Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Bhoja Babu Salian v. The State Of Maharashtra .

Bombay High Court
Apr 7, 1983
Smart Summary (Beta)

Judgment Summary — Kanade, J. (Revision Application)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, Bhoja Babu Salian, stood surety in the sum of Rs. 15,000 for an accused (Mohamed Zamil / Zameer Mohammed Aktar Chaudhary) in Case No. 341.PN/B2 before the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, 9th Court, Bandra, Bombay. The surety bond was executed on June 10, 1982 and required the accused to appear on the date(s) of hearing and continue to attend until otherwise directed by the Court. The accused failed to appear in Court on June 30, 1982. On that date the Magistrate recorded an order (reproduced in the record) which included the entry: “Accused No. 2 absent. Issue non-bailable warrant against accused No. 2 and notice to surety. R/f 6-7-82.”

A notice to the surety dated July 1, 1982 was served on the petitioner requiring him to appear on July 6, 1982 and show cause why Rs. 15,000 should not be enforced against him. The petitioner appeared on July 6, 1982; the Magistrate recorded that the surety's application to produce the accused did not show any reason for the accused’s absence, stated that the bail bond was forfeited, but granted time to produce the accused and adjourned to July 20, 1982. The petitioner and his counsel were absent on July 20, 1982, whereupon the Magistrate directed issuance of a distress warrant for Rs. 15,000 against the surety.

The petitioner appealed to the Court of Sessions for Greater Bombay (Criminal Appeal No. 362 of 1982). The Additional Sessions Judge dismissed the appeal, holding no illegality in the Magistrate’s order. The petitioner then filed the present revision application challenging the issuance of the distress warrant and the procedure followed by the Magistrate.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the issuance of a notice to a surety to show cause (and subsequent proceedings to enforce the bond) is without jurisdiction if there has been no prior order of forfeiture of the bond.
  2. Whether the procedure followed by the Magistrate complied with the statutory requirements (as framed in the opinion, particularly section 445/446 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973) relating to forfeiture of bond and issuance of notice to the surety.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's (Petitioner's) Arguments — as represented by Shri Gyani

  • It was argued that in the absence of an order of forfeiture the issuance of a show cause notice to the surety is without jurisdiction: the notice dated July 1, 1982 preceded any order of forfeiture and therefore was issued improperly.
  • The petitioner contended that the learned Magistrate actually ordered forfeiture only on July 6, 1982 (after the notice), so the procedure was reversed and contrary to the requirements of section 446 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973.
  • Reliance was placed on a number of authorities (decisions of High Courts and the Supreme Court) interpreting the earlier provision (section 514, CrPC 1898) to show a two-step procedure: (1) order forfeiting the bond with grounds recorded, and (2) serve notice to the surety to show cause why the penalty should not be realized.

Other Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent's or prosecution's counter-arguments in the revision proceeding.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Udai Raj v. The State, 1965 (2) Cri. L.J. 706 (Single Judge, Allahabad High Court) It is irregular to pass a single order forfeiting a surety bond and directing its amount to be realised as penalty; under section 514 two steps are essential: (1) order forfeiting the bonds and (2) notice to sureties to show cause why the amount be not realised. The judge acknowledged this authority as supporting the two-step procedure under the earlier CrPC provision, but evaluated the facts to determine whether an order of forfeiture could be deemed to have been made in the present case despite imperfect wording of the Magistrate's orders.
Dhanvir v. State, 1975 Cri. L.J. 1347 (Himachal Pradesh High Court) Under section 514 (CrPC, 1898) two steps are essential: (i) an order passing forfeiture of bond with grounds recorded; and (ii) service of notice to the surety to show cause why the penalty be not realized. The forfeiture order should be upon grounds recorded to the satisfaction of the Court. The judge referred to this case as emphasising the mandatory two-step procedure, and then examined the record to conclude that in the instant matter the Magistrate was in substance satisfied on June 30 and the subsequent notice and proceedings complied with the statutory requirement.
Ghulam Mehdi v. State of Rajasthan, A.I.R. 1960 S.C. 1185 (Supreme Court) Observed that under section 514 (CrPC, 1898) notice must be given before a surety becomes liable to pay the forfeited bond amount; in the absence of such notice proceedings cannot be said to be in accordance with law and may be quashed. The judge acknowledged this Supreme Court observation as relevant to the procedural requirement of notice, but concluded on the facts that a notice had in fact been issued and that the Magistrate's actions overall complied with the statutory scheme now reflected in section 446 of CrPC, 1973.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analysed the question by reference to the bond terms, the Magistrate's orders and the statutory provisions (comparative reference to the old section 514 of CrPC, 1898 and the present provisions in sections 445/446 of CrPC, 1973 as relevant). The judge proceeded step-by-step as follows:

  1. Examined the bond: it obligated the accused to appear on the date(s) of hearing and to continue to attend until otherwise directed; it stipulated forfeiture of Rs. 15,000 in case of default.
  2. Identified the material fact of breach: the accused (No. 2) was not present on June 30, 1982, and the Magistrate recorded an order on that date directing that a warrant be issued against the accused and that a notice be sent to the surety (record entry reproduced in the opinion).
  3. Considered the formal sequence: the record showed a notice to the surety dated July 1, 1982 (served) requiring appearance on July 6, 1982 to show cause why Rs. 15,000 should not be enforced. On July 6 the Magistrate recorded that the bail bond was forfeited and granted further time to produce the accused; on July 20, with the surety absent, the Magistrate directed issuance of a distress warrant.
  4. Addressed the counsel's complaint about procedure: the petitioner argued the notice was issued before an order of forfeiture and thus was jurisdictionally defective. The judge accepted that the Magistrate's orders were not “happily worded” and appeared mechanical, but emphasised substance over form.
  5. Found that the Magistrate was "deemed to have passed an order of forfeiture" on June 30, 1982: the absence of the accused on the date of hearing provided sufficient material for the Magistrate to be satisfied that a condition of the bond had been breached. Given the bond's terms (forfeiture on breach), forfeiture operated by virtue of the bond contents once the Court was satisfied of the breach.
  6. Concluded that issuance of the notice on July 1, 1982 and the Magistrate’s later statements on July 6, 1982 that the bond was forfeited demonstrated compliance with the statutory requirement (the judge refers to section 446 of CrPC, 1973). On this factual and legal assessment the Court found full compliance with the relevant statutory procedure and no error of law.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision application was dismissed and the rule discharged. The Court held that, on the record, there was compliance with the requirements of the relevant provision of the Code of Criminal Procedure (as discussed in the opinion) and no error of law requiring interference.

Implications and Consequences:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The petitioner’s revision was not allowed; the Orders of the Magistrate (including the direction to issue a distress warrant) and the decision of the Sessions Court were upheld. The petitioner is, however, permitted to appear before the Magistrate to show cause as to why a distress warrant should not be issued; the Magistrate is directed to give the petitioner an opportunity to reply and to adduce evidence, if any, in response to the show cause notice.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion resolved the case on the facts by treating the Magistrate’s acts as satisfying the statutory requirements in substance despite imperfect wording of orders. The judgment does not purport to lay down a novel legal principle beyond applying existing statutory requirements and authorities; no new principle of general application is pronounced in the opinion.
Show all summary ...

Kanade, J.:— The short question involved in this revision application is as to whether without an order of forfeiture of a bond executed by a surety the issuance of notice of show cause will be without jurisdiction. The said question arises on the following facts of this case.

2. The petitioner, Bhoja Babu Salian, stood surety in the sum of Rs. 15,000/- for an accused, Mohamed Zamil Mohamed A. Chaudhary, in Case No. 341.PN/B2 in the Court of the Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, 9th Court, Bandra, Bombay. The said surety bond, was executed by the petitioner on June 10, 1982. It was for appearance of the accused in the said case. The accused failed to appear in the Court on June 30, 1982. On that day the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate passed the following order:

“Accused Nos. 1 and 3 produced.

Accused No. 2 absent.

Issue non-bailable warrant against accused No. 2 and notice to surety.

R/f (that is, returnable) 6-7-82.”

(bracketed portion supplied.)

3. In pursuance of the aforesaid order a notice to the surely was sent dated July 1, 1982, which was served on the petitioner. On the next date of hearing, that is, on July 6, 1982, it is stated in the Roznama as follows;

“Accused Nos. 1 and 3 in custody.

Warrant against accused No. 2 returned unexecuted.

The case of accused No. 2 is separated.

A separate charge is framed against accused Nos. 1 and 3 sections 467, 457, 458, 461, 472 and 419 of the Indian Code, Both accused pleaded not guilty.

issue summonses to prosecution witnesses.”

4. The notice issued to the petitioner states as follows:

“Whereas on 10th day of June 1982 you become surety for one Mohamed Zameer Mohammed Aktar Chaudhary (that is, the accused) of Bombay that he should appear before this Court on 30th day of June 1982 (that is, on the date of hearing) and should continue to attend until otherwise directed by the Court and bound yourself in default thereof to forfeit the sum of Rs. 15,000/-.

And whereas the said accused has failed to appear before this Court on 30th day of June 1982 and by reason of the said default you have forfeited the aforesaid sum of Rs. 15,000/-, you are hereby required to appear before this Court on 6th day of July 1982 at 11 A.M (S.T) and show cause, if any, why the payment of Rs. 15,000/- should not be enforced against you.”

5. In pursuance of the said notice the petitioner appeared before the Court on July 6, 1982. On that day the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate heard the advocate for the petitioner end passed the following order:

“Surely with advocate Singh.

Surety was noticed to show cause why the order of forfeiture should not be enforced against him for failure of the accused to attend in the Court on 30/6/82. Surety has filed an application praying for time to produce the accused. The application does not show any reason for the absence of the accused on 30/6/82, As the surety has not shown any cause, the bail bond is forfeited. However, I shall grant time to produce the accused by the next date. Adjd, to 20/7/82.”

6. The next day, that is, July 20, 1982, the surely (that is, the petitioner) and his Counsel were both absent, and the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate directed to issue a distress warrant for Rs. 15,000/- against the surety.

7. Feeling aggrieved by the said order of issuing a distress warrant against him, the petitioner filed an appeal to the Court of Sessions for Greater Bombay, being Criminal Appeal No. 362 of 1982. The learned Additional Sessions Judge, Greater Bombay, dismissed the appeal, holding that there was no illegality in the order passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. It is against this order the present revision application has been filed.

8. Shrl Gyani, learned Counsel appearing in support of this petition, submitted that in the absence of an order of forfeiture the issuance of a show cause notice against the petitioner is without Jurisdiction. It is argued that in the first instance there was no order of forfeiture at all, but a show cause notice is issued on July 1, 1982 and thereafter an order of forfeiture has been passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate on July 6, 1982. According to Shri Gyani, the procedure followed fay the learned Additional Sessions Judge is contrary to the provisions of section 446 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. In support of his contention a number of authorities have been relied upon by learned Counsel. The first of them is 1(Udai Raj v. The State), 1965 (2) Cri. L.J 706. This case is decided by a Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court, it is observed that:

“It is irregular to pass a single order, forfeiting a surety bond, and directing its amount to be realised as penalty. According to section 514 two steps are essential; (1) an order has to be passed forfeiting the bonds and (2) notice has to be served on the sureties to show cause why the amount of the bond be not realised from them by way of penalty.”

9. The contention raised in the said case was that the order of the learned Sessions Judge was unsustainable in law inasmuch as he had given opportunity to the applicants to show cause against the forfeiture of their bonds, but did not provide them an opportunity to show cause as to why the amount be not realised from them by way of penalty. It is on this contention the learned Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court held that under section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1898, twofold requirement was necessary.

10. The second case, very strongly relied upon by Shri Gyani, is of the Himachal Pradesh High Court, namely, 2(Dhanvir v. State), 1975 Cri. L.J 1347. In the said case it is observed that:

“A perusal of section 514 will make it abundantly clear that the Court has to be satisfied in the first instance that a bond for appearance was taken and that the said bond has been forfeited for which it shall record the grounds. The order as to forfeiture of bond, which is upon grounds to be recorded to the satisfaction of the Court, is almost automatic no sooner the condition of the bond is disregarded and the persons fails to appear before the Court. It is only after such an order of forfeiture is made by the Court that a notice to show cause is to be issued to the surety either to pay the penalty or to show a sufficient cause why the penalty be not paid. Thereafter the Court has to consider the grounds made by the surety in support of his case and after considering the case on merits, if the Court is dissatisfied with the reasons shown, an order is to be made for the realization of the penalty. In the instant case this procedure has not been followed by the learned Magistrate.”

11. It is further observed in the said case that under section 514 two steps are essential; (i) an order has to be passed forfeiting the bond, and (ii) notice has to be served on the surety to show cause why the amount be not realised from him by way of penalty.

12. In fairness to this Court Shri Gyani also pointed out the decision of the Supreme Court in 3(Ghulam Mehdi v. State Of Rajasthan), A.I.R 1960 S.C 1185. That, case is not relevant for decision of the instant case. It is observed in the case that section 514 of the Code of Criminal Procedure 1898, shows that before surety becomes liable to pay the amount of the bond forfeited, it is necessary to give notice why the amount should not be paid, and in the absence of such notice the proceeding cannot be said to be in accordance with law and should, therefore, be quashed.

13. There is a little change in section 445 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, but the important provision remains the same. The question involved is as to whether it is necessary to pass an order of forfeiture in a case where the surety has executed a bond to produce the accused person on each of the charge of hearing. The bond, which is at page 36 of the record of the original case, states that the accused has bound himself to see that the accused appears in the Court of the teamed Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate on June 15, 1982 next, to answer to the said charge and to continue so to attend until otherwise directed by the Court; and in case of making default herein, the accused bound himself to forfeit to Government the sum of Rs. 15,000/-. Now in the bond itself the forfeiture is mentioned if branch of the condition of the bond is made. Admittedly the accused was absent on June 30, 1982. On that day the Court has passed an order which has been reproduced hereinabove. The learned Additional Chief Metropolian Magistrate ought to have mentioned that the bond was forfeited and then ought to have issued a notice to the petitioner-surety. What has been done by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate is that a bailable warrant is issued against the accused and a notice to the petitioner-surety. A notice to the surety cannot be issued unless the order of forfeiture is passed. Impliedly, the order of forfeiture is there. Without passing an order of forfeiture there was no cause to issue a notice to the surety. Shri Gyani, in fairness to this Court, pointed out that the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate meant that the bond was forfeited, and issued notice to the surety. In fact, such an order of forfeiture has not been passed. It is then the question arises whether the order of issuing a notice to the surety is as a result of a forfeiture of the bond and whether that notice was a notice in compliance with the provisions of section 446 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973. In fact, such a notice was issued on July 1, 1982, which clearly indicates that the order of forfeiture has been passed and a notice was issued to show cause why the amount of Rs. 15,000/- should not be recovered by way of a distress warrant. On further date, that is, on July 6, 1982, the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate had stated that the bond was forfeited and the distress warrant was to be issued. Shri Gyani contended that actually the forfeiture of a bond is ordered by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate on July 6, 1982 and thereafter there was no show cause notice issued to the petitioner and, therefore, the procedure followed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate is erroneous in law. The orders passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate are not happily worded. It appears that he has passed some mechanical orders. No order as regards forfeiture is passed by him. However, a notice is issued, and the petitioner having appeared before him further time is given to him to produce the accused in the Court, and ultimately a distress warrant is ordered to be issued. Notwithstanding the exact order that has been passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, it has to be seen as to whether the requirements of law namely, the provisions of section 445, have been complied with or not.

14. From the record I am satisfied that the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate is deemed to have passed an order of forfeiture on June 30, 1982. The question is as to whether he was satisfied that there is breach of a condition of the bond on that day and whether there was sufficient material before him to be satisfied that there was breach of a condition of the bond. The bond is admittedly for appearance of the accused at the date of hearing. Admittedly the accused No. 2 was not present in the Court on the date of hearing, and, therefore, the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate issued a bailable warrant against the accused No. 2. The said fact was sufficient to satisfy the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate in holding that there was breach of a condition of the bond. If the Court was satisfied on the proof, then the forfeiture is automatic by virtue of the contents of the bond itself, and it is necessary to issue a notice to the surety to show cause as to why the amount contained in the bond should not be recovered from him. That order is also passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate on July 6, 1982, in my view, there is full compliance of the provisions of section 446 of the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, and there is no error of law in the order passed by the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate. It is, therefore, no interference is called for in the revision application.

15. In the result, the criminal revision application foils and the same is dismissed and the rule is discharged. Since the petitioner has not appeared before the Court of the learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate, 9th Court, Sandra, Bombay, to show cause in pursuance of the notice issued to him, he shall be at liberty to appear before the said Court and show cause as to why a distress warrant should not be issued against him. The learned Additional Chief Metropolitan Magistrate shall give an opportunity to the petitioner to reply and adduce evidence, if any, in response to the show cause notice served on the petitioner by the Court.