- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Plaza Chemical Industries v. Kohinoor Chemical Company Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
Plaza Chemical Industries (petitioners) appealed an order of the Joint Registrar of Trade Marks rejecting their application for rectification (removal) of a trade mark registered in the name of Kohinoor Chemical Co. Ltd. (respondents). The respondents' trade mark, registered from April 16, 1943, was a label showing a woman's head, snow‑clad mountains and the word "Tibet" in respect of facial cream. After partition the respondents migrated to Pakistan. The petitioners began manufacturing and marketing a facial cream labelled "Tibet snow" circa 1962 and sought registration of that label in Delhi on March 6, 1964; that application was refused because of the respondents' registered mark. On March 4, 1966 the petitioners applied in Bombay for removal of the respondents' registered trade mark, alleging (a) the respondents obtained registration without bona fide intention to use it for facial cream and (b) the respondents had not used the mark in respect of facial cream for a continuous period of five years up to one month before the application, rendering it an abandoned mark.
The respondents opposed removal, admitting non‑use in India for the requisite period but attributing non‑use to government import restrictions and asserting continued use by means of advertisements in publications circulated in India and readiness to resume exports once the embargo was lifted. The Joint Registrar accepted the respondents' contention that the non‑use was due to special circumstances under section 46(3) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958, and rejected the petitioners' application. The petitioners appealed from that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the conditions of section 46(1)(b) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958 (a continuous period of five years' non‑use up to one month before the application) were satisfied in this case.
- Whether non‑use of the respondents' registered trade mark for the requisite period was "due to special circumstances in the trade" within the meaning of section 46(3), thereby precluding the petitioners from relying on non‑use under section 46(1)(b).
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to have the respondents' registered trade mark removed from the register on the ground of non‑use in the circumstances of this case.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The registered trade mark had not been used bona fide in relation to facial cream for a continuous period of five years up to one month before the application, satisfying s.46(1)(b).
- Import restrictions imposed by the Central Government could not be regarded as "special circumstances" under s.46(3) that would justify non‑use and prevent removal.
Respondents' Arguments
- Prior to partition the respondents carried on business in Delhi and after partition shifted to Karachi; goods covered by the registration had been sold in India until the Government of India imposed an import ban.
- The mark continued to be used in India by means of advertisements in leading newspapers and journals having circulation in India.
- The non‑use was caused by temporary suspension of exports due to government import restrictions; such restrictions amount to "special circumstances" under s.46(3), and therefore non‑use could not be relied upon to remove the mark.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Bali Trade Mark1 | Held that import restrictions constitute "special circumstances in the trade" within s.46(3); such special circumstances continue as long as importation is impracticable in a business sense. | The court applied this principle to conclude that the respondents' non‑use of the mark was attributable to import restrictions and therefore constituted special circumstances under s.46(3), preventing reliance on non‑use under s.46(1)(b) to remove the mark. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded stepwise:
- It noted the rights conferred by registration under section 28: if valid, registration gives the proprietor the exclusive right to use the trade mark in relation to the goods for which it is registered. It was accepted that the respondents were registered proprietors of the mark for face cream from April 16, 1943.
- Section 46(1)(b) sets out that a registered trade mark may be removed if, up to one month before the application, a continuous period of five years or longer elapsed during which there was no bona fide use of the mark by any proprietor for the goods in question. On the evidence before the Joint Registrar, those conditions were fulfilled.
- However, the court emphasized that s.46(3) prevents an applicant from relying on non‑use under s.46(1)(b) if the non‑use is shown to have been due to "special circumstances in the trade" relating to the goods. The core question therefore became whether the respondents' non‑use was due to such special circumstances.
- The court relied on the decision in Bali Trade Mark1, which establishes that import restrictions can amount to special circumstances within the meaning of s.46(3), and that those circumstances continue so long as importation remains impracticable in a business sense.
- The court found it undisputed that from 1954 onward, government import policy prohibited import of cosmetics into India. Given these restrictions, the respondents were unable to use their registered trade mark in India; this constituted the special circumstances envisaged by s.46(3).
- Because the non‑use was attributable to those special circumstances, the petitioners could not rely upon non‑use under s.46(1)(b) to procure removal of the respondents' registered mark. Consequently the Joint Registrar's rejection of the petitioners' application was upheld.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Holding: The court dismissed the appeal and upheld the Joint Registrar's decision to refuse removal of the respondents' registered trade mark. The court quantified costs at Rs. 400 in favour of the respondents.
Implications: As a direct effect, the respondents retain their registration and the petitioners' application for removal was unsuccessful. The court applied existing precedent (Bali Trade Mark1) to determine that government import restrictions constituted special circumstances under s.46(3) and therefore barred reliance on non‑use under s.46(1)(b). The opinion does not purport to establish a new principle beyond applying the cited precedent.
Kantawala, J.:— Plaza Chemical Industries, the petitioners, have filed this petition by way of an appeal against an order passed by the Joint Registrar of Trade Marks rejecting their application for rectification. As from April 16, 1943 a trade mark consisting of a label containing a device of a head of a woman, snow clad mountains and the word “Tibet” was registered in the name of the respondents Kohinoor Chemical Co. Ltd. in respect of facial cream. Upon partition of India the respondents migrated to Pakistan. It is the case of the petitioners that since 1962 they started manufacturing and marketing a facial cream under a label containing the words “Tibet snow”. On March 6, 1964 the petitioners filed an application in the office of the Trade Marks Registry at Delhi for registration of the said label as a trade mark. That application was refused stating that the respondents were Registered Proprietors of a trade mark containing the words “Tibet snow”. On March 4, 1966 the petitioners made an application in the office of the Trade Marks Registry at Bombay for removal of the registered trade mark in the name of the respondents. In support of this application they alleged that the respondents; got the said trade mark registered without any bona fide intention on their part to use it in respect of facial cream. They further alleged that upto one month before the date of the application for rectification, the respondents have not used the said trade mark for a continuous period of five years in respect of facial cream. According to them, under the circumstances, this should be regarded as an abandoned mark by the respondents.
2. The application for removal of the trade mark was resisted by the respondents. In their affidavit in reply they contended that prior to partition of the country they were carrying on business at Delhi and after the partition of the country they shifted to Karachi in West Pakistan. They also stated that the goods covered by the registration of the trade mark were being sold in India until a ban on imports by the Government of India was imposed. In spite of the ban, according to them, the mark was being used in India through the medium of advertisement in leading newspapers and journals, all of which had circulation in India as well.
3. They also stated that no sooner the embargo placed on import of cosmetics in India is lifted by the Central Government, they would readily and immediately export their goods to India. They submitted that the temporary suspension of export due to restrictions imposed by the Government was not a ground for rectification.
4. Before the Joint Registrar of Trade Marks the application of the petitioners for removal was supported in view of the provisions of s. 46(1)(b) of the Trade and Merchandise Marks Act, 1958. The ground was that upto one month before the date of the application, a continuous period of five years or longer had elapsed during which there was no bona fide use thereof in relation to those goods by any proprietor thereof for the time being. It was admitted by the respondents that for the requisite period the mark was not used in India. It was however alleged that such a non-user was due to special circumstances in the nature of import restrictions imposed by Government and, therefore, in view of the provisions of s. 46(3) of the Act the petitioners were not entitled to rely upon such non-use. That contention was accepted by the Joint Registrar of Trade Marks and the application of the petitioners was rejected.
5. The present petition is filed by way of appeal against that order.
6. Mr. Shah on behalf of the petitioners contended that a continuous period of five years has elapsed during which the trade mark was registered and during which there was no bona fide use thereof in relation to those goods by the respondents thereof for the time being. His submission is that imposition of restrictions qua import by the Central Government, cannot be regarded as a special circumstance and that the Joint Registrar was in error in not allowing the petitioners' application for removal of registration of the trade mark.
7. Section 28 enunciates the rights conferred by registration. Under that section, subject to the other provisions of the Act, the registration of a trade mark shall, if valid, give to the registered proprietor of the trade mark the exclusive right to the use of the trade mark in relation to the goods in respect of which the trade mark is registered and to obtain relief in respect of infringement of the trade mark in the manner provided by this Act. It is not disputed that as from April 16, 1943 the respondents are the registered proprietors of a trade mark consisting of a label containing a device of a head of a woman, snow clad mountains and the word “Tibet” in respect of face cream. As such registered proprietors the respondents have the exclusive right to the use of the trade mark in relation to face cream.
8. Section 46 of the Act lays down the circumstances under which a trade mark may be removed from register. Reliance is placed upon the provisions of s. 46(1)(b) in the present case to support the application for removal. It is as under:
“46. (1) Subject to the provisions of section 47, a registered trade mark may be taken off the register in respect of any of the goods in respect of which it is registered on application made in the prescribed manner to a High Court or to the Registrar by any person aggrieved on the ground either—
(b) that up to a date one month before the date of the application, a continuous period of five years or longer had elapsed during which the trade mark was registered and during which there was no bona fide use thereof in relation to those goods by any proprietor thereof for the time being:”
9. On the evidence before the Joint Registrar, the conditions laid down in sub-s. (1)(b) above, were fulfilled. However, that by itself is not sufficient to remove the trade mark from register in view of the provision of sub-s. (3) of s. 46. The relevant part of sub-s. (3) lays down that an applicant shall not be entitled to rely for the purpose of cl. (b) of sub-s. (1) on any non-use of a trade mark which is shown to have been due to special circumstances in the trade mark in relation to the goods to which the application relates. Question arises whether it is established in the present case that the non-use of the trade mark for the requisite period constitutes a special circumstance within the meaning of s. 46(3) of the Act. It is well-settled in view of the decision in Bali Trade Mark1, that import restrictions constitute special circumstances within the meaning of s. 46(3) of the Act. It was laid down in that case that “special circumstances in the trade” justifying non-use of the trade mark did not end when the Government restrictions on importation from America were cased, but continued as long as importation was impracticable in a business sense. It is not disputed in the present case that right from the year 1954 onwards in view of the import policy declared from time to time by the Government of India, import of cosmetics is prohibited in this country. These special circumstances exist due to which the respondents were unable to use their registered trade mark in India. Their case is, therefore, covered by the provisions of s. 46(3) and even though the conditions laid down in s. 46(1)(b) are fulfilled in the present case, they will not be entitled to have the respondents' registered trade mark removed from the register.
10. In the result, the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs. Costs quantified at Rs. 400.
11. Appeal dismissed.
Alert