- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mrs. Shobha Venkat Rao v. K.R Mahale .
Structured Summary of the Opinion
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal challenged an order dated 19 August 1965 made by a Judge of the Bombay City Civil Court holding that the suit's subject-matter value exceeded Rs. 25,000, that the Court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction, and ordering the plaint returned for presentation to the proper court.
The plaintiff was a licensee of a restaurant (Meenakshi Bhuvan, later Central Cafe Udipi) and had granted a sub-licence to defendant No. 1, who ran the restaurant with defendant No. 2. The plaintiff alleged breach of the sub-licence, terminated the licence, and on 3 March 1959 filed a suit against defendants Nos. 1 and 2 for:
- Recovery of possession of the restaurant (including fittings, furniture and articles listed in Exhibit C to the plaint), and
- Rs. 3,500 as arrears of licence fees and future mesne profits (prayer (b)).
The plaintiff obtained an interim order appointing a receiver; when the receiver sought possession, defendants Nos. 3 and 4 were found in possession and were subsequently joined as parties. Defendant No. 3 was the plaintiff's licensor and defendant No. 4 a fresh licensee placed in possession.
Defendants filed a written statement (no jurisdictional objection was taken then). Issues were settled in July 1963 and trial proceeded. At the stage of arguments the defendants relied on a statement by the plaintiff's constituted attorney asserting that the market value of the property exceeded Rs. 25,000 and raised the point of jurisdiction.
The trial Judge appointed the Registrar to inquire into the value of the subject to determine pecuniary jurisdiction under Section 12 of the Court-fees Act, 1870 (in force at the suit's institution). The Registrar reported a total value of Rs. 30,336.75 (premises Rs. 13,850; movable property Rs. 16,486.75). At the defendants' instance the Registrar had added a List No. 3 of five items valued at Rs. 5,500.
The plaintiff objected to the Registrar's report and sought to amend the plaint to abandon parts of the claim so as to fall within the Court's jurisdiction. The trial Judge refused the amendment on the ground that, if the Court had no jurisdiction, it could not entertain an application to amend. The Judge then made the impugned order returning the plaint for presentation to the proper Court. The plaintiff appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Bombay City Civil Court had pecuniary jurisdiction over the suit given the Registrar's valuation exceeding Rs. 25,000.
- Whether the plaintiff could abandon a part of her claim (voluntarily) under Order 23, Rule 1(1) of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, after the Registrar's valuation report but before the Court had made a final finding on jurisdiction.
- Whether the trial Court, having a Registrar's report indicating excess value, was nonetheless competent to record the plaintiff's unilateral abandonment of part of the claim without an amendment application and thereby retain jurisdiction.
- Whether the Court-fees Act, 1870 (Section 6(v)), required court-fee to be calculated on the market value of the property sought to be recovered or on the value of the plaintiff's licence-right (a point raised but not pressed on appeal).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's (Plaintiff's) Arguments — as presented on appeal
- The Registrar wrongly included five items (List No. 3, valued at Rs. 5,500) in his valuation; those articles were not claimed in the plaint and should be excluded from the valuation.
- Even after excluding the Rs. 5,500, the suit could be brought within the Court's jurisdiction by the plaintiff abandoning part of her claim (specifically the 44 articles in List No. 2 valued at Rs. 2,416 and Rs. 1,200 out of the Rs. 3,500 arrears), which she sought to do by a draft amendment.
- Under Order 23, Rule 1(1) of the CPC, the plaintiff may abandon part of her claim at any time after institution of the suit without needing the Court's leave (i.e., amendment was not necessary to effect voluntary abandonment).
- Alternatively, under Section 6(v) of the Court-fees Act, 1870, court-fee might be payable on the value of the licence-right (alleged to be not more than Rs. 6,500) rather than the full market value of the property — a point not pressed on appeal.
Respondents' (Defendants') Arguments — as presented in the record
- The constituted attorney's statement in evidence indicated the market value of the property exceeded Rs. 25,000; therefore the trial Court lacked pecuniary jurisdiction.
- Once the Registrar made a valuation report showing the suit's value exceeded Rs. 25,000, the trial Court had no jurisdiction to entertain an application to amend or to record an abandonment — the Court could only return the plaint to be presented to the proper Court.
- The defendants had caused the Registrar to include List No. 3 (five items valued at Rs. 5,500) in the valuation, which kept the total over Rs. 25,000.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The appellate Judge proceeded through the following analytical steps, applying statutory provisions cited in the record:
- Examination of the Registrar's valuation: the appellate Judge found that the Registrar had included five items (List No. 3 valued at Rs. 5,500) which were not claimed in the plaint. Because those items were not claimed, they were improperly included and the Rs. 5,500 must be excluded. That reduces the Registrar's total valuation from Rs. 30,336.75 to Rs. 24,836.75, which would place the suit within the pecuniary jurisdiction of the Bombay City Civil Court if those were the only claims.
- Consideration of the arrears claim in prayer (b): adding the Rs. 3,500 claim for arrears of licence fees would again push the total above Rs. 25,000. The plaintiff therefore sought to abandon parts of the claim (44 articles in List No. 2 valued at Rs. 2,416, and Rs. 1,200 of the Rs. 3,500 arrears) so as to remain within jurisdiction.
- Legal effect of abandonment under Order 23, Rule 1(1), CPC: the appellate Judge held that Order 23, Rule 1(1) permits a plaintiff at any time after institution of a suit to abandon a part of his claim by unilateral act — a statement to the Court suffices; no formal amendment or leave of Court is necessary for voluntary abandonment. Thus the draft amendment the plaintiff presented merely sought to effect abandonment, which could lawfully have been accomplished by the plaintiff's statement recorded by the Court.
- Competence of the trial Court to record abandonment after the Registrar's report: the appellate Judge rejected the defendants' contention that the trial Court lost competence to record an abandonment once the Registrar's report indicated excess value. The Judge reasoned that until the trial Court itself makes a finding that it lacks jurisdiction and orders the plaint returned, the Court remains seized of the matter and may determine its own jurisdiction, and it is therefore open to a party to abandon part of the claim so as to bring the suit within the Court's jurisdiction. If the contrary position were accepted, it would produce impractical and unfair consequences (forcing re-presentation as a new suit and re-trial despite evidence already recorded).
- Relationship with other Code provisions (Order 2, Rule 2(2)): the appellate Judge noted Order 2, Rule 2(2) is not the sole provision relating to relinquishment of claims and that Order 23, Rule 1(1) independently allows voluntary abandonment. Thus the plaintiff's unilateral abandonment could have been recorded and the trial Court could have proceeded if the remaining claim fell within jurisdiction.
- On the point under Section 6(v) of the Court-fees Act, 1870 (whether court-fee should be assessed on the market value or on the licence-right), the appellate Judge observed the plaintiff raised the contention but did not press it because, after excluding the unclaimed Rs. 5,500 and the plaintiff's stated abandonment, the suit fell within the City Civil Court's jurisdiction; thus no finding was necessary on that statutory point.
- Conclusion from the analysis: because the trial Judge refused to treat the plaintiff's proposed abandonment as a unilateral statement and therefore refused to retain the plaint despite the possibility of bringing the suit within jurisdiction, the appellate Judge concluded the trial Judge ought to have recorded the abandonment and proceeded. The trial Judge's order was therefore set aside.
- Directions as to further procedure: the appellate Judge remanded the suit to the City Civil Court for further proceedings consistent with the judgment and directed that, because evidence had already been recorded and the original Judge had retired, the matter be placed before another Judge of the City Civil Court to proceed from the predecessor Judge's stage under Order 18, Rule 15 of the CPC. Costs of the appeal were ordered to be costs in the suit.
Holding and Implications
Core Ruling: The appellate court set aside the trial Judge's order returning the plaint and remanded the suit to the Bombay City Civil Court for further proceedings consistent with the judgment; the plaintiff's proposed abandonment of parts of her claim should have been treated as a unilateral abandonment under Order 23, Rule 1(1), CPC, and the trial Court retained the competence to record such abandonment before concluding it lacked jurisdiction.
Direct consequences:
- The Registrar's inclusion of unclaimed items (List No. 3 valued at Rs. 5,500) was held to be incorrect and those items are to be excluded from the valuation.
- The trial Court was directed to proceed with the suit (subject to the plaintiff's abandonment already made before the appellate court) and the matter is to be placed before another Judge of the City Civil Court to continue from the stage at which evidence was left under Order 18, Rule 15 of the CPC.
- Costs of the appeal were ordered to be costs in the suit.
Broader implications: the opinion clarifies that, under Order 23, Rule 1(1) CPC, a plaintiff may voluntarily abandon part of a claim at any stage after institution by a unilateral statement to the Court and that a trial Court remains able to record that abandonment and decide its jurisdiction until it itself formally finds it lacks jurisdiction and returns the plaint. The opinion does not state that it creates binding precedent beyond its application to the facts; no case-law precedent was cited in the provided opinion.
Final Disposition: Suit remanded to the City Civil Court for further proceedings not inconsistent with this judgment.
1. This is an appeal against an order dated 19th August, 1965 passed by a Judge of the Bombay City Civil Court, holding that the value of the subject-matter of the suit was over Rupees 25,000 and the Court therefore, had no pecuniary jurisdiction to try the suit and ordering that the plaint be returned to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper Court.
2. The plaintiff claims to be a licensee of a restaurant known as Meenakshi Bhuvan and lately known as Central Cafe Udipi situated in Vishwas Bhuvan, King Edward Road, Parel, Bombay. She appears to have granted a sub-licence in respect of this restaurant to the defendant No. 1 who was running it with the assistance of the defendant No. 2. The plaintiff claims to have terminated the licence of the defendant No. 1 on the ground that he had committed breach of the terms of the sub-licence.
3. She, therefore, filed the present suit against defendants Nos. 1 and 2 only for recovery of possession of the said restaurant and a sum of Rs. 3,500 as arrears of licence fees and future mesne profits. She filed the suit on 3rd March, 1959. In the suit she took out a notice of motion and got an interim order for appointment of receiver. When the receiver went to take possession, he found that the defendants Nos. 3 and 4 were in possession. The plaintiff thereafter joined them as party defendants to the suit. Defendant No. 3 is the plaintiffs licenser. Defendant No. 4 is a fresh licensee from the defendant No. 3. It appears that in order to spite the plaintiff the defendant No. 1 had handed over possession of the suit premises to the plaintiff's licenser who in turn had put a new licensee in possession.
4. The defendants filed their written statement. No defence as to jurisdiction was taken. Issues were settled in July 1963. It appears from the issues that no issue was raised as to jurisdiction. The suit proceeded to trial Both parties led evidence and the matter was being argued. At the stage of arguments it appears the defendants relied upon a statement in the evidence by the constituted attorney of the plaintiff indicating that the market value of the property of which possession was sought to be recovered in the suit was over Rs. 25,000. The defendants, therefore, at that stage raised the point of jurisdiction. The learned Judge appointed the Registrar of the Court to hold an enquiry and make a report as to the value of the premises possession whereof was sought to be recovered evidently with a view ultimately to determine the value himself under the provisions of Section 12 of the Court-fees Act, 1870, which was in force at the date of the institution of the suit. The learned Registrar made a report in which he held that the total value of the premises, possession whereof was claimed in prayer (a) of the plaint, was Rs. 30,336.75, namely. Rs. 13,850 being the value of the premises and Rs. 16,486.75 being the value of the movable property sought to be recovered. The plaintiff filed objections to this report. The learned Judge heard the objections. Probably finding that the learned Judge Was inclined to accept the valuation made by the Registrar, the plaintiff presented a draft amendment and sought leave to amend the plaint. This draft amendment is at page 103 of the paper-book. By this draft amendment the plaintiff sought to abandon a part of the claim so as to bring the suit within the jurisdiction of the Court. The learned Judge, however, did not grant this amendment and ultimately passed the order, which is the subject-matter of this appeal.
5. The first point argued before me by Mr. Varghese on behalf of the plaintiff is that in prayer (a) of the plaint the plaintiff seeks to recover possession of the restaurant with all its fittings, furniture and fixtures and things and articles mentioned in Ex. C to the plaint. Ex. C consists of two lists, one comprising 71 items and the other comprising 44 items. The learned Registrar of the City Civil Court has valued all the movable articles at Rs. 16,486.75. This consists of Rupees 8.570.75 being the value of 71 articles in list No. 1, and Rs. 2,416.00 being the value of 44 articles comprised in list No. 2. To this report the Registrar has at the instance of the defendants added list No. 3 consisting of five Items valued at Rs. 5,500. The plaintiff points out that these articles have not been claimed in the plaint and therefore, the learned Registrar has wrongly included them in the list. This contention of the plaintiff appears to be correct. Mr. Dudhat appearing for the defendants has not been able to point out that the plaintiff claimed these articles in the plaint. This item of Rs. 5,500 will, therefore, have to be knocked out from the valuation of the learned Registrar. This by itself will reduce the valuation by the Registrar from Rs. 30,336.75 to Rs. 24,836.75, which would bring it within the jurisdiction of the Bombay City Civil Court.
6. This, however, leaves out of consideration the claim of the plaintiff in prayer (b) for Rs. 3,500 as arrears of licence fees. If this is added, the claim would again exceed Rs. 25,000. It is for this reason that the plaintiff presented the draft amendment at page 103 of the paper-book whereby she intended to abandon two parts of her claim, namely, recovery of 44 articles covered by list No. 2 valued at Rs. 2,416.00 and a sum of Rs. 1200 out of the claim of Rs. 3,500 for arrears of licence fees covered by prayer (b). The abandoning of these two parts of her claim would have brought the suit within the jurisdiction of the City Civil Court. This amendment was, however, not allowed on the ground that if the Court had no jurisdiction to entertain the suit, it would have no jurisdiction to entertain an application to amend the plaint.
7. I have examined the draft amendment and I find that it was not necessary for the plaintiff to amend the plaint in terms thereof. The only purpose of the amendment was to abandon a part of her claim. Order 23, Rule 1(1) of the CPC provides that at any time after the institution of a suit, the plaintiff may abandon a part of his claim. The plaintiff was, therefore, within her right to abandon a part of her claim. This did not require any amendment of the plaint or any permission of the Court. She could have done so voluntarily by a unilateral act of herself. She could have made a statement to the Court and the Court would normally record the statement and proceed to try the suit with regard to the remaining part of the claim. The draft amendment should actually, have been treated as such statement. Unfortunately the provisions of O. 23, R. 1(1) of the CPC do not appear to have occurred to the plaintiff's Advocate and in fairness to the learned Judge I must say that they, were not pointed out to him.
8. Mr. Dudhat has argued before me that once the learned Registrar had made a report and according to that report even if Rs. 5,500 are taken out of the valuation, the claim in suit would still exceed Rs. 25,000, the Court would, therefore, have no jurisdiction over the suit and was therefore, not competent even to record a statement of the plaintiff abandoning a part of the claim. I am afraid, this contention is not correct. After the report the Court has to hear the parties on the report and the objections to it and to give a finding on the valuation and jurisdiction. As long as the Court has not given a finding that it had no jurisdiction and the plaint should be returned for presentation to the proper Court, it is seized of the matter because the Court has the right to decide the question of its own jurisdiction even if the decision ultimately be that it has no jurisdiction. As long as the Court is seized of the matter, it is open to a party at any time to abandon a part of the claim by a unilateral act by making a statement to that effect which the Court must record if thereafter the suit is within its jurisdiction, the Court should proceed to hear it. If this position were not correct, it would only mean that the Court must make an order returning the plaint for presentation to the proper Court and the plaintiff must withdraw the plaint, amend it by abandoning a part of his claim and represent it to the same Court. The only consequence of such procedure would be that the suit must be numbered as a new suit and under the conditions prevailing to-day be heard after another six years and if evidence has already been recorded, as it has been done in this case, the suit must be re-tried. From the words of Order 23, Rule 1(1) I do not think that such consequence is inevitable. Order 2, Rule 2(2) is not the only provision in the Code of Civil Procedure for voluntary relinquishment of claims or parts of claims. In my opinion, before the Court had passed an order returning the plaint for presentation to the proper Court, it was open to the plaintiff to abandon any part of her claim under Order 23, Rule 1(1) of the CPC, so as to bring it within the jurisdiction of the Court. In such even it would not be necessary for the Court to return the plaint to the plaintiff for presentation to the proper Court. This is the procedure that the learned Judge ought to have adopted and since he has not done so, his order must be set aside. Mr. Varghese on behalf of the plaintiff has made such statement before me abandoning the parts of his claim covered by the draft amendment at page 103.
9. Mr. Varghese has also taken up a contention that under Section 6(v) of the Court-fees Act, 1870, the plaintiff has to pay court-fee on the market value of the property which he is seeking to recover. According to him, as he was a licensee of the defendant No. 3 and the licence was only up to 30th April, 1965, it is the value of his right to the property on which he will have to pay court-fee and such value will not exceed Rupees 6,500 which is the amount at which the relief was originally valued, However, in view of the fact that the suit now falls within the jurisdiction of the City Civil Court, Mr. Varghese has not pressed this point and it is not necessary for me to record any finding on that point.
10. in view of what I have stated above, I remand the suit to the City Civil Court for further proceedings not inconsistent with this judgment. As the evidence has already been completed and the learned Judge before whom it was taken has retired, I direct that the mattes should be placed before some, other Judge of the City Civil Court who may proceed with the suit from the stage at which his predecessor left it under the provisions of Order 18, Rule 15 of the CPC. Costs of this appeal will be costs in the suit.
KSB
11. Suit remanded.
Alert