Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City-Ii v. Indokem Private Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Mar 27, 1981
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Sawant, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The reference arises under section 256(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1961. The assessee is a private limited company engaged in the business of dyes and chemicals. For the accounting year ending 31 March 1964 (relevant to assessment year 1964-65), the company paid its employees salaries, dearness allowance, and also bonus and commission to some employees. There was no written agreement for payment of bonus or commission, and the commission percentages varied by year and employee.

During assessment proceedings the Income-tax Officer (ITO) required details of emoluments paid to employees earning in excess of Rs. 7,500 per annum and took the view that section 40(c)(iii) of the Act applied to the bonus and commission payments. The ITO proposed to disallow the portion in excess of the statutory threshold and calculated a total of Rs. 18,914, applying a pro rata one-twelfth because the relevant provision became operative from February 1964; the ITO's adjustment in the year therefore amounted to Rs. 4,970 (as worked out by him).

The assessee appealed to the Appellate Assistant Commissioner (AAC), who, relying on an amendment to sub-clause (iii) of clause (c) of section 40 and construing the deletion of the word "remuneration" as excluding cash emoluments, restricted disallowance to Rs. 781 (benefits such as use of car and reimbursement of medical expenses) and deleted the remainder (Rs. 18,133). The Department appealed to the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (Tribunal), which affirmed the AAC's decision. The Department sought and obtained a reference to this High Court; the Tribunal framed the legal question of whether Rs. 18,133 was not deductible in computing income under "Profits and gains of the business" on proper interpretation of section 40(c)(iii).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the bonus and commission paid by the assessee to its employees during the accounting year ending 31 March 1964 are covered by the expression "benefit or amenity or perquisite" used in section 40(c)(iii) of the Income‑tax Act, 1961, and therefore can be disallowed as revenue expenses under that provision.
  2. Whether, on the facts and circumstances of the case and on a proper interpretation of section 40(c)(iii), the sum of Rs. 18,133 was not deductible in computing income under the head "Profits and gains of the business".

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue / ITO's Position

  • The ITO treated the bonus and commission payments as falling within section 40(c)(iii) and proposed a disallowance of the portion exceeding the statutory threshold (computed by him as aggregating Rs. 18,914, with a pro rata figure of Rs. 4,970 applicable to the relevant period).
  • Before the Tribunal and on appeal, the department argued that the expression "benefit or amenity or perquisite" in section 40(c)(iii) would include payments by way of bonus and commission.

Assessee's Position

  • The assessee contended that the payments of bonus and commission were cash payments and therefore were not covered by the phrase "benefit or amenity or perquisite".
  • Accordingly, the assessee argued these payments should be deductible as business revenue expenses and not susceptible to disallowance under section 40(c)(iii).

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CIT v. Kanan Devan Hills Produce Company Ltd., [1979] 119 ITR 431 (Calcutta High Court) Held that certain allowances (overseas allowance, managing allowance, devaluation allowance, transport allowance) did not fall within "benefit", "amenity" or "perquisite" and thus were deductible. Used as supporting authority to show other High Courts have construed "benefit/amenity/perquisite" as not encompassing cash emoluments; the court relied on its reasoning to support the present conclusion.
CIT v. Manjushree Plantations Ltd., [1980] 125 ITR 150 (Madras High Court) Held that a cash leave allowance was salary rather than a perquisite, since perquisite implied something other than a cash payment arising from the contract of service. Relied upon by this court as corroborative authority: the Madras High Court followed the Calcutta High Court and treated cash payments as not constituting perquisites under the relevant provisions.
This Court's prior decisions (not specifically named in the opinion) Consistent earlier view of this court that "benefit/amenity/perquisite" as used in sub-clause (iii) did not include cash payments made directly to employees. Cited by the court to show consistency of the interpretation adopted by the bench in prior cases; the present conclusion accords with that line of authority.
Decision of the Supreme Court in a batch of petitions arising from decisions of this court (unnamed in the opinion) Indicated that the Supreme Court has upheld the view adopted by this court regarding the interpretation of the expression "benefit/amenity/perquisite". Noted by the court as further confirmation that the higher court has accepted the interpretation that cash emoluments are not covered by sub-clause (iii); this supported the court's conclusion in the present reference.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's analysis focused on statutory interpretation of the phrase "any benefit or amenity or perquisite" in sub-clause (iii) of clause (c) of section 40 and on the legislative history of that provision.

  1. Historical background: The Court examined the original insertion of cl. (c)(iii) by the Finance Act, 1963 (effective 1 April 1963) and then the substitution effected by the Finance Act, 1964 (effective 1 April 1964). The relevant assessment year for the present matter was 1964-65, so the 1964 amended language governs.
  2. Textual change and its significance: The 1964 amendment removed the word "remuneration" from the clause and replaced the provision's measure by reference to "any benefit or amenity or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not," and measured disallowance by one-fifth of salary beyond a threshold. The Court regarded the deletion of "remuneration" as deliberate and meaningful: had the Legislature intended to include cash emoluments it would not have deleted "remuneration".
  3. Interpretation of "whether convertible into money or not": The inclusion of the phrase "whether convertible into money or not" was taken by the Court to indicate Parliament was concerned with non‑cash benefits (those which may or may not be convertible), and that reference would be unnecessary if cash payments were intended to be captured.
  4. Comparative drafting in other sub-clauses: The Court noted that sub-clause (i) retained the word "remuneration" alongside "benefit" and "amenity" even after the 1964 amendment, demonstrating legislative awareness of distinctions among the terms and a deliberate choice to omit "remuneration" from sub-clause (iii).
  5. Consistency with judicial authority: The Court observed that its own prior decisions had consistently taken the view that sub-clause (iii) did not include cash payments made directly to employees, and that the Supreme Court had appeared to uphold that view. The Court also cited two High Court decisions (Calcutta and Madras) that reached similar conclusions on analogous facts.
  6. Application to facts: On this interpretive basis the Court accepted the Tribunal's finding (and the AAC's reasoning) that the payments of bonus and commission, being cash emoluments paid directly to employees in the absence of written agreements treating them as non‑cash perquisites, did not fall within the phrase "any benefit or amenity or perquisite" in section 40(c)(iii).

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Court answered the referred question by holding that the amount (the sums paid by way of bonus and commission amounting to Rs. 18,133) would be deductible because it is not covered by the provisions of section 40(c)(iii) of the Income‑tax Act.

Direct implications and immediate consequences:

  • The disallowance imposed by the ITO in respect of those cash payments was not sustained; the sums are deductible in computing business profits for the assessment year at issue.
  • The assessee was directed to obtain costs from the revenue (i.e., the assessee to get costs from the revenue).

Broader implications: The opinion grounds its conclusion in textual and legislative-history reasons and notes consistency with prior decisions of this court, the Supreme Court (as indicated in the opinion), and at least two other High Courts. The opinion does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond the interpretation applied to the facts of this reference.

Show all summary ...

Sawant, J.:— This is a reference under s. 256(1) of the I.T Act, 1961 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”).

2. The short question that falls for our consideration in this reference is whether the bonus and commission paid by the assessee to its employees during the accounting year ending on March 31, 1964, is covered by the expression “benefit or amenity or perquisite” used in s. 40(c)(iii) of the Act, and, therefore, can be disallowed as a revenue expense under the Act. The assessee is a private limited company carrying on business in dyes and chemicals. It paid to its employees salaries, dearness allowance and bonus. Some of the employees were also paid commission and bonus. There was no written agreement for the payment of the bonus or commission, and the percentage of commission paid to the employees varied from year to year and from employee to employee. In the course of the assessment proceedings for the assessment year 1964-65, the relevant previous year being the year ending on March 31, 1964, the ITO called for the details of the salary, dearness allowance, bonus and commission paid to the employees who had been paid in all more than Rs. 7,500 per annum. The ITO took the view that the provisions of s. 40(c)(iii) were applicable to the said payments, and proposed to disallow a portion in excess of one-fifth of the total emoluments. The assessee-company contended that the provisions of the section were not applicable to the said payments, since the same were in cash and were not covered by the expression “benefit or amenity or perquisite”. The ITO rejected the said submission and calculated the excess in the case of the 22 employees to whom the payments were made. The total amount worked out by the ITO was Rs. 18,914. He, however, took one-twelth of the said amount, viz., Rs. 4,970(?), the relevant provision being operative from February, 1964, and the assessee's accounting year being the year ending on March 31, 1964.

3. The assessee appealed to the AAC. In the appeal, the AAC took the view that the language of the said provision as applicable to the relevant assessment year 1963-64 had undergone a change, since by an amendment the word “remuneration” was dropped therefrom. This indicated, according to him, the intention of the Legislature to exclude cash emoluments from the expression “benefit or amenity or perquisite In this view of the matter, the AAC restricted the disallowance to Rs. 781, being the benefit which was given by way of the use of the company's car and the reimbursement of the medical expenses, and deleted the balance of Rs. 18,133.

4. Against the order of the AAC the department went in appeal before the Tribunal and urged before it that the expression “benefit or amenity or perquisite” used in the said s. 40(c)(iii) would include payment by way of bonus and commission. The Tribunal, accepting the reasoning of the AAC, affirmed the finding and dismissed the appeal. Thereafter, the department applied to the Tribunal for making a reference to this court, and by its order dated the 28th November 1970, the Tribunal referred the following question of law:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case and on a proper interpretation of section 40(c)(iii) of the Income-tax Act, 1961, the sum of Rs. 18,133 was not deductible in computing the income under the head ‘Profits and gains of the business’?”

5. That is how the present reference has come up before us for final hearing. Since the answer to the question depends upon the interpretation of the phrase “any benefit or amenity or perquisite” occurring in the said sub-cl. (iii) of cl. (c) of s. 40 of the Act, it will be helpful for a correct conclusion on the point to know the history of the said clause. When the Finance Act, 1963, for the first time added the said cl. (c)(iii) to s. 40 which came into effect from 1st April, 1963, it ran as follows;

“(iii) any expenditure which results directly or indirectly in the provision of any remuneration or benefit or amenity to an employee who is a citizen of India, to the extent such expenditure exceeds the amount calculated at the rate of five thousand rupees per month for any period of his employment after the 28th day of February, 1963:

Provided that in computing the aforesaid expenditure, any payments by way of gratuity or any sums comprised in the transferred balance of an employee participating in a recognised provident fund referred to in clause (vii) of sub-section (1) of section 17, or the amount of any compensation referred to in clause (i) or any payment referred to in clause (ii) of sub-section (3) of that section shall not be taken into account.”

6. The said sub-clause was substituted by the following sub-clause by the Finance Act, 1964, with effect from 1st April, 1964:

“(iii) any expenditure incurred after the 29th day of February, 1964, which results directly or indirectly in the provision of any benefit or amenity or perquisite, whether convertible into money or not, to an employee (including any sum paid by the company in respect of any obligation which but for such payment would have been payable by such employee), to the extent such expenditure exceeds one-fifth of the amount of salary payable to the employee for any period of his employment after the aforesaid date:

Provided that in computing the aforesaid expenditure any payment by way of gratuity or the value of any travel concession or assistance referred to in clause (5) of section 10 or passage moneys or the value of any free or concessional passage referred to in sub-clause (i) or any payment of tax referred to in sub-clause (vii) of clause (6) of that section or any sum referred to in clause (vii) of sub-section (1) of section 17 or in clause (v) of sub-section (2) of that section or the amount of any compensation referred to in clause (i) or any payment referred to in clause (ii) of sub-section (3) of that section or any payment referred to in clause (iv) or clause (v) or any expenditure referred to in clause (ix) of sub-section (1) of section 36 shall not be taken into account:

Provided further that nothing in this sub-clause shall apply to any expenditure which results directly or indirectly in the provision of any benefit or amenity or perquisite to an employee whose income chargeable under the head ‘Salaries’ is seven thousand five hundred rupees or less.”

7. What is relevant for our purpose is the language of the clause as it stood amended from 1st April, 1964, since we are concerned in the present case with the assessment year 1964-65, the relevant previous year of the assessee being the year ending on March 31, 1964. It is thus apparent that by the amendment of the Finance Act, 1964, the word “remuneration” was dropped from the relevant phrase, giving an indication that the Legislature did not intend to include cash emoluments in any of the words “benefit “or “amenity” or “perquisite”. This is also clear from the the fact that by the said amendment the Legislature also added the words “whether convertible into money or not If the Legislature had intended to include in any of the said words “benefit”, “amenity” and “perquisite” cash to the employees, the question of the cash being convertible into money or not would not arise. That was yet another pointer that the Legislature had no intention to include cash or money paid directly to the employees, in the said sub-clause. Yet another indication of the said intention of the Legislature was the fact that in sub-cl. (i) of the said cl. (c) of s. 40, the word “remuneration” was retained along with the other words “benefit” and “amenity” even after the aforesaid amendment of sub-cl. (iii). This also further showed that the Legislature was conscious of the distinction between the relevant words, and keeping in mind the said distinction the Legislature had deliberately chosen to delete the expression “remuneration” from sub-cl. (iii). All these factors show that the expression “any benefit or amenity or perquisite whether convertible into money or not” used in the said sub-cl. (iii) was not intended to include cash or money paid directly to the employee. This court has taken this view of the said provisions consistently so far, and it also appears that the Supreme Court has upheld the said view.

8. We may also point out that at least two other High Courts have taken a similar view of the said provisions. The Calcutta High Court in a decision in CIT v. Kanan Devan Hills Produce Company Ltd., [1979] 119 ITR 431, for similar reasons, has held that the amounts paid as overseas allowance, managing allowance, devaluation allowance and transport allowance to the employees did not fall within the expressions “benefit”, “amenity” or “perquisite” used in the said provisions, and, therefore, were deductible in computing the business profits of the assessee-company. Similarly, the Madras High Court in CIT v. Manjushree Plantations Ltd., [1980] 125 ITR 150, relying upon the aforesaid decision of the Calcutta High Court as well as the decision of the Supreme. Court in a batch of petitions arising from the decisions of this court, has taken the same view. Before the Madras High Court the question was whether the cash payment made as leave allowance was salary or benefit or amenity or perquisite and whether their disallowance by the ITO was proper. The High Court took the view that in order to term a payment as a perquisite it had to be a payment other than a cash payment in pursuance of a contract of service. As the payment in that case was cash payment, the same did not constitute perquisite and hence could not be disallowed under s. 40(c)(iii) or s. 40(a)(v) of the Act. We are, therefore, of the view that the finding recorded by the Tribunal that the amount paid by way of bonus and commission to the employees was not covered by the provisions of sub-cl. (iii) of cl. (c) of s. 40 of the Act and, therefore, the same could not have been disallowed as a revenue expenditure by the ITO is correct and proper. In the circumstances, we answer the question as follows:

That the said amount would be deductible since it is not covered by the provisions of s. 40(c)(iii) of the Act.

9. The assessee to get the costs from the revenue.