Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Gandhi v. State Government Of Andhra Pradesh .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Oct 28, 1991
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner, a teacher, filed an application for anticipatory bail apprehending arrest for alleged complicity in causing the death of one Viswam. He had previously filed two anticipatory bail applications: the first in Crl. Petition No. 1295/91 was rejected by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Chittoor; the second in Crl. Petition No. 1529/91 was rejected by this court. The petitioner filed the present third application, asserting changed circumstances to justify reconsideration. The matter was initially before Justice Iyyapu Pandurangarao, who directed it to be placed before the Chief Justice for orders regarding its posting; it subsequently came before the current judge.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether a second or subsequent application for anticipatory bail under Section 438 of the Criminal Procedure Code (Cr.P.C) is maintainable after the rejection of an earlier application.
  2. Whether the absence of changed circumstances since the prior bail application affects the maintainability of a subsequent application.
  3. Whether any statutory restriction exists under Section 438 Cr.P.C limiting the number of anticipatory bail applications that may be filed.

Arguments of the Parties

Public Prosecutor's Arguments

  • A second application for anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C is not maintainable.
  • Relied on the decision in Malta Ramarao v. the State and the unreported Amia Kumar v. State to support this position.
  • Conceded that the decision in Malta Ramarao should not be interpreted to bar filing before the High Court after rejection by the Sessions Judge.
  • Argued that the present petition should be dismissed due to lack of any changed circumstances since the first application.

Petitioner's Arguments

  • There is no bar under Sections 437, 438, or 439 Cr.P.C to file multiple bail applications if circumstances have changed.
  • Section 438 Cr.P.C contains no language limiting the number of anticipatory bail applications.
  • Relied on the Supreme Court decision in Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab (1980) to support the maintainability of multiple applications.
  • Contended that anticipatory bail can be sought on reasonable apprehension of arrest without necessarily furnishing the crime number.
  • Suggested that the decision in Malta Ramarao v. The State requires reconsideration by a Division Bench.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Malta Ramarao v. the State Second anticipatory bail application not maintainable after rejection of the first. Referenced by the Public Prosecutor; court noted it should not be strictly construed to bar High Court applications after Sessions Judge rejection.
Amia Kumar v. State (unreported) Rejected second anticipatory bail application as not maintainable. Relied upon in Malta Ramarao; supported the Public Prosecutor's initial argument.
Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab, 1980 2 SCC 565 No statutory bar on filing multiple anticipatory bail applications under Section 438 Cr.P.C. Relied on by petitioner; court found this decision strengthened the view that multiple applications are not barred.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court examined the statutory language of Section 438 Cr.P.C and relevant case law, particularly the decision in Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab, to determine whether a second anticipatory bail application is maintainable. It acknowledged the Public Prosecutor’s concession that the principle in Malta Ramarao should not be interpreted to bar filing before the High Court after rejection by the Sessions Judge. However, the court found that the present petition did not disclose any changed circumstances since the rejection of the earlier bail application. Since changed circumstances are a necessary condition for entertaining a subsequent anticipatory bail petition, the court held that the present application was not maintainable. Consequently, the court dismissed the petition without requiring a Division Bench to consider the broader question of maintainability of multiple applications.

Holding and Implications

The petition for anticipatory bail is dismissed.

The court's decision directly affects the petitioner by denying anticipatory bail due to the absence of changed circumstances since the prior rejection. The ruling does not establish a new precedent limiting the number of anticipatory bail applications under Section 438 Cr.P.C, as the court declined to conclusively decide on that broader legal question. Instead, it emphasized the necessity of demonstrating changed circumstances for subsequent applications to be entertained.

Show all summary ...

1. The petitioner, who is a teacher, filed this petition for anticipato???y bail apprehending arrest for his alleged complicity for having caused the death of one Viswam. He earlier moved this court for anticipatory bail in Crl. Petition No. 1529/91 after a similar application filed by him in Crl. Petition No. 1295/91 was rejected by the First Additional Sessions Judge, Chittoor. This court rejected Crl;. Petition No. 1529/91. He filed the present application stating that there were changed circumstances, justifying the filing of the second application for anticipatory bail.

2. The matter had earlier come up before my learned brother Justice Iyyapu Pandurangarao on 15-10-91 and the learned Judge directed that the matter may be placed before the Hon'ble the Chief Justice for orders with regard to the posting of the matter before a Division Bench or before another learned single Judge. The matter has come up before me, as referred to above.

3. The learned Public Prosecutor submits that a second application for grant of anticipatory bail under Section 438 Cr.P.C is not maintainable. He relied on Malta Ramarao v. the State in Crl. Petition No. 1459/91 (1) where learned Single Judge, Radhakrishna Rao relying on Amia Kumar v. State Crl. No. 1459 of 1991 of APHC unreported. of West Bengal2 rejected the application for anticipatory bail for a second time, as not maintainable after the rejection of the first application.

4. Sri A.T.M Rangaramanujam, appearing for the petitioner contends that there is no bar to the filing of a second application for bail either under Section 437, 438 or Section 439 Cr.P.C and that any number of applications for bail can be entertained, in altered circumstances, if the situations or requires. He further contended that in Section 438 Cr.P.C, there are no words restricting the scope of the provision of law to the filing of only one bail application and that no words can be read into the statute to limit its scope. He relied on Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab 1980 2 SCC 565. The next submission of the learned counsel was that an application for anticipatory bail can be filed on a reasonable apprehension that the petitioner will be arrested for a non-bailable offence and that there was no need for furnishing the crime number. The learned counsel contends that the decision in M. Ramarao v. The State, (1 supra) requires reconsideration by a Division Bench.

5. The learned Public Prosecutor fairly concedes that the decision the Malla Ramarao v. the State (1 supra) need not be construed so as to limit the scope of Section 438 Cr.P.C only to the filing of one bail application either before the Sessions Judge or before the High Court, and that application before the High Court is maintainable, even though the application before the Sessions Judge is rejected. He submits that the question whether a second application for anticipatiory bail before the High Court is maintainable or not, need not be gone into in the present case, as the averments in the bail application do not reveal any change in the circumstances after the rejection of the first application filed by the petitioner, and that the petition may be dismissed on that ground itself.

6. Though there is some force in the contention of the learned Counsel for the petitioner that a second application for anticipatory bail is not barred under Section 438 Cr.P.C, on a reading of Section 438 and further strengthened by the decision in Gurbaksh Singh v. State of Punjab, (3 supra) I do not think that it is necessary that this matter should go before a Division Bench on that aspect, in view of the fact that the bail application does not reveal any changed circumstances since the rejection of the first application filed by the petitioner. In that view of the matter, the petition is dismissed.