Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Smt. Setti Siddamma v. S. Ramulu & Anr.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Sep 2, 2004
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This civil revision petition arises from a suit filed by the petitioner for declaration of title and perpetual injunction concerning the suit schedule property. The respondents filed a written statement but initially failed to file certain documents, which they subsequently sought to submit through an application under Order VIII Rule 1(3) of the Code of Civil Procedure (C.P.C). The trial Court permitted the reception of these documents, and the petitioner’s revision challenging this order was dismissed. The petitioner closed evidence on their part, and the respondents filed an affidavit in lieu of chief examination referencing the documents admitted by the trial Court. The petitioner objected to the reference of these documents in the affidavit, but the trial Court overruled the objections, holding that such objections could be addressed during cross-examination of the respondent’s witness.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether documents referred to in an affidavit filed in lieu of chief examination, which were admitted by the trial Court, can be objected to on grounds of admissibility or existence at the stage prior to cross-examination.
  2. The procedural stage at which objections regarding admissibility and proof of documents should be considered when affidavits in lieu of chief examination are filed under the amended Code of Civil Procedure.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner’s Arguments

  • Several documents referred to in the affidavit of the respondent’s witness are either inadmissible or non-existent, including pattadar pass books invalidated by subsequent revenue authority orders.
  • Allowing the trial Court to mark such documents at this stage would make it difficult to exclude them later.
  • Relies on the Supreme Court judgment in R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu Visweswaraswami and V.P Temple to support the objection.

Respondents’ Arguments

  • Merely receiving or marking documents is not a final adjudication under the current procedural scheme.
  • Objections to documents can be properly raised and considered during the cross-examination of the witness who referred to the documents in the affidavit.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu Visweswaraswami and V.P Temple, (2003) 8 SCC 752 : AIR 2003 SC 4548 Clarification of procedural stages for considering admissibility and proof of documents when affidavits in lieu of chief examination are filed under amended C.P.C. The Court relied on this precedent to explain that mere reception of documents does not amount to final admission, and objections can be raised during cross-examination.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court analyzed the procedural framework for admitting documents in civil suits under the amended Code of Civil Procedure. It identified three stages at which admissibility can be considered: (1) when documents are filed into the Court, involving a broad consideration such as registration or relevance to the suit transaction; (2) at the recording of evidence through witnesses, involving both admissibility (including relevancy) and proof; and (3) at the stage of arguments, where only admissibility can be reconsidered but not proof.

The Court observed that the amendment allowing affidavits in lieu of chief examination shifts the stage at which detailed scrutiny of documents occurs to cross-examination. Documents referred to in such affidavits are not automatically admitted or proved upon reception by the Court. The opposing party may raise objections during cross-examination, and only documents that withstand these objections will be admitted as evidence. The Court noted that the trial Court’s order aligns with this procedural understanding and that no exception can be taken to it.

Holding and Implications

The civil revision petition is dismissed.

The petitioner is permitted to raise objections regarding the admissibility or proof of documents relied upon by the respondent’s witness during cross-examination. The decision clarifies that the mere reception or marking of documents at an earlier stage does not constitute their final admission as evidence. There is no indication that this ruling sets a new precedent beyond the application of existing procedural principles under the amended Code of Civil Procedure.

Show all summary ...

1. This civil revision petition is filed by the plaintiff in O.S No. 42 of 1999 on the file of Senior Civil Judge, Narayanpet, aggrieved by the order dated 30.07.2004 in C.F.R No. 557 of 2004.

2. Petitioner filed the suit for declaration of title and perpetual injunction in respect of the suit schedule property.

3. Respondents filed their written statement. They could not file certain documents along with the written statement. Therefore, they filed I.A No. 27 of 2004 under Order VIII Rule 1(3) C.P.C to receive the documents. The trial Court ordered the same and received the documents. The petitioner filed a revision before this Court challenging the same, and the revision was dismissed.

4. The evidence on behalf of the petitioner was closed. On behalf of the respondents, an affidavit in lieu of chief-examination was filed. In that, reference was made to various documents that were received by the trial Court through its order dated 19.02.2004 in I.A No. 27 of 2004. The petitioner filed a memo dated 02.07.2004 taking objection to the reference to various documents in the affidavit filed by D.W 1, in lieu of his chief examination. Through its order under revision, the trial Court overruled the objections, and held that they can be considered at the time of cross examination of D.W 1 and not at a stage, earlier thereto.

5. Sri N. Ashok Kumar, learned counsel for the petitioner, submits that several documents, referred to in the affidavit, filed in lieu of chief examination of D.W 1, are, either inadmissible or non-existent. By referring to the specific documents, he submits that in view of the subsequent orders passed by the revenue authorities, the documents such as pattadar pass books cannot be said to be in existence. He contends that if marking is given by the trial Court for such documents, it would be difficult for eschewing them at a later point of time. He places reliance upon the Judgment of the Supreme Court in R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder v. Arulmigu Visweswaraswami and V.P Temple (2003) 8 SCC 752 : AIR 2003 SC 4548.

6. Sri M. Janardhana Rao, learned counsel for the respondent, on the other hand, submits that mere receiving or giving mark to the documents is not final, particularly in the present scheme of the Code of Civil Procedure and the objections raised by the petitioner can certainly be taken into account, at the time of cross examination of D.W 1.

7. The petitioner raised objections for reference of certain documents in the affidavit filed by D.W 1 in lieu of his chief examination. The objections range from the admissibility of documents, to the very existence of some of them. During the trial of the suit, the admissibility of the documents can be considered by the Court at three stages viz. when the documents are filed into the Court, at the time of recording of evidence, in which the documents are introduced through witnesses, and at the stage of arguments. The nature of consideration by the Court in these three stages differs from each other. At the first stage, it would be on broad consideration, such as, whether the document is registered or whether it relates to the suit transaction. At the second stage, the consideration will be both (a) as to the admissibility, which takes in itself, the elements of relevancy, and, (b) as to proof. At the third stage, the Court is not entitled to reopen the question of proof. However, the question of admissibility can be considered. The law, on this aspect, was reviewed and enunciated by the Supreme Court in its recent judgment in R.V.E Venkatachala Gounder's case (cited supra).

8. A party to the suit cannot have any substantial grievance when the Court receives a particular document. Mere receiving of a document does not entail any adjudication as to its admissibility or proof. Before the Code of Civil Procedure was amended, the questions as to admissibility and proof used to be considered during the course of chief examination of a witness through whom the documents are introduced. In view of the amendment to the Code, a witness is entitled to file an affidavit in lieu of his chief examination. In the affidavit, the documents, which he intends to rely upon, are invariably referred to. In such a case, there would not be any occasion either for the Court or for the opposite party to scrutinize the admissibility or proof of a document. This, however, does not mean that every document, which is referred to in the affidavit, has to be treated either as having been admitted or proved. The event, which hitherto, used to occur at the stage of chief examination, stands relegated to the stage of cross-examination. During, the course of cross-examination, the opposite party can certainly raise objections as to the admissibility or proof of any document. In such an event, the witness or the party, who intends to rely upon the document, may chose either to withdraw the document from the evidence, or to meet the objections that may have been raised by the opposite party. In such an event, only those documents, which survive the objections raised by the opposite party, can constitute the documentary evidence of the case, and not those in respect of which the objections are sustained. The result would be, notwithstanding the fact that the documents were referred to with a particular marking in the affidavit filed in lieu of the chief examination, the Court has, invariably to exclude such of those documents, which are found either to be inadmissible or not proved. Consequently, a new numbering and marking needs to be assigned to the documents introduced through a witness and found to have been proved and admissible, at the conclusion of the cross-examination. Though not, in so many terms, the trial Court indicated such a course of action. Hence, no exception can be taken to the order under revision.

9. The civil revision petition is accordingly dismissed, leaving it open to the petitioner to raise objections as to the admissibility or proof of the documents relied upon by D.W 1 during the course of his cross-examination.