Login
  • Bookmark
  • PDF
  • Share
  • CaseIQ

Sheela v. Jeevanlal .

Andhra Pradesh High Court
Dec 24, 1986
Important Paras
Please sign up to view Important Paras.
Smart Summary (Beta)

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Amareswari, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

This appeal concerns the custody of three minor children: a boy of 13 years, a girl aged 12 years and a boy of 10 years. The appellant (Sheela) and respondent (Jeevanlal), both Hindus, were married on 28-6-1972 and had three children; the last child was born in 1977. After the birth of the last child the appellant underwent a tubectomy operation.

The appellant's case was that the respondent treated the family badly, came home drunk, abused the wife and children, played cards and kept bad company. She stated that in September, 1985 he drove her out and she took a separate house in Olettuguda next to her mother's home. To support the children she took employment as a teacher in Pratapagiri Memorial School on a stated salary of Rs. 1,200/- per month.

In 1984 the appellant filed O.P. No. 297 of 1984 for divorce on grounds of desertion and cruelty; the O.P. was allowed ex parte on 5-12-1984. After waiting six months she married William (a Christian) on 10-6-1985 under the Special Marriage Act, though she did not change her religion. On 11-6-1985 the respondent filed a petition to set aside the ex parte decree and the petitions to set aside were allowed; the wife carried the matter in revision to the High Court unsuccessfully. The divorce petition on the ground of cruelty remained pending.

During these proceedings the respondent attempted to take away the children. The appellant then filed O.S. No. 1994 of 1984 in the Court of the VIIIth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court, for an injunction restraining the husband from interfering with custody; the Civil Court ordered status quo as on 12-6-1985. Thereafter the respondent filed O.P. No. 137 of 1985 for custody of the children under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890, later amended to include Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956.

At trial both parties presented evidence. The trial Court allowed the father's petition and granted custody to him. The wife (appellant) appealed against that order, and this opinion arises from that appeal. The appellate court (Amareswari, J.) heard the appeal, interviewed the children in chambers, received additional evidence (bank passbook and a sterilisation certificate) and ultimately allowed the appeal, setting aside the order of the court below. The opinion concludes with "Appeal allowed" and an order of no costs.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Which person should be entrusted with the custody of the three minor children — the father (respondent) as natural guardian or the mother (appellant) — when the father's petition under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 (amended to include Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956) is opposed by the mother?
  2. How should the court apply the statutory principle that the welfare of the minor is the paramount consideration (Section 13 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 and Section 17(1) of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890) in determining custody here?
  3. To what extent should the mother's remarriage to a person of a different religion (a Christian) and her continued Hindu status affect the custody decision?
  4. What weight should be given to (a) the children's expressed preference, (b) the financial positions of the parents, and (c) allegations of cruelty and the father's alleged vices (drinking, spending on bad habits) in deciding custody?

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments (Wife)

  • The trial Court committed a serious error in granting custody to the father by ignoring the paramount consideration of the welfare of the minors.
  • The trial Court relied on incorrect circumstances: (1) that the wife has married a Christian, (2) that she has no independent source of livelihood, and (3) that it is not advisable after remarriage for the children to remain with the mother.
  • The mother contended the husband was addicted to vices, a drunkard, and spent his salary on bad habits; therefore the minors' interests would be adversely affected if entrusted to him.
  • The mother emphasised her employment (teacher) and that she had taken up work to support the children, receiving a salary she stated as Rs. 1,200/- per month (and later produced bank passbook showing Rs. 1,125/- monthly entries).

Respondent's Arguments (Father)

  • The father is the natural guardian and cannot be deprived of that right on flimsy or light grounds.
  • The mother, having married a Christian, cannot be expected to act in the interests of the minors and it is not safe to entrust custody to her.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Shila v. Soli Phirozsha Shroff, AIR 1981 Bom 175 Conversion to a different faith or remarriage to a person of a different religion is not a disqualification for custody so long as the guardian is capable of providing a congenial, comfortable and happy home for the minor. The court relied on this precedent to hold that the mother's remarriage to a person belonging to a different religion cannot be treated as a negative factor where she remained a Hindu, contributed to a stable home (husband sends money from Kuwait), and otherwise was capable of providing for the children.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court began by identifying and applying the relevant statutory provisions: the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 (an earlier Act), and the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 (a later Act). The court noted that Section 2 of the 1956 Act provides that its provisions are in addition to and not in derogation of the Guardians and Wards Act, and that Section 6 of the 1956 Act designates the father as the natural guardian of a Hindu minor (for a boy or an unmarried girl), the mother coming next. However, those rights are not absolute: Section 13 of the 1956 Act makes the welfare of the minor the paramount consideration in appointment or declaration of guardianship by a court, and Section 17(1) of the 1890 Act lists relevant factors to consider (age, sex and religion of the minor, character and capacity of the proposed guardian, nearness/kinship, and the minor's intelligent preference if old enough).

Applying these statutory principles, the court examined the evidence:

  • The court interviewed all three children in chambers. The eldest boy (about 13) and the girl (about 12) gave intelligent answers and expressed that they could not live without their mother and did not want to live with their father. The third boy (younger) expressed the same preference but was considered too young to form an opinion. The court noted it is desirable that siblings who lived together should remain together.
  • The mother's financial position was examined. While the trial court had observed no proof of her income, the appellant produced a bank passbook as additional evidence showing monthly salary entries of Rs. 1,125 and employment from 1983 onwards (marked Ex. B-11). The court admitted this relevant evidence. The mother was thus found to be employed and drawing a higher salary than the respondent, whose gross salary had been stated as Rs. 843/- with a net of about Rs. 600 and odd (and elsewhere noted as about Rs. 640/-), and who had to support aged parents and other family members.
  • The court considered the mother's remarriage to a Christian. It noted the legal position from precedent (Shila v. Shroff) that conversion or remarriage to a person of a different religion is not a disqualification for custody if the guardian can provide a congenial and comfortable home. Here the mother had not changed her religion and remained a Hindu; her second marriage was solemnized under the Special Marriage Act. The court also took into account that the second husband worked in Kuwait and regularly sent money, and that the mother had undergone sterilisation (certificate produced showing sterilisation on 18-7-1977), removing concerns about new children.
  • Allegations of cruelty by the father and that he drove the mother out were noted, but the court emphasized the controlling inquiry remains the minors' welfare. The court observed there was "nothing against the mother which prejudicially affects the Children."
  • Balancing the statutory factors, the children's expressed preference (the two older children being old enough to form an intelligent preference), the mother's better financial position and family support (her mother to help when she was at work), and absence of disqualifying factors tied to religion or capacity, the court concluded that custody with the mother better served the paramount consideration of the minors' welfare.

Holding and Implications

APPEAL ALLOWED — custody of the three minor children is to remain with the mother (appellant), and the order of the trial Court granting custody to the father is set aside.

Direct consequences:

  • The appellate court allowed the appeal and set aside the trial court's order awarding custody to the father.
  • No costs were imposed.

Broader implications:

The opinion applies the established statutory principle that the welfare of the minor is the paramount consideration (Section 13 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956, read with Section 17 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890) and follows precedent (Shila v. Soli Phirozsha Shroff) that remarriage to or association with a person of a different religion does not automatically disqualify a mother from custody if she can provide a congenial and comfortable home. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying these principles to the facts of this case.


Source: Opinion of Amareswari, J., as provided. This summary is limited strictly to information contained in the provided opinion and does not add or infer facts beyond that text.

Show all summary ...

Amareswari, J.:— This appeal relates to the custody of three minor children, a boy of 13 years, a girl aged 12 years and a boy of 10 years. The appellant sheela was married to the respondent Jeevanlal, both Hindus on 28-6-1972. The respondent was working as a Chowkidar in the Chief Engineer's Office, Picket, Secunderabad drawing a gross salary of Rs. 843/- and after deductions a net of Rs. 600/- and odd. The appellant was a housewife at the time of marriage. They had three children, two sons and one daughter. The last child was born in 1977. After the birth of the last child, the appellant underwent tubectomy operation. According to the appellant-wife, the husband respondent never treated the family well, he was coming home in a drunken state and was often abusing the wife and children. He was playing cards and keeping bad company. It is her case that in September, 1985, he drove her out. She had taken a separate house in Olettuguda, next to the house of her mother and ever since, she has been residing there. The children who were till then studying in the defence school were admitted in the English Medium schools at Mettuguda, so that they may be nearer to their new home. To support herself and the children, the appellant had taken up a job and she was working as a Teacher in Pratapagiri Memorial School on a salary of Rs. 1200/- per month. In the year 1984, she filed O.P No. 297 of 1984 for divorce on the grounds of desertion and cruelty by the husband. The O.P was allowed on 5-12-1984 and an ex parte decree of divorce was passed After waiting for six months, she married one William on 10-6-1985. The marriage was solemnized under the Special Marriage Act. Mr. Williams is a Christian. She has not changed her religion.

2. On 11-6-1985 i.e, the next day after her marriage with Williams, the husband filed a petition to set aside the ex parte order after condoning the delay. The said petitions were allowed and the ex parte decree was set aside. The wife carried the matter in revision to the High Court unsuccessfully. The petition for divorce on the ground of cruelty is pending.

3. During these proceedings, the respondent husband made an attempt to take away the children. The wife then filed O.S No. 1994 of 1984 in the Court of the VIIIth Assistant Judge, City Civil Court for an injunction restraining the husband from interfering with the custody of children. The Civil Court ordered status quo as on 12-6-1985 (Ex. A-2). The Children are thus with the mother always.

4. Thereafter the husband filed O.P No. 137 of 1985 out of which the present appeal arises for custody of the children under Section 25 of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. Later he amended the petition by including Section 6 of the Hindu Minority and Guardian ship Act, 1956.

5. The appellant resisted the petition contending that the husband was addicted to all vices, that he is a drunkard, he spends the entire salary on his bad habits and the minors' interests would be adversely affected if they are entrusted to the father. She also stated that he has a large family with parents, two sisters and three brothers and the meagre income he gets is hardly sufficient to have a decent living. She further stated that she has taken up the employment only to support the children and she gets a salary of Rs. 1200/- per month.

6. In support of their contentions, the parties adduced evidence. On an evaluation of the material on record, the trial Court allowed the petition of the father and granted custody of the children to him.

7. Aggrieved thereby the wife has now come up in this appeal. The main contention of Mr. R.V Subba Rao the learned counsel for the appellant is that the trial Court has committed a serious error in granting custody of the minor children to the father ignoring the paramount consideration, namely, the welfare of the minors. It is submitted that the circumstances relied upon by the Court below, namely (1) that the wife has married a Christian, (2) That she has no independent source of livelihood and (3) that it is not advisible after remarriage by the wife to keep the children with her are incorrect.

8. On the other hand, it is contended by Mr. Suryakiran Reddy, the learned Counsel for the Respondent that the father is the natural guardian and he cannot be deprived of that right on flimsy and light grounds, that the mother who has married a Christian cannot he expected to act in the interests of the minors and that it is not safe to entrust custody of the children to such a woman.

To decide this controversy, it is necessary to refer to the relevant provisions of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890 and the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956. The Guardians and Wards Act is the earlier Act and the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act of 1956 is the later Act, S. 2 of the later Act says that the provisions of the Act shall be in addition to and not in derogation of the Guardians and Wards Act, 1890. The present petition is admittedly filed after the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act, 1956 came into force. We find there is not much difference in the provisions concerning the custody of the children between the two Acts. S. 6 of the later Act says that the natural guardian of a Hindu minor in the case of a boy or an unmarried girl is the father and after him the mother. We are not concerned with the other provisions as they have no relevancy to the present case. The reason for conferring such a right on the father is apparent, namely that in our society it is usually the male member that earns the bread for the family. But in reality it is the mother who devotes all her life for the children looking after their interests. However, the rights of the father or mother are not absolute. They are subject to the other provisions of the Act. Section 13 of the Hindu Minority and Guardianship Act is as follows:

“13. Welfare of minor to be paramount consideration:— (1) in the appointment or declaration of any person as guardian of a Hindu minor by a Court, the welfare of the minor shall be the paramount consideration.”

Thus it is plain that it is the minors' welfare and their welfare alone that is relevant and any right of the father or the mother is subordinate to that. S. 17 of the 1890 Act prescribes the matters to be taken into consideration in appointing guardian. S. 17(1) which emphasises on the welfare of the minor says that regard must be had to the age, sex and religion of the minor, besides the character and capacity of proposed guardian and his nearness or kinship to the minor and if the minor is old enough to form an intelligent preference, to give consideration to that also.

9. Bearing these principles contained in S. 13 read with S. 17, we will now examine the evidence in the case. Out of the three minor children, two are boys and one is a girl aged about 12 years. To ascertain their wishes, we have interviewed them in the chambers. The eldest boy aged about 13 years gave very intelligent answers and said that he cannot live without his mother, that she bestows a lot of attention on all the children and that they do not want to live with their father. The girl who is aged about 12 years also expressed in the same manner. Both the minors appear to understand life and matters and are aged enough to exercise a preference. The third boy also said the same thing, but he is too young to form an opinion. But all the three lived together from their childhood and it is desirable that they should all stay together. They indicated their preference in favour of the mother.

10. The appellant is employed as a teacher and gets a salary of about Rs. 1200/- per month. The trial Court observed that there was no proof of her income. Now, she filed her Bank pass Book showing her monthly salary as Rs. 1125/- as additional evidence. The entries in the pass book show that she is employed from 1983 onwards. Since this is a relevant piece of evidence, we deem it fit to allow the petition. The pass book is marked as Ex. B-11. The Mother is employed and drawing a higher salary than the respondent, who gets a net salary of about Rs. 640/- and he has to support his aged parents and number of sisters and brothers. The children were always with the mother right from the time of their birth and there can be no substitute for the affection and love of a mother.

11. The only factor to be considered is whether it would be in the interests of the minors to entrust the custody to the mother, who married another man belonging to a different relegion.

12. In Shila v. Soli Phirozsha Shroff, AIR 1981 Bom 175, it was held that conversion to a different faith cannot be regarded as a disqualification for custody of the minor so long as the guardian is capable of providing a congenial, comfortable and a happy home for the minor. In the present case, the mother has remarried six months after she obtained a decree of divorce. Thus, she married a person belonging to a different religion. But she has not changed her religion. She still remains a Hindu. The marriage was solemnized under the Special Marriage Act. Her Second husband is working in Kuwait, he sends her money regularly. She supplements that with her income. After the birth of the last child in 1977 i.e, and before her second marriage, she had undergone tubectomy operation and there is no chance of having any more children. She has now filed a certificate to that effect by way of additional evidence before us. The certificate is issued by a Doctor attached to the Government Maternity Hospital, Hyderabad that she underwent sterilisation on 18-7-1977. We see no reason to disallow this relevant piece of evidence. It is accordingly ordered. In fact, no counter is filed to the petition for receiving the additional evidence. In the circumstances, the second marriage of the mother with a person belonging to a different religion cannot be a negative factor.

13. Serious allegations are made against the respondent, that he was treating the appellant cruelly and has driven her out. Whatever might be the truth of these allegations, the fact remains that there are differences between the parties and they are living separately. The Divorce proceedings are pending. What is to be done with the Children? We think that in the interests and welfare of the minors, they should be allowed to remain with the mother. This is also their wish. The mother is better placed financially and has the help of her mother to look after the children when she is away at School. There is nothing against the mother which prejudicially affects the Children.

14. In the result, we allow the appeal and set aside the order of the Court below. No costs.

Appeal allowed.