- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Abdullabhai Abdul Kader v. Commissioner Of Income Tax, Bombay City
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from a reference before the court on March 22, 1950, concerning the appointment of the assessee as a statutory agent under section 43 of the Income Tax Act for the non-resident Haji Mahomed Syed Alberbary. The Tribunal was directed to submit a supplementary statement of the case, which raised various questions. The assessee was appointed statutory agent for the assessment years 1943-1944, 1944-1945, and 1945-1946, although the non-resident principal died on March 26, 1946, before the appointment order dated June 27, 1946. The Tribunal found that the assessee acted as a commission agent for the non-resident for several years, entering into numerous transactions under his instructions, though not as the sole selling agent. The court was tasked with interpreting the scope of "business connection in the taxable territories" under section 42 and the validity of the statutory agency appointment under section 43.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the assessee can be assessed as a statutory agent under section 43 for the years 1943-1944, 1944-1945, and 1945-1946 despite the death of the non-resident principal before the appointment order.
- What is the true meaning of the expression "any business connection in the taxable territories" under section 42, and when can a non-resident be said to have such a connection rendering him liable to tax.
- Whether the agency connecting the non-resident with the assessee must be of a permanent and exclusive character to constitute a business connection under section 42.
- This question was withdrawn by the Solicitor General and is not answered.
- Whether the additional question raised on the supplementary statement of the case should be answered in the affirmative.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The assessee, represented by Sir Jamshedji, argued that the appointment of the statutory agent under section 43 for the years after the non-resident’s death was invalid, as the death of the principal ends any agency relationship.
- He contended that the agency connecting the non-resident with the assessee must be permanent and exclusive to constitute a business connection under section 42.
- He relied heavily on the Allahabad High Court decision in Hira Mills Ltd., Cawnpore v. Income-Tax Officer, emphasizing that the agent must be "retained" by the principal, implying a contractual obligation to act as an agent.
Court's Observations on Arguments
- The court distinguished statutory agency under section 43 from contractual agency, noting that statutory agents can be appointed posthumously based on the business connection during the accounting year.
- The court rejected the requirement that the agency must be permanent and exclusive, holding instead that some element of continuity is necessary but not exclusivity.
- The court interpreted the term "retained" in the Allahabad High Court decision as meaning employment or engagement, not necessarily a contractual obligation, and found that the facts did not support the appellant’s narrow reading.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Hira Mills Ltd., Cawnpore v. Income-Tax Officer, Cawnpore (Allahabad High Court) | Definition and scope of "business connection" under section 42; requirement of agency being "retained" by principal. | The court clarified that "retained" means employed or engaged, not necessarily under contractual obligation; the precedent was distinguished on facts and not accepted as requiring exclusivity or permanence. |
| Commissioner of Income-tax, Burma v. Steel Brothers & Co. Ltd. (Rangoon High Court) | Broad construction of "business connection" to include branches, factorship, agency, etc. | The court agreed with the Bombay High Court that this view was too narrow and that the term should be interpreted widely. |
| Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. National Mutual Association of Australasia Ltd. | Interpretation of "business connection" as a broad and inclusive term. | The court adopted this broader interpretation over the Rangoon High Court's narrower view. |
| Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay v. Metro-Goldwyn Mayer (India) Ltd. | Requirement of some element of continuity in the business connection under section 42. | The court cited this authority to support the view that continuity is necessary but exclusivity is not. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analyzed the nature of statutory agency under section 43, distinguishing it from contractual agency by emphasizing that appointment can be made after the death of the principal if the relevant business connection existed during the accounting year. The court interpreted "business connection in the taxable territories" under section 42 as a broad and deliberately vague term, meant to include various forms of business presence in India beyond mere transactions with Indian customers. The court rejected the appellant’s narrow interpretation requiring permanence and exclusivity of agency, instead holding that continuity of agency is essential but not exclusivity. The court found on the facts that the assessee’s commission agency was of sufficient continuity and substance to constitute a business connection. The court carefully examined the precedent relied upon by the appellant, clarifying that the need for an agent to be "retained" means engagement or employment, not necessarily a contractual obligation, and found the appellant’s reading too restrictive. Ultimately, the court concluded that the non-resident had a business connection in India and that the appointment of the statutory agent was valid for the relevant years.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court answered the questions submitted in the affirmative (except one withdrawn and one answered negatively), specifically holding that the assessee was rightly treated as a statutory agent under section 43 for the accounting years 1942-1943 through 1945-1946, and that the non-resident had a business connection in India within the meaning of section 42.
Implications: This decision confirms that statutory agency under section 43 can be appointed posthumously based on the business connection during the relevant accounting year. It clarifies the interpretation of "business connection in the taxable territories" as requiring continuity but not exclusivity or permanent contractual agency. The ruling emphasizes a broad and practical approach to business connection, avoiding narrow or overly technical constructions. The direct effect is to uphold the Department's assessment and the appointment of the statutory agent in this case. No new precedent beyond the facts and legal interpretation provided is established.
Chagla, C.J:—
This reference was before us on March 22, 1950. On that day we directed the Tribunal to submit a supplementary statement of the case. That supplementary statement has now been submitted by the Tribunal; and on this supplementary statement various questions arise which have got to be considered.
The first question which has been argued by Sir Jamshedji on behalf of the assessee is, that with regard to the assessment years 1943-1944, 1944-1945 and 1945-1946 his client cannot be assessed as an agent under s. 43 in view of the death of the non-resident. Now, the facts which are necessary to be considered with regard to this contention are that the assessee was appointed a statutory agent under s. 43 for the year 1942-1943 on March 12, 1945. The non-resident died on March 26, 1946, and the orders appointing the assessee statutory agent with regard to assessment years 1943-1944, 1944-1945 and 1945-1946 were passed on June 27, 1946. Sir Jamshedji's contention is-that inasmuch as the non-resident was dead, no order can be passed after his death, appointing the assessee as statutory agent. It is perfectly true that when one has to deal with a contractual agency, death of the principal brings the agency to an end. But under s. 43 we are dealing, not with a contractual agency, but with a statutory agency, and a statutory agent can be appointed under s. 43 provided the conditions laid down in that section are satisfied; and the conditions necessary are that any person employed by or on behalf of the person residing out of the taxable territories or having any business connections with such person or through whom such person is in the receipt of any income, profits or gains can be appointed a statutory agent. Now the employment contemplated, the business connection contemplated, and the receipt of income contemplated by this section are all within the accounting year. We are concerned here with business connection; therefore, if there was a business connection in the year of account, a statutory agent can be appointed under s. 43, notwithstanding the fact that at the date of the appointment of the statutory agent the non-resident was not alive. The material and relevant period to consider is, not the date of the appointment of the statutory agent, but the period covering the year of account. Now, admittedly during the accounting period the non-resident was alive; and we are concerned with the business connection which he had within the taxable territories. Therefore, the Department was within its rights in appointing the assessee the statutory agent on June 27, 1946, notwithstanding the fact that the non-resident died on March 26, 1946.
The next question urged by Sir Jamshedji is a much more important and interesting question; and the question that falls to be considered is, what is the true meaning to be given to the expression used by the Legislature in s. 42 “any business connection in the taxable territories”? When can it be said that a non-resident has a business connection in the taxable territories so as to render him liable to pay tax under s. 42 on the ground that income has deemed to accrue or arise within the taxable territories. Now, before considering the question of law it is necessary, to state the facts of this particular case.
It has not been found by the Tribunal that the non-resident, Haji Mahomed Syed Alberbary, had been exporting or importing goods only through the assessee. The Tribunal has also held that the assessee was not the sole selling agent of the non-resident. But it has also been found by the Tribunal that the assessee acted as a commission agent of the non-resident for several years and that the assessee entered into several transactions on behalf of the non-resident. The Income-tax Officer who has made an order, under s. 43 found that the assessee had been regularly purchasing and selling goods, on behalf of the non-resident and under his instructions. The assessee also transacted ready and forward business in cotton piecegoods and other articles on behalf of the non-resident and they were regularly purchasing and selling goods on behalf of the non-resident and under his instructions. These findings have been accepted by the Tribunal. The questioned is whether on these facts it can be stated that the assessee was rightly made a statutory agent of the non-resident under s. 43 of the Act. Now, it is not necessary to emphasize the fact that s. 43 merely sets up a machinery to give effect to the substantive provisions of s. 42. Therefore, before we can go to s. 43 we must find that the non-resident was liable to pay tax under s. 42. It is only when he is so liable that the question of appointing a statutory agent under s. 43 can arise. Now, the non-resident would only be liable to pay tax under s. 42 in this particular case provided he had any business connection in the taxable territories. Now, it is no use concealing the fact that the expression “any business connection in the taxable territories” is by no means a very precise expression, capable of being construed with any precision. It may be that the Legislature advisedly used a vague and uncertain expression so that the interpretation should not be restricted to any narrow limits. But one or two aspects of this expression may be emphasized. It is clear that the Legislature did not intend to tax a non-resident in respect of income, profits or gains accruing or arising from any business connection with taxable territories. In other words it is not sufficient that a non-resident should do business with India, in order that he should make himself liable under s. 42. The business connection contemplated by s. 42 is something wider than mere doing business with India. The preposition used by the Legislature is “in” and not “with”, and proper emphasis must be given to the particular word “in” used by the Legislature. Therefore, we can easily exclude all those cases in which we find that a non-resident is merely doing business with India. It is also clear from the expression “any business connection in the taxable territories” that the non-resident must be carrying on business in India through some agency. There must be some connection between the non-resident and the taxable territories. The contention of Sir Jamshedji is that the agency which connects the non-resident with the assessee must be an agency of permanent and exclusive character. Now, we were not prepared to accept that contention. It is difficult to understand why only a permanent and exclusive agency can constitute a business connection between a non-resident and an assessee. As I have already pointed out the language used by the Legislature is very wide; any business connection is not necessarily that business connection which is constituted by a permanent and exclusive agency. On the other hand a mere casual connection, a connection which has no continuity, would also not be a business connection as contemplated by the Legislature under s. 42. Therefore, in order that the agency which constitutes a connection between a non-resident and the assessee should be a business connection as contemplated by s. 42 there must be an element of continuity in the agency. An isolated transaction through an agent, or even a connection for a short period, would not necessarily constitute business connection. It is impossible to give an interpretation to this expression which would be a good interpretation for all the innumerable cases which may arise. It is only possible to interpret the expression negatively rather than positively. I can only point out what is excluded from the expression “business connection” but it is not possible to say what is included in it. In most cases it would depend upon the facts of the particular case as to whether the business connection has been established or not.
Now, applying this test to the facts of the present case it is clear that the connection between the assessee and the non-resident was not of a casual character. We have not here a case where an assessee entered into a few isolated transactions with the non-resident. Continuity of agency has been definitely established on the facts of the case. As I pointed out for several years the assessee has been acting as a commission agent of the non-resident. During these years he has entered into a large number of transactions. It is true that the assessee is not the sole agent of the non-resident. It is also true that the non-resident does business through other agents as well. But the mere fact that the non-resident has more than one agent is not sufficient to my mind to lead me to the conclusion that the assessee is not necessarily a person who can be appointed a statutory agent under s. 43.
Turning to the authorities on which reliance is placed, Sir Jamshedji has very strongly relied upon a decision of the Allahabad High Court, Hira Mills Ltd., Cawnpore v. Income-Tax Officer, Cawnpore. In that case the Allahabad High Court held that business connection was not established between the Hira Mills which was a non-resident company and carried on business of manufacturing cloth at Ujjain, Gwalior State, and British India. The facts proved in that case were that the assessee company sold goods in India to British Indian customers if and when the customers either directly or through brokers offered to purchase them by sending an order to Ujjain. Therefore, the mills sold the cloth to customers in British India either directly or through brokers who offered to purchase the cloth on behalf of their constituents. It is in the light of these facts found that the observations made by the learned Judges of the Allahabad High Court must be appreciated. Now, in the first place the Allahabad High Court rejected the view taken by the Rangoon High Court of the expression “business connection” in The Commissioner of Income-tax, Burma v. Steel Brothers & Co., Ltd.. The view taken by the Rangoon High Court was that the expression “business connection’ was a compendious expression to cover such concerns in the nature of trade, commerce, or manufacture as arise through a branch, factorship, agency, receivership or management. The Allahabad High Court took the same view as was taken by this Court in Commissioner of Income-tax, Bombay v. National Mutual Association of Australasia Ltd. that the Rangoon view placed too narrow a construction on the words “business connection.” But what is emphasized by Sir Jamshedji is that at p. 430 of the judgment in the Allahabad case the learned Judges point out that—
“…The brokers were not, as far as we know, retained by the assessee. The assessee had no claim upon goodwill of the brokers.”
Sir Jamshedji says that these sentences make it clear that their Lordships of the Allahabad High Court were emphasizing the fact that the agent must be retained by the principal before he can be constituted a statutory agent under s. 43. In other words Sir Jamshedji says that there must be contractual obligation upon the agent to accept the work sent to him by the principal. According to Sir Jamshedji a distinction was drawn in this case between the free lance brokers, as the learned Judges called the brokers in Cawnpore who entered into the transaction on behalf of the constituents in British India with the mills, and an agent under an obligation to act as such. Now, in my opinion that is not the true reading of this case. The learned Judges have used the expression “retained” not in the sense in which Sir Jamshedji wants us to understand it. All that the learned Judges emphasized (as they were entitled to do) is that the brokers were not employed or engaged by the mills. The brokers were free lance brokers in the sense that they offered to purchase cloth on behalf of their constituents. No occasion arose for the Allahabad High Court to lay down that there must be a contractual obligation upon the agent to act as an agent before he could be appointed a statutory agent under s. 43. On the facts of that particular case it is clear that no business connection within the meaning of s. 43 was established. It may be pointed out that at p. 428 of the report in the judgment it is pointed out that no definition of the expression “business connection” was given by the Act itself and the Legislature had apparently deliberately chosen to use words of wide, if uncertain, meaning; and it is stated at p. 430 that every question that had got to be decided as to the application of s. 42 should be what their Lordships chose to call a “practical question.”
A reference may also be made to a decision of our High Court, Commissioner Of Income-Tax, Bombay v. Metro-Goldwyn Mayer (India) Ltd.…Assessees.), Limited. Beaumont C.J was also considering what proper construction should be put upon the expression “business connection,” and at p. 383 he points out that
“…I think, there must be some element of continuity in the relationship between the parties, and in every case one has to look at the particular facts of the case to see whether it falls within s. 42.”
Therefore, in my opinion, the non-resident, Haji Mahomed Sayed Alberbary, had a business connection in India within the meaning of s. 42(1) of the Act and the assessee was rightly treated as an agent of the non-resident for the accounting years 1942-1943, 1943-1944, 1944-1945 and 1945-1946.
The result, therefore, is that we answer the questions submitted to us as follows:
No. 1:—In the affirmative.
No. 2:—In the affirmative.
No. 3:—In the negative.
No. 4:—This question has been withdrawn by the Solicitor General and we therefore do not answer this question.
The additional question raised on the supplementary statement of the case will be answered in the affirmative.
Assessee to pay three-fourths of the costs of the reference.
Attorneys for applicants: Amarchand & Mangaldas.
Attorneys for respondent: N.K Petjgara.
Answer accordingly.
P.M.P
Alert