- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dasari Laxmi v. Union Of India .
Summary of the Opinion — Appeal from Railway Claims Tribunal (Secunderabad Bench)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appeal challenges an award of the Railway Claims Tribunal, Secunderabad Bench in O.A.A. No. 8 of 1997 dated 16.10.1997, which dismissed a claim for compensation. The claimant (applicant) is the wife and dependent of the deceased, Dasari Nageswara Rao. According to the application, on 9.10.1996 the deceased slipped and fell while attempting to board the Secunderabad–Palasa Visakha Express at Yelamanchili Railway Station, sustained injuries and died subsequently in Government Hospital, Visakhapatnam (death recorded on 10.10.1996). The claimant sought compensation of Rs. 2,00,000/-. The Railway did not file a written statement. The Tribunal framed and decided the issue whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger and, finding no evidence that a ticket was purchased, held that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger and dismissed the claim. The claimant appealed.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the claimant-appellant is entitled to compensation under the provisions of the Railways Act (specifically Section 124-A and related provisions) for the untoward incident that led to the death of the deceased passenger.
- On whom the burden of proof lies to establish that the deceased was a bona fide passenger (i.e., whether the claimant must prove purchase of a ticket or whether the Railways must prove lack of bonafide passenger status to deny liability).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The Tribunal erred in rejecting the claimant's application: the deceased was engaged in selling cigars and was travelling to Visakhapatnam by the Visakha Express with two co-sellers.
- Evidence from a co-passenger (co-seller, examined as P.W.2) established that the deceased purchased the ticket after borrowing Rs. 20/- from that co-passenger because the deceased had only a Rs.100/- note and the booking counter had no change.
- In absence of any contrary evidence, and because P.W.2's testimony was not effectively challenged in cross-examination, the Tribunal should have accepted that the deceased purchased a ticket.
- The burden to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger should lie on the Railways; it is impractical to require dependents to prove that the deceased had a ticket (relying on Madhya Pradesh High Court and other decisions).
- Relied on Raj Kumari v. Union of India (1993 ACJ 846 (MP)), Union of India v. Soram Bai (1998 (2) AJR 254), and Gullipali Lakshmikanthamma v. C.M. South Central Railway (2003 ACJ 1582 (AP)) in support of the proposition that the burden to disprove bona fide passenger status is on the Railways or that an inference of ticket-holding can be drawn.
Respondent (Railways) Arguments
- The Tribunal's conclusion was correct: it is the claimant who must prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger in order to claim compensation.
- There was a dispute both as to the occurrence of the accident and whether the deceased was travelling with a valid ticket; on the evidence the Tribunal correctly found the deceased was not a bona fide passenger.
- Relied on decisions of the Allahabad High Court — Sundari v. Union of India (1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad)) and Sudha Srivastava v. Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway (1985 ACJ 404 (Allahabad)) — to support the view that a passenger excludes trespassers or those travelling without ticket and that the claimant bears the burden in certain circumstances.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court in this Appeal |
|---|---|---|
| Raj Kumari v. Union of India, 1993 ACJ 846 (MP) | Held that the burden is on the Railways to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger; relied on Sections of the Evidence Act (including s.114) to support a presumption that passengers travelling have tickets when boarding without authorization is prohibited. | The Court relied on this decision to conclude that the burden to disprove bona fide passenger status lies on the Railways and that a presumption in favour of ticket-holding can be drawn; this supported setting aside the Tribunal's finding against the claimant. |
| Union of India v. Soram Bai, 1998 (2) AJR 254 (Rajasthan HC) | Expressed similar view to Raj Kumari, following that decision (i.e., supporting the proposition that the burden to disprove bona fide passenger status rests with the Railways). | The Court cited Soram Bai as reinforcing the Madhya Pradesh decision and used it to support the position that the Tribunal's approach was contrary to established authority. |
| Gullipali Lakshmikanthamma v. C.M. South Central Railway, 2003 ACJ 1582 (AP) | Held that an inference can be drawn that the deceased was a bona fide passenger given the realities of the situation; tickets may be lost or missing in the circumstances of injury/death. | The Court relied on this Court's prior decision to justify drawing an inference in favour of the claimant where circumstances and evidence (including eyewitness testimony) support bona fide passenger status. |
| Sundari v. Union of India, 1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad) | Full Bench held that 'passenger' does not include trespassers or persons travelling without ticket, pass or authority; compensation not payable for death of such trespasser in a train accident. | The respondent relied on Sundari; the present Court noted the decision but observed that Sundari does not address the burden of proof on whom it lies to show bona fide passenger status and thus distinguished its applicability to the present burden question. |
| Sudha Srivastava v. Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway, 1985 ACJ 404 (Allahabad) | Division Bench decision where the burden was held to lie on the claimant in that case; the dispute there included whether death resulted from the train accident and the Court found no reliable evidence of ticket purchase. | The respondent relied on this decision; the present Court distinguished it because the factual finding in Sudha was absence of any evidence of travelling or ticket, and thus it could not be taken as authority for placing the general burden on claimants where evidence (as here) supports ticket purchase. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded by addressing two linked matters: first, whether an untoward incident (accident) occurred on 9.10.1996 causing the death of the deceased; second, whether the deceased was a "passenger" within the Explanation to Section 124-A of the Railways Act (i.e., had purchased a valid ticket or valid platform ticket).
On the occurrence of the accident, although the Railway's witness R.W.1 (the Guard) denied any accident, the Tribunal had earlier found there was no controversy as to the occurrence of the untoward incident and the court accepted that finding — the deceased had suffered injuries on 9.10.1996 and died on 10.10.1996.
On the key legal question of burden of proof regarding bona fide passenger status, the court examined the competing authorities. It noted the appellant's reliance on Raj Kumari (Madhya Pradesh) which, interpreting earlier and comparable statutory provisions and sections of the Evidence Act, concluded that it was impractical to require dependents to prove a ticket was possessed at the time of boarding and that Section 114 could be invoked to draw a presumption that passengers travelling were ticket-holders when boarding without a ticket is prohibited. The Rajasthan decision in Soram Bai and this Court's earlier decision in Gullipali were cited as consistent authorities permitting an inference that a deceased was a bona fide passenger given realistic circumstances where tickets may be lost or unavailable after fatal injury.
The court also considered the Allahabad decisions relied upon by the Railways. Sundari holds that a 'passenger' does not include trespassers or those travelling without ticket, but that decision did not address who bears the burden of proof. Sudha Srivastava was found factually distinguishable: in that case the court found no reliable evidence that the deceased boarded the train or bought a ticket, so Sudha could not be treated as authority for the general proposition that the claimant must always bear the burden.
Turning to the evidence before the Tribunal: P.W.1 (the claimant) was not present at the time of ticket purchase and therefore her testimony was of limited value on that fact. However, P.W.2 was an eyewitness and co-seller who testified that he lent the deceased Rs.20/- because the booking counter had no change for a Rs.100/- note and that the deceased thereby purchased the ticket. Importantly, P.W.2's testimony was not effectively challenged — no suggestion was put in cross-examination denying that he had advanced Rs.20/- or disputing that the deceased purchased the ticket. The court found those omissions significant.
By contrast, R.W.2 (the Assistant Station Master) gave a version that a crowd had said the injured had a season ticket and he prepared a memo accordingly, but in cross-examination R.W.2 denied being pressured to mention a season ticket and admitted he could not identify any particular face in the crowd; his evidence was described by the court as "shaky" and lacking clarity on who pressed him to record the season-ticket assertion. The Tribunal had given more weight to R.W.2 and rejected P.W.2's evidence — a conclusion which the court found to be unjustified, particularly in view of P.W.2's unchallenged account and the tenuous and inconsistent aspects of R.W.2's testimony.
Applying the legal principles from the cited precedents (permitting a presumption or inference in favour of bona fide passenger status where appropriate and recognizing the impracticality for dependents to prove possession of a ticket lost in a fatal incident), and on the facts (credible eyewitness testimony that the deceased had purchased a ticket), the court concluded that the Tribunal erred in rejecting the claimant's case. Accordingly, the Tribunal's findings on the passenger/ticket issue were set aside.
Holding and Implications
CORE RULING: APPEAL ALLOWED; THE IMPUGNED ORDER OF THE TRIBUNAL IS SET ASIDE.
Direct effect on the parties:
- The claimant's appeal succeeds; the court held that the claimant is entitled to compensation in accordance with Part I of the Schedule to the Railway Accidents (Compensation) Rules, 1990 (thereby granting compensation as claimed subject to application of that Schedule).
- No costs were awarded.
Broader implications: The Court applied and followed earlier High Court and this Court decisions that favour drawing an inference of bona fide passenger status and placing the onus on the Railways to disprove such status in appropriate circumstances. The opinion does not assert that it is laying down a new precedent beyond applying and following the cited authorities and the statutory framework; it resolves the dispute on the particular facts and authorities presented.
1. This is an appeal filed by the applicant against the award passed by the Railway Claims Tribunal, Secunderabad Bench, Secunderabad in O.A.A. No. 8 of 1997, dated 16.10.1997 dismissing the claim.
2. As per the averments of the application, on 9.10.1996 while the deceased Dasari Nageswara Rao was trying to board Secunderabad-Palasa Visakha Express' at Yelamanchili Railway Station, he slipped and fell down from the train accidentally and sustained injuries. Subsequently, he died in the Government Hospital, Vishakhapatnam. The applicant being the wife, who is a dependent of the deceased, made a claim for compensation of Rs. 2,00,000/- in respect of the death of her husband.
3. No written statement was filed by the respondent Railway authorities. Thereafter, Tribunal framed the issue whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger or not and thereafter recorded the evidence of both sides and decided the issue holding that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger as there is no evidence showing that he had purchased the ticket and, therefore, dismissed the application of the claimant. Aggrieved by that, the applicant has come up in the present appeal.
4. The learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the Tribunal erred jn rejecting the claim of applicant. It is contended that the deceased was carrying on business in the sale of cigars at Visakhapatnam. On the date of accident, he along with two others, who were carrying similar business, was proceeding to Vishakhapatnam by 'Visakha Express' and the evidence of the co-passenger (co-seller) clearly shows that the deceased purchased the ticket by borrowing Rs. 20/- from the co-seller, as at the booking-counter, it was informed that there is no change for Rs. 100/- note which was offered for the purchase of the ticket and hence the deceased had borrowed Rs. 20/- from RW. 2 and purchased the ticket, which was clearly deposed by RVV. 2. In the light of the said evidence and in the absence of any other contra evidence, the Tribunal was not justified in rejecting the claim of the appellant/claimant. Learned Counsel also contended that the provisions which are intended to award compensation to the dependents of the deceased m an accident where it causes death of a passenger, the burden cannot be imposed on the dependents to prove that the deceased passenger was a bona fide passenger. The learned Counsel also contended that the burden should be on the Railways to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger in order to deny its liability to pay the compensation as provided under the provisions of the Railways Act. Learned Counsel also relied upon a decision of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of Raj Kumari v. Union of India 1993 ACJ 846 (MP), where it was held that the burden to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger is on the Railways. The learned Counsel also relied upon a decision of the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Union of India v. Soram Bai 1998 (2) AJR 254, where a similar view was taken by the Rajasthan High Court, following the decision of Madhya Pradesn High Court referred to above. The learned Counsel also relied upon a decision of this Court in the case of Gullipali Lakshmikanthamma v. C.M. South Central Railway 2003 ACJ 1582 (AP). The learned Counsel, therefore, contended that the view taken by the Tribunal is contrary to the above decisions, apart from the evidence on record and, therefore, sought for setting aside the impugned order.
5. The learned Standing Counsel for the respondent Railways on the other hand, supported the order of the Tribunal. The learned Counsel contended that it is for the claimant to prove that the deceased was a bona fide passenger in which case alone the claimant is entitled for compensation. The learned Counsel contended that there is a dispute both as to the accident as well as to the fact that the deceased was travelling with a valid ticket. Basing on the evidence adduced by both sides the Tribunal came to the conclusion that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger and, therefore, the claim was rightly rejected. The learned Counsel also relied upon two decisions of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Sundari v. Union of India 1984 ACJ 614 (Allahabad) and. Sudha Srivastava v. Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway 1985 ACJ 404 (Allahabad). The learned Counsel, therefore, sought for dismissal of the appeal.
6. Heard both sides and considered the material on record.
7. The dispute in this appeal is whether the claimant-appellant is entitled for any compensation under the provisions of the Railways Act, 1989.
8. Though it was disputed even as to the factum of accident, but the Tribunal on consideration of the material on record gave a finding that there is no controversy as to the untoward incident (accident) that had occurred on 9.10.1996 in which the deceased had received injuries and subsequently died in the hospital on 10.10.1996. Therefore, it is to be considered whether the deceased was a passenger as referred to in Clause (2) to the Explanation under Section 124-A, which reads as under:
Compensation on account of untoward incidents.-
(i) xxx xxx xxx
(ii) a person who has purchased a valid ticket for travelling, by a train carrying passengers, on any date or a valid platform ticket and becomes a victim of an untoward incident.
9. In order to decide the above, it is to be considered on whom the burden lies. Is it on the claimant or on the respondent authorities, who wants to deny the liability? In order to prove that the burden lies on the Railways, the appellant relied upon the judgment of the Madhya Pradesh High Court in the case of Raj Kuninri v. Union of India (supra). In that case, a Division Bench of the Madhya Pradesh High Court had an occasion to consider similar issue with reference to a claim under section 82-a of the old act, which corresponds to section 124. of course section 124-a was inserted for the first time in the year 1994 under which the compensation payable on account of untoward incident was specifically incorporated. Similarly, under Section 123, the term 'untoward incident' was also defined so as to include even the accidental falling of any passenger under a train carrying passengers. The Division Bench after considering the rival contentions and also referring to some of the relevant provisions of the Railways Act, which specifically prohibits travelling without pass or ticket, which would in fact result in imposition of punishment of imprisonment or fine and concluded that the burden is on the Railways to prove that the deceased was not a bona fide passenger. The relevant portion of the judgment reads as under:
The main question that arises in this case is on whom the onus of proof lies in such claim cases and whether any presumption under the Evidence Act can be raised. Normally, under Sections 101 and 102 of the Evidence Act, the burden to prove such facts, on which the legal right or liability depends, is on such person who asserts existence of these facts. But the question before us is whether the burden of proof that the deceased held a valid ticket, pass or permission during his journey, in which he died in accident, can be placed on his dependents. Obviously, such burden of proof is impossible to be discharged by the dependents, who can have no means of knowledge, whether the deceased, before boarding the train, had purchased a valid ticket, pass or permission from the railway authorities. It is likely that such a deceased passenger held a valid ticket, pass or permission, but the same is lost in the accident with the death of person and loss of his belongings, if any.
Thereafter, the Court referred to the provisions of Section 114 of the Evidence Act and held that when there is a prohibition to board the train and travel without a ticket or pass, it should be presumed that the passengers travelling in the train are the passengers with ticket. Holding so, the appeal was allowed granting compensation to which the claimants are entitled.
10. Similar view was taken by the Rajasthan High Court in the case of Soram Bai (supra). A learned Single Judge of this Court had also an occasion to consider a similar issue in case of Gullipalli Likshmikanthamma (supra), where the claimant's appeal was allowed holding as under:
After considering the same, I am of the opinion, that an inference can be drawn to the effect that the deceased is a bona fide passenger having regard to the realities and realistic and pragmatic approach of the question involved. It cannot invariably be conceived or comprehended that, always, ticket should be traced. One has to imagine the circumstances, that will prevail, at the relevant time and whether keeping of the ticket should be given that much of importance at the crucial time, when the deceased was suffering from fatal injuries died, the ticket could have been missing. So, from the material on record, it must be found that the deceased is a bona fide passenger.
11. On the other hand, learned Counsel for the respondent relied upon a decision of the Allahabad High Court in the case of Sundari v. Union of India (supra), where a Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court had considered the expression 'passenger' and held that it does not include trespasser or person travelling without ticket, pass or authority and, therefore, the compensation is not payable for the death of such trespasser in a train accident. The said decision does not deal with the burden on whom it lies to prove whether the deceased was a bona fide passenger or not. Similarly, in the case of Sudha v. Claims Commissioner, Northern Railway (supra), a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court had considered the scope of Sections 82-A and 82-F of the Railways Act. Though in that case it was held that the burden of proof lies on the claimant, in fact the dispute in that case was whether the deceased died in consequence of the train accident and the Court gave a finding that there was not reliable evidence to show that the deceased purchased a ticket and boarded the train. In that case the finding was that there is no evidence as to the travelling of the deceased in the train, which met with the accident. Therefore, it could not be an authority to support the contention of the respondent authorities that the burden lies on the claimant to prove that the deceased was a passenger in terms of Explanation to Section 124-A of the Act.
12. In the light of the above decisions, if we examine the evidence, which was considered by the Tribunal for recording a finding, on behalf of the claimant, the claimant herself was examined as P.W. 1 and got examined P.W. 2, who is said to be an eye-witness to the accident as well as to the purchase of the; ticket. In fact the evidence of P.W. 1 cannot be of much relevance as to the purchase of ticket as she was not present either at the time of the purchase of ticket or at the time of the accident. P.W. 1 categorically stated that the deceased tendered Rs. 100/- note at the railway booking counter and as the booking-clerk informed the deceased that he does not have the change; the deceased borrowed Rs. 20/- from P.W. 2 and purchased the ticket. In fact, hi the cross-examination of the said witness/not even a suggestion was made disputing his version that he had advanced Rs. 20/- to the deceased for purchasing the ticket and the purchase of ticket by the deceased. On behalf of the railway authorities, no counter or written statement was filed but examined R.W. 1 who is a Guard of the said train, Visakha Express, under which the deceased came under and was ran over. His evidence is that there was no accident at all. He must have been examined to prove that there was no such accident at all. But as the Tribunal gave a categorical finding as to the factum of accident, his evidence is not at all relevant for the present appeal. Coming to the evidence of R.W 2, who was the Assistant Station Master at the relevant point of time, his evidence shows that he was informed by some people that a man had fallen down accidentally from the train and was lying injured on the platform. According to this witness, he went to the spot and came back to his office to make arrangement for sending the injured to the Government Hospital. His further version was a part of the crowd told him that they had arranged a rickshaw and would undertake to carry the injured to the hospital and they only wanted a memo from R.W. 2 addressing the hospital authorities for forwarding the injured. According to this witness, the crowd told him that injured was having a season ticket and when he wanted to see the said season ticket, the crowd had pressurised him to issue memo informing that the injured was having professed bleeding. Therefore, this witness has issued a memo incorporating the said fact. In the cross-examination, however, his version was recorded as
"He denies the suggestion that he mentioned about the season ticket on the ground of pressuring him to do so". He has even deposed in the cross-examination that he could not recollect any particular face in the crowd and cannot identify any one. The witness has also admitted that there was no rowdy behaviour of the mob immediately after the accident.
13. The Tribunal based on the above version of R.W. 2, rejected the claim of the claimant on the ground that the claimant failed to prove that the deceased was a passenger as defined in the Act. The conclusion arrived at by the Tribunal is not proper and just even going by the evidence. P.W. 2 categorically stated that he advanced Rs. 20/- to the deceased as he could not purchase ticket with his own money as he was having Rs. 100/- note for which there was no change at the booking counter. When his version was not even doubted by giving any suggestions in the cross-examination, there is absolutely no justification in not accepting his version. In fact, the evidence of R.W. 2 is in a way of shaky. He was not very clear, who has pressurised him to note that the deceased was having a season ticket. According to his own version, when he was informed by the mob, he went to the spot and came to his office for preparing a memo. Therefore, under the above circumstances, the Tribunal is not justified in giving much importance to the evidence of R.W. 2 rather than the evidence of RW. 2. The Tribunal showed the reason for not accepting the evidence of P.W. 2 that though he was along with the deceased when he was lying injured, he did not inform R.W. 2 that he had purchased a ticket and he was not having a season ticket. R.W. 2 did not state that P.W. 2 was aware of the preparation of the memo and whether he was present in the crowd, who pressurised him to issue the memo stating that the deceased was having the season ticket. In the light of the above evidence as well as in the light of the decisions cited earlier, the conclusion arrived at by the Tribunal is not just and proper and accordingly the said findings are liable to be set aside. Therefore, the impugned order is set aside and the claimant is, therefore, entitled for compensation as claimed in accordance with Part-I of Schedule to the Railway Accidents (Compensation) Rules, 1990.
14. In the result, the appeal is allowed. No. costs.
Alert