- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
V.V Projects And Investments P. Ltd. v. Deputy Commissioner Of Income-Tax
Factual and Procedural Background
The assessee is a company engaged in manufacture of chemicals and operating a hotel in Kurnool. For the Assessment Year 1995-96 the company filed an original return on 30.11.1995 disclosing nil income and claiming 50% depreciation on solar equipment (depreciation claimed Rs. 22,21,065 on an asset of Rs. 44,42,129 acquired after September 1994). The original return was processed under Section 143(1)(a) on 30.8.1996.
The assessee later filed a revised return on 4.5.1998 for A.Y. 1995-96 declaring total income of Rs. 4,77,510, withdrawing the earlier claim for depreciation on the ground that the supplier (M/s Solardur Energy Systems (P) Ltd.) could not produce records. The revised return was stated to be voluntary to avoid protracted litigation. The Assessing Officer accepted the revised return and completed assessment under Section 143(3) on 16.3.2001 determining tax payable as Rs. 3,95,979, and separately initiated penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c).
A show-cause notice dated 17.9.2001 proposed penalty in the range of 100% to 300% of tax evaded. The AO levied penalty of Rs. 9,10,800 on 27.9.2001. The assessee appealed to the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on 21.2.2002; that appeal was dismissed on 22.8.2002. The assessee then appealed to the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad, which upheld the levy of penalty but remanded the matter for re-quantification of penalty after giving the assessee a reasonable opportunity (order dated 29.10.2004). The assessee challenged the Tribunal's order before this Court under Section 260-A of the Income-tax Act.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the Assessing Officer can initiate penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act without recording in the assessment order his satisfaction that the assessee had concealed particulars of income or furnished inaccurate particulars?
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The penalty of Rs. 9,10,800 levied under Section 271(1)(c) is contrary to law and unsustainable.
- Recording of satisfaction as to concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars is a condition precedent to initiating proceedings under Section 271(1)(c); the AO did not record such satisfaction in the assessment order but accepted the revised return.
- Because the AO accepted the revised return, the penalty proceedings are impermissible and without jurisdiction.
- The impugned order relies on a statement allegedly made by K.S. Rao (Managing Director of the supplier) without giving the assessee an opportunity to cross-examine him, thus violating principles of natural justice.
Respondent's Arguments
- The penalty proceedings do not suffer from jurisdictional error and therefore do not warrant interference by the Court.
- Relying on a Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court (C.I.T. v. Gopal Krishna Singhania), the respondent contended that the satisfaction may be recorded in the penalty order and that proceedings being independent, it is sufficient if satisfaction is recorded in the penalty order (i.e., the AO need not have recorded the satisfaction in the assessment order itself).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| D.M. Manasvi v. C.I.T. (S.C.) 86 I.T.R. 557 | That the assessing authority must be satisfied in the course of proceedings under the Act about matters in s.271(1); satisfaction precedes issue of notice and may be formed during proceedings. | The Court relied on this to show that satisfaction must be formed in the course of proceedings; however, the opinion emphasizes that the satisfaction must be recorded and be apparent from the record. |
| C.I.T. v. Munish Iron Store (P. & H.) 263 I.T.R. 484 | Jurisdiction to impose penalty flows from recording of the satisfaction; a jurisdictional defect in assumption of jurisdiction cannot be cured. | The Court cited this to support the proposition that failure to record satisfaction is a jurisdictional defect and cannot be cured. |
| CIT v. Vikas Promoters P. Ltd. (Delhi) 277 I.T.R. 337 | The satisfaction must be reflected in the record/order; authorities exercising quasi-judicial functions must give reasons; penal provisions are to be strictly construed. | The Court relied on this authority to hold that satisfaction cannot be presumed from files or from initiation of proceedings and must be apparent from the assessment order itself. |
| C.I.T. v. Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd. (Delhi) 246 I.T.R. 568 | Initiation of penalty proceedings alone does not establish that the assessing authority had formed the requisite satisfaction; such satisfaction must be spelled out. | The Court used this precedent to reinforce that mere initiation of proceedings does not substitute for a recorded satisfaction in the assessment order. |
| Dilip N. Shroff v. Joint CIT (S.C.) 291 I.R.T. 519 | Orders imposing penalty under Section 271(1)(c) are penal in nature and must be strictly construed. | The Court cited this to emphasize strict construction of penal provisions when considering whether the AO complied with the requirement to record satisfaction. |
| C.I.T. v. Gopal Krishna Singhania (All.) 89 I.T.R. 27 (Full Bench, Allahabad) | Dealt with proceedings under Section 34 (old Act) corresponding to reassessment provisions and held that penalty under old s.28(1)(c) could be levied during course of proceedings under s.34 for defaults in original assessment. | The Court distinguished this decision on facts and scope: it was held inapplicable to the present case because it concerned different statutory provisions and factual matrix (reassessment proceedings), so the Full Bench ratio was not followed. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court began with a textual reading of Section 271(1) of the Income-tax Act and observed that the subsection empowers the Assessing Officer or appellate authorities to levy penalty where they are satisfied that specified defaults (including concealment or furnishing inaccurate particulars) have occurred. The Court emphasized that the statutory language makes formation and recording of satisfaction a condition precedent to invocation of Section 271(1).
The Court reviewed binding and persuasive authorities:
- It noted D.M. Manasvi for the principle that satisfaction is formed in the course of proceedings and that notice follows satisfaction.
- It relied on Munish Iron Store to stress that jurisdiction to impose penalty stems from recording of satisfaction and that jurisdictional defects cannot be cured.
- The decisions of Delhi High Court in Vikas Promoters and Ram Commercial were invoked to underline that satisfaction must appear from the record/the order itself and cannot be inferred by the courts from material outside the order.
- Dilip N. Shroff was cited to apply the rule of strict construction to penal provisions (orders imposing penalty are penal in nature and must be strictly construed).
The respondent's contention—that the satisfaction could be recorded in the penalty order and that proceedings are independent—was supported by reliance on the Allahabad Full Bench in Gopal Krishna Singhania. The Court distinguished that authority on its facts and statutory background (it related to old Act provisions concerning reassessment) and held it inapplicable.
Applying the law to the facts, the Court found that the AO had accepted the revised return in the assessment order dated 16.3.2001 after verification of information and books of account; the assessment was completed accepting the revised return. The assessment order did not record any satisfaction regarding concealment or inaccurate particulars as required by Section 271(1). The subsequent show-cause notice dated 17.9.2001 also did not state any satisfaction formed by the AO. The Revenue did not place any material before the Court to show that the AO had other material or had recorded satisfaction in the course of proceedings.
Consequently, the Court concluded that initiation and levy of penalty under Section 271(1)(c) in the absence of a recorded satisfaction constituted a jurisdictional defect. Given the penal nature of Section 271(1)(c) and the requirement of strict construction, the impugned penalty proceedings were held to be without jurisdiction, arbitrary and illegal.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Court set aside the impugned penalty proceedings and allowed the appeal in favour of the assessee. The operative relief recorded in the opinion is:
IMPUGNED PENALTY PROCEEDINGS UNDER SECTION 271(1)(c) SET ASIDE; APPEAL ALLOWED.
Implications:
- Direct effect on the parties: The penalty of Rs. 9,10,800 (and the related penalty proceedings) levied under Section 271(1)(c) were quashed; the assessee's appeal was allowed and no costs were awarded.
- Scope and precedent: The Court applied and reiterated extant principles requiring that the Assessing Officer must form and record satisfaction as to concealment or furnishing of inaccurate particulars in the course of proceedings under the Act before invoking Section 271(1)(c). The opinion distinguished the Allahabad Full Bench decision relied upon by the revenue as factually and legally inapplicable. The opinion does not purport to create any new legal principle beyond applying and following the cited authorities.
No costs were awarded in the judgment.
1. Aggrieved by the order of the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad, Bench 'B' in I.T.A. No. 865/Hyd/2002, dated 29.10.2004, the assessee preferred this Appeal under Section 260-A of the Income-tax Act, 1961 (for short, 'the Act').
2. The facts, in brief, are as under:
The Appellant (hereinafter referred to as 'the Assessee Company') is engaged in the business of manufacture of chemicals and also running a hotel in Kurnool Town. The Assessee Company filed its return of income for the Assessment Year 1995-96 on 30.11.1995 disclosing 'Nil' income. The return was processed under Section 143(1)(a) of the Act on 30.8.1996. It is to be noted that in its return dated 30.11.1995 the assessee company claimed 50% depreciation on Rs. 44,42,129/- on the Solar Equipment acquired by it for its hotel project. While stating that the solar equipment was acquired and installed after September, 1994, the Assessee Company claimed 50% depreciation amounting to Rs. 22,21,065/- for the assessment year 1995-96.
3. While so, the assessee filed another return of income for the same Assessment Year 1995-96 on 4.5.1998 declaring total income of Rs. 4,77,510/- stating that it gave up its claim for depreciation on the solar equipment since M/s, Solardur Energy Systems (P) Limited, Hyderabad, who supplied the solar equipment did not properly maintain its records and books and expressed its inability lo produce evidence toe I lie equipment supplied. It was also stated that with a view to avoid protracted litigation the revised return of income was being filed voluntarily and the same may be accepted since the additional income offered in the revised return did not represent concealed income.
4. The said revised return was accepted by the assessing officer - Deputy Commissioner of Income Tax, and an order of assessment was passed on 16.3.2001 under Section 143(3) of the Act determining total tax payable as Rs. 3,95,979/-, but stating that penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act are initiated separately. The relevant portion of the said order may be extracted hereunder:
After verification of the information filed and books of accounts produced assessment is completed by accepting the returned net. income as per revised return of income.
3. The said order was followed by show-cause notice dated 17.9.2001 issued by the Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax calling upon the assessee company to show-cause as to why penalty under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act amounting to a minimum of Rs. 9,10,800/ being 100% of tax evaded and a maximum of Rs. 27,32,400/ being the 300% of fax evaded should not be levied. The assessee company submitted its explanation dated 27.9.2001 requesting to drop the proceedings stating that it was not a case of concealment of particulars of income or furnishing of inaccurate particulars.
However, the assessing officer - Deputy Commissioner of Income-tax, Hyderabad, rejected the contention of the assessee company that it was a voluntary declaration and passed an order dated 27.9.2001 levying a penalty of Rs. 9,10,800/- in exercise of the powers conferred under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act.
Aggrieved by the same, the assessee company preferred an Appeal before the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on 21.2.2002. The said Appeal was dismissed by order dated 22.8.2002 thereby upholding the penalty levied by the assessing officer. Challenging the said order, the assessee company preferred a further appeal before the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal, Hyderabad. After hearing both the parties, the Tribunal though upheld the order of the Commissioner of Income-tax (Appeals) on the issue of levy of penalty, expressed that the matter requires reconsideration so far as the quantification of penalty is concerned. Accordingly, by order dated 29.10.2004 while allowing the Appeal in part, the matter was remanded to the assessing officer to re-quantify the penalty after giving reasonable opportunity to the assessee in accordance with law. Aggrieved by the same, the assessee company preferred the present Appeal under Section 260-A of the Act.
4. We have heard the learned Counsel for both the parties and perused the material on record.
5. The learned Counsel appearing for the appellant/assessee company vehemently contended that the penalty of Rs. 9,10,800/- purportedly levied under Section 271(1)(c) of the Income-tax Act, 1961 by the respondents is contrary to law and unsustainable.
While submitting that recording of satisfaction of concealment of income by the assessee is a condition precedent for initiating proceedings for levy of penalty under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act, the learned Counsel contended that since the assessing officer in the assessment order dated 16.3.2001 did not record such satisfaction, but. on die other hand accepted the returned net income as per the revised return filed by the assessee, the impugned penalty proceedings are impermissible and without jurisdiction. The learned Counsel also contended that the impugned order which is based on a statement allegedly made by one K.S. Rao, Managing Director of M/s. Solardur Energy Systems (P) Ltd., without affording an opportunity to the assessee to cross-examine him is in violation of the principles of natural justice.
6. On the other hand, the learned Counsel appearing for the respondent contended that the impugned penalty proceedings do not suffer from any jurisdictional error warranting interference by this Court.
7. Having regard to the submissions made by the learned Counsel, the following substantial question of law arises for consideration by this Court:
Whether it is permissible for the assessing officer to initiate penally proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act without recording his satisfaction in the assessment order that the assessee concealed the particulars of his income or furnished inaccurate particulars?
For proper appreciation of the controversy involved, it is necessary to refer to Section 271 of the Act which deals with failure to furnish returns, comply with notices, concealment of income, to the extent it is relevant for the present case.
271. (I) If the Assessing Officer or the Commissioner (Appeals) or the Commissioner in the course of any proceedings under this Act, is satisfied that any person -
(a) ...
(b) ...
(c) has concealed the particulars of his income or furnished inaccurate particulars of such income, or
(d) ...
he may direct that such person shall pay by way of penalty,-
(i) ...
(ii) ...
(iii) in the cases referred to in Clause (c) or Clause (d) in addition to tax, if any, payable by him, a sum which shall not be less than, but which shall not exceed three times, the amount of tax sought to be evaded by reason of the concealment of particulars of his income or fringe benefits or the furnishing of inaccurate particulars of such income or fringe benefits.
On a plain reading of Sub-section (1) of Section 271 of the Act, it is clear that the assessing officer, in the course of any proceedings under the Act, is empowered to levy penalty in the circumstances specified in Clauses (a) to (d), which included concealment of particulars of income or furnishing inaccurate particulars of income. However, the language of Sub-section (1) of Section 271 of the Act itself makes it clear that recording of satisfaction of concealment of income by a person or furnishing inaccurate particulars of such income is a condition precedent for levying penally invoking the power under Section 271(1) of the Act.
While interpreting the object and intendment of Section 271(1) of the Act, the Supreme Court in D.M. Manasvi v. C.I.T. (S.C.) 86 I.T.R. 557, held as under:
What is contemplated by clause (1) of section 271 is that the Income-tax Officer or the Appellate Assistant Commissioner should have been satisfied in the course of proceedings under the Act regarding matters mentioned in the clauses of that sub-section. It is not, however, essential that notice to the person proceeded against should have also been issued during the course of the assessment proceedings. Satisfaction in the very nature of things precedes the issue of notice and it would not be correct to equate the satisfaction of the Income-tax Officer or Appellate Assistant Commissioner with the actual issue of notice. The issue of notice is a consequence of the satisfaction of the Income-tax Officer or the Assistant Appellate Commissioner and it would, m our opinion, be sufficient compliance with the provisions of the statute if the Income-tax Officer or the Appellate Assistant Commissioner is the satisfied about the matters referred to in Clauses (a) to (c) of Sub-section (1) of Section 271 during the course of proceedings under the Act even though notice to the person proceeded against in pursuance of that satisfaction is issued subsequently.
In C.I.T. v. Munish Iron Store (P. and H.) 263 I.T.R. 484, a Division Bench of Punjab & Haryana High Court while referring to the ratio laid down in the above decision that under Section 271(1) of the Act, it is the assessing authority which has to form its opinion and record its satisfaction before initiating the penalty proceedings, further held that the jurisdiction to impose penalty flows from recording of the satisfaction and in case there is a jurisdictional defect in the assumption of jurisdiction it cannot be cured.
The above proposition of law has been reiterated by the High Court of Delhi in CIT v. Vikas Promoters P. Ltd. (Delhi) 277 I.T.R. 337, emphasizing as under:
...the satisfaction is not to be in the mind of the Assessing Officer but must be reflected from the record. It is a well-settled rule of law that the authorities performing quasi-judicial or judicial function must give reasons in support of its order so as to provide in the order itself the ground which weighed with the authorities concerned for passing an order must give reasons in support of its order so as to provide in the order itself the ground which weighed with the authorities concerned for passing an order adverse to the interest of the assessee. Further more the provisions of section 21(1)(c) are penal in nature thus must be strictly construed, the element of satisfaction should be apparent from the order itself. It is not for the courts to go into the mind of the authorities or trace the reasons from the files of such authorities.
The Delhi High Court in C.I.T. v. Ram Commercial Enterprises Ltd. (Delhi) 246 I.T.R. 568, held that merely because the penalty proceedings have been initiated it cannot be assumed that such a satisfaction was arrived at in the absence of the same being spelt out by the order of the assessing authority.
8. In a recent decision reported in Dilip N. Shroff v. Joint CIT (SC) 291 I.R.T. 519, the Supreme Court having reviewed all the decided cases relating to penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act held that the order imposing penalty under Section 271(1)(c) being penal in nature, the rule of strict construction shall apply.
From die legal position noticed above, it is clear that the assessing officer has to form his own opinion and record his satisfaction of concealment of income or furnishing inaccurate particulars of income before initialing penalty proceedings under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act. It is also clear that such satisfaction of the assessing officer must be spelt out in the order of assessment itself but cannot be assumed from the issue of a notice under Section 271(1)(c) of the Act. Failure to record such satisfaction amounts to a jurisdictional defect which cannot be cured.
9. However, while placing strong reliance upon the expression 'in the course of any proceedings under the Act' in Section 271(1) of the Act, the learned Counsel for the respondent sought to contend that the penally proceedings being independent it is sufficient if the satisfaction is recorded in the order levying penalty. The learned Counsel in support of his submission cited a Full Bench decision of Allahabad High Court in C.I.T. v. Gopal Krishna Singhania (All.) 89 I.T.R. 27.
10. In the above decision, the Full Bench of Allahabad High Court was dealing with proceedings under Section 34 of the Income-tax Act, 1922 which corresponds to sections 147 & 148 of the new act of 1961 which provide for reassessment of income chargeable to tax which has escaped assessment. Having considered the scope and object of the said provisions, the Full Bench held that penalty under Section 28(1)(c) of the old Act (corresponding to Section 271(1)(c) of the new Act) can be levied during the course of proceedings under Section 34 in respect of a default committed during the original assessment proceedings.
The said decision is clearly distinguishable on facts and the ratio laid down therein is not applicable to the instant case.
11. It is also relevant to note that whether the assessee has concealed his income or has deliberately furnished inaccurate particulars thereof is essentially a finding of fact which has to be spelt out by way of recording the satisfaction of the Assessing Officer as required under Section 271(1) of the Act. Therefore, in the absence of such a finding in the assessment order no penalty proceedings can be initiated.
12. As noticed above, the declaration of income made by the assessee company in revised return and the explanation that it had done so to buy peace with the department and to avoid protracted litigation was accepted by the Assessing Officer in his order dated 16.3.2001 without raising any objection. Admittedly the assessing officer accepted the returns filed by the assessee after verification of the information filed and books of accounts produced. Thus, the assessment was completed accepting the returned net income as per the revised return of income. Not only the assessment order did not. reflect any satisfaction as required under Section 271(1) of the Act but even the show-cause notice dated 17.9.2001 was silent with reference to the satisfaction arrived at by the assessing officer with reference to the concealment of income by the assessee company. Nothing has been placed before this Court by the Revenue to show that any other material was available with the assessing officer to the effect that, the assessee concealed the income. In the circumstances, it is not open to the Assessing Officer to invoke the power under Section 271(1)(c) levying penalty.
13. For the aforesaid reasons, we are of the opinion that, the impugned penalty proceedings arc without jurisdiction apart from being arbitrary and illegal.
14. Accordingly, we set aside the impugned proceedings and allow the Appeal in favour of the ussessee. No costs.
Alert