- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Dynamic Forgings India Limited, Bombay - 400002 v. Nagarjuna Investment Trusts Ltd.
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition was filed under Section 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure seeking quashment of C.C. No. 367 of 1991 pending before the V Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad. The undisputed factual matrix in the opinion is as follows:
- The first petitioner is a company and the second petitioner is its Director.
- On March 30, 1991 the first petitioner issued a cheque for Rs. 5,00,000 drawn on Karnataka Bank, Bombay, pursuant to a hire-purchase arrangement.
- The cheque was first presented for collection at Hyderabad on April 1, 1991 and on April 8, 1991 it was returned with the endorsement "funds expected, present again".
- The cheque was represented in May 1991 and on May 16, 1991 it was again returned with the endorsement "referred to drawer".
- After issuance of the statutory notice, the first respondent filed C.C. No. 367/91 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. The petitioners challenged that complaint by way of the present Section 482 petition.
- The petitioners admitted financial difficulty in contemporaneous communications: a telex dated May 13, 1991 ("We could not honour due to financial constraint"), a letter dated May 26, 1991 (explaining financial constraints and intention to clear arrears), and a letter dated July 10, 1991 describing a financial crisis.
The petition raises two principal procedural contentions: alleged limitation problems as regards prosecution under Sections 138 (read with Section 142) of the Negotiable Instruments Act and a challenge to the jurisdiction of the Metropolitan Magistrate at Hyderabad.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the criminal complaint C.C. No. 367/91 under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act should be quashed under Section 482 CrPC.
- Whether the second presentation of the cheque (after the first dishonour) was an impermissible attempt to save limitation or whether it was valid under the law permitting presentation within six months.
- Whether the 5th Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad has jurisdiction to try the offence or whether jurisdiction lies exclusively in Bombay.
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The prosecution based on the first dishonour would be out of time under Sections 138 and 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act; the second presentation was made only to save limitation.
- The courts at Hyderabad have no jurisdiction because: the hire-purchase contract was entered into in Bombay; payments were to be made at Bombay; the dishonour occurred at Bombay; and post-dishonour meetings between the parties took place at Bombay — therefore any offence, if at all, was committed at Bombay.
Respondent's Arguments
- The cheques were issued to the first respondent at Hyderabad and were presented for collection at Hyderabad; the first respondent received information of the dishonour only at Hyderabad.
- Sections 178 and 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure confer jurisdiction on the courts at Hyderabad because part of the cause of action arose there and/or consequences ensued there.
- As a practical proposition, the debtor must find the creditor and therefore the court within whose local jurisdiction the creditor's office is located has jurisdiction to try the case.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| V.R. Krishnan v. V.S. Narayanan (1990 (1) Madras WN (Criminal) 76) | Explains that in banking parlance the endorsement "referred to drawer" is generally used when a cheque is returned for want of funds in the drawer's account. | The court relied on this observation to support the factual finding that the cheque was returned for want of funds (paucity of funds) on the second presentation. |
| Voltas Limited v. Hiralal Agarwala (Cal.) 1991 (71) Company Cases 273 | Held to be to the same effect as V.R. Krishnan regarding the meaning/implication of the bank endorsement "referred to drawer". | Used to reinforce the conclusion that the second return also indicated insufficiency of funds rather than some other technicality. |
| Union Roadways (P) Ltd. v. Shah Ramlal Satesh Kumar (1992 (1) An. W.R 372) | Referenced in the opinion as an Andhra Pradesh decision which the court stated has no application in the present facts. | The court distinguished the present facts from that Andhra Pradesh decision and held it not to be applicable. |
| Richard Samson Sherrat v. State of A.P. (1992 (2) A.P.L.J. 27) | Holds that a cheque may be presented to the bank within six months from the date on which it is drawn (or within its period of validity, whichever is earlier), and clause (a) of the proviso to Section 138 does not limit the number of times a cheque may be presented within that period. | The court relied on this decision to hold that the second presentation within six months was permissible and not an impermissible attempt to save limitation. |
| K.V. Iyer, Prop. Reapwel Consultancy Services v. Chitra & Co. (1990 (2) Madras WN (Criminal) 47) | Supports the position that multiple presentations of a cheque within the permissible period are not proscribed by the proviso to Section 138. | Used alongside Richard Samson Sherrat to conclude that the second presentation in the present case was not unwarranted. |
| M.M. Malik v. Prem Kumar Goyal (1991 Criminal Law Journal 2594) | Observed that the debtor has to find the creditor and that the court within whose jurisdiction the creditor's office is located will have jurisdiction. | The court cited this decision to support the proposition that Hyderabad courts have jurisdiction since the creditor (first respondent) has its office at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad. |
| Ess Bee Food Specialities v. Kapoor Brothers (1991 Criminal Law Journal 2594 / cited later as 1992 Crl. LJ 739) | Holds that where the case was instituted at the place where the cheque was dishonoured, that court has jurisdiction. | The court invoked this authority to reinforce that the place of dishonour/presentation (Hyderabad) confers jurisdiction on the Hyderabad courts. |
| Shree (Sree) Bharat Laxmi Wool Store v. P.N.B (1992 Crl. LJ 739 / 1992 Important & Selected Judgments (Banking) 111) | Held that when a cheque is presented and dishonoured at a particular place (example given: Bangalore), the courts at that place have jurisdiction. | The court relied on this line of authorities to conclude that, as the cheque was presented and dishonoured at Hyderabad and the creditor's office was there, the Hyderabad Magistrate has jurisdiction. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court's reasoning proceeds in a sequence closely tied to the undisputed documentary record and established authorities:
- Acceptance of facts: The court accepted as not in dispute that the cheque for Rs. 5 lakhs was issued on 30-3-1991, presented at Hyderabad on 1-4-1991, and dishonoured on two occasions (8-4-1991 endorsement "funds expected, present again"; and 16-5-1991 endorsement "referred to drawer").
- Meaning of bank endorsements: Invoking V.R. Krishnan and Voltas Ltd., the court interpreted "referred to drawer" in banking parlance as generally indicating return for want of funds in the drawer's account. On this basis, together with the petitioners' own telexes and letters admitting financial constraints ("We could not honour due to financial constraint" and later letters), the court concluded that the cheque bounced on both occasions due to paucity of funds in the first petitioner's account.
- Limitation and second presentation: The petitioners argued the second presentation was to save limitation. The court analysed precedent (Richard Samson Sherrat and K.V. Iyer) which the court construed as holding that a cheque can be presented more than once within the six-month (or validity) period and that clause (a) of the proviso to Section 138 does not prescribe a limit on the number of presentations within that period. Applying those authorities to the present facts (where the cheque was presented twice within the stipulated period and dishonoured both times), the court held the second presentation was permissible and could not be treated as an improper device to evade limitation rules.
- Jurisdictional analysis: The petitioners contended that only Bombay courts had jurisdiction because the contract and payments related to Bombay and because the dishonour occurred there. The respondent relied on the fact that the cheques were issued to and presented at Hyderabad and invoked Sections 178 and 179 CrPC. The court quoted Sections 178 and 179 CrPC and applied them: where part of an offence or consequence occurs in a local area, a court having jurisdiction over that area may inquire into or try the offence. The court also relied on authorities (M.M. Malik, Ess Bee, and Shree Bharat Laxmi Wool Store) holding that the court where the creditor's office is located or where the cheque is presented/dishonoured has jurisdiction. Given that the first respondent's office is at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad, and the cheque was presented at Hyderabad, the court concluded that part of the cause of action arose in Hyderabad and that the Hyderabad Magistrate had jurisdiction.
- Conclusion on the petition: Because the court found the second presentation valid and Hyderabad to have jurisdiction, the petition seeking quashment of C.C. No. 367/91 was found to have no merit and was dismissed.
Holding and Implications
DISMISSED
Holding (core ruling): The criminal petition under Section 482 CrPC seeking quashment of C.C. No. 367/91 was dismissed. The court held (i) the cheque was dishonoured on both occasions due to insufficiency of funds as evidenced by bank endorsements and the petitioners' own communications; (ii) the second presentation within the stipulated period was permissible under the cited authorities and could not be struck down as a device to save limitation; and (iii) the courts at Hyderabad had jurisdiction to try the complaint by reason of Sections 178 and 179 CrPC and supporting case law.
Implications: The direct effect is that the prosecution under Section 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act (as initiated in C.C. No. 367/91 before the V Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad) may proceed. The opinion expressly permits the petitioners to raise all available pleas at the trial court ("this does not bar the petitioners to take all such pleas available to them under law in the trial court"). The decision, as rendered, applies the cited authorities to the facts but does not purport to establish any novel legal principle beyond the application and reconciliation of precedent on presentation of cheques and territorial jurisdiction.
1. The petition is directed under Sec. 482 of the Code of Criminal Procedure (hereinafter referred to as ‘the Code’) to call for the records in C.C No. 367 of 1991 on the of the Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad and to quash the same. The facts which are not in dispute are that the first petitioner is a company of which the second petitioner is the Director. In lieu of a hire purchase arrangement a cheque was issued by the first petitioner for Rs. 5 lakhs on March 30, 1991 on the Karnataka Bank, Bombay. The same was presented for encashment on 1-4-1991 and the same was bounced with an endorsement “funds expected, present again”. The same was represented again in the month of May 19, 1991 and on the second occasion too, it bounced with an endorsement “referred to drawer”. As such having issued the statutory notice, the first respondent filed C.C No. 367/91 on the file of the V Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad under Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act. Thereupon the petitioners who are the accused, filed the present criminal petition under Sec. 482 of the Code to quash C.C No. 367/91 pending on the file of the V Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad. The fact that the petitioners issued the cheque dt. 30-3-1991 for Rs. 5 lakhs on the Karnataka Bank is not in dispute. Similarly the further fact that the said cheque was presented at Hyderabad for collection on 1-4-1991, on 8-4-1991 the said cheque was bounched with an endorsement “funds expected, present again” and for the second time when it was presented in the month of May, 1991 it once again bounced as per the endorsement of the bank “referred drawer” dt. 16-5-1991 is not in dispute. In V.R Krishnan v. V.S Narayanan (1) 1990 (1) Madras Weekly Notes (Criminal) page 76, it is observed that in the banking parlance the reason “referred to drawer” when cheques are returned unpaid is used generally of returning the cheque for want of funds from the drawer's account. To the same effect are the decisions reported in Voltas Limited v. Hiralal Agarwala (Cal.) (2) 1991 (71) Company cases page 273.
2. In this case it is more than evident that on both the occasions, the cheque was bounced due to paucity of funds in the account of the Ist petitioner. The correspondence between the parties and as a matter of fact, the averments in the Criminal petition categorically show that the cheque is question bounced on both the occasions for want of funds. In the Telex dated 13-5-1991 referring to the first dishonour the first petitioner mentioned as follows:
“We could not honour due to financial constraint” The said Telex is annexure ‘C’ in the material papers. Similarly in the letter dated May 26, 1991 by the petitioners to the whole time Director, it is mentioned as follows:
“We explain to you, due to various financial constriants we were not able to make payments in time due to which arrears were accumulated. We have every intention of clearing up of the arrears.”
3. It is significant to note that this letter was addressed after the cheque in question was bounced for the second time. Coming to the averments in the criminal petition it is observed as follows:
“As the petitioner is in financial difficulties for the last about one year the first petitioner has been irregular in payment instalments to the first respondent ——— The petitioner No. 1 by their Telex message dated 13-5-1991 expressed their financial difficulties and requested respondent No. 1 to bear with the petitioner No. 1.
4. The petitioner No. 1 by its letter dated July 10, 1991 once again stated the financial crisis through which it was passing requested the first respondent to wait for some more time for payments.
5. Thus, even in the petition it was clearly admitted that the first petitioner company was passing through financial crisis and consequently could not arrange for payment of the amount convered by the cheque in question. Thus this is not a case where the Andhra Pradesh decision referred to in Union Roadways (P) Ltd. v. Shah Ramlal Satesh Kumar (3) 1992 (1) An. W.R 372 has any application and on the contra the facts in the case clinches in establishing that due to financial difficulties the first petitioner-company admits that it could not arrange for payment of the amount covered by the cheque in question on both the occasions.
6. On behalf of the petitioners it is submitted that the presecution launched by the first respondent will not be in time as per the provisions of Sec. 138 read with 142 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, if a criminal case were to be filed basing on the first dishonour to get over the said difficulty, the cheque was presented for the second time only with a view to see that limitation is saved. This position is covered by a judgment of this court reported in Richard Samson Sherrat v. State of A.P (4) 1992 (2) A.P.L.J page 27 wherein it was held that the cheque can be presented to the bank within a period of six months from the date on which it is drawn or within the period of its validity which ever is earlier. Clause (a) of proviso to Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act does not lay down as to the number of times a cheque can be presented to the bank, when the statute has not laid down any limitation on the number of times that a cheque may be presented within a period of six months or any shorter period under clause (a) of proviso to Sec. 138 of the Negotiable Instruments Act, it will not be desirable to read into the said clause any such restriction as to the number of times a cheque may be presented.” That was a case where the cheque was presented twice within six months and the same was dishonoured on both the occasions as in the present case. Hence Rechard Samson Sherrets case it was held that presentation of the cheque for the second time within a the stipulated period of six months is not bad under law. To the same effect is the decision reported in K.V Iyer, Prop. Reapwel Consultancy Services v. Chitra & Co. (5) 1990 (2) Madras Weekly Notes (Criminal), 47. Thus in view of the above two decisions, I hold that the presentation of the cheque for the second time within the stipulated period of six months is not unwarranted and it cannot be said that the second presentation in this case is an excuse to save the limitation.
7. Mr. Venkataramana, the learned counsel for the petitioner submit that the 5th Metropolitan Magistrate, Hyderabad has no jurisdiction and consequently the complaint petition has to be returned for presentation to proper court. Elaborating his submission, the learned counsel for the petitioner submits that the contract of hire purchase was entered into at Bombay; the payment was proposed to be made at Bombay; the dishonouring the cheque took place at Bombay; the first petitioner and the first respondent had meetings to discuss the payment of money at Bombay and after the dishonour of the cheque there have been several meetings between the first petitioner and the first respondent at Bombay and consequently the offence if any was committed only at Bombay and the courts at places other than the Bombay have no jurisdiction to take cognizance of the offence. It is the contention of the first respondent that the cheques were issued to the first respondent at Hyderabad, the cheques were presented for collection at Hyderabad, the first respondent received information regarding bouncing of cheques only at Hyderabad and consequently the Courts at Hyderabad have got jurisdiction. It is further submitted on behalf the first respondent that by virtue of Secs. 178 and 179 of the Code of Criminal Procedure the courts at Hyderabad have got jurisdiction. It is further submitted that the debtor has to find the creditor and consequently the place where the creditor company is having its office, will have jurisdiction to try the case.
8. Section 178 of the Code so far as it is relevant and Sec. 179 reads thus:
Section 178: Place of Enquiry or trial:
(a) xxxxxx
(b) Where an offence is committed partly in one local area and partly in another, or
(c) xxxxxx
(d) Where it consists of several acts done in different local areas, it may be inquired into or tried by a Court having jurisdiction over any of such local area;
9. Sec. 179: Offence triable where act is done or consequence ensues:
When an act is an offence by reason of anything which has been done and of a consequence which has ensued, the offence may be inquired into or tried by a Court within whose local jurisdiction such thing has been done or such consequence has ensued”.
10. It is to be seen that the office of the first respondent is located at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad over which the 5th Metropolian Magistrate, Hyderabad has jurisdiction. The cheque was issued in favour of the first respondent company with head office at Nagarjuna Hills, Hyderabad, the said cheque was presented at Hyderabad for collection and consequently part of the cause of action arose at Hyderabad by virtue of Sec. 178 and 179 of the Act and consequently the court at Hyderabad have got jurisdiction to try the offence.
11. In M.M Malik v. Prem Kumar Goyal (6) 1991 Criminal Law Journal page 2594 it is observed that the debtor has to find creditor and the court within whose jurisdiction the office of the Creditor company is located will have jurisdiction. To the same effect are the decisons reported in Ess Bee Food Specialities v. Kapoor Brothers (6) 1991 Criminal Law Journal page 2594 and Sree Bharat Laxmi Wool Store v. P.N.B (7) 1992 Crl. LJ 739.
12. Ess Bee Food Specialities v. Kapoor Brothers (7) 1992 Criminal Law Journal page 739 is a case where the case was instituted at the place where the cheque was dishonoured and it was held that the court where the cheque was dishonoured has jurisdiction.
13. Shree Bharat Laxmi Wool Store v. P.N.B (8) 1992 Important and Selected Judgments (Banking) page 111, is a case where the cheque was presented for collection at Bangalore and the said cheque was dishonoured and it was held that the Courts at Bangalore have got jurisdiction to try the case. Under these circumstances, finding no merits the Criminal Petition is dismissed.
14. But this does not bar the petitioners to take all such pleas available to them under law in the trial court.
Alert