Act qua the Roha factory is well justified.
7. Mr. Kapadia, learned Counsel for the Company invited this Court's attention to a Division Bench ruling of this Court in Korula Rubber Company Pvt. Ltd. v. The Regional Provident Fund Commissioner . Spl. Civil Appln. No. 198 of 1978 decided on 3-8-1981., as also to my own judgment in Albright Morarji & Pandit Ltd. v. N.G Desai . Writ Petition No. 1438 of 1980 decided on 15-6-1984. Both these rulings support the learned Counsel's contentions and fairly and squarely govern the instant case in favour of the Company herein. However, Mr. Master, learned Counsel for the respondents invited my attention to a Division Bench ruling of the Gujarat High Court in Indian Rayon Corporation Ltd. v. Miss K.P Sarojini . Spl. Civil Appln. No. 4617 of 1983 decided on 23-9-1983., which, in the facts and circumstances of that case, took the view that the two units therein involved, constituted one establishment and, therefore, covered by the Act. It was expressly found in the Gujarat ruling that the Company therein and Jaya Shree Insulators constituted one integrated whole; that the establishment of Jaya Shree Insulators at Halol was a part and parcel of the unit of the Company; that the services of the technical staff of the Company were made available by way of transfers or loan from one or the other unit of the Company to Jaya Shree Insulators at Halol; that the services of as many as ten executives were placed at the disposal or Jaya Shree Insulators at Halol by way of transfer in the year 1981; that Jaya Shree Insulators at Halol was looked after by the managerial and executive personnel who were working at the Hooghly unit of the Company and the technical staff of the Hooghly unit was also transferred/loaned to the Halol unit of Jaya Shree Insulators. It is thus obvious that the facts and circumstances in the Gujarat ruling were different from those in the present case. It is in the said set of facts and circumstances that the Gujarat High Court confirmed the decision of the Provident Fund Commissioner there that the two units therein involved, constituted functional integrity by ownership, management and control resulting in the said two establishments being but one unit. The said ruling is thus clearly distinguishable.
8. That apart, between the two Division Bench rulings viz., one of the Gujarat High Court and the other of this Court, the Division Bench ruling of this Court would bind me. It is also relevant to note that against the Division Bench ruling of this Court, the respondents had preferred Special Leave Petition to the Supreme Court vide statement accordingly made before me by Mr. Master, learned Counsel for the respondents. And what is relevant is that the Supreme Court dismissed the said Special Leave Petition. In all the circumstances reliance sought to be placed by Mr. Master on the Gujarat ruling cannot avail the respondents here in this case.
9. In this view of the matter, this petition succeeds and is allowed. The impugned decisions embodied in the 1st respondent's communications dated 4th March, 1980 (Ex. C), 12th June, 1980 (Ex. G) and 2nd July 1980 (Ex. H) are set aside and quashed. The respondents are restrained from acting thereon. It is held and directed that so far as the Roha factory is concerned, the petitioner Company is exempted from the provisions of the Employees' Provident Fund and Miscellaneous Provisions Act, 1952 for a period of two years from 9th July, 1977.
10. Under orders of this Court the petitioner Company has deposited with the 1st respondent Rs. 1,27,600 being the provident fund contribution for the first two years of the establishment of its Roha factory. As it is now held that the petitioner Company is exempted from the aforesaid Act for the said period of first two years qua Roha factory, the 1st respondent is directed to refund to the petitioner Company the said sum of Rs. 1,27,600 as expeditiously as possible and preferably within three months from today. The petitioner Company is also in turn directed that on receipt of the aforesaid amount from the 1st respondent, the petitioner Company shall, within one month therefore, return to the respective workman at Roha factory, his (workman's) respective contribution, if the same had been earlier recovered from him by the Company.
11. Rule is made absolute in terms aforesaid. In the circumstances of the case, however, there will be no order as to costs.
Rule made absolute.
Alert