Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ
 

Miss Sophy Kelly v. The State Of Maharashtra

Bombay High Court
Sep 9, 1966
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This opinion analyzes the validity of certain regulations made under the Maharashtra Secondary Education Boards Act, 1965, specifically focusing on the powers of the State Board and Divisional Boards to regulate secondary education and conduct the Secondary School Certificate (S.S.C.) Examination. The dispute arose over new regulations, particularly regulation 42(2) dispensing with the progress certificate as a condition for eligibility for the S.S.C. Examination, and regulation 49(8) which removed the right of heads of secondary schools to withhold applications of candidates based on unsatisfactory academic progress. The petitioners challenged these regulations as ultra vires and unreasonable, raising issues about the extent of delegated powers and the internal autonomy of educational institutions. The court examined the statutory scheme, the nature of the regulations, and the common law rights of heads of schools in relation to the conduct of the examination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the regulations framed by the State Board under the Maharashtra Secondary Education Boards Act, 1965, have the force of law and constitute delegated legislation or are merely administrative orders.
  2. Whether regulation 42(2) and regulation 49(8) are ultra vires the powers granted to the State Board under the Act.
  3. Whether regulation 49(8) is a statutory rule or a bye-law and the implications of this classification on its validity.
  4. Whether regulation 49(8) is unreasonable and repugnant to the general law.
  5. Whether the regulation unjustifiably interferes with the common law rights of heads of secondary schools to withhold applications of candidates for the S.S.C. Examination on grounds of unsatisfactory academic progress.
  6. Whether regulation 49(8) violates the principle of equality under Article 14 of the Constitution by creating discriminatory standards between different Divisions.
  7. Whether the State Board’s regulation-making power includes the authority to override the internal disciplinary autonomy of schools.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Petitioners)

  • Regulations 42(2) and 49(8) are ultra vires because they exceed the regulation-making powers granted under the Act.
  • The regulations interfere with the main purpose of the Act, which is to maintain educational standards in secondary schools.
  • Regulation 49(8) is a bye-law and is invalid as it is unreasonable and repugnant to the general law.
  • The heads of schools have a common law right, arising from implied contractual terms, to withhold applications of students who have not made satisfactory academic progress.
  • The impugned regulation unjustifiably removes this right, thereby harming the internal autonomy of educational institutions and lowering educational standards.
  • Regulation 49(8) imposes a gratuitous and oppressive interference with the rights of heads of schools.
  • The regulation is discriminatory under Article 14 of the Constitution as it creates unequal standards between the Poona and Nagpur Divisions.

Respondent's Arguments (State Board and State Government)

  • The regulations framed under the Act have the force of law and are valid delegated legislation.
  • The Board is empowered under Section 18(f) and Section 36(2)(c) of the Act to prescribe conditions for admission to the final examination, which includes forwarding applications of candidates.
  • The right of heads of schools to withhold applications is contractual and revocable by the parent, and does not override the statutory powers of the Board.
  • The regulation 49(8) is reasonable and necessary to ensure equality and uniformity in admitting candidates to the S.S.C. Examination.
  • The difference in powers between heads of schools in different Divisions arises from historical and geographical reasons and is not discriminatory.
  • The Board’s regulation-making power extends to carrying out the general purposes of the Act, including maintaining academic standards.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Kruse v. Johnson [1898] 2 Q.B 91 Definition and validity criteria of bye-laws; reasonableness as a test for validity. Used to distinguish between statutory rules and bye-laws; helped establish that the regulations under the Act are bye-laws subject to reasonableness review.
Mulchand Gulabchand v. Mukund, 1951 54 Bom. L.R 285 Distinction between statutory rules and bye-laws; statutory rules not subject to unreasonableness challenge. Supported the view that the regulations under the Act are bye-laws and can be challenged on grounds of unreasonableness.
Dukhwram Gupta v. Co-op. Agri. Assocn, [1960] A.I.R M.P 273 Approval of distinction between statutory rules and bye-laws and the applicability of reasonableness test. Reaffirmed the approach that the court can consider reasonableness of the bye-laws under the Act.
Powell v. May, [1946] 1 K.B 330 Bye-laws repugnant to general law are invalid; forbidding lawful common law acts is valid if intra vires. Supported the conclusion that the impugned regulation is not repugnant to general law as it forbids what was lawful at common law but within the regulation-making authority.
Rev. Fr. Joseph v. State, [1958] A.I.R Kerala 290 Governmental control over aided schools via rules without statutory limitations. Distinguished as not applicable because the present Act involves statutory limitations unlike the Travancore Education Code.
P.R Jodh v. A.L Pande, [1965] 2 S.C.R 713 Legislative enactments or valid rules can extensively interfere with management rights of educational institutions. Accepted principle that legislative or statutory rules can override common law rights.
Chief Inspector of Mines v. Lala Karan Chand Thapar, [1962] 1 S.C.R 9 Regulations made by Government under statute can have force of statutory rules. Distinguished because the present regulations are bye-laws, not statutory rules.
Wicks v. Director of Public Prosecutions, [1947] A.C 362 Emergency regulations treated as having effect of enactments. Distinguished on facts; not applied to the bye-laws under the Act.
Anant Prasad Lakshminivas Generiwal v. State of Andhra Pradesh, [1963] Supp. 1 S.C.R 844 Geographical classification on historical basis is not discriminatory under Article 14. Applied to uphold difference in regulations between Poona and Nagpur Divisions as non-discriminatory.
Narayanaswamy v. Krishnamurthi, [1958] A.I.R Mad. 343 Interpretation of powers conferred by statute and regulations. Referenced in argument but not accepted as justifying broad regulation-making power of the Board.
Dr. Indramani Pyardal Gupta v. W.R Nathu, [1963] 1 S.C.R 721 Scope of legislative interference in management of educational institutions. Referenced in argument; principle accepted that legislative enactment can interfere but subject to limits.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court began by analyzing the statutory scheme of the Maharashtra Secondary Education Boards Act, 1965, emphasizing its limited objective to regulate “certain matters” pertaining to secondary education rather than the entire domain. It examined the composition, powers, and duties of the State Board and Divisional Boards, noting that the Board’s powers to make regulations are confined to carrying into effect the provisions of the Act.

The Court rejected the argument that the regulations were mere administrative orders without the force of law, holding that the regulations made under the Act have the force of law and are enforceable judicially.

On the ultra vires challenge, the Court distinguished between the rights of the heads of schools under implied contractual terms and the statutory powers of the Board. It recognized that heads of schools have a common law right to withhold applications of students who have not made satisfactory academic progress, a right exercised historically and recognized in practice. This right is contractual and binding on pupils and guardians but can be overridden by valid regulations.

However, the Court found no express provision in the Act empowering the Board to compel heads of schools to forward applications of all candidates regardless of academic progress. The power under Section 18(f) to prescribe conditions for admission to the final examination allows the Board to impose conditions but does not itself create a right for students to appear for the examination. The Court held that regulation 49(8), which removes the right of heads of schools to withhold applications, is not supported by the Act and is ultra vires.

Regarding the nature of the regulations, the Court analyzed authoritative definitions and concluded that the regulations under the Act are bye-laws rather than statutory rules. This classification is significant because bye-laws are subject to judicial review for reasonableness, whereas statutory rules generally are not.

On the issue of reasonableness, the Court applied established tests from case law, observing that regulation 49(8) amounts to a gratuitous and oppressive interference with the rights of heads of schools. It noted that the Board failed to appreciate the beneficial disciplinary purpose of the heads of schools’ right to withhold applications and that the regulation would likely lower educational and disciplinary standards, particularly harming better schools maintaining higher standards.

The Court rejected the argument that the regulation was discriminatory under Article 14, holding that differences between Divisions arise from historical and geographical reasons and do not constitute unjustified discrimination.

In a concurring opinion, the Court further elaborated that the State Board is a statutory body deriving powers exclusively from the Act and cannot exercise inherent powers. It emphasized an implied limitation that regulations made by the Board in relation to the final examination must not interfere with the teaching function and internal autonomy of schools. The impugned regulation was held to adversely affect teaching and discipline, thus exceeding the Board’s regulatory powers.

The concurring opinion also discussed the historical purpose of school recognition, which is to ensure minimum educational standards, and found that compelling schools to lower their standards under threat of withdrawal of recognition is not authorized by the Act.

Overall, the Court held that regulation 49(8) is ultra vires the regulation-making powers of the State Board and is manifestly unreasonable.

Holding and Implications

Regulation 49(8) is declared ultra vires and invalid. The respondents are directed not to enforce this regulation.

The direct effect of this decision is to preserve the common law right of heads of secondary schools to withhold applications of students who have not made satisfactory academic progress, thereby maintaining the internal autonomy of schools in disciplining students and upholding educational standards. The ruling clarifies the limited scope of the State Board’s regulation-making powers under the Maharashtra Secondary Education Boards Act, 1965, emphasizing that regulations must not encroach upon the teaching function and disciplinary autonomy of schools. No new precedent beyond the interpretation of the Act and the invalidation of the specific regulation has been established.

Show all summary ...

Tarkunde, J.:— After setting out the facts, his Lordship proceeded]: According to its preamble the object of the Act is “to regulate certain matters pertaining to secondary education in the State of Maharashtra and for other purposes hereinafter appearing.” It will be noticed that on the one hand the object of the Act is not confined, like that of the Bombay Secondary School Certificate Examination Act of 1948, to the holding and conducting of the S.S.C Examination and prescribing courses of studies for the examination, and that on the other hand the object of the Act is not so wide as that of the Madhya Pradesh Secondary Education Act of 1955 which was “to establish a Board to regulate secondary education in Madhya Pradesh.” The present Act is designed to regulate “certain matters” pertaining to secondary education and not to regulate secondary education generally. Section 2(1) of the Act defines the term “recognised by a Divisional Board” with reference to a secondary school as meaning “recognised by a Divisional Board for the purposes of admission to the privileges of that Board.” The term “secondary education” is defined in s. 2(o) as meaning

“such general, technical, vocational or special education…which is designed to meet the needs of the period of adolescence and which follows immediately primary education and precedes immediately education controlled by Universities established by law in India.”

2. Section 3 provides for the establishment of the State Board and the three Divisional Boards, and ss. 4 to 17 define the constitution of these Boards and provide for their mode of functioning. Of these sections, s. 5 deals with constitution of the State Board. It shows that the Board is to consist of 44 members of whom 8 are officials and the rest non-officials. Most of the non-official members, however, are nominees of the State Government. Out of the 44 members of the Board, 35 are nominated by the State Government and 9 are elected, 6 by each of the University in the State, 2 by the Legislative Assembly and 1 by the Legislative Council. Section 18 defines the powers and duties of the State Board. Under s. 18(a) one of the functions of the Board is to advise the State Government on matters of policy relating to secondary education in general. Under s. 18(b) the Board can lay down guiding principles for determining curricula and syllabi for the entire secondary course, and to determine the curricula and detailed syllabi for the final examination. Section 18(c) relates to recommendations of text-books. Under s. 18(d) the Board can prescribe standard requirements in respect of staff, buildings, furniture, equipment, stationary and other things required for secondary schools. Section 18(f) is important for our present purpose. It empowers the Board “to prescribe conditions for admission to the final examination, for regular and private candidates”. Under s. 18(1) the Board can call for any information from any secondary school recognised by a Divisional Board “to ensure maintenance of academic standards in secondary education.” Section 18(m) empowers the Board to recommend measures to promote physical, moral and social welfare of students in institutions recognised by the Divisional Boards, and to prescribe conditions of their residence and discipline. Section 18(t) empowers the Board “to make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act.” Under s. 18(v) the Board can “exercise such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred or imposed on it by or under this Act,” Under s. 18(w) the Board can “do all such acts and things as may be necessary to carry out the purposes of this Act.” Then s. 19 defines the powers and duties of a Divisional Board. Under s. 19(f) one of the functions of a Divisional Board is “to conduct in the area of its jurisdiction the final examination on behalf of the State Board.” Under s. 19(h) a Divisional Board admits candidates for the final examination “according to the regulations made by the State Board in this behalf.” Section 19(m) empowers a Divisional Board “to generally evaluate the performance of students in all examinations in secondary schools including the final examination and make necessary recommendations to the State Board in that behalf.” Under s. 19(n) a Divisional Board has a power “to grant recognition to secondary schools or withdraw the same in the prescribed manner.” Under s. 19(o) a Divisional Board can call for any information from a recognised secondary school “to ensure maintenance of academic standard”, and to withdraw recognition of schools who failed to maintain “the required academic standard”. Under s. 19(q) a Divisional Board is authorised “to require institutions recognised by it and the Education Department to extend their co-operation in the conduct of the final examination.” Section 34 gives power to the State Government to issue to the State Board such directions consistent with the Act as it may think fit, Section 36 relates to the power of the State Board to make regulations. Sub-section (1) of s. 36 lays down that the State Board may make regulations “for the purposes of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act.” Sub-section (2) of s. 36 enlists the particular topics on which such regulations may be made without prejudice to the generality of the power granted by sub-s. (1). The topic mentioned under s. 36(2)(c) is “the admission of candidates to the final examinations and conditions governing such admission.” The topic under s. 36(2)(f) is “the arrangements for the conduct of final examinations by the Divisional Boards and publication of results.” Sub-section (3) of s. 36 provides that no regulation made under this section shall have effect until the same has been sanctioned by the State Government. As already mentioned, s. 37 lays down that the first regulations shall be made by the State Government and that they shall continue to be in force until new regulations are duly made and sanctioned under s. 36. Section 38 empowers the State Board to make bye-laws “consistent with this Act and the regulations made thereunder” for the purpose of providing for such matters as the procedure to be followed at the meetings of the State Board and the Divisional Boards, the compensatory allowance which may be drawn by members of the Boards and other matters solely concerning the Boards and their Committees. By s. 40 the Bombay Act of 1948 and the Madhya Pradesh Act of 1951, which have been referred to above, were repealed. The old regulation 42 framed by the State Government having been replaced by the new regulation 42 framed by the Board, the attack of Mr. Palkhivala at the resumed hearing was directed towards cl. (2) of the new regulation 42 which dispensed with the progress certificate as one of the conditions of eligibility of candidates for the S.S.C Examination and cl. (8) of regulation 49 which purported to take away the right of heads of secondary schools to withhold the applications of candidates who fail to make satisfactory academic progress in the final year. One of the arguments advanced by Mr. Palkhivala in this behalf can be dealt with separately from the rest of his arguments. This argument was not pursued by him on the ground that it was unnecessary to do so, but was not formally given up. He argued that the powers which have been granted under the Act to the State Board and the Divisional Boards are powers of delegated administration and not of delegated legislation, and that therefore the regulations framed by the State Board cannot impose any obligations or interfere with any rights where such imposition or interference is not expressly provided for by the Act, The expression “delegated administration” used by Mr. Palkhivala was perhaps not an appropriate one. The Legislature being not an administrative body, the conferment of administrative powers under an enactment cannot be looked upon as an act of delegation. However, what Mr. Palkhivala meant was that the regulations which the State Board was empowered to make under the Act are in the nature of administrative orders and cannot have the force of law. We do not find it, possible to accept this argument. The regulations made under the Act are capable of being enforced by judicial means and this implies that the regulations have the force of law. For instance, one of the regulations is to the effect that a student who gets 35 per cent marks in each subject at the S.S.C Examination is to be declared by the Divisional Board as having succeeded in the examination. There can be little doubt that if a student gets the requisite number of marks and is not shown to have succeeded in the examination, he or his guardian can adopt appropriate judicial means to require the Divisional Board to declare him as having succeeded in the examination. Instances of this type can be multiplied. We are accordingly of the view that the regulations made under the Act have the force of law.

3. The other arguments of Mr. Palkhivala can be summarised under the following heads:

(a) the new regulation 42(2) and regulation 49(8) are ultra vires, because

(i) they are not covered by the regulation making powers which the Act has granted to the Board, and because

(ii) they are contrary to the main purpose of the Act which is the maintenance of standards of education in secondary schools;

(b) that the said regulations are in the nature of bye-laws and not statutory rules, and are invalid, because they are

(i) unreasonable, and

(ii) repugnant to the general law;

(c) that the said regulations are discriminatory and bad under art. 14 of the Constitution as they introduce inequality between the Head Masters of secondary schools in the Poona Division and the Head Masters of secondary schools in the Nagpur Division.

4. An additional point which was taken in the petition was that the impugned regulations amount to an unreasonable encroachment on the fundamental right of the petitioners to conduct and run the business or vocation of an educational institution efficiently and in the proper interest of the pupils and were, therefore, violative of art. 19(1)(g) of the Constitution. This contention was not pressed by Mr. Palkhivala in view of the suspension of that article by art. 358 of the Constitution during the operation of the Proclamation of Emergency.

5. We pointed out to Mr. Palkhivala at an early stage of his arguments that it would not be possible for the Court to grant any relief to the petitioners in respect of their grievance about the new regulation 42(2). It was within the competence of the Board to lay down the conditions of eligibility of candidates for the S.S.C Examination. The mere fact that regulation 42 does not contain one of the conditions of eligibility (viz. the requirement of a progress certificate from the head of the school) which was found in the corresponding regulation 27 made under the earlier Bombay Act of 1948 cannot afford any legitimate ground for holding that regulation 42 is either ultra vires or unreasonable or repugnant to the general law. Regulation 42 was a fresh regulation under the present Act, and cannot be looked upon as a mere amendment of regulation 27 which was framed under the old Act. It is true that from the point of view of the petitioners the new regulation 42 had another objectionable feature. It stated in a positive form that a candidate “shall be eligible to appear for the Secondary School Certificate Examination” on fulfilling the conditions laid down in that section. Such language was probably used by the Board in order to emphasise what was expressly stated in cl. (8) of regulation 49 that the heads of secondary schools shall not be entitled to withhold the applications of candidates on any ground other than those mentioned in the new regulation 42. If, however, cl. (8) of regulation 49 is found and declared to be invalid, the new regulation 42 cannot by itself have the effect of depriving the heads of schools of the power claimed by them to withhold the applications of candidates on the ground of inadequate academic progress. By itself and in the absence of cl. (8) of regulation 49, the new regulation 42 will merely imply that the Divisional Boards shall admit all candidates whose applications have been forwarded and who are found to be eligible according to the conditions laid down in that regulation. Mr. Palkhivala accepted this view and confined his attack under the above heads to cl. (8) of regulation 49.

6. On the questions canvassed before us was whether the regulations framed under the Act were in the nature of statutory rules or bye-laws. This question is relevant in considering the second part of Mr. Palkhivala's arguments, viz. that regulation 49(8) is bad because it is unreasonable and because it is repugnant to the general law. According to Mr. Palkhivala, regulation 49(8) is ultra vires the powers of the Board irrespective of whether that regulation is looked upon as a statutory rule or a bye-law. The latter question will accordingly be considered while dealing with the second part of Mr. Palkhivala's arguments.

7. In considering whether regulation 49(8) is ultra vires the powers of the Board it is very important to know by what right the petitioners claim to be entitled to withhold the applications of candidates on the ground that their academic progress is unsatisfactory. It will be found that the vires of regulation 49(8) as well as its alleged unreasonableness depend on the existence of the above right claimed by the petitioners as heads of secondary schools. The nature, of that right was explained by Mr. Palkhivala in the course of his arguments with reference to a passage from Halsbury which will be presently quoted. When the learned Advocate General commenced his reply, he on behalf of the respondents and Mr. Sorabjee on behalf of the petitioners agreed that the nature of the right claimed by the petitioners should be specified in the form of an amendment to the petitions. Paragraph 12(aa) was accordingly added to the petitions by way of an amendment and a supplementary affidavit in reply was filed by the respondents.

8. According to the petitioners, the right claimed by them arises from the implied terms which the common law attaches to the contract to educate. These implied terms are the basis of the internal autonomy of educational institutions. In Halsbury's Laws of England, in the volume dealing with “Education”, the following portion appears under the heading “Common Law Rights and Duties” and the sub-heading “The Contract to educate” (Halsbury, Third edn., Vol. 13, p. 590, paras. 1241 and 1242).

“1241. Parents and school proprietors. In schools which are not maintained by local education authorities the relations between the parent and the proprietor of the school are governed by the terms (express or implied) of the contract for the education of the child. Subject to the express terms of the contract, there is an implied term that the proprietor shall continue to be responsible for the education of the child so long as the child's conduct does not warrant his expulsion from the school…”

“1242. Position of schoolmasters. The authority of a schoolmaster is, while it exists, the same as that of a parent. A parent, when he leaves his child with a school master, delegates to him all his own authority, so far as is necessary for the welfare of the child, and so far as is necessary to maintain discipline with regard to the child committed to the teacher's care. The delegation is revocable, and in case of conflict the authority of the parent must prevail and he may have a habeas corpus if the master detains the child against his wish. The parent undertakes that the master shall be at liberty to enforce with regard to the child the rules of the school or at all events such rules as are known to him and to which he has expressly or impliedly agreed. The master is bound to take such care of his pupils as a careful father would take of his children.”

9. Applying these principles to the case before us, it seems clear that when a parent gets his child admitted to a secondary school he undertakes that the Head Master shall be at liberty to enforce with regard to the child such rules of the school as are reasonably designed to promote the education of the child and to maintain discipline in the school. The main purpose of education in secondary schools is to prepare pupils for the S.S.C Examination. A few secondary schools in the State prepare some pupil for another examination called the Indian School Certificate Examination which has a higher standard than the S.S.C Examination. It was, however, common ground before us that only those secondary schools which teach in the English medium are allowed to prepare students for the Indian School Certificate Examinations, and that even these schools usually have a section which prepares students for the S.S.C Examination. Since the main purpose of education in secondary schools is to prepare pupils for the S.S.C Examination, it follows that the parent who gets his child admitted to a secondary school undertakes that the Head Master shall be at liberty to enforce with regard to the child such rules of discipline as are reasonably designed to prepare him for that examination. Under the implied terms of the contract the Head Master is entitled to withhold promotion of a pupil from one standard to the next, if the pupil does not show satisfactory academic progress. The same right is exercised by Head Masters in respect of pupils in the final standard by refusing to grant them leave to appear for the S.S.C Examination unless satisfactory progress is made by them. Such a rule is obviously designed to promote habits of regular and diligent study in the pupils. The Head Masters claim the right to judge the academic progress and performance of their pupils before presenting them for the S.S.C Examination, but that right results from the more basic rule enforced in the school that only those students will be presented for the S.S.C Examination who have studied regularly in the course of the year and made adequate academic progress.

10. It was averred by the petitioners, and was not denied by the learned Advocate General, that in actual practice the Head Masters in the Bombay Province exercised the right for well-nigh 100 years of presenting for the final examination only such students as were found to be fit to pass the preliminary examinations held by the schools. We have no evidence whether this practice originated in a conscious recognition of the common law rights of educational authorities, but it does appear that the practice coincided with those rights. It seems, moreover, that the right was recognized by the Bombay University in respect of the Matriculation Examination which used to be held by the University. A form of application for admission to that examination was required to be endorsed by the Head Master with a statement that the student had the “permission” of the Head Master to present himself or herself for the Matriculation Examination of the particular year. The right is still recognized by the University of Cambridge Local Examinations Syndicate which is responsible for the holding of the Indian School Certificate Examination in India and similar examinations in other parts of the world. The candidates appearing for that examination are described as having been “presented” by affiliated schools and entry forms are prescribed for “school candidates”. The settled practice which is followed in presenting candidates to the Indian School Certificate Examination has been described in an affidavit filed by the petitioners of Reverend G. Ridding, who is the Convenor of the Bombay Branch of the Council for the Indian School Certificate Examination and the Principal of the Cathedral and John Connon Boys' School in Bombay. He stated:

“In fact the Principals of the Schools are free to detain pupils who are not fit and whose academic progress was unsatisfactory and not to present them as candidates of their schools if in their bona fide judgment they so think fit and proper and are further free to withdraw even a listed candidate.”

11. It appears from the rules that the Principals of schools are required to send the applications of candidates for the Indian School Certificate Examination much in advance of the end of the academic year. They are, however, entitled to withdraw the name of a listed candidate, if by the end of the academic year they find that his progress is not satisfactory. We find that this practice is recognized by the University of Cambridge Local Examinations Syndicate itself. In the Introductory notes to their Regulations of 1962 the Syndicate stated:

“Owing to the long interval between the date of entering and the examination it sometimes happens that a school withdraws a candidate who has been duly entered, on the ground that he has not yet reached the standard required.”

12. Even in the present regulations framed under the Act, expressions have been used which indicate that the heads of secondary schools have the right to “present” candidates for the S.S.C Examination. Regulation 19(6) for instance lays down that “no secondary school which is not recognised by the Divisional Board concerned shall be permitted to present candidates for any final Examination conducted by it.” Such an expression is also used in regulation 47(1). It is safe to conclude that heads of schools have a common law right which has been recognized in practice of presenting only such of their pupils for the final examination as have shown adequate academic progress and of not presenting the others.

13. The learned Advocate General argued in this connection that the common law rights on which the petitioners rely are contractual rights, that the terms of the contract, express or implied, are only binding on the parties to the contract, and that those terms have no relevance to the public examination held by the Board. The learned Advocate General argued that the schools have no common law right to send up students for a public examination. The right to send up students for a public examination depends upon the recognition of the school by the authority which conducts the examination and the right is subject to such rules as may be made by that authority. The learned Advocate General further argued that the right of withholding the applications of candidates on the ground of want of academic progress was granted to Head Masters by law, and what was granted by law could always be taken away by law. Hence the Head Masters cannot, according to the learned Advocate General, claim any right to withhold the applications of candidates for the S.S.C Examination.

14. It appears to us that these arguments miss the point in dispute. It was not claimed on behalf of the petitioners that the implied terms of contract between the head of a school on the one hand and the pupil's guardian on the other bind any person other than the parties to the contract. The whole concept of the internal autonomy of educational institutions arises from such implied terms which are not binding on third parties. As far as the S.S.C Examination is concerned, the effect of the implied contractual terms is that a student is not entitled without the permission of his Head Master to appear for the examination unless a right to that effect is validly conferred on him id supersession of the contractual terms. The point in dispute is whether the Board has been authorised by the Legislature to grant such a right on the student in supersession of the implied contractual terms. It is not disputed that the Legislature could itself have passed a law to that effect and it is also not disputed that the Legislature could have authorised the Board to make a regulation to the same effect having the force of law.

15. In support of his argument the learned Advocate General relied on a decision of the Kerala High Court in Rev. Fr. Joseph v. State . [1958] A.I.R Kerala 290.. In that case the Court held inter alia that schools which had sought recognition and accepted aid from the State Government were bound by the extensive powers of control which the Government had given to themselves by rules made in the Travancore Education Code. That decision offers no assistance in the present case, because the Travancore Education Code was a body of executive instructions having no statutory limitations. It is obvious that in the absence of any statute regulating the powers of the Government to grant aid to schools, the Government can make any rules to control the management of schools which seek and accept Government aid, provided those rules do not violate any fundamental right guaranteed by the Constitution. The learned Advocate General also relied on certain passages from the opinion given by the Supreme Court in In re The Kerala Education Bill, 19572, and the decisions of the Supreme Court in P.R Jodh v. A.L Pande . [1965] 2 S.C.R 713., to show that extensive interference in the right of management of educational institutions can be brought about by a legislative enactment or by rules validly made thereunder. That position, however, is not disputed by the petitioners.

16. It was further argued by the learned Advocate General that the Head Master's authority under the implied terms of the contract to educate a pupil is revocable at the instance of the parent, and that the Head Master cannot therefore claim, on the basis of such authority, a right to disallow the pupil from appearing for the final examination. We are unable to accept this argument also. In the context of the right claimed by the Head Masters in the present case, the parent can revoke the authority delegated by him to the Head Master only by withdrawing the pupil from the school. He cannot by exercising the power of revocation compel the Head Master to forward the pupil's application for the S.S.C Examination, just as he cannot in the exercise of that right compel the Head Master to promote the pupil from one standard to the next.

17. We may accordingly conclude that the heads of schools represented by the petitioners have a right, which is contractual in nature and which is binding on pupils and their guardians, of not permitting the pupils to appear for the S.S.C Examination if the Head Masters find that the pupils have failed to make adequate progress, and that this right is capable of being overridden by a valid regulation.

18. That leads us to the question whether the Board in the present case was authorised by the Act to make regulation 49(8) so as to override the above right of the heads of schools. Section 18 of the Act defines the powers of the Board and the only provision of that section which directly relates to this topic is contained in cl. (f). Clause (f) of s. 18 empowers the Board “to prescribe conditions, for admission to the final examination, for regular and private candidates.” It was claimed by the learned Advocate General that this provision enables the Board to confer on students the right to be admitted to the final examination, on their satisfying the conditions prescribed by the Board. Now, it cannot be disputed that where a power is granted to a subordinate legislative body to impose conditions for the exercise of a right and conditions in that behalf are imposed by that body, the right in question can as a matter of course be exercised if the conditions so imposed are fulfilled. It is, however, clear that the right itself does not arise from the power to impose conditions on its exercise. It follows that if the students in the final standards of secondary schools had a right to appear for the S.S.C Examination, then on their fulfilling the conditions prescribed by the Board under s. 18(f) they would be entitled to appear, for the examination. Their right to appear for the examination cannot, however, be derived from the power given to the Board under s. 18(f). The point involved can be brought out by an illustration. Municipalities are authorised by law to impose conditions on persons who want to start certain types, of businesses in the areas of their jurisdiction. In pursuance of that power a municipality may make a bye-law that no person can construct a theatre or start a hotel without obtaining a licence, which would be given if certain conditions are fulfilled. On fulfilling those conditions any person desiring to construct a theatre or to start a hotel is entitled to get a licence from the municipality. His right to construct a theatre or to start the business of a hotel is not, however, derived from the power granted by the Act to the municipality of prescribing conditions for the exercise of that right. His right arises independently of the power granted to the municipality. We must accordingly hold that the power granted to the Board under s. 18(f) to prescribe conditions for admission of students to the final examination does not by itself enable the Board to confer on students the right to appear for the examination, if that right has been already surrendered to the heads of schools under the implied terms of the contract of education.

19. Notice must be taken in this connection of another argument advanced by the learned Advocate General. He argued that the heads of schools represented by the petitioners claim in effect the power to decide the eligibility of candidates for the S.S.C Examination, whereas the power to make that decision has been granted by the Legislature to the Board. Since the right to prescribe the conditions of eligibility of students has been granted by the Legislature to the Board the Head Masters cannot, according to the learned Advocate General, exercise the same right and override the regulation made by the Board in that behalf by withholding the applications of students wishing to appear for the examination. This argument overlooks the fact that the right claimed by the Head Masters has nothing whatever to do with the right granted by s. 18(f) to the Board. The right of the Board to prescribe conditions of eligibility arises from the Act, whereas the right of the Head Masters arises from the implied terms of the contract of education. The Board prescribes conditions of eligibility for all students wishing to appear for the examination, whereas the Head Masters make a disciplinary rule for their own students that they would be permitted to appear for the examination if they study properly and make adequate progress during the final year. There is no conflict whatever between the statutory power of the Board and the contractual right of the Head Masters.

20. A reference may then be made to s. 36(2)(c) of the Act which provides that one on the topics on which the Board may make regulations is “the admission of candidates to the final examinations and conditions governing such admission.” It will be noticed that the clause has two parts: (1) admission of candidates to the final examination and (2) conditions governing such admission. The second part of this clause corresponds to the power granted on the Board by s. 18(f). Mr. Palkhivala argued, and in our opinion rightly, that the first part of cl. (c) of s. 36(2) is intended to cover such procedural matters as the date before which candidates must apply for admission to the examination, the authority to whom the applications should be sent, and so forth, and that regulations affecting rights of admission to the examination can only be made under the second part of that clause, to the extent allowed by s. 18(f). This follows from the fact that sub-s. (1) of s. 36 empowers the Board to make regulations “for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the Act” and the relevant provision in this connection is contained in s. 18(f). This position was not contested by the learned Advocate General, who, however, argued that the forwarding of applications of candidates by the heads of schools is merely a matter of procedure and can be covered by the first part of cl. (c) of sub-s. (2). The learned Advocate General argued that it was administratively convenient to the Board to have the applications of all candidates forwarded through the heads of recognised schools. The learned Advocate General supported this argument by referring to several regulations. He also referred to s. 19(q) which provides that a Divisional Board can require institutions recognised by it (i.e recognised schools) to extend their co-operation in the conduct of the final examination. Now, if the heads of schools had no common law right to decide which of their students should be permitted to appear for the final examination, the forwarding of the applications of candidates by these heads of schools could have been looked upon as a purely procedural matter. In that case, regulation 49(8) which provides that heads of schools shall not withhold the applications of candidates who have fulfilled the conditions prescribed by the Board, could have been held to be covered by the regulation making power specified in s. 36(2)(c). We have, however, found that the heads of schools have a substantive right of withholding the applications of their pupils for want of academic progress, and regulation 49(8) cannot therefore be looked upon as a mere matter of procedure covered by the first part of cl. (c) of s. 36(2).

21. We must accordingly hold that there is no express provision in the Act which enables the Board to compel the heads of schools to forward the applications of all candidates irrespective of their academic performance.

22. The learned Advocate General, however, argued that in the absence of an express provision to that effect, the Board has the power of making regulations for carrying out the general purposes of the Act and not merely the purposes of its specific provisions, and that regulation 49(8) can be held to have been made in the exercise of that power. In support of this argument the learned Advocate General referred to s. 18(v) which provided that the Board can “exercise such other powers and perform such other duties as may be conferred or imposed on it by or under this Act.” The learned Advocate General argued that the expression “under this Act” means under the regulations made under the Act. In support of this argument he relied on the decision of the Madras High Court in Narayanaswamy v. Krishnamurthi . [1958] A.I.R Mad. 343. and the decision of Supreme Court in Dr. Indramani Pyardal Gupta v. W.R Nathu . [1963] 1 S.C.R 721.. The learned Advocate General further argued that under s. 36(1) the Board has been empowered to make regulations “for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act,” that one such provision is contained in s. 18(v) referred to above, and that, therefore, the Board has the power to make regulations for carrying into effect not only the provisions, but also the general purposes of the Act. He further contended that the general purposes of the Act include the purpose of regulating secondary education, and that, therefore, regulation 49(8) was within the regulation making powers of the Board. We must observe that we found this line of argument very confusing. In the first place, the purpose of the Act, as stated in the preamble, is “to regulate certain matters pertaining to secondary education in the State of Maharashtra and for other purposes hereinafter appearing.” It is clearly not the purpose of the Act to regulate secondary education in all its aspects. What matters pertaining to secondary education are intended to be regulated, and what other purposes are intended to be fulfilled, can be ascertained only from the provisions of the Act. Moreover, s. 18(t) empowers the Board “to make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act,” and s. 36(7) also says that “the State Board may make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act.” It follows that the Board cannot assume power to make regulations on a topic which is not covered by any of the provisions of the Act. We agree that the expression “under this Act” in s. 18(v) means under the regulations made under the Act. But it seems to us clear that the power of the Board to make regulations cannot be derived from or extended by what is stated in s. 18(v). This is because, in the first place, s. 18(v) is preceded by s. 18(t) which, as already stated, provides that the Board may make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of this Act. Section 18(v) enables the Board to exercise such ‘other’ powers and such ‘other duties as may be conferred or imposed on it by or under this Act. Obviously the powers and duties referred to in s. 18(v) are other than the powers and duties referred to in the earlier provisions including cl. (t) of s. 18. There is also another reason why we cannot accept the argument of the learned Advocate General. His argument implies that the power of the Board to make regulations can be derived either from the provisions of the Act or from the regulations made under the Act. It appears to us obvious that the power to make regulations cannot be derived from the regulations themselves. It can only be derived from the provisions of the Act. It is not difficult to ascertain what type of powers and what type of duties are meant to be covered by the expression “under this Act” occurring in s. 18(v). The Board may provide by regulations that it may grant exemptions in certain eases or may give special awards and certificates, and so forth. Such powers and duties, granted to or imposed upon the Board under the regulations, would be covered by the expression “under this Act” in s. 18(v).

23. It was also argued by the learned Advocate General that the Board has the power to prescribe conditions for the recognition of schools, that one such condition is found in regulation 49(5), and that therefore the regulation cannot be ultra vires of the powers of the Board. The Act, however, does not say that the Board can prescribe any conditions, it likes on schools which seek recognition from one of the Divisional Boards. Substantial powers have been granted to the Board by cls. (b) to (e) of s. 18 of controlling certain matters relating to the upkeep and functioning of secondary schools. Neither these provisions, nor any other provision of the Act, empower the Board to interfere with the right of the heads of secondary schools to make and enforce disciplinary rules for ensuring diligent study on the part of their students. The Board cannot lawfully interfere in the internal autonomy of secondary schools, beyond what is allowed by the specific provisions of the Act, under the garb of prescribing conditions for the recognition of these schools.

24. We are accordingly of the view that regulation 49(8) is not covered by any of the regulation making powers of the Board and is ultra vires.

25. The second ground urged by Mr. Palkhivala in support of his contention that regulation 49(8) is ultra vires the powers of the Board was that the regulation is calculated to defeat the purpose of the Act which is the maintenance of standards of education in secondary schools. In appreciating this argument we must assume that the Board had the power to make a regulation on the topic covered by regulation 49(8) and we must consider on that assumption whether that regulation is ultra vires on the ground that it tends to defeat the main purpose of the Act as stated above. We will have to notice the arguments advanced by Mr. Palkhivala in this connection in deciding whether regulation 49(8), being a bye-law, is invalid on the ground of unreasonableness. If we were to assume, however, that regulation 49(8) is a statutory rule and not a bye-law, that its reasonableness cannot be examined by the Court, and also that it is covered by the rule making powers of the Board, we do not think it would be right to hold that the regulation is ultra vires on the ground that, in our view, it is contrary to one of the main purposes of the Act which is the maintenance of academic standards in secondary schools. Hardly any arguments were addressed before us in support of this submission, apart from arguments relating to the alleged unreasonableness of the regulation which we will presently notice.

26. We will next turn to the question whether regulation 49(8) is invalid, because it is unreasonable and because it is repugnant to the general law. In dealing with this question, we have first to consider whether the regulations made under the Act are bye-laws or statutory rules.

27. The distinction between these two types of subordinate legislation is well-known. Where an Act lays down the general policy of the Legislature and delegates to some authority the function of filling in the details of that policy, the regulations made by that authority are in the nature of statutory rules. Such power is usually granted by the Legislature to the executive, but where the matter relates to judicial procedure the power is sometimes given to the judiciary. On the other hand, where the Legislature provides for the constitution of a local authority or a statutory Corporation, defines its purpose, and empowers it to make provisions for carrying into effect the purpose for which it was constituted, the regulations made by the local authority or statutory Corporation are in the nature of bye-laws.

28. A bye-law was explained by Lord Russell of Killowen in the well known case Kruse v. Johnson . [1898] 2 Q.B 91., The Court was concerned in that case with the validity of a bye-law made by a county council under the Local Government Act of 1888. The learned Judge observed (p. 96):

“…A by-law, of the class we are here considering, I take to be an ordinance affecting the public, or some portion of the public, imposed by some authority clothed with statutory powers ordering something to be done or not to be done, and accompained by some sanction or penalty for its non-observance.”

29. It will be noticed that in that case the authority which made the bye-law had been set up by a statute. The term was also defined in Odgers on the Common Law. The learned authors say (1927 edn., p. 92):

“The term by-law includes any order, rule or regulation made by any local authority or statutory corporation subordinate to Parliament.”

30. A bye-law was thus explained by Lindley, L.J in London Association of Ship-owners and Brokers v. London and India Docks Joint Committee . [1892] 3 Ch. 242. (p. 252):

“…A by-law is not an agreement, but a law binding on all persons to whom it applies, whether they agree to be bound by it or not. All regulations made by a corporate body, and intended to bind not only themselves and their officers and servants, but members of the public who come within the sphere of their operation, may be properly called ‘by-laws’,…”

31. A Division Bench of our Court considered the nature of a bye-law as distinguished from a statutory rule in Mulchand Gulabchand v. Mukund . 1951 54 Bom. L.R 285.. After pointing out that a statutory rule cannot be challenged in a Court of law on the ground of unreasonableness, Chagla, C.J delivering the judgment of the Division Bench observed (p. 287):

“…Now, there is a clear distinction between statutory rules and by-laws. By-laws are usually framed by corporations under their inherent powers in order to carry out the purposes of the corporation or they are framed by public authorities set up by Parliament, and as it is left to the corporations or the public authorities to frame these by-laws and carry out theirpurposes, the Courts have retained certain amount of control over the by-laws by considering their reasonableness. But statutory rules stand on entirely different footing. Parliament or Legislature, instead of incorporating the rules into the statute itself, ordinarily authorises Government to carry out the details of the policy laid down by the Legislature by framing the rules under the statute, and once the rules are framed, they are incorporated in the statute itself and become part of the statute, and the rules must be governed by the same principles as the statute itself. And, therefore, although a by-law may be challenged on the ground that it is unreasonable, a statutory rule cannot be so challenged.”

32. These observations were quoted with approval by a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in Dukhwram Gupta v. Co-op. Agri. Assocn . [1960] A.I.R M.P 273..

33. On these authorities it is clear that the regulations under the present Act are in the nature of bye-laws and not statutory rules. The Legislature in this case constituted the State Board, defined the scope of its powers and duties, and gave it authority to make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the Act.

34. The learned Advocate General argued that the regulations made under the Act are statutory rules and not bye-laws. According to him, there is no distinction in principle between the two, and that the nomenclature given by the Legislature is determinative of the category in which the provisions fall. The learned Advocate General relied on the definition of the term ‘rule’ in s. 3(39) of the Bombay General Clauses Act, 1904 which says:

“‘rule’ shall mean a rule made in exercise of a power conferred by any enactment, and shall include a regulation made as a rule under any enactment.”

35. According to the learned Advocate General, therefore, the fact that the Legislature empowered the Board to make “regulations” meant that those regulations were “rules” and had the force of statutory rules. A reference was then made by the learned Advocate General to the decision of the Supreme Court in Chief Inspector of Mines v. Lala Karan Chand Thapar . [1962] 1 S.C.R 9.. In that case the “Coal Mines Regulations” made by the Government under the Mines Act were treated as statutory rules. A reference was also made to the decision of the House of Lords in Wicks v. Director of Public Prosecutions . [1947] A.C 362., where “the Defence (General) Regulations” made under the Emergency Powers (Defence) Act, 1939, were held to have the effect of an enactment. The learned Advocate General urged that the question whether a provision amounts to a statutory rule or a bye-law cannot depend upon whether it was made by the Executive, and referred in this connection to ss. 122 and 129 of the Code of Civil Procedure which confer extensive powers on High Courts to make rules regarding the procedure to be followed in civil cases. It was further argued by the learned Advocate General that the present Act requires the State Government to make the first regulations, that the legal status of these first regulations cannot be different than that of the regulations which may be subsequently made by the Board, and that the first regulations made by the State Government as well as subsequent regulations made by the Board should both be held to have the effect of statutory rules.

36. These contentions of the learned Advocate General do not persuade us to hold that the regulations under the Act are statutory rules and not bye-laws. The definition of the word “rule” in s. 3(39) of the Bombay General Clauses Act, 1904, does not advance the argument of the learned Advocate General in any way, because it does not say that every regulation is a rule, but says that only a regulation which is “made as a rule” is a rule. Whether regulation 49(8) was “made as a rule” is the very question which we have to answer, and this question is not answered by a recourse to s. 3(39) of the Bombay General Clauses Act, 1904. The reference to the two cases mentioned above is also of no assistance, because in those cases the regulations were obviously in the nature of statutory rules. That the term “regulation” is not confined to statutory rules can be easily demonstrated. In Craies on Statute Law, Sixth edn., (p. 298), delegated legislation has been thus classified:

“Delegated legislation falls under two main heads:

(a) Statutory instruments,

(b) By-laws or regulations made—

(i) by authorities concerned with local Government;

(ii) by public corporations or societies clothed with statutory or common law powers.”

37. In this instance the learned author has used the term regulation as having the same meaning as a bye-law. We have already quoted from Odgers on the Common Law (1927 edn., p. 92) where the term bye-law has been defined as including “any order, rule or regulation” made by any local authority or statutory corporation subordinate to Parliament. That certain types of statutory rules are sometimes made by the judiciary does not require us to hold that there is no difference in principle between a bye-law and a rule, or that the Legislature can give the effect of a bye-law or a rule to any provision by mere nomenclature. In Craies on Statute Law, “Rules made by Judges” have been put into a separate category, distinct from bye-laws (Sixth edn., p. 318). In Salmond on Jurisprudence (Eleventh edn., p. 142) it has been stated that there are five chief forms of subordinate legislation: (1) Colonial, (2) Executive, (3) Judicial, (4) Municipal, and (5) Autonomous. The present regulations fall in the fifth category of autonomous subordinate legislation. It seems clear that municipal and autonomous subordinate legislation has the character of bye-laws and the rest of rules. It is true that the first regulations under the present Act are to be made by the State Government, but they partake of the character of bye-laws as they are liable to be replaced by regulations made by the Board. We are accordingly of the view that regulation 49(8) is a bye-law and not a statutory rule.

38. For appreciating the arguments advanced for the petitioners against regulation 49(8) as a bye-law, the following passage in Halsbury's Laws of England on the validity of bye-laws is relevant (Third edn., Vol. 24, p. 515, para 948):

“Four elements are essential to the validity of a bye-law; it must be intra vires the local authority who makes it; it must not be repugnant to the law of England; it must be certain and positive it its terms, and it must be reasonable.”

39. Before us regulation 49(8) was challenged on two of these grounds, viz. that it is repugnant to the general law, and that it is unreasonable. In considering the arguments advanced on behalf of the petitioners in this connection we will assume that regulation 49(8) is covered by the topics on which the Board has been empowered to make regulations and is intra vires. On that assumption, we will first consider whether that regulation is unreasonable.

40. The grounds on which a bye-law may be held to be unreasonable were thus stated by Lord Russell of Killowen in Kruse v. Johnson (p. 99):

“…But unreasonable in what sense? If, for instance, they (the bye-laws) were found to be partial and unequal in their operation as between different classes; if they were manifestly unjust; if they disclosed bad faith; if they involved such oppressive or gratuitous interference with the rights of those subject to them as could find no justification in the minds of reasonable men, the Court might well say, ‘Parliament never intended to give authority to make such rules; they are unreasonable and ultra vires.’ But it is in this sense and in this sense only, as I conceive that the questions of unreasonableness can properly be regarded.”

41. In Halsbury, Vol. 24, Third edn., p, 517, para 952 the same test has been given of the unreasonableness of a bye-law:

“Byelaws must be reasonable. A bye law to be valid must be reasonable. Unless it is manifestly unjust, capricious, inequitable or partial in its operation, or involves oppressive gratutious interference with the rights of those subject to it, the question of its reasonableness is one to be decided by the authority making it…”

42. On behalf of the petitioners regulation 49(8) was claimed to be unreasonable on the ground that it amounts to a gratuitous as well as an oppressive interference with the rights of the heads of schools. According to the petitioners, the regulation is not only gratuitous in the sense that it serves no useful purpose, but it is positively harmful as it is calculated to lower the standards of education and discipline in secondary schools. The non-observance of the requirements of regulation 49(8) is likely to lead to the cancellation of the recognition of a secondary school, for that is the only sanction behind that regulation. Recognition for the purpose of presenting candidates to the S.S.C Examination is necessary for the very existence of a secondary school. It was accordingly claimed that the imposition, by the threat of withdrawal of recognition, of a bye-law which required the heads of secondary schools to surrender their right of enforcing a beneficial disciplinary rule, was clearly oppressive, besides being-gratuitous.

43. In dealing with this issue it is necessary to consider a connected question which was raised before us. The question was whether we should presume, till the contrary is proved, that the impugned regulation is reasonable and that it deserves to be supported as far as possible. The following observations of Lord Russell of Killowen, C.J in Kruse v. Johnson are relevant in this connection (p. 99):

“…the great majority of the cases in which the question of by-laws has been discussed are not cases of by-laws of bodies of a public representative character entrusted by Parliament with delegated authority, but are for the most part cases of railway companies, dock companies, or other like companies, which carry on their business for their own profit, although incidentally for the advantage of the public. In this class of case it is right that the Courts should jealously watch the exercise of these powers, and guard against their unnecessary or unreasonable exercise to the public disadvantage. But, when the Court is called upon to consider the by-laws of public representative bodies clothed with the ample authority which I have described, and exercising that authority accompanied by the checks and safeguards which have been mentioned, I think the consideration of such by-laws ought to be approached from a different standpoint. They ought to be supported if possible. They ought to be, as has been said, ‘benevolently’ interpreted, and credit ought to be given, to those who have to administer them that they will be reasonably administered.”

44. The Board in the present case is not a representative body. As stated before, 35 out of its 44 members are nominated by the State. On the other hand the Board is also not a profit-making concern. It was urged before us by Mr. Sorabjee on behalf of the petitioners that since the Board is not a representative body, the so called rule of benevolent construction referred to in the above quotation has no application in considering the reasonableness or otherwise of regulation 49(8). It appears to us that in setting up a public corporation consisting largely of specialists in a particular field the Legislature may often find that the mode of nomination is preferable to that of election. That consideration may well apply to the composition of the Board whose purpose is to advise the State Government on matters of policy relating to secondary education and to regulate certain matters pertaining to secondary education. A statement of the educational qualifications and other particulars of the members of the Board has been produced on behalf of the respondents, and it shows that 23 out of the 44 members of the Board are or have been teachers in either schools or colleges. On the whole, therefore, we think that it would be proper to approach the question of the reasonableness of the impugned regulation by assuming that the regulation is reasonable until the contrary is shown, and that it should be supported as far as possible.

45. It is necessary, however, in view of the multiplicity of the arguments advanced before us, to specify the question at issue. It is regulation 49(8) which is challenged on the ground of unreasonableness and not regulation 42(2). The question is not whether it was reasonable on the part of the Board to dispense with the progress certificate as a condition of admission of candidates to the S.S.C Examination. It was open to the Board to dispense with that condition, and yet keep intact the discretion of heads of secondary schools to present for the examination only those candidates whose academic progress and performance was in their judgment satisfactory. The question at issue is whether it was reasonable for the Board to have cast an obligation on the Head Masters to forward the applications of all candidates irrespective of their academic progress and performance.

46. It will be noticed that the question has two aspects—one relating to the rights of the Head Masters and the other to the interests of the students. We are of the view that there is not, and cannot be, any conflict between the two. The rights of the Head Masters coincide with the interests of the students. It is the duty of the Head Masters to offer proper tuition to the students, and their right to enforce such rules of discipline as would advance that purpose. Correspondingly, it is the right of the students to receive proper tuition and their duty is to study diligently and to abide by such rules of discipline as may be properly made by the Head Masters. There is no conflict between these duties and rights, because they arise from the common object of giving proper education to the students. Before us, however, the question was argued on behalf of the respondents on the supposition that there was a conflict between the rights of the Head Masters on the one hand and those of the students and their parents on the other. The fact is that the parent requires for his child a good school, which means a school having a good standard of education and proper rules of discipline. Students attending secondary schools are of immature age, and their parents as well as the Head Masters know that rules of discipline are necessary in order that they may study with diligence. It is true that some parents feel aggrieved if their children are either detained or not promoted on the ground of want of adequate progress. Such a grievance, however, does not represent a conflict between the interest of the students and their guardians on the one hand and of the Head Masters on the other.

47. It follows that the result must be the same whether the issue of reasonableness of the impugned regulation is approached from the point of view of the rights of the Head Masters or from that of the interests of the students. The former approach leads to the question “Was it reasonable for the Board to interfere with the right of the Head Masters to forward the applications of only those students who in their judgment had made adequate academic progress during the year?” The latter approach leads to the question “Was it reasonable for the Board to deprive the students of the advantage of a rule of discipline which required that no student would be presented as a candidate to the S.S.C Examination who failed to make adequate academic progress during the year?” The two questions cannot be differently answered.

48. It appears to us that the approach which was adopted by the Board on both aspects of this issue was basically wrong. On the one hand, the Board was not even aware that the Head Masters had a right at common law of disallowing their students from appearing for the S.S.C Examination on the ground of unsatisfactory progress. This is quite clear from the procedure adopted by the Board in passing the impugned regulation. The questionnaire which was issued by the Board was confined to the criteria, such as attendance and progress certificate, which were to be adopted in prescribing the conditions of admission of regular students to the final examination. It was assumed that if the requirement of a progress certificate was dispensed with, it would automatically follow that the Head Masters would have to forward the applications of all eligible candidates irrespective of their academic progress. There were in fact three alternatives before the Board—(1) to retain the progress certificate as a condition of eligibility, (2) to dispense with that condition and leave it to the discretion of the Head Masters to forward the applications of all students or to detain some of them for want of satisfactory progress, and (3) to dispense with the progress certificate and also to abrogate the right of the Head Masters to withhold the applications of their students for unsatisfactory progress. The Board did not realise that the second of these alternatives was open to it and proceeded to adopt regulation 49(8) by merely deciding that a progress certificate from the head of a secondary school should no longer be a condition for admission to the final examination. Before us also it was denied by the Board that the Head Masters had any right to detain some of their students for want of adequate progress.

49. What is worse, the approach of the Board was, in our view, basically wrong in considering the second aspect also, viz. the interests of the students. In deciding whether the progress certificate should be retained as a condition of eligibility the Board did not consider what was in the interest of the students as a whole, but virtually confined themselves to the question whether it was in the interest of the detained students that they should be detained. It appears to us that the Board failed to realise that the detention of a few students by the Head Masters was merely the result of the enforcement of a rule which was beneficial to all students and which required that they should study properly and diligently throughout the year so that their applications may be forwarded by the Head Masters. When a Head Master detained a student for want of progress, the cause of the detention was not that the student would not pass if he were allowed to appear for the S.S.C Examination. It was always possible that the student may have better luck and may pass in the S.S.C Examination despite his inadequate progress. It was also possible that the student may study better after his preliminary examination and pass the S.S.C Examination as a result of that study. The student was detained in such a case because the rule, which operated for the benefit of all students and which required that all students should make proper progress during the course of the final year, had to be enforced. The enforcement of that rule must unavoidably result in some students being prevented from appearing for the S.S.C Examination even though they might have some chance of success in that examination. The Board themselves approved of another condition which had the same purpose, the condition, namely, that only those candidates who had attended the final year in the school for 75 per cent of the days would be allowed to appear for the S.S.C Examination. There can be little doubt that if the students who had neglected to attend school for the requisite number of days are allowed to appear for the S.S.C Examination, some of them may pass out. The condition of minimum attendance has been imposed, not in the interest of those students who fail to attend for the requisite number of days, but in order that the students as a whole should be regular in their attendance. The condition of the progress certificate had the same purpose. Its purpose was not that those students who fail to make adequate progress should be detained, but that all students should study diligently and regularly throughout the year and should satisfy their Head Masters about their academic progress and performance. We are no longer concerned with whether the progress certificate should have been retained as a condition of eligibility. The point, however, is that the Board adopted the same faulty approach in deciding whether the Head Masters should be required to forward the applications of all candidates irrespective of their academic progress.

50. [His Lordship then proceeded to enumerate the main considerations which supported the petitioners' submission that regulation 49(8) amounted to a gratuitous and oppressive interference with the rights of Head Masters. After enumerating three such considerations, his Lordship continued as follows.]

51. Fourthly, the impugned regulation 49(8) is bound to operate with relatively greater harshness on the better schools which insist on maintaining high standards of education and academic performance. In such schools not only the teachers would be highly qualified, but the tests to which the students have to submit would he more strict. A student who gets 35 per cent marks in a paper in the preliminary examination of such school may easily get 50 per cent marks in the same paper in an inferior school. Since the reputation of these schools depends on the high standard maintained by them, they are bound to suffer very gravely if students in the final year are not required to prepare for any of the school tests and are allowed with impunity to become slack in their studies. The regulation will not operate with the same degree of severity on those schools in which the standards of education and discipline are comparatively low.

52. In connection with this last submission of the petitioners the learned Advocate General advanced an argument which appeared to us to be open to a serious objection. The learned Advocate General assured us that what he stated was the opinion of the Board. The learned Advocate General said that standards are to be maintained in relation to the students for whom the examination is provided and with proper regard to factors, economic, social and educational, which affect the student population. Attempts must be made to improve the economic and social conditions in the country, but at the same time the standards of examinations must be kept constantly in review. In particular, if the number of student's in secondary school increases and if social and economic conditions do not improve, a lower standard has got to be fixed for the examination. Since the maintenance of educational standards is admittedly the main responsibility of the Board, we do not appreciate how the Board can claim the right of fixing a lower standard for the S.S.C Examination if it finds that the number of students has increased and that the social and economic conditions in the State have not shown adequate improvement. The Board, in our view, has no power to consciously fix a low standard for the examination, when the Legislature has charged it with the duty of maintaining educational standards. What the learned Advocate General stated, however, does not have a direct bearing on the question before us, because he was speaking of the standard of the S.S.C Examination, and not the standard of education to be maintained in secondary schools. Even supposing the Board is entitled to reduce the standard of the S.S.C Examination, it is clearly not entitled to make regulations so as to lower the standard of education in secondary schools. The learned Advocate General added that those schools which wanted to maintain a high standard of education can present their candidates to the Indian School Certificate Examination instead of the S.S.C Examination held by the Board. That obviously is no solution. There is no reason why schools wishing to prepare students for the S.S.C Examination should be required to lower their educational standard. Moreover, it was admitted that only those secondary schools which teach in the English medium are entitled to present students to the Indian School Certificate Examination.

53. In this connection notice must be taken of another argument advanced by the learned Advocate General. He argued that the principle of equality enunciated in art. 14 of the Constitution requires that all pupils in different secondary schools who acquire a certain minimum academic standard should be able to appear for the S.S.C Examination and that it is therefore not permissible for any school to maintain a higher standard for its own students for being allowed to appear for the examination. The learned Advocate General added that if regulation 49 had left it open to the school authorities to forward or not to forward the applications of their students according to their respective school standards, the regulation would have contravened art. 14 of the Constitution. It appears to us very fortunate that we are not required to accept this argument, which would necessitate a uniform standard of dull mediocrity to be maintained in all secondary schools. The principle of non-discrimination enunciated in art. 14 does not require standards to be uniform, for diversity of standards can itself be a basis of reasonable classification. It is well known that many parents want their children to be admitted in the better type of schools. This is because what the parents want is not that their children should somehow scrape through the S.S.C Examination, but that they should succeed with distinction. The parents send their children to the better type of schools, not inspite of the higher standard of education and discipline maintained there, but because of that standard. The policy behind the impugned regulation is calculated to deprive the parents and their children of such type of schools.

54. [His Lordship after considering the arguments advanced by the Advocate General in support of regulation 49(8), concluded.]

55. Having started with the presumption that the impugned regulation is reasonable unless the contrary is shown, and that it should be supported if possible, and after having considered all the arguments in that behalf advanced by the learned Advocate General, we have come to the conclusion that the impugned regulation is manifestly unreasonable. It would be an understatement to say that it amounts to a gratuitous interference in the rights of the Head Masters. If the impugned regulation had been useless as well as harmless, it could have been characterised as gratuitous. In our view, it is fraught with great harm. It is likely to lead to a lowering of standards of education and of discipline in the final year in secondary schools. Its impact will be particularly harmful on precisely those schools which require to be recognised and encouraged, i.e schools which try to maintain high standards of education. It is also oppressive because it compels heads of schools not to act in the best interests of education, on pain of the recognition of their schools being withdrawn. The learned Advocate General impressed upon us that if two reasonable views are possible on this question, we should not hold the impugned regulation to be invalid on the ground of unreasonableness. We are of the opinion, however, that it cannot be reasonably doubted that the impugned regulation amounts to a gratuitous and oppressive interference with the rights of Head Masters. The Board appears, to have adopted the impugned regulation partly because it was not aware of the existence of the Head Masters' common law rights, and partly because it failed to see that the Head Masters' right of detention was beneficial to the students as a whole and that its justification was to be determined by assessing its impact on the general body of students, and not on that minority which comes to be detained. We must accordingly hold that regulation 49(8) is invalid on the ground that it is unreasonable.

56. It was argued by Mr. Palkhivala that regulation 49(8) is also bad on the ground that it is repugnant to the general law. We do not think that this argument is sound. What the impugned regulation does is to forbid the Head Masters from doing what they were entitled to do at the common law, viz. to withhold the applications of their students on the ground of unsatisfactory progress. A bye-law which is intra vires the powers of the authority which made it cannot be held to be invalid on the ground of its repugnancy to the general law, if it merely forbids a person from doing what he is entitled to do at common law. In Powell v. May . [1946] 1 K.B 330., Lord Goddard, C.J observed (p. 335):

“…There is no question but that a by-law which is repugnant to the general law is invalid’ but it is not so easy to determine what is covered by the word ‘repugnant’, and under what circumstances a by-law is to be held invalid on that ground. Obviously, it cannot permit that which a statute expressly forbids nor forbid that which a statute expressly permits, though it can, of course, forbid that which otherwise would be lawful at common law, otherwise no prohibitory by-law could be valid.”

57. The impugned regulation in the present case does nothing further than “forbid that which otherwise would be lawful at common law”, and cannot therefore be held to be repugnant to the general law.

58. The attack of Mr. Palkhivala on the impugned regulation on the ground of discrimination cannot also be sustained. He argued that by adopting regulation 49(8) the Board has brought about an unjustified difference in the powers and status of Heads of schools in the Poona Division as compared to the heads of schools in the Nagpur Division. Prior to the adoption of regulation 49(8) the heads of schools in the Poona Division were in a position to withhold the applications of their students for want of satisfactory progress, whereas the heads of schools in the Nagpur Division were able to assign 20 per cent of the marks in each subject of the final examination on an internal assessment of their students. By adopting regulation 49(8) the Board deprived the head? of schools in the Poona Division of the right of detention without granting them the right of internal assessment and thereby discriminated against them in comparison to the heads of schools in the Nagpur Division. In reply to this contention it was stated in the affidavit filed by the Chairman of the Board that the system of internal assessment has been prevailing in the Vidarbha area for many years, that there is no similarity in the system of detention and the system of internal evaluation, that in any case the Board is going to consider whether the system of internal evaluation which prevails in the Nagpur Division should be introduced in other parts of the State, and that this consideration is bound to take some time. It was averred that the difference in the systems of the Nagpur Division and the other Divisions is due to historical reasons, and is not discriminatory. In our view, regulation 49(8) cannot by itself be regarded as discriminatory, because it actually removes the difference which existed in the regulations applicable to the Nagpur and the Poona Divisions. Regulation 78(5), which applies to the Nagpur Division, provides that heads of secondary schools shall not withhold the applications of candidates who have fulfilled the prescribed conditions for appearing at the final examination without the previous sanction of the Divisional Chairman, and the same provision has now been introduced in the Poona Division by regulation 49(8). It is true that there is a substantial difference at present in the powers of the Head Masters in the Nagpur Division and those in the Poona Division, arising from the system of internal assessment in the Nagpur Division which is absent in the Poona Division. The system of internal assessment has been prevailing in the Nagpur Division since before the time the Yidarbha area came to be included in the Maharashtra State. In Anant Prasad Lakshminivas Generiwal v. State of Andhra Pradesh . [1963] Supp. 1 S.C.R 844., the Supreme Court found that there were two laws in force in two parts of the State of Andhra Pradesh with respect to religious endowments and that the two laws were different in many matters. The reason why two different laws on the same subject prevailed in two parts of the State was that one of the parts came to the State from the former Madras State and the other from the former Hyderabad State. The Supreme Court were informed on behalf of the State of Andhra Pradesh that steps were being taken to assimilate the laws in the two parts of the State, and to bring them under a common pattern, but that time was required for the complete assimilation of the laws. The Supreme Court held under these circumstances that the difference in the two parts of the State where the two laws on the same subject prevailed was due to “geographical classification on historical basis”, and was not discriminatory. In the present case also the difference between the Nagpur and the Poona Divisions has to be upheld on the ground of geographical classification on historical basis.

59. We accordingly find that regulation 49(8) is invalid on the ground that it is ultra vires the powers of the Board, and also on the ground that, supposing it is intra vires, it is unreasonable. Regulation 49(8) is, therefore, quashed and the respondents are directed not to enforce it.

60. [The rest of the judgment is not material to this report.]

M.V Paranjape, J.:— I respectfully agree with the conclusions and the reasonings in support of those conclusions, given in the judgment of my learned brother. But I would like to add my own reasons in support of the conclusion that Regulation No. 49(8) is ultra vires the regulation making power of the State Board whether the Regulation is regarded as a rule or a bye-law properly so called.

61. I would like to approach the problem from the point of view that the State Board is a creature of statute and it derives its powers from the provisions of the statute which brought it into existence. No inherent powers, as such, can be claimed by the State Board and, therefore, the Regulation must be justified on the basis of the provisions contained in the Maharashtra Secondary Education Boards Act, 1965.

62. My learned brother has exhaustively discussed the scheme of the Act with reference to the several provisions contained in the Act and I do not propose to repeat that discussion here. But after analysing the various provisions of the Act I think that the provisions can be classified in four different groups: (1) provisions relating to the constitution and composition of the Divisional Board and the State Board, its capacity, to sue and be sued, to hold and dispose of property, etc; (2) provisions which deal with advisory functions of the State Board; (3) provisions which deal with matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of final examination; and (4) provisions dealing with the final examination as such. We are not concerned with the provisions relating to the constitution and composition of the Boards and other incidental matters. We are also not concerned with the advisory powers of the State Board. I will not, therefore, refer to those provisions in my judgment. We are concerned with the provisions relating to matters concerning secondary education upto the stage of final examination (which provisions hereinafter I will refer to as provisions falling in the first category), and with the provisions which relate to the final examination itself (which provisions hereinafter I will refer to as provisions falling in the second category). The provisions falling in the first category are inter alia contained in ss. 18 and 19 read with s. 36 and also read with the definitions contained in s. 2 of the Act. Section 36 of the Act gives power to the State Board to make regulations for the purpose of carrying into effect the provisions of the Act.

63. “Secondary Education” has been defined in cl. (o) of s. 2 of the Act and it is in the following terms:

“‘secondary education’ means such general, technical, vocational or special education (including any combined course thereof), which is designed to meet the needs of the period of adolescence and which follows immediately primary education and precedes immediately education controlled by Universities established by law in India,”

64. Clause (b) of s. 18 confers power upon the State Board to lay down guiding principles for determining curricula and syllabi for the entire secondary course, to approve the detailed syllabi prepared by the Divisional Boards for all standardis except the final standard and to determine the curricula and detailed syllabi for the final examination. Clause (b) of s. 19 confers power upon a Divisional Board to prepare for the consideration of the State Board detailed syllabi for all standards, except the final standard, and make suggestions for the syllabi for the final examination. Clause (c) of s. 18 confers powers upon the State Board to formulate general principles for recommending text-books, and also to sanction such books from amongst those recommended by the Divisional Boards, subject to such conditions, if any, as the State Board may deem fit to impose. Clause (c) of s. 19 confers power upon the Divisional Board to recommend to the State Board for sanction text-books for all standards, except the final standard. The provisions contained in cl. (d) of s. 18 enables the State Board to prescribe standard requirements in respect of staff, buildings, furniture, equipment, stationery and other things required for secondary schools. clause (e) of s. 18 enables the State Board to prescribe and prepare text-books for the standards leading to the final examination. Clause (k) of s. 18 gives power to the State Board to demand and receive such fees as may be prescribed, from secondary schools recognised by the Divisional Boards, whereas cl. (1) of that section enables the State Board to call for special reports and information from the Director of Education or other officer of the Education Department and any information from any secondary school recognised by a Divisional Board in order to ensure maintenance of academic standards in secondary education. Clause (m) of that section enables the State Board to recommend measures to promote physical, moral and social welfare of students in institutions recognised by the Divisional Boards, and to prescribe conditions of their residence and discipline. Clause (n) of s. 19 gives power to the Divisional Board to grant recognition to secondary schools or withdraw the same in the prescribed manner. clause (o) of s. 19 gives power to the Divisional Board to call for any information from any secondary school recognised by it to ensure maintenance of academic standard and to call for special reports and information either on being referred to by the State Board or on its own initiative’, from the Regional Deputy Director of Education concerned on secondary schools recognised by it not maintaining the required academic standard, to withdraw recognition granted by it and to recommend to the Directorate of Education or the Directorate of Technical Education, as the case may be, withdrawal of recognition granted under the Secondary Schools Code, in cases of poor academic results and grave academic irregularities. These are the provisions which deal with matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of final examination. To sum up, these provisions give power to the State Board for laying down curricula and syllabi, for prescribing text-books, gratuity or withdrawing recognition to a secondary school and laying down standard requirements in respect of staff, building, furniture, equipment, stationery and other things required for secondary schools. But this list does not exhaust all the matters pertaining to secondary education upto the stage of final examination. There are still certain other matters pertaining to secondary education upto the stage of final examination which are not within the purview of these provisions, for instance, the teaching itself or the method or manner of teaching in schools, maintenance of discipline in schools as also instilling study habits in students and helping them to learn application of mind. These are matters which obviously are not covered by the provisions mentioned above.

65. The provisions falling in the second category, namely, provisions relating to the final examination itself, are contained in cls. (f), (g) and (h) of s. 18 and cls. (f), (g), (h), (i), (j), (k) and (l) of s. 19 of the Act. These provisions enable the State Board to make regulations prescribing conditions for admissions to the final examination, awarding certificates to candidates passing the final examination, instituting and awarding scholarships, stipends, medals, prizes and other rewards, and prescribing conditions therefor. Further these provisions enable the Divisional Board to conduct the final examination and for that purpose to appoint paper setters, translators, examiners, moderators, supervisors and other necessary personnel for evaluation of candidates' performance. Power is also given by these provisions to declare the results of the candidates appearing at the final examination. Thus, all the aspects dealing with the final examination have been entrusted to the two Boards together constituted under the Act.

66. Now, as stated above, besides laying down curricula and syllabi and other standard requirements as contemplated by cl. (d) of s. 18, there are other matters pertaining to secondary education which are not within the purview of the Act. That is because as the preamble itself makes it clear, the present Act is not for the purpose of regulating the entire secondary education in all its aspects, but the Act is intended only for the purpose of regulating certain matters pertaining to secondary education. Therefore, obviously the Legislature intended that matters which are not referred to in the above clauses of ss. 18 and 19 and which pertain to secondary education up to the stage of final examination are to be left out of the regulation-making power of the State Board. Therefore, the control of the State Board on matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of final examination is envisaged to the extent of these provisions and no further. I have already detailed these provisions and on a plain reading of those provisions it is clear that those provisions are intended to give power to the State Board to lay down minimum standards in respect of matters mentioned in those clauses of ss. 18 and 19 of the Act, Matters which are not covered by these clauses and matters which pertain to secondary education above the minimum prescribed by the State Board are entirely left to the school authorities. It must not be forgotten that the function which is left to the school authorities, namely, teaching, is a function complementary to the function of holding the final examinations, and I should say that this function which is left to the school authorities is at least as important, if not more, as the function of holding the final examination itself. The Legislature has contemplated this division, namely, that matters which pertain to secondary education up to the stage of final examination, subject to the observance of the minimum standards, laid down by the State Board (as indicated above with reference to the several provisions mentioned earlier), are left with the school authorities and the function of holding the final examination has been exclusively entrusted to the State Board. If the Legislature intended that the teacher should carry on the function of teaching and other matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of final examination, subject to the observance of the minimum standards laid down by the State Board, and the State Board should be exclusively in charge of the final examination, can it be said that the Legislature intended that the State Board will regulate its own function, namely, the function of holding the final examination in such a manner as to interfere with or adversely affect the function of teaching? Can it be said that the Legislature intended that the State Board should have such power as to adversely affect the function of teaching which must precede the holding of final examination and which is intended for the final examination? In my opinion, the answer is that the Legislature did not contemplate that the State Board should so exercise its function as to adversely affect the first part of secondary education, namely, matters connected with secondary education including teaching up to the stage of final examination. If that is so, then it follows that we must read these sections, which give power to the State Board to exclusively perform the function of holding the final examination in such a way that the State Board shall not carry on that function in such a manner or regulate that function in such a manner that it will adversely affect the function of teaching. In other words, there is an implied limitation on the regulation making power of the State Board that the regulations framed by the State Board for the purpose of holding the final examination will not be such as to interfere with the function of teaching, which is still retained by the Legislature with the teachers. To explain my point further, I will say that the Legislature has left the task of teaching to the teachers subject to the observance of minimum standards which are to be prescribed by the State Board. This will involve that the Legislature has left it to the teachers to inculcate study habits amongst students, to instil discipline amongst students, to help the students to learn the application of mind and to do all other things which are necessary for the purpose of enabling the students to develop their natural faculties, including a desire to acquire more and more knowledge. If the process of teaching envisages all these things, naturally we must assume that the Legislature never intended that the State Board, while making regulations for the purpose of governing or regulating its function, namely of holding the final examination, will frame those regulations in such a manner as will encourage disobedience amongst the students or as will detract application of the mind of students or as will bring about a result whereby the teacher may not be in a position to maintain his authority in the school. Therefore, I am inclined to take the view that the regulation making power of the State Board shall be so exercised as not to affect the function of teaching which is still retained with the teachers or the schools.

67. All this discussion was necessary because the validity of Regulation No. 49(8) was sought to be justified on the basis that the State Board has the power to prescribe conditions for admission to the final examination of regular candidates, as conferred by cl. (f) of s. 18 of the Act. The validity of this regulation was also sought to be justified on the provisions of cl. (q) of s. 19, which says that a Divisional Board will have the power to require institutions recognised by it and the Education Department to extend their co-operation in the conduct of the final examination. If the limitations mentioned by me are to be read in the regulation making power of the State Board, I should think that the Board is not entitled to make a regulation prescribing conditions for admission to the final examination of regular students in such a manner that regulation will encourage disobedience amongst the students or will detract the authority of the teachers. That regulation must be so framed as not to encroach upon the function of teaching, which is still left by the Legislature to the teachers subject to the power of the State Board to prescribe the minimum standards therefor under s. 18. If cl. (f) of s. 18 or cl. (q) of s. 19 is to be read, it would naturally mean that the regulation making authority will be transgressing that limit if a regulation is made by it which has the tendency to interfere with or adversely affect the function of teaching. That Regulation No. 49(8) has that tendency has been sufficiently discussed by my learned brother in his judgment and I do not repeat the same here. I merely want to point out that here is a regulation which says that whatever may be the academic achievements of a student who somehow has managed to get into the XI Standard, he must be sent to the final examination by the school authorities even though the school authorities conscientiously feel that the student is not fit to appear for the examination. In fact, this authority with the school teachers, namely, not to send the candidate to the final examination, does always have a salutary effect of keeping the students on their guard and of persuading them to devote more to their studies; and if this instrument is removed, one can very well imagine what the effect would be. The student will no longer be under the apprehension that he would be prevented from completing his secondary education by the school authorities, if he does not satisfy the school authorities in the matter of acadamic progress and, for that matter, he need not have any academic progress at all in the XI Standard, because there is no fear of detention, there is no fear that lie will not be allowed to complete his secondary education. I, therefore, feel that Regulation No. 49(8) has every tendency to encourage disobedience amongst students and it will obviously adversely affect the function of teaching and, as stated earlier, any such regulation which transgresses its limit will be ultra vires. Therefore, this regulation will be ultra vires on this additional ground.

68. There is another aspect of the matter from which the validity of this regulation can also be tested. It is true that the State Board has been given the power to frame regulations for the conduct of the final examination. Similarly, the State Board has also been given the power to prescribe minimum standards in respect of certain educational matters mentioned in this s. 18 up to the stage of the final examination itself. The State Board will have no authority to pass any regulation which will regulate matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of the final examination, excepting that of laying down a minimum standard. In other words, the school authorities are free to regulate those matters as they like and the State Board has no power to make any regulation in that behalf. By resorting to the powers for regulating the final examination itself, can the State Board assume to itself a power with regard to matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of the final examination? I think the State Board cannot do in an indirect way, what it cannot do in a direct way. If the State Board has no power to regulate matters connected with secondary education up to the stage of the final examination, excepting laying down minimum standards, that power cannot be assumed by the State Board in the garb of laying down conditions for admission of students to the final examination or in its power to regulate the final examination.

69. It is interesting to note how the regulation itself has been framed. According to me, it is a clever device adopted by the State Board to assume power which it did not possess. Regulation No. 19 deals with conditions to be complied with by a secondary school seeking recognition from the Divisional Board or to be complied with by a secondary school which desires the continuation of the recognition already granted to it. That regulation lays down the minimum standards in respect of matters, pertaining to secondary education up to the stage of final examination which are to be complied with by such a school. Regulation No. 49(8) is not contained in the set of regulations, which deal with recognition of schools, but it is contained in the set of regulations dealing with matters pertaining to the filing of an application for admission to the final examination. Though in its form the regulation purports to lay down conditions for admission to the final examination, in substance it is a regulation which interferes with or adversely affects the function of teaching; and if the real substance and the impact of the, regulation is seen, it substantially touches a matter which is beyond the regulation making power of the State Board. I therefore feel that this is a clever device adopted by the State Board for assuming power to itself which it did not possess.

70. The regulation is also sought to be justified by the powers conferred upon the Divisional Board to grant recognition to secondary schools or withdraw the same in the prescribed manner, as per cl. (n) of s. 19 of the Act. Elaborate arguments were advanced before us as to the meaning and the real scope of cl. (n) of s. 19 read with cl. (o) of that section. In order to appreciate this argument, I will not be unjustified if I refer to the historical background of this clause, though the same has not been referred to in the arguments of either of the counsels. In order to understand what the concept of recognition of a school means, I would like to see how the question of recognition originally arose so far as this part of the country is concerned. When the investigation is so made, one finds that prior to the establishment of the University of Bombay, which was the only University in this part of the country till 1948, there were several educational institutions which were imparting instructions to students. The Bombay University Act, 1857 (XXII of 1857) was passed whereby the University of Bombay was established. Section 12 of the said Act laid down qualification for admission of candidates for degrees, and the qualification was that the candidate was to present to the Chancellor, Vice-Chancellor, etc., a certificate from one of the institutions authorised in that behalf by the Governor of Bombay in Council to that effect that he had completed the course of instructions prescribed by the Chancellor, etc. This Act was further amended and modified by the Indian Universities Act, 1904 (VIII of 1904). Clause (o) of s. 25 of the said Act laid down that the Senate would have the power to make regulations with regard to the conditions to be complied with by schools desiring recognition for the purpose of sending up pupils as candidates for the matriculation examination and the conditions to be complied with by candidates for matriculation, whether sent up by recognised schools or not. The provisions of Bombay Act XXII of 1857 were further modified after that Act itself was replaced by Bombay Act IV of 1928. Clause (kk) of sub-s. (2) of s. 33 of that Act provided that the Senate was entitled to make Statutes not inconsistent with the Act for the purpose of laying down the conditions to be complied with by schools desiring recognition for the purpose of sending up pupils as candidates for the Matriculation Examination and the conditions to be complied with by candidates for the Matriculation Examination whether sent up by recognised schools or not. It may be of interest to note here that the first Matriculation Examination in this part was held in October 1859 for the purpose of admission of students to the University (Vide Gazetteer of Bombay City and Island, Vol. III, p. 110), and after the abolition of the Public Service Certificate Examination the Matriculation Examination itself came to serve a three-fold purpose, namely, (1) providing qualification for admission to the University, (2) providing for the school leaving certificate, and (3) providing minimum qualification for employment in public service. By virtue of the powers derived by the University under s. 33(2)(kk) of the Act of 1928 the University of Bombay framed statutes laying down the conditions to be complied with by the schools in order to enable the schools to be recognised. The conditions which the University of Bombay laid down were as follows:

“(a) That the school maintains regular classes from the 4th Anglo Vernacular standard upwards or the corresponding standards of European and English teaching schools;

(b) that the school supplies a need in the locality in which it is situated;

(c) that the management is so constituted as to offer a reasonable prospect that the school will be well conducted;

(d) that the qualifications of the teaching staff and the conditions governing their tenure of office are such as to make due provision for the courses of instruction to be undertaken by the school and to ensure a reasonable continuity of its teaching staff;

(e) that the school is housed in suitable building and adequately equipped;

(f) that the resources at the disposal of the management are such as to afford a reasonable expectation that the school will be efficiently maintained;

(g) that the fee paid by the pupils will not involve such competition with any existing school in the same locality as would be injurious to the interest of education;

(h) that the admissions and promotions of pupils have been made in accordance with the instructions issued by the Syndicate from time to time in that behalf.”

71. These clauses will show that the purpose of recognition of an institution was to see that the institution possessed the requisite equipment and had the capacity to maintain the minimum educational standard. In the year 1948, after the establishment of another University, namely, the Poona University, in this region, a Board was constituted, namely, the Secondary School Certificate Examination Board, under the Bombay Secondary School Certificate Examination Act, 1948, for the purpose of holding the school certificate examination. A consequential amendment was also made in the Bombay University Act in 1928 by addition of s. 28A. The result was that a student who had passed the school certificate examination was entitled to join the college and prosecute his studies in the Bombay University and a similar provision was also incorporated in the Poona University Act, though these Universities were given the power to hold entrance examinations. But a candidate who had passed the school certificate examination was entitled to get admission to the colleges without being inquired to appear for the University entrance examination. Clause (h) of s. 2 of the 1948 Act defined “recognised high school” to mean a high school recognised by the Director of Education, Bombay State, or an officer authorised by him in this behalf or a high school registered by any University established by law in the State. Under the present Act, by virtue of the provisions of cl. (d) of s. 40(2), on the appointed day all institutions recognised and admitted to the privileges of any dissolved Board immediately before the appointed day shall be deemed to be recognised and admitted to the privileges of the corresponding Divisional Board established under this Act, save in so far as such recognition or privilege may be withdrawn, restricted or modified by or under the provisions of this Act. Therefore, when the present Act conferred the power on the Divisional Board to grant recognition to a secondary school it cannot be said that the purpose in granting recognition is different from the one which was envisaged under the enactment authorising the University of Bombay to recognise institutions. The purpose obviously under cl. (n) of s. 19 of the Act is also to see that the institutions, which seek recognition, are in a position to maintain the minimum standard of education. If they are found to be competent to turn out students who are fit to be admitted to the University—one of the purposes for which the final examination is held—they have earned a recognition by virtue of their competence, and the higher the competence the stronger the claim to recognition. Therefore, recognition is not a bounty or favour from the Divisional Board but it is something which is granted on account of the merit possessed by the institution. This is made further clear if we turn to the provisions of cl. (o) of s. 19 of the Act itself. That clause confers powers upon the Divisional Board to call for any information from any secondary school recognised by it to ensure maintenance of academic standard and to call for special report and information either on being referred to by the State Board or on its own initiative from the Regional Deputy Director of Education concerned on secondary schools recognised by it, not maintaining the required academic standard, in order that the Divisional Board may withdraw recognition granted by it, etc. Withdrawal of the recognition is contemplated by the Act only in cases: where the institution concerned is not in a position to maintain the academic standard, and the required academic standard would mean the minimum standard laid down by the State Board. Can the power which is granted to the Divisional Board to recognise an institution, be utilised for the purpose of saying that the school, which wants to maintain a higher academic standard, should not maintain that higher standard? The schools which want to detain their candidates and not to forward their applications for the final examination want to do so for the purpose of maintaining an academic standard higher than the minimum prescribed by the State Board and also their educational reputation. But the effect of the present Regulation No. 49(8) is to tell such schools, “Do not do that. You need not maintain an academic standard higher than the one prescribed by the State Board. Do not bother about higher academic standard. Let all students be permitted to appear for the final examination.” The schools which want the power of detention want to tell their students that they are under constant threat of their applications being withheld and unless they achieve higher academic standard they will not be permitted to appear for the S.S.C Examination and complete their secondary education, whereas the State Board says by Regulation No. 49(8) “Do not compel them to have higher standard. Let them be content with the minimum standard prescribed. “And if the schools go against this, they will be threatened with withdrawal of their recognition under cl. (7) of Regulation No. 19. The justification for the validity of Regulation 49(8) on the ground of powers of recognition comes to this, namely, that the State Board will tell the schools that it will refuse to recognise the schools if they want a higher educational standard. Is that the purpose of that Act? I ask myself a further question. Does the State Board possess that power to tell the schools that you shall not have a higher educational standard? I think the State Board does not possess that power. The argument advanced before us was in this form: That it is not the State Board which compels the schools to seek recognition. If the schools want any recognition, they must be agreeable to abide by any conditions that may be imposed by the Divisional Board and if the schools are not agreeable to comply with those conditions they will not get their recognition continued. This is tantamount to saying that the State Board, which is charged with the duty of maintaining academic standards and which has been given the power to recognise educational institutions which have the capacity to maintain minimum educational standards, wants to assume to itself a power that it will lay down a condition for recognition that the school shall not have a standard higher than the minimum prescribed by the State Board that the school shall have no freedom to maintain higher standard. I think this power has not been conferred on the State Board by cl. (n) of s. 19 of the Act. I, therefore think that the validity of Regulation No. 49(8) also cannot be justified under cl. (n) of s. 19 of the Act.

72. For the reasons I am of the opinion that Regulation No. 49(8) is ultra vires the regulation making power of the State Board.