Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay City I v. Mahindra And Mahindra Ltd.

Bombay High Court
Oct 4, 1972
Smart Summary (Beta)

Court Opinion Summary — Kantawala, J. (Reference under Section 66(1), Income-tax Act, 1922)

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference under section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1922 posed the question whether two sums — Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 — were properly held to be capital profits. The question arose from assessments for the assessment years 1952–53 and 1953–54 (with the relevant previous years ending 31 October 1951 and 31 October 1952).

The assessee was a private limited company (shareholders from the Mahindra family and nominees) whose business included import and sale of diesel engines. Around 1947 the assessee pursued a plan to manufacture diesel engines in India based on a proposal involving an American, Kilberi, and plant/machinery from Vess Sevenin Machine Company Inc. The Government of India sanctioned foreign exchange ($500,000) and permitted the purchase of the machine company’s plant on the understanding the machinery would be transferred to India by 30 June 1949.

The assessee floated another Indian company in May 1948. Between February and August 1948, $450,000 was remitted to the U.S.; $30,000 was used to buy the 250-share capital of the machine company (11 Feb 1948) and $420,000 was advanced as a loan to that company (promissory note). The machine company formed a subsidiary (referred to in the opinion as the "new company") and transferred assets (book value $475,646) to it in exchange for shares, leaving a substantial "paid in surplus." Ultimately the assessee acquired the entire share capital of the new company.

The manufacturing project was abandoned in 1949 after engines sold to the Bombay Government proved unsuitable. The assessee repatriated funds to India in October 1949 (two remittances totalling $225,000) and later remittances aggregating $230,562 between July 1951 and October 1952 from sale proceeds of shares (100 shares of the new company and 137 shares of the machine company). These transactions produced surplus realisations of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 in the relevant previous years.

At initial assessment the Income-tax Officer did not have all material facts and treated these amounts as taxable income. On appeal the Appellate Assistant Commissioner, after a remand report, held the realisations were capital gains and not taxable. The Income-tax Tribunal confirmed that view on appeal by the revenue. The present reference asks the court to determine whether these sums were properly held to be capital profits.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the sums of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 were properly held to be capital profits (i.e., capital gains) rather than taxable revenue receipts.

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments (Mr. Hajarnavis)

  • The transaction was substantially in the nature of a trading activity rather than a capital investment.
  • The assessee's purchase of the machine company and related dealings should be viewed in context of a business plan tied to obtaining a large government order (the assessee wanted an order for 1,000 engines and the government agreed to 250 initially), suggesting a commercial-trading purpose.
  • The remand report showed a large disparity between the book value of fixed assets ($39,471) and the value of finished parts/goods ($334,807) on 31 July 1948, implying the acquisition included circulating assets (stock-in-trade) and not merely fixed capital.
  • Only $30,000 was paid for the 250 shares while $420,000 was advanced as a loan — the structure indicates amounts invested in the trading enterprise and trading accretions should be treated as income.
  • Legal principle asserted: every accretion invested in trade is income; therefore the two sums cannot be regarded as capital gains but are assessable as revenue profits.

Assessee's Position

  • Before the Income-tax Officer the assessee had contended that the whole transaction was of a capital nature; this contention was reiterated on appeal.
  • Counsel for the assessee disputed the correctness of the figures relied upon by the revenue (specifically the values presented in the remand report), although no extended reply was called for by the court because the bench was not persuaded by the revenue's contentions.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court analysed both the factual matrix and the governing legal distinction between capital receipts and revenue receipts:

  1. Principle: The court reiterated the settled legal distinction — a receipt is not taxable when it is fixed capital; it is taxable as revenue when referable to circulating capital or stock-in-trade. Fixed capital is retained by the owner to yield profit by possession; circulating capital yields profit by being parted with and changing owners.
  2. Nature of the project: The assessee's project was to establish a factory in India to manufacture diesel engines using imported plant and machinery; correspondence with the Government shows an intention to set up manufacturing before 30 June 1949. The project was abandoned only because the engines proved unsuitable for Indian conditions (86 engines sold to Bombay Government were found unsuitable).
  3. Structure of the acquisition: The assessee purchased the entire 250 shares of the machine company (for $30,000) and advanced $420,000 as a loan (via promissory note). The machine company had created a subsidiary and transferred assets into it; the assessee came to hold the entire share capital of that new company. The court emphasised that buying shares does not equate to buying the company's stock-in-trade — a shareholder's rights are to dividends and participation in profits/losses of the company, not to direct ownership of underlying trading stock.
  4. No trading in shares: The court found the assessee "never traded in the shares" of the machine company; the purchase was not part of a pattern of trading activity. The assessee's dealings were investment-oriented to acquire control of assets for the manufacturing project rather than for resale as stock-in-trade.
  5. Realisation and remittances: When the project failed and the investments were liquidated (sale of 100 shares of the new company and 137 shares of the machine company), the proceeds remitted to India were proceeds of liquidation of investments. The Tribunal's figures showed proceeds of $150,000 (new company shares) and $91,333.33 (137 machine-company shares), totalling $241,333.33. The larger total remitted ($455,562) included repayments against the earlier loan; even if treated as loan repayment, no revenue income arose because the amounts repaid were less than the principal.
  6. No pleading that sums represented sale of stock-in-trade: The court noted that the revenue at no stage argued these sums were referable to any sale of stock-in-trade. Absent any assertion that the transactions related to stock-in-trade, the court treated the composite acquisition (plant, machinery and finished parts acquired because the entire concern was bought) as capital in nature.
  7. Composite transaction still capital: Even if the acquisition is viewed as a composite transaction (acquisition of all assets of the machine company including finished goods), the court held that because the overall purpose and character of the transaction were capital — to establish a manufacturing concern — any gain on abandonment and liquidation remained capital gain and not revenue income.
  8. Procedural note: The court observed it was not persuaded by the revenue's contentions and therefore did not require a further reply from the assessee's counsel.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The court answered the reference in the affirmative — the sums of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 were properly held to be capital profits (capital gains) and were not taxable as revenue income.

Immediate consequences:

  • The decision confirms the Tribunal and Appellate Assistant Commissioner findings that the realised surpluses arose from liquidation of capital investments and are capital in nature.
  • The revenue was ordered to pay the costs of the assessee-company.

Broader implications:

  • The opinion applies the established distinction between fixed (capital) and circulating (trading) capital to a factual situation where an enterprise acquired an entire foreign company (including both fixed assets and finished goods) for the purpose of establishing manufacturing in India and subsequently liquidated those holdings after abandoning the project. The court's analysis emphasises that acquisition of shares and the control that flows from that is not the same as acquiring stock-in-trade.
  • The opinion does not purport to set out a novel legal principle or cite new precedent; it applies settled principles to the facts. No specific case law was cited in the provided opinion.

Disposition: Question answered in the affirmative; revenue to pay the assessee's costs.

Show all summary ...

Kantawala, J.:— By this reference under section 66(1) of the Income-tax Act, 1922, the following question is referred to us for determination:

“Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the sums of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 were properly held to be capital profits?”

2. This reference arises out of the assessment for the assessment years 1952-53 and 1953-54, the relevant previous years being the years ending October 31, 1951, and October 31, 1952, respectively. During these assessment years, the assessee was a private limited company and its share capital was held by the members of the Mahindra family and their nominees. The assessee-company's business consisted, amongst others, in import and sale of diesel engines. In or about the year 1947, the assessee-company came across a suggestion regarding manufacture of diesel engines in India, for lift irrigation purpose from one Kilberi, an American citizen. The said manufacture was to be done with the machinery to be acquired from an American company called Vess Sevenin Machine Company Inc. (hereinafter referred to as “the machine company”). The machine company was in financial difficulties and a committee of creditors was appointed for proper distribution of its assets. In December, 1947, the assessee-company presented a scheme to the Government of India for manufacture of diesel engines. In December, 1947, a conference was held between the representatives of the assessee-company and those of the Government of India. As a result of this conference, the scheme propounded by the assessee-company was accepted and it was decided to sanction foreign exchange to the tune of five lakhs U.S dollars. Permission was granted to the assessee-company for purchase of plant of the machine company for having it installed in India and thereafter the assessee-company was required to start manufacture of diesel engines. The import of machinery was contemplated to take place on or before June 30, 1949. As a part of the scheme, the assessee-company desired that Government should place with it a firm order for purchase of 1,000 diesel engines. The Government decided to place an order for 250 engines and for the balance, orders were to be placed as and when capable. In view of the decision, the Government wrote to the Reserve Bank stating that it has sanctioned the remittance to the assessee-company of five lakhs U.S dollars for purchase of machine company, a company manufacturing complete diesel engines, on the understanding that the machinery and plant covered by the purchase are transferred to India by the 30th of June, 1949.

3. For the purpose of carrying out this project, the assessee-company floated another company in India in May, 1948, and the business was to be carried on in Calcutta. Between February, 1948, and August, 1948, 4,50,000 dollars were remitted to America. The balance of 50,000 dollars out of the sanctioned foreign exchange was kept reserved for payment of freight, shipping charges, etc.

4. The capital of the machine company was 30,000 U.S dollars divided into 250 shares of 120 dollars each. On February 11, 1948, the assessee-company entered into an agreement with the shareholders of the machine company and purchased the entire share capital for 30,000 dollars. The balance of 4,20,000 dollars was paid over to the machine company as loan and a promissory note for the amount was taken. The machine company floated a new company as its subsidiary called Venn Sevenin company (hereinafter called as the “new company”). Capital of the new company was to consist of 10,000 dollars. Upon incorporation of the new company the entire machinery and other assets of the book value of 4,75,646 dollars were transferred by the machine company to the new company in exchange for 100 shares of 100 dollars each allotted to the machine company. After adjusting the sum of 10,000 dollars in the share capital account the new company showed the balance of 4,65,646 dollars as a “paid in surplus”—a kind of capital reserve. Thereafter, the machine company transferred 100 shares of the new company to the assessee-company and the loan of 4,20,000 dollars made to it by the assessee-company was treated as discharged. After this transaction, the entire share capital of the new company was held by the assessee-company. It appears that in or about the year 1948, 86 diesel engines were sold to the Bombay Government but these engines were not found suitable to Indian conditions. The assessee-company did not succeed in its efforts with the Government to secure a firm order. Consequently, in the year 1949, the project for manufacture of diesal engines in India with the help of the said machinery was abandoned. The assessee-company repatriated to India 1,00,000 dollars on October 10, 1949, and 1,25,000 dollars on October 27, 1949. The pound sterling was devalued in September, 1949, and the rupee was also simultaneously devalued. The rupee value of 2,25,000 dollars remitted to India after the devaluation came to Rs. 10,68,500. This capital is paid out of the paid in surplus in the new company. Thereafter, between July, 1951, and October, 1952, there were remittances aggregating to 2,30,562 dollars. These remittances were from the sale proceeds of 100 shares held by the assessee in the new company and 137 shares in the machine company. The remaining 113 shares in the machine company were held by Kilberi and Webster. They were given to them for the help rendered by them to the assessee-company in October, 1949. As a result of these remittances during the relevant years, there were surplus realisations of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342, respectively, in the relevant previous years. At the time when the assessee-company was assessed by the Income-tax Officer, all relevant facts material to this transaction were not available to the Income-tax Officer. It was, however, contended by the assessee-company before the Income-tax Officer that the whole transaction was one of a capital nature, but that contention was not accepted by him and he subjected both these amounts to tax in the two assessment years.

5. In the appeals filed by the assessee-company for these two years, the Appellate Assistant Commissioner remanded the case and called for a report from the Income-tax Officer. After the remand report, the matter was considered by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and he held that the profits realised by the assessee-company as a result of the liquidation of the investments and remittances thereof to India represented capital gains. He, therefore, took the view that neither the sum of Rs. 4,38,472 nor the sum of Rs. 2,27,342 was subject to tax. On an appeal by the revenue the Income-tax Tribunal confirmed the finding of the Appellate Assistant Commissioner that the transaction was a capital gain and that the surplus was not taxable.

6. Mr. Hajarnavis, on behalf of the revenue, contended that the transaction substantially was in the nature of a trading activity; that the assessee-company wanted the transaction for purchase of plant and machinery to be tied up with an order for sale of 1,000 diesel engines to the Government. He also pointed out that it is apparent from the remand report submitted by the Income-tax Officer that the value of the fixed assets of the machine company was only 39,471 dollars whereas the value of the finished parts and goods as on July 31, 1948, was at 3,34,807 dollars. He also pointed out that in purchasing 250 shares of the machine company only a sum of 30,000 dollars was utilised while the balance of 4,20,000 dollars was given by way of loan for which a promissory note was passed by the machine company. He submitted that every accretion invested in trade is income, and the two sums of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 cannot be regarded as capital gains or profits but that they should be regarded as income to the assessee-company.

7. As we are not satisfied with the contentions urged on behalf of the revenue, we have not called upon the counsel for the assessee-company to reply. However, counsel for the assessee stated that the correctness of the figures supplied and relied upon by the revenue is not accepted by the assessee-company.

8. It is well settled that a receipt is not taxable when it is a fixed capital. It is taxable as a revenue item when it is referable to circulating capital or stock-in-trade. The fixed capital is what the owner turns to profit by keeping it in his own possession. Circulating capital is what he makes profit of by parting with it and letting it change its masters. The entire nature of the transaction has been analysed by the Appellate Assistant Commissioner and by the Tribunal in their respective orders. The project of the assessee-company was to establish a factory for manufacture of diesel engines in India and for that purpose to import requisite plant and machinery in India. That factory was intended to be established as shown by the correspondence with the Government prior to June 30, 1949. The project had, however, to be abandoned because 86 diesel engines which were sold to the Government were found unsuitable for conditions in India. The assets of the machine company consisted partly of plant and machinery and partly of finished parts and goods. But the assessee-company only purchased all the 250 shares of the machine company and advanced to it as and by way of loan a sum of 4,20,000 dollars on a promissory note. The assessee-company never traded in the shares of the machine company and the purchase thereof did not form part of its trading activity. The purchase of shares of the machine company does not mean purchase of stock-in-trade of that company. The machine company continued its business and sales of its products. The profit and loss belonged to that company. A shareholder of the machine company had merely a right to get dividends, if they were declared. When the project was abandoned all the 100 shares of the new company and 137 shares of the machine company were sold. The profits realised as a result of liquidation of the investments and the remittances thereof to India thus remains the capital gain.

9. Between October, 1949, and October, 1952, a total sum of 4,55,562 dollars was remitted to India. These remittances commenced after the asses-see-company agreed to sell its holding of 100 shares in the new company and 137 shares in the machine company to J.J Sugarman & Co. As the order of the Tribunal shows, the proceeds of the 100 shares of the new company were 1,50,000 dollars and those of 137 shares of the machine company were 91,333.33 dollars. The total proceeds of the sale of these shares amount to 2,41,333.33 dollars. The investment in these shares is not a trading activity of the company. By realising 2,41,333.33 dollars in respect of the price of the shares, no revenue income accrued to the assessee-company. If the difference between 4,55,562 dollars and 2,41,333.33 dollars is regarded as the payment made towards the loan of 4,20,000 dollars, even then there is no income whatsoever because the amount so repaid is much less than the principal amount.

10. As shown in the statement of case at no stage the revenue had taken up the position that the sums of Rs. 4,38,472 and Rs. 2,27,342 were wholly or in part referable to any sale of stock-in-trade and as such within the meaning of the profits. Even if the transaction is regarded as of a composite nature to acquire all the assets of the machine company with the object of establishing a company for manufacture of diesel engines in India, it is of a capital nature. As the entire assets of the machine company had to be purchased, both its plant and machinery and its finished products and parts had to be purchased. The composite transaction being of a capital nature, if any gain ultimately resulted to the assessee-company by reason of the project being abandoned, the amount will be in the nature of capital gain and not by way of revenue income.

11. Our answer to the question referred to us is in the affirmative. The revenue will pay the costs of the assessee-company.

12. Question answered in the affirmative.