Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

The Hindustan Oil Mi... v. The Special Deputy C...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Mar 26, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The claimants filed this revision against an order of the Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad refusing to grant enhanced benefits (solatium, interest and benefits under Section 23(1‑A) of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84). The learned Judge relied on the dates of the awards — the Land Acquisition Officer's award dated 9-3-64 and the Civil Court's award on reference under Section 18 dated 11-9-67 — and held that both awards predated 30-4-82, rendering the claimants ineligible for benefits under the amended Act. The claimants challenged that order by this revision.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the claimants are entitled to enhanced compensation (solatium and interest) under the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84.
  2. Whether the claimants are entitled to benefits under Section 23(1‑A) of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84.

Arguments of the Parties

Claimants' Arguments

  • Reliance on Hindustan Oil Mills Ltd. v. Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) (1990 1 SCC 59), particularly para 14, to claim entitlement to additional benefits under the amended Act.
  • Submission (relying on para 18 of a cited judgment) that if the Collector's award was passed on 23-9-84, benefits under Section 23(1‑A) would be available but not if passed on 25-9-84; and analogous contention regarding 30-4-82 vs 29-4-82, asserting discrimination violative of Article 14 of the Constitution.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Hindustan Oil Mills Ltd. v. Special Deputy Collector (Land Acquisition) 1990 1 SCC 59 The claimants relied on observations in para 14 to support entitlement to enhanced benefits under the amended Act. The court found nothing in para 14 to support the contention that claimants are entitled to enhanced benefits under the Amending Act 68/84; the cited decision dealt with valuation and market value determination and did not decide entitlement to enhanced compensation under the amending Act.
Union of India v. Raghubir Singh 1989 2 SCC 754 Constitution Bench holding on availability of benefits under the amended Act. The court treated this decision as authoritative and binding: benefits of the Amended Act are available only if either the award of the Land Acquisition Officer or the award of the Civil Court was rendered between 30-4-82 and 24-9-84; since both awards in this case predate 30-4-82, claimants are not entitled.
Union of India v. Filip Tiago De Gama Principle on Section 23(1‑A): availability depends on date of the Land Acquisition Officer's award. The court applied the holding that benefits under Section 23(1‑A) are available only if the award of the Land Acquisition Officer was passed between 30-4-82 and 24-9-84 and that this requirement has nothing to do with the date of the Civil Court's award; accordingly, claimants with a Land Acquisition Officer's award dated 9-3-64 are not entitled.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the claimants' reliance on Hindustan Oil Mills and found para 14 of that judgment did not support entitlement to enhanced benefits under Amending Act 68/84, observing that that case addressed valuation and market value determination, not the applicability of the amending provisions. The court relied on the Constitution Bench decision in Union of India v. Raghubir Singh that the benefits of the amended Act apply only where either the Land Acquisition Officer's award or the Civil Court's award falls between 30-4-82 and 24-9-84; here both awards (9-3-64 and 11-9-67) predate 30-4-82. For Section 23(1‑A), the court followed Union of India v. Filip Tiago De Gama that availability turns solely on the date of the Land Acquisition Officer's award (must be between 30-4-82 and 24-9-84); because the Land Acquisition Officer's award was dated 9-3-64, Section 23(1‑A) benefits are unavailable. The court noted the claimants' Article 14 discrimination contention but stated it was bound by the Supreme Court's authoritative rulings.

Holding and Implications

Revision dismissed.

Consequences: The claimants are not entitled to enhanced solatium, interest or benefits under Section 23(1‑A) of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84 because the Land Acquisition Officer's award (9-3-64) and the Civil Court's award on reference (11-9-67) predate 30-4-82. No costs were awarded. The court did not purport to set new precedent and followed binding Supreme Court decisions.

Show all summary ...

1. This revision is filed by the claimants questioning the order of the learned Additional Chief Judge, City Civil Court, Hyderabad refusing to grant additional benefits with regard to solatium, interest and also the benefits u/s. 23(1 A) of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84. The learned Judge referred to the fact that the award of the Land Acquisition Officer was dt. 9-3-64, and the award of the Civil Court on reference u/s. 18 of the Act was dt. 11-9-67 and held that in view of the fact that the awards of both the Land Acquisition Officer as well as the Civil Court are prior to 30-4-82, the claimants are not entitled to the benefits under the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84. Questioning the said order, this revision is filed by the claimants.

2. The learned counsel for the claimants contended that in view of the Judgment in Hindustan Oil Mills Ltd. v. Special Deputy Collector (Land Aacquisition) 1990 1 SCC 59 he is entitled to the additional benefits. The learned counsel relied upon the observations in para 14 of the said judgment. I am unable to find anything in para 14 of the above mentioned judgment to support the contention that the claimants are entitled to the enhanced benefits of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Amending Act 68/84. In the said decision, the learned Judges, after an exhaustive consideration of the matter, held that the compensation payable to the company should be worked out at Rs. 9/- per square yard and the rate payable to Sampathlal is at Rs. 8/- per square yard and that the market va???ue of the land should be determined as per the notification dt. 28-2-63. In the said judgment there is no decision with regard to the fact whether the claimants are entitled to the enhanced compensation as per the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84. On the other hand, this question has been set at rest by a Constitution Bench of the Supreme Court in Union of India v. Raghubir Singh 1989 2 SCC 754, which was followed by this Court also. As per the said judgment, the benefits of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84 will be available to the claimants in case either the award of the Land Acquisition Officer or the award of the Civil Court is rendered be???een 30-4-82 to 24-9-84. In view of the above authoritative decision of the Supreme Court which was followed by this Court and which is binding, I hold that the claimants in this case are not entitled to the enhanced solatium and interest as per the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84 in view of the fact that the award of the Land Acquisition Officer was dt. 9-3-64 and the award of the Civil Court on reference u/s. 18 was dt. 11-9-67.

3. The benefits conferred by Section 23(1-A) of the Land Acquisition Act are also not available to the claimants in the present case for the reason that the award of the Land Acquisition Officer was passed prior to 30-4-82, viz., it was passed on 9-3-64. These propositions are also authoritatively laid by their Lordships of the Supreme Court of India in a decision Union of India v. Filip Tiago De Gama.3 The learned Judges of the Supreme Court clearly held that the benefits are???available u/s. 23 (1-A) of the Act only if the award of the Land Acquisition Officer was passed between 30-4-82 to 24-9-84. This has nothing to do with the award of the Civil Court. In that view of the matter, it is not possible to hold that the benefits of the Land Acquisition Act as amended by Act 68/84 are applicable to the present case. The claimants in the present case are not entitled to the benefits of the Amended Land Acquisition Act.

4. Sri P.S Narayana, learned counsel for the claimants contended, relying upon para 18 of the judgment cited supra (3) that if the award of the Collector was passed on 23-9-84, the benefits u/s. 23 (1A) of the Act are available, but if it is passed on 25-9-84 by the Collector, the same are not available. Similar is the position with reference to the date of 30-4-82 and 29-4-82 and contends that it is discriminatory and violative of Art. 14 of the Constitution of India. Whatever may be the contention advanced before me in this regard, 1 am bound by the judgment of the Supreme Court referred to supra.

5. In that view of the matter, this revision is dismissed. No costs.