Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Ms. Ismath Ahmedizade Mahmoodi Abidi v. Mrs. Kurshidunnisa Begum .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Sep 13, 2002
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This Civil Revision Petition challenges the order dated 17 February 2000 in I.A. No. 90 of 2000 in O.S. No. 1007 of 1993, passed by the II Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. The Revision Petitioner is the defendant in the suit and the petitioner in I.A. No. 90 of 2000; the Respondent is the plaintiff.

O.S. No. 1007 of 1993 was instituted by the plaintiff seeking recovery of possession of the suit premises. The plaintiff alleged she was the absolute owner and had previously let the premises to the defendant's father under an oral agreement; after the father's death the defendant continued as tenant and ran a hotel business called "Tehran Cafe". The plaintiff alleged non-payment of agreed rent and filed the suit.

After the plaintiff closed evidence and before the defendant's evidence commenced, the General Power of Attorney (GPA) holder for the defendant filed I.A. No. 90 of 2000 under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice seeking permission to act, appear and depose on behalf of the defendant. The GPA holder (Smt. Naima Ismaili) filed an affidavit asserting management of the defendant's business and affairs, including rent payments.

The plaintiff opposed the application, contending that the GPA holder was not an Indian citizen and that, under provisions of the Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (FERA), a foreigner cannot carry on business in India without Reserve Bank of India (RBI) permission; therefore the GPA holder had no locus standi to present or conduct the defence. The trial court dismissed I.A. No. 90/2000 on 17.2.2000, holding that neither the defendant nor the GPA holder had produced RBI permission and therefore the suit could not be defended through the GPA holder. The defendant filed the present revision petition against that order.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the order under revision suffers from any illegality or material irregularity in the exercise of jurisdiction under Section 115 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, warranting interference.
  2. Whether the Court below erred in dismissing I.A. No. 90 of 2000 solely on the ground that neither the defendant nor the General Power of Attorney holder produced permission from the Reserve Bank of India under provisions of FERA.
  3. Whether the General Power of Attorney holder could be permitted under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice (and Order 3 Rule 2 C.P.C.) to act, appear and depose on behalf of the defendant.
  4. Whether it was appropriate at the interlocutory stage of I.A. No. 90 of 2000 for the trial court to decide the question of RBI permission/FERA compliance, or whether such questions are premature and amount to deciding merits of the main suit.

Arguments of the Parties

Revision Petitioner (Defendant) — Arguments

  • Learned counsel for the petitioner argued that the Court below ought to have permitted the GPA holder to act, appear and depose on behalf of the defendant under Rule 32.
  • It was contended that at that stage the Court below ought not to have gone into the issue of alleged RBI permission required under FERA and that deciding that question then effectively amounted to granting a decree in favour of the plaintiff.
  • The petitioner submitted that the impugned order was erroneous and unsustainable.

Respondent (Plaintiff) — Arguments

  • The respondent's counsel submitted that under Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice granting permission to a GPA holder to represent a party is within the court's discretion and must be exercised in light of the facts and circumstances.
  • The respondent contended the Court below rightly refused permission because the defendant failed to produce the necessary RBI permission under FERA.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
K. Bharathi v. Labour Officer, (1) 1999 (3) ALT 428 Holds that the word "acts" in Rule 2, Order 3 C.P.C. does not include the act of a Power of Attorney (POA) holder appearing as a witness on behalf of a party; a POA holder may testify in his/her personal capacity about facts within personal knowledge but cannot appear as a witness "on behalf" of the party in the capacity of the POA holder. The Court adopted and agreed with this view, using it to limit the competence of a GPA holder: a GPA holder cannot represent the party and depose on his/her behalf, although the GPA holder may be examined in a personal capacity regarding facts within personal knowledge.
Salar Jung Museum v. Atiya Talat, (2) 2000 (5) ALT 557 Considered whether a husband (GPA holder) could be examined on behalf of the plaintiff; one judgment (Vaman Rao, J.) indicated there could be no objection to permitting the husband to be examined as a witness on her behalf, but observed Rules 1 and 2 of Order 3 C.P.C. do not govern examination of witnesses; the issue is to be determined by reference to the Power of Attorney Act, 1882 and Chapter X of the Indian Contract Act on agency. The Court noted that even in Salar Jung the conclusion was that a POA holder can appear as a witness in his/her personal capacity but not in the capacity of representing the party; the decision was treated as supportive of the K. Bharathi position to that extent.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The revisional court first examined the record and the impugned order. The trial court had dismissed I.A. No. 90/2000 on the basis that neither the defendant nor the GPA holder had obtained permission from the Reserve Bank of India to hold leasehold rights or do business in India, and that both were foreign nationals; consequently, the suit could not be defended through the GPA holder.

The revisional court reviewed the relevant procedural provisions: Rule 32 of the Civil Rules of Practice (which requires filing of the power of attorney or written authority and permits the judge to record permission for an agent to appear), and Order 3 Rule 2 C.P.C. (which recognises agents holding powers-of-attorney and persons carrying on trade or business for parties). The court reproduced and relied on the text of these provisions to frame the limits and formalities for agents appearing in court.

The court then considered precedent on the scope of a POA/GPA holder's competence to act and to testify. Citing K. Bharathi v. Labour Officer, the court accepted the proposition that the word "acts" in Order 3 Rule 2 does not extend to allowing a POA holder to appear as a witness "on behalf" of a party; instead, a POA holder may give evidence only in his or her personal capacity about facts within personal knowledge. The court observed that Salar Jung Museum v. Atiya Talat, while noting some divergence, in substance supported the same practical limitation: POA holders may be witnesses in their personal capacity though not as a party's representative in that capacity.

Applying these legal principles, the revisional court held that it is open to the trial court to examine whether the filed power of attorney complied with Order 3 C.P.C. and Rule 32 of the Civil Rules and to pass appropriate orders. However, the revisional court found it was impermissible for the trial court to refuse permission to the GPA holder solely because of non-compliance with the RBI permission requirement under FERA at that interlocutory stage. The revisional court characterized such a refusal as premature and as amounting to a conclusion on the merits of the main suit.

Concluding that the trial court had committed a material irregularity by dismissing I.A. No. 90/2000 only on the ground of non-production of RBI permission, the revisional court set aside the order and remitted the matter for fresh consideration. The revisional court expressly allowed the trial court, when considering the matter afresh, to take into account the effect of Section 32 and other provisions of FERA in the context of the main suit after affording both parties opportunity to lead necessary evidence.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The revision petition is allowed; the order under revision dated 17.2.2000 in I.A. No. 90 of 2000 is set aside and the matter is remitted to the Court below for fresh consideration.

Direct effects and directions:

  • The trial court is directed to consider I.A. No. 90 of 2000 afresh and to pass appropriate orders within four weeks from receipt of the revisional order.
  • It is open to the trial court to take into consideration the effect of Section 32 and other provisions of FERA when deciding the issues in the main suit, but such consideration should be made after affording due opportunity to both parties to adduce necessary evidence; refusal solely on the ground of non-production of RBI permission at the interlocutory stage was held to be premature and improper.
  • There shall be no order as to costs (the revisional court explicitly ordered no costs).

Broader implications:

The opinion does not set out broader new legal principles beyond applying existing procedural provisions and cited precedents; its immediate effect is to require the trial court to re-examine the application for permission under Rule 32 in accordance with Order 3 Rule 2 C.P.C., relevant precedents and FERA provisions, with opportunities for evidence and argument. There is no express statement in the opinion purporting to establish a novel binding precedent beyond these directives.

Show all summary ...

1. This Civil Revision Petition is directed against the order dated 17th February 2000 in I.A No. 90 of 2000 in O.S No. 1007 of 1993 on the file of the Court of II Senior Civil Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad. Revision Petitioner, who is the defendant, is the petitioner in I.A No. 90 of 2000. Respondent is the plaintiff in the suit. For the sake of convenience, the parties shall be referred to as they were arrayed in the suit.

2. O.S No. 1007 of 1993 was filed seeking a decree against the defendant for recovery of possession of the suit schedule premises. According to the plaintiff, she is the absolute owner of the suit schedule premises, which has been let out to the father of the defendant under an oral agreement. After the death of her father, defendant continued as a tenant and has been carrying on hotel business under the name and style of Tehran Cafe. Since the defendant failed to pay the agreed rent in spite of the repeated requests, plaintiff has been constrained to file O.S No. 1007 of 1993 seeking recovery of possession. After the evidence on the side of the plaintiff was closed and while the suit was coming up for the evidence of defendant, the General Power of Attorney holder of the Defendant filed I.A No. 90 of 2000 under Rule 32 of the civil Rules of Practice seeking permission to act, appear and depose on behalf of the defendant. In the affidavit filed in support of the said petition, one Smt. Naima Ismaili W/o. Syed Ali Asgar Ismaili stated that she is the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant and in terms of the General Power of Attorney executed in her favour, she has been managing the business of the defendant and managing all the affairs including payment of rents to the plaintiff, and, therefore, she may be permitted to depose on behalf of the defendant. The said application has been opposed by the plaintiff. She filed a counter contending that the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant is not a citizen of India and that under the provisions of Foreign Exchange Regulation Act, 1973 (for short ‘FERA’) a foreigner cannot carry on business in India unless necessary permission is obtained from the Reserve Bank of India, and, therefore, the General Power of Attorney holder has no locus standi to present the case or to conduct the same on behalf of the defendant. The Court below by order dated 17.2.2000 dismissed the petition holding that since the defendant as well as her General Power of Attorney holder did not file any permission from the Reserve Bank of India to hold any property in India, the suit cannot be defended through the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant, who is a foreign national. Aggrieved by the said order, the defendant has come up with the present civil revision petition.

3. I have heard Sri Bajrang Singh Thakur, learned counsel appearing for the petitioner, who contended that in the facts and circumstances of the case, the Court below ought to have permitted the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant to act, appear and depose on behalf of the defendant. He also vehemently contended that at this stage it is not open to the Court below to go into the issue relating to the alleged permission under the provisions of the FERA; and that the order under revision virtually amounts to granting a decree in favour of the plaintiff. Accordingly he contended that the order under revision is Erroneous and cannot be sustained.

4. On the other hand, the learned counsel for the respondent submitted that under Rule 32 of the civil Rules of Practice granting permission to the General Power of Attorney holder to represent a party to the suit is the discretion of the Court, which has to be exercised on the basis of the facts and circumstances of the case, and that, in the present case, the Court below has rightly refused to grant permission since the defendant failed to produce necessary permission from the Reserve Bank of India.

5. Having regard to the rival contentions raised by the parties, the question that arises for consideration is whether the order under Revision suffers from any illegality or material irregularity in exercise of jurisdiction vested under law warranting interference under Sec. 115 of C.P.C

6. I have perused the order under revision and other material on record. As can be seen, the Court below dismissed the application in question on the ground that the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant has not obtained any permission from the Reserve Bank of India to hold any property on lease or to do any business in India. The Court below concluded that since the defendant and her General Power of Attorney Holder are foreign nationals, they cannot be permitted to do any business or to hold any leasehold rights in India without the permission of the Reserve Bank of India as prescribed under Sec. 31 of the FERA.

7. Rule 32 of the civil Rules of Practice, which provides for party appearing by Agent, runs as follows:

“(1) When a party appears by any agent, other than an advocate, the agent shall, before making of or doing any appearance, application, or act, in or to the court, file in court the power of attorney, or written authority thereunto authorising him or a properly authenticated copy thereof together with an affidavit that the said authority still subsisting, or, in the case of an agent carrying on a trade or business on behalf of a party, without a written authority, an affidavit stating the residence of his principal, the trade or business carried on by the agent on his behalf and the connection of the same with the subject-matter of the suit, and that no other agent is expressly authorised to make or do such appearance, application, or act.

(2) The Judge may thereupon record in writing that the agent is permitted to appear and act on behalf of the party; and unless and until the said permission is granted, no appearance, application, or act, of the agent shall be recognised by the Court”.

8. It is also relevant to refer to Order 3 Rule 2 of C.P.C, which provides for recognised agents.

“The recognised agents of parties by whom such appearances, applications and acts may be made or done are—

(a) persons holding powers-of-attorney, authorizing them to make and do such appearances, applications and acts on behalf of such parties;

(b) persons carrying on trade or business for and in the names of parties not resident within the local limits of the jurisdiction of the Court within which limits the appearance, application or act is made or done, in matters connected with such trade or business only, where no other agent is expressly authorized to make and do such appearances, applications and acts”.

9. A plain reading of the above provisions shows that the persons, holding powers-of-attorney authorising them to make and to do such appearances, applications and acts on behalf of the parties, are recognized as agents and they are competent to appear and act on behalf of such parties. The question, whether the word “acts” used in Rule 2 of Order 3 of C.P.C includes the act of power of attorney holder to appear as a witness on behalf of the party, has been considered by this Court in K. Bharathi v. Labour Officer (1) 1999 (3) ALT 428, in which it is held as follows:

“…..word ‘acts’ used in Rule 2, Order 3 C.P.C does not include the act of Power of Attorney Holder to appear as a witness on behalf of the petitioners. Power of Attorney Holder of a party can appear only as a witness in his personal capacity to speak about the facts which are within his personal knowledge about the case, but, he cannot appear as a witness on behalf of a party in the capacity of that party”.

10. However, learned court for the respondent, while relying upon a decision in Salar Jung Museum v. Atiya Talat (2) 2000 (5) ALT 557, contended that Vaman Rao, J. in the said case, dissented from the view expressed in K. Bharathi's case (1 supra). In Salar Jung Museum's case (2 supra) the question that arose for consideration was whether the husband, who happened to be the General Power of Attorney holder of the plaintiff, could be examined on her behalf as a witness. Vaman Rao, J. followed the view expressed in Bharathi's case (1 supra) and held that there can be no objection in permitting the plaintiff to examine her husband as a witness on her behalf. However, the learned Judge expressed that Rules 1 and 2 of Order 3 of C.P.C have nothing to do with the examination of a witness by a party to the proceeding and, therefore, the question in issue has to be determined in the light of the provisions of the Power of Attorney Act, 1882 and the provisions in Chapter-X of Indian Contract Act relating to Agency. Thus, even in Salar Jung Museum's case (2 supra) it is accepted that a power of attorney holder can appear as a witness in his personal capacity though not on behalf of the party in the capacity of a power of attorney holder. Hence, to that extent, the said decision also lends support to the view expressed in K. Bharathi's case (1 supra). I respectfully agree with the view expressed in K. Bharathi's case (1 supra). The General Power of Attorney holder cannot be permitted to represent the party in the suit and to depose on his/her behalf, but it is always open to the General Power of Attorney holder to appear as a witness in his/her personal capacity to speak about the facts which are in his/her personal knowledge about the case.

11. In the instant case, the General Power of Attorney holder of the defendant seeks permission of the Court to act, appear and depose in the main suit on behalf of the defendant. The power of attorney, under which Smt. Naima Ismaili was appointed to act on behalf of the defendant, was filed into the Court. It is open to the Court to examine whether the same is in conformity with the provisions of Order 3 of C.P.C and Rule 32 of Civil Rules of Practice and to pass appropriate orders. However, refusing permission to the General Power of Attorney Holder to appear and act on behalf of the defendant only on the ground of non-compliance with the requirements of Sec. 32 of FERA is not permissible. I am of the view that it is premature to express any such opinion while considering the application in question. It would amount to arriving at a conclusion on the merits of the main suit.

12. For the reasons stated above, in my considered opinion, the Court below committed an error in dismissing I.A No. 90 of 2000 only on the ground that the defendant and her General Power of Attorney holder failed to produce the required permission from the Reserve Bank of India to hold any property to lease or to do any business in India. The order under revision, therefore, suffers from material irregularity in exercise of jurisdiction and cannot be sustained.

13. Accordingly the order under revision is set aside and the matter is remitted back to the Court below for consideration afresh and to pass appropriate orders in I.A No. 90 of 2000 in the light of the observations made above, within four weeks from the date of receipt of this order. It is made clear that it is open to the Court below to take into consideration the effect of Sec. 32 and other provisions of FERA while deciding the issues in question in the main suit after affording due opportunity to both the parties to adduce necessary evidence.

14. In the result, the revision petition is allowed.

15. There shall be no order as to costs.