Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Agnigundala Lead Pro... v. Hindustan Zinc Worke...

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Aug 21, 1987
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Baskaran, C.J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The core dispute concerns the dismissal of the second petitioner, M. Venkateswarlu, a driller-cum-blaster. He was placed under suspension on 5 December 1982 and ordered dismissed by the disciplinary authority (the Superintendent of Mines) on 6 March 1983. The second petitioner filed O.S. No. 20 of 1983 in the Munsiff's Court, Vinukonda, challenging the dismissal.

Workmen went on strike from 9 March 1983 in protest. The Assistant Commissioner (Conciliation) submitted a failure report on 18 March 1983 but returned to continue negotiations at the management's request on 25 March 1983. Those renewed negotiations produced a document described as "minutes of discussions" (dated 25 March 1983), which set out six clauses of agreement between the union and the management, including that the second petitioner would appeal to the Chairman-cum-Managing Director and that the management agreed to award a punishment other than dismissal, discharge or removal from service.

The settlement was signed by management and union representatives. Despite the settlement, the fourth respondent (the Chairman) disposed of the appeal by reducing the punishment to discharge (an outcome inconsistent with the clause that the punishment would not be dismissal, discharge or removal). The second petitioner challenged the order of discharge (communicated 23 July 1983) by filing Writ Petition No. 7820 of 1983.

On 3 May 1984 the Government referred the dispute to the Industrial Tribunal, Hyderabad, under S. 10(1) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947. When the writ petition was heard on 15 November 1984, the High Court dismissed it as the dispute was then before the Tribunal. The Tribunal, however, in Misc. Petn. No. 7 of 1985 in I.D. No. 36 of 1984, upheld a preliminary objection to the reference and by order and award dated 9 September 1985 rejected and terminated the reference, holding that the 25 March 1983 arrangement was a settlement binding on the management and that the discharge order was illegal.

The management did not implement the Tribunal's award; the union sent a lawyer's notice on 2 December 1985 and the management replied on 14 December 1985 denying that any award had been passed. The petitioners then filed the writ petition that was disposed of by the learned Single Judge, who set aside the fourth respondent's order of 23 July 1983, directed reinstatement of the second petitioner with continuity and consequential benefits, and assessed costs of Rs. 2,000 in favour of the second petitioner.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether there was any valid ground for interfering with the decision of the learned Single Judge that set aside the order of discharge and directed reinstatement and other reliefs in favour of the second petitioner.
  2. Whether the document dated 25 March 1983 (described as "minutes of discussions") constituted a valid and binding settlement within S. 2(p) (and S. 12(3) / S. 18 where relevant) of the Industrial Disputes Act, 1947.
  3. Whether a settlement reached after the Conciliation Officer submitted a failure report (dated 18 March 1983) can be binding on the parties.
  4. Whether the management's representatives who signed the 25 March 1983 document had authority to bind the management, and whether the formality requirements (including rule 58 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules) were essential to the settlement's validity.
  5. Whether the reference under S. 10(1) of the Act to the Industrial Tribunal (made on 3 May 1984) was valid in light of the 25 March 1983 settlement and the Tribunal's later finding that the reference was bad and terminated.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant (Management) — submissions by Sri K. Sreenivasa Murthy

  • The 25 March 1983 document was not a settlement within S. 12(3) of the Act; it was only "minutes of discussions".
  • The document did not constitute an agreement under S. 18 (sub-sections (1) and (3)) and therefore did not bind the parties.
  • The persons who signed the document were not officers authorized to conclude a settlement on behalf of the management.
  • The settlement was not in the form prescribed by rule 58 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules and therefore was not binding on the management.
  • Because the Conciliation Officer had earlier submitted a failure report on 18 March 1983, a later document dated 25 March 1983 could not be treated as a settlement under S. 12(3) of the Act.
  • The management relied on several authorities (cases) in support of these contentions.

Respondents / Petitioners

  • The petitioners implemented their part of the obligations under the 25 March 1983 arrangement and relied on it as a settlement binding on the management.
  • The union (second respondent-writ petitioner) later told the court it was not interested in any penal action being taken against the appellants; consequently a direction for penal action in the Single Judge's judgment was deleted by the court on that basis.
  • The Industrial Tribunal had already ruled (9 September 1985) that the 25 March 1983 arrangement was a settlement binding on the management; that award was not appealed and had therefore become final.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Workmen of Delhi Cloth and General Mills, Ltd. v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills, Ltd. (1971 — I L.L.J 99) Cited by the management to support the proposition that the post-failure report document did not amount to a binding settlement (or to challenge the binding nature of the 25 March 1983 document). The court examined the decisions and concluded that the facts and circumstances in those cases were quite different from the instant case and therefore the precedent did not govern the result here; the management's reliance on it was rejected.
Jhagrakhan Collieries (Private), Ltd. v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Jabalpur [1974 — II L.L.N 511] Cited by the management in support of its contention that the 25 March 1983 document was not a binding settlement. The court found the factual matrix of the cited decision to be different and declined to apply it to defeat the settlement's binding character in the present case.
Brooke Bond India, Ltd. v. Their Workmen [1981 — II L.L.N 286] Cited by the management to challenge the binding status of the "minutes of discussions." The court held that the circumstances of the Brooke Bond case differed materially from the present facts and therefore the management could not rely on it to avoid the settlement obligations.
Air India v. Nergesh Meerza [1981 — II L.L.N 57???] Cited by the management (Bombay High Court decision cited before the court) to support the contention that the document was not a binding settlement. The court observed that facts leading to decisions in the cited cases, including this one, were different and declined to treat those authorities as determinative; the management's reliance on them was rejected.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court undertook a fact-sensitive analysis and explained why it would not disturb the Single Judge's decision. The reasoning follows these principal strands, rendered here in the sequence the court treated them:

  1. Nature and effect of the 25 March 1983 document: The court accepted the conclusion of the learned Single Judge and the Industrial Tribunal that the "minutes of discussions" constituted a settlement within the meaning of S. 2(p) of the Industrial Disputes Act. The basis for this conclusion as set out by the court included that the settlement had been signed by responsible and senior management officers and was acted upon by the workmen (who called off the strike).
  2. Authority of management representatives: The court rejected the management's contention that the signatories lacked authority. The court found it implausible that the Chairman and the management were not aware of the terms pursuant to which the strike was called off and declined to accept that the management's representatives acted without authorization or beyond their authority.
  3. Conduct and good faith: The court characterized the management's conduct as having "taken full advantage" of the settlement and then acting "vindictively and dishonestly" to repudiate its commitments. The court viewed this behaviour as inconsistent with promoting industrial peace and not something courts should condone.
  4. Effect of the Industrial Tribunal's decision: The Industrial Tribunal had on 9 September 1985 held that the 25 March 1983 arrangement was a valid settlement binding on the management and that the reference was bad and terminated. The court noted that the Tribunal's award had not been appealed and thus had become final. This final award substantially fortified the view that there remained no dispute to be adjudicated when the Government referred the matter.
  5. Legal question whether post-failure settlements bind the parties: The court stated that it had not been shown any authority to the effect that a settlement reached after the Conciliation Officer had submitted a failure report is not binding. In consequence, the court affirmed the Single Judge's acceptance of the Tribunal's finding that the 25 March 1983 settlement was binding despite the earlier failure report dated 18 March 1983.
  6. Precedents relied on by management: The court considered the authorities cited by the management but found that the factual situations in those cases were materially different and that they did not control the outcome here. Accordingly, the court rejected the management's reliance on those precedents.
  7. Remedies and directions: The court confirmed the Single Judge's setting aside of the fourth respondent's order dated 23 July 1983 that had imposed a penalty of "discharge" and directed reinstatement with continuity of service and all consequential benefits. The court also addressed the Single Judge's suggestion that the Labour Commissioner take action under S. 29 read with S. 32 of the Act, but, on the second respondent's express representation that no penal action was sought, the court deleted that direction.
  8. Final practical directions: Rather than interfering with the substance of the Single Judge's reliefs, the court directed the fourth appellant (the Chairman) to consider the appeal filed by the second respondent under Clause (2) of the 25 March 1983 agreement and to pass appropriate orders within two weeks from receipt of a copy of the judgment. The court reiterated that in terms of Clause (2) the management could impose only punishment other than dismissal, discharge or removal and thus the second respondent should be reinstated (if not already done) within two weeks from receipt of the judgment, with continuity of service and consequential benefits.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ appeal is dismissed.

Direct consequences and instructions imposed by the court:

  • The Single Judge's order setting aside the fourth respondent's order dated 23 July 1983 (which imposed the penalty of discharge) remains in force.
  • The fourth appellant (Chairman, Hindustan Zinc Ltd.) is directed to consider the appeal dated 25 March 1983 filed by the second respondent in terms of Clause (2) of the agreement dated 25 March 1983 and to pass appropriate orders within two weeks of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
  • In accordance with Clause (2) of the 25 March 1983 agreement (which limited permissible punishment to options other than dismissal, discharge or removal), the second respondent-writ petitioner shall be reinstated into service (if not already reinstated) within two weeks of receipt of a copy of this judgment.
  • The second respondent is entitled to continuity of service and all consequential benefits, monetary or otherwise, as if he had continued in service from the date of dismissal.
  • The earlier direction in the Single Judge's judgment that the Labour Commissioner take action under S. 29 read with S. 32 of the Act has been deleted, because the second respondent told the court he did not seek penal action against the appellants.
  • No costs were awarded against the parties by the disposing court of the writ appeal ("No costs").

Broader implication: The court treated the combination of objective indicia — signed minutes, implementation by the union (calling off the strike), and the Industrial Tribunal's final award rejecting the reference — as determinative that a post-failure conciliation settlement was binding. The court therefore refused to permit the management to avoid its commitments on technical grounds concerning formality or asserted lack of authority.

Show all summary ...

Baskaran, C.J:— The short point that falls for decision in this appeal at the instance of the management is whether there is any valid ground for interference with the decision of the learned Single Judge, who disposed of the writ petition granting substantial reliefs to respondent 2 herein.

2. In the course of the discussion, parties will be referred to as they were arrayed in the writ petition. The facts having been narrated in great detail in the judgment appealed against, there appears to be no need for repetition. Suffice it to notice the facts in brief. The second petitioner, a driller-cum-blaster in the company placed under suspension pending enquiry on 5 December 1982, was ordered to be dismissed by the disciplinary authority, second respondent (Superintendent of Mines) on 6 March 1983, accepting the enquiry report. The second petitioner had filed O.S No. 20 of 1983 in the Munsiff's Court, Vinukonda, against the order of dismissal. The workmen went on strike with effect from 9 March, 1983 in protest against the dismissal of the second petitioner. Though the Assistant Commissioner (C) of Labour, who conciliated the dispute raised by the first petitioner-union in regard to the dismissal of the second petitioner, submitted a failure report on 18 March 1983, he went over to the company at the request of the management on 25 March 1983, to continue to explore the possibility of a settlement in view of the prevailing strike. The renewed negotiations that day yielded a settlement found on pages 56-57 of the material papers filed along with the writ appeal, described as “minutes of discussions” (annexure II). The terms of that settlement are as follows:

“(1) The union regretted for what has happened with effect from 9 March, 1983 and both the union and management condemned violence from any corner.

(2) Since Sri M. Venkateswarlu, driller-cum-blaster assistant, has not exhausted the provisions of appeal, it is agreed that Sri Venkateswarlu will appeal to the Chairman-cum-Managing Director which in turn will be forwarded by the Superintendent of Mines, for decision within 15 days. The management has agreed to award punishment other than dismissal, discharge or removal from service.

(3) The union will call off the strike which commenced on 8 March, 1983 with immediate effect.

(4) Such of those employees who have got leave may apply for leave for the period of their absence from 9 March, 1983 and management will sanction the same in case if they are entitled for any leave. In all other cases the employees will be treated as on leave without pay.

(5) In view of this understanding the employee who filed a case in the Court of Munsiff Magistrate, Vinukonda, and the management which filed a suit for vacation of injunction order in the Court of Subordinate Judge, Narasaraopet, will withdraw the cases.

(6) No disciplinary action will be taken against workers who are on strike for their absence.”

This settlement was signed by four representatives of the management and five representatives of the union. The management representatives included the Superintendent of Mines, the Manager (Mill) and the Senior Engineer (Mining). Though the petitioners implemented their part of the obligations, the fourth respondent-Chairman disposed of the appeal filed by the second petitioner in terms of Cl. (2) of the settlement, reducing the punishment only to discharge from dismissal though the understanding was that the punishment would not be dismissal, discharge or removal from service. Aggrieved by the order of dismissal communicated on 23 July 1983, the second petitioner filed Writ Petition No. 7820 of 1983. Thereafter, by the order, dated 3 May 1984, the Government of India referred the dispute between the management and the union, relating to the award of punishment of discharge to the second petitioner, under S. 10(1), Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 (the Act), to the Industrial Tribunal, Hyderabad, for adjudication. When the writ petition came up for final hearing on 15 November 1984, this Court took the view that the dispute having been referred to the Industrial Tribunal, the proper forum for settling the dispute was that Tribunal before which the dispute was pending. Accordingly, the writ petition was dismissed. Before the Tribunal, in Miscellaneous Petition No. 7 of 1985, in I.D No. 36 of 1984 the first petitioner-union raised a preliminary objection in regard to the validity of the reference. The Tribunal by the order, dated 9 September 1985, upheld that objection and rejected and terminated the reference. On the same day, the Tribunal also passed an award in I.D No. 36 of 1984 to the effect that the reference was bad and it stood terminated. The Tribunal held that the arrangement, dated 25 March 1983, was a clear settlement arrived at in the course of conciliation proceedings and, therefore, the management could not go back; it was not a settlement arrived at as a result of fraud, misrepresentation or undue influence; there was no such contention also hence the reference was bad and was not maintainable, and that the settlement was binding upon the management. The Tribunal observed that it was open to the Chairman-cum- Managing Director (fourth respondent) to apply his mind to award a punishment other than dismissal, discharge or removal from service on the second petitioner as per the understanding arrived at on 25 March 1983, and that the order of discharge passed against the second petitioner was illegal. The management not having implemented its part of the obligations under the settlement even after the Industrial Tribunal passed the order and award, dated 9 September 1985, rejecting and terminating the reference, a lawyer notice was issued on behalf of the first petitioner-union on 2 December 1985, demanding the implementation of the award. To this, a reply, dated 14 December 1985, was sent by the management stating that the question of implementing the award did not arise as no award had been passed by the Industrial Tribunal. It is thereafter the petitioners filed the present writ petition seeking the reinstatement of the second petitioner into service with continuity of service and back-wages and other allied reliefs. The learned Single Judge in an elaborate judgment rejected the technical contentions raised on behalf of the management, and upheld the Industrial Tribunal's view that the minutes of discussions, dated 25 March 1983, constituted a valid settlement within the meaning of S. 2 (p) of the Act, and that the settlement was clearly binding on the employer and also on the workmen. The Judge set aside the order of the fourth respondent - Chairman, dated 23 July 1983, and directed the reinstatement of the second petitioner into service with entitlement to continuity of service and all consequential benefits, monetary and otherwise, as if he continued to be in service right from the date when he was dismissed from service, within one week from the date of the receipt of the copy of the judgment. The arrears found due on the basis of the above direction was ordered to be ascertained and paid to 1 December, 1985 demanding the implementation of the date of the receipt of the copy of the judgment. The management was directed to pay to the second petitioner his costs assessed at Rs. 2,000.

3. Before us Sri K. Sreenivasa Murthy, learned counsel for the management, contended that the so-called settlement, dated 25 March 1983, was no settlement of the dispute arrived at in the course of the conciliation proceedings within the meaning of S. 12(3) of the Act. It was also submitted that it did not amount to a settlement arrived at by agreement between the employer and workman otherwise than in the course of conciliation proceedings so as to bind the parties to the agreement in terms of Sub-secs. (1) and (3) of S. 18 of the Act. It was the submission of the learned counsel that what was recorded on 25 March 1983, was only the minutes of discussions, not a settlement; those who signed that document were not officers who could enter into any settlement; and that the settlement not having been in the form prescribed in rule 58 of the Industrial Disputes (Central) Rules, it was not binding on the management. He had also a contention that in view of the failure report submitted by the Conciliation Officer on 18 March 1983, the settlement, dated 25 March 1983, could not be deemed to be a settlement under S. 12(3) of the Act. The decisions of the Supreme Court in Workmen of Delhi Cloth and General Mills, Ltd. v. Delhi Cloth and General Mills, Ltd. (1971 — I L.L.J 99], Jhagrakhan Collieries (Private), Ltd. v. Central Government Industrial Tribunal-cum-Labour Court, Jabalpur [1974 — II L.L.N 511] and Brooke Bond India, Ltd. v. Their workmen [1981-II L.L.N 286], and a decision of the Bombay High Court in Air India v. Nergesh Meerza [1981-II L.L.N 57???], were cited before us. We have carefully gone through these decisions, and are of the opinion that the facts and circumstances leading to the decision in those cases are quite different from those present in the instant case. This is a clear case where the management is guilty of dishonouring its commitments under a settlement, whether it is called the “understanding” or the “minutes of discussions.” The management took full advantage of the terms of the settlement, in implementation of which the workmen on their part called off the strike. The settlement was signed by responsible officers holding high ranks in the company and it is too much for us to swallow the contention of the management that the officers who represented the management at the conciliation proceedings on 25 March, 1983 had acted either without authorisation or in excess of the authorisation given to them. Are we to believe that the Chairman and the management were not apprised of the terms of the agreement pursuant to which the strike was called off by the union? We have absolutely no hesitation in rejecting the contention that it was without due authorisation that the management's representatives agreed to the terms of settlement, or that the Chairman and the management were not aware of the terms of the agreement. The truth, on the other hand, is that after having trapped the union into an agreement and after having taken advantage of that agreement, the management acted vindictively and dishonestly against the terms of agreement on the pretext that the settlement was not binding on the management. Moreover, on 9 September 1985, the Industrial Tribunal has passed an award stating that the agreement, dated 25 March 1983, was a settlement binding on the management. The award of the Tribunal, not having been appealed against, has become final. This arrogant and arbitrary attitude of the management is not certainly praiseworthy, and is not conducive for the promotion and maintenance of industrial peace and harmony. The union and the management are not equal in withstanding prolonged litigation; and other things being equal, to further the ends of justice, the Court should normally lean towards the weak, namely, the workmen. Both the Industrial Tribunal and the learned Single Judge have, on careful consideration of the facts and the circumstances of the case, entered the findings that the agreement, dated 25 March 1983, was a settlement within the meaning of S. 2(p) of the Act, and that it is binding on the management. The direction given by the learned Single Judge is without prejudice to the right of the first respondent-management to pass a fresh order within two weeks from the date of the receipt of the copy of the judgment in terms of the settlement arrived at on 25 March 1983.

4. We have not been shown any authority to the effect that a settlement arrived at, whether in the course of a conciliation proceeding or otherwise, subsequent to the submission of the failure report by the Conciliation Officer, is not binding on the parties. It is precisely for this reason the learned Single Judge upheld the finding of the Industrial Tribunal that in view of the settlement arrived at on 25 March 1983, though it was after the Conciliation Officer submitted the failure report on 18 March 1983, there was, as on 3 May 1984, only a settlement to be implemented, not a dispute surviving to be referred by the Central Government to the Tribunal for adjudication. The order and award, dated 9 September 1985, passed by the Tribunal that the reference was not valid and was liable to be rejected and terminated were accordingly upheld by the learned Single Judge.

5. In Para. 20 of the judgment appealed against, the learned Single Judge has stated: “it is for the Labour Commissioner to take such action as he may consider appropriate under S. 29 read with S. 32 of the Act,” expressing the opinion that the management had committed breach of the settlement arrived at on 25 March 1983. When the matter came up for hearing, the learned counsel for the second respondent - writ petitioner submitted that the writ-petitioner was not interested in any penal action being taken against any of the appellants. Recording this submission, we delete the direction to the Labour Commissioner for action under S. 29 read with S. 32 of the Act contained in Para. 20 of the learned Single Judge's judgment.

6. We would dispose of this writ appeal directing the fourth appellant, the Chairman, Hindustan Zinc, Ltd., to consider the appeal, dated 25 March 1983, filed by the second respondent-writ petitioner in terms of Cl. (2) of the agreement, dated 25 March 1983, and pass appropriate orders within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. The learned Single Judge has already set aside the impugned order of the fourth appellant, dated 23 July 1983, imposing penalty of discharge instead of dismissal from service. The order of the learned Single Judge, so far as the setting aside of the order is concerned, would stand. Inasmuch as, in terms of Cl. (2) of the agreement, dated 25 March 1983, the management is entitled to impose only punishment other than dismissal, discharge or removal from service, the second respondent-writ petitioner, as directed by the learned Single Judge, shall be reinstated into service, which ought to have been done long ago. But if it has not been done till now, it should be done within two weeks from the date of receipt of a copy of this judgment. As held by the learned Single Judge, the second respondent - writ - petitioner shall be entitled to claim continuity of service and all consequential benefits, monetary or otherwise, as it he continued to be in service right from the date when he was dismissed from service.

7. The writ appeal is dismissed in the above terms. No costs.