Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

State Of A.P v. Food Corporation Of India, Hyd.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Jun 24, 1996
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Summary of Opinion — Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri, J.

Factual and Procedural Background

The State is the petitioner in this T.R.C., challenging an order of the Tribunal in T.A. 1107/79 dated 17 December 1986. The dispute concerns the assessment year 1972–1973 and arises under the Central Sales Tax Act (the Act). The principal legal question presented is whether the Food Corporation of India (FCI), a Central Government entity, qualifies as a "dealer" within the meaning of Section 2(b) of the Act as it stood prior to amendment by Act 103 of 1976.

The assessment order quoted the pre-amendment definition of "dealer" as: "'dealer' means any person who carries on the business of selling goods and includes a Government which carries on such business." A Division Bench judgment of this Court in T.R.C. Nos. 28 of 1976 and batch (dated 3 December 1976) had held that the FCI was an agent of the Central Government selling goods on its behalf and was therefore a "dealer" in that sense, but that the question of "carrying on" business remained for determination.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the Food Corporation of India (FCI), being an agency of the Central Government, is a "dealer" within the meaning of Section 2(b) of the Central Sales Tax Act (as it stood before amendment by Act 103 of 1976).

Arguments of the Parties

The opinion does not contain a detailed account of the parties' legal arguments.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
T.R.C. Nos. 28 of 1976 and batch (Division Bench judgment dated 3 December 1976) Held that FCI was an agent of the Central Government selling goods on its behalf and therefore would be a "dealer" in that agency sense; but left open the separate question whether there was "carrying on" of business. The Court acknowledged that FCI could be an agent selling on behalf of the Central Government (as per this judgment) but emphasized that, for the purposes of the statutory definition then in force, the separate requirement of "carrying on" business remained to be assessed (including inquiry into profit motive).
Joint Director of Food v. State of A.P., (1976) 38 STC 330 (Supreme Court) Established that the systematic activity of buying and selling food-grains and fertilizers by the State amounts to trade or business, but an assessee becomes a "dealer" under the Central Sales Tax Act only if there is a profit motive in the sales. The Court relied on this authority to affirm that although the activity was trade or business in character, the absence of a profit motive in the FCI's distributions meant the FCI did not satisfy the statutory threshold to be a "dealer" for exigibility of tax for the relevant period.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded by identifying the operative statutory definition of "dealer" as it existed prior to the 1976 amendment: inclusion of any person who "carries on the business of selling goods" and including a Government which carries on such business. The reasoning followed these steps:

  1. The Court acknowledged the earlier Division Bench conclusion that FCI functioned as an agent of the Central Government selling goods on its behalf, which, standing alone, would support classification as a "dealer."
  2. However, the Court emphasized that the statutory phrase required not only selling but "carrying on" the business of selling goods; under the pre-amendment law, a profit motive was a necessary ingredient of "business."
  3. The factual finding in the present case was that FCI was distributing fertilizers according to allotments made by the Agriculture Department to States or their nominees and that there was no profit motive in those distributions.
  4. Relying on the Supreme Court's ruling in Joint Director of Food v. State of A.P., which confirmed that state activity in buying and selling could be trade or business but that "dealer" status under the Central Sales Tax Act required profit motive, the Court applied that principle to the present facts.
  5. Given the absence of profit motive in the FCI's distributions during the relevant period, the Court concluded that FCI did not meet the statutory requirements to be a "dealer" for purposes of exigibility of tax under the Act for the assessment year in question.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The T.R.C. is DISMISSED.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: For the assessment year 1972–1973 and for the purposes of exigibility of tax under the Central Sales Tax Act as it then stood, the Food Corporation of India was not a "dealer" because there was no profit motive in its distributions; accordingly the challenge to the Tribunal's order is dismissed.
  • No costs were awarded by the Court.
  • The opinion does not purport to create a new legal principle beyond applying the existing authority (including the Supreme Court decision cited) to the facts; no broader implications or novel precedent are articulated in the text.

This summary is confined strictly to the information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Syed Shah Mohammed Quadri, J.:— The State is the petitioner in this T.R.C It challenges the validity of the order of the Tribunal in T.A 1107/79 dated December 17, 1986. The dispute relates to the assessment year 1972-1973 and it arose under the Central Sales Tax Act (for short ‘the Act’). The short question that arises for consideration in this case, is whether the Food Corporation of India (for short FCI), Central Government, is ‘dealer’ within the meaning and expression in Section 2(b) of the Act. In the assessment order, the definition of the ‘dealer’ as it stood before the amendment of Section 2(b) of the Act by Act 103 of 1976, was as follows:

“‘dealer’ means any person who carries on the business of selling goods and includes a Government which carries on such business.”

2. It is concluded by a Division Bench Judgment of this Court in T.R.C Nos. 28 of 1976 and batch dated December 3rd, 1976 that the F.C.I is an agent of the Central Government selling the goods on behalf of it and is, therefore, a ‘dealer’, but that, however, would not conclude the issue because for purposes of the definition carrying on is also necessary business.

3. As it stood before the amendment of Section 2(b) by Act 103 of 1976, profit motive was a necessary ingredient of ‘business’ under the Central Sales Tax Act. In the instant case, a finding is recorded to the effect that the F.C.I was distributing the fertilizers as per allotment made by the Agriculture Department to the States or their nominees and that there was no profit motive. In view of those findings it cannot but be held that it was not a ‘dealer’ during the relevant period for purposes of exigibility of tax under the Act. In Joint Director of Food v. State of A.P (1976) 38 STC 330) while confirming the judgment of this Court, the Supreme Court laid down that the systematic activity of buying food-grains and fertilizers and selling them by the State, although in fulfilment of a beneficent national policy was nevertheless trade or business; but the assessee would become a ‘dealer’ under the Central Sales Tax Act only if there was a profit motive in the sales effected by the assessee to the Andhra Pradesh State.

4. For the above reasons, the T.R.C is liable to be dismissed and accordingly it is dismissed.

5. No costs.