Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Pudi Balraju v. Jallu Annapoorna

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Aug 1, 2003
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Concise Analytical Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner is the plaintiff in O.S. No. 38 of 2000 before the learned Junior Civil Judge, Narasannapeta. This Civil Revision Petition challenges the order dated 26 March 2002 in O.S. No. 38 of 2000 overruling an objection by the petitioner-plaintiff to the admissibility of an unregistered partition deed dated 19-1-1985, which the respondent-defendant sought to mark during the cross-examination of PW1.

During cross-examination PW1 admitted his signature on the document dated 19-1-1985. The petitioner’s counsel objected that the document was insufficiently stamped and unregistered. The trial Judge examined the recitals, found it to be a deed of partition, overruled the objection and allowed the document to be marked for limited, collateral purposes (in particular to establish severance in status and the nature/character of possession), while not permitting it to serve as the source of title or to prove division by metes and bounds.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the unstamped and unregistered partition deed dated 19-1-1985 can be received into evidence.
  2. If admissible, for what purposes may such an unregistered partition deed be used in evidence (i.e., whether it may prove terms of partition or only collateral matters such as severance in status and character of possession)?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Petitioner‑Plaintiff)

  • The petitioner's counsel objected to the marking of the document on the ground that it was insufficiently stamped and was not registered (i.e., it failed the statutory requirements for a registered instrument).

Respondent‑Defendant

  • The opinion records that the respondent‑defendant sought to mark the partition deed during the cross‑examination of PW1. The text does not set out any further, specific argument advanced by the respondent in support of admissibility beyond seeking to mark the document and using it as evidence.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy (Full Bench) Held that an unregistered partition document is inadmissible to prove the terms of partition (it is the source of title) but may be looked at to establish a severance in status; severance may be proved by oral communication or a writing which, though unregistered, is admissible to show intention to separate. The court relied on this Full Bench rule to support the proposition that the impugned unregistered deed cannot prove the terms of partition or serve as source of title but may be used to establish severance in status (a collateral purpose).
C.S. Kumaraswami v. A. Gounder (Division Bench, Madras High Court) Explained the three stages of partition (division in status; division of properties by metes and bounds; taking possession). Held that only written division by metes and bounds, if reduced to writing, requires registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act; unregistered partition deed cannot prove terms/allotments but can be used for collateral purposes like proving division in status and nature/character of possession. The court invoked this authority extensively to justify admitting the deed for collateral purposes (to prove division in status and character of possession) while excluding it as proof of metes-and-bounds allotments or as a source of title.
Rajangam Ayyar v. Rajangam Ayyar (50 Ind App 134 = AIR 1922 PC 266) Referenced as an earlier authority supporting the distinction between admissibility for collateral purposes and inadmissibility to prove the terms of a partition when the deed is unregistered. Cited within the reasoning of C.S. Kumaraswami and relied upon to underpin the court's conclusion that an unregistered partition deed may be admissible for collateral purposes such as showing the character of possession.
Bai Gulabbai v. Sri Datgarji (1907) 9 Bom LR 393 Defines "collateral purpose" as any purpose other than creating, declaring, assigning, limiting or extinguishing a right to immovable property; used to explain the scope of admissibility for collateral transactions under the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act. Used to support the proposition that proof of severance in status or the character of possession is a collateral purpose that does not require registration and therefore can be established by an unregistered document.
Ramlaxmi v. Bank of Baroda (Bombay High Court) Discussed the meaning of "collateral transaction" and explained how a written instrument may contain a collateral purpose separable from a primary (registrable) transaction. Relied on to show that the memo of partition could contain a collateral element (severance of status) though the main partition/allotment required registration; this supports admitting part of the unregistered document for collateral purposes.
K. Vijaya v. K. Venkataiah (Single Judge of this Court) Applied the Full Bench and Madras Division Bench authorities to hold that only the stage of dividing properties by metes and bounds (if reduced to writing) requires registration under Section 17(1)(b); an unregistered partition deed is admissible for proving division in status and character/nature of possession (collateral purposes). The court cited this decision as consistent authority for admitting an unregistered partition deed only for collateral purposes and used it in confirming the trial Judge's approach in the present case.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the narrow question as whether the unstamped and unregistered partition deed dated 19-1-1985 could be received in evidence and, if so, for what purposes. The court observed that the legal question is not novel and turned to earlier authorities to extract the applicable principles.

The authorities establish a categorical distinction between: (a) the stage of dividing properties by metes and bounds and allotting specific items (which, if reduced to writing, creates a document that must be registered under Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act and cannot be proved by an unregistered document); and (b) collateral matters such as a division in status (severance of coparcenary) and the character or nature of possession and taking possession, which do not by themselves create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish rights in immovable property and therefore do not require registration.

The court applied these principles to the facts: - It accepted the trial Judge's factual finding that the questioned document is a deed of partition and that it is unstamped and unregistered. - It agreed with the trial Judge that while the document cannot be used to prove the terms of the partition or to serve as the source of title (i.e., cannot prove division by metes and bounds or specific allotments), it can be examined for collateral purposes. - Specifically, the unregistered document may be used to show severance in status (an unequivocal intention to separate) and the taking of possession and the nature/character of possession of the shares allotted — matters collateral to the registrable transaction.

The court also took into account the procedural posture of the suit: the present action was for declaration of title and perpetual injunction, not a suit for partition and separate possession; that context supported admitting the deed for limited collateral purposes relevant to the issues in suit.

Finally, the court concluded that the trial Judge's decision to admit and mark the document for collateral purposes was correct and consistent with the cited authorities.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The Civil Revision Petition is dismissed. The court concluded that the trial Judge correctly received the document dated 19-1-1985 into evidence for limited, collateral purposes.

Core Ruling: The unregistered and insufficiently stamped partition deed dated 19-1-1985 is admissible in evidence only for collateral purposes (to prove a division in status/severance and the fact and character of possession) but cannot be utilized to prove the stage of dividing properties by metes and bounds or to serve as a source of title.

Direct consequences and orders explicitly stated in the opinion:

  • The civil revision petition was dismissed; no order as to costs was made.
  • The interim stay previously granted by the Court was vacated.
  • The respondent-defendant had failed to appear despite notice; the Court appointed and acknowledged the assistance of Sri Y. Ramathirtha, Advocate as Amicus Curiae.

Implications: The opinion applies existing authorities to the facts but does not purport to establish a new legal principle. The decision's practical effect is limited to the parties: the document may be used in the ongoing suit for collateral evidentiary purposes only, and it may not be relied upon to prove metes-and-bounds partition or title.

This summary is based exclusively on the content of the provided opinion text.

Show all summary ...

1. The plaintiff in O.S. No. 38 of 2000 on the file of the learned Junior Civil Judge, Narasannapeta is the petitioner in this Civil Revision Petition directed against the order dated 26th March, 2002 made in O.S. No. 38 of 2000 by the learned Judge overruling the objection raised by the petitioner-plaintiff as to the admissibility of un-registered partition deed dated 19-1-1985 filed by the respondent-defendant during the course of cross-examination of PW1.

2. During the course of cross-examination of PW1, he was confronted with a document dated 19-1-1985. PW1 readily admitted his signature on the said document dated 19-1-1985. The counsel for the petitioner-plaintiff, however, raised an objection contending that the said document cannot be marked as the same is insufficiently stamped and is not registered. The learned Judge upon perusal of the recitals of the said document found the same to be a deed of partition. There is no dispute whatsoever that the said deed of partition, which is now sought to be marked by the respondent-defendant, is neither stamped properly nor registered.

3. The learned Judge, however, overruled the said objections and held that the said document, though unregistered, can be looked into for the limited purpose of establishing a severance in status though that severance would clearly affect the nature of possession. The learned Judge further found that the said document can be used for the limited and collateral purpose of showing the division of properties between the parties and accordingly held that the document dated 19-1-1985 is admissible for collateral purposes.

4. The short question that falls for consideration in the instant case is whether the unstamped and unregistered partition deed dated 19-1-1985 can at all be received into evidence and if so for what purposes?

5. The question that falls for consideration is not res integra. In Muthyalareddy v. Venkatareddy (FB) a Full Bench of this Court held that where a partition takes place, the terms of which are incorporated in an unregistered document, that document is inadmissible in evidence and cannot be looked for the terms of the partition. It is in fact the source of title to the property held by each of the erstwhile coparceners. That document, though unregistered, can, however, be looked into for the purpose of establishing a severance in status, though that severance would ultimately affect the nature of the possession held by the members of the separated family who from thence onwards, hold it as co-tenants. That, for a severance in status, all that is required is a communication to the other members of the joint family, of an unequivocal intention to separate. This communication of intention could be done orally or by a notice in writing to the coparceners, or by other means depending upon the facts and circumstances of the case. If the intention is expressed by reducing the same to writing such a document, though unregistered, is admissible and can be looked into, as long as it is not the source of title of any of the properties which each of the erstwhile coparceners hold as a result of that partition. (Emphasis is supplied).

6. A Division Bench of Madras High Court in C.S. Kumaraswami v. A. Gounder, , after an elaborate consideration of the matter and referring to the earlier precedents including the judgments of the Privy Council stated the law in the following terms:

"A partition in a joint Hindu family may denote either of two things: (i) a division in status as between the members of the coparcenary; and (ii) an actual division of the properties belonging to the joint family by metes and bounds as between the different members of the family. The expression 'partition' has been used indiscriminately to denote either one or the other of the two things. Once a partition of the properties by metes and bounds has taken place, naturally there will be the consequential transaction of the parties, to whom the properties have been allotted separately, taking possession of these properties. Thus it will be seen that in the case of an express, completed partition there will be three different stages- (i) the stage of effecting a division in status, (ii) the stage of dividing the properties by metes and bounds, and (iii) the stage of each party taking possession of the properties allotted to his share. As far as these three stages are concerned, it is conceded, having regard to the decided cases, that each and every one of them can be effected orally without there being a document. Even if there is a written document in respect of the first and third stages, then also it is conceded that the document does not require registration, because neither the division in status nor the actual taking possession of the properties can be said to create, declare, assign, limit or extinguish any right, title or interest to or in immovable property. Therefore, it is only with regard to the second stage, namely, division of properties in different shares and allotment thereof to the various members, if the same is reduced to writing, it requires registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Act. Under the Hindu law, it is well settled that, severance in status can take place either by the unilateral declaration of one of the coparceners or by agreement between all the coparceners. Where severance is effected as above, it is not a transaction which requires any writing and even if it is effected by means (if any instrument in writing, that will not fall within the scope of Section 17(1)(b) of the Act. Similar will be the position with regard to taking possession of the properties. From the very nature of the case, once a division of the properties by metes and bounds has taken place as between the members of a coparcenary and the parties take possession as exclusive owners of the respective items allotted to them, such a partition assumes a division in status having taken place between the parties. Therefore, though an unregistered partition deed cannot be admitted in evidence to prove the terms of the partition, it can certainly be admitted in evidence for proving the division in status and the fact of partition, as pointed out by several decisions based on the judgment of the Privy Council in Rajangam Ayyar v. Rajangam Ayyar, 50 Ind App 134 = (AIR 1922 PC 266). Similarly, taking possession of the shares allotted to each one of the parties at the partition will be a purpose collateral to the purpose of partition and such taking possession not creating, declaring, assigning, limiting or extinguishing any right, title or interest to or in immovable property, will not require registration, and therefore an unregistered deed of partition can be used for the collateral purpose, namely, for proving the nature and character of the possession of the respective items of properties in the hands of the members of the coparcenary. In Bai Gulabbai v. Sri Datgarji, (1907) 9 Bom LR 393, it was pointed out that a collateral purpose is any purpose other than that of creating, declaring, assigning, limiting or extinguishing a right to immovable property. Therefore a collateral transaction within the meaning of the proviso to Section 49 of the Act means a transaction other than the transaction affecting immovable property, but which is in some way connected with it. In Ramlaxmi v. Bank of Baroda, the Bombay High Court pointed out--

'The expression 'collateral' transaction is used not in the sense of an ancillary transaction to a principal transaction or a subsidiary transaction to a main transaction. The root meaning of the word 'collateral' is running together or running on parallel lines. The transaction as recorded would be a particular or specific transaction. But it would be possible to read in that transaction what may be called the purpose of the transaction and what may be called a collateral purpose, the fulfillment of that collateral purpose would bring into existence a collateral transaction, a transaction which may be said to be a part and parcel of the transaction but nonetheless a transaction which runs together with or on parallel lines with the same.

An obvious illustration of this is the transaction which is recorded in the memo of petition before us. The transaction therein recorded was a transaction of partition of the movable and immovable properties belonging to the joint family. These properties were allotted to the shares of the respective members of the family. A partition was in fact effected by this document and that transaction took place under the terms of the document itself. The memo of partition thus required registration and not being registered could not be admitted in evidence under the terms of Section 49, Registration Act. There was, however, involved in this transaction itself a collateral transaction, viz., that of the severance of the joint status which transaction by itself did not require to be registered by any law for the time being in force. A severance of joint status could be effected under Hindu law in various modes, one of the modes being an unequivocal expression of an intention to separate. A partition could be effected orally as well as by a written document, and it would be open to a party to prove that there was a partition or severance of joint status effected between the parties without its being effected by a registered instrument. A partition i.e., severance of joint status thus would be a collateral transaction, and would certainly fall within the proviso to Section 49 of the Registration Act."

It is further observed:

"..... .even though an unregistered deed of partition, as in the present case, is not admissible in evidence for proving the terms of the partition as well as the items of the properties that were allotted to the appellant on the one hand and his deceased elder brother on the other, certainly it can be used as evidence for the purpose of showing the character in which the deceased........ was in possession of the properties allotted to his share......"
(Emphasis is of mine).

7. A learned single Judge of this Court in K. Vijaya v. K. Venkataiah, , relying upon the Full Bench decision of this Court in Muthyalareddy (supra) and the Division Bench decision of the Madras High Court in C.S. Kumaraswami (supra) held that it is only with regard to the stage of dividing the properties by metes and bounds and allotment thereof to the various members, if the same is reduced to writing, it requires registration under Section 17(1)(b) of the Registration Act. An un-registered partition deed though not admissible to prove the terms of the partition can be admitted in evidence for proving the division in status and the nature and character of the possession of the shares, these being collateral purposes.

8. In the instant case, the learned Judge having overruled the objections ordered the document in question to be received and marked in evidence for collateral purposes. The suit on hand is not a suit for partition and separate possession of any immovable properties. The suit is only for declaration of title and perpetual injunction. It is under those circumstances, the learned Judge came to the conclusion that the document dated 19-1-1985, though unregistered, for a limited collateral purpose to prove the division in status, taking of possession and the nature and character of the possession of the shares allotted since these being collateral purposes, can be received into evidence.

9. In the circumstances, I am of the considered opinion that the document dated 19-1-1985 has been rightly received into evidence for collateral purposes. The said document, however, cannot be uitlised to prove the stage of dividing the properties by metes and bounds. The documents can certainly be uitlised for the collateral purposes, viz., to prove the stage of effecting a division in status and the stage of parties taking possession of the properties allotted to them.

10. For the aforesaid reasons, I do not find any merit in this civil revision petition. The same shall accordingly stand dismissed. No order as to costs.

11. Consequently, the interim stay earlier granted by this Court shall accordingly stand vacated.

12. The respondent-defendant in spite of receiving the notice failed to respond and enter her appearance. In the circumstances, the Court has requested Sri Y. Ramathirtha, Advocate to assist the Court as Amicus Curiae. The Court acknowledges the invaluable assistance rendered by the learned Amicus Curiae.