Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Nerati Pichamma And Another v. Pasumala Arogiya And Others

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Feb 28, 1989
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K. Ramaswamy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The appeals and the civil revision petition arise out of the same accident and are disposed of together. The appeals challenge the common order and decrees dated 19 August 1985 of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Nalgonda, in O.P. Nos. 216 of 1983 and 218 of 1983.

Key procedural posture and parties (as stated in the opinion):

  • C.M.A. No. 1247 of 1985: filed by the father and mother (claimants in O.P. No. 216 of 1983) of the deceased Rajaiah (aged 18). They sought Rs. 50,000; the Tribunal awarded Rs. 20,000 to the 1st petitioner (the mother) and dismissed the claim of the 2nd petitioner (the father).
  • C.M.A. No. 1407 of 1985: filed by Arogiya (the driver, 2nd respondent in O.P. No. 216 of 1983) aggrieved by the Tribunal’s direction that he pay the compensation while the claim against the owner was dismissed.
  • C.R.P. No. 3749 of 1985: filed by the same driver (2nd respondent in O.P. No. 218 of 1983) aggrieved by the Tribunal’s direction that he pay Rs. 1,000 as compensation to the injured person Ashok, while the claim against the owner was dismissed.

Admitted facts of the accident (as recited): the owner of the tractor-cum-trailer was K. Narayana Reddi (1st respondent in both O.Ps). The driver was Arogiya (2nd respondent). On 21.8.1983 the driver and his father hired the tractor-cum-trailer for 15 days for transplantation work and brought it to Dattapuram, parking it in an open space in front of the school. On 1 September 1983 at about 5:00 a.m., when the driver started the tractor and reversed, the tractor allegedly ran over the deceased Rajaiah (a cowboy) and injured Ashok, who was a direct witness (PW 2).

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the driver, Arogiya, drove the vehicle rashly and negligently, thereby attracting liability for the death and injury.
  2. Whether the owner, K. Narayana Reddi, is vicariously liable for the accident by operation of section 59 read with section 5 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (i.e., whether the owner remains liable despite the vehicle being in the hands of a third party).
  3. Whether an agreement (Exhibit B-1) between the owner and the driver established that the driver undertook special responsibility for any liability arising from use or unauthorised use of the vehicle.
  4. Whether the quantum of compensation awarded by the Tribunal (Rs. 20,000 to the mother of the deceased; Rs. 1,000 to the injured Ashok) was justified, including the proper approach to assessing future contribution of the deceased to his family.

Arguments of the Parties

Driver's Arguments (Mr. D. Reddappa Reddy)

  • The driver did not drive rashly or negligently and therefore no legal liability could be fastened on him for the accident.
  • The owner (Narayana Reddi) remained the owner by operation of section 59 read with section 5 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939, and therefore the owner ought to be held liable for payment of damages rather than the driver.

Claimants' Arguments (Mr. Jaganmohan Reddi)

  • Exhibit B-1 (an agreement) shows that Arogiya undertook that he alone should bear any liability arising from the accident or unauthorised use of the vehicle—i.e., Arogiya had a special responsibility to pay damages.
  • On quantum: the deceased, aged 18, would have contributed earnings (argued at Rs. 10 per day) over a period of 12 to 15 years; the Tribunal erred in its approach and in granting Rs. 20,000 in lump sum without adequately accounting for such future contributions.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt, 1966 ACJ 89 (SC) Doctrine of vicarious liability: master is vicariously liable for acts of servant done in the course of employment; presumption that a vehicle is driven on master's business can be rebutted; owner not liable where vehicle driven by unauthorised person on his own business. The court relied on this authority to hold that vicarious liability requires a jural master-servant relationship and that the owner cannot be held liable merely because the vehicle was entrusted to a third party who was driving for his own purposes. This supported exculpation of the owner in the present case.
Samson v. Aitchison, (1912) AC 844 (Lord Atkinson) Retention of control is the key; whether a person is styled servant or agent is less important than whether the principal retained control; agent/principal liability arises when act is within scope of authority or under actual control. The court cited this authority for the proposition that liability of a principal depends on retention of control and scope of authority, reinforcing the need for a master/servant or principal/agent relationship before imposing vicarious liability.
Barwick v. English Joint Stock Bank, LR (1867) 2 Ex. 259 Discussed (critically) the extension of master's liability on the basis that acts were done for the master's 'benefit'. The opinion referenced the case to explain why the court did not adopt an extension based on 'benefit' and preferred the clearer tests of 'course of employment' or 'scope of authority'.
Devki Devi Tiwari v. Raghunath Sahai Chatmth, 1978 ACJ 169 (Allahabad) Followed Sitaram; affirmed that vicarious liability depends on master-servant relationship and cannot be imposed merely because the owner entrusted the vehicle to a third party. The court treated this decision as confirming the settled law and used it to support the conclusion that the owner cannot be held vicariously liable where the jural relationship is lacking.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded in two main strands: (A) whether the driver was negligent, and (B) whether the owner was vicariously liable.

(A) Driver's negligence:

  • The court accepted the Tribunal's finding that the driver was responsible for the accident. It relied on the Tribunal's careful consideration of oral and documentary evidence.
  • The evidence of PW 2 (the injured, Ashok) was treated as direct, clear and cogent: PW 2 witnessed the occurrence, sustained injuries in the same accident, and stated that the wheels of the trailer ran over the deceased and hit him. The court found PW 2 had no motive to lie against the driver.
  • Based on this evidence, the court confirmed that the accident occurred due to the rash and negligent driving of the appellant (driver).

(B) Owner's liability (vicarious liability):

  • The court acknowledged provisions such as section 59 and section 5 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 regarding permits and conditions for use of vehicles in public places, but identified the crucial inquiry as whether a jural master-servant relationship existed between owner and driver for purposes of vicarious liability.
  • The court relied on the Supreme Court decision in Sitaram Motilal Kalal (as explained at length in the opinion) and on the Allahabad High Court decision in Devki Devi Tiwari to reiterate settled law: vicarious liability arises only when the tortious act is committed by a servant acting in the course of employment or an agent acting within the scope of authority or under actual control of the principal.
  • Applying those principles, the court found the driver had taken the vehicle for agricultural operations (hired it) and that the jural relationship of master and servant between the owner and the driver was absent. Given that absence, the Tribunal was justified in exculpating the owner from liability.

(C) On the claimants' reliance on Exhibit B-1 and quantum:

  • The court considered the claim that Exhibit B-1 constituted an agreement making the driver solely responsible for any liability arising from the vehicle's use. The court found no force in that contention (i.e., it did not accept that Exhibit B-1 required a different result).
  • On quantum, the court examined the contention that the deceased (a cowboy earning about Rs. 10 per day) would have contributed over 12–15 years. The court held that the deceased's employment was precarious and not assured; the possibility of future contribution would likely diminish with adulthood and marriage, and therefore the Tribunal's lump sum award of Rs. 20,000 could not be said to be arbitrary.
  • Nonetheless, the court held that the claimants were entitled to interest at 9% per annum on the amount awarded by the Tribunal from the date of the claim until realization.

Holding and Implications

Holding:

- C.M.A. No. 1247 of 1985 (claimants' appeal) is allowed to the extent indicated in the judgment (the Tribunal's award of Rs. 20,000 to the mother of the deceased is upheld and interest at 9% per annum from the date of the claim is awarded); the allowance is made without costs. - C.M.A. No. 1407 of 1985 (driver's appeal) is dismissed. - C.R.P. No. 3749 of 1985 (driver's revision) is dismissed.

Direct consequences and implications:

  • The Tribunal's award of Rs. 20,000 to the mother of the deceased is sustained; the claim against the owner was correctly dismissed by the Tribunal given absence of a master-servant (jural) relationship.
  • The driver remains personally liable to pay the compensation amounts awarded by the Tribunal (including Rs. 20,000 to the mother and Rs. 1,000 to the injured Ashok as previously directed), and the appeals filed by the driver are dismissed.
  • Interest at 9% per annum is awarded on the amount(s) from the date of the claim until realisation.
  • The opinion applies and follows existing precedent on vicarious liability; it does not purport to lay down new law or a novel principle beyond applying settled authorities (Sitaram Motilal Kalal and Devki Devi Tiwari) to the facts of this case.

Orders: "Orders accordingly." (final decretal directions as recorded in paragraphs 14–15 of the opinion).

Show all summary ...

K. Ramaswamy, J.:— Both the appeals and the civil revision petition are disposed of together as they arise out of the same cause of action.

2. Both the appeals are filed against the common order and decrees in O.P Nos. 216 of 1983 and 218 of 1983, dated August 19, 1985, on the file of the Motor Accidents Claims Tribunal, Nalgonda. The appellants in C.M.A No. 1247 of 1985 are the father and mother of the deceased, who are claimants in O.P No. 216 of 1983. They preferred this appeal claiming compensation of Rs. 50,000/- as against Rs. 20,000/- awarded by the Tribunal below to the 1st petitioner and dismissing the claim of the 2nd petitioner therein.

3. The appellant in C.M.A No. 1407 of 1985 is the driver, 2nd respondent in the very same O.P No. 216 of 1983. He filed this appeal aggrieved by the direction of the court below to pay the compensation to the claimant.

4. Civil Revision Petition No. 3749 of 1985 is filed by the driver, 2nd respondent in O.P No. 218 of 1985, aggrieved by the order and decree therein, wherein he was directed to pay Rs. 1,000/- as compensation to the injured person by name Ashok in the same accident.

5. Thus, all the three cases are disposed of together by a common judgment.

6. The admitted facts are that one K. Narayana Reddi, first respondent in both the O.Ps, is the owner and one Arogiya, second respondent in both the O.Ps, is the driver of the tractor-cum-trailer bearing Nos. APL 4722 and APN 5105 respectively. One Ludharaiah, father of the driver and the 2nd respondent driver took the tractor-cum-trailer on 21.8.1983 on hire for 15 days for transplantation work and they brought the same to Dattapuram and parked it in the open space in front of the school. On the fateful day, i.e, on September 1, 1983, in the early hours at 5.00 a.m when the driver started the tractor and drove it in the reverse direction in a rash and negligent manner, without noticing the deceased and the injured who were sleeping there, the deceased by name Rajaiah aged 18 years, a cowboy, was run over by the tractor and one Ashok sustained injuries. The father and mother of the deceased laid their claim for compensation of Rs. 50,000/- in O.P No. 216 of 1983 and the injured person, Ashok, laid his claim for compensation in O.P No. 218 of 1983. In O.P No. 216 of 1983, the Tribunal below has awarded a sum of Rs. 20,000/- to the 1st petitioner, mother of the deceased and dismissed the claim of the 2nd petitioner. The Tribunal further directed the 2nd respondent driver to pay the compensation amount to the 1st petitioner while dismissing the claim as against the owner of the vehicle, the first respondent therein. Dissatisfied with the order and decree of the court below, the claimants filed C.M.A No. 1247 of 1985.

7. The driver, 2nd respondent in O.P No. 216 of 1983, is the appellant in C.M.A No. 1407 of 1985. He filed this appeal aggrieved by the direction of the court below, directing him to pay the compensation amount to the 1st petitioner while dismissing the claim against the owner, 1st respondent. C.R.P No. 3749 of 1985 is filed by the driver, 2nd respondent in O.P No. 218 of 1983, which was filed by the injured Ashok in the same accident. The court below awarded Rs. 1,000/- to the injured and directed the driver to pay that amount while dismissing the claim as against the owner of the vehicle.

8. TWo contentions have been raised by Mr. D. Reddappa Reddy, learned counsel for the driver, appellant in C.M.A No. 1407 of 1985 and for the revision petitioner in C.R.P No. 3749 of 1985.

9. Firstly, it is contended that Arogiya had not driven the vehicle rashly and negligently and no legal liability can be fastened to the driver. I find no force in this contention. The court below on a careful consideration of the entire oral and documentary evidence found that the driver was responsible for the accident. In fact, PW 2, the injured in the same accident and claimant in O.P No. 218 of 1983 is a direct witness to the occurrence. The fact that PW 2 sustained injuries during the course of the same accident clearly shows that he witnessed the occurrence. Moreover, his evidence is quite clear and cogent. PW 2 stated that the wheels of the trailer actually ran over the deceased and also hit him (PW 2). He has no axe to grind against the appellant driver. The court below has rightly held that the driver alone was responsible for the accident accepting the evidence of PW 2.1, therefore, confirm the finding that the accident occurred due to rash and negligent driving of the appellant.

10. Next, it is contended that Narayana Reddi, being the owner of the vehicle, by virtue of operation of section 59 read with section 5 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1939 (Act 4 of 1939), for short ‘the Act’, continues to be the owner and that therefore, he is liable for payment of damages for death of the deceased or bodily injury to the victim. I find no force in this contention also. It may be that, under section 59 of the Act, the general conditions attached to the permit are, the permit shall not be transferred except with the permission of the transport authority which granted the permit and that the owner continues to be governed by the provisions of the Act for use of the vehicle in the public place in the manner provided in the permit. Section 5 of the Act is also to the same effect. But, the crucial question is whether there is vicarious liability between the owner and the driver of the vehicle. Admittedly, the driver had taken the vehicle for agricultural operations. Unless there is jural relationship of master and servant between the owner and driver, the doctrine of vicarious liability cannot be extended to the third party. In Sitaram Motilal Kalal v. Santanuprasad Jaishankar Bhatt , 1966 ACJ 89 (SC), their Lordships of the Supreme Court considered the doctrine of vicarious liability. Speaking for the Bench Hidayatullah, J. (as he then was) held:

“The law is settled that a master is vicariously liable for the acts of his servant acting in the course of his employment Unless the act is done in the course of employment, the servant's act does not make the employer liable. In other words, for the master's liability to arise, the act must be a wrongful act authorised by the master or a wrongful and unauthorised mode of doing some act authorised by the master. The driver of a car taking the car on the master's business makes him vicariously liable if he commits an accident. But it is equally well-settled that if the servant, at the time of the accident, is not acting within the course of his employment but is doing something for himself the master is not liable. There is a presumption that a vehicle is driven on the master's business and by his authorised agent or servant but the presumption can be met. It was negatived in this case, because the vehicle was proved to be driven by an unauthorised person and on his own business. The de facto driver was not the driver or the agent of the owner but one who had obtained the car for his own business not even from the master but from a servant of the master. Prima facie the owner would not be liable in such circumstances.

XXXXXXXXX

11. The law with regard to agents is the same. As was observed by Lord Atkinson in Samson v. Aitchison, (1912) AC 844, it is a matter of indifference whether a person be styled a servant or agent since it is the retention of control which makes the owner or the principal responsible. Just as the tort must be committed by a servant either under the actual control of his master or while acting in the course of his employment, the act of agent will only make the principal liable if it is done within the scope of his authority. By a process of ratiocination, the courts have made a slight distinction by attempting to find a ‘right of control’ as the basis of the master's liability and have distinguished it from a ‘right to control’ in cases of simple agency to bring the two cases together. We find it simpler to state the law that an agent will make the principal responsible so long as the agent does the act within the scope of his authority or does so under the actual control of the principal. We do not subscribe to the extension of the doctrine that the act of the servant or the agent must be for the master's benefit. This extension was made by Willes, J. in Barwick v. English Joint Stock Bank, LR (1867) 2 Ex. 259. The word ‘benefit’ is vague and it is better to adhere to the words ‘course of employment’ or the ‘scope of authority’. There is much institutional criticism of such extension. Similarly, we are doubtful whether the extension of the principle by the introduction of the doctrine of implied authority, which was relied upon in the school master's case referred to above, was quite correct. If the dictum is accepted, not only the master would be liable for what he may be supposed to have ‘impliedly authorised’ the servant to do (however illegal) but also for all the servant's negligence not in doing his duty but in doing something on his own account when he should be properly acting for the master.”

12. The above decision was followed in Devki Devi Tiwari v. Raghunath Sahai Chatmth, 1978 ACJ 169 (Allahabad), by a Division Bench of the Allahabad High Court. Thus, it is settled law that unless the jural relationship of master and servant is established between the owner of the vehicle and the person who drove the vehicle, vicarious liability cannot be fastened merely because the owner happened to entrust the vehicle to third party and the accident occurred when the third party was driving the vehicle. The doctrine of vicarious liability has arisen only on account of jural relationship that for every tortious act committed by the servant, the master should be made liable. Otherwise, the master could easily escape the liability for the tortious act committed by the servant during the course of employment and for the benefit of the master. In this case, since the jural relationship of master and servant is absolutely lacking, the Tribunal below is well justified in exculpating the liability of the owner and I do not find any compelling reasons to differ from the conclusion arrived at by the Tribunal below.

13. It is contended by Mr. Jaganmohan Reddi, learned counsel for the appellants-claimants in C.M.A No. 1247 of 1985 that Exh. B-1 clearly shows that there is an agreement that the said Arogiya alone should undertake the liability if any such liability has arisen on account of the accident or unauthorised user of the vehicle and therefore, it is clear that he has undertaken a special responsibility for the damages due to unauthorised user of the vehicle handed over to him by the owner thereof. He further contended that the deceased is aged 18 years and he would have contributed even at the rate of Rs. 10/- per day atieast for over a period of 12 to 15 years and the court below committed error in deciphering the reasons for granting Rs. 20,000/- in lump sum. I find no force in the contention. Admittedly, the deceased is only a cowboy and it is not an assured employment. He may be earning Rs. 10/- per day so long as there is work. Since it is a precarious work, there is no continuity of assured employment. That apart, the deceased after attaining majority and after getting married, the possibility of his contributing the entire earnings to the family would gradually recede, and he may not contribute the same amount even after marriage to the parents. Considered from either perspective, the amount of Rs. 20,000/- granted by the Tribunal below cannot be said to be arbitrary. But, however, the claimants are entitled to interest at 9 per cent per annum on the amount awarded by the Tribunal below from the date of the claim till the date of realisation.

14. For all the aforesaid reasons, the appeal C.M.A No. 1247 of 1985 is allowed to the extent indicated above, but without costs. The appeal C.M.A No. 1407 of 1985 and C.R.P No. 3749 of 1985 are dismissed and there shall be no order as to costs.

15. Orders accordingly.