- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Messrs Modern Builder v. Hukmatrai N. Vaziram
Factual and Procedural Background
The plaintiffs (appellants before the High Court) sued the defendant in the Bombay City Civil Court for recovery of about Rs. 14,900. On April 6, 1963, by consent of the parties the dispute was referred to arbitration before two arbitrators — the advocates of the respective parties — with an express term in the order of reference that the two arbitrators "shall nominate an Umpire." The arbitrators did not appoint an umpire but heard the parties and recorded evidence in three meetings on May 13, 16 and 17, 1963. The court, by consent of parties, extended the time for making the award. The arbitrators made an award on November 28, 1964, directing the defendant to pay Rs. 8,500 with interest and costs.
The plaintiffs applied to the City Civil Court to set aside the award, advancing as their principal ground that clause 2 of the First Schedule to the Arbitration Act, 1940 — which required arbitrators (when they are even in number) to appoint an umpire not later than one month from their appointment — was mandatory and that failure to comply rendered the award invalid. The trial judge held the award valid, that clause 2 was not mandatory, and that the plaintiffs had waived non-compliance by their conduct. The plaintiffs appealed from that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether clause 2 of the First Schedule to the Arbitration Act, 1940 (requiring arbitrators to appoint an umpire where there is an even number of arbitrators, "not later than one month from the latest date of their respective appointments") is mandatory such that non-compliance invalidates an award.
- If clause 2 is mandatory, whether the plaintiffs' conduct in participating in arbitration meetings and consenting to time extensions amounted to waiver of the non-compliance and thereby validated the award.
- Whether, even if clause 2 is directory, the failure to appoint an umpire in the circumstances of this case amounted to legal misconduct that would vitiate the award.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' (Plaintiffs') Arguments
- The plaintiffs (through counsel Mr. Dhanuka) contended that clause 2 of the First Schedule to the Arbitration Act, 1940, was mandatory — the use of the word "shall" and the change from the earlier Act's "may" indicated a legislative intention that appointment of an umpire was obligatory and that failure to appoint an umpire must render any award invalid.
- It was argued that, because the decretal order of reference contained the clause incorporating clause 2 by operation of s. 3 (and s. 25), the term could not be waived or altered by consent of the parties without a fresh order of the Court; hence the plaintiffs could not be taken to have waived the statutory requirement.
- Alternatively, the plaintiffs argued that even if clause 2 were directory, the breach amounted to legal misconduct (given the circumstances) and therefore vitiated the award.
Respondent's (Defendant / Opposing Party) Arguments and Trial Court's Position
- The trial Court held and respondents maintained that clause 2 is not mandatory but directory; non-compliance did not automatically invalidate the award.
- It was further asserted (and the High Court accepted) that the plaintiffs, by attending arbitration meetings, producing evidence, and consenting to extension of time, had waived the non-compliance with clause 2; having waived it, they could not later object to the award on that ground.
- The respondents relied on statutory context (clauses 4 and 5 of the First Schedule and s. 8 of the Act) to show the statutory scheme allowed for curing of non-appointment (e.g., court appointment of an umpire) and therefore clause 2's breach should not vitiate an award.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vinayak Vishnu v. B.G. Gadre [1959 A.I.R. Bom. 39] | Set aside an award made by two arbitrators without appointing an umpire; contained obiter observations that cl. 2 is mandatory. | The Court noted that the decision turned on an express contractual term requiring nomination of an umpire before starting inquiry; the remark that cl. 2 is mandatory was treated as obiter and unsupported by reasons, so it was not followed as authoritative. |
| Firm Shriram v. The President [1954 A.I.R. Nag. 236] | Contains observations on cl. 2 of the First Schedule. | The Court observed only casual comments on cl. 2 and did not find this case to show cl. 2 being treated as mandatory; the opinion was regarded as consistent with a non-mandatory view. |
| Tikaram v. Hansraj [1954 A.I.R. Nag. 241] | Detailed reasons supporting that cl. 2 is directory, not mandatory. | The High Court expressly agreed with the reasoning in this Nagpur decision and adopted its view that cl. 2 is directory. |
| Jawala Prasad v. Amar Nath [1951 A.I.R. All. 474] | Held an award by two arbitrators without nominating an umpire invalid; stated cl. 2 is mandatory (without reasons). | The Court treated this authority as having been weakened by a later Allahabad decision (Shambhu Nath) and noted the lack of reasons; it did not follow Jawala Prasad as authoritative on the mandatory point. |
| Shambhu Nath v. Hari Shankar Lal [1954 A.I.R. All. 673] | Held failure to appoint an umpire does not vitiate an award; breach may be irregularity and waivable; relied on s. 8. | The Court relied on this later Allahabad decision to show that Jawala Prasad's authority was weakened and to support the view that cl. 2's breach may be irregular and waivable. |
| Ram Kishore v. Raj Narain [1963 A.I.R. All. 23] | Set aside an award made within one month without nominating an umpire; treated cl. 2 as mandatory in that factual context. | The High Court expressly disagreed with this decision, holding there is nothing in clause 2 or the Act preventing an arbitrator from making an award within one month and that the case was wrongly decided on principle. |
| Harak Chand Damani v. Ramsarup Lakkar [1948 85 C.L.J. 232] | Held appointment of an umpire after expiry of the one-month period under cl. 2 was invalid. | The Court disagreed with this view, relying on s. 8(2) which contemplates appointment after the period and therefore permits valid appointments after one month. |
| United Printing v. Kishori Lal [1956 A.I.R. Cal. 593] | Overruled objection to award made by two arbitrators without appointing an umpire; non-compliance with cl. 2 did not vitiate the award. | The Court cited this Calcutta decision as conforming to its view that cl. 2 is not mandatory and does not automatically invalidate an award. |
| Louis Dreyfus & Co. v. Hemandas [1940 A.I.R. Sind 37] | Decision consistent with the view that cl. 2 is not mandatory. | Included among authorities demonstrating that a number of courts have treated cl. 2 as directory rather than mandatory. |
| Sheoramprasad v. Gopalprasad [1959 A.I.R. M.P. 102] | Authority aligning with the directory view of cl. 2. | Cited as part of the body of case law supporting the Court's conclusion that cl. 2 is directory. |
| Chacko v. Chacko [1959 A.I.R. Kerala 149] | Supports the view that cl. 2 is directory. | Relied upon as another precedent consistent with the Court's conclusion. |
| Ratnawa v. Gurushiddappa [1962 A.I.R. Mysore 135] | Also in conformity with view that cl. 2 is directory. | Cited to show the bulk of judicial opinion favours the directory classification. |
| Bandu Hari v. Bhagya Laxman [1953 55 Bom. L.R. 753] | Held a mandatory provision (notice under O. XXI, r. 22 CPC) enacted for a party's benefit could be waived by that party. | Used by the Court as an example showing that even some mandatory provisions enacted for the benefit of parties may be waived; applied to support the proposition that waiver can operate in the arbitration context. |
| Sherbanubai Jafferbhoy v. Hooseinbhoy [1947 50 Bom. L.R. 89] | Held that parties cannot alter terms of a Court reference by mere consent; a fresh order of the Court is required to alter court-directed terms of reference. | The Court considered and rejected an argument relying on this decision to assert that the statutory term incorporated into a court's order could not be waived by parties; distinguished waiver (agreeing to non-compliance) from amendment (altering terms). |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The High Court's analysis proceeded in a series of logical steps, grounded in statutory construction, functional analysis of the umpire's role, and examination of related statutory provisions and authorities.
-
Statutory incorporation and applicable provision:
Section 3 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, read with section 25 (which makes s.3 applicable to arbitrations in suits), means the First Schedule's provisions are deemed included in the arbitration agreement/order of reference unless a different intention is expressed. Clause 2 of the First Schedule thereby applied to the Court's order of reference in this case.
-
Functional role of an umpire:
The Court examined the First Schedule (particularly clauses 4 and 5) to determine an umpire's function. An umpire is to "enter on the reference" only if the arbitrators either fail to make an award within the time allowed or deliver notice that they cannot agree. If arbitrators agree and make an award within time, an umpire has no function. Thus the umpire replaces arbitrators only in specific contingencies.
-
Mandatory vs directory analysis — principles:
The Court invoked established interpretive principles (citing Maxwell) that whether a statutory command is mandatory or directory depends on the scope, object, considerations of convenience and justice, and whether nullification of subsequent proceedings would promote or frustrate the legislative aim. The mere use of "shall" does not conclusively render a provision mandatory with nullifying effect.
-
Application to clause 2:
Applying those principles, the Court reasoned that when arbitrators (an even number) make an award in agreement, an umpire would have had no role; invalidating such awards for failure to appoint an umpire would cause inconvenience and injustice without advancing cl. 2's object. Further, where arbitrators disagree, section 8 provides a remedy — parties may serve a notice to compel appointment, and the Court may appoint an umpire if the arbitrators do not act — demonstrating that the statutory scheme contemplates curing non-appointment and is inconsistent with a rule of automatic nullification.
-
Temporal aspect of clause 2:
Clause 2 prescribes appointment "not later than one month" from latest appointment, but clause 2 does not require appointment prior to commencing the reference or hearing. Arbitrators may validly hear and make an award within a month, making subsequent appointment unnecessary. Sub-section (2) of section 8 contemplates appointment after the one-month period (through the notice-and-wait mechanism), which indicates the one-month limit was not intended to be a strict jurisdictional bar rendering later appointments invalid.
-
Consideration of authorities:
The Court reviewed multiple decisions. It distinguished cases where the agreement's express terms materially differed (Vinayak Vishnu) and noted conflicting authorities. It found persuasive the Nagpur decision in Tikaram v. Hansraj and the Allahabad Shambhu Nath decision, as well as several other High Court rulings, which treated clause 2 as directory. Decisions holding the clause mandatory were either treated as fact-specific, obiter, or insufficiently reasoned and thus not followed.
-
Waiver:
Even assuming, arguendo, that clause 2 were mandatory in form, the Court held the plaintiffs had waived non-compliance by their conduct: after the one-month period expired, three arbitration meetings occurred with plaintiffs participating and producing evidence, and plaintiffs agreed to court extension of time for award. The Court analyzed waiver principles (citing Craies and a local divisional decision) and held that statutory requirements enacted for the benefit of parties (as opposed to public interest or conferring jurisdiction) may be waived by those parties. Clause 2 was held to be for the parties' benefit and not jurisdictional in nature; hence it is waivable.
-
Misconduct argument:
The Court rejected the submission that non-appointment in this case amounted to legal misconduct vitiating the award. Because arbitrators agreed and an umpire would have had no role, non-appointment could not constitute legal misconduct here.
-
Conclusion of reasoning:
Synthesizing statutory scheme, the functional role of the umpire, interpretive principles, and relevant authorities, the Court concluded clause 2 is directory and not mandatory; alternatively, even if mandatory, plaintiffs had waived non-compliance. Therefore the award was not invalidated by the failure to appoint an umpire in the circumstances of the present case.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The appeal is dismissed. The Court held that clause 2 of the First Schedule to the Arbitration Act, 1940 is directory and not mandatory; and, in any event, the plaintiffs had waived non-compliance with that provision by their conduct. The award made by the two arbitrators was therefore not invalidated.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The arbitral award made on November 28, 1964, directing payment of Rs. 8,500 with interest and costs, stands; the plaintiffs' challenge to set it aside fails and the appeal is dismissed with costs.
- On broader law: The Court relied on and cited a number of High Court decisions in support of the proposition that the statutory requirement to appoint an umpire (clause 2) is generally directory and that failure to comply does not automatically invalidate an award; the Court also recognized some contrary decisions but distinguished or declined to follow those which were fact-specific or inadequately reasoned. The Court applied the established interpretive approach that the consequence of non-compliance depends on legislative purpose, convenience and justice, and whether the requirement is jurisdictional or protective of parties' interests.
- The Court further held that where a statutory requirement is inserted primarily for the benefit of parties (and does not confer jurisdiction), it may be waived by those parties; hence waiver may cure non-compliance in appropriate circumstances.
This summary is prepared strictly from the text of the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond what the opinion contains.
Tarkunde, J.:— This appeal arises from an order of the Bombay City Civil Court refusing to set aside an award made on a Court reference.
2. The appellants before us were the original plaintiffs. They had filed a suit in the Bombay City Civil Court for the recovery of Rs. 14,900 and odd from the defendant. When the suit reached hearing on April 6, 1963, the matter in dispute was by consent of the parties referred to the arbitration of two arbitrators, who were the two advocates of the parties. One of the terms in the order of reference provided that the two arbitrators “shall nominate an Umpire”. The arbitrators did not appoint an umpire but heard the parties and received their evidence in three meetings held on May 13, 16 and 17, 1963. The time for making the award was enlarged by the Court by consent of parties. The arbitrators made an award on November 28, 1964, by which they directed that the defendant shall pay to the plaintiffs Rs. 8,500 with interest and costs. Being dissatisfied with the award the plaintiffs applied to the City Civil Court for setting it aside. The main ground advanced on their behalf was that the provision contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule of the Arbitration Act, 1940, which required the arbitrators to appoint an umpire was a mandatory provision and that the breach of that provision by the arbitrators rendered the award invalid. The learned trial Judge held that the award was not invalid, that the provisions in cl. 2 of the First Schedule was not mandatory and that in any case the plaintiffs had by their conduct waived the non-compliance with that provision. This decision has been challenged by the plaintiffs in this appeal. Although the order of reference made by the trial Court by consent of parties contained a clause that the two arbitrators “shall nominate an Umpire”, the clause did not provide the time within which the nomination was to be made. Section 3 of the Arbitration Act, 1940, which relates to an arbitration without the intervention of a Court, lays down that—
“An arbitration agreement, unless a different intention is expressed therein, shall be deemed to include the provisions set out in the First Schedule in so far as they are applicable to the reference.”
3. By s. 25 the provision of s. 3 has been made applicable to arbitrations in suits. Clause 2 of the First Schedule on which the plaintiffs rely is in the following terms:
“If the reference is to an even number of arbitrators, the arbitrators shall appoint an umpire, not later than one month from the latest date of their respective appointments.”
4. Since a different intention has not been expressed in the decretal order of reference this clause must be deemed to have been included in that order by virtue of s. 3 read with s. 25 of the Act.
5. On behalf of the plaintiffs Mr. Dhanuka urged before us that cl. 2 of the First Schedule is mandatory and that the failure of the arbitrators to appoint an umpire as required by that clause must render their award invalid. Judicial opinion does not appear to be uniform on whether that clause is mandatory. It will be convenient if we first deal with that question on principle before referring to authorities.
6. In considering whether cl. 2 of the First Schedule is mandatory or directory, it is material to notice what function an umpire is expected to perform. An umpire is not an arbitrator ab initio. He does not act as a third arbitrator. He has no function to perform if the two arbitrators do not disagree with each other and proceed to make an award within the agreed time or within such extended time as the Court may allow. The functions of an umpire have been specified in cls. 4 and 5 of the First Schedule. Clause 4 provides that if the arbitrators have allowed their time to expire without making an award or if they have delivered to any party or to the umpire a notice in writing stating that they cannot agree, “the umpire shall forthwith enter on the reference in lieu of the arbitrators”. Clause 5 says that the umpire shall make his award within two months of entering on the reference or within such extended time as the Court may allow. It is clear from these provisions that an umpire replaces the arbitrators if the latter fail to make an award within the time allowed to them or fail to agree with each other and that the umpire has no function if such a contingency does not arise.
7. Although an umpire has no function to perform in the absence of a disagreement between the arbitrators or their failure to make an award in the time allowed, the terms of cl. 2 clearly show that the Legislature intended that the arbitrators shall appoint an umpire as a matter of course irrespective of whether they do or do not agree with each other. Mr. Dhanuka pointed out in this connection that, prior to the Arbitration Act of 1940, it was not obligatory on the arbitrators when they were even in number to appoint an umpire. The corresponding clause in the First Schedule to the indian arbitration act of 1899 provided that the arbitrators “may appoint an Umpire at any time within the period during which they have power to make an award”. In cl. 2 of the First Schedule of the Arbitration Act of 1940 the language was changed and it was provided that the arbitrators “shall appoint an Umpire not later than one month from the latest date of their respective appointments.” The change was undoubtedly deliberate and it appears to have been made because the Legislature felt that the arbitrators, if they fail to agree on the matters referred to them, may also disagree on the nomination of an umpire and that it was desirable that they should nominate an umpire soon after they are appointed arbitrators. Relying on this legislative history, Mr. Dhanuka argued that the use of the word “shall” in cl. 2 of the First Schedule, instead of the word “may” which appeared in the corresponding clause of the earlier Act, showed that the Legislature intended that the provision of cl. 2 should be mandatory and not directory. We do not agree that the use of the word “shall” is decisive of the question. When the Legislature had used the word “may” in the former clause, the appointment of an umpire by the arbitrators was discretionary. With the use of the word “shall” in the present clause the appointment has been made obligatory. It is, however, obvious that an obligatory rule may be either mandatory or directory, depending upon whether the Legislature intended that non-compliance with the rule should or should not result in the nullification of subsequent proceedings. The real question, therefore, is whether the Legislature intended that the failure of the arbitrators to appoint an umpire should result in depriving them of the power to proceed with the arbitration and in rendering invalid any award made by them.
8. As observed in Maxwell on Interpretation of Statutes, the question must be decided on the scope and object of the provision in question and on considerations of convenience and justice. The learned author says (11th edn., p. 364):
“It has been said that no rule can be laid down for determining whether the command is to be considered as a mere direction or instruction involving 110 invalidating consequence in its disregard, or as imperative, with an implied nullification for disobedience, beyond the fundamental one that it depends on the scope and object of the enactment. It may, perhaps, be found generally correct to say that nullification is the natural and usual consequence of disobedience, but the question is in the main governed by considerations of convenience and justice, and when that result would involve general inconvenience or injustice to innocent persons, or advantage to those guilty of the neglect, without promoting the real aim and object of the enactment, such an intention is not to be attributed to the legislature. …”
9. We have seen above that an umpire has no function to perform if the arbitrators do not disagree and proceed to make an award within the agreed time or such extended time as may be allowed by the Court. When an award made by an even number of arbitrators is challenged on the ground that they had failed to appoint an umpire, the challenge is necessarily made in circumstances in which an umpire, if appointed, had no function to perform. The arbitrators make an award when they agree with each other, and the fact that they make an award itself shows that an umpire, if he had been appointed, would not have been required to enter on the reference as contemplated by r. 4 of the First Schedule. No considerations of convenience or justice require that an award made in such a case should be invalid.
10. On the other hand, even in eases where the arbitrators do not agree with each other, a failure on their part to appoint an umpire would not necessarily render the arbitration proceedings infructuous. In such a case any party to the reference can approach the Court under s. 8 for the appointment of an umpire. Section 8(1)(c) provides inter alia that where the arbitrators are required to appoint an umpire and do not appoint him, any party may serve the arbitrators with a written notice to concur in the appointment of an umpire. Sub-section (2) of s. 8 provides that if the appointment is not made within fifteen clear days after the service of the said notice, the Court may, on the application of the party who gave the notice and after giving the other parties an opportunity of being heard, appoint an umpire.
11. Thus if the provision contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule is considered in the contest of cls. 4 and 5 which define the functions of an umpire and s. 8 which provides, for the appointment of an umpire by the Court, it would appear that non-compliance with cl. 2 was not intended by the Legislature to have the consequence of nullifying the proceedings before the arbitrators. The arbitrators may either agree or fail to agree. In the first eventuality the appointment of an umpire is redundant and in the second the failure of the arbitrators to appoint an umpire can be made good by the Court appointing an Umpire. That being so, compliance with cl. 2 cannot be regarded as a condition for the validity of an award, in the absence of an express legislative provision to that effect.
12. There is another reason why cl. 2 must be held to be directory and not mandatory. Under that clause the arbitrators are to appoint an umpire within one month of their appointment. Nothing, however, prevents the arbitrators from hearing the parties and giving an award within a month of their appointment. Clause 2 does not provide that the arbitrators shall appoint an umpire before they enter on the reference. If the arbitrators give an award within one month of their appointment, it is not contemplated that they should subsequently appoint an umpire. That shows that cl. 2 could not have been intended by the Legislature to be mandatory.
13. It also appears that the time limit of one month for the appointment of an umpire specified in cl. 2 was not intended by the Legislature to be mandatory. If the arbitrators were to appoint an umpire after the period of one month, the appointment would not be invalid. This is clear from the terms of s. 8. As observed earlier, cl. (1)(c) of s. 8 lays down that any party may serve the arbitrators with a written notice to concur in the appointment of an umpire “where…the arbitrators are required to appoint an Umpire and do not appoint him”. The arbitrators cannot be said to have failed to appoint an umpire till the expiry of the period of one month specified in cl. 2 of the First Schedule. It follows that the written notice to be served on the arbitrators which is contemplated by cl. (1)(c) of s. 8 can only be given after the expiry of the said period of one month. Then sub-s. (2) of s. 8 says that “if the appointment is not made within fifteen clear days after the service of the said notice”, the Court may itself appoint an umpire. This provision clearly contemplates that the arbitrators may appoint an umpire after they receive a notice from a party under sub-s. (1)(c) of s. 8, which notice itself would be given to them after the expiry of the period of one month specified in cl. 2. Thus the terms of sub s. (2) of s. 8 show that the Legislature itself contemplated a valid appointment of an umpire being made by the arbitrators after the expiry of the period specified in cl. 2.
14. Turning to authorities, the only decision of this Court which was cited before us was that of a Single Judge in Vinayak Vishnu v. B.G Gadre . [1959] A.I.R Bom. 39.. In that case an award made by two arbitrators without appointing an umpire was set aside. A reference to the judgment shows that the decision turned on the wording of the arbitration agreement which required the arbitrators to nominate an umpire before they proceeded “to start an inquiry”. The learned Judge held that in view of the express term of the agreement mentioned above, cl. 2 of the First Schedule was not attracted and that the matter was governed only by the said term of the arbitration agreement. In the course of his judgment, however, the learned Judge made some observations, which are clearly obiter, to the effect that cl. 2 of the First Schedule is mandatory and not merely directory. No reasons are given by the learned Judge in support of this view. The learned Judge referred to two decisions of the Nagpur High Court and expressed his agreement with one and disagreement with the other. He also referred with approval to a decision of the Allahabad High Court.
15. The decision of the Nagpur High Court with which the learned Judge expressed agreement was in Firm Shriram v. The President . [1954] A.I.R Nag. 236.. There are some casual observations in that case on cl. 2 of the First Schedule, but those observations do not show that, according to the learned Judges who decided that case, the provision in cl. 2 of the First Schedule was mandatory. On the other hand, the Nagpur decision with which disagreement was expressed in the aforesaid Bombay case was in Tikaram v. Hansraj . [1954] A.I.R Nag. 241.. Detailed reasons are given in that judgment in support of the view that cl. 2 of the First Schedule is directory and not mandatory. With respect, we are in agreement with the views expressed in that judgment.
16. The decision of the Allahabad High Court on which reliance was placed in the Bombay case was in Jawala Prasad v. Amar Nath . [1951] A.I.R All. 474.. In that case an award which was made by two arbitrators in a Court reference was held to be invalid on the ground that the arbitrators had not appointed an umpire. It was held that the provision of cl. 2 of the First Schedule is of a mandatory character, but no reasons were given in support of that view. The authority of this case has been considerably shaken as a result of a subsequent decision of the same Court in Shambhu Nath v. Hari Shankar Lal . [1954] A.I.R All. 673.. One of the Judges who was concerned with the previous decision was a member of the Bench which decided this later case. Here also two arbitrators had made an award without nominating an umpire. The learned Judges referred to the provision contained in s. 8(1)(c) of the Act and observed that the failure to appoint an umpire is not such a breach of cl. 2 of the First Schedule as to vitiate the award and that the breach may amount merely to an irregularity which it is possible to waive. Referring to the earlier case in Jawala Prasad v. Amar Nath it was observed that the learned Judges in that case had taken care “to confine their decision to the facts of that particular case”.
17. Mr. Dhanuka, however, relied upon a subsequent decision of a Single Judge of the Allahabad High Court in Ram Kishore v. Raj Narain . [1963] A.I.R All. 23.. In this case the learned Judge confirmed the order of the lower Court setting aside an award made by two arbitrators within a month of their appointment without nominating an umpire. The learned Judge relied on the decision in Jawala Prasad v. Amar Nath and distinguished the subsequent case of Shambhu Nath v. Hari Shankar Lal on the ground that the award in that case was made more than one month after the appointment of arbitrators, so that the parties had an opportunity to approach the Court for the appointment of an umpire under s. 8(1)(c) of the Act. The learned Judge held that where the arbitrators failed to appoint an umpire as required by the mandatory provision of cl. 2 of the First Schedule and gave an award within one month of their own appointment so as to deprive the parties of any opportunity to take recourse to s. 8(1)(c) of the Act, the award made is invalid. With respect, we are quite unable to agree with this view. There is nothing in cl. 2 of the First Schedule or any other provision of the Act which prevents the arbitrators from giving an award within one month of their appointment or which requires the arbitrators to appoint an umpire prior to the end of the said period of one month.
18. Mr. Dhanuka relied on a decision of a Single Judge of the Calcutta High Court in Harak Chand Damani v. Ramsarup Lakkar . 1948 85 C.L.J 232.. In that case it was held inter alia that the appointment of an umpire by two arbitrators after the expiry of the period of one month specified in cl. 2 of the First Schedule was invalid. With respect we do not agree with this view. We have pointed out above that the provision of sub-s. (2) of s. 8 indicates that the Legislature contemplated a valid appointment of an umpire being made by the arbitrators after the lapse of the period of one month mentioned in cl. 2 of the First Schedule.
19. There is another decision of the Calcutta High Court, United Printing v. Kishori Lal . [1956] A.I.R Cal. 593., which is in conformity with our view that cl. 2 of the First Schedule is not a mandatory provision. In that case a Single Judge overruled an objection which had been taken to the validity of an award made by two arbitrators without appointing an umpire. The learned Judge held that non-compliance with cl. 2 of the First Schedule did not vitiate the award.
20. Decisions in conformity with the view which we are inclined to take are also found in Louis Dreyfus & Co. v. Hemandas . [1940] A.I.R Sind 37., Sheoramprasad v. Gopalprasad . [1959] A.I.R M.P 102., Chacko v. Chacko . [1959] A.I.R Kerala 149. and Ratnawa v. Gurushiddappa . [1962] A.I.R Mysore 135.. Thus the bulk of judicial opinion favours the conclusion that the provision contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule is directory and not mandatory.
21. Supposing, however, that cl. 2 of the First Schedule is mandatory, we are of the view that its breach does not invalidate the award in the present case because the plaintiffs have by their conduct waived the non-compliance with that provision. After the expiry of the time specified in cl. 2 of the First Schedule for the appointment of an umpire, three meetings were held by the arbitrators and the plaintiffs appeared at those meetings and produced their evidence. They also agreed to the extension by the Court of the time for making the award. Having thus waived the non-compliance with cl. 2 of the First Schedule, the plaintiffs cannot object to the award on that ground.
22. In some of the cases cited above it was assumed that a directory provision is capable of being waived but not a mandatory provision. With respect, it does not appear to us that the principle of waiver is applicable to directory provisions only and that it cannot extend to mandatory provisions. There are two well recognised limitations to the application of the principle of waiver. In the first place, a party cannot waive a statutory requirement which has been inserted by the Legislature in the public interest as distinguished from the interest of the parties to an action. Secondly, the parties cannot by waiver invest a tribunal with a jurisdiction which it does not have. In “Craies on Statute Law”, the learned author has observed (6th edn., p. 269):
“If the object of a statute is not one of general policy, or if the thing which is being dona will benefit only a particular person or class of persons, then the conditions prescribed by the statute are not considered as being indispensable…. As a general rule, the conditions imposed by statutes which authorise legal proceedings are treated as being indispensable to giving the court jurisdiction. But if it appears that the statutory conditions were inserted by the legislature simply for the security or benefit of the parties to the action themselves, and that no public interests are involved, such conditions will not be considered as indispensable, and either party may waive them without affecting the jurisdiction of the court….”
23. The requirement contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule regarding the appointment of an umpire by the arbitrators is for the benefit of the parties to a reference and does not involve public interest. It is also clear that the appointment of an umpire is not a condition which determines the jurisdiction of the arbitrators to decide the dispute referred to them. It must follow that the requirement of cl. 2 of the First Schedule is capable of being waived.
24. As an instance of a mandatory provision which was held to have been waived by a party, we may refer to the decision of a Divisional Bench of this Court in Bandu Hari v. Bhagya Laxman . 1953 55 Bom. L.R 753.. In that case a notice under O. XXI, r. 22 of the Civil Procedure Code had not been issued to a judgment-debtor but the latter had actually appeared in execution proceedings and had raised various objections but not the objection regarding the failure to issue such a notice. The Court observed that the provision contained in O. XXI, r. 22 of the Civil Procedure Code regarding the issue of a notice to the judgment-debtor was mandatory, but that the provision was enacted for the benefit and protection of the judgment-debtors and can be waived by them.
25. In an effort to show that the principle of waiver cannot apply to the present case, Mr. Dhanuka relied on the decision of a Division Bench in Sherbanubai Jafferbhoy v. Hooseinbhoy . 1947 50 Bom. L.R 89.. In that case a reference to arbitration had been made by an order of the Court, and after the reference the parties agreed to confer on the arbitrator wider powers than those which were given by the Court's order of reference. It was held that the award made in the exercise of those wider powers was invalid. The Division Bench held that where a reference to arbitration is made without an order of the Court the parties are at liberty to agree to alter or amend the terms of reference, but that no such alteration or amendment can be made in a Court reference without an order of the Court to that effect. The Division Bench observed:
“Where, therefore, in a reference to arbitration by an order of the Court the parties desire that an arbitrator should have powers wider than or different from those originally conferred upon him by the order of the Court, the proper procedure for the parties to follow is to go back to the Court and get a frosh order of reference or get the original order of reference amended or altered but parties cannot by their mere consent confer upon the arbitrator powers different from those which the Court had originally conferred;…”
26. Relying on this decision Mr. Dhanuka argued that the provision contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule was by virtue of s. 25 of the Act incorporated in the decretal order of reference made by the City Civil Court in the present case, that the said term was incapable of being altered or amended by consent of parties without a fresh order of the Court to that effect, and that, therefore, the term was incapable of being waived by either party. We are unable to accept this ingenuous argument. When a party waives a certain provision he does not purport to vary or amend it. He merely agrees to its non-compliance. If waiver implied variation or amendment of the provision which is claimed to have been waived, there can never be any waiver of a statutory provision, for no party has the right of altering or amending a statute. The parties in the present case could not have altered or amended any of the terms of reference, express or implied, without the sanction of the Court, but this did not prevent them from waiving one of those terms.
27. Finally it was argued by Mr. Dhanuka that even if the provisions contained in cl. 2 of the First Schedule were held to be directory, the breach of that provision by the arbitrators amounts to legal misconduct and vitiates the award. There is no substance in this argument. Since the arbitrators did not disagree with each other, an umpire had no function to perform in the present arbitration, even if he were appointed in pursuance of cl. 2 of the First Schedule. The non-appointment of an umpire cannot, under the circumstances, amount to legal misconduct. In the result the appeal fails and is dismissed with costs.
28. Appeal dismissed.
Alert