- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dawoodali Rahemtulla Versi (Original Claimant), v. The State Of Bombay (Original Opponent), .
Factual and Procedural Background
In January 1948 the Government of Bombay requisitioned rooms in two chawls at Gundavli, Andheri by orders dated 23 January 1948 (later modified 30 January 1948). The modified order requisitioned all 18 rooms and allotted them to the tenants in occupation on terms that included a monthly charge of Rs. 25 (Rs. 22 rent + Rs. 3 water), notice requirements and a proviso that the allotment was subject to any further conditions Government might impose.
The Bombay Land Requisition Act (XXXIII of 1948) came into force on 11 April 1948, repealing the earlier Ordinance but continuing the requisitions as if made under the Act. Section 8(1) of the Act required payment of compensation to owners for requisitioned property and directed that an authorised officer should hold an inquiry, guided so far as applicable by provisions of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894. Rules to determine compensation were framed and published in 1949.
After the rules were published, the allottees asked the Government to settle the compensation payable to the owner. They also contended that the Rs. 25 monthly charge was excessive. The Compensation Officer issued notice to the owner under the 1949 Rules, held an inquiry and, by order dated 24 January 1951, determined the fair and reasonable compensation for each of the 18 rooms at Rs. 10 per month (rent) plus Rs. 3 per month (water) plus permissible Municipal General Tax, payable from the date of occupation, subject to the owner executing a prescribed agreement. The owner appealed to this Court under section 8 clause (3) of the Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether proceedings to ascertain compensation initiated at the instance of the allottees were maintainable.
- Whether the terms of allotment (including the Rs. 25 monthly charge) constituted a contract between the allottees and the owner, thereby binding the allottees and affecting the owner's claim to statutory compensation.
- Whether the Compensation Officer applied correct principles in ascertaining compensation (i.e., the correct basis and factors to determine compensation for loss of user under the Act).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant (Owner)'s Arguments
- The proceedings before the Compensation Officer, commenced at the instance of the allottees, were not maintainable.
- The Government's requisition and the subsequent allotment on stated terms constituted a contract between the owner and the allottees, binding the allottees (and implying that payments due under the allotment affected the owner's compensation rights).
- The Compensation Officer's ascertainment of compensation was based on erroneous principles.
Allottees' Contentions
- The allotment condition requiring payment of Rs. 25 per month was excessive and unreasonable and therefore not binding on them.
- They requested the Compensation Officer to ascertain a reasonable compensation for the owner.
Compensation Officer / Government Position (as reflected in the proceedings)
- The Compensation Officer proceeded under r.4(c) of the Bombay Land Requisition (Determination of Compensation) Rules, 1949, issuing notice to the owner and holding an inquiry under s. 8(1) of the Act.
- The Compensation Officer concluded that the allotment terms were conditional and not final, and therefore he had jurisdiction to inquire and determine fair compensation under the Act.
- After evidence, the Compensation Officer determined the fair rental value at Rs. 10 per month plus Rs. 3 water charges and permissible taxes, and linked payment to the date of occupation subject to the owner executing a form “B” agreement.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Chaturbhuj v. Province of Bombay (Division Bench) | Held that an allottee has no right to appeal against the Compensation Officer's decision and that the allottee has no locus standi in compensation proceedings; established that an allottee is a licensee of the Government (not a tenant) under the Act's scheme. | The Court relied on this precedent to confirm that allottees lack locus standi in compensation proceedings and to support the view that allotments do not create privity of contract between owner and allottee; payments by allottees are effectively on behalf of Government. |
| Bengal Province v. Board of Trustees for the Improvement of Calcutta (Calcutta High Court) | In context of requisition under Defence of India Rules, observed that requisition deprives owner of possession and that the basis of compensation must be fair rent (the requisitioning authority is akin to a statutory tenant for compensation purposes). | The Court cited this passage to support the conclusion that compensation based on fair rent, considering relevant restrictions, is an adequate basis for periodic compensation for loss of user. |
| Mohd. Ekramal Haque v. Bengal Province (Calcutta High Court) | Held that in requisition cases the market value should be assessed on the basis of a notional fair rent of a hypothetical tenant, and that restrictive legislation like Rent Control Orders should not be taken into account when assessing that notional rent. | The appellant relied on this case. The Court discussed and rejected the approach that rent restrictive legislation should be ignored; it treated Mohd. Ekramal Haque as supporting the opposite view and declined to follow it for assessing periodic compensation. |
| Collector of Darjeeling v. G. Mackertich (Calcutta High Court) | Held that market value for possessory interest in requisition cases must reflect the realities of the market, which include the existence of Rent Control Orders; therefore the owner could not claim a higher value than would be realized under the Rent Control Order. | The Court accepted the principles laid down in this case as correctly stating how to assess compensation based on fair rent and applied those principles to hold that rent restriction statutes must be taken into account in ascertaining periodic compensation. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded stepwise, following the statutory framework and the evidence recorded by the Compensation Officer:
- Jurisdiction and maintainability: Section 8(1) of the Bombay Land Requisition Act imposes an obligation on a competent officer to hold an inquiry to determine compensation and to be guided by relevant provisions of the Land Acquisition Act. Although the rules require an application by the owner (Rule 3), an owner's application is not a condition precedent to the initiation of the statutory inquiry. Therefore, proceedings started at the request of the allottees are not necessarily without jurisdiction or not maintainable.
- Locus standi of allottees and nature of relationship: The Court accepted the principle (drawn from Chaturbhuj) that the allottee becomes a licensee of the Government and does not acquire privity of contract with the owner simply by reason of the Government's allotment. Consequently, the allottee has no locus to raise or defend compensation proceedings as if he were a private landlord/tenant in relation to the owner, and payments made by allottees to the owner are regarded as being made on behalf of the Government.
- Whether allotment terms constituted a contract affecting compensation: The Court held that the terms of the Collector's allotment could not operate as a contract between the owner and the allottees (no order under s.9A made them tenants). The liability to pay compensation rests on the Government as requisitioning authority, irrespective of any charge the Government may levy on allottees for occupation.
- Basis for ascertaining compensation: Section 8(1) requires the Compensation Officer to determine as he deems just "having regard to all the circumstances" and to be guided by ss. 23(1) and 24 of the Land Acquisition Act "in so far as they can be made applicable." The Court explained that where the Government acquires only the right of user for an indefinite period (not full ownership), the appropriate compensation is a periodic payment representing the value of the user's loss.
- Effect of Rent Restriction legislation: The Court addressed competing authorities from the Calcutta High Court. It rejected the submission that rent restrictive legislation should be ignored in determining the notional market value; instead, the Court held that statutory restrictions (such as the Rent Restriction Act) are material circumstances existing at the time of requisition and must be taken into account. The Court endorsed Collector of Darjeeling v. G. Mackertich as correctly stating the applicable approach and declined to follow the contrary approach in Mohd. Ekramal Haque.
- Application to facts: The Compensation Officer found standard rent at Rs. 5 per month and, after considering repairs, area, amenities and the Collector's order (which had been acquiesced in), fixed compensation at Rs. 10 per month plus Rs. 3 water charges and permissible municipal tax. The Court noted that this quantum of compensation was not challenged substantively.
- Required modification to the Compensation Officer's order: The Court concluded that an order for payment "by each respective tenant" was impermissible because the allottees had no locus in the compensation proceedings; the proper defendant/obligor is the Government. The Court therefore struck out the words making payment by tenants and added a clause crediting any payments in fact made by allottees toward the Government's liability.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
APPEAL DISMISSED.
The Court upheld the Compensation Officer's determination of compensation (Rs. 10 per month as rent plus Rs. 3 per month as water charges plus permissible Municipal General Tax) subject to the following modification:
- The words in the Compensation Officer's order that made payment to the owner "by each respective tenant as ordered by Government on January 30, 1948" were struck out.
- The Court substituted a clause that any payments made by the allottees to the owner, or which may be made directly to the owner under any arrangement between the allottees and the Government, shall be credited towards the liability of the Government to pay compensation at the rate fixed by the Court.
Implications and consequences:
- The direct effect on the parties is that the Government (the requisitioning authority) is liable to pay the compensation fixed by the Compensation Officer (as varied), and allottees are not the proper parties against whom payment orders in the compensation proceedings may be made.
- The Court applied existing statutory principles and prior case law to explain the correct basis for periodic compensation for loss of user and to determine that statutory rent-restriction regimes must be taken into account; the opinion does not purport to purport the establishment of a novel departure from established principles but applies and endorses authorities (notably Collector of Darjeeling v. G. Mackertich) for the approach it adopts.
Order: Appeal dismissed with costs; Compensation Officer's order modified as indicated.
Shah, J.:—
By two orders dated January 23, 1948 the Government of Bombay in exercise of the powers conferred by sub-s. (4) of s. 4 of the Bombay Land Requisition Ordinance of 1947 requisitioned 8 out of 9 rooms in Chawl No. 200 and 9 rooms in Chawl No. 201 of ‘Versey Colony’ at Gundavli, Andheri. By the same orders the Government directed the Inspector of Land Requisition to allot the rooms to the tenants whose names were mentioned in a list supplied to that officer, on such conditions ‘as may be found necessary.’ The orders were modified by order dated January 30, 1948 and all the 18 rooms in the two chawls were requisitioned and were allotted to the tenants in occupation thereof. The terms of allotment in so far as they are material were:—
“(1) Monthly rent of each room will be Rs. 25 including water-charges but excluding electricity charges; Rs. 22 will be the rent and Rs. 3 will be the water-charges…. (3) The tenants should give one calender month's notice in case of their vacating failing which they are liable to forfeit one month's rent in lieu of the calender month's notice. (4) In case the tenant vacates after giving due notice the landlord shall return the balance of the rent to the tenant and intimate to this office of his having done so. (5) As already indicated in this office Order No. R.E.Q.O.R.D 7 dated January 23, 1948, the allotment of this tenancy is subject to such conditions as may be imposed by Government hereafter in similar cases.”
The Bombay Land Requisition Act (XXXIII of 1948) came into operation on April 11, 1948. By s. 20 of that Act the Bombay Land Requisition Ordinance of 1947 was repealed, but the orders for requisition and the requisition made thereunder continued as if the same were made under Act XXXIII of 1948. Section 8 sub-s. (1) of Bombay Act XXXIII of 1948 provides for payment of compensation to the owner of the property requisitioned. Section 19 confers upon the State Government power to make rules to carry into effect the purposes of the Act. Even though the Act was passed in 1948, the rules under which compensation was to be ascertained for requisition of premises under the Act were not made by the Government of Bombay till the year 1949. They were first published in June 1949. The Rules are printed on pages 167 onwards of Vol. I of Rules and Orders under Bombay Act, (1951 edition). After the rules were framed the allottees applied to the Government to settle the amount of compensation payable under s. 8 clause (1) to the owner of the premises.
The allottees contended that the condition of allotment requiring them to pay Rs. 25 per month was not binding as rent was excessive and unreasonable. They requested the Compensation Officer to ascertain reasonable compensation. The Compensation Officer thereupon issued a notice to the owner State under r. 4(c) of the Bombay Land Requisition (Determination of Compensation) Rules, 1949, requiring him to produce any documentary or other evidence in support of his claim for compensation. The owner thereupon appeared before the Compensation Officer and contended that the Compensation Officer had no jurisdiction to enter upon an inquiry. The Compensation Officer held that the “rent terms” dated January 30, 1948 “and contained in paragraph 5 making the allotment conditional, subject to such conditions as may be imposed by Government thereafter in similar cases,” showed that the “rent terms” arrived at by the Collector were not final and the Compensation Officer who was authorised by the Government under s. 8(1) of the Bombay Land Requisition Act, 1948, had a right to proceed with the inquiry for the purpose of determining compensation. The Compensation Officer recorded the evidence led before him and came to the conclusion that the owner was charging rent from his tenants at the rate of Rs. 5 per month in respect of each room in the year 1942-1943. Having regard to the expenses incurred for making the repairs, having regard to the area of the rooms and the amenities provided by him and after taking into account the order of the Collector which had been acquiesced in by the allottees, by his order dated January 24, 1951 the Compensation Officer declared under r. 4(3) of the Bombay Land Requisition (Determination of Compensation) Rules 1949 that the fair and reasonable rate of compensation for each of the 18 requisitioned rooms was determined at Rs. 10 per month in respect of rent plus Rs. 3 per month as water charges plus permissible additional Municipal General Tax and ordered that same be paid to the owner from the date of occupation of each room by the respective tenant, as ordered by Government on January 30, 1948, subject to the condition that the owner executes an agreement in form “B” prescribed for the purposes under the rules. The owner has appealed to this Court under s. 8 cl. (3) of the Act.
The conclusion of the Compensation Officer that Rs. 10 per month is the fair rental, having regard to the circumstances has not been challenged before me. But three points have been urged by Counsel for the owner in support of the appeal: (1) That the proceedings commenced at the instance of the allottees were not maintainable; (2) that the Government having requisitioned the premises and having rented the same to the allottees on certain terms and conditions, the conditions constituted a contract between the allottees and the owner and the allottees were bound by that contract. (3) The ascertainment of compensation cannot be sustained because it is based on erroneous principles.
It appears that the proceedings for ascertaining compensation were initiated after the application was submitted by the allottees to the Government. It is also true that in the proceedings for ascertaining compensation the allottees have no locus standi. The proceedings for ascertaining compensation are between the Government as the requisitioning authority, and the owner whose property is requisitioned. The liability to pay compensation is of the requisitioning authority and the person to whom the land or the premises were allotted have nothing whatever to do with the proceedings for ascertaining compensation. In Chaturbhuj v. Province of Bombay(5) it has been held by a Division Bench of this Court that the allottee has no right to appeal against the decision of the Compensation Officer as he has no locus standi to appear in those proceedings. But s. 8 cl. (1) imposes an obligation upon the Compensation Officer to hold an inquiry for ascertaining compensation payable to the owner. The rules framed under s. 19 do require that the owner should make an application (see Rule 3) for ascertaining compensation. When however s. 8 imposes an obligation upon the Compensation Officer to make an inquiry as to compensation, an application by the owner is not a condition precedent to the initiation of the proceedings and even if the proceedings are started on a request made by the allottees they cannot be regarded as without jurisdiction and consequently not maintainable.
The order of the Collector, Bombay Suburban District, under which the rooms were requisitioned and allotted was made subject to certain terms and conditions. Those terms and conditions did not and could not operate as a contract between the owner and the allottees. After requisition the premises were given by the Government to the allottees and the allottees became the licensees of the Government. The liability for payment of compensation rests under s. 8 of the Act upon the Government, as the requisitioning authority. The Government may levy a charge from the allottees in consideration of allowing them a right of occupation, but that can have no bearing on the amount of compensation payable by the Government to the owner. In this connection the following observations made by a Division Bench of this Court in the case of Chaturbhuj v. Province of Bombay(6) are pertinent (p. 999):—
“Under the scheme of the Bombay Land Requisition Act, it appears Shah J. that the requisition is to be made by Government and it is Government who are liable to pay the compensation in respect of the premises requisitioned. Under sub-s. (3) of s. 8B the allotment of any land to any person, or the continuance of any person or the permission to any person to continue to remain in occupation or possession of any land, referred to in sub-s. (1), shall be deemed to be a licence in favour of such person for the use and occupation of the said land. Therefore, even after the requisition, the person permitted to remain in occupation or the person to whom the requisitioned premises are allotted becomes a licensee of Government. Formerly, under s. 9A of the Act, which has been subsequently repealed, it was within the competence of Government to make the allottee a tenant of the premises requisitioned and the relationship of landlord and tenant arose between the allottee and the person whose premises were requisitioned. But s. 9A has been deleted and the person to whom the requisitioned premises are allotted continues to hold them as a mere licensee from Government under sub-s. (3) of s. 8B.”
Therefore even if the allottees were permitted to pay the charges agreed to be paid by them to the Government, directly to the owner, the allottees could not be regarded as tenants of the owner, and the payments made by the allottees must be regarded as made on behalf of Government. It is true that under s. 9A of the Act (which has since been repealed by Bombay Act V of 1952), it was open to the Government to make an allottee of requisitioned premises a tenant thereof. No order was however made under the provisions of s. 9A of the Bombay Land Requisition Act making the allottees tenants of the owner, and consequently the allottees cannot be regarded as tenants of the owner by reason of the order of allotment. As stated earlier, the liability for payment of compensation rests upon the Government and it is no concern of the owner whether the Government recovers anything from the allottee for allowing him to occupy the premises requisitioned. Under the Act requisition may be made for the purpose of the State or for public purposes. But if there is a valid requisition the subsequent allotment does not create any privity of contract between the allottee and the owner of the property. It may be that Government in view of special circumstances give the premises requisitioned for occupation to an allottee free of charge, but thereby the Government cannot escape liability to Pay compensation to the owner. It may also happen that the Government makes a charge in excess of fair or economic rent of the premises, but provided the requisition is lawful the extent of the liability of the Government as requisitioning authority cannot be judged by reference to such charges. The allottee is a licensee of the Government, and the charge made by the Government, if any, has no bearing on the liability of the Government to pay compensation to the owner. If the allottee fails to pay rent and the same cannot be recovered or the premises remain unoccupied, the liability of the requisitioning authority to pay compensation may not thereby be affected. The “rent terms” in the order of the Collector cannot be regarded as a contract between the owner and the allottees. In any event, the owner is not entitled to recover anything more than the amount of compensation which is required to be ascertained under s. 8 of the Act and the owner's right to statutory compensation cannot be prejudiced even if the requisitioning authority does not collect or is unable to collect the charges for which the allottees are permitted to occupy the requisitioned premises. The mere fact therefore that under the order of allotment the allottees were required to pay rent at the rate of Rs. 25 per month for occupation of the premises and were also required to pay the amount directly to the owner does not deprive the Compensation Officer of his authority to ascertain the amount of compensation payable to the owner.
The method of ascertaining compensation is set out in s. 8 sub-s. (1). That sub-section states:—
“When any land is requisitioned or is continued to be subject to requisition under this Act, there shall be paid, subject to the provisions of s. 7, compensation to persons for the interest in such land the amount of which shall be determined by an officer authorised in this behalf by the State Government who shall hold an inquiry in the manner prescribed. The officer shall determine such amount as he deems just having regard to all the circumstances of the case; and in particular he shall be guided by the provisions of sub-s. (1) of s. 23 and s. 24 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894, in so far as they can be made applicable.”
Now, when the Government do not acquire the entire interest of the owner in the premises by requisition, but merely acquire the right of user for an indefinite period, the ownership of the premises is not affected thereby. In the very nature of things the compensation to be awarded to the owner in those circumstances is not the value of the property but the value of the user to which he is entitled and of which he is under the authority of law expropriated. Inasmuch as the requisition is not for a fixed period and the premises may be released from requisition at any time by the Government, the compensation must of necessity be a periodical payment which is to enure so long as the owner remains deprived of the use of his property. Section 8 requires that the Compensation Officer shall be guided by ss. 23(1) and 24 of the Land Acquisition Act, in so far as those provisions may be applicable. In the application of those provisions to cases where there is a requisition, that is, expropriation of a limited interest for a period of undefined duration, the expression “land” must mean “the user of the land” and the expression “market value” under s. 23(1) must be the periodic payment which a willing owner may expect to receive in an open market from a willing transferee as consideration for parting with the right of user in favour of the transferee who is at liberty at any time to abandon the transfer but who cannot be compelled so long as he is unwilling to surrender it. It is true that such transfers are rarely made voluntarily. But a monthly tenancy protected by the normal rent restriction statute is the nearest equivalent to it and the rent that such a monthly tenant may pay affords a fairly accurate basis for ascertaining the periodic compensation to be rendered.
It is true that the inability of the owner to compel the requisitioning authority to vacate does to a certain extent theoretically reduce the value of the reversion to the owner and he may be justified in claiming additional compensation for that reduction. But in view of the stringent provisions of the Rent Restriction Act which have considerably reduced the value of the reversion to the owner and have imposed upon him severe restriction on the general liberty of contract between landlord and tenants, that theoretical reduction in the value of the reversion may be regarded as amply compensated by the comparatively greater security of the amount of compensation payable and by the regularity in payment thereof. It is also true that under s. 8A of the Act an owner may be compelled by the Government to execute the necessary repairs and on his failure to keep the premises in a good and tenantable condition the Government may cause such repairs to be executed at the expense of the owner and recover the costs thereof. But the provision by which an owner is entitled when the premises are released from requisition to compensation for any deterioration caused to the premises otherwise than by reasonable wear and tear or irresistible force, confers an advantage upon the owner, whose premises are requisitioned, over a landlord who has demised the premises to a private tenant. In my view, therefore, the rent which the premises would fetch, having regard to the provisions of any Rent Restriction Statutes operative at the time of the requisition, must be accepted as an adequate basis for ascertaining the periodic compensation to be made to the owner.
In Bengal Province v. Board of Trustees for the Improvement of Calcutta,(7) a Bench of the Calcutta High Court, in dealing with compensation to be awarded to an owner of premises requisitioned under Rule 75A of the Defence of India Rules, observed at page 423:—
“The effect of a requisition under the defence of india rules is to deprive the owner of his possession. He must, therefore, get the value of his possession. Looking from another aspect, the requisitioning authority gets the possession from the owner and becomes, so to say, a statutory tenant. The basis of compensation must, therefore, be fair rent.”
Without endorsing the view that a requisitioning authority is in the position of a statutory tenant of the owner whose property is requisitioned, in my view, compensation based on the fair rent which the premises would fetch in an open market having regard to the relevant Rent Restriction legislation operative at the time of requisition would be adequate compensation to the owner for the loss suffered by him.
Counsel for the appellant has contended that the market value for the loss of user must be ascertained on the basis of an economic rent which a willing tenant may pay to a willing landlord without reference to the restrictions imposed by the Rent Restriction Act. Counsel has urged that requisition does not create any relation of landlord and tenant between the owner and the requisitioning authority and the value of the loss of user to the owner who is not willing to let out his premises cannot be arrived at by ascertaining the rent which a tenant may pay under the restrictive legislation which imposes disabilities upon the landlord and interferes with the liability of contract. I am unable to accept that contention. Section 8 of the Act requires that in ascertaining compensation the Compensation Officer must be guided by s. 23 and s. 24 of the Land Acquisition Act. Section 24 of that Act requires the Court in ascertaining compensation inter alia to exclude from consideration “any disinclination of the person interested to part with the land acquired.” Therefore the Court must ignore that disinclination of the owner to part with possession of the premises to be requisitioned and he must be assumed to be a willing transferor. It is true that in ascertaining the market value the Court must have regard to the value of the property to the owner in its actual condition at the time when he is expropriated with all its existing advantages and potentialities; but the value must be ascertained in the light of circumstances existing at the time of requisition and not divorced therefrom. Any circumstance which puts statutory restrictions upon the liberty of contract or otherwise depreciates the value must be taken into consideration. In my view, therefore, the provisions of the Rent Restriction Act cannot be excluded in ascertaining the periodic compensation.
Counsel for the owner has relied upon a judgment of the Calcutta High Court reported in Mohd. Ekramal Haque v. Bengal Province(8) and particularly upon the observations made at page 84 columns 1 and 2 to the following effect:—
“It is clear that in case of a requisition, where possession is taken, and there is not a complete acquisition of ownership of the land or building, compensation has to be assessed under s. 23, Land Acquisition Act on the basis of fair market value for such interest in land. The relationship created is not that of a landlord and a tenant. The requisition is by the Government by virtue of its suzerain position by which it can forcibly take away any one's property. It is the superior authority which the State possesses by virtue of which such compulsory acquisition or requisition is made. It does not bring about any actual relationship of landlord and tenant. Therefore, the Rent Control Order or other legislation or executive order with the backing of legislation have very little direct bearing upon the assessment of compensation. The market value of the interest taken away from the owner has got to be assessed. …………Therefore, in deciding upon fair rent, for the purpose of s. 23, Land Acquisition Act, it must be a notional fair rent of a hypothetical tenant, and the assessment of such notional fair rent must be based upon a consideration which does not take into account restrictions temporarily imposed by any restrictive executive order or legislation like Rent Control Order etc. The assessment in practice should be as if it was of a house of like nature let out for the first time to a tenant who is not compelled to take it up and by a landlord who is not compelled to let it out. The practical method will be to assess rent as if it was a new house for the first time let out on that date.”
It is difficult to accept the view that the ‘notional fair rent’ must be ascertained unaffected by the rent restrictive legislation operative at the date of requisition. The rent which a building fetches depends upon a variety of circumstances, such as the nature of the construction, the locality, the convenience provided for the parties for which the building may be used, the surroundings and the general economic conditions and the statutory restrictions imposed by legislation upon the quantum of rent which may be charged. The rent ascertained without considering all the circumstances and especially the legislative restrictions may in my view be regarded as unreal rent. It is true that a relation of landlord and tenant does not result from requisition. But if the test for ascertaining compensation is the loss which the owner may suffer by being compelled to part with the land, the real basis for compensation can only be that which the owner would have obtained if he had parted with his right of possession to a willing transferee at the time of expropriation. If the Statute imposes a limit upon what can legitimately be regarded as rent, any attempt to ignore the provisions of the Rent Restriction Statute would be to ascertain rent by imputing to the parties an intention to agree to an unreal rent the liability for payment of which cannot be enforced by legal proceedings. It has to be noted that another Bench of the Calcutta High Court took a view different from the one stated in Mohd. Ekramal Haque's case. That case is reported in Collector of Darjeeling v. G. Mackertich(9). The learned Judge observed at page 308 after referring to the decision in Mohd. Ekramal Haque's case:—
“The above observations (observations on page 84 of Mohd. Ekramal Haque's case, which have been set out earlier) are somewhat broadly stated. In a case of requisition the Court is called upon to assess the market value of the possessory interest of the owner in the premises in question. Such a market value cannot be determined in the abstract. Market value means the value which a willing seller may expect from a willing purchaser in the open market. Transactions in the open market will be motived by the fact that the premises is subject to an order under the Rent Control Order. If the land had not been requisitioned the owner could have realised nothing more than the rent as determined under the Rent Control Order during the subsistence of that order. The owner cannot claim a higher value of his interest because of the requisition.”
In my view the case reported in Collector of Darjeeling v. G. Mackertich lays down the correct principles for ascertaining the compensation based on fair rent in respect of premises requisitioned.
The Compensation Officer has held that the standard rent of the room was Rs. 5 per month. He has then taken into consideration the amount spent by the owner and has also taken into consideration the contract between the Government and the allottees and has ascertained the compensation at Rs. 10 per month in respect of rent plus Rs. 3 per month as water charges plus permissible additional Municipal General Tax. That conclusion is not challenged. The only challenge was as to the applicability of the correct principles.
The order passed by the Compensation Officer must however be modified in certain respects. There can be no order for payment against the allottees. The allottees had no locus standi before the Compensation Officer and no order can be passed against them. The order should have been made by the Compensation Officer against the Government.
Accordingly I modify the order by striking out the words “by each respective tenant as ordered by Government on January 30, 1948” from the last paragraph of the judgment of the Compensation Officer. I further add the following clause:—
“Any payments made by the allottees to the owner or which may under any arrangement by the allottees with the Government be made directly to the owner shall be credited towards the liability of the Government to pay compensation at the rate hereby fixed.”
Subject to that variation the order of the Compensation Officer is upheld. The appeal is dismissed with costs.
Appeal dismissed.
K.B.S
Alert