- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Mohd. Hussain v. Apsrtc, Hyderabad And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
This appeal challenges the judgment dated 19 August 1998 of a learned single Judge in Writ Petition No. 3848 of 1998, which dismissed the writ petition filed by the appellant. The appellant held the post of Foreman (Mechanical) and the post served as a feeder post for promotion to Assistant Engineer (Mechanical). Vacancies for Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) arose in 1992, 1993, 1996 and 1997. The appellant alleged that despite his seniority his case for promotion was ignored because the post was treated as a "selection post," and he claimed entitlement to promotion (including a contention regarding promotion to the post of Depot Manager based on prior non-consideration). The respondent (the Corporation) contended before the single Judge that the Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) post was a "selection post." The single Judge accepted the respondent's contention and held that the post was a selection post. The appellant appealed that decision.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) is a "selection post" such that promotion to it must be by selection rather than by seniority as provided in the Recruitment/Service Regulations applicable to the Corporation.
- Whether a purported Corporation resolution (dated 1977) declaring the post a "selection post" could alter the specific method of recruitment/promotion laid down in the Recruitment Regulations and earlier amendments that prescribe promotion by seniority.
- Whether amendments to the Regulations (including the 1995 amendment) have retrospective effect so as to affect the appellant's entitlement to promotion for vacancies that arose prior to the amended Regulations coming into force.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The appellant (through Mr. Baig) urged that the method of recruitment/promotion for the post was prescribed by the Recruitment Regulations and the learned single Judge erred in disregarding those regulatory provisions.
- The appellant relied on a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, APSRTC, WA No.1435 of 1989 dated 11 June 1991, which held that the Corporation's power to declare a post as a "selection post" cannot nullify specific methods of recruitment laid down in the Regulations; that power is residual and applies only where no specific recruitment method is prescribed.
- The appellant contended that because his case had not been considered earlier, he was entitled to promotion (the petition also stated a claim relevant to promotion to Depot Manager as a consequence of earlier non-consideration).
Respondent's Arguments
- The respondent (through Mr. K. Harinath) maintained that Regulation 2(xv) of the Recruitment Regulations authorized the Corporation to declare a post a "selection post" by resolution, and that the Corporation did so in 1977 in relation to Assistant Engineer (Mechanical).
- The respondent argued that because such a resolution existed, the learned single Judge correctly held the post to be a "selection post."
- The respondent further argued that the method of promotion is not a "condition of service" and therefore, in their submission, it did not need to be prescribed by way of Regulations (i.e., they contended regulation-making procedure was not required for determining method of promotion).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, APSRTC, WA No.1435 of 1989 (Division Bench) dated 11-6-1991 | Holds that the Corporation's power under Regulation 2(xv) to declare a post a "selection post" cannot nullify specific provisions in the Regulations that lay down specific methods of recruitment; the residual power to declare applies only where no specific method is prescribed. | The appellant relied on this decision; the Court referenced it and used the principle to support the conclusion that a resolution cannot override specific recruitment provisions prescribing promotion by seniority. |
| Manik Ram v. Emperor, 1916 Patna 133 (FB) | Stated in the opinion as authority for the proposition that an interpretation clause is not a positive enactment. | The Court invoked this authority to observe that interpretation clauses do not constitute positive enactments and to support the application of the doctrine Generalia Specialibus Non Derogant in the context of conflicting regulatory provisions. |
| A.A. Calton v. Director of Education | Cited as authority for the proposition that an amendment to subordinate legislation has prospective effect and cannot affect vested rights; a subsequent amendment does not affect appointments if vested rights would be impaired. | The Court relied on this authority (along with others cited) to hold that amendments to the Regulations operate prospectively and cannot be applied to defeat vested rights of candidates with respect to past vacancies. |
| Y. V. Rangaiah v. Sreenivas Rao | Cited for the principle that amendments to regulations are prospective and cannot affect vested rights acquired under earlier rules. | The Court cited this decision as part of the authority for the conclusion that the 1995 amendment could not retrospectively alter the mode of promotion for vacancies arising prior to its effective date. |
| P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka | Used to illustrate that subsequent amendments to regulations do not affect previously accrued or vested rights. | The Court relied on this precedent, together with others, to conclude that the appellant's entitlement (if any) to promotion must be measured by the Regulations in force at the time the vacancies arose, not by later amendments. |
| Bengal Immunity Co. v. State of Bihar | Quoted at length for the rule in Heydon's Case: established four-part test of statutory construction and the principle that interpretation must suppress the mischief and advance the remedy (Heydon's case rule). | The Court applied the Heydon's-case rule (as expounded in Bengal Immunity) to interpret regulatory amendments and to conclude that the rule-making authority intended to correct the mischief — supporting the conclusion that prior to the 1995 amendment the post was not a selection post and the amendment served to correct that position prospectively. |
| Heydon's Case (as cited in Bengal Immunity) | Provides the classical rule of interpretation (identify the common law before the act, the mischief, the remedy appointed, and the true reason for the remedy; interpretation should suppress mischief and advance remedy). | The Court invoked this principle (via Bengal Immunity) to interpret the intention behind the 1995 amendment and to reason about the remedial purpose of the amendment rather than to give it retrospective effect. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded through a structured analysis grounded on the statutory framework, the Regulations, the Corporation's resolutions, and authoritative case law cited in the opinion.
-
Statutory and regulatory framework:
- The Court noted Section 45 of the Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950, which empowers the Corporation, with State Government sanction, to make Regulations for administration, including conditions of appointment and service (sub-section (2)(c)).
- The Andhra Pradesh Road Transport Corporation Employees (Service) Regulations, 1964 and the Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation Employees (Recruitment) Regulations, 1966 were produced and their relevant provisions were examined (including Regulation 4 on promotion and Regulation 2(xiv)/(xv) defining 'selection' and 'selection post').
-
Effect of Corporation resolutions and amendments:
- The Court observed that Regulation 2(xv) appears to permit the Corporation to declare a post a "selection post" by resolution. A 1977 resolution purporting to declare certain promotional posts as "by selection" was placed before the Court.
- However, the Court noted that specific methods of recruitment for Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) had been prescribed in the Regulations themselves (with details showing promotion by seniority/ratio provision for promotion from Foreman etc.).
- The Court observed that the Regulations — including their annexed method-of-recruitment provisions — had been amended subsequently (resolution/amendments in 1983 notified in 1984 with Government approval), and again in 1995 by an amendment effective 19-9-1995 which changed the stated method of recruitment for the Assistant Mechanical Engineer/Assistant Works Manager post.
-
Legal principles limiting the effect of a resolution:
- The Court relied on the Division Bench decision in the APSRTC matter (WA No.1435 of 1989) which held that a Corporation's power to declare a post a "selection post" cannot nullify specific recruitment methods laid down in the Regulations; that residual power applies only where the Regulations are silent.
- The Court applied the doctrine Generalia Specialibus Non Derogant (general provisions do not derogate from special provisions) and observed that an interpretation clause is not a positive enactment (citing Manik Ram v. Emperor), supporting the conclusion that a purported resolution cannot override specific recruitment provisions already forming part of the Regulations.
-
Prospective effect of amendments and protection of vested rights:
- The Court analyzed the nature of the Regulations as subordinate legislation and stated that amendments to such Regulations operate prospectively. It relied on authority to the effect that a subsequent amendment cannot affect vested rights previously accrued (citing A.A. Calton v. Director of Education; Y. V. Rangaiah v. Sreenivas Rao; P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka).
- Applying these authorities, the Court concluded that prior to the 1995 amendment, the mode of selection for the Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) post — relevant to vacancies arising in 1992, 1993, 1996 and 1997 — had to be determined by the Regulations in force at the relevant times, which provided for promotion by seniority (not by selection).
-
Application of interpretative rule (Heydon's case):
- The Court invoked the rule in Heydon's case as expounded in Bengal Immunity Co. v. State of Bihar to interpret the intention behind the regulatory amendment in 1995 and to conclude that the amendment was remedial and prospective in character, intended to correct a prior situation rather than to deprive persons of previously accrued rights.
-
Conclusion of analysis:
- On this combined basis — the primacy of specific recruitment provisions in the Regulations, the limited scope of the Corporation's power to declare posts as selection posts where specific methods exist, the prospective operation of regulatory amendments, and protection of vested rights — the Court found that the learned single Judge's conclusion (that the post was a selection post as a result of the 1977 resolution) was incorrect.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The impugned judgment of the learned single Judge is set aside.
Directions and immediate consequences for the parties:
- The respondents are directed to consider afresh the matter relating to promotion of the writ petitioner-appellant to the post of Assistant Mechanical Engineer, taking into account his seniority in the post of Foreman (Mechanical).
- Such consideration must be made on the basis of eligibility at the relevant time and the promotion consideration shall be reckoned from the date when the relevant post fell vacant in 1992.
- If, as a consequence of grant of promotion in terms of this judgment, the petitioner-appellant is found entitled to any further promotion, the respondents are directed to consider those further promotions as well.
- The appeal and the writ petition are disposed of subject to these directions; no order as to costs was made in the facts and circumstances of the case.
Broader implications: The Court's decision applies the established principles that specific recruitment provisions in Regulations prevail over a general power to declare posts as "selection posts"; that subordinate legislation amendments operate prospectively; and that vested rights are protected against retrospective regulatory changes. The opinion focuses on the parties' rights and the appropriate application of existing regulatory and judicial authorities rather than announcing a novel legal doctrine.
1. This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 19th August, 1998 passed by a learned single Judge of this Court in WP No.3848 of 1998, whereby and whereunder the writ petition filed by the appellant herein was dismissed.
2. Bereft of all unnecessary details, the fact of the matter is as follows:
The appellant, at all material times, was holding the post of Foreman (Mechanical). It is not in dispute that for the purpose of promotion to the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) the said post is a feeder post.
3. In the years 1992, 1993, 1996 and 1997, the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) fell vacant. The petitioner contended that although he was senior, his case for promotion was ignored treating the said post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) as a 'selection post'. According to the petitioner, having regard to the fact that his case had not been considered in the earlier years, he is entitled to be promoted to the post of Depot Manager.
4. The contention raised on behalf of the respondent in the writ petition before the learned single Judge was that the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) was a 'selection post'. By reason of the impugned judgment, the learned single Judge has held that the said post is a 'selection post'.
5. It is not in dispute that the conditions of service of the employees of the first respondent herein are governed by the provisions of the Road Transport Corporation Act, 1950 (hereinafter referred to for the sake of brevity as 'the Act'). Section 45 of the Act reads thus:
45. (1) A Corporation may, with the previous sanction of the State Government, make Regulations, not inconsistent with this Act and the Rules made thereunder for the administration of the affairs of the Corporation.
(2) In particular, and without prejudice to the generality of the foregoing power, such regulations may provide for all or any of the following matters, namely:--
(a) the manner in which, and the purposes for which, persons may be associated with the Board under Section 10;
(b) the time and place of meetings of the Board and the procedure to be followed in regard to transaction of business at such meetings;
(c) the conditions of appointment and service and the scales of pay of officers and other employees of the Corporation other than the Managing Director, the Chief Accounts Officer and the Financial Adviser or, as the case may be, the Chief Accounts Officer-cum-Financial Adviser;
(d) the issue of passes to the employees of the Corporation and other persons under Section 19;
(e) the grant of refund in respect of unused tickets and confessional passes under Section 19."
In terms of the power conferred upon the State under sub-section (3) of Section 45 of the Act, service Regulations of the first respondent-Corporation have been framed known as the A.P. Road Transport Corporation Employees (Service) Regulations 1964. Regulation 4 of the said Regulations reads thus:
"4. Promotion--
(a) No member of a service or class of service shall be eligible for promotion from the category in which he was appointed to the service unless he has satisfactorily completed his probation in that category.
(b)(1) Promotion in a service or class to a Selection Category or to a Selection Grade shall be made on grounds of merit, seniority being considered only where merit is approximately equal."
6. Further, the Corporation, upon obtaining prior approval of the State Government, framed another set of Regulations known as the Andhra Pradesh State Road Transport Corporation Employees (Recruitment) Regulations, 1966. Regulation 2(xiv) and (xv) define 'selection' and 'selection post' in the following terms:
(xiv) 'Selection' means the selection of a person for appointment to a post in the service of the Corporation by the Selection Committee, if any, appointed for the purpose under Regulation 6 or by the appointing authority in its discretion when no Selection Committee has been appointed, provided that the Regulations as regards the method of recruitment and qualification in respect of the post for which the selection is made, are fulfilled.
(xv) 'selection post' means a post which is declared as such by a resolution of the Corporation."
Despite the fact that Regulation 2(xv) purports to empower the Corporation to declare a post as 'selection post' by a resolution, which forms part of the Regulation, in relation to posts of promotion from Executive Director to Chief Industrial Engineer, directed to be made 'by selection' and in relation thereto the Government gave sanction vide letter dated 29-4-1977. No such direction was issued in the matter of filling up of the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) by promotion. The method of recruitment, inter alia, in respect of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) and Assistant Works Manager, has been stated in the following manner.
SI. No Category of Post Method of Recruitment Qualifications Assistant Mechanical Engineer and Assistant Works Manager.
In a unit of five vacancies, the first, the third and fifth shall be filed in by appointment of an officer Under Training who was successfully completed his training and the second and fouith by promotion of a Foreman For promotion - the Foreman, -
(a) Must hold LME or LAE Diploma from Govt. Polytechnic or anyother recognised or any institution or posses an equivalent qualification; and
(b) Must ave put in not less than 5 years of services as such A member of the Supervisory staff who has passed sections 'A' and 'B' of the Associate Membership Examination of the institute of Engineers (India) and who has shown outstanding merit may also be considered for promotion along with the Foreman.
For Direct Recruitment - the candidate -
(a) Must hold a degree in Mechanical Engineering from a recognised University or have passed sections 'A' and 'B' of the Associate Membership Examination of the Instituion of Engineers (India) or hold a diploma or a certificate recognised by the Institution of Egineers (India) as exempting him from sections 'A' and "B' of the Associate Membership Examination, If a suitable candidate is not available in a particular category for filling up a vacancy reserved for that category the vacancy may be filled in by a suitable candidate from the other category.
(b) Must have served a regular Apprenticeship of not less than two years duration in Mechanical Engineering, preference being given to one who has served his apprenticeship in a Workshop, engaged in either the manufacture and assembly Ot the repair, overhaul afid maintenance Of commercial vehicles;
If no suitable candidate is available in any of the categories mentioned above, the post may be filled in by direct recruitment by selection.
(c) Must have had subsequent to his training not less than two years experience as an executive in control of large and well organised workshop engaged in either the manufacture and assembly or the repair, overhaul and maintenance of commercial motor vehicles; and
(d) Must not be above 30 years of age as on 1st July of the year, in which the recruitment is made."
The said provision was amended vide Resolution No.184/1984, dated 3-12-1983 and notified through Lr. No.P1/93(8) 83-PD dated 26-3-1984. It appears, the said amendment received the approval of the Government through letter No.89/Tr. IV(2)/84-1, Dated 9-2-1984.
7. Before the learned single Judge as also before us, the purported resolution passed by the Corporation in the year 1977 had been placed and pursuant thereto a contention has been raised that the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) is a 'selection post'. The said contention raised on behalf of the respondent found favour with the learned single Judge.
8. The learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the appellant inter alia submitted that having regard to the fact that the mode of selection was prescribed by reason of the aforementioned Regulation, the learned single Judge erred in not relying thereupon. Our attention has been drawn by Mr. Baig to a Division Bench judgment of this Court in Vice-Chairman and Managing Director, APSRTC, WA No.1435 of 1989 dated 11th June, 1991, disposed of on 11-6-1991 wherein, while considering the case of the Assistant Foreman (Mechanical) and Foreman (Mechanical) it was held:
"The power conferred on the Corporation to declare by a Resolution, a post as 'selection post' under sub-clause (xv) of Regulation 2 cannot nullify the specific provisions in the Regulations laying down specific methods of recruitment for appointment to the posts. It is only in respect of posts for which no specific method of recruitment is laid down in the Regulations, the residual power of the Corporation comes into play under sub-clause (xv) of Regulation 2."
Mr. Baig would urge that having regard to the aforementioned Division Bench judgment the learned single Judge must be held to have erred in passing the impugned judgment.
9. Mr. K. Harinath, learned Counsel appearing on behalf of the respondent on the other hand would urge that the point at issue is covered by Regulation 2(xv) of the Recruitment Regulations. According to the learned Counsel, having regard to the terminology used in the said provision as aforementioned, in the year 1977 the Corporation has passed a Resolution to the effect that the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) is a 'selection post', the learned single Judge must be held to have determined the issue correctly. The learned Counsel has also submitted that the method of promotion being not a condition of service, the same is not required to be prescribed by way of Regulation.
10. It is not in dispute that the method of selection which had been appended to the Regulations forms part of the regulations as indicated herein before. It is also not in dispute that the Resolutions passed by the Corporation were amended from time to time and such amended Regulations received the approval of the Government. It is needless to point out that previous sanction was required to be obtained in terms of subsection (1) of Section 45 of the said Act. It appears that the relevant Regulations were amended in the year 1995 as would appear from a notification dated 9th October, 1995, which reads thus:
"The Corporation Board vide Resolution No. 116/94 dated 8-9-1994 has approved the amendment to the method of recuitment and qualifications prescribed for the posts of Assistant Traffic Manager, Assistant Mechanical Engineer/Asst. Works Manager.
The Secretary to Government, Transport, Roads and Buildings (Tr.III) Department vide their Lr. No.589/Tr.III-2/95-1 dated 19-9-1995 has communicated approval of the Government to the method of recruitment and qualifications prescribed for the posts of Asst. Traffic Manager, Assistant Mechanical Engineer/Assistant Works Manager. A copy of the amended recruitment Regulations is enclosed.
The amended Regulation is deemed to have come into effect from 19-9-1995."
By reason of the aforementioned amendement, the method of recruitment, in relation to the post of the Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) is:
Category of Post Method of Recruitment Qualifications Assistant Mechanical Engineer/ Assistant Works Manager by transfer of Officersin equivalent category; or Qualifications for Promotion The Sr. Supdt. (Mechanical)-
(ii) by appointment of OUT (Tech.) who has successfully completed training and by promotion of Senior Supdt. (Mech.) by selection in the ratio of 1:2 respectively.
(a) Must hold LME or LAE Diploma from a Govt. Polytechnic or any other recognised institution or possess an equivalent qualification and must have put in not less than five years of service as such; or
(b) Must have passed SSC/ITI or its equivalent examination and must have put in not less than 8 years
(c) Should have passed Higher Management Departmental examination irrespective of age.
2. For Direct Recruitment :
The candidate
(a) No change
(b) No change
(c) No change
(d) No change It is, therefore, evident that the Corporation proceeded on the basis that the method of recruitment being a condition of service coming under sub-section (2) of Section 45, was required to be made by way of Regulations or amended upon by following the due procedure laid down therefor. It, therefore, in our opinion, does not lie in the mouth of the Corporation now to contend that pursuant to or in furtherance of the purported Resolution of 1977, the post of Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) was declared as a 'selection post'. As indicated hereinbefore, since the said Resolutions of the Corporation have been amended in the year 1983, which received the approval of the Government in the year 1984, the latter would prevail over the former. In any event, as is well known, an interpretation clause is not a positive enactment (vide Manik Ram v. Emperor, 1916 Patna 133 (FB). In a case of this nature, the doctrine 'Generalia Specialibus Non Derogant' shall squarely apply.
11. Having regard to the fact that the Regulations framed in terms of Section 45 are a subordinate legislation, the same will only have a prospective effect. Having regard to the provision contained in Section 45 of the said Act, there cannot be any doubt that any amendment carried out in the Regulation shall have a prospective effect. It is further beyond any cavil of doubt that any amendment affecting a right of a party by reason of a subsequent amendment shall have no effect for the purpose of appointment or otherwise if thereby a vested right is affected (vide A.A. Calton v. Director of Education, ); Y. V. Rangaiah v. Sreenivas Rao, ; P. Mahendran v. State of Karnataka, .
12. In view of the aforementioned authoritative pronouncements of the Apex Court, we have no other option but to hold that prior to coming into force of the amended Regulations 1995, the mode of selection applicable to the case of the appellant herein i.e., the Assistant Engineer (Mechanical) could have only been carried out in terms of the Regulations as was existing at the relevant point of time namely 'promotion by seniority' and not 'promotion by selection'.
13. When the method of recruitment has been laid down by a statute, the same could be altered only upon following the due procedure laid down under the statute and not otherwise. In any event, having regard to the fact that the State thought it necessary to amend the regulations in the year 1995 itself is a pointer to the fact that it was alive to the situation that prior thereto it was a 'non selection post' and in that view of the matter the Rule in Heydon's case must be applied as thereby the rule making authority intended to suppress the mischief and advance the remedy. In Bengal Immunity Co. v. State of Bihar, , the law has been laid down in the following terms:
(22) It is a sound Rule of construction of a statute firmly established in England as far back as 1584 when .... Heydon's case.....was decided that ....."for the sure and true interpretation of all statutes in general (be they penal or beneficial, restrictive or enlarging of the common law) four things are to be discerned and considered:
1st. What was the common law before the making of the Act;
2nd. What was the mischief and defect for which the common law did not provide;
3rd. What remedy the Parliament hath resolved and appointed to cure the disease of the Common wealth; and 4th. The true reason of the remedy; and then the office of all the judges is always to make such construction as shall suppress the mischief, and advance the remedy, and to suppress subtle inventions and evasions for continuance of the mischief, and 'pro privato commodo', and to add force and life to the cure and remedy, according to the true intent of the makers of the Act, 'pro bono publico'."
The said Rule has been followed subsequently by the Apex Court in various other decisions.
14. For the reasons aforementioned we are unable to agree with the findings of the learned single Judge. The impugned judgment is, therefore, set aside. The respondents are directed to consider the matter relating to promotion of the writ petitioner-appellant herein to the post of Assistant Mechanical Engineer afresh upon taking into consideration his seniority in the post of Foreman (Mechanical). It goes without saying that the case of the petitioner-appellant be considered if he is otherwise eligible and such consideration for promotion shall be reckoned from the date when the said post fell vacant in the year 1992. If the petitioner-appellant is found to be entitled to any further promotion consequent upon grant of promotion in terms of this judgment, the respondents are directed to consider the same also. This appeal and the writ petition are disposed of with the aforementioned directions but in the facts and circumstances of the case there shall be no order as to costs.
Alert