- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
State Bank Of Hyderabad v. Kotha Papi Reddy And Another
Factual and Procedural Background
This opinion arises from five revision petitions concerning the proper stamp duty payable on a set of documents related to loan agreements and guarantees executed by defendants in suits filed by the State Bank of Hyderabad. Specifically, in one representative case (O.S.S.R No. 1281 of 1972, leading to C.R.P No. 165 of 1974), the Bank sued two defendants to recover a loan amount. The first defendant executed a deed of hypothecation stamped adequately, while the second defendant executed an agreement of guarantee stamped with Rs. 2-30 Ps. The trial court office objected, contending that the guarantee agreement should have been stamped at Rs. 22-50 Ps under Article 18 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act, demanding deficit stamp duty and penalty. The trial court upheld this objection and ordered the plaint to be returned for payment of the deficit stamp duty and penalty. The Bank filed these revision petitions challenging that order.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the agreement of guarantee executed by the second defendant is chargeable to stamp duty under Article 48 or Article 5 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act.
- Whether the agreement of guarantee should be stamped as a security bond or as an agreement.
- The sufficiency of the stamp duty paid on the agreement of guarantee.
Arguments of the Parties
Appellant's Arguments
- The agreement of guarantee is chargeable under Article 5 of Schedule 1-A, not under Article 6 or Article 48 as held by the lower court or contended by the Government Pleader.
- The instrument is an agreement of guarantee as defined under section 126 of the Contract Act and should be stamped as an agreement, not as a security bond.
- The agreement is attested and signed but does not constitute a security bond because the guarantor has not provided security himself, only guaranteed payment by the borrower.
Respondent's Arguments
- The agreement of guarantee falls under Article 48 of Schedule 1-A as a security bond executed by the surety to secure due performance of a contract.
- The instrument qualifies as a bond under section 2(5)(b) of the Indian Stamp Act since it is attested and obliges a person to pay money to another.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Board of Revenue v. Rani Pictures (Madras High Court) | Classification of bond as a bond and pledge where borrower obliges to pay and gives security. | Distinguished on facts; no obligation by guarantor to pay himself and no security given by guarantor, so precedent did not support respondent's contention. |
| Rex v. Lane | Guarantee for due performance of charterparty does not require stamp as charterparty or agreement. | Referenced to illustrate that guarantees are agreements and may not require security bond stamp. |
| Joyman Bewa v. Easin Sarkar (Division Bench) | Oral or written guarantee renders guarantor liable under section 145 of Contract Act. | Supported the principle that guarantees need not be in form of security bond and can be oral or written contracts. |
| In re: Imperial Bank of India (Special Bench, Rangoon High Court) | Deed of guarantee liable to stamp duty under Article 5(c) of Schedule 1, not Article 6 or 40. | Applied to hold that guarantee agreements are to be stamped as agreements, not as security bonds. |
| Karzppan Chettair v. Nagappa (Madras High Court Division Bench) | Contract of guarantee defined under section 126 of Contract Act need not be in form of security bond or writing. | Supported the liberal construction that guarantees are agreements and need only be stamped accordingly. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Court examined the nature of the agreement of guarantee to determine the applicable stamp duty. It noted that the instrument was an agreement guaranteeing payment by the borrower, but the guarantor did not himself undertake an obligation to pay money directly to the Bank unless the borrower defaulted. This distinction was crucial since section 2(5)(b) of the Indian Stamp Act requires a bond to oblige a person to pay money to another, which was absent here.
The Court further reasoned that the instrument was not a security bond under Article 48 because the guarantor did not furnish any security; the borrower had provided the security. The Court distinguished the precedent from Board of Revenue v. Rani Pictures, where the borrower had both an obligation to pay and provided security, unlike the present case.
Relying on section 126 of the Contract Act, which defines a contract of guarantee as a contract to perform the promise or discharge the liability of a third person in case of default, the Court held that such a contract, when reduced to writing, is chargeable with the stamp duty applicable to agreements under Article 5(c) of Schedule 1-A.
The Court cited multiple precedents supporting the view that guarantee contracts are agreements and need not be treated as security bonds for stamp duty purposes. It concluded that the existing stamp of Rs. 2-30 Ps on the guarantee agreements was sufficient.
Holding and Implications
The Court set aside the order of the lower Court and allowed the revision petitions. It directed the trial Court to proceed on the basis that the agreements of guarantee were duly stamped.
The parties were directed to bear their own costs of the revision petitions. The Court imposed a consolidated advocate's fee of Rs. 10,000.
No new precedent was established; the decision clarified the proper classification and stamp duty applicable to written agreements of guarantee under the Indian Stamp Act.
1. In these five revision petitions a common question relating to the proper stamp duty that is payable on a set of documents has to be considered.
2. The circumstances and the material relating of the documents in all the five matters are the same. To take for instance the facts in O.S.S.R No. 1281 of 1972, out of which C.R.P No. 165 of 1974 arises, is a suit filed by the State Bank of Hyderabad to recover a sum of Rs. 4,498-52 Ps. from two defendants. On 8th December, 1969 the first defendant borrowed a sura of Rs. 3,90-50 Ps. from the Bank for purchasing a pump set and executed an agreement hypothecating the ??? set and its accessories. On the same day, the second defendant executed another agreement in favour of the Bank guaranteeing due payment of the loan. The Bank filed the suit alleging that the defendants had failed to repay the amount. The deed of hypothecation passed by the first defendant was engrossed on stamp paper of the value of Rs. 20-30 Ps. There is no difficulty in regard to the sufficiency of the stamp on that deed. It was accepted as sufficient by the Court below. The difficulty arose only in regard to the agreement of guarantee executed by the second defendant which bears a stamp of Rs. 2-30 Ps. The offence of the trial Court raised an objection saying that the agreement of guarantee falls under Article 18 of Schedule 1-A of the Indian Stamp Act and so it should have been engrossed on stamp paper worth Rs. 22-50 Ps. A deficit stamp of Rs. 20-20 Ps. and a penalty of Rs. 202 were demanded from the plaintiff Bank.
3. Learned Counsel for the plaintiff took the stand that the agreement of guarantee comes under Article 6(2) of the Schedule 1-A and so the stamp it bears is sufficient. Consequently the matter was placed before the Court. The Court below upheld the objection raised by the office, holding that the agreement of guarantee is chargeable under Article 48. In the result, it directed the plaintd to be returned for payment of deficit stamp duty, and penalty as demanded by the office. The plaintiff, which is common to all the five proposed suits has filed these revision petitions. Sri C. Poornaiah for the plaintiff-petitioner contends that what the second defendant has executed is only an agreement of guarantee and has to be stamped only as an agreement, though it is an attested one. In his submission, the agreement of guarantee comes within the purview of Article 5 and not under Article 6 as contended by his counterpart in the lower Court or under Article 48 as held by the Court below. On the other hand, learned Government Pleader seeks to support the view of the trial Court.
4. Before considering what Article governs the deed of guarantee, it is necessary to refer to the material recitals in it. At the top of the agreement there is a direction that the agreement is to be signed by the guarantor. It has to be stamped with the highest agreement stamp duty in force in the State. It is an agreement of guarantee obtained in the case of instalment credit loans. The first paragraph refers to the fact that the borrower borrowed a particular sum by way of instalment credit to pay for moveable machinery and equipment, tools and accessories. This is by way of a preamble to the succeeding paragraphs whereunder the guarantor has guaranteed the payment of the money borrowed. Paragraph 2 states that the guaranteed guarantees to the Bank the payment on demand of all moneys at any time and from time to time thereafter due to the Bank by the borrower in respect of the above mentioned accommodation with interest from the date of demand and also the due performance and observance by the borrowere of all the terms pertaining to the accommodation given to him land the payment of all costs and expenses incurred by the Bank in relation to the premises. Further, the guarantor agreed to pay and make good to the Bank on demand all damages, losses, costs and expenses occasioned to the Bank by reason of the non-payment of the moneys or causing a breach or non-performance or non-observance of any of the terms by the borrower. The second paragraph shows that the guarantor has agreed that no failure in requiring or obtaining the security of the machinery given by the borrower or in the observance or performance of any of the stipulations or terms of the borrower's agreement and no default of the Bank in requiring or enforcing the observations or performance of any of the stipulations or terms shall have the effect of releasing him (guarantor) from his liability to the Bank.
5. The other provisions of the agreement of guarantee are not material for consideration of the question posed before me. That question as deduced from the contentions of the learned Counsel on both sides is whether it is Article 48 or Article 5 of Schedule 1-A that covers the guarantee agreement. Article 48 governs security bonds or mortgage deeds, executed by way of security for the due execution of an office or to account for money or other property received by virtue thereof or executed by the surety to secure due performance of a contract Learned Government Pleader submits that the deed in question is a security bond under which the guarantor has undertake to account for money or other property received by virue thereof or executed by the surety to secure the due performance of a contract.
6. Bond is defined is section 2(5) of the Act and it is the contention of the learned Government Pleader that it comes under sub-clause (b) of Clause (5): According to it bond includes any instrument attested by a witness and not payable to order or bearer whereby a person obliges himself to pay money to another. The deed in question is certainly attested by a witness. It does not refer to whether it is payable to order or bearer, it is, however, payable on demand.
7. The next important ingredient of sub-clause (b) and indeed the most important is that a person should oblige himself to pay money to another. But that is absent in the deed in question. The obligation to pay money is on the borrower. The guarantor has simply guaranteed the payment on demand all moneys due to the Bank by the borrower and also the observance by the borrower of all the terms relating to the accommodation given to him. It cannot, therefore, be said that the guarantor has undertaken the obligation to himself pay the money to the Bank. His obligation to pay arises only when the borrower does not comply with the terms of the agreement for instalment credit which he has executed. I am not, therefore, satisfied that the essential ingredient of section 2(5)(b) is satisfied in this case.
8. What is more, it should be noted that it is not sufficient for an instrument to come within the ambit of Article 48 if it is merely a bond. It should be a security bond too. A security bond envisages furnishing security. In the instrument under consideration, the guarantor has not himself given any security. The borrower has given one and the guarantor has only undertaken to guarantee the payment by the borrower and the observance of the terms and conditions of the bond which the former has executed. It is thus patent that there is no security given by the guarantor under the instrument. So the deed cannot be called a security bond. In the result, it does not come under Article 48.
9. Learned Counsel, however, relies on a decision of the Madras High Court in Board of Revenue v. Rani Pictures(1) There a Special Bench was dealing with a case when the borrower himself obliged to pay amounts and in addition gave a camera as security. The Special Bench held that it was a bond as well as a pledge. That was on the ground that the borrower obliged himself by an instrument to pay a particular amount in a particular manner and in addition gave a camera as security. In the present case, there is no obligation undertaken by the guarantor to himself pay the amount and there is no security given by him. The security has been given by the borrower himself. So this case does not help the contention of the learned Government Pleader.
10. On the other hand, the bond appears to come under Article-5. It is common ground that the deed contains only an agreement of guarantee. The contents of the deed also, which I have given above, would demonstrate this beyond any doubt. A contract of guarantee is defined in section 126 of the Contract Act. It says that it is a contract to perform the promise or to discharge the liability of a third person in case of his default. According to it a guarantee may be either oral or written. When a gurantee can even be oral, there is no point in insisting on its being engrossed on stamp of a security or a mortgage deed. If it is reduced to writing it has to be stamped as a contract or an agreement, which it really is as per the specific provisions of section 126. I am thus satisfied that a contract of guarantee is chargeable with a stamp required for an agreement, when it is reduced to writing. A written undertaking signed by a person and attested by another to be answerable for the debt or default of another is nothing more than an agreement. Consequently, I am of the opinion that the deed which is an agreement of guarantee comes under Article 5, clause (c). Clause (c) covers all agreements which are not otherwise provided for. For such agreements increased stamp duty is Rs. 2-50 P. The deeds in question bear that stamp.
11. I may here usefully refer to a few cases which bear on the question. In Rex v. Lane, it was held that
“a guarantee for the due performance dose charterparty does not require to be stamped, as charterparty or agreement for the charter of any ship, or any memorandum, letter or other writing between the captain or owner of any ship and any other persons, for or relating to the freight or conveyance of goods, on board such ship”.
12. In Joyman Bewa… v. Easin Sarkar….(2), a Division Bench held that in Case where a person has contracted expressly that he will guarantee the performance of any of the obligations set out in section 145, whether such a contract be oral or in writing, he renders himself liable to be proceeded against in execution of the decree as provided in section 145
13. A Special Bench of the Rangoon High Court held In re: Imperial Bank of India(3), that a deed of that nature is liable to stamp duty under Article 5(c) of Schedule 1 and not under Article 6 or Article 40.
14. A Division Bench of the Madras High Court while dealing with a similar situation in Karzppan Chettair v. Nagappa held that the contract they were dealing with was one of guarantee within the meaning of section 126 of the Contract Act. It was not necessary that a contract of suretyship should be in the form of a security bond or in writing.
15. When such is the liberal construction given to a contract of guarantee it is futile to argue that it should be in the form of a security bond. Since it has been reduced to writing it has to be stamped only as an agreement under Article 5(c) of Schedule I-A. Since it already bears the required stamp of Rs. 2-30 P. it is sufficiently stamped. For these reasons, I set aside the order of the lower Court, allow the revision petitions and direct the Court below to deal with the matters on the basis that the agreements of guarantee are duly stamped. Having regard to the circumstances of the case I direct the parties to bear their own costs of the revision petitions. Consolidated Advocate's fee is Rs. 10000.
M.S.K
16. Revisions allowed.
Alert