Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Management Of Ramakr... v. State Authority Unde...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Feb 14, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Provided Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

Two writ petitions (WP No. 29009 of 1995 and WP No. 2873 of 2000) were filed by the petitioner (a manufacturer of homoeopathic medicines employing about 36 persons at a factory in Katedan Industrial Area, Ranga Reddy District) challenging orders of the first respondent authority in Minimum Wages (MW) cases. The first challenged order (MW No. 13 of 1995 dated 30-11-1995) directed deposit of Rs. 1,71,844-50 paise towards the alleged difference in minimum wages under G.O. Ms. No. 1833 dated 26-12-1992. The second challenged order (MW No. 1 of 1997 dated 29-12-1999) directed deposit of Rs. 12,37,709/- comprising Rs. 6,18,854.50 paise as difference of minimum wages and an equal amount as compensation.

The second respondent (a union representing employees) filed the MW cases under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act. The petitioner management opposed the claims contending (inter alia) that it did not fall under scheduled employment and/or that G.O. Ms. No. 1833 was not applicable; additionally, the management relied on a statutory settlement with the union under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act and on the contention that total emoluments paid exceeded the minimum prescribed by the GO.

The first respondent authority ultimately allowed the claims in both MW cases, treating the GO as applicable and directing deposits including compensation. The petitioner challenged those orders by filing the above writ petitions.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, where the recognised union raised a charter of demands and a statutory settlement under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act was reached, the employees can nevertheless claim the difference of minimum wages on the ground that the basic wage component fixed under the Government notification (G.O. Ms. No. 1833) was not paid.
  2. Whether, for the purpose of determining compliance with a minimum wage notification under the Minimum Wages Act, the total emoluments actually paid (including allowances such as special allowance, conveyance allowance, house rent allowance and dearness allowance) must be taken into account, or whether the basic wage component must be separately compared without including such allowances.
  3. Whether conveyance allowance can be treated as distinct from travelling allowance and whether any particular allowances are excluded from the concept of "wages" under Section 2(h) of the Minimum Wages Act when assessing compliance with a minimum wage notification.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner (management) — Principal Contentions

  • The petitioner is a manufacturer of homoeopathic medicines and does not fall under the category of scheduled employment notified under Section 27 of the Minimum Wages Act; therefore G.O. Ms. No. 1833 is not applicable to it (petitioner's initial contention).
  • The petitioner and the union had entered into a statutory settlement under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act after the union raised a charter of demands; that settlement is binding and the employees cannot now contend that the minimum wages paid are less than the GO-prescribed minimum.
  • The total emoluments being paid to employees (including special allowance, conveyance allowance, HRA and DA) exceed the minimum wages prescribed by the GO; therefore there has been no contravention. The petitioner relied on the definitions in Section 2(h) and on Section 4 of the Minimum Wages Act to submit that minimum wage may be composite and include such allowances.
  • Conveyance allowance is different from travelling allowance (the latter is for outstation journeys whereas conveyance is to reach the factory); therefore the authority erred in treating/conflating them.
  • Counsel relied on a judgment of the Bombay High Court (HJDG Hindu Sabha Hospital v. M.G. Kamgar Union) and other precedents to support the proposition that the total pay packet is the relevant criterion.

Second Respondent (union / employees) — Principal Contentions

  • The basic wage as fixed by the Government in the GO has not been paid and therefore the authority correctly allowed the claim for the difference and compensation.
  • Conveyance allowance is not different from travelling allowance for the purposes of exclusion under Section 2(h); the definition excludes travelling allowance and therefore such amounts should not be taken into account.
  • The Minimum Wages Act is a beneficial legislation and the authority's interpretation in favour of employees was appropriate.

Learned Government Pleader for Labour — Principal Contentions

  • Travelling allowance and conveyance allowance are identical in effect and the authority correctly implemented the minimum wages fixed by the Government after due process (notification and inviting objections).
  • The basic pay prescribed in the GO has not been paid; in absence of any specific order by the appropriate Government authorising inclusion of conveyance and other special allowances, the employer is not justified in including them while claiming compliance with the GO.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
HJDG Hindu Sabha Hospital v. M.G. Kamgar Union, 2000 (1) LLJ 163 (Bom) The opinion reproduces and relies on the Bombay High Court's articulation that Section 4(1) of the Minimum Wages Act allows the minimum rate to consist of component parts and that, if the employer has paid total wages more than the minimum rate (taken as a package), there is no contravention of the Act. The court adopted the principle that total wages (inclusive of component allowances) are the relevant criterion and used this precedent to support the conclusion that payment of total emoluments exceeding the notified minimum precludes a finding of contravention.
Airfreight India Limited v. State of Karnataka (Apex Court) The opinion cites the Apex Court's holdings (as reproduced) that: (a) Notification under the Act applies widely and payment of more than prescribed minimum is not relevant to applicability; (b) Amounts excluded under Section 2(h) must be excluded when determining whether minimum rates are paid; (c) Minimum rate of wages is a single package and dearness allowance linked to cost of living is part of the package. The court relied on these principles to explain that the total pay packet must be considered and that excluded items under Section 2(h) should not be counted toward the minimum; the opinion uses this authority to support treating the pay package as the determinative measure.
Municipal Borough v. Gundawan, 1965 (II) LLJ 26 (Karnataka High Court) This opinion mentions the case as one of several authorities considered in the Bombay High Court decision cited above. The provided text does not set out a specific rule or principle from this case. The opinion does not specify how this case was applied independently in the present reasoning; it was referenced as part of the body of authority noted in HJDG Hindu Sabha Hospital.
Imperial Tobacco Company v. State (Patna High Court) This opinion mentions the case as one of several authorities considered in the Bombay High Court decision cited above. The provided text does not set out a specific rule or principle from this case. The opinion does not specify a distinct application of this case to the present facts beyond its citation within the authorities relied upon by the petitioner.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court framed the central controversy narrowly as whether the total wages paid must be considered for compliance with the minimum wages notification and whether employees can claim a difference after having entered into a statutory settlement under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act.

The court reviewed the statutory definitions and provisions cited by the parties, including: (a) the definition of "wages" under Section 2(h) of the Minimum Wages Act (as reproduced in the opinion), which excludes specified items such as travelling allowance from the concept of wages; and (b) Section 4(1) of the Minimum Wages Act, which contemplates that a minimum rate may consist of component parts (e.g., basic rate, cost of living allowance, all-inclusive rate).

The court then examined the settlements entered between the petitioner and the union under Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act, noting that such a settlement is statutory in nature and binding on both parties. The petitioner had raised a charter of demands and, having reached a settlement with the union through conciliation, the court held that the union (second respondent) could not later contend that the basic pay component alone was less than the GO-prescribed minimum while ignoring other components of pay agreed in the settlement.

The court relied on the principle (as articulated in the cited precedents, particularly the Bombay High Court decision reproduced in the opinion and the Apex Court's decision in Airfreight) that the minimum wage must be considered as a package and that, where the employer has paid total wages in excess of the minimum rate (after excluding amounts expressly excluded by Section 2(h)), there is no contravention. The court found that the first respondent authority had not objectively examined whether the total emoluments payable to the employees exceeded the notified minimum and that the authority erred in separating out the basic wage component while disregarding the settled total pay.

On the factual application of these legal principles, the court observed that, on the record, the employees were receiving wages that were more than the amount fixed by the GO (when the total pay packet was considered). Consequently, the authority's determination of difference and imposition of compensation was unsustainable.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: The court quashed the impugned orders in both writ petitions (i.e., the orders in MW No. 13 of 1995 and MW No. 1 of 1997) and allowed the writ petitions. The court ordered that there be no costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The directions issued by the first respondent authority to deposit the sums ordered in the MW cases are set aside; the employer's statutory settlement and the total pay packet received by employees were held sufficient to preclude the claim for difference in minimum wages.
  • The opinion applies and reiterates existing principles from higher courts concerning the composite nature of minimum wages (treating the minimum as a package and considering allowances that form part of the pay packet), but it does not purport to announce a new legal precedent beyond applying those authorities to the facts. The opinion records that no costs were awarded.

Note: All content in this summary is drawn exclusively from the provided opinion text. No information has been added beyond what was present in that text.

Show all summary ...

1. WPNo. 29009 of 1995 is filed seeking a writ of certiorari to quash the order of the first respondent in MW No. 13 of 1995 dated 30-11-1995 directing the petitioner to deposit Rs. 1,71,844-50 ps. towards the difference in minimum wages payable under G.O. Ms. No. 1833 dated 26-12-1992 and the actual wages being paid by the petitioner management. WP No. 2873 of 2000 is filed by the same petitioner to quash the order in MW No. l of 1997 dated 29-12-1999 directing them to deposit Rs. 12,37,709/- which includes the alleged difference of minimum wages of Rs. 6,18,854.50 ps. and equal amount of compensation.

2. The facts in brief are that the second respondent-employees in the petitioner company filed MW Case Nos. 1 of 1997 and 13 of 1995 claiming Rs. 9,56,785/- and Rs. 1,71,844-50 ps. respectively towards payment of difference of wages due to the workmen and the compensation thereof.

3. The petitioner is engaged in the manufacture of Homoeo medicines at its factory in Katedan Industrial Area, Ranga Reddy District. The petitioner employs about 36 persons in its manufacturing activity. The service conditions of the employees of the petitioner are governed by various settlements entered into between the petitioner and the second respondent union under Section 12(3) of Industrial Disputes Act and the employees are paid accordingly.

4. The second respondent in both the writ petitions filed Minimum Wages Cases under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act and subsequently, the petitioner filed writ petition in WP No. 19945 of 1993 seeking a direction to the respondent authority not to proceed with the MW Case No. 13 of 1995. The said writ petition was disposed of directing the respondent authority to adjudicate the legal issue along with the merits of the case.

5. The petitioner management contested MW Case No. 13 of 1995 stating that the petitioner being a manufacturer of Homoeo medicines will not come under the category of scheduled employment and has not been notified as such under Section 27 of the Act and that G.O. Ms. No. 1833 dated 26-12-1992 is not applicable to the petitioner. The respondent authority allowed the claim in MW Case No. 13 of 1995 and also awarded compensation of Rs. 1,75,294/-, which is the same as the difference of wages claimed by 2nd respondent. Further, the authority has imposed compensation at the rate of 100% on the petitioner.

6. The second respondent in WP No. 2873 of 2000 also filed MW Case No. 1 of 1997 under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act claiming wages as per G.O. Ms. No. 1833 dated 26-12-1992. The respondent authority allowed the claim and directed the petitioner to deposit Rs. 6,18,854-50 ps. towards difference of minimum wages plus one time compensation of Rs. 6,18,854-50 ps. for non-payment of minimum wages. Thus the petitioner was directed to deposit Rs. 12,37,709/-.

7. The first respondent authority having adverted to the evidence adduced on behalf of the management held that in view of the manufacturing activity being undertaken by the petitioner and the nature of finished products, the said GO is applicable and ordered the difference in wages since the management is not paying basic wages as contemplated in the said GO. There is no dispute with regard to applicability of the GO, but GO contemplates payment of minimum wages in respect of each category and the said minimum basic pay has not been paid. The petitioner management had advanced a contention that the total emoluments being paid to the employees is higher than the minimum prescribed and the management had been paying other allowances namely special allowance, conveyance allowance, HRA and DA. Thus, the wages being paid are higher than the minimum wages prescribed in the said GO.

8. Learned Counsel of the petitioner management contended that the first respondent authority did not consider the scope of Section 12(3) of the Industrial Disputes Act and the settlement between the petitioner management and the union, who is a signatory to the settlement, which is a statutory one and inspite of the same, the workmen filed a claim petition under Section 20 of the Minimum Wages Act. Considering the charter of demands raised by the union, the management entered into a settlement and the total wages being received by the employees are more than the minimum wages.

9. Learned Counsel for the petitioner management submits that the petitioner does not come under Scheduled Employment and even assuming that GO is applicable, the petitioner management is paying more than the wages prescribed in the said GO. Learned Counsel has drawn my attention to the definition of 'wages' as per Section 2(h), which reads:

"wages" means all remuneration, capable of being expressed in terms of money, which would if the terms of the contract of employment, express or implied, were fulfilled be payable to a person employed in respect of his employment or of work done in such employment and includes house rent allowance but does not include--

(i) the value of--

(a) any house accommodation, supply of light, water, medical attendance; or

(b) any other amenity or any service excluded by general or special order of the appropriate Government.

(ii) any contribution paid by the employer to any Pension fund or Provident fund under any scheme of social insurance;

(iii) any travelling allowance or the value of any travelling concession.

(iv) any sum paid to the person employed to defray special expenses entitled to him by the nature of his employment; or

(v) any gratuity payable on discharge."

Section 4 of the Minimum Wages Act reads as under:

"(1) Any minimum rate of wages fixed or revised by the appropriate Government in respect of scheduled employment under Section 3 may consist of --

(i) a basic rate of wages and a special allowance at a rate to be adjusted at such interval and in such manner appropriate Government may direct to accord as nearly as practicable with the variation in the cost of living index number applicable to such workers (hereinafter referred to as the cost of living allowance); or

(ii) a basic rate of wages with or without the cost of living allowance and the cash value of the concession in respect of supplies of essential commodities at concession rates where so authorised; or

(iii) an all-inclusive rate allowing for the basic rates the cost of living allowance and the cash value of the concession, if any."

10. The petitioner and second respondent union representing the employees entered into a settlement and the employees cannot contend that the minimum wages paid is less than the one fixed under GO. Accordingly, under Section 12(3) of the Act, an agreement is statutory in nature and binding on the petitioner and having raised the charter of demands and agreed to the settlement with the aid of conciliation, the second respondent cannot contend that the basic pay excludes other allowances namely special allowance, conveyance allowance and HRA. Learned Counsel for the petitioner has also drawn by attention to Section 4 of the Minimum Wages Act to the effect that minimum wages fixed for scheduled employment is inclusive of special allowances. It is further contended that the Travelling Allowance and Conveyance Allowance are different and distinct and the Travelling Allowance is given to an employee for the outstation journey whereas Conveyance Allowance is paid to the employees to enable them to reach the factory and the authority was not justified in granting claimed amount. The total pay, which the employees are being paid, are more than the minimum wages fixed by the Government. Learned Counsel has drawn my attention to the judgment of the Bombay High Court in HJDG Hindu Sabha Hospital v. M.G. Kamgar Union, 2000 (1) LLJ 163 (Bom.), wherein an identical controversy as in the present case was decided in favour of the management considering the judgments of the Apex Court in Airfreight India Limited v. State of Karnataka, , and Karnataka High Court in Municipal Borough v. Gundawan, 1965 (II) LLJ 26, and Patna High Court in Imperial Tobacco Company v. State, and held as under:

It is thus clearly seen that Section 4(1) of the Act provides for the minimum rate which could consist of component parts. Section 4(1) does not postulate different minimum for the several components; nor can each such minimum constitute the minimum rate of wages within the meaning of Section 4(1). If the employer has paid the total wages more than the minimum rate of wages within the meaning of Section 4(1), there cannot be any contravention of the provisions of the Act. In the instant case, the minimum wages comprises of two component parts, namely, basic wages and dearness allowance. It is not disputed that the employee in the present case has been paid the wages under both the component parts and the total amount paid to the employee is higher than the minimum wages prescribed under the notification. Under the circumstances, it cannot be said that the employer has contravened the provisions of the Minimum Wages Act.

11. The Apex Court in Airfreight v. State of Karnataka (supra) held as under:

"The Notification issued under the Act prescribing minimum wages applies to all kinds of shops and commercial establishments big or small and that payment of more than prescribed minimum rates of wages is not relevant for deciding its applicability. It cannot be stated that as they are paying more than the prescribed minimum wages the Act or the Notification would not be applicable. For determining whether they are paying minimum rates of wages or not, the amount paid for the value of items which are excluded under Section 2(h) of the Act is not to be taken into consideration.

Minimum rate of wages fixed under the Act is remuneration payable to the worker as one package of fixed amount. In cases where minimum wage is linked with the cost of living index, the amount paid on the basis of dearness allowance is not to be taken as an independent component of the minimum wages but as part and parcel of the process of computing the rates of minimum wages which is to be determined after taking into consideration the cost of various necessities."

12. Learned Counsel for the second respondent contended that the basic wage as fixed by the Government has not been paid and the authority has rightly allowed the claim and there is no difference between the conveyance allowance and travelling allowance and they are identical to each other. The definition specifically excludes the travelling allowance and hence the same has to be deleted. The Act is a beneficial legislation and the authority has interpreted in favour of the employees.

13. Learned Government Pleader for Labour contended that Travelling Allowance and Conveyance Allowance are identical and the authority rightly implemented the minimum wages fixed by the Government after issuing notification and inviting objections and the minimum wages fixed vide, the said GO as also the basic pay have not been paid. Further, in the absence of any specific order of the appropriate Government, the employer is not justified in including the conveyance and other special allowances.

14. The controversy lie in narrow compass namely whether the total wages paid to the employees by the employer have to be taken into consideration and when once the recognised union has put up a charier of demands and subsequently entered into settlement in the course of conciliation and when once the aggrieved parties had entered into a settlement, whether it is open to the employees to claim difference of wages on the ground that the basic wage is not a as fixed vide said GO and whether the special allowances have to be included or not. Section 4 of the Minimum Wages Act clearly postulates the inclusion of special allowances which the employer is paying to the employees and in an identical case in HJDG Hindu Sabha Hospital v. M.G. Kamgar Union (supra) where the employer was paying less than the basic wage prescribed by the Government, the Bombay High Court upheld that the total pay is the criteria. Section 4 includes special allowances and also variable dearness allowance paid to the employees in case of inflationary trends in the markets to meet the exigencies.

15. Considering the law laid down by the Apex Court, I am of the view that the petitioner and the second respondent having entered into a statutory settlement after raising a charter of demand and having agitated the matter before the Conciliation Officer, the settlement is binding on the petitioner and the second respondent and the first respondent authority has not examined the matter objectively. The Apex Court clearly laid down that the total pay packet has to be taken into consideration for fixing the minimum wages as revised from time to time. In the instant case, the employees are receiving the more wages than the one fixed by the GO. Further, it is not open to the second respondent to separate only one component namely minimum wage and contend that the basic wages paid arc less than the wages prescribed under GO.

16. In view of the above circumstances, the impugned orders in both the writ petitions are quashed and the writ petitions are accordingly allowed. No costs.