- Bookmark
- Share
- CaseIQ
A. Ramachandran And Another v. Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. And Another
Judgment Summary — Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. (Winding Up Petition)
Factual and Procedural Background
This petition under section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956 was brought for the winding up of the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. The petitioners are two preference shareholders, each holding 100 fully paid preference shares of Rs. 50. The 1st respondent is the company (represented by its managing director, Sri G.V. Subbarao) and the 2nd respondent is G.V. Subbarao in his personal capacity.
The company was incorporated in 1935 under the Indian Companies Act, 1913, as a public company limited by shares, with its registered office at Guntur, Andhra Pradesh. Its main object was to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet. The entire undertaking of the company was acquired by the Government on February 26, 1951 (Madras Act XIII of 1949, later replaced by Andhra Act XV of 1954), and compensation of Rs. 1,06,977 was awarded and deposited in the bank.
Since the acquisition in 1951 the company had ceased to carry on the principal business; the petitioners allege that no other business was carried out thereafter and that the company has no significant assets except the compensation (and some furniture). The petitioners assert the managing director engaged in fruitless litigation and dissipated company funds; an attempt to hold a voluntary winding-up meeting on August 18, 1968 failed for want of quorum. The petitioners therefore sought winding up on grounds that the company had ceased to do business and that it was just and equitable to wind up the company.
The respondents filed a counter-affidavit denying certain contentions: the managing director says he was not appointed solely for winding up and that there were several objects in the memorandum beyond electricity distribution; he also contends litigation was not fruitless and that balance-sheets continued beyond 1967 (last balance-sheet for year ending March 31, 1968, allegedly published and audited). A reply reiterated that the managing director was appointed to effect winding up and that, in practice, the company's only real business from 1934 was electricity distribution and no other objects had been pursued since the 1951 acquisition.
Legal Issues Presented
- Whether the company has ceased doing business after February 26, 1951, when the undertaking was taken over by the Government?
- Whether it is just and equitable that the company should be wound up?
Arguments of the Parties
Petitioners' Arguments
- The company's entire undertaking was acquired by the Government on February 26, 1951, and compensation was paid and deposited in the bank.
- As a result of the acquisition, the company ceased doing any business and has no realistic prospect of resuming its primary business.
- The company has no assets other than the compensation and some furniture; the managing director engaged in fruitless litigation and wasted company funds.
- A meeting to resolve voluntary winding up failed for want of quorum (meeting called for August 18, 1968).
- Given the cessation of the company's main business, it is just and equitable to wind up the company.
Respondents' Arguments
- The managing director denies he was appointed solely to wind up the company and asserts he can exercise all powers under the memorandum and articles.
- There were several objects in the memorandum beyond electricity supply and therefore the company could potentially pursue other businesses.
- The litigation engaged in by the managing director was not fruitless.
- The petition is not bona fide and arose from differences between the 1st petitioner and the managing director; it is not in the interests of the company and its shareholders.
- The company continued to publish balance-sheets after 1967, with the last balance-sheet said to be for the year ending March 31, 1968, duly audited.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent | Rule or Principle Cited For | Application by the Court |
|---|---|---|
| Cotman v. Brougham [1918] AC 514, 522 H.L. | Holds that the substratum of a company is gone when the main purpose has become impossible. | Used as an authoritative statement that disappearance of substratum justifies winding up; supports conclusion that the company's substratum had gone. |
| In re German Date Coffee Company | Illustrates that substratum is gone where main purpose becomes impossible. | Cited as additional authority corroborating the principle that failure of substratum permits winding up. |
| In re Baku Consolidated Oilfields Ltd. | Holds that when the substratum of a company has failed and it is impossible to carry out its objects, winding up is appropriate. | Relied on to show consistency of principle that failure of substratum warrants compulsory winding up. |
| Halsbury's Laws of England, 2nd ed., vol. V, para 885 | States it may be just and equitable to wind up a company where its substratum is gone. | Cited to support the general legal principle applied in the present case. |
| Davco Products Ltd. v. Kameswarlal, A.I.R. 1954 Cal. 195 S.C. | Indian decision ordering winding up where substratum was found to be gone. | Referenced as an instance of Indian court practice in similar circumstances. |
| Lawang Tshang… v. Goenka Commercial Bank Ltd. [1961] 31 Comp. Cas. 45 | Indian decision relevant to winding up where substratum has failed. | Noted among Indian authorities that have ordered winding up on substratum grounds. |
| O.P. Basra v. Kaithal Cotton and General Mills Co. Ltd. [1961] 31 Comp. Cas. 461 | Another Indian decision where winding up was ordered on substratum failure. | Used as supporting domestic precedent showing similar application of the substratum principle. |
| Nageswararao v. R.E.S.C. Ltd., Rajahmundry [1957] A.L.T. 728 (also cited as Nageswararao v. Rajahmundry Electric Supply Corporation Ltd.) | Illustrates an almost identical factual situation where winding up was ordered. | Cited to show a closely comparable local instance in which winding up was ordered on similar grounds. |
| Seth Mohanlal v. Grain Chambers Ltd. [1968] 38 Comp. Cas. 543 | Explains considerations in just and equitable winding up: court considers interests of shareholders and creditors; substratum disappearance defined; focus on circumstances as at date of petition. | Quoted to emphasize the multi-factorial approach and the importance of the situation at the date of the petition; the court applied these considerations in evaluating the present petition. |
| Davis & Co v. Brunswick (Australia) Ltd. [1936] 6 Comp. Cas. 227 | States that the court must fairly consider all circumstances connected with formation and carrying on of the company; decisive question is whether there was any reasonable hope at petition date of attaining the company's profit-making object. | Applied to support the approach that the court must examine whether any reasonable hope existed at the date of petition to carry on the company's objects profitably. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The court proceeded in a stepwise factual and legal analysis:
- Factual determination: The court accepted the petitioners' uncontested averments that the company's entire undertaking was acquired by the Government on February 26, 1951, compensation was paid and deposited in the bank, and that the company ceased to carry on its primary business of supplying electrical energy thereafter. The court found no credible evidence that any other business had been carried on by the company since 1951 despite other objects appearing in the memorandum.
- Assessment of memorandum objects: Although the respondents pointed to other objects in the memorandum, the court observed that these appeared to have been inserted "ex abundanti cautela" and had not been acted upon in the nearly two decades since 1951. The absence of any attempt to pursue other objects was treated as significant.
- Legal principle applied (substratum doctrine): The court applied established authorities holding that where the substratum (the main purpose) of a company has gone or become impossible to fulfill, it may be just and equitable to wind up the company. The court relied on several English and Indian authorities and Halsbury's statement of the principle to frame its legal test.
- Consideration of competing interests: The court acknowledged counsel's submission that shareholders' views might be considered and that distributional consequences (preference shareholders gaining over ordinary shareholders) arise under the statute. The court noted that statutory provisions govern distribution on liquidation and that working those provisions would not itself constitute inequity sufficient to defeat a just and equitable winding-up order.
- Conclusion on just and equitable ground: Given the finding that the main object could no longer be carried out and that no alternative business had been pursued, the court concluded the substratum had disappeared. On this basis, and applying the cited authorities, the court held it to be just and equitable to wind up the company.
- Practical directions: The court then issued specific orders to effect the winding up and to secure the company's assets and records, specifying notices, filings, and actions to be taken by the official liquidator and the petitioners.
Holding and Implications
The petition for winding up of the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. is granted; the company is ordered to be wound up on the ground that its substratum has disappeared.
Direct consequences and directions ordered by the court (as stated in the opinion):
- Intimation of the winding-up order will be sent to the Official Liquidator and the Registrar of Companies.
- An advertisement of the order shall be made under rule 113 in the Indian Express and the Andhra Prabha within 14 days of the order.
- The Official Liquidator will take charge of the assets, books and other papers of the company forthwith under rule 114.
- The petitioners will, under section 445, file with the Registrar a certified copy of this order within 30 days from the date of the order.
- The petitioners must deposit advertisement charges within seven days.
- The Official Liquidator will take the directions of the court for any legal assistance necessary.
- The costs of the petition will be paid from the company's estate; advocate's fee of Rs. 500 was fixed.
The court applied established principles from prior decisions; the order implements those principles in the facts of this case. The opinion does not purport to create a new legal precedent beyond applying the existing substratum/just-and-equitable doctrine to the facts before it.
Narasimham, J.:— This is a petition under section 433 of the Companies Act, 1956 (Act 1 of 1956), for the winding up of the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd.
2. The two petitioners are the preference shareholders each of them holding 100 preference shares, each of Rs. 50 fully paid up. The 1st respondent to this petition is the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd., represented by its managing director, Sri G.V Subbarao, and the 2nd respondent is G.V Subbarao.
3. The material averments in the petition are these:— The Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd., hereinafter to be referred to as the company, was registered under the Indian Companies Act, 1913, in 1935 as a public company limited by shares. The registered office of the company was at Guntur in Andhra Pradesh. The nominal capital of the company was Rs. 1,50,000 divided into equity shares and preference shares, 2,000 equity shares were fully paid up and 1,000 preference shares were fully paid up. The object of the company was to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet.
4. The entire undertaking of the company was acquired on February 26, 1951, by the then Government of Madras under the provisions of the Madras Act XIII of 1949 which was later replaced by the Andhra Act XV of 1954. The company was awarded compensation of Rs. 1,06,977 for the acquisition and the company has ceased to do any business for it has no business objects.
5. The 2nd respondent is the managing director of the company on a remuneration of Rs. 250 per month from 1962 and his main duty was to take up proceedings to wind up the company. The company has no other assets apart from the compensation amount which was deposited in the bank except items of furniture. As he has been engaging himself in fruitless litigation in courts in Guntur and wasting the funds of the company which has ceased to do business, the 1st petitioner compelled the managing director to call for a meeting for the voluntary winding-up of the company and the meeting for that purpose was held on August 18, 1968. But that meeting could not be-held for want of quorum. The last balance-sheet issued by the company for the year 1967 is not sound. The petitioners have, thereto sought the winding-up of the company on grounds that the company had ceased to do any business since 1951, when the entire undertaking was taken over and that there is no possibility of the company doing any kind of business in the foreseeable future and that it is just and equitable that the company is wound up.
6. The respondents filed a counter, opposing the application, but admitting that the meeting of the general body of shareholders of the company was called for considering the question of liquidating the company. He denied that he was appointed as managing director only for the purpose of winding-up the company and said that he could exercise all powers under the memorandum and articles of association of the company. He denied that the object for which the company was inaugurated was only to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet town and alleged that there were several other objects besides the supply of energy as referred to in the memorandum and articles of association. The litigation referred to was not fruitless. The 1st petitioner had differences with him and the present petition is not bona fide and is not in the interests of the company and its shareholders. It is not true that there were no balance-sheets after 1967. The last balance-sheet of the company was published for the year ending March 31, 1968, duly audited.
7. A reply has been riled reiterating that the 2nd respondent was appointed as managing director only for the purpose of speedily winding up the company, as the only business of the company, viz., electricity distribution, was acquired by the Government in 1951. The company did the only business of distribution of electricity in and around Narasaraopet from 1935 and the other objects mentioned in the memorandum are merely inserted therein ex abundanti cautela. No attempt has been made up to date either by the 2nd respondent or by any other shareholder to carry out the so-called other business objects of the company, even though the company ceased doing business on and from February 26, 1951, when the acquisition was made by the Government.
8. The points which arise for consideration on the averments in the petition are:
“(1) Whether the company has ceased doing business after February 26, 1951, when the undertaking was taken over by the Government?
(2) Whether it is just and equitable that the company should be wound up?”
9. The averments in the petition that the entire undertaking of the company was acquired on February 26, (951, by the Government of Madras, that the company was awarded compensation of Rs. 1,06,977 which was deposited in the bank and that, as a consequence of the acquisition, the company ceased to do any business are not contradicted in the counter. But it is alleged in the counter that there are several other objects of the company occurring in the memorandum. (A copy of the memorandum and articles of association of the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. is placed before me). But, the said averment is met in the reply that they were all inserted as in the case of every other company, that the only business which the company did from 1934 was to distribute the electricity in and around Narasaraopet, and, further, that no attempt has been made up-to-date either by the 2nd respondent or by any other shareholder to carry out the other objects of the company even though the company ceased to do business on and after February 26, 1951, when the acquisition was made by the Government. This would make it clear that the main object of the company was to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet and that the other objects were only theoretical and have no real significance, in the context of the business to be carried on or intended by the company. It is, therefore, clear that after the undertaking was taken over by the Government in about 1951, the business of the company in relation to the main object of the company ceased and all these years no other business was intended or commenced as an ancillary business of the company.
10. I have, therefore, no reason to doubt the fact that the main object of the company was to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet and when the undertaking was taken over by the Government in 1951 the business of the cdmpany ceased.
11. Point No. 2: In view of my finding on point No. 1, I would have no hesitation in saying that the substratum of the company has disappeared, when the main object of the company was to supply electrical energy in and around Narasaraopet and when the undertaking was taken over by the Government in 1951 and, consequently, the business of the company ceased from then. Courts have invariably held consistently that where the substratum of the company had failed and it was impossible to carry out the main object of the company for which it was formed, it was just and equitable that the company should be wound up (vide Cotman v. Brougham [1918] AC 514, 522 H.L.): where it was held that the substratum of the company is gone when the main purpose has become impossible (vide also In re German Date Coffee Company2): where it was held that the substratum of the company had failed and it was impossible to carry out the objects for which it was formed; and, therefore, that it was just and equitable that the company should be wound up (vide also In re Baku Consolidated Oilfields Ltd.3): where it was held that when the whole substratum of the company had gone, compulsory order ought to be made. All these cases elucidate the principle enunciated in Halsbury's Laws of England, second edition, volume V, at paragraph 885 that it may be just and equitable to wind up a company where its substratum is gone. A number of decisions of Indian courts have ordered winding up on the finding that the substratum is gone (vide Davco Products Ltd. v. Kameswarlal A.I.R 1954 Cal. 195 S.C., Lawang Tshang… v. Goenka Commercial Bank Ltd.…. [1961] 31 Comp. Cas. 45, O.P Basra v. Kaithal Cotton and General Mills Co. Ltd. [1961] 31 Comp. Cas. 461 and Nageswararao v. R.E.S.C Ltd., Rajahmundry [1957] A.L.T 728.). The learned counsel for the respondent has cited Seth Mohanlal v. Grain Chambers Ltd. [1968] 38 Comp. Cas. 543, where the following occurs at page 557:
“In making an order for winding up on the ground that it is just and equitable that a company should be wound up, the court will consider the interests of the shareholders as well as of the creditors. Substratum of the company is said to have disappeared when the object for which it was incorporated has substantially failed, or when it is impossible to carry on the business of the company except at a loss, or the existing and possible assets are insufficient to meet the existing liabilities……… Primarily the circumstances existing as at the date of the petition must be taken into consideration for determining whether a case is made out for holding that it is just and equitable that the company should be wound up……”
12. There are also observations specifically to this effect in Davis & Co v. Brunswick (Australia) Ltd. [1936] 6 Comp. Cas. 227 that the position of the court in determining whether it is just and equitable to wind up the company requires a fair consideration of all the circumstances connected with the formation and the carrying on of the company, etc. But it was also observed at page 121, column 1 of the reported decision, that a general rule could not be laid down as to the nature of the circumstances which have to be borne in mind in considering whether the case comes within the phrase and that the decisive question must be the question whether at the date of the presentation of the winding-up petition there was any reasonable hope that the object of trading at a profit, with a view to which the company was formed, could be attained.
13. From a conspectus of the decisions, it would emerge that each case has to be decided on its own facts. The learned counsel has urged that the shareholders' views may be ascertained, although it would appear that from 1951 the business has ceased. He would say that a preference shareholder would stand to gain by the liquidation and the ordinary shareholders would be at a disadvantage. The distribution of assets is a matter provided for under the Act and it would not be correct to suggest that by working the provisions of the Act in a liquidation ordered under the Act on grounds contemplated by the Act, inequity would result.
14. I can say from the circumstances of this case that the substratum of the company has gone, the undertaking has been taken over by the Government and the main object of the company no longer could be carried on after 1951 and what the shareholders are entitled to now is the compensation amount paid by the Government. It is inconceivable what reasonable alternative suggestions the shareholders could make in these circumstances. The fact that there were other objects listed out in the memorandum of association makes no difference in the circumstances because it is not pretended that there was any attempt to carry out any other object after 1951 for these last 19 years. I would, therefore, consider that it is just and equitable that, in the circumstances of the case, the company should be wound up. I may add that in almost similar circumstances, a judge of this court ordered winding up of the Rajahmundry Electric Supply Corporation Ltd., the order being reported in Nageswararao v. Rajahmundry Electric Supply Corporation Ltd., Rajahmundry. For the said reasons, the petition for winding up of the Narasaraopet Electric Corporation Ltd. is ordered. Intimation of this will be sent to the official liquidator and the Registrar of Companies. An advertisement of this order shall be made under rule 113 in the Indian Express and the Andhra Prabha within 14 days of this order. The official liquidator will take charge of the assets, books and other papers of the company forthwith under rule 114. The petitioners will, under section 445, file with the Registrar certified copy of this order within 30 days from the date of this order. The petitioners to deposit advertisement charges within seven days. The official liquidator will take directions of this court for any legal assistance necessary. The costs of this petition will come from the estate. Advocate's fee Rs. 500.
Alert