- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A.K Velu v. K.S Ramkrishnan And Another
Summary of Legal Opinion — Desai, J.
Factual and Procedural Background
This matter arises from Criminal Application No. 165.S of 1979 filed by an accused in the Court of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 31st Court, Vikhroti. The complainant in the Magistrate's Court is K.S. Ramkrishnan (the first respondent before the High Court). The complaint was instituted under section 12 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction, Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 1963, and concerns a building called "Shanker Kunj" situate at Plot No. 19-B, Asalpe, Bombay 400084.
The complainant claimed to be joint owner, builder and promoter of the property and relied on an agreement dated 9 March 1978 executed between the complainant and his wife on the one hand and two accused on the other. The complaint alleged breach of clause 17 read with clauses 21 and 44 of that agreement — specifically (a) failure to pay monthly outgoings at Rs. 122 per month and (b) failure to cooperate in formation of the common organisation.
The accused (the petitioner in the High Court revision) challenged the complaint on the ground that the agreement relied upon was not registered as required under the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act and, by virtue of section 4 of that Act, the Indian Registration Act. The High Court considered a Division Bench decision of this Court (Letters Patent Appeal No. 44 of 1976 — The Association of Commerce House Block Owners Limited v. Vishindas Samaldas) decided on 8th/9th December, 1980.
Paragraph 13 of the revision petition expressly stated that the agreement was not registered; the petitioner verified that paragraph. The first respondent was served but did not appear. The High Court proceeded on the footing that the agreement was not registered and delivered the judgment summarized below.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether an agreement of sale governed by the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act must be registered under the Indian Registration Act (by reason of section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act).
- What is the legal effect of non-registration of such an agreement — whether an unregistered agreement is invalid, ineffective, and incapable of founding rights or liabilities relied upon in the complaint under section 12 of the Act.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments
- The owner/builder/promoter (first respondent) failed to register the agreement of 9 March 1978 with the accused, contrary to the mandatory requirement under section 4 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act.
- Section 4 imports the requirement of registration under the Indian Registration Act, and a failure to register renders the agreement invalid and ineffective, so that no rights can be founded on it.
First Respondent's Position
The first respondent, though duly served, did not appear and therefore did not advance any arguments in the High Court proceedings.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| The Association of Commerce House Block Owners Limited v. Vishindas Samaldas (Letters Patent Appeal No. 44 of 1976), decided 8th/9th December, 1980 | Holds that agreements of the type under the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act are compulsorily registrable and that an unregistered agreement must be treated as invalid and ineffective and cannot be the foundation of any rights. | The High Court relied on paragraphs 40 to 52 of this Division Bench decision to conclude that the unregistered agreement in the present case is invalid and cannot form the basis of the complaint or any liability against the petitioner. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court first observed that, prima facie, the case in the Magistrate's Court fell within section 12 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act. The petitioner's advocate submitted that the impugned agreement was not registered and that section 4 of the Act requires such agreements to be registered under the Indian Registration Act.
The court considered the Division Bench decision in The Association of Commerce House Block Owners Limited v. Vishindas Samaldas and examined paragraphs 40 to 52 of that decision, which supported the petitioner's submission: such agreements are compulsorily registrable and an unregistered agreement must be treated as invalid and ineffective.
The court noted that paragraph 13 of the revision petition specifically admitted non-registration of the agreement and that the petitioner had verified that paragraph. Because the first respondent did not appear despite being served, the court proceeded on the basis that the agreement was not registered.
Applying the principle from the Division Bench decision — that a compulsorily registrable agreement which is not registered is invalid and cannot found rights — the court concluded that the unregistered agreement could not constitute the foundation of any liability against the petitioner or accused No. 2, nor could it support the complaint under section 12.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The High Court granted the relief sought by the petitioner and made the Rule absolute in terms of prayer (a).
Implications:
- The direct effect of the decision is that the specific agreement dated 9 March 1978, being unregistered, is to be treated as invalid and ineffective for the purposes of the complaint; it cannot form the basis of rights or liabilities against the petitioner or accused No. 2 in the criminal complaint under section 12 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act.
- The opinion applied an existing Division Bench precedent; it does not purport to set a new precedent beyond applying that authority to the present facts.
Desai, J.:— This is a Criminal Application No. 165.S of 1979 filed by the accused in the Court of the learned Metropolitan Magistrate, 31st Court, Vikhroti. The complainant in the said case is K.S Ramkrishnan, the 1st respondent before me. The complaint is under section 12 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats Act, 1963. The said complaint refers to a building known as Shanker Kunj situate at Plot No. 19-B, Asalpe, Bombay 400084. The complainant claims to be joint owner, builder and promoter of the said property. The complaint refers to an agreement dated 9th March, 1978 executed between the complainant and his wife on the one hand and the two accused on the other and proceeds that accused has committed a breach of clause 17 read with clauses 21 and 44 of the said agreement. The breach is in failure to pay monthly outgoings at the rate of Rs. 122/- per month. The other alleged failure is to co-operate with the builder in the formation of the common organisation.
2. Prima facie, the case is covered by section 12 of the Maharashtra Ownership Flats (Regulation of the Promotion of Construction. Sale, Management and Transfer) Act, 1963 (Act XLV of 1963). The advocate for the petitioner has however, submitted that there has been a failure on the part of the owner, builder and promoter (respondent No. 1) to register the agreement for sale with the two accused persons.
3. According to his further submission section 4 of the said Act requires that such agreements shall be registered under the Indian Registration Act. It is submitted further that if there is any failure to comply with this mandatory requirement, no rights can be founded on such an agreement and the agreement must be treated as invalid and ineffective.
4. During the course of argument it was submitted that the position has now been crystalised as far as this High Court is concerned by the decision of a Division Bench of this Court (Chandurkar and Bhonsale, JJ.) in Letters Patent Appeal No. 44 of 1976, 1(The Association of Commerce House Block Owners Limited v. Vishindas Samaldas), decided on 8th/9th December, 1980.
5. I have gone through paragraphs 40 to 52 of the aforesaid decision and it bears out the submission of the learned advocate.
6. In paragraph 13 of the revision petition the fact that the agreement between the petitioner and respondent No. 1 is not registered is clearly adverted to. The petitioner has duly verified the contents of paragraph 13. The first respondent though duly served has chosen to remain absent. I must accordingly proceed upon the footing that the agreement is not registered. According to the decision of the Division Bench it was compulsorily registrable and if it is not registered it must be treated as invalid, ineffective and cannot be the foundation of any rights. Equally so it can not constitute the foundation of any liability on either the revision petitioner or accused No. 2 in the said case.
7. In the result the petitioner is entitled to the order sought for. Rule accordingly made absolute in terms of prayer (a).
Alert