- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Bheemati Dawood v. Madichetty Rachaiah And Others
Case Summary: Revision under Section 91 of the A.P. (T.A.) Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed an application under Section 32 of the A.P. (T.A) Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950 before the Mandal Revenue Officer (the 2nd respondent) claiming that his late father, Baliga, was the protected tenant of lands in Sy. Nos. 504, 505 and 506 of Sadasivapet Village and Mandal (about 10 acres), and that the 1st respondent (landlord) was unauthorisedly in possession. The Mandal Revenue Officer rejected the petitioner's claim by order dated 8-8-1994. The petitioner appealed to the Revenue Divisional Officer, Sanga Reddy, who dismissed the appeal on 8-5-1995. The petitioner then presented an appeal to the Joint Collector (the 3rd respondent) with an application to condone the delay; the 3rd respondent dismissed that appeal by order dated 10-4-2003. The petitioner filed the present revision (CRP) under Section 91 of the Act challenging those decisions.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the petitioner (as the successor of his father) was entitled to restoration of possession of the lands under Section 32 of the Act as a protected tenant or legal representative of a protected tenant.
- Whether the absence of an ownership certificate under Section 38-E of the Act defeats a claim for restoration of possession under Section 32.
- Whether an alleged surrender of tenancy recorded by the Tahsildar in 1963 complied with the procedure prescribed by Section 19 of the Act and thus precluded the petitioner from seeking relief under Section 32.
- Whether a belated application under Section 32 can be refused on grounds of delay, changed position of the opposite party, estoppel or acquisance, having regard to Supreme Court authority on reasonable time for filing such applications.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner's Arguments (as presented by learned counsel for the petitioner)
- Once an individual is declared a protected tenant under the Act, the protected tenant or his legal representatives are entitled to restoration of possession irrespective of the time gap between dispossession and the date of application.
- The 2nd respondent wrongly rejected the application on the ground that no ownership certificate under Section 38-E was issued; the 3rd respondent wrongly held that the petitioner's father was not a protected tenant.
- The final record of agricultural tenancies (Form No. V / Part I) in respect of the lands conforms to Part I (protected tenancies) and minor discrepancies are inconsequential.
- The alleged surrender of tenancy by the 1st respondent does not conform to the statutory procedure and is therefore invalid.
- There was no valid surrender of tenancy; an improper surrender is inoperative in law. Reliance was placed on Section 32, the Full Bench judgment in Sada v. Tahsildar, Utnoor (1987 (2) ALT 749 (FB)), and the Bombay High Court judgment in Keshav Ganesh Badekar v. Gopinath Krishna Salunke (2003 AIHC 1918) to support entitlement to restoration.
1st Respondent's Arguments (as presented by learned Additional Advocate-General appearing for the 1st respondent)
- The initiation of proceedings under Section 32 requires the existence of an undisputed protected tenancy; the final record of tenancies shows non-protected tenancy for the land in question.
- The father of the petitioner surrendered the tenancy in 1963 and that surrender was recorded by the then Tahsildar in accordance with Section 19 of the Act.
- The absence of a Section 38-E ownership certificate is relevant and the petitioner cannot rely on such a certificate to establish rights not shown in the record.
- Reliance on the Supreme Court judgment in Ponnala Narsing Rao v. Nattolla Pantaiah — a belated application under Section 32 cannot be maintained because a reasonable time is required; delay can prejudice the other side which may have changed position or incurred expenditure.
- The 1st respondent developed the land, incurred expenditure, created third-party rights after 1963, and an application under Section 32 cannot be entertained after 30 years (submission advanced by counsel).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Sada v. Tahsildar, Utnoor, 1987 (2) ALT 749 (Full Bench) | The Full Bench view that a tenant or his legal heir is entitled to be restored possession of land covered by the tenancy irrespective of the date of dispossession; Section 32 can apply without a time limit. | The Court noted this Full Bench view but recorded that the Supreme Court subsequently adopted a different approach emphasizing reasonable time; the Full Bench rule was considered but not followed as an absolute bar to applying Supreme Court guidance on delay. |
| Ponnala Narsing Rao v. Nattolla Pantaiah (Supreme Court) | Although Section 32 contains no express limitation period, applications must be moved within a reasonable time because belated applications may prejudice the other side (changed position, expenses, equities). | The Court relied on this principle to assess the present case and concluded that the factors identified by the Supreme Court (delay, change of position, expenditure by the 1st respondent) were established, supporting dismissal of the petition. |
| Keshav Ganesh Badekar v. Gopinath Krishna Salunke, 2003 AIHC 1918 (Bombay High Court) | The decision holds that surrender of tenancy must comply with the statutory procedure and an improper surrender cannot be recognized in law (analogous provision in the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948). | The Court cited this authority for the proposition that Section 19's procedural requirements must be satisfied for a valid surrender; after examining the record, the Court found the 1963 endorsement by the Tahsildar to indicate compliance with Section 19 and treated that surrender as valid. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining the statutory framework and the available records, and then applied the law to the facts before it:
-
Statutory framework:
- The Act distinguishes protected and non-protected tenancies; Section 34 prescribes the circumstances in which a person is deemed a protected tenant.
- Section 38-E provides a mechanism by which a protected tenancy may ripen into ownership, but the Court observed that the right to restoration under Section 32 does not depend on the existence of a Section 38-E certificate.
- Section 19 prescribes the procedure for surrender of tenancy: surrender must be in writing, admitted before the Tahsildar, and made in good faith; though no form is prescribed, the presence of the Tahsildar is the prime requirement.
-
Examination of the records:
- The petitioner relied on the final list of tenancies (Form No. V). That list contained an inconsistency: on one hand it was indicated as prepared in Part I (protected tenancies) and on the other hand described as for non-protected tenancies.
- The Kasara Pahani for 1954-55 recorded the 1st respondent as in possession and as the person cultivating the land; the father of the petitioner was recorded in the encumbrances/rights column as tenant.
- The abstract of protected tenancies in Part I contained an endorsement dated 1963 by the then Tahsildar (in Urdu) recording that the protected tenant had surrendered his tenancy; the petitioner disputed the existence/validity of those proceedings but could not produce the certified file extracts requested earlier.
-
Application of Section 19 to the 1963 endorsement:
- The Court emphasized that surrender must occur in the presence of the Tahsildar. The 1963 endorsement by the Tahsildar, and the fact that a separate file/proceedings were referenced, led the Court to conclude that the requirements of Section 19 had been complied with.
- The Court rejected the petitioner's contention that the surrender did not take place in accordance with Section 19, finding the petitioner's challenge to the existence of the surrender difficult to accept in the face of the Tahsildar's recorded endorsement and subsequent events.
-
Consideration of subsequent conduct and detrimental reliance:
- After the alleged surrender in 1963, the 1st respondent exercised rights of absolute ownership in respect of the land, submitted a declaration under the Ceiling Act showing these survey numbers as part of his holding, and the Land Reforms Tribunal treated the land as part of his ownership and adjusted holdings under the Ceiling Act.
- The 1st respondent also purportedly developed the land and incurred expenditure; third-party rights were said to have been created after 1963.
- The father of the petitioner lived until 1984 and did not seek restoration during his lifetime; the petitioner only applied in 1994. The Court considered this prolonged silence and the passage of time as reinforcing the validity of the recorded surrender.
-
Effect of judicial authority on delay:
- The Court acknowledged the Full Bench view in Sada that there is no time limit for seeking restoration under Section 32, but noted that the Supreme Court in Ponnala Narsing Rao clarified that applications must be moved within a reasonable time because delay may prejudice the other side.
- Applying the Ponnala factors (delay, change of position, expenditure and equities in favor of the respondent), the Court found that the circumstances in the present case established prejudice and change of position by the 1st respondent, and therefore sustained refusal of the belated claim.
-
Conclusion of analysis:
- Given the Tahsildar's 1963 endorsement of surrender complying with Section 19, the subsequent acts of the 1st respondent (exercise of ownership, declarations under the Ceiling Act, development and expenditure), and the long delay before the petitioner's application, the Court concluded that the petitioner had not made out a case for restoration under Section 32.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The revision petition (CRP) is dismissed.
Implications and immediate consequences:
- The orders of the Mandal Revenue Officer (2nd respondent) rejecting the petitioner's Section 32 application and the order of the Joint Collector (3rd respondent) dismissing the appeal were effectively upheld by this Court through dismissal of the revision.
- The petitioner is not entitled to restoration of possession of the lands in Sy. Nos. 504, 505 and 506 on the facts before the Court.
- No costs were awarded ("No costs").
- The Court applied existing authorities (including the Supreme Court's guidance in Ponnala) and statutory interpretation to the facts; the judgment resolves the dispute between the parties on these facts and does not purport to lay down a new general precedent beyond applying cited authorities to the record before it.
This summary is prepared strictly from the content of the provided opinion. No outside facts or inferences beyond the text have been introduced.
1. This revision is filed under Section 91 of the A.P. (T.A) Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to as "the Act").
2. The petitioner submitted an application under Section 32 of the Act before the Mandal Revenue Officer, Sadasivapet Mandal, Medak District, the 2nd respondent, claiming that his father late Baliga was the protected tenant in respect of lands in Sy.Nos.504, 505 and 506 of Sadasivapet Village and Mandal, admeasuring about 10 acres and the 1st respondent, who is the landlord, is unauthorisedly continuing the possession of the said land. He prayed for restoration of possession to him. The 2nd respondent passed an order dated 8-8-1994, rejecting the claim of the petitioner.
3. Aggrieved by the same, the petitioner preferred an appeal before the Revenue Divisional Officer, Sanga Reddy. The appeal was dismissed through orders dated 8-5-1995. Alleging that the proper forum of appeal is the Joint Collector, the 3rd respondent herein, the petitioner presented another appeal before the 3rd respondent against the order of the 2nd respondent with an application to condone the delay. Through his orders dated 10-4-2003 the 3rd respondent dismissed the appeal. Hence, this revision.
4. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that once an individual is declared as a protected tenant under the Act in respect of a piece of land, such protected tenant or his legal representatives are entitled to be restored possession of such land, irrespective of the gap between the date of dispossession and date of submission of application. He contends that while the 2nd respondent rejected the application of the petitioner on the ground that ownership certificate under Section 38-E of the Act, was not issued for such lands, the 3rd respondent rejected the appeal on the ground that the father of the petitioner was not the protected tenant at all. He contends that the final record of agricultural tenancies issued in Form No. V in respect of the lands in question conforms to part I; applicable protected tenancies and the minor discrepancies therein were inconsequential. He also contends that the plea of surrender of tenancy put forward by the 1st respondent does not accord with the procedure prescribed by law.
5. Learned Counsel contends that in the appeal presented to the Revenue Divisional Officer improperly, an altogether a different view was taken and in that view of the matter, the orders under revision cannot be sustained in law. He submits that there is no valid surrender of tenancy and an improper surrender of tenancy is inoperative in law. Placing reliance upon Section 32 of the Act, the judgment of this Court rendered by a Full Bench in Sada v. Tahsildar, Utnoor, 1987 (2) ALT 749 (FB), and the judgment of the Bombay High Court in Keshav Ganesh Badekar v. Gopinath Krishna Salunke, 2003 AIHC 1918, he submits that the petitioner is entitled to be restored the possession of the land.
6. Learned Additional Advocate-General appearing for the 1st respondent submits that the basic requirement for initiation of proceedings under Section 32 of the Act is the existence of an undisputed protected tenancy. He contends that the extracts of final record of tenancies in respect of the land in question clearly demonstrate that it was issued for nonprotected tenancies. It is also his case that whatever be the nature of the tenancy, the father of the petitioner had surrendered it, way back in the year 1963, and that it was recorded by the then Tahsildar in accordance with Section 19 of the Act. Learned Additional Advocate-General also contends that in view of the judgment of the Supreme Court in Ponnala Nursing Rao v. Nallolla Pantaiah, , a belated application under Section 32 of the Act, cannot be maintained. He further contends that the 1st respondent had developed the land, incurred expenditure, and created 3rd party rights after 1963, and that an application under Section 32 of the Act, cannot be entertained after 30 years.
7. The petitioner claims that his father was the protected tenant in respect of the land referred to above. On that basis, he submitted an application under Section 32 of the Act. The claim was rejected by the Mandal Revenue Officer, the 2nd respondent, and the rejection was affirmed in the appeal by the 3rd respondent.
8. The A.P. State Legislature enacted the Act with a view to confer rights on the tenants of agricultural lands. Two types of tenancies were dealt with under the Act, namely, protected tenancies, and non-protected tenancies. Section 34 of the Act prescribed the circumstances under which a person can be deemed to be a protected tenant, such as, being a tenant for a period not less than six years preceding 1-1-1948, or for a period not less than six years commencing from 6-10-1943 etc., and having cultivated the land personally during such period. The Act provides for the transformation of protected tenancies into ownership rights, under Section 38-E. Such a facility does not exist in case of non-protected tenancies. They are dealt with under Section 5 of the Act.
9. The Act contemplates preparation of list of final tenancies. Once such a list is published, the effected persons, be it, tenants or landlords, are permitted under Section 35 to submit their objections within a period of one year from the date of commencement of the Act, in the prescribed form to the Tahsildar. Under Sub-section (2) thereof, the list, which is prepared after consideration of such objections, assumes finality.
10. Rules are framed under the Act for the purpose of preparation of final list of non-protected tenancies and other allied matters. The record of agricultural tenancies is required to be maintained in Form No. V. Part-I thereof applies to protected tenancies and part-II for non-protected tenancies.
11. A tenancy in respect of agricultural land can be terminated only in accordance with the procedure prescribed under Section 19 Of the Act. It insists that the surrender of the tenancy shall be in writing, admitted before the Tahsildar and made in good faith.
12. Reverting to the facts of the case, the petitioner did not place much material before the 2nd respondent along with the application. However, the 1st respondent filed copy of final list of tenancies prepared in 1951; copy of Kasara Pahani for 1954-55; copy of record of rights of the year 1979-80; Pahani for 1991, and copy of the judgment of the Land Reforms Tribunal, passed in the declaration submitted by him.
13. The petitioner relied upon the final list of tenancies prepared in respect of the village. There is some discrepancy as to the heading of the list. On the one hand, it is indicated that the list is prepared in Part-I and on the other hand, it is described as the one for non-protected tenancies. As observed earlier, this Part applies to protected tenancies.
14. The list is followed by a revenue record called as Kasara Pahani, which is prepared in the years 1954-55. This constituted the basis for recording of the nature of the rights in respect of the lands, at the relevant period of time. In this, the land is recorded in the name of the 1st respondent. In column No. 17, relating to the name of the person, who is actually cultivating the land, the name of the 1st respondent is entered. In column No. 15, which relates to the encumbrances and other rights, the name of the father of the petitioner is entered as tenant. Since the Act is part of agrarian reforms, the benefit of doubt deserves to be read in favour of the tenants. Therefore, for all practical purposes, it can be proceeded as though the father of the petitioner was the protected tenant in respect of the said lands.
15. The 2nd respondent took the view that the material before him does not support the claim of the petitioner and at any rate no certificate under Section 38-E of the Act, was issued for the land. He treated non-existence of a certificate under Section 38-E, as a circumstance against the petitioner. In this regard, it needs, however, to be observed that the right of a protected tenant or his successor to be restored the possession of the land, does not depend on the existence of a certificate under Section 38-E. It may be true that a protected tenancy, subject to certain conditions, may ripen into an ownership under Section 38-E. However, the fact that a protected tenant or his successor is not issued any ownership certificate under Section 38-E, does not, in any way, water down his rights, under Section 32 of the Act. Therefore, it needs to be seen as to whether the father of the petitioner continued to be a protected tenant in respect of the said lands.
16. In the copy of the abstract of protected tenancies issued in Part-I, the name of the father of the petitioner figured vis-avis the lands referred to above. In the same abstract, there is an endorsement vide proceedings No. C2/3144/1963 made by the then Tahsildar. This is in Urdu. The translation thereof is said to be to the effect that the protected tenant has surrendered his tenancy. The tenancy, be it, protected or otherwise, referred to in the Act, can be surrendered only in the manner prescribed under Section 19. Any surrender otherwise than through the procedure prescribed under Section 19, cannot be recognized in law. The Bombay High Court in Keshav Ganesh Badekar v. Gopinath Krishna Salunke (supra) held so, while dealing with an analogous provision in the Bombay Tenancy and Agricultural Lands Act, 1948. There are several judgments of this Court to the same effect.
17. Neither Section 19 nor the Rules prescribe any form, for the purpose of surrendering any tenancy. Section 19, however, insists that the surrender shall be in writing and the tenant shall admit of such surrender, in the presence of the Tahsildar. Therefore, the prime requirement is that the surrender shall take place in the presence of the Tahsildar. In the case on hand, the endorsement as to surrender was made by the Tahsildar in the year 1963. It refers to certain proceedings, which indicate that a separate file is prepared therefor. Learned Counsel for the petitioner submits that when the petitioner made applications for such certified copy of the said proceedings, they were not furnished. On that basis, he disputes the very existence of surrender.
18. It is too difficult to accept the contention of the petitioner in this regard. The endorsement made by the Tahsildar is in the year 1963. The provisions of section 19 can be said to have been complied with, in the matter of surrender. The fact that ever since the surrender, the 1st respondent exercised the right of an absolute owner in respect of that land, would add strength to the validity of such surrender. It is a matter of record that the 1st respondent submitted a declaration under the provisions of the A.P. Land Reforms (Ceiling on Agricultural Holdings) Act, 1973 (for short "the Ceiling Act"), showing the land in Sy.Nos. 504, 505 and 506, as part of his holding. The Land Reforms Tribunal held that the 1st respondent owns an extent of 8 standard holdings and the land to that extent was surrendered by the 1st respondent. Thereby, he suffered detriment in the form of surrender of equivalent extent of lands under the Ceiling Act. Had there been any dispute as to the surrender of tenancy, the occasion to part with equal extent of land would not have arisen.
19. The father of the petitioner was alive till the year 1984. He did not make any claim for the lands in the said survey numbers during his lifetime. While tenancy is a phenomenon brought about by operation of law, surrender comes into existence with specific acts of parties. If the person alleged to have surrendered the tenancy remains silent for more than two decades after such surrender, an inference as to its validity can necessarily be drawn. Therefore, it is not open to the petitioner to take exception to the surrender of tenancy by his father. Though it is alleged that the endorsement as to surrender of tenancy was made when the matter was pending before the Revenue Divisional Officer, a perusal of the record discloses that the contention is without any basis. Once the tenancy was surrendered in accordance with Section 19 of the Act, it was not open to the petitioner to submit an application under Section 32 of the Act.
20. In Sada v. Tahsildar, Utnoor (supra) the Full Bench of this Court took the view that a tenant or his legal heir is entitled to be restored the possession of the land covered by the tenancy, irrespective of the date of dispossession. Section 32 applies to non-protected and protected tenancies. The plea of adverse possession against the tenants of any category, was held to be not available. In a way, it was indicated that there is no time limit for seeking restoration of possession under Section 32. Recently, the Supreme Court struck a different note on this aspect, mostly on the grounds of estoppel and acquisance. In Ponnala Narsing Rao v. Nattolla Pantaiah (supra), the Supreme Court held as under:
"So far as the second contention is concerned, it is true that though no express period of limitation is provided for filing application under Section 32 of the Act, such applications have to be moved within reasonable time. It may be because of such belated applications, the other side may stand adversely affected. It may have changed its position in the meantime. Equities may have arisen in his favour, he may have spent large amounts on land by improving it."
21. In the present case, the petitioner did not plead as to when his or his father dispossessed. The entries in the Kasara Pahani for the years 1954-55 discloses that the 1st respondent was in possession of the land. Though the father of the petitioner was shown as protected tenant, his tenancy was surrendered in the year 1963. The application is made for the first time by the petitioner in the year 1994. The 1st respondent exercised the rights of absolute ownership at least from 1963. He surrendered the land from other survey numbers equivalent extent in these survey numbers under the Ceiling Act. It is categorically pleaded that he has developed the land by incurring huge expenditure. The factors indicated by the Supreme Court to reject a belated application under Section 32 of the Act are clearly established in this case through record.
22. Under these circumstances, the petitioner cannot be said to have made out a case for restoration of possession under Section 32 of the Act.
23. The CRP is accordingly dismissed. No costs.
Alert