- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dubai Dry Docks Co. Ltd. v. Hede Navigation Ltd.
Court Opinion Summary
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition was instituted by Dubai Dry Docks Co. Ltd. seeking the winding up of M/s. Hede Navigation Co. Ltd. (the respondent company) on the ground that the respondent was unable to pay a debt of Rs. 13,88,725 corresponding to US$1,24,985 (of which US$1,06,825 was principal and the remainder interest).
Background facts set out in the opinion:
- Estimates for dry-docking and repairs of the vessel Discaria Harvest were prepared on 22 March 1986 for US$597,658, but the parties agreed that repairs to the value of US$151,000 would be carried out, and those repairs were performed in April 1986. An invoice dated 26 April 1986 records the repairs for US$151,000 and contains an “agreed” acknowledgement by B.M. Hans, the respondent's technical manager.
- Respondent received a 5% reduction (US$7,550) and an additional remission of US$1,000. The respondent sought rescheduling of payment and asserted financial difficulty due to leakage of ammonia cargo and alleged blacklisting at Gulf ports.
- The parties agreed to a payment schedule of four instalments of US$35,625 each, the first payable on 25 July 1986. Only one instalment (US$35,625) was paid; subsequent instalments were delayed by repeated requests for time and rescheduling by the respondent, with various telexes describing further proposed instalment plans through December 1987.
- Despite the unresolved dues for Discaria Harvest, the respondent entrusted another vessel, Shanta Rohan, to the petitioners for repairs in June 1986, but later disputed liability for Shanta Rohan's repairs.
- The petitioners instituted Summary Suit No. 379 of 1987 on the Original Side of the Bombay High Court on 10 February 1987 to recover amounts; a motion for attachment before judgment in respect of Shanta Rohan was made but was dismissed by order dated 10 September 1987, and the respondent obtained unconditional leave to defend that suit.
- The present winding up petition was filed on 15 October 1987.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent company was unable to pay its debt to the petitioners such as to justify a winding up petition.
- Whether the disputes and counterclaims raised by the respondent company were bona fide or merely a device to delay payment (i.e., whether the respondent's disputes were frivolous and a cloak for inability to pay).
- Whether the petitioners themselves acted bona fide in instituting the winding up petition (specifically, whether the petition was used to pressurise the respondent after failing in attachment proceedings).
- What interim measures (if any) the court should take pending satisfaction of issues of bona fides and resolution of contested claims (e.g., stay of advertisement and conditional deposit directions).
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The petitioners relied on documentary correspondence and representations showing that the respondent acknowledged the debt and repeatedly sought time and rescheduling rather than disputing liability on the merits.
- They argued that the respondent raised frivolous disputes only as a cloak for inability to pay a just debt, and therefore the petitioners were entitled to wind up relief.
- Despite concessions and an agreed instalment schedule, the respondent paid only a single instalment of US$35,625 and then defaulted; further promises to pay were not honoured.
- The petitioners emphasized that the respondent never disputed liability for Discaria Harvest until January 1987 and only adopted a contentious stance after the petitioners instituted the Bombay suit relating to Shanta Rohan.
- The petitioners challenged the respondent's affidavit assertions of heavy losses and large repair costs as inconsistent with earlier correspondence and therefore not credible.
Respondent Company's Arguments
- The respondent vehemently opposed the winding up petition, asserting that a petitioner seeking winding up must first establish its own bona fides and, if the petitioner fails, the petition should be dismissed.
- Counsel pointed out that the petitioners had filed the Bombay suit limiting the claim to Shanta Rohan, and had pursued attachment before judgment (which failed), suggesting that the winding up petition was a device to pressure the respondent after failing in the attachment application.
- The respondent asserted a counter-claim far in excess of the petitioners' claim and urged that this circumstance warranted refusing winding up relief.
- On the factual merits, the respondent maintained there was leakage of ammonia cargo, blacklisting by foreign ports, and operational failures (for example, relief valves lifting at 4 bar instead of 15 bar), supporting a prima facie case that the petitioners had not carried out adequate repairs and that substantial subsequent repairs (allegedly costing large sums) were necessary.
- The respondent relied on a reservation in the telex of 14 May 1986 (that damages might be sought later) and on materials disclosed in the Bombay suit to show the counter-claim was bona fide.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Cotton Corporation of India Ltd. v. United Industrial Bank Ltd., (1983) 4 SCC 625 ; AIR 1983 SC 1272 ; [1984] 55 Comp Cas 423 | That in a winding up petition a petitioner must first establish bona fides; if the petitioner fails to establish bona fides, the petition must be dismissed at the threshold. | The court noted counsel's reliance on this authority. While acknowledging the principle, the court did not accept the respondent's submission that the petitioners' conduct established bad faith; instead the court directed an interim accommodation (staying advertisement for three months and ordering the respondent to deposit Rs. 10 lakhs) to enable the respondent to establish bona fides. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court conducted a fact-based prima facie analysis focused on documentary correspondence, admissions, and the sequence of events:
- The invoice dated 26 April 1986 showed itemised repairs amounting to US$151,000 and bore an explicit acknowledgement “agreed” by B.M. Hans, the respondent's technical manager. Reductions and remissions were concessionary and reflected negotiation rather than dispute on liability.
- The correspondence (including a telex of 14 May 1986) showed the respondent seeking rescheduling and alleging financial difficulty caused by cargo leakage; the petitioners accepted rescheduling and instalments. Only one instalment was paid and subsequent instalments were repeatedly deferred by the respondent.
- The court observed that, prima facie, the respondent never disputed liability to pay the Discaria Harvest invoice until January 1987; prior communications consistently sought accommodation and time, rather than contesting the debt on its merits.
- The court found it significant that, after the Discaria Harvest repairs, the respondent entrusted another vessel (Shanta Rohan) to the petitioners for repair, which undercuts the contention that the petitioners' workmanship was clearly deficient at the earlier date.
- The petitioners had pursued a summary suit in Bombay and an attachment before judgment in respect of Shanta Rohan; the attachment was dismissed and the respondent obtained leave to defend. The court noted that attachment-before-judgment matters stand on a different footing and did not treat the failure of attachment as determinative of the winding up petition's bona fides.
- The court found some assertions by the respondent (for example, in an affidavit that they had sustained large losses and incurred significant outlays) inconsistent with earlier letters, making those assertions suspect on a prima facie review.
- The court examined the respondent's claim of a reservation in the telex of 14 May 1986 for later damages but regarded the existence of a clear reservation as "highly doubtful" on a prima facie view; the telex mainly detailed messages and criticism of the party that nominated Discaria Harvest as unseaworthy.
- While the respondent raised specific technical complaints (leakage, blacklisting, relief valves lifting at 4 bar), the court was not prima facie persuaded that these matters demonstrated a bona fide or dispositive defence to the petitioners' claim at the threshold.
- Given the contested factual matrix and competing contentions about bona fides, the court adopted a conditional and interim approach rather than an immediate dismissal or an immediate winding up order.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The court did not dismiss the winding up petition outright nor did it immediate order winding up. Instead, the court ordered the following interim measures:
- The court stayed the advertisement of the winding up petition for a period of three months to enable the respondent company to establish its bona fides.
- The respondent company was directed to deposit a sum of Rs. 10,00,000 (Rs. 10 lakhs) in the Court on or before 30 June 1988.
- During the stay period the respondent was permitted to adopt any proceedings it wished against the petitioners to establish its case.
- In the event the respondent did not deposit Rs. 10 lakhs by 30 June 1988, the petition was to be advertised and the petition was to be placed on board immediately after 30 June 1988; the rule was made accordingly.
Implications: The direct consequence of the decision is conditional preservation of the petitioners' remedy while giving the respondent a limited opportunity to demonstrate bona fides by making a security deposit and pursuing substantive proceedings. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new precedent; it resolves the immediate contest by an interim, conditional order affecting the parties' procedural position.
G.D Kamat, J.:— This petition is instituted by Dubai Dry Docks Co. Ltd. for winding up of M/s. Hede Navigation Co. Ltd., for short, “the respondent company”, on the ground that the respondent company is unable to pay the debt of Rs. 13,88,725 corresponding to US I 1,24,985 which includes their claim in the principal amount of US $1,06,825, the remaining being interest.
2. The respondent company wanted the petitioners to dry dock a vessel, Discaria Harvest, to carry out repairs. Estimates were prepared on March 22, 1986, amounting to US $ 5,97,658. However, the respondent company indicated that they were not in a position to carry out the repairs for that value and that they would be content to carry out such repairs so as to maintain the class of the vessel as a result whereof it was agreed that the repairs of the value of US $ 1,51,000 be carried out and accordingly repairs were done in April, 1986. The invoice dated April 26, 1986, speaks of repairs being carried out worth US $ 1,51,000. Despite the repairs, no payment was forthcoming. Several promises were held out, concessions were given by the petitioners and despite the proposal of payment of the value by instalments, except for a single instalment of US $ 35,625 corresponding to 25% of the invoice, nothing further has been paid. That in the meantime another vessel by name Shanta Rohan owned by the respondent company also got repaired in June, 1986, but the respondent company disputed their liability to pay for the repairs of that vessel, Shanta Rohan. It is in this view of the matter that the petitioners pray that the respondent company be wound up and a liquidator appointed.
3. Shri P. Sancheti, learned counsel appearing for the petitioners, took me through various documents and more particularly the correspondence exchanged and relying upon various statements and representations made by the respondent company, he urges that a clear case is made out that the respondent company is trying to delay the payment by raising frivolous disputes which are not genuine but merely a cloak for their inability to pay a just debt and that, therefore, the petitioners are entitled for the orders prayed for in the petition.
4. Invoice dated April 26, 1986, gives details of the repairs carried out item-wise of the value of US $ 1,51,000 and there is an acknowledgment “agreed” by one B.M Hans who is undisputably the technical manager of the respondent company. It is common ground that a reduction of 5% was made in favour of the respondent company corresponding to US $ 7,550 and the correspondence further shows that yet another remission of US $ 1,000 was made. By the telex dated May 14, 1986, the respondent company while seeking reduction prayed for rescheduling the payment of the invoice value on making a reference that the respondent company had been placed in some hopeless situation and faced the problem of leakage of the ammonia cargo as a result of which they are black listed in Gulf ports. The petitioners accepted the schedule of payment as suggested in four instalments, each of US $ 35,625, the first to be paid on July 25, 1986, followed by payment every quarter thereafter. However, even before the payment of the first instalment fell due, by the telex of July 14, 1986, the respondent company held out to the petitioners that they are awaiting the Reserve Bank's permission and, therefore, the payment would be delayed by a week beyond July 25, 1986. The petitioners agreed to the payment latest by August 13, 1986, or else they would charge interest at 1½% per month. With some delay, the first instalment was paid but by that time the second instalment fell due, the respondent company sought time up to November by the telex of October 29, 1986. By another telex of November 4, 1986, the respondent company held out that they will try to adhere to the payment schedule. Pursuant to the demands of the petitioners by another telex of January 3, 1987, the respondent company held out that, viz., Discaria Harvest, they would pay the balance thereof in five instalments of US $ 25,000 in February, 1987, April, 1987, UL 1987 (must be July, 1987), April, 1987, (must be August, 1987, or September, 1987), October, 1987, and the balance of US $ 6,825 in December, 1987.
5. It is no doubt true that in one of the telex a mention has been made that there was a problem of leakage and heavy losses being incurred by the respondent company but then, however, it must be prima facie conclusively held that the respondent company never disputed their liability to pay and on top of it they always acknowledged and only sought accommodation to meet out the same.
6. It is also a fact which cannot be overlooked that on getting the vessel, Discaria Harvest, repaired, the respondent company entrusted their other vessel, Shanta Rohan, to the petitioners for dry docking and repairs and they disputed their liability to pay for the repairs. Having found that no money was forthcoming from the respondent company, the petitioners instituted a suit on the Original Side of the Bombay High Court, being Summary Suit No. 379 of 1987 on February 10, 1987. It is equally indisputable that a motion for attachment before judgment, viz., Shanta Rohan, was made. The respondent company succeeded in obtaining leave to defend that suit and equally clear from the order made on September 10, 1987, that the motion for attachment before judgment was dismissed.
7. In the light of these facts, circumstances and correspondence, it is urged by learned counsel for the petitioners that at no stage, prior to the filing of the suit in Bombay, any challenge was made to the repairs carried out by the petitioners to the vessel, Discaria Harvest, and what is more, for the first time a climate is sought to be created for making a counter-claim against the petitioners in that suit while opposing the motion for attachment for bad workmanship in relation to Discaria Harvest. It is urged that the respondent company having conclusively accepted their liability are now putting up a hoax to cover up their inability to pay a just debt. The averment made in the affidavit in reply dated December 2, 1987, by M.M Sardesai, director of the respondent company, says that they were required to sustain a loss and had to spend Rs. 31 lakhs for repairs and another Rs. 20 lakhs by way of standing charges for having the ship repaired at Singapore in January, 1987. This is palpably false or untenable, urges Shri Sancheti, when compared to the earlier statement in their letter dated January 12, 1987. In answer to one of the letters of the petitioners while pointing out certain defects in repairs of Discaria Harvest, the respondent company held out:
“Due to these defects, the class as well as surveyors at various ports had been called for extensive surveys and we have been asked to go for heavy repairs on many items which were otherwise not due. Consequently, the company had to face heavy losses and the ship was required to spend over U.S $ 5,00,000 for remaining in commercial service.”
8. It is argued that if the petitioners were to be blamed for bad workmanship in respect of Discaria Harvest, in April, 1986, the respondent company would not have entrusted their other vessel, Shanta Rohan, in June, 1986, and this being the telltale in the matter, there is nothing bona fide on the part of the respondent company.
9. This petition is being vehemently opposed. Shri M.S Usgaonkar, learned counsel appearing for them in the first instance, mentions that in a winding up petition, a petitioner must first establish bona fides and when the petitioner fails, the petition must be dismissed even at the threshold Despite knowing that the petitioners had to recover a large amount of money, counsel points out that the petitioners filed that suit at Bombay restricting the claim only in respect of Shanta Rohan though a reference was made to their claim, viz., Discaria Harvest. Now, he says that despite the fact that the claim had matured, it was not taken in that suit and what is more, with a view to pressurise the respondent company, a motion for attachment of Shanta Rohan was sought and having lost that attachment, the petitioners, with a view to further pressurise the respondent company, have instituted the present proceedings under bad faith. On the facts disclosed, learned counsel brings to my notice that unconditional leave is granted to defend that suit.
10. Once the unconditional leave was granted and by the order dated September 10, 1987, attachment was dismissed despite the fact that the claim was ripe and no relief sought in that suit, the present petition is instituted significantly on October 15, 1987, and in that context it is now urged by counsel that the action to wind up the company is not bona fide. Reliance has been placed on the authority of Cotton Corporation of India Ltd. v. United Industrial Bank Ltd., (1983) 4 SCC 625 : AIR 1983 SC 1272; [1984] 55 Comp Cas 423.
11. It is next mentioned that the counter claim that the respondent company has is far in excess of the claim of the petitioners and this by itself is a good circumstance for refusing the relief.
12. Mr. Usgaonkar now mentions that the vessel is admittedly meant for transporting ammonia and despite the repairs carried out by the petitioners, there was such leakage in the foreign port that the port authorities have black-listed the respondent company and, therefore, the fact remains that works were not carried out according to the requirement and, therefore, the claim of the respondent company cannot be labelled as not genuine. The;second aspect raised is that the relief valves have lifted at 4 bar pressure instead of 15 bar pressure and this was again against the requirement. Having regard to the correspondence made by the captain of the ship and its chief engineer, a prima facie case that no adequate repairs had been carried out is made and, therefore, the respondent company were forced to carry out repairs at a huge cost of Rs. 21 lakhs and hence no want of bona fides can be attributed to the respondent company. Mr. Usgaonkar now says that three facts are established, firstly, the fact of leakage, secondly, black listing and, thirdly, substantial repairs. This being the position, he now argues that four matters stand out, 1. that the counter-claim raised by the respondent company is bona fide, 2. that counter-claim made is far in excess, 3. that a right was clearly reserved in the telex of May 14, 1986, that damages would be sought at a later date, and 4. that all this material was brought out when the suit was filed in Bombay in respect of Shanta Rohan. Having regard to the above, it is urged that the present proceedings instituted after the attachment was dismissed lends support to their case. He now submits that if the petitioners were to file a suit against the respondent company and to seek an interim relief, the petitioners would have met the same fate as they met in the case of Shanta Rohan and, therefore, resort to the present petition as a device to wield pressure cannot be ruled out.
13. I, am, however, not prima facie in agreement with what is contended by the respondent company.
14. The question as to whether in the telex of May 14, 1986, any reservation was at all made for a claim against the petitioners is highly doubtful. It merely quotes certain messages exchanged and the cudgel appears to be against the party which nominated Discaria Harvest as unsea worthy. I am prima-facie of the view that the petitioners’ claim for repairs was never disputed until January, 1987, and it is only vehemently disputed when that suit was filed relating to recovery of dues in respect of Shanta Rohan. Prior to that, the correspondence reveals that the respondents wanted only time to pay. What is more, they sought instalments and a reschedule of the payments from time to time. The further fact remains that the petitioners were forced to file that suit because Shanta Rohan is owned by the respondent company whereas Discaria Harvest does not belong to them. Even while arguments were going on, Mr. Usgaonkar was unable to dispute seriously the claim of the petitioners and the emphasis was that the counter-claim of the respondent company is far in excess of the claim of the petitioners. I am also unable to accept that merely because the petitioners did not club this claim in their summary suit filed in Bombay, it can have any impact on the present petition or for that matter on the motion for attachment which was lost. It requires no reiteration that matters relating to attachment before judgment stand on different footing.
15. Since Mr. Usgaonkar insisted that the respondent company wants to file a suit for recovering their claim against the petitioners all that I can do is to stay the advertisement of this petition for 3 months in order to enable the respondent company to establish their bona fides. The respondent company is to deposit a sum of Rs. 10 lakhs on or before June 30, 1988, in this court and adopt in the meantime any proceedings they want against the petitioners. In the event Rs. 10 lakhs are not deposited before June 30, 1988, this petition be advertised. Petition accordingly to be on board immediately after June 30, 1988. Rule accordingly made.
Alert