Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Roha Ashtami Co-Op. Urban Bank Ltd. v. The Judge, Co-Op. Court, Alibag

Bombay High Court
Jul 11, 1977
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner bank is a co-operative society with a Managing Committee, of which respondent No. 3, Dattatraya Desai, was an elected member. Respondent No. 3 obtained a loan from the bank but failed to repay it within the prescribed period of one year, and also did not repay within the extended period of three months allowed under the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961. Although the loan was fully paid on January 21, 1976, the Managing Committee met on January 23, 1976 and declared that respondent No. 3 ceased to be a member due to this default, based on sub-rule (2) of Rule 58 of the 1961 Rules. Respondent No. 3 challenged this resolution under section 91 before the Co-operative Court, which ruled in his favor since payment was made before the resolution. The petitioner bank appealed to the Co-operative Appellate Court, where the Judge declined to decide the point, noting the committee's term was ending soon. The petitioner then filed the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a sitting member of the Managing Committee of a co-operative society incurs disqualification under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 58 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961, by failing to repay a loan within the prescribed period and extended grace period.
  2. Whether the disqualification arises automatically upon expiry of the repayment period, or only upon a formal resolution of the Managing Committee.
  3. The legal effect of the Managing Committee’s resolution declaring cessation of membership after the default period but following payment shortly before the meeting.

Arguments of the Parties

Respondent No. 3's Arguments

  • The disqualification does not become operative unless the Managing Committee passes a resolution declaring the member disqualified.
  • Since payment was made before the Managing Committee’s meeting and resolution, respondent No. 3 had effectively cured the default and did not cease to be a member.

Petitioner Bank's Arguments

  • Disqualification under clause (a) of sub-rule (1) of Rule 58 operates automatically upon expiry of the repayment period including the extended grace period.
  • The Managing Committee’s resolution is only to acknowledge the vacancy and initiate the procedure for filling it, not to create or delay the disqualification.
  • Respondent No. 3 ceased to be a member as of December 24, 1975, when the extended repayment period expired without payment.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the relevant provisions of Rule 58 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961. Sub-rule (1) sets out eligibility criteria for election to the Managing Committee, including absence of default in loan repayment. Sub-rule (2) provides that a member shall cease to hold office if any disqualification under sub-rule (1) is incurred after election.

The Court emphasized that disqualification arises automatically when the conditions in sub-rule (1) are met, without requirement of any formal resolution. The Managing Committee’s resolution under bye-law 35(9) is procedural, aimed at recording the vacancy and initiating the process for filling it under bye-law 29, but does not affect the automatic operation of the disqualification.

Since respondent No. 3 failed to repay the loan within the one-year period plus the three-month extension, he incurred disqualification as of December 24, 1975. Payment made after this date but before the Managing Committee meeting could not cure the disqualification retroactively. Therefore, the resolution declaring cessation of membership was valid and the orders of the Co-operative Court and Appellate Court were quashed.

Holding and Implications

The Court’s final decision was to allow the petition and quash the orders of the Co-operative Court and the Appellate Court. It held that respondent No. 3 incurred disqualification and ceased to be a member of the Managing Committee as of December 24, 1975, upon expiry of the repayment period including the grace period.

The implication is that disqualification under Rule 58 occurs automatically upon the expiry of the prescribed repayment period and is not contingent upon any formal resolution by the Managing Committee. The Managing Committee’s resolution serves only to recognize and act upon the vacancy thus created. No new precedent was set beyond the direct effect of confirming the automatic operation of the disqualification provision in this factual context.

Show all summary ...

Deshmukh, J.:— The petition was posted to-day for hearing the interim rule regarding ex parte injunction but by the consent of the parties, the whole petition is heard and is finally disposed of. It pertains to only one question regarding incurring disability by sitting member of the Managing Committee of a Co-operative Society. For understanding that question a few facts that should be noted are these:

The petitioner bank is a co-operative society. It has a Managing Committee of which respondent No. 3 Dattatraya Desai was an elected member. He obtained a loan from the Bank, which he could. He did not repay the loan within one year, nor within a further period of three months. The last date for payment in this manner with the extended period of three months expired on or about December 24, 1975. He, however, made full payment of the debt on or about January 21, 1976. However, a meeting of the Managing Committee was already called on January 23, 1976 where one of the items on the agenda was to consider the default of respondent No. 3. It appears that respondent No. 3 was not present in that meeting, though he was a member of the Managing Committee. The Managing Committee took notice of the fact that respondent No. 3 had not repaid the amount within one year, which was the normal period for repayment of the general debt extending upto Rs. 1,000 as provided by bye-law 39 of the society. However, the Managing Committee further noted that not only within that period the loan was not repaid but it was also not paid within the extended period of three months as contemplated by cl. (a) of sub-r. (1) of R. 58 of the Maharashtra Co-operative Societies Rules, 1961. They seem to have ignored the fact that payment was actually made on January 21, 1976 just two days before the meeting of the Managing Committee.

2. On these facts the Managing Committee declared that respondent No. 3 ceased to be a member as provided by sub-r. (2) of R. 58 of the 1961 Rules. Being aggrieved by this resolution, respondent No. 3 raised a dispute under s. 91 before the Co-operative Court.

3. The learned officer presiding over that Court held that since the payment was made before the resolution was passed by the Managing Committee, the disqualification was cured and respondent No. 3 had not ceased to be a member of the Managing Committee. An appeal was carried against the decision by the petitioner bank to the Co-operative Appellate Court. The learned Judge of that Court has not positively decided the point in dispute but merely observed that three years period of the Managing Committee of the present society comes to an end by June 30, 1977 and no useful purpose would be served by giving a decision for or against respondent No. 3. Against such an order, present writ petition has been filed.

4. In our view the point is very clear. Under R. 58 of the said Rules of 1961 disqualifications for membership of a committee of the society are provided for. Sub-rule (1) deals with eligibility for being elected as a member of the committee. Sub-rule (2) points out that a member of the committee of a society shall cease to hold office if he incurs any of the disqualifications mentioned in sub-r. (1). In other words sub-r. (1) operates at the threshold of the entry of the member into the Managing Committee of the society and sub-r. (2) refers to the same disqualifications as in sub-r. (1) but they have to be incurred after one becomes a member of the Managing Committee. The provisions of sub-r. (2) are prima facie self-operative and they do not require that some authority, officer or the committee of the society itself has to decide the fact of having incurred a disqualification.

5. In the present case, reference is being made to cl. (a) of sub-r. (1) of R. 58. That clause says that a person is not eligible to be elected as a member if he is in default to any society in respect of any dues from him, either as a borrower or as a surety for such period as is specified in this behalf in the bye laws of the concerned society, or for a period exceeding three months, which ever is less. Disqualification for being elected also constitutes a disqualification for a sitting member, if he commits a default and answers the description of that clause.

6. In the present case, admittedly the general loan of Rs. 1,000 taken by respondent No. 3 was repayable within one year from the date of borrowing as is provided by bye-law 39. Admittedly, he has not paid that loan. As required by sub-cl. (a) of sub-r. (1) of R. 58 the society has not provided any specific period and as such that clause will become operative. In other words in order not to incur a disqualification respondent No. 3 had to pay the loan within a total period of fifteen months from the date of borrowing, which cover the two different periods of twelve months under bye-law 39 extended upto three months under cl. (a) of sub-r. (1) of R. 58 of the Rules of 1961. Even that is not done by respondent No. 3. He has undoubtedly paid after this entire period was over but a few days before the Managing Committee met to take cognizance of this incurring disqualification and to take further steps for filling in the vacancy as is required to be done under bye-law 35(9) read with bye-law 29.

7. Shri Badkar for respondent No. 3 wants to say that unless a resolution is passed by the Managing Committee the disqualification does not become operative and the person does not cease to be a member of the Managing Committee.

8. We see no warrant for such an interpretation. It may be that the Managing Committee has to make a resolution under bye-law 35(9) but that resolution is merely to be made for the purpose of taking cognizance of the existence of a vacancy so that procedure under bye-law 29 could be adopted for filling up the vacancy for the balance period of the Managing Committee. The disqualification under cl. (a) of sub-r. (1) of R. 58 operates the moment the loan is not repaid within the period specified and the member of the Managing Committee who has committed that default ceases to be a member any more. The recognition of that fact on the record of the society in the form of a formal resolution subsequently cannot amount, as if giving extended time for payment until the next Managing Committee meets and passes such a resolution. That would be the effect of the argument of Mr. Badkar, if we were to hold that until the Managing Committee passed its resolution on January 23, 1976 the disqualification could not be said to have been incurred. The disqualification, according to us, automatically was incurred on December 24, 1975 itself when the grace period of payment in addition to the original period provided by the bye laws was over when respondent No. 3 ceased to be a member and the petitioner bank was within its rights in passing the impugned resolution. This being our view of the matter, we quash the order passed by the Co-operative Court and also quash the Appellate Court's order though it decides nothing but takes the colour as if confirming the order of the trial Court. We also hold that respondent No. 3 has already incurred a disqualification as from December 23, 1975 and ceased to be a member of the Managing Committee from that date. The petition is thus allowed. Rule made absolute. There will be no order as to costs.

9. Petition allowed.