- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ningappa Balappa And Others v. Abashkhan Gouskhan, .
Factual and Procedural Background
The respondent-plaintiff obtained a decree for partition and separate possession of his share in several agricultural lands in Suit No. 336 of 1947. This decree was passed in 1949 and confirmed by the High Court on 22-1-1952. Subsequently, on 5-11-1952, the case papers were sent to the Collector under Section 54 of the Civil Procedure Code (C.P.C) for effecting partition of the lands. In 1955, two applications were made by appellants claiming tenancy rights under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, seeking only symbolical possession to be delivered to the respondent-plaintiff without disturbing their actual possession. Both applications were rejected, and appeals were filed against these rejections, leading to the present appeals.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Court retains jurisdiction to entertain applications under Section 47 or Section 151 of the Civil Procedure Code to control or direct the Collector in executing a partition decree relating to lands assessed to Government revenue.
- Whether the tenancy rights under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, can prevent the execution of a partition decree passed prior to the commencement of the Act.
- Whether appellants who are tenants or lessees, some prior to and some after the suit, can invoke the Court's inherent powers or execution provisions to restrain possession delivery under the partition decree.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- Appellants 1 to 11 contended they were tenants of the suit lands since before the institution of the suit and thus could not be evicted under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948.
- They sought that only symbolical possession be delivered to the respondent-plaintiff without disturbing their actual possession.
- Appellants 1 to 14 in the Letters Patent Appeal argued that some lands had been leased to them after the suit date and made a similar prayer for symbolical possession.
- Reliance was placed on precedents such as Calicut Bank Ltd. v. Radhalakshmi and Mt. Aziz Patma v. Mukund Lal, where rights acquired during pendency of suit under local tenancy laws were recognized.
- They also invoked the inherent powers of the Court under Section 151 C.P.C as an alternative to Section 47.
Respondent-Plaintiff's Arguments
The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the respondent-plaintiff's arguments.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Jacinto v. Fernandez, AIR 1939 Bom 454 | Once a partition decree relating to government revenue assessed lands is passed, the Court’s duties end; the Collector must execute the partition and put parties into possession. | The Court relied on this precedent to hold that its role is finished after passing the decree and forwarding papers to the Collector, who acts independently to effect partition. |
| Ramabai Govind v. Anant Daji, AIR 1945 Bom 338 | Confirmed the limited judicial control the Court retains over the Collector's execution of the decree; control is only exercised if the Collector acts ultra vires or refuses to execute the decree. | The Court applied this to emphasize that no executing proceedings lie before it unless the Collector contravenes the decree or law. |
| Dev Gopal v. Vasudev Vithal, 12 Bom 371 | Clarified the limited scope of judicial control retained by the Court over partition decrees executed by the Collector. | Supported the principle that the Court’s control is very limited and does not extend to routine execution by the Collector. |
| Mt. Aziz Patma v. Mukund Lal, AIR 1932 All 480 | Recognized rights acquired during pendency of suit under local rent control and tenancy laws. | Appellants relied on this precedent to argue tenancy rights under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, but the Court distinguished it based on timing and nature of rights. |
| Calicut Bank Ltd. v. Radhalakshmi, AIR 1945 Mad 65 | Considered rights acquired under local tenancy laws during pendency of suit. | Appellants cited this to support their claim to tenancy rights preventing eviction, but the Court held the decree-holder’s rights accrued prior to the Act’s commencement prevail. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began by clarifying the legal framework governing partition decrees relating to lands assessed to Government revenue under Section 54, Civil P.C and Order 20 Rule 18. It relied on binding precedents establishing that once the Court passes a partition decree, its judicial role concludes and the Collector is responsible for executing the decree and delivering possession.
The Court emphasized that its control over the Collector’s execution is limited to instances where the Collector acts contrary to the decree, law, or refuses execution. In the present case, no such transgression by the Collector was alleged.
The applications filed under Section 47 C.P.C to direct the Collector to deliver only symbolical possession were held to be not maintainable, as executing proceedings cannot be entertained by the Court after decree issuance in such matters.
Regarding the appellants’ tenancy claims under the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, the Court examined Section 89(2) of the Act, which preserves rights existing before the Act’s commencement. Since the respondent-plaintiff’s rights accrued on the date of the suit, prior to the Act, they prevail over any tenancy rights acquired thereafter.
The Court rejected the appellants’ reliance on inherent powers under Section 151 C.P.C, noting that such powers cannot be invoked absent an allegation that the Collector intends to act contrary to the decree or law.
Consequently, the Court found no legal basis to interfere with the execution of the partition decree or to protect the appellants’ possession claims under the tenancy Act.
Holding and Implications
The appeals are dismissed with costs.
The Court held that after a partition decree relating to government revenue assessed lands is passed and confirmed, the judicial role ends, and the Collector is exclusively responsible for executing the decree. No executing proceedings or applications under Section 47 or Section 151 C.P.C can be entertained by the Court unless the Collector acts ultra vires or refuses execution.
Tenancy rights acquired after the commencement of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, cannot override rights accrued prior to the Act as embodied in the partition decree. The decision directly affects the parties by upholding the respondent-plaintiff’s right to possession and rejecting appellants’ claims to retain possession under tenancy laws.
No new precedent was established; the ruling reaffirms established principles regarding partition decrees and limited judicial control over execution by the Collector.
Chainani, J.:— The facts giving rise to these two appeals are briefly these: In Suit No. 336 of 1947 the respondent-plaintiff obtained a decree for partition and separate possession of his share in several agricultural lands. This decree was passed in 1949. It was confirmed in appeal by the High Court on 22-1-1952. On 5-11-1952, the papers were sent to the Collector under S. 54, Civil P.C for effecting partition of the lands.
2. On 11-1-1955, appellants 1 to 11 in First Appeal No. 292 of 1955 made an application (Ex. 88) to the Court. They stated in that application that they were tenants of the suit lands since before the institution of the suit and that they could not, therefore, be evicted from the lands in view of the provisions of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948.
3. They, therefore, prayed that the papers should be called for from the Collector & that an order should be made directing the Collector to deliver only symbolical possession of the lands to the respondent-plaintiff, without disturbing the actual possession of these appellants.
4. On the same day, 11-1-1955, another application Ex. 89 was made by the 14 appellants in Letters Patent Appeal No. 33 of 1955, in which they alleged that some of the suit lands had been leased to them after the date of the suit. They made a similar prayer as was made in Ex. 88 for an order to the Collector to deliver only symbolical possession of the lands to the respondent-plaintiff.
5. Both these applications were rejected. Against the orders passed on these applications P.A No. 292 of 1955 was filed by all the 25 persons who claimed to be tenants. This appeal came up for admission before Bavdekar J. He admitted the appeal of appellants 1 to 11 and dismissed the appeal of the other tenants. Against his order dismissing the appeal of the other tenants, Letters Patent Appeal No. 33 of 1955 has been filed.
6. As I have stated, the decree passed in the suit was a partition decree directing partition of the suit lands. Section 54, Civil P.C, provides that where the decree is for partition of lands assessed to the payment of revenue, the Collector or any gazetted subordinate of the Collector deputed by him in this behalf, in accordance with the law for the time being in force relating to partition.
7. O. 20 R. 18 provides that where the Court passes a decree for the partition of property, then if and in so far as the decree relates to an estate assessed to the payment of revenue to the Government, the decree shall declare the rights of the several parties interested in the property, but shall direct such partition or separation to be made by the Collector, or any gazetted subordinate of the Collector deputed by him in this behalf, in accordance with such declaration and with the provisions of S. 54.
8. It has been held by this Court in ‘Jacinto v. Fernandez’, AIR 1939 Bom 454 (A) that where a Court has passed a decree for partition of lands assessed to Govt. revenue the Court's duties are finished as soon as the decree is passed and that it is for the Collector to carry out the partition and put the parties into possession.
9. It was also observed in that case that in forwarding the papers to the Collector to carry out the partition directed by the decree, the Court performs only a ministerial Act. This decision has been approved by a Full Bench of this Court in ‘Ramabai Govind v. Anant Daji’, AIR 1945 Bom 338 at page 341 (B), Lokur, J. observed:
“As pointed out by Beaumont C.J in ‘Jacinto v. Fernandez’, (A) when an order in the form prescribed in O. 20, R. 18(1) is made, the Court's duties are finished, though as held in ‘Dev Gopal v. Vasudev Vithal’, 12 Bom 371 at p. 376 (C), the Court is not deprived of its judicial control of its decree. But that control is very limited.
It is only if the Collector contravenes the decretal order, or transgresses the law or otherwise acts ultra vires, or refuses to carry out the decree, that his action is liable to be controlled and corrected by the Court which passed the decree.
Apart from this limited control the Collector can give effect to the partition made by him, without waiting for confirmation by the Court, and deliver possession of the shares to the respective sharers.
Thus the court having nothing further to do with the decree passed by it under O. 20, R. 18(1). Beaumont C.J in AIR 1939 Bom 454 (A) described the order directing the partition of the lands assessed to Government revenue to be effected by the Collector as a final decree”.
10. Weston J. also agreed with this view and at pp. 343, 344 he observed that though the Collector was bound by the decision of the Court, he could not be said to be a ministerial officer of the Court.
11. According to these decisions, therefore, after a decree for partition of lands assessed to revenue has been passed, the Court has nothing further to do with the decree. The decree is to be executed and the partition is to be effected by the Collector.
12. There cannot, therefore, be any executing proceedings before the Court in the case of such a decree. The present applications, which are said to have been made under S. 47, C.P.C were therefore, not maintainable.
13. It is true that it has been held in several cases that the Court is not entirely deprived of controlling the action taken by the Collector. But this control is very limited. It is to be exercised only if the Collector contravenes the decretal order or transgresses the law relating to partition or refuses to execute the decree. See the cases cited at p. 228 of Sir Dinshaw Mulla's Code of Civil Procedure, 12th Edition.
14. In this case, it is not alleged that the Collector has acted or intends to act contrary to the decree or any law relating to partition. What is alleged is that the Collector might act contrary to the Provisions of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948.
15. But, as the Court's duties came to an end when it passed the decree and as no proceedings in execution can be taken by it, it is not open to the Court to entertain an application under S. 47 and give directions to the Collector in regard to the manner in which he should execute the decree.
16. Mr. Jahagirdar for the appellants has urged that even if the present applications cannot lie under S. 47, they may be treated as applications under S. 151. So far as appellants 1 to 11 in First Appeal No. 292 of 1955 are concerned, their case is that they have been cultivating the lands since prior to the date of the suit. They were not parties to the suit.
17. They cannot also be said to be representatives of the judgment-debtor; for, the lands are said to have been leased to them before the date of the suit. They are, therefore, really strangers to the suit and it is not open to them to make an application either under S. 47 or under S. 151, Civil P.C
18. As regards appellants 1 to 14 in Letters Patent Appeal No. 33 of 1955, the lands are said to have been let to them after the date of the suit. They can, therefore, be said to be representatives of the judgment-debtor within the meaning of S. 47.
19. But we do not think that even they can invoke the inherent powers of the Court under S. 151 when it is not alleged that the Collector has acted or intends to act contrary to the terms of the decree or contrary to any law relating to partition.
20. All that is alleged is that the Collector proposes to deprive them of their possession of the lands, contrary to the terms of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948, Mr. Jahagirdar has relied on Calicut Bank Ltd. v. Radhalakshmi, AIR 1945 Mad 65 (D) and Mt. Aziz Patma v. Mukund Lal, AIR 1932 All 480 (E) in which certain rights had been acquired during the pendency of the suit under the local rent control and tenancy laws.
21. He has also relied on the decision of this Court in First Appeal No. 144 of 1951 (Bom) (F). In that case the attention of the Court does not appear to have been invited to S. 89(2), Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948. This section saves all rights in respect of which a suit was pending at the date of its commencement.
22. Section 89(2)(b) of the Act provides that save as expressly provided in this Act, nothing in this Act shall affect or be deemed to affect any right, title or interest acquired before the commencement of the Act and any legal proceeding or remedy in respect of any such right, title or interest shall be continued and disposed of as if this Act was not passed.
23. The suit filed by the respondent-plaintiff was pending when the Act came into force in December 1948, though the decree was passed subsequently. The rights given to the respondent-plaintiff by the decree however had accrued to him on the date of the suit. He is, therefore, entitled to execute the decree as if the Act had not been passed.
24. His rights must, therefore, prevail over any rights acquired under the Act after its commencement; for if the Act had not been passed the decree-holder would have been entitled to obtain possession from all persons brought on the lands by the judgment-debtor after the date of the suit.
25. The rights, if any, acquired by the appellants in Letters Patent Appeal No. 33 of 1955 by their leases cannot, therefore, affect the right of the respondent-plaintiff to obtain possession of his share in the suit lands, which had accrued to him before the commencement of the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948.
26. Both the appeals must, therefore, fail and are dismissed with costs.
D.H.Z
Appeals dismissed.
Alert