- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
M/S. Apollo Health And Lifestyle Limited And Another v. Anupam Saraogi
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal was heard by consent of counsel for the parties. It is directed against the judgment dated 09-04-2014 in O.S. No. 692 of 2007 passed by the XIII Additional Chief Judge (Fast Track Court), City Civil Court, Hyderabad, whereby the trial court decreed the suit instituted by the respondent/plaintiff for recovery of money. Counsel for the appellants was M/s. Lawyers & Solicitors; counsel for the respondent was Ms. Manjari S. Ganu. The appellants challenged the trial court's procedure and framing of issues; the respondent maintained that, although a specific issue on jurisdiction was not framed, the trial court considered jurisdiction on merits.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the trial court failed to frame issues as required by Order 14 Rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure.
- Whether such failure to frame and decide appropriate issues resulted in misdirection or failure of justice warranting interference/remand.
- Whether the absence of a specifically framed jurisdictional issue was cured by the trial court considering jurisdiction on merits.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellants' Arguments
- The trial court did not frame the issues that arose in the suit for determination and thereby misdirected itself and/or failed to consider the real issues involved in the suit.
Respondent's Arguments
- Although no specific issue on jurisdiction was framed, the court below considered jurisdiction on merits and answered it in the affirmative; therefore, it cannot be said that issues for determination were not framed while deciding the suit.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court analysed the trial judge's conduct against the requirements of Order 14 (Rules 1–3 and Rule 5) and related procedural provisions (including Rule 2 of Order 10 and sub-rule (2) of Rule 2 of the Code as referenced). It stated that:
- Issues must cover all important questions involved, and must not be general or vague; the trial court must not pursue mere speed at the cost of intelligent disposal.
- At first hearing, after reading pleadings and examination under Rule 2 of Order 10 and after hearing parties, the court must ascertain material propositions of fact or law on which parties differ and frame issues on which the right decision depends.
- Even if a case may be disposed of on a preliminary issue, the court shall, subject to sub-rule (2) of Rule 2, pronounce judgment on all issues; where both law and fact issues arise, an issue of law (e.g., jurisdiction) may be tried first.
- While framing issues, the trial court must bear in mind allegations on oath, pleadings, answers to interrogatories and documents; under Rule 5 of Order 14 it must record reasons for its decision on each issue independently based on an independent assessment of evidence.
- In the present case the trial court framed only one issue—whether the plaintiff is entitled to recovery—which the bench found hopelessly inadequate. The trial judge did not refer to material evidence (notably Exs. A-3 and A-4 and relevant clauses) and adopted a casual approach.
- Because of these deficiencies, the court concluded there was a failure to comply with Order 14 and that this resulted in failure of justice; the parties had agreed to the order the court proposed to pass when the deficiencies were pointed out during hearing.
Holding and Implications
The appeal is ALLOWED.
Holding (direct effect): The impugned judgment and decree dated 09-04-2014 are set aside; O.S. No. 692 of 2007 is restored to file and remanded to the trial Court to be decided afresh from the stage of arguments as expeditiously as possible, preferably on or before 30-06-2015. The trial judge is directed to frame proper issues, deal with them on merits in accordance with law, and indicate all issues proposed to be framed and addressed to counsel before commencement of arguments. No order as to costs. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, are disposed of. The parties were directed to appear before the trial Court on 02-02-2015 with a copy of this judgment; refund of court fee, if any, as per rules.
Implications: The decision returns the matter to trial for proper issue-framing and fresh determination; the opinion identifies procedural requirements of Order 14 but does not purport to set a new precedent beyond applying existing procedural principles to these facts.
Counsel for the appellants : M/s. Lawyers & Solicitors
Counsel for Respondent: Ms. Manjari S. Ganu
>Head Note:
? Cases referred:
: (Per Hon'ble Sri Justice Dilip B. Bhosale)
By consent of learned counsel for the parties, the appeal
itself is taken up for hearing at this stage.
2. The appeal is directed against the judgment
dated 09-04-2014 in O.S.No.692 of 2007 passed by the
XIII Additional Chief Judge (Fast Track Court), City Civil Court,
Hyderabad, whereby the learned Judge has decreed the suit
instituted by the respondent/plaintiff for recovery of money.
3. The learned counsel appearing for the appellants, at the
outset, invited our attention to the judgment of the trial court
to contend that the trial court did not frame the issues that
arose in the suit for determination and as a result thereof, it
misdirected itself and/or failed to consider the real issues
involved in the suit for determination.
4. On the other hand, learned counsel appearing for the
respondent submitted that though no specific issue in respect
of jurisdiction was not framed, the court below considered it
on merits and answered the same in the affirmative and,
therefore, it cannot be stated that the issues for determination
were not framed by the learned judge while deciding the suit.
5. It is now well settled that issues, as contemplated by
Order 14 Rules 1, 2 and 3 of the Code of Civil Procedure (for
short the Code), must cover all important questions involved
in the case and they should not be general and vague. The
learned judge dealing with the suit should not approach the
suit merely from the point of speedily disposing of the same.
The suit must be also intelligently disposed of after taking note
of the arguments advanced, the issues arising from the
arguments, and the other materials on record and then decide
those issues properly on merits. A failure to understand the
object of the provisions contained in Order 14, in particular
Rules 1 to 3 thereof, in the instant case has demonstrably
resulted in failure of justice.
6. A bare look at the provisions contained in Rules 1 to 3 in
particular of Order 14 of the Code would show that a
duty/responsibility is cast on the trial court, at the first hearing
of the suit, after reading the plaint and the written
statements, if any, and after examination under Rule 2 of
Order 10 and after hearing the parties or their pleaders,
ascertain upon what material propositions of fact or of law the
parties are at variance, and shall thereupon proceed to frame
and record the issues on which the right decision of the case
appears to depend. Notwithstanding that a case may be
disposed of on a preliminary issue, the court shall, subject to
the provisions of sub-rule (2) of Rule 2 of the Code, pronounce
judgment on all issues. Where issues both of law and of fact
arise in the same suit, and the court is of opinion that the case
or any part thereof may be disposed of on an issue of law
only, it may try that issue first, if that issue relates to the
jurisdiction of the court or a bar to the suit created by any law
for the time being in force and for that purpose may, if it
thinks fit, postpone the settlement of the other issues until
after that issue has been determined, and may deal with the
issue in accordance with the decision on that issue.
7. It is also necessary for the learned judge, while framing
the issues, to bear in mind the allegations made on oath by
the parties, or by any persons present on their behalf, or
made by the pleaders of such parties; the allegations made in
the pleadings or in answers to interrogatories delivered in the
suit; and the contents of the documents produced by their
party. It is also mandatory for the trial court to assess the
evidence of the parties and consider the relevant issues which
arise for adjudication and bearing of the evidence on those
issues. Thus, as contemplated by Rule 5 of Order 14 of the
Code, the trial court must record reasons for its decision on
each issue independently and such exercise should be done
after formulating the issues, that arise for
consideration/determination. In other words, the trial court
while considering and deciding the suit should realise that it
has to be decided strictly in adherence with the provisions
contained in Order 14 of the Code. The provisions contained in
this Order deal with the judgment to be pronounced by the
court on all issues. When a requirement such as this is insisted
upon by the procedural law, one must try to understand the
object and scope of such provision. It must be evident from
the judgment of the trial court that it has properly appreciated
the facts/evidence, applied its mind and decided the case
considering the materials/evidence on record. Unless the trial
courts judgment is based on independent assessment of the
relevant evidence on all issues, it would not amount to
substantial compliance of the provisions contained in Order 14
of the Code. It is, therefore, necessary for the trial court to
frame the issues for determination and examine the same in
the light of the facts/evidence led by the parties. Merely
asking the question as to whether the plaintiff is entitled for
recovery of suit amount as prayed for is hopelessly an
inadequate method of meeting the requirement of the
provisions contained in Order 14 of the Code. Thus, it is
necessary that the entire evidence must be considered and
discussed in detail and such exercise should be done after
formulating the issues for determination in terms of the
provisions contained in Order 14 of the Code.
8. In the present case, the trial court has framed only one
issue for consideration i.e., whether the plaintiff is entitled for
recovery of suit amount as prayed for. This
practice/procedure adopted by the learned judge was wrong
and it was inadequate requirement of the provisions contained
in Order 14 of the Code. We find the approach of learned
judge was absolutely casual in dealing with the suit. It is
apparent that the learned judge even did not refer to the
material evidence on record, such as Exs.A-3 and A-4 and the
relevant clauses thereof, in particular. When we noticed all this
and expressed our view, in the course of hearing, the learned
counsel for the parties agreed for an order that we propose to
pass. Hence, we dispose of this appeal by the following order:-
a. The appeal is allowed. The impugned judgment and
decree dated 09.04.2014 is set aside and the suit (O.S.No.692
of 2007) is restored to file and remanded to the trial Court.
The trial Court shall decide the suit, from the stage of the
arguments, afresh as expeditiously as possible, preferably on
or before 30.06.2015.
b. It is needless to mention that the learned Judge shall
frame proper issues and deal with the same on merits in
accordance with law. Further, the learned Judge shall indicate
all the issues that he proposes to frame and address, while
delivering the judgment, to the learned counsel appearing for
the parties even before commencement of arguments so as to
enable them to address their arguments on all issues. No
order as to costs.
9. Pending miscellaneous petitions, if any, also stand disposed
of.
10. At this stage, as requested by the learned counsel for
the parties, the parties are directed to appear before the trial
Court on 02.02.2015 along with a copy of this judgment.
Refund of Court fee, if any, as per the rules.
_____________________
DILIP B. BHOSALE, J
______________________
R. SUBHASH REDDY, J
23rd December, 2014
Alert