- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Hassan Ali Khan v. The Regional Passport Officer, Passport Office, Hyderabad .
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitioner filed a writ petition seeking a writ of Mandamus to declare the respondent's retention of his passport illegal, arbitrary, and violative of fundamental rights under Articles 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. The petitioner, involved in multiple criminal cases and granted bail on condition of surrendering his passport, initially surrendered the passport pursuant to a Magistrate's order. Subsequently, this Court modified that order directing the release of the passport upon deposit of a sum in the lower Court and subject to conditions regarding travel permissions.
The petitioner later submitted the passport again to the respondent for visa endorsement, but the respondent retained it without decision or communication. The petitioner challenged this retention as illegal and violative of fundamental rights. The respondent countered that the passport was impounded under Section 10(3)(e) of the Passport Act, 1967, based on requests from police and a bank due to the petitioner’s involvement in criminal cases, and alleged the petitioner had not sought requisite permissions to travel. The respondent also noted procedural lapses but maintained the impounding was valid. The Court found the impounding circular issued without notice or opportunity to the petitioner, violating principles of natural justice and the Passport Act. The writ petition was allowed, setting aside the impounding circular and directing the respondent to reconsider the passport’s release after affording the petitioner a reasonable opportunity to be heard.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the respondent’s retention and impounding of the petitioner’s passport without notice or opportunity to be heard was legal and in accordance with the Passport Act, 1967.
- Whether the petitioner’s fundamental rights under Articles 14, 19(1)(a), and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India were violated by the impounding and retention of the passport.
- The procedural requirements and jurisdiction of the respondent in impounding a passport under the Passport Act, 1967.
- The legality and validity of the impounding circular issued by the respondent without affording the petitioner an opportunity to explain.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioner’s Arguments
- The retention of the passport by the respondent is illegal, arbitrary, and violates fundamental rights under Articles 14, 19(1)(a), and 19(1)(g).
- The petitioner complied with Court orders by surrendering the passport and depositing the required sum for its release.
- The respondent failed to take any decision or communicate regarding the passport after receiving it for visa endorsement.
- The impounding circular was issued without notice or an opportunity to be heard, violating principles of natural justice.
- The impounding was based on outdated letters from police and a bank, and the petitioner was not given a chance to respond.
- The petitioner challenged the impounding action as beyond the respondent’s jurisdiction and inconsistent with this Court’s prior directions.
Respondent’s Arguments
- The passport was impounded under Section 10(3)(e) of the Passport Act, 1967, due to the petitioner’s involvement in multiple criminal cases.
- The impounding was requested by the Police and the State Bank of India due to habitual criminal involvement.
- The petitioner did not obtain permission from the Magistrate to leave the country, nor made a formal request for passport release after the Court’s order.
- No directions were received from this Court or the Magistrate regarding passport release after impounding.
- The petitioner is entitled to appeal against the impounding before the appellate authority.
- There was a procedural lapse in recording the decision to impound, but the impounding circular dated 14-5-1993 conclusively established the impounding.
Table of Precedents Cited
No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the procedural history and found that the respondent impounded the passport by issuing a circular without recording a formal decision or affording the petitioner any notice or opportunity to be heard. The Court emphasized that under the Passport Act, 1967, and settled legal principles, a passport holder must be given a reasonable opportunity to explain before impounding. The respondent's reliance solely on police and bank requests without following due process was held to be illegal and arbitrary. The impounding circular dated 14-5-1993 was declared void for non-compliance with statutory and natural justice requirements. The Court directed the respondent to reconsider the petitioner's request for passport return after affording him a fair hearing and to complete the process within three months, ensuring adherence to legal norms.
Holding and Implications
The writ petition was allowed, setting aside the respondent’s impounding of the passport through the circular dated 14-5-1993.
The respondent is directed to reconsider the petitioner’s request for the return of the passport in accordance with law, after providing a reasonable opportunity of hearing. This process must be completed within three months from the date of the order. Costs were awarded to the petitioner in the sum of Rs. 500/-.
The decision directly affects the parties by restoring procedural fairness in passport impounding matters but does not establish any new legal precedent beyond enforcing statutory and natural justice requirements under the Passport Act, 1967.
1. The petitioner in the instant writ petition prays for issuance of an appropriate writ particularly one in the nature of writ of Mandamus declaring the action of the respondent in retaining the passport of the petitioner as illegal, arbitrary and violative of fundamental rights guaranteed by Article 19(1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India. The petitioner also prays for issuance of a consequential direction to the respondent to release the passport bearing No. 31575/86 after renewing the same.
2. The petitioner in this case, admittedly, is involved in more than one criminal case. Bail is stated to have been granted to him. However, in Cr. No. 67/1992 the learned XXI Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad passed an order granting bail to the petitioner on 1-8-1992 on condition of the petitioner executing a personal bond for a sum of Rs. 10,000/- with two sureties for a like sum each on condition that the petitioner shall appear before the Police, C.C.S. to assist in completing the investigation and the petitioner should surrender his passport before the Court. The passport is surrendered by the petitioner pursuant to the said order passed by the Court. However, the said order passed by the learned Magistrate is modified by this Court by an order D/- 31-3-1995 in Crl. Petition No. 1199/95 directing the release of the passport in favour of the petitioner on condition of the petitioner depositing a sum of Rs. 25.000/- in the lower Court. This Court further directed that in case the petitioner wants to leave India he has to take permission of the learned Magistrate and also bring to the notice of the Passport authority that the prosecution is pending against him. On depositing the amount, the passport is already released to the petilioner.
3. The petitioner once again submitted the passport to the respondent for adding visa leaves to the passport and the same is received by the respondents on 17-4-1995. The respondent having received the passport did not release the same in favour of the petitioner. Hence this writ petition.
The complaint in the instant writ petition is that the respondent herein having received the passport did not take any decision in the matter and return the same. No order is communicated to the petitioner. The petitioner placed reliance upon the order passed by this Court in Crl. Petition No. 1199/95 D/- 28-7-1995 directing the passport to be released in favour of the petitioner. It is slated that the respondent has no jurisdiction whatsoever to retain the passport. On account of the impugned action of the respondent, the petitioner is not in a position to leave the Country, even if the Court giants permission to leave the Country. The action of the respondent, according to the petitioner, is not only illegal and arbitrary but violative of the fundamental rights guaranteed by Articles 14. 19 (1)(a) and 19(1)(g) of the Constitution of India.
4. In the counter-affidavit, it is stated that the respondent has passed orders impounding his passport under Section 10(3)(e) of the Passport Act, 1967 as the petitioner is facing number of criminal cases relating to cheating in a Court of law. The respondent is alleged to have received request from not only the Police but also from the State Bank of India to impound the passport of the petitioner, as he is habitually involving in criminal cases. It is stated that the petitioner did not obtain any order from the learned Magistrate permitting him to leave the Country. The petitioner, according to the respondent did not make any request for release of the passport setting out the details as to what happened pursuant to the order passed in Crl. Petition No. 1199/1995. It is specifically stated that the respondent has not received any direction whatsoever either from this Court in the said Criminal petition or from the Metropolitan Magistrate Court. It is stated that the petitioner is entitled to prefer an appeal before the appellate authority in case he is aggrieved by the action taken by the respondent in impounding the passport.
5. The petitioner filed an additional affidavit stating that he has learnt for the first time that the order impounding the passpolrt from what is stated in the counter-affidavit. No notice has been issued to the petitioner before passing an order of impounding. The order is stated to have been passed basing on the letter written by the Additional Director General and Commissioner of Police, Hyderabad in the year 1992 and the letter of the State Bank of India D/- 15-2-1990, It is also slated that the order passed by this Court in Crl. Petition No. 1199/1995 D/- 28-7-1995 was communicated to the respondent-Passport Officer. The fact that he is not a party to the case does not absolve him of his responsibility in complying and implementing with the order passed by this Court is the submission. The petitioner also filed an application to amend the prayer and raise additional grounds challenging the impugned action of impounding the passport by the respondent.
6. In the additional counter-affidavit, it is staled that it was decided to impound the passport of the petitioner and consequently an impounding circular was also issued on 14-5-1993 which conclusively establishes the fact of impounding of the passport. It is however, accepted and conceded about procedural lapse on the part of the respondent and the decision was not recorded which is the usual practice.
7. Pursuant to the directions of the Court, the records are produced by the respondent and the record also docs not disclose thai any decision as such was recorded in the file. It is rather difficult to appreciate as to how the respondent could have dealt with the matter in such a casual fashion. The record also does not disclose any proceeding except the requesi made by the Police Department to impound the passport of the petitioner. The passport appears to have impounded even while the passport was in the custody of the Court. It is settled law that the respondent herein could not have taken steps for impounding the passport without issuing notice to the petitioner and affording him an opportunity to submit his explanation. Opportunity of hearing is required to be given to a passport holder before the decision to impound the passport is taken. The passport holder is entitled for a reasonable opportunity of being heard. The respondent-Passport Officer would not have adopted the present method of straightway issuing a circular impounding the passport. The action is totally illegal and arbitrary. The action of impounding the passport could not have been taken by the respondent herein on the basis of some information furnished by the Police alone. The petitioner should have been put on notice as to why the passport should not be impounded in exercise of the power conferred upon the Passport Officer under the provisions of the Passport Act, 1967. No such procedure is followed. The Circular Dt. 14-5-1993 issued declaring as if the petitioner's passport is impounded is to be declared as non est in law.
8. Evidently the respondent has not chosen to consider the request of the petitioner for the return of the passport on the ground that the same had already been impounded through the Circular Dl. 14-5-1993. The said action also cannot be countenanced. The method and procedure adopted by the respondent in dealing with the case of the petitioner is totally illegal and arbitrary. The action of the respondent is required to be fair and reasonable and free from arbitrariness. Nothing prevented the respondent from issuing appropriate notice to the petitioner based upon the information available with him and directing him to show-cause as to why appropriate action should not be taken against him. If no such procedure is adopted by the respondent, the action is not only ultra vires the provisions of the Passport Act, 1967 but also violative of principles of natural justice. However, no direction as prayed for by the petitioner to straightway issued and return the passport can be granted, the matter is required to be reconsidered by the respondent. It is open to the respondent to issue an appropriate notice to the petitioner herein giving him an opportunity of explanation and then decide as to whether his passport could be returned by including the visa. It is also open to the respondent to issue notice to the petitioner if there is any need for impounding the passport of the petitioner. A detailed enquiry is required to be made by the respondent and after affording reasonable opportunity to the petitioner and then only decide the matter in accordance withlaw.
9. The writ petition is accordingly allowed setting aside the action of the respondent in impounding the passport through the Circular D/- 14-5-1993.
The respondent is directed to consider the request of the petitioner for return of the passport in accordance with law. The whole process in this regard shall be completed within a period of three months from the date of receipt of a copy of this order.
10. The writ petition is accordingly allowed with costs quantified at Rs. 500/- (Rupees five hundred).
Alert