- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Ch. Chinnaiah v. Govt. Of A.P And Others
Judgment Summary — Appeal against dismissal of W.P. No. 29892/98 (judgment dated 23-3-1999)
Factual and Procedural Background
The appellant, who obtained rank No. 1253 in the B.Ed Common Entrance Test-1998, filed Writ Petition No. 29892/98 challenging Rule 10(3)(f) of the A.P. Colleges of Education (Regulation of Admission into B.Ed Course through Common Entrance Test) Rules, 1989. The impugned rule reserves 10 seats in each Government comprehensive college of education for specified categories of government and ministerial employees (Section Officers and other non-Gazetted officials, including Record Assistants and Attenders, working in the Education Department and related local bodies), with selection for admission to be made by the Director of School Education "purely on the basis of rank assigned in the common entrance test," and any unfilled reserved seats to be returned to the general pool.
The appellant's primary grievance was that the application of this reservation deprived him of a seat he would otherwise have obtained. He contended that precedent from the Supreme Court and this Court invalidating reservations in favour of children or wards of employees, and invalidating separate assessment criteria distinct from the general assessment criteria, required the impugned rule to be declared void for want of rational classification. The learned single Judge dismissed the writ petition, rejecting these contentions, and the appellant brought this appeal.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether Rule 10(3)(f) of the A.P. Colleges of Education Rules, 1989 (reserving 10 seats in each Government college for specified categories of government/ministerial employees) is constitutionally valid.
- Whether the reservation effected by the impugned rule constitutes an irrational classification lacking a nexus with the object sought to be achieved (i.e., whether it breaches Article 14 principles).
- Whether the reservation contravenes the 50% ceiling on reservations as articulated in Indra Sawhney and related authority.
- Whether reservations of this character fall outside the permissible scope of Articles 15 and 16 such that they lack any constitutional foundation (or whether they may be sustained as a classification under Articles 14 and 15).
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The impugned rule reserves seats that resulted in the appellant losing a seat he would otherwise have obtained by merit.
- The rule is analogous to cases where reservations in favour of children/wards of employees were invalidated; those precedents and the principle that admissions must be strictly on merit require invalidation of the impugned reservation.
- The classification is irrational and lacks a rational nexus to the object sought to be achieved.
- The reservation may cause the 50% ceiling on reservations (as in Indra Sawhney) to be exceeded.
- The reservation falls outside the reservations permitted under Articles 15 and 16 and therefore lacks a constitutional foundation.
- Specific authorities were cited by the appellant's counsel, including S.V.U. Teachers Association v. Srivenkateswara University (to support validity) and Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology v. State of Punjab / J.P. Unni Krishnan (to argue limits of permissible reservation practices).
State / Respondent's Arguments (as recorded)
- The impugned rule was enacted to enable ministerial and related employees to acquire B.Ed qualifications to become eligible for transfer/promotion to teaching posts and to provide them with the requisite academic knowledge and expertise for duties in the Education Department and related institutions.
- The reservation is restricted to Government comprehensive Colleges of Education, which are administered and funded by the State, and is aimed at improving the administration and effectiveness of the State's educational machinery.
- Selection for the reserved seats is to be made by the Director of School Education on the basis of rank assigned in the common entrance test; thus admissions are not made by an entirely separate, arbitrary assessment scheme.
- With respect to the 50% ceiling contention, the State pointed out that only a limited number of ministerial staff would in practice seek admission and that unfilled reserved seats are reverted to the general pool; for example, in 1997–1998 only 22 of 70 reserved seats were taken up and 48 seats were returned to the general pool. The State thus contested any factual showing that the 50% ceiling is or will be exceeded.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| S.V.U. Teachers Association, Tirupati v. Srivenkateswara University, Tirupati, 1998 (4) Andh LD 305 | Addresses withdrawal of reservation in favour of wards of teaching/non-teaching staff; Division Bench upheld withdrawal following settled law that such reservations are impermissible. | The court noted this decision was cited by appellant's counsel. The court distinguished it as dealing with reservations in favour of children/wards of staff and held that its ratio has no relevance to a reservation in favour of the employees themselves. |
| Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology v. State of Punjab, AIR 1997 SC 793 : (1997 AIR SCW 615) | Holds that reservation of additional seats for wards of college/mill/school staff, where a separate merit list is drawn for those seats (rather than admission strictly on the basis of common merit), is impermissible; applies J.P. Unni Krishnan principle that admission must be strictly on basis of merit. | The appellant relied on the Supreme Court's observations in Thapar to assert parity with the impugned rule. The court analysed Thapar and concluded its invalidation rested on the fact that those reservations were for wards and involved separate inter se merit lists; the court distinguished Thapar as not applicable to the impugned reservation which is for employees (not wards) and where selection is to be made on the basis of rank in the common entrance test. |
| J.P. Unni Krishnan v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1993 SC 2178 : (1993 AIR SCW 863) | Establishes the principle that admission should be given strictly on the basis of merit as laid down by the Supreme Court. | The opinion recognises that the Supreme Court in Thapar invoked J.P. Unni Krishnan in reasoning that separate merit lists for reserved wards failed the strict-merit test. The High Court used that contextual link to explain why Thapar struck down reservations for wards, and then distinguished those facts from the present case. |
| Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : AIR 1993 SC 477 | Establishes the well-known principle of a 50% ceiling on reservations (as part of the settled law on reservation limits). | The appellant invoked Indra Sawhney to argue that the impugned rule could lead to exceeding the 50% reservation ceiling. The court declined to decide whether the impugned reservations must be counted towards the 50% ceiling because the petitioner failed to place factual particulars to show that the ceiling has in fact been or will be exceeded; the court refused to invalidate the rule on hypothetical grounds. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded through a fact-sensitive analysis guided by precedent and constitutional principles. The key strands of the court's reasoning, as recorded in the opinion, are:
- Characterisation of the impugned reservation: The court emphasised that the reservation under Rule 10(3)(f) is for specified categories of government/ministerial employees themselves (Section Officers, other non-Gazetted officials, record assistants, attenders, etc.), and is not a reservation in favour of their children or wards.
- Distinguishing precedent concerned with wards/children: The court analysed the authorities relied upon by the appellant (notably Thapar and S.V.U. related decisions) and found them factually distinguishable because those cases addressed reservations made for wards/children of staff and often involved separate inter se merit lists. The Supreme Court in Thapar had invalidated such reservations because admission was not being given strictly on the basis of the common merit list; rather a separate list was drawn for the reserved seats. The court held that the ratio in those cases therefore does not apply to a reservation in favour of the employees themselves.
- Application of the impugned rule to merit: The impugned rule provides that selection for admission of the specified employees "will be made by the Director of School Education purely on the basis of rank assigned in the common entrance test." On this basis the court treated the selection mechanism as tied to the common ranking generated by the entrance test rather than an independent or separate assessment that would offend the strict-merit principle identified in Thapar/J.P. Unni Krishnan.
- Rational nexus and legitimate State purpose: The State's stated rationale—facilitating ministerial employees to acquire B.Ed qualifications to enable transfer/promotion and to enhance expertise within the Education Department and local-body run educational institutions—was accepted by the court as a legitimate object. Given that the rule applies only to State-administered and funded Government Colleges of Education, the court found a rational nexus between the classification (specified categories of employees) and the purpose (improving administration and functioning of State educational machinery). The court therefore rejected the argument that the classification was irrational or without adequate nexus to the object.
- 50% ceiling contention analysed on factual footing: Although the appellant alleged the reservation could breach the 50% ceiling on reservations (Indra Sawhney), the court declined to decide this issue because the petitioner did not furnish concrete substantiation (numbers/particulars) to show the ceiling had in fact been or would be exceeded. The court emphasised the settled principle that a statutory instrument should not be invalidated on hypothetical assumptions or merely as an academic exercise.
- Constitutional foundation under Articles 14/15: While the appellant argued the reservation fell outside Articles 15 and 16 and therefore had no constitutional foundation, the court concluded that the impugned reservation is a form of classification permissible under Articles 14 and 15. The court saw no ground to invalidate the rule on the basis that it lacked constitutional foundation.
- Overall appraisal: The court concluded that none of the appellant's contentions had merit. It found no error in law or in exercise of discretion by the learned single Judge and therefore dismissed the appeal.
Holding and Implications
APPEAL DISMISSED.
Direct effect on the parties:
- The judgment of the learned single Judge dismissing the writ petition is affirmed; the appellant's challenge to Rule 10(3)(f) fails on the merits.
- The appeal is dismissed without costs.
Broader implications:
The court expressly distinguished precedents invalidating reservations in favour of children/wards of staff from the present case, which involves reservations in favour of the employees themselves and which, on the facts recorded, were found to have a rational nexus to legitimate State objectives and to involve selection linked to the common entrance ranking. The opinion does not purport to lay down any new, sweeping precedent beyond applying settled principles (rational nexus under Articles 14/15 and the strict-merit considerations in Thapar/J.P. Unni Krishnan), and the court declined to rule on the 50% ceiling question in the absence of concrete factual demonstration that the ceiling would be exceeded.
Appeal dismissed.
Goda Raghuram, J.:— This appeal is directed against the judgment dated 23-3-1999 in W.P No. 29892/98, dismissing the writ petition. The appellant appeared for B.Ed Common Entrance Test-1998, and obtained rank No. 1253. In the writ petition he challenged Rule 10(3)(f) of the A.P Colleges of Education (Regulation of Admission into B.Ed Course through Common Entrance Test) Rules, 1989. The said rule reads as under:
“10 seats in each Government comprehensive college of Education (it is now being called as Government Institution of Advanced Study in Education)/Government College of Education (This is now being called as College of Teacher Education) shall be reserved for Section Officers and other non-Gazetted officials including Record Assistants and Attenders working in the Education Department of Andhra Pradesh Secretariat, as permitted by the Government and ministerial staff including the Record Assistants and Attenders working in the offices under the control of the Director of School Education and the ministerial staff including record assistants and attenders working in the recognised non-Government institutions like Zilla Parishads, Panchayat Samitis, Municpalities, private institutions under the administrative control of the Director of School Education, Andhra Pradesh, Hyderabad, as permitted by the Director of School Education. Their selection for admission will be made by the Director of School Education purely on the basis of rank assigned in the common entrance test. If sufficient number of candidates are not available under this quota, they may be filled in by the candidates from the general pool.”
In the appellant's contention on account of the operation of the impugned rule ten seats in each of the Government comprehensive colleges of Education having been appropriated towards the said reservation, the appellant has been unable to obtain a seat which he would have otherwise obtained. He has contended that the judgments of the Supreme Court as well as this Court invalidated reservations made in favour of children of retired employees and also wards of college and industry staff and separate assessment criteria distinct from the general assessment criteria has been declared invalid and on a parity of reasoning the reservation prescribed in the impugned rule has to be declared as invalid and inoperative. He has also contended that the reservation prescribed by the impugned rule is bereft of rational classification inasmuch as the classification has no rational nexus with the object sought to be achieved. The learned single Judge having dismissed the writ petition rejecting all the aforesaid contentions, the appeal is preferred.
2. At the hearing of appeal learned Counsel for the appellant reiterated the same contentions. The appellant's counsel cited a decision of a Division Bench of this Court in S.V.U Teachers Association, Tirupati v. Srivenkateswara University, Tirupati, 1998 (4) Andh LD 305, in support of his contention that the impugned rule is valid. The S.V and J.N.T Universities in the State of A.P created supernumerary posts for the purpose of children of teaching and non-teaching staff of the respective educational institutions. Following the earlier decision of this Court invalidating such practice, the State Government directed the Universities concerned to withdraw such facility and consequent on such withdrawal, writ petitions were filed challenging the withdrawal of the policy of reservation in favour of wards of teaching and non-teaching staff in the two Universities. Following the settled law on this aspect of the matter the Division Bench upheld the withdrawal of the policy.
3. Another decision cited by the learned Counsel is Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology v. State of Punjab, AIR 1997 SC 793 : (1997 AIR SCW 615). The Technological Institute of Textile and Science at Bhiwani (for short ‘the TIT&S’) is running an institute imparting education in Textile Technology, Textile Chemistry, Computer Science and Management Science leading to the award of B.Tech/M.Tech/M.M.S Degrees, and also owns and runs a Textile Mill in the same premises. Apart from 90 seats for B.Tech Course run by TIT&S, 4 additional seats have been provided for the wards of the employees, two of such additional seats are in the discipline of Computer Science and two other in Textiles. Of the 4 seats, two are earmarked for the college staff and two for mill/school staff. The TIT&S does not receive any financial aid from the State Government or Central Government or affiliating University or any other local authority. To be eligible for admission to those earmarked seats the candidate is required to have at least 60% marks in the aggregate of three subjects (Physics, Chemistry and Maths) of 10 + 2 examination and admission is to be made on the basis of the merit to be earned according to the marks secured in the entrance examination conducted by the respondent-University. Seats earmarked for college and mill/school staff can be interchanged in case there is no eligible candidate in one particular group and if a seat allotted for computer course is not desired by the allottee, he shall be offered a seat in the Textile Course and, if any seat remains vacant, the requirement of service period may be relaxed with prior approval of the Chairman of the Societies. The wards of the employees who secure admission on their own merit or on reserved seats of wards are eligible for freeship. The affiliating University directed TIT&S not to make any admissions under this category. Aggrieved thereby the writ petition was filed and on dismissal thereof the matter came to be considered by the Supreme Court. Another institute-Thapar Institute of Engineering and Technology, Patiala (for short ‘the TIET’) also reserved 2% of its seats in favour of the children of the employees and 5% for the children of employees of Thapar Group of Companies. On being directed by the Government of Punjab to discontinue the said reservation a writ petition was filed, which was dismissed by the High Court and came to be considered by the Supreme Court along with TIT&S case. Following the earlier judgment in J.P Unni Krishnan v. State of Andhra Pradesh, AIR 1993 SC 2178 : (1993 AIR SCW 863), the Supreme Court upheld the view taken by the High Court that the reservation made by the appellants therein in favour of the wards of its employees was unsustainable in law. During the course of its reasoning, the Supreme Court made the following observations:
“16. It is no doubt true that the four additional seats for which reservation was made for the wards of the college and mill/school staff of the TIT&S are in addition to 90 seats and admission is made on the basis of marks obtained in the Entrance Examination conducted by the respondent-University. But for the purpose of admission to these four seats a separate merit list is drawn in respect of the candidates who are eligible for these seats and admission is not made according to merit as reflected in the common merit list. Such reservation in favour of wards of the college and mill/school staff of the TIT&S does not satisfy the test of admission being given strictly on the basis of merit as laid down by this Court and has been rightly held to be impermissible by the High Court. The said appeal is, therefore, liable to be dismissed.”
4. The appellant herein strongly relies on the observation of the Supreme Court in the passage extracted supra, to contend that as in the facts in the case before the Supreme Court, in the B.Ed, course also the reserved category of Government employees, though they have to pass the Common Entrance Test, are considered for allotment of seats on the basis of their own inter se ranking for allotment of seats within the quota earmarked for the said category. Their entitlement to a seat not having to depend on their general ranking in the merit list, the observations of the Supreme Court equally apply to the impugned reservation and result in the invalidation of the rule impugned in the writ petition. An analysis of the judgment of the Supreme Court clearly discloses that the statement of facts recorded by the Supreme Court in respect of the reservation which fell for its consideration was in the context of the principle reiterated by it as is apparent from the sentence immediately following the said statement of facts— “such reservation in favour of wards of the college/mill/school staff of the TIT&S does not satisfy the test of admission being given strictly on the basis of the merit as laid down by this Court and rightly held to be impermissible by the Supreme Court.” (Emphasis supplied). The invalidation of the reservation policy by the Supreme Court was on the basis that the reservation in favour of wards of the employees is an irrational classification.
5. Coming to the case on hand, the reservation by the impugned rule is not for the children or wards of Government employees. In fact it is not for the children and wards. The reservation is for Section Officers and other Non-Gazetted Officials including Record Assistants and Attenders working in the Education Department of A.P Secretariat as permitted by the Government and Ministerial Staff including Record Assistants and Attenders working in the offices under the control of the Director of School Education and the Ministerial Staff including Record Assistants and Attenders working in local body Institutions like Zilla Parishads, Panchayat Samitis, Municipalities etc. Further their selection for admission will be made by the Director of School Education purely on the basis of rank assigned in the Common Entrance Test.
6. The State Government in the counter-affidavit filed in the writ petition stated that the impugned rules have been enacted in order to “enable the ministerial employees to acquire B.Ed qualification to become eligible for transfer/promotion to the post of teaching category and further the employees working in the Educational Department being expected to acquire B.Ed, qualification to gain the requisite academic knowledge for dealing with the matters of Department of School Education and to ensure better expertise in the Department.”
7. The reservation by the impuged rule is limited only to the comprehensive Colleges of Education/Government Colleges of Education, which are exclusively administered and funded by the State. The rationale underlying the rule clearly appears to be to enrich the cadre of its employees working in the Education Department and its allied Departments and the Educational Institutions under the local bodies, so as to enable them to more effectively perform their duties, which are in the realm of administration of Education Department or of the Educational Institutions themselves. In the circumstances it cannot be held that the reservation in favour of such category of Government employees is either irrational or has no rational nexus with the objects sought to be achieved. The object of reservation is rational and related to the general purpose of the State and the Local Bodies in the matter of administration of Educational Institutions. Well equipped Government servants and employees of the academic institutions run by the local bodies are a sine qua non for effective administration of this crucial State activity. The cases cited by the appellant all deal with invalidation of reservation made in favour of the children or wards of staff of educational institutions. The ratio of these cases has no relevance or application to the reservation impugned herein. We are clearly of the view that on this account the impugned rules does not suffer from the vice of irrationality or improper classification.
8. It has been vehemently urged that the reservation by the impugned rule would also violate the settled law that no reservation can be made in excess of 50%. In the affidavit filed in support of the writ petition it is pleaded that there are 12 Government Colleges in the State, in which there are 160 seats each in most of the colleges and that by allotting 10 seats in each college it would amount to reserving 6% seats to the reserved category and consequently this could run counter to the 50% ceiling on reservations declared by the extant law including the ratio in Indra Sawhney v. Union of India, 1992 Supp (3) SCC 217 : (AIR 1993 SC 477). In reply thereto the State in its counter in the writ petition stated that there are 7 Government Colleges in the State having an in-take capacity of 160 seats each and though 10 seats in each of the colleges are reserved, only a limited number of ministerial staff would desire to undergo B.Ed, training for future promotions being available on the basis of the ranking assigned in the BEDCET and the other seats are left to be filled by the candidates allotted by the Convenor of the BEDCET in the general pool. As an illustration it is stated that for the year 1997-1998 of the 70 seats reserved by the impugned rule, only 22 ministerial staff had applied and the remaining 48 seats earmarked for this reservation quota have been thrown back to the general pool. Considering this contention, learned single Judge held that though a vague statement is made that the reservation by the impugned rule would result in 50% ceiling of reservation being exceeded, no substantiation has been made by furnishing particulars and in the circumstances no case has been made out by the petitioner for invalidation of the reservation.
9. We have not been provided with further assistance on the matter at the hearing of the appeal. It is a settled principle that a statutory instrument is not to be invalidated on hypothetical assumptions or as an academic exercise. Nothing has been placed before us to demonstrate that 50% reservation has been exceeded. In the circumstances we decline to go into the question whether the reservation made by the impuged rule is also comprehend within the reservations made in favour of SC, ST and BCs under Articles 15(4) and 16(4) of the Constitution of India, for the purpose of calculating the 50% ceiling on reservations. The factual subtratum of the case is in apposite for consideration of this issue.
10. The other contention of the appellant is that inasmuch as this reservation falls outside the reservations permitted under Articles 15 and 16 of the Constitution, there is no constitutional foundation for the exercise of State/Executive power in making these reservations. We are clearly of the view that the reservations by the impugned rule in favour of specified State Government employees is a species of the generic power of the State to make classification available to it under Articles 14 and 15 of the Constitution. We see no ground to invalidate the impugned rule on this ground either.
11. In the result, we are of the view that there are no merits in any of the contentions on behalf of the appellant. The judgment of the learned single Judge is vitiated neither by any error in the application of law nor in exercise of discretion. The writ appeal accordingly fails and is dismissed, but in the circumstances without costs.
Appeal dismissed.
Alert