Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Aparna Agencies, Hyd. v. P. Sudhakar Rao & Anr.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jul 19, 1999
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the complainant against an order of acquittal dated 23-3-1998 in CC No. 100 of 1997 delivered by the XVI Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad. The complainant is a dealer in steel scrap and supplied iron and steel items to the accused, raising various bills. The accused made part payments, the last being Rs. 3,00,000 on 14-12-1996; as on 15-12-1996 a balance of Rs. 1,51,875.25 was due.

The accused issued cheque No. 646517 dated 1-1-1997 drawn on State Bank of Hyderabad for the outstanding amount. When presented the cheque was returned dishonoured with the endorsement “insufficient funds.” At the accused's request the complainant represented the cheque on 3-1-1997; it was again returned with the same endorsement on 7-1-1997. A legal notice was issued on 17-1-1997; the registered cover was returned unserved on 17-2-1997 with the endorsement “addressee out of station-door locked for 7 days.”

The complainant initiated proceedings under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The Magistrate took cognizance, issued process, and after trial (complainant examined as PW1, another witness as PW2; Exs. P1–P26 for complainant and Exs. D1–D4 for accused), the learned Magistrate found that (a) it was not necessary to arraign the firm as an accused, but (b) the mandatory notice had not been proved to have been served, and on that ground acquitted the accused. The complainant appealed against the acquittal.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a notice sent by registered post and returned by postal authorities with an endorsement that the "addressee [was] out of station" (and the door locked for seven days) is to be treated as deemed service for the purposes of Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  2. Whether the trial court's acquittal, based solely on the ground of non-service of the mandatory notice under Section 138, was sustainable in view of the evidence of dispatch and the authorities on deemed service.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Complainant)

  • The complainant complied with the legal requirement of issuing the prior notice (sent by registered post) required under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
  • The accused had knowledge of the cheque being dishonoured and had requested re-presentation; this supports the contention that he was aware of the default.
  • The registered notice was properly addressed, pre-paid and posted and was returned by postal authorities as "addressee out of station"; such a return is, according to the appellant, a situation in which the notice is deemed to have been served under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act. The appellant relied on several authorities (including V. Satyanarayana v. A.P. Travel, Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand, G.S. Srikanth v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers, Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills, Indian Bank v. Datla V. C. Raju, and Shashi Kumar v. Dharam Pal).
  • Accordingly, the appellant asked that the acquittal be set aside and the matter remanded for fresh disposal.

Respondent's Arguments (Accused)

  • Prior notice is a sine qua non for prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, and here the accused did not receive such a notice; therefore the complaint was rightly dismissed by the Magistrate.
  • The accused relied specifically on the judgment in A. Sudershan v. Mannan (Shabir) (1997 (6) ALD 202) to contend that where a registered cover is returned as "addressee not available," the presumption of deemed service under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act or Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act cannot be raised.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
V. Satyanarayana v. A.P. Travel and Tourism Development Corporation Ltd., Secunderabad, 1997 (1) ALD (Crl.) 706 (AP) Authority for treating a registered-post notice sent to correct address as giving rise to a presumption of service even where postal endorsements show redirection and eventual return. The court noted that this authority held the notice was not sent to a wrong address and impliedly that the notice was deemed to have been served; the opinion relied on it to support the presumption of service.
M. Ramachandra Reddy v. G. Ram Reddy, 1997 (2) ALD (Crl.) 189 (AP) : 1997 (2) ALT (Crl.) 347 (AP) Holds that if notice is sent to a proper address and returned on ground that addressee not found, it can still be deemed to have been served. The court cited and treated this authority as affirming the proposition that a returned registered cover (for non-availability) does not necessarily negate the presumption of service.
Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand, (1989) 1 SCC 264 : AIR 1989 SC 630 Interpretation of Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act: posting a prepaid registered letter properly addressed gives rise to a presumption of delivery in the ordinary course and thus deemed service. The court relied on paragraph 6 of this judgment to emphasize that once a prepaid registered letter is posted it is presumed to have been delivered and the sender loses control over the postal process; this supports deemed service.
G.S. Srikanth, M.D., TR&M Products v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers, 1998 (2) ALD (Crl.) 378 (AP) High Court authority holding that if registered post acknowledgement due is used and neither the unserved cover nor the acknowledgement is received, a presumption of service arises. The court relied on this High Court decision as consistent with the line of authorities supporting a presumption of deemed service upon proper dispatch by registered post.
Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills, (1996) 9 SCC 471 Considered effect of notice sent by registered post acknowledgement due where neither acknowledgment nor unserved envelope was received; held such notice to be deemed service under Order V Rule 19-A CPC, Sec. 27 General Clauses Act and Sec. 114(e) Evidence Act. The court treated this decision as supporting the proposition that deemed service arises in circumstances where registered-post processes indicate proper dispatch even without actual receipt.
Indian Bank v. Datla Venkata Chinna Krishnam Raju, 1991 Supp (2) SCC 714 : AIR 1991 SC 908 Authority where a registered cover was returned yet the Supreme Court raised a presumption of deemed service. The opinion relied on this case to reject the narrow view that a returned registered cover always negates the presumption of service; the court said this authority demonstrates that return does not necessarily preclude the presumption.
Shashi Kumar v. Dharam Pal, AIR 1981 Del 169 Held that even notice sent under certificate of posting is presumed to be service (relied on by appellant to show a stronger case where registered post was used). The court noted this authority to reinforce the appellant's contention that posting by registered/certificate methods generally supports raising a presumption of service.
A. Sudershan v. Mannan (Shabir), 1997 (6) ALD 202 Relied on by respondent to argue that where registered cover is returned for non-availability of the addressee, the presumption under Sec. 27 or Sec. 114(e) cannot be raised. The court considered this authority but distinguished it as taking the opposite view; the court ultimately regarded that reasoning as incorrect in the light of higher authorities and/or other decisions and did not follow it.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court focused on whether the registered-post notice, returned with the postal endorsement "addressee out of station-door locked for 7 days," could be treated as deemed service under Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act.

Step-by-step analysis as reflected in the opinion:

  1. The court inspected Ex. P4 (the registered cover) and found that the address on the cover matched the addresses used in the complainant's bills (Exs. P6–P17). Ex. P4 also contained dates showing that postal visits had been made to the address.
  2. The accused did not contend that an incorrect address had been supplied on Ex. P4.
  3. The court examined Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and identified the three statutory requirements for the presumption of service: (1) proper addressing; (2) pre-payment; and (3) posting by registered post. The court emphasized that nothing in the plain language of Section 27 requires that the cover must not be returned in order to attract the presumption.
  4. The court reviewed higher authority (Supreme Court decisions such as Madan & Co., Attabira and Indian Bank) and relevant High Court decisions (including M. Ramachandra Reddy v. G. Ram Reddy and G.S. Srikanth v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers) which supported the proposition that a properly addressed and posted registered document gives rise to a presumption of delivery/service even where the postal cover is not ultimately delivered in the ordinary course.
  5. The court considered the contrary view taken in A. Sudershan v. Mannan and another single-judge decision which conditioned the presumption on the registered cover not being returned, but concluded that such a qualification is not contemplated by the statutory language of Section 27 and that those decisions failed to take into account the cited Supreme Court authorities (in particular Indian Bank v. Datla V. C. Raju).
  6. Applying the statutory test to the facts (Ex. P4 properly addressed, pre-paid and posted; address matched the bills; postal visits noted; no challenge to address correctness), the court held that the requirements for raising the presumption of deemed service were met in this case.
  7. Because the trial court's sole ground for acquittal was non-service of the mandatory notice under Section 138, and that finding was found unsustainable, the trial court's acquittal on that ground was set aside. Nonetheless, the court considered that the matter required a reassessment of the evidence by the trial court, and therefore remanded the case for fresh disposal.

Holding and Implications

Final Disposition: APPEAL ALLOWED; the judgment of acquittal dated 23-3-1998 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the trial Court for fresh disposal according to law.

Implications and direct consequences:

  • The trial court's sole ground of acquittal—non-service of the mandatory notice under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act—has been reversed by the appellate court on the basis that the complainant had satisfied the statutory prerequisites for deemed service by registered post.
  • The matter is remitted to the trial court for reassessment of the evidence and fresh disposal. The appellate court directed the trial court to dispose of the matter expeditiously, preferably within two (2) months from receipt of records, given the age of the case.
  • The opinion relies on existing authorities to support the statutory interpretation of Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114(e) of the Evidence Act; it does not purport to announce a novel legal principle beyond that interpretive conclusion. The decision's immediate effect is to require further trial-court consideration rather than to pronounce a new binding precedent beyond application of the cited authorities.

If any section above appears concise, it reflects the court's own focus in the provided opinion (primarily on the legal question of deemed service of registered-post notices and the consequent setting aside of an acquittal on that basis).

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal against acquittal filed by the complainant in CC No. 100 of 1997 on the file of XVI Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad, dated 23-3-1998. The parties will be referred to as complainant and accused.

2. The complainant is a dealer in steel scrap for re-rolling, melting and M.S Flats, angles, TOR Steel etc. He supplied the iron and steel items of various specifications as required by the accused and raised various bills. The accused paid a sum of Rs. 12,94,000/- as part-payment, the last payment of Rs. 3 lakhs being on 14-12-1996. The accused was due to the complainant a sum of Rs. 1,51,875.25 ps. as on 15-12-1996. He issued a cheque bearing No. 646517, dated 1-1-1997 for the said amount drawn on State Bank of Hyderabad, Kavadiguda Branch, Secunderabad. When it was presented in the bank it was returned dishonoured with an endorsement “insufficient funds”. It was brought to the notice of the accused and at his request, the complainant represented the cheque once again in his bank on 3-1-1997, but it was returned once again with the same endorsement on 7-1-1997. Thereupon the complainant got a legal notice issued on 17-1-1997 which was returned unserved on 17-2-1997 with an endorsement “addressee out of station-door locked for 7 days”. According to the complainant the notice is deemed to have been duly served on the accused. Thus, he has failed to make payment inspite of demand made by the complainant and thereupon he has committed an offence under Sec. 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act. The learned Magistrate recorded the sworn statement of the complainant and took cognizance of the case under Section 138 of Negotiable Instrument Act and issued process to the accused. He entered appearance and received copies of the complaint and documents. When he was examined under Section 251 Cr. P.C, he denied the complaint allegations and pleaded not guilty. Thereupon the complainant examined himself as PW1 and another witness as PW 2. Exs. P1 to P26 have been marked for the complainant. The accused got Exs. D1 to D4 marked. The learned Magistrate scrutinized the above oral and documentary evidence and considered the contentions of both sides. On behalf of the accused it was firstly contended that the cheque was issued by the firm, but the firm is not arraigned as an accused and secondly that no notice is received by him.

3. The learned Magistrate held on first objection that it is not necessary to arraign the firm. However, he upheld the second objection and held that the accused is not guilty and acquitted him hence the appeal by the complainant.

4. Sri M. Ramachandra Reddy, learned Counsel for the appellant contended that the complainant has complied with the requirement of issuing notice and that the finding of the learned Magistrate in that regard is erroneous. According to him the accused had knowledge of the bouncing of cheque and it was at his request that the complainant represented the cheque and thereafter it was bounced once again. He asserted that the registered notice which was returned by postal authorities that the addressee was absent is deemed service. He relied on the judgments in V. Satyanarayana v. A.P Travel and Tourism Development Corporation Ltd., Secunderabad, 1997 (1) ALD (Crl.) 706 (AP); M. Ramachandra Reddy v. G. Ram Reddy 1997 (2) ALD (Crl.) 189 (AP) : 1997 (2) ALT (Crl.) 347 (AP); Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand, (1989) 1 SCC 264 : AIR 1989 SC 630; G.S Srikanth, M.D, TR&M Products v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers, 1998 (2) ALD (Crl.) 378 (AP); and Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills, (1996) 9 SCC 471. Thus, he sought for allowing the appeal and to set aside the judgment under appeal and to remand the case for fresh disposal.

5. Sri Ashok Kumar, learned Counsel for the accused while supporting the judgment contended that prior notice is a sine qua non for a prosecution under Sec. 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act and in this case no such notice was received by the accused and hence the complaint was rightly thrown out and relied on a judgment in A. Sudershan v. Mannan (Shabir), 1997 (6) ALD 202.

6. Having regard to the rival contentions, the short point that arises for consideration is whether notice sent by registered post and returned by postal authorities is deemed service.

7. I applied my anxious consideration to the rival contentions. It is not in dispute that the complainant sent a notice by registered post and it was returned after one month with the endorsement that “addressee out of station and door locked for seven days”. The registered cover is marked as Ex. P4. I carefully perused Ex. P4 and I find that the address therein tallies with the address noted in Exs. P6 to P17 cash/credit bills. It also contains various dates indicating that the post-man had visited the house on all those dates. Ultimately the cover had been returned with the aforesaid endorsement. It is not the case of the respondent/accused that a wrong address was given in Ex. P4. Sri M. Ramachandra Reddy placed strong reliance upon Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act and argued that Ex. P4 is properly addressed, pre-paid and posted by registered post as is evident from a perusal of the document itself and contended that under Sec. 27 it amounts to deemed service. Section 27 is reproduced below for ready reference:

“Meaning of service by post:— Where any Central Act or Regulation made after the commencement of this Act authorises or requires any document to be served by post whether the expression “serve” or either of the expressions “give” or “send” or any other expression is used, then, unless a different intention appears, the service shall be deemed to be effected by properly addressing, pre-paying and posting by registered post, a letter containing the document, and, unless the contrary is proved, to have been effected at the time at which the letter would be delivered in the ordinary course of post”.

8. It is true that the language of the above provision is plain. Evidently three requirements are to be fulfilled for presuming deemed service, viz., (1) properly addressing, (2) pre-paying and (3) posting of registered post. The above provision has been interpreted by the Apex Court in the judgment cited Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand (supra). Para 6 of the judgment runs as under:

“…..The proviso insists that before any amount of rent can be said to be in arrears, a notice has to be served through post. All that a landlord can do to comply with this provision is to post a prepaid registered letter (acknowledgement due or otherwise) containing the tenant's correct address. Once he does this and the letter is delivered to the post office, he has no control over it. It is then presumed to have been delivered to the addressee under Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act”.

9. On another occasion the Supreme Court in the judgment Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills (cited supra) considered the effect of a notice sent by registered post acknowledgement due, but neither acknowledgement nor unserved envelope received back and in such circumstances the notice is held to be deemed service within the meaning of Order V Rule 19-A of CPC, Section 27 of the General Clauses Act and Section 114(e) of Evidence Act.

10. This question was considered by our High Court in several judgments. In the judgment M.D TR&M Products v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers (cited supra), my learned Brother B. Sudershan Reddy, J., referred to the above judgments of the Apex Court besides the judgment in Indian Bank v. Datla Venkata Chinna Krishnam Raju 1991 Supp (2) SCC 714 : AIR 1991 SC 908 and held—

“In my considered opinion, if the holder or the payee of a cheque makes a demand for payment by giving a notice, in writing to the drawer of the cheque under registered post acknowledgement due and if neither the unserved postal cover nor the acknowledgement is received by the payee or the holder of the cheque, a presumption would arise about the service of notice upon the drawer of the cheque”.

11. In the judgment M. Ramachandra Reddy v. G. Ram Reddy (cited supra), the contention that if a notice is sent on a proper address even if it is returned on the ground that the accused was not found on the said address, it will be deemed to have been served on the addressee has been affirmed. In the judgment V. Satyanarayana v. A.P Travel and Tourism Development Corporation Ltd. Secunderabad (cited supra) this Court considered the case of the notice being addressed to the correct address and sent by registered post and the postal authorities endorsing that the addressee is at present residing at Gangala Kurru Agraharam and then the notice was redirected to that address and there the postal authorities endorsed that neither the addressee nor the care/of are residing at that address and returned to sender, it has been held that notice was not sent to wrong address and accordingly the contention of the petitioner was repelled and impliedly notice was deemed to have been served.

12. The learned Counsel for the appellant also relied on the judgment in Shashi Kumar v. Dharam Pal AIR 1981 Del 169, and contended that even a notice sent under certificate of posting is presumed to be service of notice and hence the case on hand is on a better footing inasmuch as notice was sent by registered post to the correct address and therefore, a presumption under Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act and Sec. 114(e) of Evidence Act should have been drawn in favour of the appellant.

13. On the other hand Sri Ashok Kumar, “learned Counsel for the respondent relying upon the judgment cited A. Sudershan v. Mannan (Shabir) (cited supra) strenuously argued that Ex. P4 registered cover was returned as the addressee was not available and in such circumstances the presumption either under Sec. 27 of General Clauses Act or under Sec. 114(e) of Evidence Act cannot be raised”.

14. I carefully perused all the above judgments and also the judgment rendered by another learned single Judge Justice B.S Raikote. “It is true that in the above case registered notice was returned on account of non-availability of the addressee continuously for seven days. The learned Judge distinguished a case of a registered cover not being returned back from a case of returned with endorsement that addressee was not available and according to him a presumption under Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act and Sec. 114(e) of Evidence Act can be raised in former cases and not in the latter cases”. After extracting Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act, the learned Judge held—

“From the reading of the above section it is clear that any document under Central Act is required to be served by post, such a service shall be effected by delivering the same in the ordinary course of post. It further makes it clear that unless different intention appears as per any Act or Regulation, such a service shall be deemed to be effected by properly addressing pre-paying and posting by a registered post. In other words if such a document is sent by registered post and if it does not return back it is deemed to have been served, (emphasis supplied). But, such a presumption is a rebuttable presumption and it is always open to the addressee to prove that in fact he did not receive such a registered post. It is only having regard to this kind of presumption found under Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act 1897 and also similar presumption found under Sec. 114 of the Indian Evidence Act the Courts in India have presumed the service of such a notice or document when such a registered post is not returned back. Such a presumption is raised even in case the registered post is returned with postal shara ‘refused’ in view of the fact that such a refusal presumes knowledge of the addressee and presumably knowing the contents he has wantonly refused it”.

15. I read the relevant provisions viz., Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act and Sec. 114(e) of Evidence Act again and again with a view to see whether the interpretation in the underlined sentence is possible or not. In my considered opinion “the qualification that ‘if the registered cover does not return back’ is not at all contemplated by the above provisions. The plain meaning of the above provision is that service shall be deemed to be effected by (1) properly addressing; (2) pre-paying and (3) posting by registered post. These are the requirements for invoking Sec. 27 of the General Clauses Act and nothing more. There is no requirement of that cover not returning back for raising a presumption. It is seen that the judgments of the Apex Court cited Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand; Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills and Indian Bank v. Datla Venkata Chinna Krishnam Raju (cited supra) are not brought to the notice of the learned Judge especially the judgment Indian Bank v. Datla Venkata Chinna Krishnam Raju (cited supra), wherein the registered cover was in fact returned and yet the presumption of deemed service was raised. I am sure that if the above authorities were brought to the notice of the Hon'ble Judge, his view would have been different. Hence, with all respect I hold that the above judgment is per incuriam.

16. On a careful consideration of the authorities cited V. Satyanarayana v. A.P Travel and Tourism Development Corporation Ltd., Secunderabad; M. Ramachandra Reddy v. G. Ram Reddy, Madan & Co. v. Wazir Jaivir Chand; G.S Srikanth, M.D TR&M Products v. Sri Lakshmi Financiers; Attabira Regulated Market Committee v. Ganesh Rice Mills, Indian Bank v. Datla Venkata Chinna Krishnam Raju and Shashi Kumar v. Dharam Pal (supra), I have no hesitation to hold that the requirements for raising a presumption of deemed service are made out by the appellant and hence, the view of the trial Court on this point is clearly unsustainable. The point is answered accordingly. It is evident from the judgment under appeal that the only ground on which the respondent was acquitted was on the ground of non-service of mandatory notice under Sec. 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act and such a finding is set aside. Accordingly the order of acquittal on that ground is also set aside. However, I am of the view that the matter requires reassessment of evidence by the trial Court.

17. In the result, the appeal is allowed and the judgment dated 23-3-1998 is set aside and the matter is remanded to the trial Court for fresh disposal according to law. This being an old case, the trial Court is directed to dispose of the same as expeditiously as possible preferably within two (2) months from the date of receipt of records.