- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Andhra Engineering Corpn., Secunderabad v. Tci Finance Ltd., Sec-Bad. & Anr.
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Criminal Revision (Crl. A. No. 91/98)
Factual and Procedural Background
This Revision is filed against the judgment and sentence passed in Crl. A. No. 91/98 on the file of the VI Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad. The case arises under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act.
The factual matrix as set out in the opinion is as follows: in July 1995 the petitioner/accused approached the complainant (1st respondent) for a bill-discounting facility and availed a facility amounting to Rs. 10,76,426.25. The petitioner signed the hundi, submitted invoices and a covering letter, and was required to repay within 90 days (due date 28-10-1995). The petitioner did not repay in full and issued cheque Ex. P.8 dated 28-10-1995 for Rs. 10,76,000/-. The cheque was presented on 18-3-1996 and was returned for insufficient funds.
After issuance of the cheque various payments were made on different dates. The opinion records differing aggregations in the record: at one place it is recorded that, in all, Rs. 3,01,821/- had been paid; at another place the opinion states there was no dispute that Rs. 3,50,000/- had been paid and a balance of Rs. 7,74,179/- remained due. The complainant sent legal notice Ex. P.10 (dated 30-3-1996); the petitioner replied by Ex. P.11 (dated 14-4-1996) denying the transaction. Office copies of demand letters are Exs. P.6 and P.7 (demanding Rs. 8,76,000/- as balance at that time). The complainant filed an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. to issue summons to the bank to verify the account balance; the petitioner filed a memo stating that he had less than Rs. 7,74,179/- to the credit of his account on the date of presentation (this memo was later withdrawn by the complainant).
The lower courts convicted the petitioner under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act and this revision challenges that judgment and sentence.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether a cheque issued for a larger amount (here Rs. 10,76,000/-) can validly be presented for encashment after part payment has been made by the drawer, and whether the drawer is criminally liable if the original cheque bounces for want of sufficient funds.
- Whether a demand notice that claims a figure different from the cheque amount (for example, the balance after part payments) is legally sufficient or becomes ambiguous/invalid because the cheque amount and the notice amount differ.
Arguments of the Parties
Revision Petitioner / Accused (as presented in the opinion)
- The learned senior counsel for the petitioner, Mr. T. Bali Reddy, submitted that Ex. P.8 was for Rs. 10,76,000/-, but the petitioner had already paid part of the debt (variously recorded as Rs. 3,01,821/- and Rs. 3,50,000/- at different parts of the record).
- He argued that because part payments had been made, the original cheque for Rs. 10,76,000/- could not validly be presented to recover the remaining balance (Rs. 7,74,179/- as admitted). He contended that to the extent of the part payments the cheque was invalid and consequently no liability could be fastened on the petitioner if the cheque bounced.
- He relied on several authorities (including Gopa Debi Ozha v. Sujit Paul; N.C. Nag Pal v. The State; Raj v. Rajan) which he submitted held that notices claiming amounts differing from the cheque amount are vague/illegal and accordingly the complaint should fail.
- He also relied on decisions such as Voruganti Chinna Gopaiah v. Godavari Fertilizers and Padmaja Marketing Enterprises v. V.S.R. Murthy to support arguments about agreements/part payments and the consequences for prosecution under Section 138.
Complainant / 1st Respondent (as presented in the opinion)
- The complainant's counsel relied upon the judgment in G.L. Modi v. Xedd Finance & Investments Pvt. Ltd., where the Court held that a notice that specifies interest at a specific rate in addition to the cheque amount is not necessarily invalid; the drawer could comply by paying the cheque amount alone.
- Implicitly, the complainant maintained that the notice in the present case was not ambiguous because it specifically claimed the balance amount (Rs. 7,74,179/-) and that amount was not available in the petitioner's account on the date of presentation.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court in This Opinion |
|---|---|---|
| Gopa Debi Ozha v. Sujit Paul, 1995 Crl. L.J 3412 (Calcutta High Court) | The notice claiming an amount different from the complaint/cheque amount creates uncertainty and may make the notice insufficient and vague. | The petitioner relied on this case, but the Court noted the lower appellate court declined to rely on it; the present case was distinguished because the notice here specified the balance amount clearly and was not ambiguous. |
| N.C. Nag Pal v. The State, 1979 Crl. L.J 998 (Calcutta High Court) | Interprets the proviso of Section 138 to require that the demand notice refer to the cheque amount; notices claiming amounts other than the cheque amount may be invalid. | The Court acknowledged this authority but held it inapplicable here because the notice in the present case unambiguously claimed a specific balance (the Court emphasised the proviso refers to the cheque amount but found no ambiguity in the notice as given). |
| Raj v. Rajan, 1997 (1) ALT (Crl) 359 (Kerala High Court) | Held that adding unspecified interest to the amount claimed in the notice creates uncertainty and invalidates the notice. | The Court observed this case was cited before the lower appellate court but the lower court correctly declined to rely on it since the present notice was not similarly uncertain. |
| Voruganti Chinna Gopaiah v. Godavari Fertilizers and Chemicals, 1999 (1) ALD 302 (Andhra Pradesh High Court) | Where parties enter into an agreement after issuance of the cheque that modifies the repayment terms (e.g., instalments), that agreement may "occupy the field" and the subsequent rights/actions depend on that agreement rather than the original cheque. | The Court held this case distinguishable: in Chinna Gopaiah there was an express agreement (Ex. D1) altering repayment terms; in the present case there was no such agreement, so Chinna Gopaiah did not aid the petitioner. |
| Padmaja Marketing Enterprises v. V.S.R. Murthy, 1997 (1) ALD (Crl) 814 (A.P.) | Facts similar concerning part payments and presentation, but the specific point before this Court was not finally decided and the matter was remanded for further proceedings. | The Court noted the similarity of facts but that the actual point was not decided in Padmaja; consequently that decision does not help the petitioner on the precise question presented here. |
| G.L. Modi v. Xedd Finance & Investments Pvt. Ltd., 1998 (4) ALD 365 (Andhra Pradesh High Court) | A notice calling upon the drawer to pay the cheque amount along with interest at a specific rate is not invalid merely because it claims interest; if the interest is specified, the drawer could comply by paying the cheque amount alone. | The complainant relied on this judgment; the Court treated it as supportive of the proposition that a notice need not be invalid merely because it claims additional specified interest, distinguishing it from cases where the amount claimed was ambiguous or unspecified. |
| S. Venu v. N.C. Corporation, All India Criminal Reporter 1994 (2) Madras 644 | Referenced for the proposition that a demand for a specific rate of interest does not render a notice invalid. | This authority was relied upon in G.L. Modi (supra), which the complainant placed before the Court; the present Court treated the doctrinal line as distinguishing specified-amount claims from ambiguous demands. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court proceeded by examining the precedents relied upon by the revision petitioner and the factual distinctions between those precedents and the present case.
First, the Court observed that the Calcutta and Kerala High Court decisions relied upon by the petitioner (Gopa Debi Ozha; N.C. Nag Pal; Raj v. Rajan) invalidated notices where there was ambiguity or an unexplained/unspecified increase in the amount claimed in the notice as compared to the cheque amount. Those cases turned on the uncertainty created by the notice as to what amount was demanded.
The Court then contrasted those cases with the present facts: here, although Ex. P.8 was for Rs. 10,76,000/-, the complainant's notice specifically claimed the balance amount of Rs. 7,74,179/-. The Court found no ambiguity in respect of the "said amount of money" demanded in the notice and held that the notice clearly referred to the balance due. The Court emphasised that the proviso to Section 138 requires a demand for payment of the said amount of money by notice in writing, and in this case the balance amount was specified.
The Court further noted the procedural steps taken to verify the account balance: an application under Section 311 Cr.P.C. was filed to summon the bank to ascertain whether the petitioner had the said amount on the date of presentation; the petitioner filed a memo admitting that he had less than Rs. 7,74,179/- in his account on that date (the memo was later withdrawn by the complainant). Given these facts, the Court concluded that at least the balance amount claimed in the notice was not available in the drawer's account on presentation of the cheque.
The Court also addressed other precedents relied upon by the petitioner. Voruganti Chinna Gopaiah was distinguished because that case involved an express agreement (Ex. D1) entered into after the cheque was issued which altered the parties' obligations; no such agreement existed here. Padmaja Marketing Enterprises was noted as having similar facts but not deciding the precise point now before the Court.
On the basis of these factual findings and the distinguishing of cited precedents, the Court concluded that the offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was made out against the petitioner/accused: the specified balance amount claimed in the notice was not present in the bank account on the date of presentation of the cheque.
However, while upholding liability, the Court addressed sentencing: because the accused is a company, the Court held that there is no question of imprisoning the company and therefore set aside the substantive sentence of imprisonment imposed by the lower court. The Court also considered the quantum of fine imposed and, finding it excessive in the circumstances, reduced the fine to Rs. 10,000/-.
Holding and Implications
The Court reached the following conclusions and orders:
Holding: The Court confirmed that an offence under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act was made out against the petitioner/accused because the balance specifically claimed in the demand notice (Rs. 7,74,179/-) was not available in the account on the date of presentation of the cheque. Both lower courts were held to be right in finding liability under Section 138.
The Court modified the sentence: because the accused is a company, the substantive sentence of imprisonment imposed by the lower court was set aside. The Court further reduced the fine imposed by the lower court to Rs. 10,000/- (Rupees Ten Thousand only).
The Criminal Revision Case was disposed of with the above modification.
Implications
- Direct effect on the parties: Conviction under Section 138 is sustained; imprisonment imposed earlier is set aside because the accused is a company; the monetary penalty is reduced to Rs. 10,000/-.
- Broader precedent: The Court distinguished earlier authorities that invalidated notices on grounds of ambiguity, and held that a notice demanding a clearly specified balance (after part payments) is not per se invalid. The opinion does not purport to lay down a new general rule beyond the factual distinctions it makes; the decision is applied to the facts of this case.
This summary is prepared exclusively from the content of the provided opinion. No information has been added or inferred beyond the text of the opinion supplied.
1. This Revision is filed against the judgment and sentence passed in Crl. A. No. 91/98 on the file of VI Additional Metropolitan Sessions Judge, Hyderabad.
2. The case arises under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act. Admittedly the petitioner/accused approached the complainant/1st respondent for Bill Discounting facility by entering into agreement in the month of July 1995. The petitioner availed the Bill Discounting facility amounting to Rs. 10,76,426.25 ps. The petitioner signed the Hundi and submitted invoices along with his covering letter. The petitioner had to repay the Bill discounting amount within 90 days from the period of borrowal. The due date was 28-10-1995. However, he did not repay the amount. The petitioner issued Ex. P. 8, which is the cheque in his case, dated 28-10-1995 for an amount of Rs. 10,76,000/-. Subsequent to the issuance of the cheque, an amount of Rs. 2,00,000/- was paid in the month of November 1995. Again in the month of February 1996 the petitioner paid Rs. 50,000/-. On 23-2-1996, a further amount of Rs. 1821/- was paid. In all, the petitioner paid Rs. 3,01,821/-. PW 1 who is authorised to file the complaint stated that the cheque issued by the petitioner was presented on 18-3-1996. But it was returned for insufficient funds. The complainant is used legal notice Ex. P. 10 dated 30-3-1996. The petitioner gave reply Ex. P. 11, dated 14-4-1996 denying the transaction. Thereafter, the complainant/1st respondent wrote letters to the petitioner to pay the amount. Exs. P. 6 and P. 7 are the office copies of the said letters. They demanded an amount of Rs. 8,76,000/-, which was the balance as on that day. No reply was given to these letters by the petitioner. Subsequently, some amount also was paid by the petitioner. There is no dispute that an amount of Rs. 3,50,000/- was paid and a balance of Rs. 7,74,179/- was due from the petitioner/accused. The liability of this amount is not seriously disputed in this revision. The lower appellate Court discussed about these facts in detail. Mr. T. Bali Reddy, the learned senior counsel appearing for the revision petitioner/accused submitted that the cheque Ex. P. 8, was for an amount of Rs. 10,76,000/-. Admittedly, the petitioner has paid some amounts. The cheque was presented on 18-3-1996 for the entire amount. Admittedly, the petitioner has paid Rs. 3,50,000/- already. Therefore, Ex. P. 8 cheque, to this extent, is invalid. The original cheque issued for Rs. 10,76,000/- cannot be presented to realise the balance of Rs. 7,74,179/- which is admittedly due on the date of presentation of the cheque. Therefore, if the cheque bounced, no liability can be fastened to the petitioner/accused.
3. In support of his contention a strong reliance is placed by the learned counsel for the petitioner on the judgment of Calcutta High Court in Gopa Debi Ozha v. Sujit Paul, 1995 Crl. L.J 3412. In that case, in the notice an amount of Rs. 6,50,000/- was claimed. However, the complaint was made for a sum of Rs. 5,79,000/-. In those circumstances, the learned Judge held that the difference will create difficulty to the drawee to know how much amount he has to pay or she has to pay, as the case may be, and that makes the notice insufficient and vague and the notice will become illegal.
4. For the same purpose, he also relied upon another judgment of Calcutta High Court in N.C Nag Pal v. The State, 1979 Crl. L.J 998. In that case, it was observed that nothing was indicated in the notice as to how the amount amounted to Rs. 6,50,000/-. In those circumstances, the Court held:
“28. So the wording in clause (b) to the proviso of Section 138 “a demand for payment of the said amount of money by giving notice, in writing, to the drawer of the cheque”, refers to the cheque amount and not any other amount either smaller of higher than the amount mentioned in the cheque.”
5. In the case N.C Nag Pal v. The State, (supra) and in Raj v. Rajan, 1997 (1) ALT (Crl) 359, of Kerala High Court, unspecified interest was added to the cheque amount and notice was issued. In those circumstances, the notice was held to be illegal and consequently the High Court upheld the acquittal. As a matter of fact, these two judgments were cited before the lower appellate Court in the case on hand. The lower appellate court rightly held that the notices in those cases were held illegal because of uncertainty and unexplained increase in the amount demanded in the notices, adding unspecified interest in the case Raj v. Rajan, (supra). The lower appellate Court rightly declined to rely upon those Judgments. The reasons given are quite cogent.
6. The learned senior counsel Mr. T. Bali Reddy also relied upon the judgment of this Court in Voruganti Chinna Gopaiah v. Godavari Fertilizers and Chemicals, 1999 (1) ALD 302. In that case, the accused fell in arrears to the tune of Rs. 10,99,899.90. The accused gave cheque for the said amount on 5-10-1991. The cheque was presented on the same day and it was returned by the State Bank of Hyderabad with the endorsement “funds insufficient”. The complainant gave a Phonogram to A1 asking him to arrange a draft for the same. A letter was also written by the complainant. It was also acknowledged on 1-11-1991. Inspite of that, the amount was not arranged. Subsequently, an agreement (Ex. D1) was entered into. According to that agreement, the complainant agreed to receive the amount in three instalments. PW 1 categorically admitted that the accused need not pay the amount in lumpsum and that they have no right to proceed against the accused. In the cross-examination he admitted the execution of Ex. D1. The Head Office has stated that as per the terms under taken by the accused, the accused were to pay the entire amount in four instalments and that a sum of Rs. 2,71,029.12 is payable on or before 31-12-1991 towards the first instalment. Therefore the parties had entered into agreement (Ex. D1) subsequent to the issuance of the cheque. In those circumstances this Court held that as on the date of presentation of the cheque originally given, Ex. D.1 was occupying the field and the parties are bound by the agreement. The subsequent action shall depend upon the terms of the agreement. It was also held that when the complaint was given there was no cause of action for the complainant to rely upon Ex. P. 1 cheque.
7. The Chinna Gopaiah case (supra) is quite distinguishable on facts. In the case on hand there is no such agreement like Ex. D.1 After issuance of the cheque, an amount of Rs. 3,50,000/- was paid on various dates. That does not mean that the complainant agreed to receive the amount in instalments. The cause of action does not shift from the issuance of cheque Ex. P. 8 in this case. That being the case, no reliance can be placed on the above judgment.
8. Another judgment of this Court in Padmaja Marketing Enterprises v. V.S.R Murthy, 1997 (1) ALD (Crl). 814 (AP), is brought to my notice, the facts of which are similar. But the actual point was not decided. Therefore the matter was remanded to the lower Court setting aside the acquittal recorded by the Magistrate. In that case, the amount due on a Katha was Rs. 44,117/-. The accused issued Cheque for Rs. 10,000/- on 6-4-1991. The accused paid an amount of Rs. 5,500/- to the representative of the complainant on 16-4-1991 by way of a Demand Draft. The cheque was actually presented for encashment and the same was returned on 14-8-1991 with an endorsement “insufficiency of funds”. Thereafter, a legal notice was issued. No reply was given by the accused. Then the complaint was lodged. Subsequently, another sum of Rs. 5,000/- was given in cash on 21-9-1991. The second payment was after filing of the complaint. The accused pleaded discharge of the debt. The trial Court accepted the plea and recorded acquittal. This finding was reversed and the matter was remanded. The learned Judge took into consideration the total amount of Rs. 44,117/- as due on 31-3-1991. The learned Judge also took into consideration that even after adjusting the two amounts i.e Rs. 5,500/- and Rs. 5,000/-, still the accused was liable to pay nearly an amount of Rs. 34,000/-. It was held that as long there is legally enforceable liability either on the date of issuance of cheque or on the date of encashment of cheque, the complainant is entitled to encash the cheque issued by the accused. The cheque was given admittedly for an amount of Rs. 10,000/-. The dishonour of that cheque was in question. The balance of enforceable debt i.e, Rs. 44,117/- (-) Rs. 10,000/- = Rs. 34,117/-, is not the subject matter of the complaint. The Court is concerned whether the cheque issued for Rs. 10,000/- was arranged for or not.
9. There is no decision on the point that arises in the case on hand. The question that to be answered in this case is whether the cheque issued for Rs. 10,76,000/- could be presented even after receiving part of the amount due i.e Rs. 3,50,000/- and if any offence is committed if that original cheque bounced for lack of sufficient funds. There is no answer to this question in the Judgment referred (5) above. Therefore, that decision does not come to the aid of the petitioner/accused.
10. The learned counsel for the complainant relied upon the Judgment of this Court in G.L Modi v. Xedd Finance & Investments Pvt. Ltd., 1998 (4) ALD 365. In that case, notice was issued calling upon the accused to pay the cheque amount along with interest at the rate of 24% per annum. The learned Judge held that the notice cannot be said to be bad on the ground that the interest is also claimed in the complaint. In that case, the claim was specific rate of interest. There was no ambiguity in respect of the amount. This prompted the learned Judge to hold “…… the amount claimed towards interest would be superfluous one and the drawer of the cheque could have complied with the demand for the cheque amount alone by paying the same and refusing to pay the amount towards interest claimed in the notice. For this proposition the learned Judge relied upon the Judgment of Madras High Court in S. Venu v. N.C Corporation, All India Criminal Reporter 1994 (2) Madras 644.
11. I have already held that the notices issued in the cases cited (1), (2) and (3) supra of Calcutta High Court and Kerala High Court, were ambiguous with respect to the amount claimed. In those circumstances the Courts held that the notices were not valid. In the case on hand it is true that Ex. P. 8 cheque was for an amount of Rs. 10,76,000/-. Admittedly, Rs. 3,50,000/- was paid subsequently. In the notice, the balance amount of Rs. 7,74,179/- only was claimed. There is no ambiguity in respect of the “said amount of money”. The cheque was valid for an amount of Rs. 7,74,179/-. Atleast this amount was not in the account of the petitioner/accused in the Bank. The complainant filed application under Section 311 Cr. P.C to issue summons to the Banker to know whether the petitioner/accused was having any amount in his account in the Bank. The petitioner/accused filed a Memo stating that he was having less than Rs. 7,74,179/- to the credit of his account on the date of presentation of the cheque. The Memo was withdrawn by the complainant. This being the case, it cannot be said that no offence is made out against the petitioner/accused. It would have been another case, if atleast the petitioner/accused had an amount of Rs. 7,74,179/- to the credit of his account on the date of presentation of the cheque. It is not the case admittedly. Therefore, certainly the petitioner/accused is guilty of the offence punishable under Section 138 of Negotiable Instruments Act. Both the Courts below rightly held so. The accused is a Company. There is no question of convicting the Company. Therefore the substantive sentence of imprisonment is set aside. Considering the circumstances of the case, the fine imposed is also very heavy. In these circumstances, I reduce the fine amount to Rs. 10,000/- (Rs. Ten thousand only).
12. With the above modification, the Criminal Revision Case is disposed of.
Alert