- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Steel Age Industries Ltd. And Another v. Union Of India And Others
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioners (a limited company and its director) manufacture security equipment — safes, strong boxes, safe deposit lockers and related furniture — using steel sheets and plates purchased from factories now owned by the Steel Authority of India Limited (SAIL). The petitioners pay excise duty on their manufactured products, but seek credit under Notification No. 95/79-C.E. dated 1 March 1979 for the excise duty paid on steel consumed in manufacture, subject to compliance with Rule 56A of the Central Excise Rules ("the Rules").
Rule 56A prescribes documentary procedure (original packing under A.R.I. gate passes or other Central Board-approved documents, or bill of entry evidencing payment of excise duty). The petitioners did not follow any of the three specified options; they purchased steel from SAIL. They wrote (letter dated 30 April 1979) to the Excise Department seeking permission to follow the procedure to avail of the credit. The Assistant Collector replied (dated 2 April 1979) requiring production of subsidiary gate passes and other particulars; subsequent correspondence continued with the department insisting on documents listed in Rule 56A(3)(i)(b).
The petitioners filed a petition under Article 226 of the Constitution asking the Court to direct the respondents to grant credit without insisting upon the specific documents demanded by the respondents.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioners are entitled to excise credit under Notification No. 95/79-C.E. without producing the specific documents prescribed by Rule 56A of the Central Excise Rules.
- Whether the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A (which permits the Central Government to direct that certain stocks in the country be deemed duty-paid without production of documents) applies to the petitioners' stocks (including stocks acquired from SAIL and possibly from the open market) and, if so, at what rate and on what conditions credit may be allowed.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- Counsel for the petitioners (Mr. Andhyarujina) argued it was erroneous for the respondents to insist on the specific documents in Rule 56A and that an invoice (Exhibit "M") showing excise assessment and payment by Bokaro Steel Ltd. should suffice as evidence that excise duty had been paid on the steel sheets and plates purchased by the petitioners from SAIL.
- The petitioners contended that acceptance of the invoice would constitute substantial compliance with the Rule’s requirements.
- The petitioners also invoked the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A and relied on Government of India instructions (notably the instruction dated 26 July 1963) which, they said, deem certain stocks of semi-finished steel in the market after 1 August 1963 to have paid duty, so that no proof of payment need be demanded.
- Counsel pointed to a decision of the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, Western Regional Bench at Bombay (Collector of Central Excise, Bombay v. Goodlass Nerolac Paints Limited, 1986 (26) E.L.T. 57) as supportive of a substantial-compliance approach to Rule 56A in some circumstances.
Respondents' Arguments
- The respondents (through the Assistant Collector and in their affidavit-in-reply) insisted that the petitioners produce the particular documents mandated by Rule 56A(3)(i)(b), such as subsidiary gate passes showing gate pass number, rate of duty, etc., from the dealers selling the steel sheets.
- In the affidavit-in-reply the respondents stated that the petitioners' reliance on Government letters dated 26 July 1963 and 22 September 1962 (regarding open market stock) "has no base" and attempted to distinguish stocks arising from purchases from a public sector undertaking from those acquired in the open market.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Collector of Central Excise, Bombay v. Goodlass Nerolac Paints Limited, 1986 (26) E.L.T. 57 (CEGAT, Western Bench) | Supported the proposition that Rule 56A may be treated as substantially complied with in certain factual situations (i.e., where a permitted document existed but lacked the consignee's name or certain endorsements). | The Court distinguished Goodlass Nerolac on the facts: in that case there was a document contemplated by the Rule (albeit deficient in a particular detail), whereas in the present case there was no document of the kind contemplated by Rule 56A at all. Consequently, Goodlass Nerolac did not justify accepting the invoice relied upon by the petitioners as satisfying the Rule. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded step-by-step:
- The Court observed that Rule 56A prescribes particular documentary proof that must be produced to claim the excise credit allowed by the Notification. The rule lists specified documents (A.R.I. gate passes or other Central Board-approved documents, or bill of entry).
- The Court found that the document relied upon by the petitioners (an invoice evidencing excise assessment and payment by Bokaro Steel Ltd., Exhibit "M") is not one of the documents specified by Rule 56A. The Rule does not confer discretion on the Assistant Collector to accept any other documentary evidence in lieu of the prescribed documents.
- The Court rejected the argument that the Rule should be interpreted differently because the supplier was a public sector undertaking (SAIL). The Court held that a rule cannot be construed one way for a public sector undertaking and another way for a non-public sector entity.
- The Court considered the CEGAT decision relied on by the petitioners (Goodlass Nerolac) and concluded it was distinguishable: in Goodlass Nerolac there was a document of the kind contemplated by the Rule but missing certain particulars; by contrast, in the present case there was no document contemplated by the Rule at all.
- The Court then examined the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A, which empowers the Central Government, having regard to elapsed time and market conditions, to direct that stocks of the relevant goods in the country (except stocks lying in a factory, customs area or warehouse clearly recognisable as non-duty-paid) may be deemed duty-paid and credit allowed without production of documents, at such rates and subject to such conditions as the Central Government may direct.
- The petitioners relied on government instructions, notably the instruction dated 26 July 1963, which stated that stocks of semi-finished steel existing in the market on or after 1 August 1963 should be deemed to have paid duty and no proof of payment need be demanded. The respondents' affidavit did not meaningfully engage with these averments, merely asserting that the petitioners' reliance "has no base," and attempted to draw an unexplained distinction between public-sector and open-market stocks — a distinction the Court found unwarranted under the proviso.
- The Court concluded that the petitioners are entitled to rely upon the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A. However, credit under the proviso is subject to the rate and conditions that the Central Government may direct. Thus, although the petitioners could not succeed on the basis of the invoice as a substitute for the documents specified in Rule 56A, they could claim benefit under the proviso if the conditions and directions of the Central Government applied to their stocks.
Holding and Implications
Holding:
The petition succeeds partially: the respondents are directed to calculate and grant the excise credit to which the petitioners are entitled in respect of stocks utilised by them, in accordance with the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A of the Central Excise Rules and in the light of the directions issued by the Central Government under that proviso.
Implications and direct consequences:
- The respondents are ordered to calculate the credit available to the petitioners for the period 1979-1980 to November 1981 within eight weeks from the date of the judgment, applying the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A and any relevant Central Government directions (including the instructions relied upon by the petitioners).
- The Court made clear that credit under the proviso will be at the rate and subject to the conditions as the Central Government may direct; the petitioners cannot rely on the invoice as a substitute for the specific documents mandated by the Rule.
- No order as to costs was made.
The opinion does not purport to set a new, broad precedent beyond the facts decided: it distinguishes an earlier appellate tribunal decision on its facts and applies the statutory proviso and governmental directions to the petitioners' circumstances. No further broader implications were elaborated in the text.
1. The first petitioner is a limited company of which are second petitioner is the director. For the sake of convenience, they will hereinafter be referred to as "the petitioners". The petitioners are engaged in the business of manufacture of security equipments such a safes, strong boxes, safe deposit lockers, furnitures etc. All these are made of steel. For this purpose the petitioner purchase steel sheets and plates from the factories which are now owned by the Steel Authority of India Limited which, as is well known, now owns the steel projects in the public sector. On the products manufactured by them the petitioners have to pay excise duty. However, under a Notification No. 95/79-C.E., dated 1st of March, 1979, credit is available to the petitioners to the extent of the excise duty which has been paid on steel sheets and plates consumed by the petitioners in the manufactures of their own products.
2. Rule 56A of the Central Excise Rules, hereinafter referred to as "the Rules", prescribes the procedure in accordance with which credit for the excise duty which is already paid under the notification referred to above is to be followed. A manufacture permitted to avail of the benefit of the said notification is required to bring to the factory the material or the component parts or finished products in original packing under the cover of A.R.I. (gate passes) or such other document as may be approved by the Central Board of Excise and Customs or bill of entry evidencing the payment of excise duty. In the present case the petitioners have followed none of the three options available. They purchased the steel plates and sheets from the factories owned by the Steel Authority of India Limited, hereinafter referred to as "the SAIL".
3. The petitioners addressed a letter dated 30th of April, 1979 to the Excise Department pointing out that under the notification dated 1st March, 1979 their products have been exempted from the duty paid on the steel sheets and plates in the manufacture provided Rule 56A is followed. They requested the Assistant Collector of Central Excise, to whom the said letter was addressed, to allow them to follow the procedure to avail of the said credit. The Assistant Collector of Central Excise by his reply dated 2nd April, 1979 pointed out to the petitioners that the petitioners were to produce subsidiary gate passes indicating therein all the description like the gate pass number under which the goods were cleared from the factory, rate of duty etc. from the dealers from whom they were purchasing the steel sheets. Further correspondence ensued between the petitioners and the Excise Department, the latter insisting upon the production of the documents mentioned in Rule 56A(3)(i)(b). The petitioner have now approached this Court under Article 226 of the Constitution of India praying for an order requiring the respondents to give them credit without insisting upon the documents mentioned by the respondents in their correspondence with the petitioners.
4. Mr. Andhyarujina, the learned Advocate appearing in support of the petition, has taken me through the petition and after pointing out the correspondence exchanged between the parties has sought to argue that it was an error on the part of the respondents to insist upon the production by the petitioners of the documents mentioned in the Rule referred to above. He has also placed reliance upon the invoices copy of one of which is annexed to this petition at Exhibit 'M', which show that the goods which were despatched by the Bokaro Steel Unit of the SAIL to Vidya Vihar Railway Station had been assessed to excise duty at Rs. 472.50 per M.T. and the same had been paid by Bokaro Steel Ltd.. Mr. Andhyarujina insists that this should be taken as sufficient evidence to show that excise duty has been paid on the steel sheets and plates which have been purchased by the petitioners from the SAIL. According to him this must also be regarded as substantial compliance with the requirement of the Rule on which the petitioners are placing reliance.
5. It has not been possible for me to accept this interpretation of the Rule made by Mr. Andhyarujina. The rule insists that particular documents ought to be produced. The document on which the petitioners went to place reliance is not one of the documents mentioned in the relevant rule. The relevant rule does not give discretion to the Assistant Collector to accept any other document for being satisfied that excise duty has been paid on the product in respect of which credit is being claimed. It may be, in the present case SAIL is a company in the public sector. But a rule cannot be interpreted in one way in the case of a public sector undertaking and in another way in the case of a non-public sector undertaking.
6. Mr. Andhyarujina says that even the Customs, Excise and Gold (Control) Appellate Tribunal, Western Regional Bench at Bombay, hereinafter referred to as "the CEGAT", has taken the view that Rule 56A should be held to be substantially complied with and instance should not be made on the technical compliance thereof. In Collector of Central Excise, Bombay v. Goodlass Nerolac Paints Limited, 1986 (26) E.L.T. 57, the West Regional Bench of the CEGAT at Bombay held that in order to claim proforma credit, it is not essential that the manufacturer who availed proforma credit should be shown as the consignee in G.P.I. or there should be an endorsement on the reverse of G.P.I. or there should be a subsidiary gate pass in his name. I do not see similarity between the facts in Goodlass Nerolac Paints Limited's case and the facts before me. In that case there was a document which was permitted to be relied upon, but only the name of the consignee had not been shown therein. In the present case there is no document at all which is contemplated under the rule.
7. Mr. Andhyuarujina then invited my attention to the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A, which is as follows :-
"Provided that having regard to the period that has elapsed since the duty of excise was imported on any such material, component parts or finished products, the position of demand and supply of the said goods in the country and any other relevant consideration, the Central Government may direct that with effect from a specified date all stocks of the said goods in the country, except such stocks lying in a factory, customs area (as defined in the Customs Act, 1962) (52 of 1962) or warehouse as are clearly recognisable as being non-duty paid, may be deemed to be duty-paid and credit of duty in respect of the said goods may be allowed at such rate and subject to such condition as the Central Government may direct, without production of documents evidencing the payment of duty :"
In the petition foundation for resorting to this proviso has been laid by claiming leave to refer to the instructions dated 22nd September, 1962 and 26th July, 1963 to the authorities concerned. The instructions which have been given on 26th of July 1963 are as follows :-
"Having regard to the stock position as on the 1st March, 1963 and the possibility of stocks having been consumed, it has been decided that all stocks of semi-finished steel existing in the market on or after the 1st of August, 1963 should be deemed to have paid duty and no proof of payment of duty on them need be demanded. Set-off or exemption of duty on them need be allowed assuming that the semi-finished steel including blooms, billets and slabs etc. purchased from the market on or after 1.8.1963 have paid the appropriate amount of duty."
8. In the affidavit-in-reply filed on behalf of the respondents, there is no reference at all to the petitioners' averments relating to the instruction issued by the Government of India on 26th of July, 1963, except saying that
"the stand of the petitioners with regard to open market stock of iron and steel in reference to Government of India's letter dated 26th July, 1962 and 22nd September, 1963 has no base". It is the petitioners' case that they have purchased the steel from SAIL though some part of their purchase could be from open market. Still it is not possible to understand the averment contained in paragraph 9 of the affidavit-in-reply wherein a distinction is sought to be made in respect of the stocks built up as a result of the purchases from the public sector undertaking and the purchases made from the open market. The proviso on which reliance is placed does not make any such distinction.
9. In my opinion, if the petitioners want to rely upon the proviso referred to above, they are entitled to do so, but the credit which they will get as a result of the application of the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A will be at such rate and subject to such conditions as the Central Government may direct. Since the petitioners are claiming credit in respect of the stocks lying with them after 1st of August, 1963, I am inclined to agree that they are entitled to take benefit of the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A subject, of course, to the conditions mentioned in the same proviso, namely that credit will be available to them at such rate and subject to such conditions as the Central Government may direct.
10. In the result, the petition only succeeds partially. The respondents are directed to calculated the credit that may be given to the petitioners in respect of the stock of steel utilised by them in the manufacture of their products in accordance with the proviso to sub-rule (3) of Rule 56A of the Central Excise Rules and in the light of the directions given by the Central Government with reference to that proviso.
11. The period with which the present petition is concerned is from 1979-1980 to November, 1981. The respondents shall calculate the credit available to the petitioners in respect of the said period within eight weeks from today. It is expected that in view of the proviso referred to above an the instructions given by the Government, the same procedure will be followed by the authorities for the subsequent periods.
12. There will be no order as to costs in this petition.
Alert