Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Abdul Rahman And Others v. Dayaram And Others

Bombay High Court
Nov 30, 1988

A.A Desai, J.:— This appeal is directed against judgment dated 19.12.1986 dismissing the entire claim of compensation by the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Akola. Deceased Mohammed Shafi was in the private employment as a driver. On 29.9.1983 at 2.30 a.m he was crushed by truck No. MHV 7703 while he was sleeping in the premises of Government Milk Dairy, Akola, at a place which is meant for parking of the trucks which come for loading and unloading milk cans. His parents and widow presented the claim petition under section 110-A of the Motor Vehicles Act claiming compensation of Rs. 1,00,000/- for loss of life. In support of the claim, the claimants have examined PW 1 Tayade, Security Officer of the Milk Scheme, PW 2 Abdul Rahman, father of the deceased and PW 3 Abdul Hamid, the conductor. The learned member of the Tribunal, taking into account evidence of non-applicant No. 1 Dayaram, driver of the truck, observed that at the time of accident when he turned the truck to the right side for approaching the main road, the rear wheel of the driver side ran over Mohammed Shafi and on hearing shrieks, the truck was immediately halted. Taking into account the entire evidence, the learned member of the Tribunal reached the conclusion that it cannot be said that deceased was not negligent in sleeping at the place at the time of the incident. He further observed that Dayaram, driver of the truck No. MHV 7703, cannot be said to have failed to take that care which an ordinary prudent man in his place would have taken. In his finding, the learned member of the Tribunal reached the conclusion that the accident was due to exclusive negligence and carelessness on the part of deceased Mohammed Shafi and as such the petitioners are not entitled to claim any compensation. The learned member of the Tribunal, therefore, rejected the claim petition, by order dated 19.12.1986 This award has been impugned herein.

2. We have heard Mr. Kazi, the learned counsel appearing for the appellant and Mr. Kukade, advocate for the respondent No. 3, insurance company. According to Mr. Kazi even admitting, the deceased was sleeping at a place which is normally not meant for the purpose, however, the driver Dayaram, if he had acted with due care and caution, would have averted the incident and would have saved late Mohammed Shafi. Mr. Kazi, therefore, submitted though there was negligence on the part of the deceased, the act of Dayaram driver is not free from blemish. Mr. Kazi took us through the evidence and various findings of the learned member of the Tribunal. It is true that the deceased Mohammed Shafi acted in an irresponsible manner in sleeping at the place meant for parking vehicles. However, in our opinion, immediately after starting the truck, driver Dayaram could have seen Mohammed Shafi who was sleeping there. It appears that driver Dayaram was not alert and he has by his contributor negligence, in our estimate of 40 per cent, made himself responsible to the incident. However, we find that sleeping at a place wherefrom the trucks for loading and unloading were coming and going, the negligence of deceased Mohammed Shafi was of a higher degree and we estimate it to be 60 per cent.

3. In view of this, the learned member of the Tribunal was not wholly justified in rejecting the claim of the petitioners in its entirety.

4. Mohammed Shafi at the time of incident was aged about 28 years. He was receiving total monthly remuneration of Rs. 400/-. His total life span would be 65 years. It being a private employment normally he would have continued to earn upto the age of 60. Thus, he would have supported the members of his family for a period of 32 years. Out of his earnings of Rs. 400/-, as a normal estimate he would have spent Rs. 250/- on the members of the family. In view of this, during the span of 32 years, he would have contributed Rs. 96,000/- towards the maintenance of the members of the family.

5. As we have held the contributory negligence on the part of Mohammed Shafi being 60 per cent, the amount to that extent is liable to be deducted. The claimants are, therefore, entitled after deduction to Rs. 38,400/-. Since the amount is being paid in lump sum, we further grant a discount of 10 per cent. As such, the amount of Rs. 35,650/- is payable to the claimants.

6. Mr. Kazi, the learned counsel appearing for the appellants, submitted that as per the principles of Mohammedan Law, appellant No. 1 father Abdul Rahman being the heir of deceased Mohammed Shafi is entitled to half of the total compensation and mother and widow to the extent of 14th each. We gave our anxious consideration on this aspect. However, the compensation is being paid taking into consideration the dependency of the claimants. We are of the opinion that we are not guided by the apportionment as provided under the Mohammedan Law.

7. Appellant No. 1 father Abdul Rahman is aged 61 whereas mother of deceased is aged about 43. At the time of incident, appellant No. 3 Shahnazbanu was hardly aged about 28. Her dependency is comparatively more than appellant Nos. 1 and 2, taking into consideration her age. We, therefore, feel that it would be just and reasonable to pay half of the amount of compensation to appellant No. 3 and rest of the amount in equal share, i.e, ¼th to each of appellant Nos. 1 and 2.

8. In view of our reasoning, the appeal is partly allowed. The respondents to pay to the appellants total amount of Rs. 35,650/-. As per the apportionment indicated above, i.e, 50 per cent to appellant No. 3 Shahnazbanu and 25 per cent to each of appellant Nos. 1 and 2. No order as to costs.

9. Appeal partly allowed.