Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Commissioner Of Gift-Tax v. Bandi Subba Rao

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Feb 24, 1987
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (K. Ramaswamy, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This reference under section 26 of the Gift-tax Act, 1958 was made by the Revenue seeking the court's opinion on two questions arising from a deed dated 21 March 1970. The assessee, an individual and the sole surviving coparcener with no sons, executed a partition/settlement deed on that date by which he allotted 9.94 acres of wet land to his married daughter, Smt. Sreedevi, and 10.40 acres of wet land to his unmarried daughter, Nagamani. The assessee possessed 40 acres of wet land in all and also carried on a money-lending business.

Under section 16(1) of the Gift-tax Act a notice was issued requiring the assessee to file a return. The assessee filed a nil return with a covering letter stating that no gift had been made in law. The Gift-tax Officer held that the transfers amounted to taxable gifts (valuation of the transferred property Rs. 1,05,460, minus allowable exclusion of Rs. 10,000 under section 5(1)(vii), producing an assessed gift-tax base of Rs. 95,460). The first appellate authority upheld that view. On second appeal the Appellate Tribunal (Income-tax Appellate Tribunal) held that the deed partook the nature of a family settlement and was not a transfer or alienation liable to gift-tax; it held there was no taxable gift to the married daughter even though the transfer was made years after marriage. At the instance of the Revenue, two specific questions were referred to this Court under section 26 of the Gift-tax Act.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was justified in holding that the deed executed on March 21, 1970, partakes the nature of a family settlement and that the transaction was not a transfer or alienation liable to gift-tax?
  2. Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was justified in holding that there was no taxable gift to the married daughter in spite of the transfer of agricultural lands being effected after a lapse of years after the marriage?

Arguments of the Parties

Revenue's Arguments (as presented by learned standing counsel)

  • The document dated 21 March 1970 is styled as a partition deed and, to qualify as a partition, the daughters must have had a pre-existing right in the coparcenary; the unmarried daughter has only a claim for maintenance and therefore the transfer cannot be treated as a partition.
  • If the document is not a partition deed, it must be construed as either a settlement or a gift; where made to a daughter it is effectively without consideration and thus constitutes a gift within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Gift-tax Act.
  • The assessee's obligation to maintain an unmarried daughter or to incur expenses at the time of marriage does not by itself convert a voluntary transfer into something other than a gift; the assessee must establish a custom in his caste/community to make such transfers or otherwise justify treating the deed as a family settlement rather than a gift.
  • The Gift-tax Officer and the first appellate authority had correctly applied the Act in treating the transaction as chargeable to gift-tax; the Tribunal erred in treating it as a family arrangement.

Assessee's / Tribunal's Position (as reflected in the opinion)

  • The deed should be viewed in the light of the legal obligations under Hindu law and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956 (specifically section 3(b)(ii)) which makes reasonable expenses incident to the marriage of an unmarried daughter part of the obligation of maintenance.
  • Allocating property to a married or unmarried daughter in discharge of a pre‑existing legal or moral obligation under Hindu law is not a voluntary transfer “without consideration” within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Gift-tax Act and therefore does not attract gift-tax.
  • It is not always necessary that each beneficiary under a family settlement have an antecedent, legally enforceable proprietory claim to the property; what matters is the relationship of the parties and the existence of a possible or recognizable claim (legal, moral or customary) that gives the arrangement the character of a family settlement rather than a gratuitous gift.
  • In the facts of the present case (assessee owning 40 acres, two daughters only, one married and one unmarried, the allocations being 9.94 and 10.40 acres respectively), the allocation of roughly half the property to the two daughters is not unreasonable and can be regarded as discharge of the pre-existing legal obligation rather than a taxable gift.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
CGT v. Chandrasekhara Reddy, [1976] 105 ITR 849 (AP) Accepted that section 3(b)(ii) of the Maintenance Act codifies that reasonable expenses incident to a daughter's marriage amount to maintenance; held that if giving of land is usually connected with marriage it can be incident to the marriage. Used as authority that transfers connected to marriage can be incident to maintenance and thus not gifts; the Court agreed with the underlying statutory recognition but disagreed with Chandrasekhara Reddy to the extent it required proof of custom for each community.
Smt. R. Seetharamama v. Land Acquisition Officer, [1979] 2 ALT 6 Maintenance and marriage expenses of a daughter is a legal obligation of the father; property given to her for that purpose cannot amount to a gift. Relied upon to support the proposition that transfers to daughters in discharge of maintenance/marriage obligation are not gifts.
Bhubaneswar Naik Santoshrai v. Special Tahsildar, Land Reforms, AIR 1980 AP 139 The expression "intention to give away the property for the provision of marriage of a daughter or sister" is not a gift under section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act; non-registration does not invalidate such a transfer. Applied to show that transactions intended for provision for marriage fall outside the concept of a gratuitous gift for relevant statutory purposes.
Subbayya v. Ananda Ramayya, AIR 1929 Mad 586 (Full Bench) Held that the obligation of maintaining and marrying daughters lies on the coparcenary (through the father) and that sons' shares may be liable for such expenses; obligation stems from daughter's original right which became a moral/legal obligation. Adopted as establishing that a pre-existing legal obligation arises under Hindu law and that allotments to daughters can be in discharge of that obligation rather than voluntary gifts.
Kudutamma v. Narasimhacharyulu, [1907] 17 Mad LJ 528 Father is entitled to make gifts by way of marriage portions to daughters out of family property to a reasonable extent. Supports the view that provision for daughters by way of property is an accepted legal practice and not necessarily a taxable gift.
Sundararamayya v. Sitamma, [1911] 21 Mad LJ 695 Upheld validity of a gift of ancestral land to a daughter made 40 years after her marriage. Used to demonstrate that gifts/settlements in discharge of obligations may be made long after marriage and still be valid and not taxable as gifts.
Ramasami Ayyar v. Vengidusami Ayyar, [1899] ILR 22 Mad 113 Upheld a widow's gift of land on the occasion of her daughter's marriage to the bridegroom. Illustrates that transfers connected to marriage ceremonies are recognised and can be upheld as valid non-taxable transfers when made to discharge an obligation.
Bachoo Hurkisondas v. Mankorebai, [1907] ILR 31 Bom 373 Judicial Committee upheld a father's gift of Rs. 20,000 to his daughter as valid. Supports the proposition that parental gifts to daughters for maintenance/marriage are valid and not per se void or necessarily taxable.
Devabhaktuni Sithamahalakshmamma v. Pamulpati Kotayya, AIR 1936 Mad 825 Upheld a father's gift of a reasonable portion of immovable property to his daughter without reference to his son. Reinforces that reasonable provision by a father to a daughter is recognised by Hindu law and is capable of being validly made.
Guramma Bharlar Chanbasappa Deshmukh v. Mallappa Chanbasappa, AIR 1964 SC 510 Upheld life estate to a widowed daughter; recognised that a moral obligation of father to provide for daughter can justify gifts made long after marriage and the validity/reasonableness depends on facts. Quoted and relied upon for the proposition that moral/religious obligations of parents to daughters may crystallise into valid transfers later and are assessed for reasonableness on the facts.
Smt. Kamala Devi v. Bachulal Gupta, AIR 1957 SC 434 Recognised the imperative moral/religious duty to give a girl in marriage and that promises of gifts at marriage may be fulfilled afterwards; gifts long after marriage may fulfil moral/religious obligations. Used to support the principle that transfers after marriage can validly discharge antecedent obligations and are not automatically taxable gifts.
CGT v. Bandlamudi Subbaiah, [1980] 123 ITR 509 (AP) Observed that announcements of gifts on marriage are often reduced to writing later, e.g., in partition deeds; allotment to unmarried daughters at partition to discharge obligation is not a gift. Applied to show that partition/settlement instruments executed later may memorialize pre-existing family undertakings and discharge legal obligations rather than create voluntary gifts.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court proceeded in a step-wise legal analysis grounded in statutory definitions and recognised principles of Hindu law:

  1. Definition and charge: The Court began from the statutory definition of "gift" in clause (xii) of section 2 of the Gift-tax Act, which requires a transfer to be "voluntary and without consideration in money or money's worth" to attract gift-tax under section 3 (the charging section).
  2. Referential question: The crucial question was whether the deed dated 21 March 1970 should be construed as a "gift" within section 2(xii) or whether it partook the nature of a family settlement/transfer in discharge of a pre-existing legal obligation.
  3. Relevant statutory and private-law obligations: The Court examined rights and obligations under Hindu law and the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956—particularly section 3(b)(ii) (definition of "maintenance" to include reasonable expenses incident to an unmarried daughter's marriage). The Court noted authorities and commentaries explaining that a father's obligation to provide marriage expenses includes attendant customary expenses.
  4. Precedents and principle: A series of judicial authorities were considered and synthesized. The Court accepted the principle repeatedly recognised by courts that a father's moral/legal obligation to make reasonable provision for a daughter (married or unmarried) can justify transfers of property to the daughter even long after marriage and that such transfers are made in discharge of a pre-existing obligation rather than being gratuitous gifts.
  5. Family settlement versus gift: The Court reasoned that where property is set apart to discharge an obligation to maintain or marry a daughter, the transaction is not “voluntary and without consideration” in the statutory sense because it substitutes property for the monetary liability the family would otherwise have to incur. Consequently, such a transaction is not a gift under section 2(xii) but constitutes a family settlement/settlement in discharge of legal obligation.
  6. Rejection of the requirement to prove custom: While an earlier Division Bench opinion (in Chandrasekhara Reddy) suggested that the Tribunal should examine whether there was a custom in the community to execute a gift or settlement deed subsequent to the marriage, this Court declined to endorse that requirement. The Court held that the statutory/legal obligation under Hindu law obviates the need to prove a community custom for each case: the essential criterion is that the parties are governed by Hindu law and that the transfer is in discharge of the father's or family's legal obligation.
  7. Application to facts: Applying those principles to the present facts — the assessee owning about 40 acres, having only two daughters (one married and one unmarried), and allotting 9.94 and 10.40 acres respectively — the Court considered such allotments to be within the bounds of reasonable provision and to have been made in discharge of pre-existing legal obligations rather than as taxable gifts.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The questions referred under section 26 of the Gift-tax Act are answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. The Court affirmed the finding that the deed of 21 March 1970 partook the nature of a family settlement and that there was no taxable gift to the married daughter even though the transfer occurred years after marriage. There shall be no order as to costs.

Implications:

  • Direct effect on the parties: The assessee is not liable to pay gift-tax in respect of the allotments to the married and unmarried daughters under the deed of 21 March 1970; the Tribunal's finding in favor of the assessee is affirmed.
  • Legal principle reinforced: The Court reaffirmed that transfers of property to daughters in discharge of a pre‑existing legal or moral obligation recognised by Hindu law (including the statutory definition of maintenance in section 3(b)(ii) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956) are not voluntary transfers "without consideration" within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Gift-tax Act and thus do not attract gift-tax; similarly, gifts made after marriage in fulfillment of earlier promises can discharge parental obligations and be non‑taxable.
  • On customary proof: The Court negatived the necessity of proving a caste/community custom to validate such transfers when they are founded on legal obligations under Hindu law; the requirement to prove custom is therefore not a prerequisite in such cases.

Note: This summary is restricted to the content and reasoning expressly contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer information beyond that source.

Show all summary ...

K. Ramaswamy, J.:— This reference under section 26 of the Gift-tax Act, 1958 (Act 18 of 1958) (for short “the Act”), has arisen at the instance of the Revenue for our opinion on the questions posed thus:

“(1) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was justified in holding that the deed executed on March 21, 1970, partakes the nature of a family settlement and that the transaction was not a transfer or alienation liable to gift-tax?

(2) Whether, on the facts and in the circumstances of the case, the Appellate Tribunal was justified in holding that there was no taxable gift to the married daughter in spite of the transfer of agricultural lands being effected after a lapse of years after the marriage?”

2. The material facts in support of the reference are that the assessee, an individual, during the assessment year 1970-71 executed a partition deed on March 21, 1970, by which he gave away acres 9.94 of wet land to his married daughter, Smt. Sreedevi and acres 10.40 of wet land to his unmarried daughter, Nagamani. Notice under section 16(1) of the Act was issued calling upon the assessee to file his return. Accordingly, he filed nil return with a covering letter that there is no gift in the eye of law and that, therefore, he need not pay any gift-tax. The Gift-tax Officer held that Sreedevi is a married daughter whose marriage has taken place long back and Nagamani is an unmarried daughter. Nagamani has only a claim for maintenance and, therefore, it cannot be treated as a partition as the assessee the sole surviving co-parcener. On that premise, he rejected the contention of the assessee and valued the property at Rs. 1,05,460 and excluded Rs. 10,000 under sections 5(1)(vii) of the Gift-tax Act and assessed to gift-tax Rs. 95,460 and on appeal, the assessee was unsuccessful. In second appeal, the Appellate Tribunal found that a Hindu is under a legal obligation to make provision for maintenance of an unmarried daughter and also to make provision for a married daughter for fulfilling an earlier promise made at the time of the marriage. It is not necessary that every party taking a benefit under a family settlement must necessarily be shown to have, under the law, a claim to a share in the property. All that is necessary is that the parties must be related to one another in some way and have a possible claim to the property or even a semblance of a claim on some other ground as, say, affection. Therefore, it is in the nature of a family settlement. Accordingly, it was held that the transaction was not a transfer or alienation. Therefore, the question of paying gift-tax does not arise. At the instance of the Revenue, the above questions have been referred. It is also necessary to mention that the assessee has no sons and is possessed of acres 40 of wet land at Attili, Tanuku Taluk, West Godavari District. Besides, he is also having a money-lending business. Sri M.S.N Murthy, learned standing counsel for the Revenue, contended that the document dated March 21, 1970, is styled as a partition deed and that the daughters must have a pre-existing right in the coparcenary. The unmarried daughter has only a right to maintenance. Therefore, it cannot be construed to be a partition deed. Once it is construed that it is not a partition deed, it is necessarily to be construed either as a settlement or as a gift. If it is a settlement or gift and when it is made to a daughter, it goes without saying that it is without consideration. It is, therefore, a gift within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Act and entitled only to the exclusion permissible under section 5(1)(vii) of the Gift-tax Act. The assessee has got an obligation to maintain an unmarried daughter or an obligation to incur expenses incidentally at the time of marriage of the daughters. Moreover, the assessee has to establish custom among his caste to give property to daughters. The Gift-tax Officer has rightly considered this aspect. The appellate authority upheld the view of the Gift-tax Officer. But, the Tribunal has committed an error of law in treating it to be a family arrangement and, therefore, the view of the Tribunal is clearly illegal. We are unable to agree.

3. Clause (xii) of section 2 of the Act defines “gift” as follows:

“‘gift’ means the transfer by one person to another of any existing movable or immovable property made voluntarily and without consideration in money or money's worth, and includes the transfer or conversion of any property referred to in section 4, deemed to be a gift under that section.”

4. Any transaction to be a gift must come within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Act. Then alone the liability to pay gift-tax under section 3 of the Act which is a charging section does arise. The question is, therefore, whether the document dated March 21, 1970, should be construed to be a gift. To answer this question, it is necessary to hark into the rights the married and unmarried daughters have under the Hindu law or the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act, 1956, for short “the Maintenance Act”.

5. Section 3(b) of the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act defines:

“‘maintenance’ includes—

(ii) in the case of an unmarried daughter, also the reasonable expenses of and incident to her marriage.”

6. The unmarried daughter has thereby a legal right and the father has corresponding legal obligation to provide reasonable expenses as an incident to her marriage. Mr. N.R Raghavachariar, a commentator on Hindu Law, 5th edition, states at page 1103:

“The words ‘incident to marriage’ are used to indicate the necessity for inclusion in the expenses payable for the marriage of an unmarried daughter not only the actual expenses of her marriage but also the expenses incidental to the marriage, namely, presents at the marriage and other necessary expenses that have to be customarily incurred both before and after the actual marriage such as the expenses of the betrothal function and the nuptials that may take place after the marriage.”

7. A Division Bench of this court in CGT v. Chandrasekhara Reddy, [1976] 105 ITR 849, considered a similar question. Therein, the Division Bench considering the meaning of the word “incident” as used in Black's Law Dictionary, 4th edition, at page 904, held thus (at page 852):

“Therefore, if the giving of land is usually connected with the marriage, it can be said to be incident to the marriage”

8. In Sri N.R Raghavachariar's Hindu law — Principles and Precedents, seventh edition, (vol. I) edited by Prof. S. Venkataraman, it is stated in section 213, at page 235, that a father is under a personal obligation to maintain his unmarried daughters. After his death, the unmarried sisters are entitled to be maintained out of his estate. Even after marriage, a daughter who is not able to get maintenance from the family into which she has been married on account of its poverty can claim to be maintained by the heirs of her opulent father. In Smt. R. Seetharamama v. Land Acquisition Officer, [1979] 2 ALT 6, it was held that maintenance and marriage expenses of the daughter is a legal obligation of the father and property given to her cannot amount to a gift. In Bhubaneswar Naik Santoshrai v. Special Tahsildar, Land Reforms, AIR 1980 AP 139, the expression “intention to give away the property for the provision of marriage of a daughter or sister” is not a gift within the meaning of section 122 of the Transfer of Property Act, 1882. Therefore, it was held that non-registration thereof does not invalidate the gift made in favour of the daughter. In Mayne's Hindu Law and Usage, 12th edition, edited by Justice Alladi Kuppuswami, it is stated at page 1048 that an obligation to maintain an unmarried daughter includes an obligation to provide her marriage expenses, in view of the definition of “maintenance” under section 3(b)(ii) of this Act. As maintenance and marriage expenses of the daughter is a legal obligation of the father, property given to her cannot amount to a gift. In enacting section 3(b)(ii) which defines “maintenance” as including reasonable expenses of and incident to the marriage of a daughter, the Legislature did nothing more than codify the well settled principles of Hindu law. It is further stated that so far as the unmarried daughter is concerned, the liability of her parents has no relation to her age, and it continues so long as the daughter is unable to maintain herself. In Subbayya v. Ananda Ramayya, AIR 1929 Mad 586 [FB], per majority, the Full Bench has held that in a coparcenary consisting of father and sons, the obligation of maintaining and marrying the daughters is not only on the father and through him on the coparcenary but it is an obligation on the coparcenary itself, because such an obligation, being only a historical remnant of the daughter's original right to a share in the coparcenary property, is created by birth. It was held in that case that the son's share in the joint family, on his instituting the suit for partition against his father and brothers, is also liable for the expenses of the marriage of a sister who was married after the institution of the suit and of those who are still to be married. It is thus the settled legal position that under the Maintenance Act as well as the general Hindu law, the obligation of the father to maintain his unmarried daughter as well as the married daughter so long as the daughter is unable to maintain herself from the family, viz., to which she was given, is transformed into a legal obligation.

9. In Kudutamma v. Narasimhacharyulu, [1907] 17 Mad LJ 528, it was held by a Division Bench that a Hindu father was entitled to make gifts by way of marriage portions to his daughters out of the family property to a reasonable extent. In Sundararamayya v. Sitamma, [1911] 21 Mad LJ 695, the Division Bench upheld the validity of a gift of three acres, of ancestral land by a Hindu father to his daughter after 40 years of marriage. In Ramasami Ayyar v. Vengidusami Ayyar, [1899] ILR 22 Mad 113, another Division Bench held that a gift of land made by a widow, on the occasion of her daughter's marriage, to the bridegroom was valid. In Bachoo Hurkisondas v. Mankorebai, [1907] ILR 31 Bom 373, the Judicial Committee held that a gift by a father of a sum of Rs. 20,000 to his daughter was valid. In Devabhaktuni Sithamahalakshmamma v. Pamulpati Kotayya, AIR 1936 Mad 825, it was held that a gift of a reasonable portion of the immovable property by the father to his daughter without reference to his son was upheld. In Guramma Bharlar Chanbasappa Deshmukh v. Mallappa Chanbasappa, AIR 1964 SC 510, the father had given a life estate in a small extent to his widowed daughter in addition to what was given to her at the time of marriage as maintenance and this was upheld. While upholding the maintenance, it was laid down by Subba Rao J. (as he then was) thus: (paragraph 18 at page: 519)

“The Hindu law texts conferred a right upon a daughter or a sister, as the case may be, to have a share in the family property at the time of partition. That right was lost by efflux of time. But it became crystallized into a moral obligation. The father or his representative can make a valid gift, by way of reasonable provision for the maintenance of the daughter, regard being had to the financial and other relevant circumstances of the family. By custom or by convenience, such gifts are made at the time of marriage, but the right of the father or his representative to make such a gift is not confined to the marriage occasion. It is a normal (moral) obligation and it continues to subsist till it is discharged. Marriage is only a customary occasion for such a gift. But the obligation can be discharged at any time, either during the lifetime of the father or thereafter. It is not possible to lay down a hard and fast rule, prescribing the quantitative limits of such a gift as that would depend on the facts of each case and it can only be decided by courts, regard being had to the overall picture of the extent of the family estate, the number of daughters to be provided for and other paramount charges and other similar circumstances. If the father is within his rights to make a gift of a reasonable extent of the family property for the maintenance of a daughter, it cannot be said that the said gift must be made only by one document or only at a single point of time. The validity or the reasonableness of a gift does not depend upon the plurality of documents but on the power of the father to make a gift and the reasonableness of the gift so made. If once the power is granted and the reasonableness of the gift is not disputed, the fact that two gift deeds were executed instead of one, cannot make the gift any the less a valid one.”

10. In Smt. Kamala Devi v. Bachulal Gupta, AIR 1957 SC 434, S.K Das J., speaking for their Lordships of the Supreme Court, held in paragraph 20 thus (at page 443):

“On an examination of the decisions referred to above, the following principles clearly emerge: (1) It is the imperative religious duty and a moral obligation of a father, mother or other guardian to give a girl in marriage to a suitable husband; it is a duty which must be fulfilled to prevent degradation, and direct spiritual benefit is conferred upon the father by such a marriage……………(4) Gifts by a widow of landed property to her daughter or son-in-law on the occasion of the marriage or any ceremonies connected with the marriage, are well recognised in Hindu law. (5) If a promise is made of such a gift for or at the time of the marriage that promise may be fulfilled afterwards and it is not essential to make a gift at the time of the marriage but it may be made afterwards in fulfilment of the promise. (6) Some decisions go to the length of holding that there is a moral or religious obligation of giving a portion of the joint family property for the benefit of the daughter and the son-in-law, and a gift made long after the marriage may be supported upon the ground that the gift when made fulfils that moral or religious obligation.”

11. These cases are authorities for the proposition that gift of a property can be made even long after the marriage. A Division Bench of this court in CGT v. Chandrasekhara Reddy, [1976] 105 ITR 849, accepting the statutory obligation under section 3(b)(ii) of the Maintenance Act, held that when the Legislature enacted in section 3(b)(ii) that reasonable expenses of and incident to her marriage amount to maintenance, it was merely reenacting the position which prevailed under the general Hindu law. Therefore, both under the Hindu Adoptions and Maintenance Act as well as under the general Hindu law, the father is under an obligation to give some property to the daughter on the occasion of her marriage. We respectfully agree. This case also relates to a gift to a married daughter, long after marriage. In CGT v. Bandlamudi Subbaiah, [1980] 123 ITR 509 (AP), a similar question with regard to married and unmarried daughters arose in this court. Sambasiva Rao C.J, speaking for the Division Bench, held (at pages 511 and 512):

“It is not unoften that a Hindu undivided family announces gift of certain properties, generally lands in an agricultural State like Andhra Pradesh, on the occasion of the marriage of the daughter. The gift deed or settlement deed might not have been executed simultaneously with the marriage or the announcement.

Later when the family itself splits up on account of partition, what had been agreed upon or announced would be reduced to writing in the partition deed.”

12. On the second question with regard to the properties allotted to unmarried daughters, it was held (at page 512):

“Undoubtedly, a Hindu joint family has an obligation to maintain and get an unmarried daughter married. That right of the unmarried daughter to be maintained and to get married and the obligation of the family to do this may be inchoate, in the sense, that these rights and obligations do not attach to any specific property. But there is an undoubted right under the Hindu law of an unmarried daughter to be maintained and to get married and the corresponding obligation of the Hindu family to discharge these obligations cannot, therefore, be under any doubt. Once under a partition deed or a family settlement or a gift or other instrument certain properties are set apart for the maintenance and marriage of the unmarried daughters, then the rights of the unmarried daughters and the corresponding obligations of the family gain a coherent and concrete form. They immediately attach to the property thus allotted under the instrument. Since the property is given to the unmarried daughter in recognition of her right, in discharge of the obligation of the family, by no stretch of imagination it could be treated as a gift.”

13. When the members of the joint Hindu family allotted certain proper-, ties to the unmarried daughters at the time of the partition to discharge the binding obligation on them to maintain and to get them married, it cannot be said that the properties were given to the unmarried daughters voluntarily and without consideration in money or money's worth. If they do not make such a provision for the unmarried daughters, the Hindu family would be obliged to make some other provision. By making such provision, it has ceased to have any monetary obligation towards the unmarried daughters. What the family would have been obliged to spend in money would be given in the form of movable or immovable property. That they do, as we have already observed, not quite voluntarily but only to discharge their legal obligation. Therefore, it is not a gift within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Act. We respectfully agree with the view taken by the Division Bench. Though this case pertains to allotment of immovable properties to married and unmarried daughters at the time of partition between coparceners, there is little distinction between father simpliciter and father as member of the coparcenary. The same ratio would apply to the facts in this case.

14. Giving property to an unmarried daughter as incident to maintenance is a legal obligation cast on the father or any person receiving the property of the father except, a purchaser for valuable consideration without notice of the said right of the daughter. Equally, giving a reasonable property at the time of the marriage or subsequently in the discharge of that legal obligation, is not, thereby, a voluntary gift made by the father but is in compliance with his legal obligation. Any instrument executed by the father in discharge of that legal obligation or any settlement of a reasonable portion of the property in fulfilment of the existing legal claims of a married or unmarried daughter is not without consideration of money or money's worth as contemplated under the Act nor can it be said to be a voluntary one. Equally, the promise made at the time of the marriage of a daughter to give a reasonable portion of the property or a settlement or a gift made long after the marriage is in fulfilment of the pre-existing legal obligation of the father under the general Hindu law. Therefore, it ceases to be a voluntary act nor is it to be labelled as without consideration but is one in the discharge of a pre-existing legal obligation. Therefore, it is neither an alienation nor a transfer, attracting section 2(xii) of the Gift-tax Act, but is a family settlement. There is no taxable gift made to a married daughter. Thereby the assessee is not obliged to pay gift-tax.

15. In Chandrasekhara Reddy's case, [1976] 105 ITR 849, Divan C.J, speaking for the Division Bench, held that the Income-tax Appellate Tribunal has to go further into the question whether there is a custom in the community to discharge that obligation to execute a gift or a settlement deed subsequent to the marriage. With due deference, we express our inability to accord our approval to that view for diverse reasons. It has already been held that an opulent Hindu father is obligated to set apart a reasonable portion of the property towards maintenance of an unmarried daughter or towards marriage expenses including giving of property at the time of the marriage as incident thereto. Equally, a reasonable portion would also be given to a married daughter even after the marriage. The moral or legal obligation under general Hindu law of the father to provide a reasonable portion of the property as an incident to maintenance to an unmarried daughter under section 21 of the Maintenance Act or in discharge of a promise made at the time of the marriage to a daughter, has been transformed into a legal obligation and thereby the need to prove the existence of the custom in a particular caste or community is obviated.

16. The question of prevalence of the custom in any particular community also becomes redundant because a gift or settlement is not made in recognition of the customary right in a particular caste or community but in discharge of statutory right a daughter has and a legal obligation fastened on the father, coparcenary or anybody receiving the estate of the father, except bona fide purchaser for value without notice of the right. The essential criterion is, therefore, that the parties must be Hindus and are governed by the Hindu law. The obligation to give a reasonable portion of the property to a married or unmarried daughter is to prevent degradation or destitution or to settle a decent match for a daughter consistent with the dignity and status of the father or family. So, the custom in the community ceases to have any relevancy.

17. The problem can be broached from yet another angle that when the father has a legal obligation to provide maintenance or as incident to marriage of the unmarried daughter to provide decent allowance to a daughter and makes a promise for giving property to the son-in-law or the daughter at the time of the marriage or subsequent thereto, it may be taken that there was a family arrangement among the members of the family whereat it was agreed by the members of the family that a reasonable portion could be given to a daughter so married or towards the maintenance or marriage expenses or incidental thereto reasonable property to the unmarried daughter. Legal obligation cast on the father under the Hindu law and the Maintenance Act, is prime motive for settlement which is discharged by the father by executing subsequently the instrument and, therefore, it is not a voluntary one. So, it is a family settlement and not a gift within the meaning of section 2(xii) of the Act and the assessee is not liable to gift-tax.

18. Incidentally, it may also be mentioned that the Hindu Succession Act (Andhra Pradesh Amendment Act, 1983) introduced section 29A in Chapter IIA in the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. It provides thus:

“Equal rights to daughter in coparcenary property. —Notwithstanding anything contained in section 6 of this Act—

(i) in a joint Hindu family governed by Mitakshara law, the daughter of a coparcener shall by birth become a coparcener in her own right in the same manner as the son and have the same rights in the coparcenary property as she would have had if she had been a son, inclusive of the right to claim by survivorship; and shall be subject to the same liabilities and disabilities in respect thereto as the son;

(ii) at a partition in such a joint Hindu family the coparcenary property shall be so divided as to allot to a daughter the same share as is allottable to a son.”

and she holds the property as full owner. It is undoubtedly true that the reasonableness of the property settled upon a daughter, married or unmarried, or number of daughters, as the case may be, is to be adjusted in the light of the facts and circumstances of a given case, the totality of the property held by the father or the coparcenary and the number of daughters to whom a similar provision is to be made and also number of coparceners, etc., have to be considered. It is found as a fact that the assessee is possessed of acres 40 of wet land; besides, he is doing money-lending business; he has no sons; he has only two daughters, one married and another unmarried; and he has given to the married daughter, Sreedevi, acres 9-94 cents of land and to the unmarried daughter acres 10-40 cents of land. Therefore, settling half the property on only two daughters cannot be said to be unreasonable. Under those circumstances, the finding given by the Tribunal that it is in discharge of the pre-existing legal obligation is perfectly legal. We accordingly affirm the same.

19. The questions are accordingly answered in favour of the assessee and against the Revenue. There shall be no order as to costs.