Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Khairullah And Anr. v. Anita And Ors.

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Dec 24, 1993
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

This is an appeal by the appellants (who were respondent Nos. 1 and 2 in the Tribunal — the driver and owner of the lorry) challenging the judgment dated 30.1.1989 in O.P. No. 571 of 1987 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Rangareddy District at Saroornagar. On 26.8.1987 at about 2.45 p.m. the deceased, riding a scooter from Patancheru to Kukatpalli, met with an accident at Madinaguda Darga when lorry No. ABT 8718 (proceeding from Hyderabad, driven by the 1st respondent) allegedly knocked him down. The deceased sustained multiple injuries, was treated at Hyderabad Nursing Home, and died on 18.9.1987.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the lorry driver was guilty of rash and negligent driving causing the fatal accident.
  2. Whether the absence of a post-mortem examination undermines the claimants' entitlement to compensation for death.
  3. Whether the claimant (the deceased's wife) is entitled to compensation where it was contended she had remarried.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants' Arguments

  • The driver claimed there was rain at the time of the accident and the deceased, while attempting to wear a waterproof coat holding the handle with one hand, lost control and collided with the lorry.
  • Counsel for the appellants contended no autopsy was conducted and therefore cause of death was not satisfactorily established.
  • It was contended that the first petitioner (the deceased's wife) had remarried and therefore was not entitled to compensation.

Claimants' Arguments

  • P.W.2 (Head Constable Narayana Singh) gave eyewitness evidence that there was no rain, that the lorry was coming at good speed down the middle of the road and knocked down the scooter.
  • Documentary evidence (Exhs. A-1 to A-10) including the F.I.R. and medical discharge ticket establish the sequence of events, absence of mechanical defect, injuries sustained and cause of death.

Table of Precedents Cited

No precedents were cited in the provided opinion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court accepted the Tribunal's finding that P.W.2's eyewitness testimony was credible, noting its detailed and graphic nature. The F.I.R. (Exh. A-1), lodged on PW2's report, corroborated his evidence. The Motor Vehicles Inspector's report (Exh. A-3) indicated the lorry had no mechanical defects. The Hyderabad Nursing Home in-patient discharge ticket (Exh. A-10) recorded that the deceased died of cardio-respiratory failure secondary to head injury sustained in the accident. The court addressed the appellants' contention regarding absence of post-mortem: it held this was not fatal to the claim because cause of death was established by documentary evidence (Exh. A-10) and PW2's evidence, and this was not a case under Section 302, Indian Penal Code requiring post-mortem for determining criminal culpability. Regarding the remarriage contention, the court noted the first petitioner had not remarried at the time of her testimony and of the award; in any event the court held remarriage was not a valid ground to deny compensation. Having reviewed the oral and documentary evidence, the court found no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's findings, including the quantum awarded.

Holding and Implications

DISMISSED. The Civil Miscellaneous Appeal was dismissed and the Tribunal's award of Rs. 2,14,000 was upheld. No costs were awarded.

Implications: The direct effect is that the Tribunal's findings on negligence, causation and quantum stand affirmed; the opinion does not set out any new legal precedent beyond upholding those findings.

Show all summary ...

1. This is an appeal preferred by the appellants, who were respondent Nos. 1 and 2 (driver and owner of the lorry respectively) challenging the judgment dated 30.1.1989 in O.P. No. 571 of 1987 on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Rangareddy District at Saroornagar.

2. On 26.8.1987 at about 2.45 p.m. while the deceased was returning on his scooter from Patancheru to Kukatpalli and had reached Madinaguda Darga he met with an accident on account of the lorry No. ABT 8718 proceeding from Hyderabad in the opposite direction which was driven by the 1st respondent driver in a rash and negligent manner. The lorry dashed against the scooter of the deceased and he received multiple injuries and while he was taking medical treatment in Hyderabad Nursing Home, he succumbed to the injuries on 18.9.1987.

3. The petitioners-claimants have examined PW 2, Narayana Singh, the Head Constable attached to Lingampalli P.S. who is stated to be a direct witness to the accident. According to him, on the date of accident at about 2.45 p.m. the accident took place. He stated that he was returning from Lingampalli on his cycle, that the scooter came from behind him and opposite to them from Hyderabad the offending lorry came at good speed. According to him, the lorry was coming on the middle of the road and came towards the scooterist and knocked him down. He deposed that there was no rain or drizzle at that time. According to the driver, at the time of the accident there was rain and the deceased who was driving the scooter tried to wear waterproof coat holding the handle of the scooter in one hand and in that process he lost control over the scooter and due to confusion came and dashed against the lorry. When PW 2 has stated that there was no rain at the time of accident, the taking out of the raincoat by the deceased does not arise and this is invented to throw the blame on the deceased. The Tribunal, who got the advantage of observing the demeanour of the witness, observed that the evidence of PW 2 is really picturesque and graphic in all its meticulous details. In addition to the oral evidence of PW 1, Exhs. A-1 to A-10 documents are also marked. Exh. A-1 is the certified copy of the F.I.R. which was registered on the basis of the report given by PW 2. The contents of Exh. A-1 are corroborated by the evidence of PW 2. Exh. A-3, the report given by the Motor Vehicles Inspector, also shows that the accident was not caused due to any mechanical defects of the lorry. Exh. A-10 is the in-patient discharge ticket of Hyderabad Nursing Home which shows that suddenly due to cardio-respiratory failure the deceased died which is a consequence of head injury.

4. It is vehemently contended by Mr. P. Rama Rao, learned counsel appearing for the appellants, that no autopsy was conducted over the dead body of the deceased to arrive at the cause of death. It may be remembered that the deceased died during the course of medical treatment after about 25 days after the accident and he succumbed to the injuries. As already stated, Exh. A-10, the in-patient discharge ticket of the Hyderabad Nursing Home, where the deceased was undergoing treatment at the time of his death, shows that due to cardio-respiratory failure the deceased had died which is a consequence and secondary to head injury. The head injury was sustained by the deceased at the time of the accident. It is not a case under Section 302, Indian Penal Code, wherein the conducting of post-mortem examination to know the cause of death may be necessary. In this case, the cause of death is known from the documentary evidence, especially Exh. A-10 and also from the evidence of PW 2. The evidence of PW 2 is convincing. In the light of both oral and documentary evidence available in this case, the failure to conduct post-mortem examination over the dead body of the deceased cannot be taken as a circumstance against the claimants, who are claiming compensation for the death of the deceased.

5. PW 1, who is the wife of the deceased, stated about the status of the deceased. She has filed the partnership deed, Exh. A-5. Exh. A-8, school leaving certificate, is also filed which gives the date of birth of the deceased as 26.6.1962 which means that the deceased died in his 25th year. As regards the compensation also, Exh. A-5, the partnership deed, shows that the deceased entered into partnership to carry on timber business. Exh. A-6 is the income-tax statements. The Tribunal has considered the oral and documentary evidence and ultimately fixed the compensation at Rs. 2,14,000/-. It is contended that the 1st petitioner has remarried and consequently she is not entitled to any compensation. On the date when she gave evidence and when the award was passed, she did not remarry. Even if there is remarriage it cannot be taken as a ground to refuse compensation to her. She is only a widow and no person of equal status of the deceased will come forward to marry a widow. The Tribunal has considered all the aspects of the matter in right perspective and granted the compensation and I do not see any reason to interfere with the same.

The C.M.A. is, therefore, dismissed. No costs.