- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
Aitha Narasaiah & Co. And Another v. The State Of Andhra Pradesh And Another (And Other Cases)
Structured Summary of the Opinion — Tax on Paddy and Reimbursement on Rice Exported in Inter-State Trade
Factual and Procedural Background
The petitions arise from a common question: when "rice" is taxed under the Central Sales Tax Act (Central Act, 74 of 1956), whether tax paid earlier on paddy (out of which that rice was procured) must be reimbursed to the exporter. Several dealers who had paid tax on paddy claimed reimbursement. In one instance revenue initially reimbursed and then rescinded that order; in other instances, dealers anticipated rescission proceedings after the State Government issued instructions (R.O. No. B/7000284/76 dated 14 Feb 1977) and filed writ petitions seeking to restrain revenue authorities from invoking rescission.
Representative factual details from several writ petitions before the Court include:
- M/s Sri Dhanalakshmi Rice Company, Nellore — returned inter-State turnover of rice Rs. 4,47,290 for 7 Sept 1976 to 31 Mar 1977; showed rice procured out of paddy purchased for Rs. 3,04,688 which had borne State tax Rs. 12,436. Claim for reimbursement was made in May 1978 and rejected; revision rejected under Section 20 of the State Act (Writ Petition No. 3285/1978).
- M/s Pratesh Traders, Nellore — inter-State rice turnover Rs. 1,93,973 procured out of paddy purchased for Rs. 1,34,268; tax on paddy Rs. 5,371. Claim for reimbursement made in May 1978 and rejected; revision rejected under Section 20 (Writ Petition No. 3286/1978).
- M/s Tadikonda Mallaiah & Sons — assessment finalised 13 Sept 1977 for inter-State rice turnover Rs. 98,781; rebate of tax Rs. 8,661.08 initially granted was rescinded by order dated 18 June 1978 (Writ Petition No. 2948/1978).
- Other petitioners (e.g., Sri Vijayalakshmi Rice and Oil Mill; Lakshmi Vilas Rice and Oil Mill; M/s Aitha Narasaiah & Co.; M/s Sri Laxmi Narasimha & Co.; M/s Manchala Prabhakar; Y. Venkatanarayana; M/s Vauhini Trading Co.) similarly sought reimbursement or declarations that they were not liable to pay purchase/sales tax on paddy or alternatively reduction of central tax on rice by the amount of State tax levied on paddy.
Legal Issues Presented
- When rice is taxed under the Central Sales Tax Act (in the course of inter-State trade), does the tax paid on the paddy (out of which that rice is produced) have to be reimbursed or reduced from the tax leviable on that rice?
- Whether dealers who purchased paddy are liable to pay purchase/sales tax in respect of such paddy where the rice produced from that paddy is sold in inter-State trade (i.e., can they claim exemption or reimbursement)?
- Whether provisions of Section 8(2A) of the Central Act (and related provisions) which make central tax calculable by reference to State rates prevent reimbursement when the State and Central rates are the same (i.e., does equality of rate preclude reimbursement)?
- Whether paddy and rice are to be treated as the same or different commodities for purposes of taxation under the State and Central Acts (which affects whether tax on paddy can be set off against tax on rice)?
- Whether any entitlement to reimbursement exists where paddy has been imported into the State (raised by the State Government as a possible bar)?
Arguments of the Parties
Dealers / Petitioners
- Claimed reimbursement of the tax paid on paddy for the period 7 Sept 1976 to 31 Mar 1977, on the ground that rice exported in inter-State trade had been procured out of paddy which had borne State tax.
- Some petitioners sought a declaration that they were not liable to pay purchase/sales tax in respect of paddy purchased by them.
- Counsel Sri N.K. Acharya advanced an argument that paddy and rice were not different commodities under the State Act or the Central Act (an alternative line), and that the common question would arise only if they were treated as different items; this argument was described in the opinion as extravagant and was rejected by the Court.
State Government / Revenue
- Contended (a) that the tax leviable on rice under the Central Act for rice in inter-State trade is four per cent and the tax leviable under the State Act on paddy is also four per cent; therefore, under Section 8(2A) of the Central Act the tax on rice is at the same rate and not lower, so the dealers' claim for reimbursement is not tenable. The State relied on the decision in State of A.P. v. O. Venkateswarlu & Bros. as not applicable to dealers' claim.
- Contended (b) that rice when sold in inter-State trade is not liable to be taxed under the State Act; paddy and rice are different commodities; with reference to Section 15(c) of the Central Act, tax suffered by paddy cannot be reimbursed for rice procured out of that paddy when one reads item 22 of the Third Schedule of the State Act along with Sections 8(2A) and 15(c) of the Central Act.
- Contended (c) no exemption (rebate or reimbursement) can be claimed where paddy is imported within the State (the Court noted, however, that none of the petitioners alleged that their paddy had been imported).
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court in This Opinion |
|---|---|---|
| State of A.P. v. O. Venkateswarlu & Bros. [1967] 20 S.T.C. 340 | Interpretation of Section 8(2A) of the Central Act regarding rates applicable to inter-State sales of rice derived from paddy and the issue of rate equality and discrimination. | The Court treated this decision as directly addressing the rate-equality contention raised by the State and held that it supports the dealers' position (i.e., it does not prevent reimbursement); the Court applied its reasoning to answer the State's contentions adversely to the State. |
| A.S. Ramachandra Rao & Co. v. State of Andhra Pradesh [1969] 24 S.T.C. 133 | Reading Section 5 and Section 5-A of the State Act together to ascertain the true character of an additional tax; principle that ancillary provisions may be read with charging section for rate ascertainment ("plus" approach). | The Court relied on the reasoning to show that in rate ascertainment an additive approach may apply; used this to contrast with the present statutory scheme where Explanation III provides for reduction of tax on rice by the tax on paddy. |
| Ramavatar Budhaiprasad v. Assistant Sales Tax Officer, Akola [1961] 12 S.T.C. 286 (S.C.) | Goods are to be construed in "popular sense" and commercial identification; botanical or strictly dictionary meanings are not decisive for taxation classification. | Used as part of a cluster of authorities to support the proposition that classification of goods for sales tax is determined by commercial/identification approach rather than purely botanical identity; contributed to rejecting the argument that paddy and rice must be treated as identical merely because of botanical identity. |
| Tungabhadra Industries Ltd. v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool [1960] 11 S.T.C. 827 (S.C.) | Illustration that a commodity may be treated as another in commerce despite chemical changes (commercial identification principle). | Cited to illustrate the commercial/identification approach to classification of goods for sales tax purposes; supported treating processed forms distinctly where commercial sense dictates. |
| State Of Gujarat v. Sakarwala Brothers [1967] 19 S.T.C. 24 (S.C.) | Recognition that a product (here sugar) may be identified as different commercial forms despite processing (commercial classification principle). | Used in the same line of authorities to justify classification by commercial or popular sense rather than botanical or chemical identity; supports treating paddy and rice as separate items in tax schedules. |
| Commissioner of Sales Tax, Madhya Pradesh, Indore v. Jaswant Singh Charan Singh [1967] 19 S.T.C. 459 (S.C.) | Held that "coal" can include "charcoal" from the standpoint of ordinary parlance — further demonstrating commercial/ordinary-parlance approach to classification. | Included to show judicial approach to classification in sales tax matters; the Court relied on this body of authority when addressing whether paddy and rice are separate taxable items. |
| State of Punjab v. Chandu Lal Kishore Lal [1970] 25 S.T.C. 52 (S.C.) | Demonstrated that "cotton" commercially may not include cotton-seed despite botanical inclusion — commercial identification principle. | Again part of the authorities relied upon to show courts adopt commercial identification in construing taxable items; supported the view that paddy and rice are to be treated as distinct taxable items under the Acts. |
| State of Madhya Bharat v. Hiralal [1966] 17 S.T.C. 313 (S.C.) | Bars, flats and plates from scrap identified in market as iron and steel — confirmation of "identification" approach. | Used as authority for the commercial/identification test for goods classification; cited in the cluster of decisions supporting the Court's approach to items 21 and 22 (paddy and rice). |
| Ganesh Trading Co. v. State of Haryana [1973] 32 S.T.C. 623 (S.C.) | Decision holding that the two items (paddy and rice) are different items for the purpose of the State Act (i.e., they are treated as distinct taxable items). | The Court treated this Supreme Court decision as conclusive that items 21 (paddy) and 22 (rice) are distinct taxable items and therefore the contention urging that they are not different could not be entertained; applied to reject the dealers' counsel's argument that paddy and rice are not different commodities. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court's analysis proceeded by examining the pertinent statutory amendments and their textual effect, then applying established principles from precedent to resolve the contentions.
-
Statutory amendments and their operative effect:
- Both the Central Act (74 of 1956) and the State Act (Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act, 6 of 1957) were amended with effect from 7 September 1976. Under the Central Act, paddy and rice were included as cereals in Section 14 and sub-clauses (c) and (d) were added to Section 15. Under the State Act the Third Schedule was amended adding item 21 "paddy" and item 22 "rice", and Explanation III was appended.
- Explanation III to the State Act's Third Schedule (quoted in the opinion) provides: where a tax has been levied under the State Act in respect of the sale or purchase inside the State of any paddy, the tax leviable on rice procured out of such paddy shall be reduced by the amount of tax levied on such paddy.
- Sub-clause (c) of Section 15 of the Central Act contains substantially the same provision: where a tax has been levied under State law in respect of paddy, the tax leviable on rice procured out of such paddy shall be reduced by the amount of tax levied on such paddy.
-
Addressing the State's contentions:
- On the State's argument that equal rates (four per cent) under the State and Central enactments mean Section 8(2A) precludes reimbursement: the Court examined prior decisions (notably State of A.P. v. O. Venkateswarlu & Bros.) and principles of rate ascertainment and discrimination. The Court concluded those authorities refute the State's contention and support reimbursement where Explanation III and Section 15(c) require reduction of the tax leviable on rice by the tax levied on paddy.
- The Court explicitly rejected the factual applicability of the State's contention that reimbursement is unavailable where paddy was imported, since none of the petitioners alleged imported paddy; moreover, such a claim would not be countenanced under Section 8(2A) or Section 15(c) when not pleaded.
-
Classification issue — are paddy and rice the same commodity?
- The Court considered as settled law that classification of goods under sales tax statutes is to be determined by commercial, popular or identification approaches rather than strict botanical or dictionary meanings. The opinion cites a string of Supreme Court authorities showing this methodology.
- The Court referred to Ganesh Trading Co. v. State of Haryana as dispositive that paddy and rice are two different items for the purposes of the State Act; therefore the argument that they are not different commodities was rejected as untenable.
-
Overall synthesis:
- Reading Section 8(2A) and Section 15(c) of the Central Act together with item 22 and Explanation III of the State Act leads to the same conclusion: where rice involved in inter-State trade is produced out of paddy that has borne State tax, the tax leviable on that rice must be reduced by the amount of tax levied on the paddy. The Court treated the statutory text and the cited precedents as supporting this outcome.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The writ petitions were allowed. The Court held that, in respect of rice involved in inter-State trade procured out of paddy which had suffered State tax, the tax paid on paddy is liable to be reduced (i.e., reimbursed) from the tax leviable on rice.
Implications and immediate consequences:
- The direct practical effect is that dealers who paid State tax on paddy and whose rice was sold in the course of inter-State trade are entitled to have the tax leviable on the rice reduced by the tax paid on the paddy (for the period claimed — 7 Sept 1976 to 31 Mar 1977, as in these petitions).
- The State Government's contentions that equality of rates under Section 8(2A) precludes reimbursement, that paddy and rice must be treated the same commodity for this purpose, or that reimbursement cannot be claimed where paddy was imported, were not accepted by the Court on the facts and law before it.
- The Court made no order as to costs generally, but awarded Advocate's fee of Rs. 150 in each petition.
- The opinion applies existing statutory provisions and prior authority; it does not purport to announce a new principle of law beyond the application of the cited provisions and precedents to the facts of these petitions.
Note: This summary is prepared strictly from the text of the provided opinion. No facts, arguments, or outcomes beyond those expressly stated in that opinion have been added.
1. The common question at issue in the group of writ petition is : When "rice" is taxed under the Central Sales Tax Act (74 of 1956) (the Central Act) whether the tax paid on paddy (out of which "rice" has been procured) has to be reimbursed to the exporter. The question is raised by some dealers having paid the tax on paddy, demanded .reimbursement, in one case the revenue having reimbursed the exporter rescinded the order and in other cases the dealers apprehended in like proceedings orders of rescission per instructions of the State Government in R. O. No. B/ 7000284/76 dated 14th February, 1977, and have approached this Court to interdict the revenue authorities to refrain from invoking steps as indicated in the instructions.
2. M/s. Sri Dhanalakshmi Rice Company, Nellore, between 7th September, 1976, and 31st March, 1977, returned their inter-State turnover of rice in Rs. 4,47,290 and showed the rice was procured out of paddy purchased by them in Rs. 3,04,688, which (paddy) suffered the tax of Rs. 12,436 under the Andhra Pradesh General Sales Tax Act (6 of 1957) (the State Act). Their assessment for the year 1976-77 was concluded on 13th February, 1978, but the company did not claim the amount (Rs. 12,436) instead made a claim for reimbursement in May, 1978, and the claim was rejected by the Commercial Tax Officer. The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes rejected such a claim on 27th June, 1978, when the assessee sought revision of the assessment order under Section 20 of the State Act 6 of 1957 (Writ Petition No. 3285 of 1978).
3. M/s. Pratesh Traders, Nellore, returned their inter-State turnover of rice between 7th September, 1976, and 31st March, 1977, in Rs. 1,93,973 procured out of paddy purchased for Rs. 1,34,268. The tax suffered towards such paddy was Rs. 5,371. Their assessment for the year 1976-77 was finalised on 9th January, 1978, but the amount of tax paid on paddy was not claimed instead on 22nd May, 1978, later, reimbursement was claimed by the assessee, the Commercial Tax Officer rejected the claim. The Deputy Commissioner of Commercial Taxes rejected the revision petition under Section 20 of the State Act 6 of 1957 on 27th June, 1978 (Writ Petition No. 3286 of 1978).
4. M/s. Tadikonda Mallaiah & Sons aver their assessment for the year 1976-77 was finalised on 13th September, 1977, involving a turnover of rice in Rs. 98,781 in the course of inter-State trade. The tax of Rs. 8,661.08 on that turnover (was-exempted) was reimbursed. However on 16th May, 1978, the assessee was informed by notice and subsequently the "rebate" was held "granted" under a mistake and on 18th June, 1978, by order the rebate was rescinded (Writ Petition No. 2948 of 1978).
5. M/s. Sri Vijayalakshmi Rice and Oil Mill averred as a dealer of paddy, they paid four per cent tax under the State Act 6 of 1957 in Rs. 51,664 and claimed reimbursement of the tax paid on paddy for the rice procured from such paddy has been exported (the first petitioner in Writ Petition No. 1095 of 1978). M/s. Lakshmi Vilas Rice and Oil Mill, Warangal, averred as dealer of paddy the firm paid four per cent tax under the State Act 6 of 1957 in Rs. 36,764 and claimed reimbursement of the tax paid (on paddy) for the rice procured from such paddy was exported (the second petitioner in Writ Petition No. 1095 of 1978).
6. M/s. Aitha Narasaiah & Co. and M/s. Sri Laxmi Narasimha & Co., Warangal (Writ Petition No. 814 of 1978), M/s. Manchala Prabhakar (Firm) at Bhongir (Writ Petition No. 3470 of 1978), Y. Venkatanarayana (Writ Petition No. 3465 of 1978) and M/s. Vauhini Trading Co., Warangal (Writ Petition No. 3087 of 1978) apprehend rescission proceedings and seek a direction to hold they "are not liable to pay any purchase/sales tax in respect of paddy purchased by them" or in the alternative "to reduce the tax leviable on rice under the Central Sales Tax Act (74 of 1956) by the amount of tax levied on paddy under the A. P. G. S. T. Act out of which such rice is produced".
7. All the dealers claim reimbursement for the period 7th September, 1976, to 31st March, 1977, and before we set down the opposition of the State Government to the writ petitions, it is necessary to notice some statutory changes to the Central Act 74 of 1956 and to the State Act 6 of 1957 as they are material for the decision of the question at issue.
8. The central act 74 of 1956 was amended by Act 103 of 1976. In Chapter IV, Section 14 was amended to include paddy and rice as cereals, goods of special importance in inter-State trade and commerce. Sub-clauses (c) and (d) were added to Section 15 in that chapter.
9. The State Act 6 of 1957 was amended by the Andhra Pradesh Ordinance 18 of 1976 on 7th September, 1976. In the Third Schedule of the State Act 6 of 1957, item 21 "paddy" and item 22 "rice" were added. The Third Schedule was appended with three explanations. Explanation III is relevant and reads as under :
For the purpose of items 21 and 22, where a tax has been levied under this Act in respect of the sale or purchase inside the State of any paddy, the tax leviable on rice procured out of such paddy shall be reduced by the amount of tax levied on such paddy.
10. The amendments to the Central Act 74 of 1956 and to the State Act 6 of 1957 both were given effect from the same day, i.e., 7th September, 1976. The amending Acts indicate that if paddy suffered a tax at four paise in the rupee on the point of last purchase, explanation III in the Third Schedule to the State Act 6 of 1957 recites the tax levied on paddy in respect of rice procured out of such paddy the tax paid has to be reduced. To the same effect is Sub-clause*(c) of Section 15 of the Central Act, which reads as under:
Where a tax has been levied under that law in respect of the sale or purchase inside the State of any paddy referred to in sub-clause (i) of clause (i) of section 14, the tax leviable on rice procured out of such paddy shall be reduced by the amount of tax levied on such paddy.
11. The State Government resisted the writ petitions and it is contended that (a) the tax leviable on rice under the central act 74 of 1956 is four per cent (rice involved in the inter-State trade) the tax leviable under the State Act 6 of 1957 on paddy is also four per cent therefore, with reference to the provisions of Section 8(2A) of the Central Act 74 of 1956, the tax on rice is at the same rate and not lower therefore the claim of the dealers is not tenable and it is urged the case of State of A.P. v. O. Venkateswarlu & Bros. [1967] 20 S.T.C. 340 has no application to the claim made by the dealers, (b) It is next urged rice, when sold in inter-State trade, is not liable to be taxed under the State Act 6 of 1957 for paddy and rice are two different commodities and with reference to the language used in Section 15(c) of the Central Act 74 of 1956 rice procured out of the paddy involved in the export trade, the tax suffered by paddy cannot be reimbursed, having regard to item 22 of the Third Schedule of the State Act 6 of 1957 even when read with Section 8(2A) and Clause (c) of Section 15 of the Central Act 74 of 1956. (c) Lastly it is argued no exemption (rebate or reimbursement) can be claimed when paddy is imported within the State.
12. Adverting to the last contention [ground (c)] raised by the State Government, it may be stated none of the dealers in the above writ petitions aver to have imported paddy in Andhra Pradesh. No dealer has contended in claiming exemption on the premises of paddy having been imported. Such a claim is not countenanced under Section 8(2A) or under Clause (c) of Section 15 of the Central Act 74 of 1956.
13. The other two contentions [grounds (a) and (b)] are the two facets of the same question and, in our view, are covered by the decisions of this Court. What is the rate of rice and how is the rate to be ascertained has been considered in two decisions of this Court. Sections 5 and 5-A of the State Act 6 of 1957 were considered in Writ Petition No. 2955 of 1970 (23rd November, 1970) and batch. In that case, the above two sections were considered. Section 5 is the charging section. Section 5-A was added with effect from 1st August, 1963, levying one-fourth paisa on every rupee of turnover above rupees three lakhs. The two provisions for purposes of "rate" in the context of inter-State trade were held as under :
...With regard to transactions coming under Sub-sections (2) and (2A) of Section 8 the rates of tax liability under the Central Act are made calculable at the rates applicable to the sale or purchase of the relevant goods inside the appropriate State. Therefore, with regard to transactions coming under Section 8(2) and (2A) of the Central Act, the rates of tax are those which the appropriate State charges on the sales or purchases of those goods inside that State with regard to transactions other than sales in the course of inter-State trade or commerce. Then the question arises with regard to sales that take place in this State in the course of inter-State trade or commerce what are the rates of tax applicable, namely, whether the rates that are mentioned in Section 5 of the State Act only or those rates coupled with the additional one-fourth per cent tax as provided under Section 5-A of the Act."
(emphasis supplied).
14. The question was answered: With regard to goods relating to turnovers that come under Section 5-A, the rates of tax are those mentioned under Section 5 plus the one-fourth per cent additional tax as provided under Section 5-A. In A.S. Ramachandra Rao & Co. v. State. of Andhra Pradesh [1969] 24 S.T.C. 133, similar reasoning was adopted. The following passage indicates the reasoning:
Though the additional tax on turnovers of rupees three lakhs or more is imposed under a separate provision under Section 5-A, it is merely a supplemental or ancillary provision to the main charging Section 5. In ascertaining the true nature and character of the additional tax under Section 5-A it is legitimate as well as necessary that both the sections should be read together in order to ascertain the true character of the tax sought to be imposed. We are satisfied that the tax sought to be imposed under Section 5 as well as the additional tax sought to be imposed under Section 5-A partake of the same character.
15. The two decisions are an instance "of plus" for ascertainment of rate. In the instant cases, under explanation III of the Third Schedule, the tax paid on paddy is to be reduced. The tax when reduced it cannot then be said paddy and rice are taxed at the same rate. In the decision in State of A.P. v. O. Venkateswarlu & Bros. [1967] 20 s.t.c. 340, Section 8(2A) of the Central Act 74 of 1956 was considered when under the First Schedule of the Andhra Pradesh State Act 6 of 1957 inter-State sales of rice obtained from paddy suffered was three per cent, the tax exempted was at one per cent and not at two per cent. Having considered Section 8(2A) of the Central Act it was held:
The question is what is meant by the words 'subject to tax generally' and whether that term excludes from the purview rice obtained from paddy that is made taxable under the Act at 3 nP. in the rupee. In our view, it cannot be so excluded, because the rate is generally applicable to goods which are sold or purchased in the course of inter-State sale by a dealer, who has been defined as any person who carries on the business of buying, selling, supplying or distributing goods directly or otherwise. Dealers who deal in rice either purchase paddy directly from the agriculturist or import it, mill it and sell it outside the State, or buy paddy in the market which is already subjected to sales tax, mill it and sell it outside the State. When paddy already subjected to sales tax and paddy not so subjected is milled and dealers sell it outside the State, the cost to them would be different if the sales tax is levied at the uniform rate of two per cent, i.e., the rice milled from paddy which is already subjected to three per cent sales tax would cost more. There would thus be a case of discrimination in respect of the same end-product, viz., rice. Where there are two interpretations possible for a court to take, one against the constitutionality of the provision and the other in favour of sustaining it, the interpretation which favours the latter is the one which the courts must adopt.
16. The above decision, in our view, concludes the two contentions raised by the State Government in the instant cases and the decision holds good, for in the amending Acts to the State Act 6 of 1957 and to the Central Act 74 of 1956 no change has been brought to take any contrary view of the question raised.
17. Thus Section 8(2A) and Section 15(b) and (c) of the Central Act 74 of 1956 read together and juxtaposed with items 21 and 22 of the State Act 6 of 1957, explanation III in the Third Schedule, in our view, the same conclusion follows to hold tax on rice involved in the inter-State trade procured out of paddy which suffered the State tax has to be reduced. Sri N.K. Acharya, the learned counsel on behalf of some of the dealers, however, maintained that paddy and rice are not different commodities under the State Act 6 of 1957 or under the central act 74 of 1956. The common question at issue recited in the beginning, the learned counsel argued, arises only in the alternative, otherwise the learned counsel urged the main issue is dealers "are not liable to pay any purchase/sales tax in respect of paddy purchased by them". The plea thus raised and so stated is rather extravagant. To urge paddy and rice are not two different commodities under the sales tax laws of the country at this distance of time is failure to see the obvious for such a contention is no more res Integra. The method of construction of items (or goods) under the sales tax laws with reference to the botanical name and meaning in the dictionary is no more considered a correct method and for long has been discarded. Betel leaves were construed from the standpoint of "popular sense" and held different from "vegetables" though from the standpoint of botanical name is the same as vegetables (Ramavatar Budhaiprasad v. Assistant Sales Tax Officer, Akola [1961] 12 S.T.C. 286 (S.C.). Hydrogenated oil in "commerce" notwithstanding the chemical changes was held to be groundnut oil (Tungabhadra Industries Ltd., Kurnool v. Commercial Tax Officer, Kurnool., Kurnool [1960] 11 S.T.C. 827 (S.C). Sugar in State Of Gujarat v. Sakarwala Brothers [1967] 19 S.T.C. 24 (S.C.) was held as patasa, harda and alchidana despite the chemical changes. "Coal" was held to include "charcoal" from the standpoint of "ordinary parlance" (Commissioner of Sales Tax, Madhya Pradesh, Indore v. Jaswant Singh Charan Singh [1967] 19 S.T.C. 459 (S.C.). Cotton was "commercially" not to include though in natural growth included cotton-seeds (State of Punjab v. Chandu Lal Kishore Lal [1970] 25 S.T.C. 52 (S.C.). Bars, flats and plates made out of scrap iron in the market were "identified" to be "iron and steel" [State of Madhya Bharat (Now State of Madhya Pradesh) v. Hiralal [1966] 17 S.T.C. 313 (S.C.)]. Thus goods (items) were construed from the standpoint of "popular sense" and from the standpoint of "identification" and in "commercial sense", not from the meaning in dictionaries. Dehusked paddy may be is rice. The commodities may have common botanical name (Oryza sativa L). The two items (paddy and rice), items 21 and 22 in the State Act 6 of 1957 were held in Ganesh Trading Co. v. State of Haryana [1973] 32 S.T.C. 623 (S.C.), as two different items by the Supreme Court and in that sense is no more open to be questioned, therefore the contention of Sri N. K. Acharya cannot be countenanced.
18. In the result, having regard to the provisions in Section 8(2A), Section 15(c) of the Central Act 74 of 1956, item 22 read with explanation III in the Third Schedule of the State Act 6 of 1957 "paddy" out of which rice is procured involved in inter-State trade, we hold tax paid on paddy is liable to be (reduced) reimbursed. The writ petitions are allowed with the directions indicated above and for the costs we make no order. Advocate's fee Rs. 150 in each.
Alert